When self-righteousness reaches the point of misleading others, there is still a chance to correct it, but when Cognition has been poisoned too deeply, what left is only cruel ignorance.
Husband is the path to Heaven is really ridiculous! I pity these ignorant women. They are intoxicated with all the wrong doctrines. All these men use religion and words of God to control their wives and daughters. Terrible. I hope these terrible people can be punished.
I agree but remember that GISB is a cult, much like children of god, unification church etc in other religions, and it is linked to a cult that have actually been banned in Malaysia and Indonesia. So, don't generalised.
The outrage is reserved for fake cases and perceived insult by the religion and race baiters, not the known and protected criminals. There's a whole party that's catering to just this cause. None from either there or their coalition partners will raise their voicws
Malaysian here, you gotta understand there is a law against the nons if we were to make comment against or even hinting against “them” - they will accuse us for causing disharmony. We will be arrested, thrown in lock-up for 5-7 days purportedly for “investigation” during which we might be attacked by fellow inmates and the “investigator”. After which we will have to face the court, which is not determined by the rule of law but of public opinion.
Blame M for everything and also making his children billionares but ignored the poor . Blame najib and rosmah who cared only for themselves not the homeless and the poor.
When the teacher plays politics, the students will follow. This is what toxicity looks like when it becomes out of control. In psychology, it is called toxic and manipulative. In religion, it is called listening to the devil. Same thing. No differences.
Lawlessness in its most degrading level. Why no public canning? Even the authority chief cop shook his head in the news. Those abused & victims are so pitiful. INJUSTICE!!!
It's really sad for the lack of parental support and concern over this teenaged bride. Hope her story could put a stop to future similar cases from happening.
May Allah grant you and your children a beautiful life together. I am sorry you have been through a very tough time, and I pray it will only get better from here now that you are free from this cult. Hugs ❤
So she stayed on for 14 years, have 9 children, abused, beaten and never once she thought about doing something about it? Like ok u got 14 years to think! Find a way to escape. Anything!
@ Personally I am not accusing anything. But the questions remain - how did numerous police reports, involvement of her parents can keep this horrendous act for 14 years without any news surfacing to the public? Did the journalist investigate this aspect as well?
The family dynamic is a complicated one. If not, there won’t be so many family abuse keeps happening - in a realistic world, it immediately cut off once it happens. She claims she is raped, but question why is it a rape if you bear 9 of his children. But does it means rape never happened? Then the rape is aib or crime in her context, perhaps she thought it’s aib and as long as he repents, he may turn good.
@ Bro, same like you, I have a lot of questions…but no answer 😅. But what I know about Malaysia, things rarely can be kept under wraps for long. First because Malaysians are among the world highest social media users. Second, Malaysians are quick to comment & post
law and order, IF nobody report, nothing will happen, its not like we are in a reality or game studio where everything is recorded and when the time comes you will have to settle with ACCOUNTING
Is this another sandiwara? If not, then the case SHOULD NOT be allowed to drag on for months. Have any of the perpetrators and sinners and evil doers been brought to face justice? Will they be whipped and jailed for 30 years? Looks like it's none so far. Any government that TRULY cares for its people will ensure that absolute justice is quickly meted out, that is, if it is a TRULY caring and PEOPLE CENTRIC government. Otherwise, the people will continue to suffer in grinding silence and pain without even a ray of hope for a brighter future in an improved country.😢😢
Democracy is not for protecting majority ..it's for giving evey one due say and opportunity in making liveable and respectful society for everybody...religion and state should maintain distance ..I mean revolutions in history don't take place unnecessary..people literally fought and laid lives to keep away religion , monarch from state
An isolated incident involving a cult could happen anywhere. Countries like Korea or other developed nations also have cult groups. . Malaysia's per capita income is five times higher than that of the Philippines, which is truly impressive. I have great respect for this country, as it is often underrated on the global stage.
This is beyond appalling and knowing very well this despicable practice is still carried out widely. Really sad to see that many wives and kids of such religious sect have no avenue of escaping this life.
