Tchaikovsky - Symphony No. 5 in E minor, Op. 64 (Mariinsky Theatre Orchestra, Valery Gergiev)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 เม.ย. 2024
- From the Salle Pleyel in Paris, 2010
All six Tchaikovsky Symphonies with Valery Gergiev conducting the Mariinsky Orchestra. Watch them here: bit.ly/TchaikovskySymphoniesby...
Mariinsky Theatre Orchestra
Valery Gergiev - conductor
Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky - Symphony No. 5 in E minor, Op. 64
0:00 Intro
1:05 I. Andante: Allegro con anima
17:48 II. Andante cantabile con alguna licenza
33:50 III. Valse. Allegro moderato
39:42 IV. Finale. Andante maestoso. Allegro vivace (Alla breve)
Subscribe to wocomoMUSIC: goo.gl/ahZRzC
Follow us on Facebook: / wocomo
© Licensed by Poorhouse International
#wocomoROMANTIC - เพลง
![รุ่นใหญ่ EP.2 บุกบ้าน เสรีพิศุทธ์ ระหว่าง บิ๊กต่อ กับ บิ๊กโจ๊ก อา รักใครมากกว่า ?? l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/j2inUqhN__0/mqdefault.jpg)
Gergiev is a magician.
A symphony I had come to take for granted. This performance brought back the thrill of first hearing. Goosebumps galore. Just magnificent!
Glorious! the andante is out of this world!!!!
What a principal trumpet, like a laser beam... incredible playing. Worth some cool beer after concert. Magical performance indeed.
The only Maestro I know that conducts the orchestra with a toothpick!
My favorite. Wonderful.
El espiritu y la pasion de Tchaicovsky, la perfeccion y el sentimiento del maestro Gergiev, y la exelencia de la orquesta del teatro Mariinsky es lo mas grande que se puede pedir y agradecer
Amazing horns.Gergiev gets terrific performance from this wonderful orchestra.
Fantastic performance deserving of a standing ovation !!!!!
What a tremendous performance! The best version I have heard of this glorious 5th Symphony of Tchaikovsky! Mariinsky Orchestra is out of this world and what outstanding conducting by the Maestro Gergiev! You Russians are so brilliant when it comes to Classical Music and you as a nation should be proud for all the music you have given to the world!!
Мы гордимся, потому что Божественный Свет сияет в каждом сердце! Только нужно увидеть его, и сохранить не смотря ни на что! Мира и Любви всем нам!!!
@@user-se6ej4mr7s could you kindly write in English as I can't read Russian
@@anandsamuel1978 We are proud because the Divine light shines in every heart!
You just need to see it and keep it, no matter what.
Peace to all of us and love!
@@user-se6ej4mr7s thanks so much for the translation. Peace be to you
@@anandsamuel1978 Thank you!!!
I’ve been to the mountain top in St Petersburg and such a lovely place to be. Spacibo Maestro
Бравоооо! Најбољи оркестар!! Најбољи диригент!!! Доносите радост и полет!!! Спосибо болшаја!!!
Великолепно, восхитительно, божественно!❤️❤️❤️
In the finale you can see the cavalry thundering in a giant wave across the steppe. The power!
I like this performance the most.
I especially play the trumpet, and I really like the sound of the trumpet part in this orchestra.
The sound of the principal trumpet resonates well even in orchestral formations, and is the sound I want to aim for when playing in a hall.
I especially listen to the final part of the fourth movement many times.
Thank you for your wonderful performance.
Mamma mia!!!! Maestro Gergiev what an emotional performance!
Taurus never phones it in.
Schitterende Sinfonie die zo dicht aansluit bij het leven van Tchaikovsky! Verlorenheid, verlatenheid, onrust, afgewisseld met rustige, hoopvolle, vreugdevolle momenten als de pijn voor even weg is. Deze sinfonie wordt prachtig gebracht door het Mariinsky Orkest onder de doorvoelde, schitterende leiding van Valery Gergiev. De opname techniek is prachtig! Dank voor deze ontroerende uitvoering, spiegel van een mensenleven!!!
What an Orchestra, what a Maestro!!!
I dont mean to be so offtopic but does any of you know of a tool to get back into an instagram account..?
I stupidly forgot my login password. I would appreciate any tricks you can give me!
@Dash Eden Instablaster ;)
@Kolton Jeffrey i really appreciate your reply. I found the site through google and Im in the hacking process now.
Looks like it's gonna take a while so I will reply here later when my account password hopefully is recovered.
@Kolton Jeffrey it worked and I finally got access to my account again. I am so happy:D
Thanks so much, you saved my ass !