The sad things is many of malay muslim friends and family still belive in gisb. They keep blaming the govt bow to the chinese that is why the govt raid gisb
It's a cult, not religion People angry because of selective prosecution Nothing to do with this group except for their supporters probably Stop smearing others online and abroad.
CNA, best to renerrate Al Arqam as full word Al Arqam Malaysia, .. the one in singapore has no connection to them and you may have unnecessarily cause negative stigma agaisnt them.
DURING THE 14 YEARS OF ORDEAL SHE miraculously ENDURE 🤔? THIS JUST TELL ME SHE IS JUST IGNORANT ESPECIALLY MOST OF HER TIME SHE IS NOT IN CAPTIVITY WORKING AT F&B...SHE EVEN DOES NOT SEEK HELP WHEN SHE WAS IN SG & NOW WITH 9 CHILDREN SHE IS NOW SMART ENOUGH TO GET HELP, REALLY?
Have you watched the video? She tried getting help but was backstabbed by her mum and gaslighted by others. When you live your life as captive it's very hard to escape when you have learned helplessness. It is very fortunate she finally managed to escape. You are victim blaming, do not victim blame.
@@ssummerdew I am not victim blaming somehow base on the circumstance she had a role in the whole of this mess but somehow decided to bail out towards the end when GISB were raided by police & with 9 children where else can she go except switch side. REMEMBER she was never in captivity in sg she was working at the restaurant in PUBLIC & commute daily. YOU MAY WANT TO LISTEN TO HER SIDE OF HER STORY IN ATTENTIVELY IN THIS VID
@@ii9078 you're underestimating cult brainwashing, especially for children that was born/adopted into the cult. She was one of those unfortunate children. They often don't grow up normally to think they can fight back and/or those around them always find ways to restrict help. What you're doing is victim blaming even if you think otherwise. Besides, the bigger issue is the cult itself. Why are you trying to discredit someone who is trying to bring down the cult?
Kidnappers have ways to make their victims believe that they are helpless, no one is out there to rescue them and the kidnappers are the only people they can rely on. So stop victim blaming.
Don’t be condescending especially if you don’t know people’s situation. The world is a huge place. The whole world doesn’t think, act or behave exactly the way you do due to varying circumstances.
Why isn't PAS condeming this cruel GISB action? Instead PAS wants to hold rallies against Hannah Yeoh and Nga Kor Ming.
Kerana parti tu pon 2 x 5 shj..
it is their culture! please show some respect.
All crimes can hence be ok by saying it's the culture ?
1st class hypocrisy!
This is so infuriating in Malaysia, sorry to hear that she had to endure sexual abuse for many years. 😢
Yes, it was so shameful to live there in Malaysia in such a situation and condition.
Isolated incident of a cult, or course Korea or other developed county also has cult group.
She speaks well. Wishing her and her children all the best and go through the right path.
Used Religion as a cover up......this is a very seriuos crime
Appreciate CNA for highlight about GISBH underworld society
Hope CNA will uncover inappropriate conduct in Singapore without fear of POFMA or their masters.
What about Gaza ?
What is the purpose of CNA making report like Malaysia didn't take any action at all??
Baiting for Islam-phobic and anti Malaysia comments???
@@UncleJ-m1v train delay, minister resigns. Minister has gone to jail.
Never be blinded by so called religion and race, only the courageous and wise will speak up against evils
Cult not religion
Cult not religion, but religion can be the ground to grow cult.
Not when the philosophies against the teachings and stray away.
When self-righteousness reaches the point of misleading others, there is still a chance to correct it, but when Cognition has been poisoned too deeply, what left is only cruel ignorance.
Duta Tuhan
She is a very very Brave Woman ❤❤❤❤❤
Thank you CNA
Give it to CNA, an SG entity to cover the story of GISB largely happening in Malaysia. No other news outlet in Malaysia did this...
all scared to offend, , ,
Isolated incident of a cult, or course Korea or other developed county also has cult group.
They are being reprimanded left and right
Don't go and smear the good name of your country online or abroad
Husband is the path to Heaven is really ridiculous! I pity these ignorant women. They are intoxicated with all the wrong doctrines. All these men use religion and words of God to control their wives and daughters. Terrible.
I hope these terrible people can be punished.
I agree but remember that GISB is a cult, much like children of god, unification church etc in other religions, and it is linked to a cult that have actually been banned in Malaysia and Indonesia. So, don't generalised.
There is no outrage in Malaysia over this incident. Tells you all you need to know about this country.
It's all about one damn thing that is slowly destroying Malaysia
Of course there is outrage, but if the non-muslim population were to say anything...
The outrage is reserved for fake cases and perceived insult by the religion and race baiters, not the known and protected criminals. There's a whole party that's catering to just this cause. None from either there or their coalition partners will raise their voicws
Malaysian here, you gotta understand there is a law against the nons if we were to make comment against or even hinting against “them” - they will accuse us for causing disharmony.
We will be arrested, thrown in lock-up for 5-7 days purportedly for “investigation” during which we might be attacked by fellow inmates and the “investigator”. After which we will have to face the court, which is not determined by the rule of law but of public opinion.
What do you mean there's no outrage in malaysia? Idk what your intention is, but please do your research before you discredit the country...
This is not marriage this is torture.
Blame M for everything and also making his children billionares but ignored the poor .
Blame najib and rosmah who cared only for themselves not the homeless and the poor.
And there were Malay NGOs pleading not to raid or make arrests on GISB. They even begged and supported GISB monsters.
Such deviant acts. Outrageous. Those involved should be jailed for life.
So sad to hear your story😢😢😢. I hope u gain strength and hope soon. God bless u❤
When the teacher plays politics, the students will follow. This is what toxicity looks like when it becomes out of control. In psychology, it is called toxic and manipulative. In religion, it is called listening to the devil. Same thing. No differences.
Abusing of God's words for personal gains and benefits??
Tale as old as time
Cult not religion
Where are the Muslim protests over this?
Their silence speaks volumes abt this ☪️ult.
Read through malaysia's news channels you should find many muslims condemning this.
Pls read the news and do your research before you make comments like this. Many Muslims are condemning this.
Exactly cult, not religion
Christians talking about scientology?
they will protest for gaza and syria!
Where is Akmal Salleh? ?
Your crush is it ?
Akmal will close his eyes and ears to all these revelations, nothing to gain politically I suppose.
In the name of religion the atrocities committed towards humanity especially women are mind boggling..
Stay strong Zoe…
I hope sg govt make sure no Gisb operation in Sg
GISB operations are in a number of countries outside malaysia.
GISB assets worth over RM52m identified in 10 countries as informed Malaysian police.
Pure evil.
Gaza suffering more so wheres your empathy ?
Cult not religion
This is absolutely disgurbing. This world has no regards for orphans, globally.
Lawlessness in its most degrading level. Why no public canning? Even the authority chief cop shook his head in the news. Those abused & victims are so pitiful. INJUSTICE!!!
It's really sad for the lack of parental support and concern over this teenaged bride. Hope her story could put a stop to future similar cases from happening.
Why must blame parents its not fair ok ?
Thanks for revelation 🎉
Unbelievable that this has happened in the modern age.
May Allah grant you and your children a beautiful life together. I am sorry you have been through a very tough time, and I pray it will only get better from here now that you are free from this cult. Hugs ❤
So she stayed on for 14 years, have 9 children, abused, beaten and never once she thought about doing something about it? Like ok u got 14 years to think! Find a way to escape. Anything!
" Malaysia Truly Asia "
👍👏👏👏
"Malaysia Boleh?"
Malaysia is the leader of SEA and the richest
@@WasLostButNowAmFound Everyone loves Malaysia ❤
This happens everywhere, it can be by money, sex, religion, race etc.
Truly sinful 😮
This is horrific.
So strange. After 14 years and multiple police reports, this story didn’t surface much earlier.
How much CNA pay her to fabricate this story?
@ Personally I am not accusing anything. But the questions remain - how did numerous police reports, involvement of her parents can keep this horrendous act for 14 years without any news surfacing to the public? Did the journalist investigate this aspect as well?
The family dynamic is a complicated one. If not, there won’t be so many family abuse keeps happening - in a realistic world, it immediately cut off once it happens. She claims she is raped, but question why is it a rape if you bear 9 of his children. But does it means rape never happened? Then the rape is aib or crime in her context, perhaps she thought it’s aib and as long as he repents, he may turn good.
@ Bro, same like you, I have a lot of questions…but no answer 😅. But what I know about Malaysia, things rarely can be kept under wraps for long. First because Malaysians are among the world highest social media users. Second, Malaysians are quick to comment & post
law and order, IF nobody report, nothing will happen, its not like we are in a reality or game studio where everything is recorded and when the time comes you will have to settle with ACCOUNTING
Its sick n disgusting people. I wonder why they don't look at it as a serious crime.
The GISB leaders are under investigation in Malaysia and organisation's supermarket activities are also suspended with band account blocked.
What kind of teaching is this? Having up to 9 children??
So sick of religion, race, caste, gender divisions, abuse. Being spritual has nothing to do with religion.
Ewww, they sprayed food with the remains of the dead Abuya? On food consumed by other diners too????!!!!! That's so.......
A brave and strong woman, and a good mother.
Blame this on her parents. Period.
They might be part of the cult as well...
Excellent investigative journalism . Continue until the dastardly murderers are brought to justice .
I wish i could give you and your kids a good hug... hope all is good with you all.
It's mad how msia news did not even cover this.
And nobody seems to know.
News gets weirder everytime. No description on the eviil criminals. Even when caught. What kind of sentencing justice will sentence the evil monsters?
All thanks to the new government where the enforcement able to carried out the work freely and them all justice.
Lol
Why is it that politicians are so quiet about this?..
Queer isn't it.... authorities must be busy...
Poor thing ..so sorry for her hell like experience.
How can we send her money?
Ouh wau.. I didn't know they managed to get a blind interview with a member of this.
Only PM Anuar can bring justice to these monsters
Selective prosecution against cult
scary people
In malaysian news they stated only 1 rape happen towards 1 girl only in gisb😂
Wait, she has 9 kids?
Is this another sandiwara? If not, then the case SHOULD NOT be allowed to drag on for months. Have any of the perpetrators and sinners and evil doers been brought to face justice? Will they be whipped and jailed for 30 years? Looks like it's none so far. Any government that TRULY cares for its people will ensure that absolute justice is quickly meted out, that is, if it is a TRULY caring and PEOPLE CENTRIC government. Otherwise, the people will continue to suffer in grinding silence and pain without even a ray of hope for a brighter future in an improved country.😢😢
Democracy is not for protecting majority ..it's for giving evey one due say and opportunity in making liveable and respectful society for everybody...religion and state should maintain distance ..I mean revolutions in history don't take place unnecessary..people literally fought and laid lives to keep away religion , monarch from state
What's GISB?
Hi, here's a video which explains GISB and the investigation into it: th-cam.com/video/lcTM_EsccXc/w-d-xo.html
Malaysia Boleh you know?
Wow , didn't know GISBH had operations in Singapore 😮😮
Craziness
Wow! 9 children! TFR is thru the roof!!
Did any Islam religious groups reach out to help her?
Stay strong
They even have Obedient Wives Club in Malaysia. 😮
An isolated incident involving a cult could happen anywhere. Countries like Korea or other developed nations also have cult groups. .
Malaysia's per capita income is five times higher than that of the Philippines, which is truly impressive. I have great respect for this country, as it is often underrated on the global stage.
@leejpeter3456 it would be great if you can compare Malaysia's GDP to that of Singapore.
why the children was offered Singaporean citizenship
zoey singaporean
❓❓
😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Domestic violence is common worldwide
I only watched few minutes . Can’t take it .
Tak buat police report 😮😮😮😮😅😅
This is beyond appalling and knowing very well this despicable practice is still carried out widely. Really sad to see that many wives and kids of such religious sect have no avenue of escaping this life.
Cult, not religion
Nothing surprising lah! Govt more interested in optics rather than deal with social problems like this. Sama sama PAPies' propaganda filth.
type ini mmg dah melampau!!
Another crazy thingy
What's GISB......
😮😮
The sad things is many of malay muslim friends and family still belive in gisb. They keep blaming the govt bow to the chinese that is why the govt raid gisb
It's a cult, not religion
People angry because of selective prosecution
Nothing to do with this group except for their supporters probably
Stop smearing others online and abroad.
And yet they let go so many of the perps without any solid reason 😂 Malaysia boleh 👏🏻 such a joke
Type M?
when the brain has been distorted, one cannot think
Crazy
Tolong la jgn undi PN PAS lagi
Nothing to do with them
Cult not religion
But this news will never be exposed this much in boleh land. They only telecast surface news😂
This is fitnah towards Islam, GISB is not Islam.
CNA igniting islamaphobes without explaining this is not a true islam teaching
The Sky Kingdom was better, I miss Ayah Pin.
Now investigate the shenanigan in Vati-con.
honestly
passssss
😮😮😮
CNA, best to renerrate Al Arqam as full word Al Arqam Malaysia, .. the one in singapore has no connection to them and you may have unnecessarily cause negative stigma agaisnt them.
seriously all the comments on this video especially the chinese commenter are so rude,ignorant and no sympathy at all !
yes indeed,they can say sorry later😂
abuya seorang yg teliti
How dare u all criticise them.. god is great 🙌
Yeah how dare u blame wuhan. Wuhan is clean. Free of covid and not the cause of the world shut down. Its a perfect city.
Cult, not religion
Hahaha...this is interesting
I empathised with you.however you allowed these abuses to continue.
What about Gazza ?
They only speak out after the perpetrators arrested. I can’t say I believe them wholly.
Yes. Very good Banglasia Islam education
DURING THE 14 YEARS OF ORDEAL SHE miraculously ENDURE 🤔? THIS JUST TELL ME SHE IS JUST IGNORANT ESPECIALLY MOST OF HER TIME SHE IS NOT IN CAPTIVITY WORKING AT F&B...SHE EVEN DOES NOT SEEK HELP WHEN SHE WAS IN SG & NOW WITH 9 CHILDREN SHE IS NOW SMART ENOUGH TO GET HELP, REALLY?
Have you watched the video? She tried getting help but was backstabbed by her mum and gaslighted by others. When you live your life as captive it's very hard to escape when you have learned helplessness. It is very fortunate she finally managed to escape. You are victim blaming, do not victim blame.
@@ssummerdew I am not victim blaming somehow base on the circumstance she had a role in the whole of this mess but somehow decided to bail out towards the end when GISB were raided by police & with 9 children where else can she go except switch side.
REMEMBER she was never in captivity in sg she was working at the restaurant in PUBLIC & commute daily. YOU MAY WANT TO LISTEN TO HER SIDE OF HER STORY IN ATTENTIVELY IN THIS VID
@@ii9078 you're underestimating cult brainwashing, especially for children that was born/adopted into the cult. She was one of those unfortunate children. They often don't grow up normally to think they can fight back and/or those around them always find ways to restrict help. What you're doing is victim blaming even if you think otherwise.
Besides, the bigger issue is the cult itself. Why are you trying to discredit someone who is trying to bring down the cult?
Kidnappers have ways to make their victims believe that they are helpless, no one is out there to rescue them and the kidnappers are the only people they can rely on. So stop victim blaming.
Don’t be condescending especially if you don’t know people’s situation. The world is a huge place. The whole world doesn’t think, act or behave exactly the way you do due to varying circumstances.
"Pasar Ikhwan di Putrajaya..."
Mashaallah the beauty of islam ☺🥰🥰🤲🤲