@Dash Eden glad I could help xD
Спасибо,Валера. Твоё исполнение гениально, каждая нота, каждая фраза на своём месте.
51:05 - Il sorriso del primo violino. Il piacere assoluto e senza limiti del fare, anzi, dell'essere musica.
That. Was. AMAZING. I had a headache and needed a break from life, so I put my headphones on, closed my eyes, and immersed myself in the music. I feel so much better and rejuvenated now. Best symphony ever!!
And better than Excedrin!
@@hrh4961 so true. i'm trying to not take it as much anymore so this is my new go-to. when i'm at home anyways
Maestro Gergiev!
Mariinsky Theatre Orchestra！
Great Performance！
A truly soulful performance; a perfect understanding between the Maestro, and His palate of Players. Who, but Tchaikovsky, can carry us to such emotional heights, or depths. He distills life's essence in a brief musical moment.
Exactly!
Je constate que Valery Gergiev est toujours incontestablement un chef génial, mais je veux aussi dire à quel point je suis révoltée de le voir rejeté de divers concerts et même hué à la Scala C'EST UN SCANDALE.!
Ce qui est scandaleux est que l'on ne demande pas à un chef d'orchestre d'être surtout un musicien génial, mais qu'on lui demande d'être avant tout politiquement correct. Ceci dit l'attaque de l'Ukraine par Vladimir Poutine est une ignominie et j'espère que Valery Gergiev en est conscient.
The Italians who booed probably had too much pasta before the concert!
Вы запретили не только Гергиева, вы отменили Петра Ильича Чайковского... Никогда Европе не понять силу справедливости и мощи России, только история все расставит на свои места...
Умом - Россию не понять,
Аршином общим не измерить:
У ней особенная стать -
В Россию можно только верить.
Не понимаете вы ни жертвенности, ни щедрости нашего народа... Не вам нас судить...
@@anastasiarewenzon6084 Vous avez interdit non seulement Gergiev, vous avez annulé Piotr Ilitch Tchaïkovski... L'Europe ne comprendra jamais le pouvoir de la justice et le pouvoir de la Russie, seule l'histoire remettra tout à sa place...
Mind - ne comprends pas la Russie,
Ne mesurez pas avec un étalon commun :
Elle a un devenir spécial -
On ne peut que croire en la Russie.
Vous ne comprenez ni le sacrifice ni la générosité de notre peuple... Ce n'est pas à vous de nous juger..
Voici la traduction de votre commentaire par google traduction, sinon je n'aurais pas pu répondre/commenter !
Je suis plutôt d'accord avec vous et je pensais que mon commentaire le montrait suffisamment, mais il faut croire que non ! 💔
Wonderful performance of a piece I have listened to for 55 years! Previously I enjoyed Von Karajan and the Berlin Philharmonic's version. Here the Russians excel at playing their own music. The primary melody of the second movement, played first by the solo horn at 18:50, is so heartfelt and poignant and played at just the right tempo. Bravissimo Mr. Gergiev!
I fully agree. It is really "Andante cantabile, con alcuna licenza", even if most probably slower than the composer tempo. But so cantabile, so poignant... Early in the covid related streaming season, the Mariinsky TH-cam channel broadcasted a more recent recording. Better sound, and in my souvenir, an even better second mouvement. Possibly will be broadcast one more time.
More and more, I am impressed by the capability of Gergiev to reveal great music by a slower tempo. As the final duet of act III in Boris Godunov, the Lensky-Olga duet of act I in Oneguine. Suddenly, I am amazed discovering unsuspected great music. Hats off.
@@FabGreg Gergiev owns this piece. There are several good interpretations with Mariinsky (and who knows how many times he played this without being recorded), his recording with the Vienna Philharmonic from the late 90s is amazing - my favorite cd of Tchaikovsky's 5th. I was lucky to see Gergiev and the Vienna Phil play this at Carnegie Hall in 2000s, and it was a fantastic experience. Every time he plays the 5th it might be different, but it's always great.
Brilliant and Beautiful!!! Irresistible!!!
Interesting interpretation. I discovered new sounds although had heard this symphony like 100 times.
minute 20:17 is one of my favourite cords in all of music. Bravo Piotr Ilitch!
Великолепное исполнение. Браво, оркестр Мариинского театра! Впечатлила 4-я часть своей глубиной и мощью. Валерий Гергиев - непревзойденный дирижер.
Непревзойденный? Вы это серьезно?
Sharp! Gorgeous rendition! 👏👏👏
Soberbio, solo el maestro Gergiev es capaz de interpretar asi a Tchaikovsky, BRAVO!!!!!!
Nobody can reach the level of this prestation ! The best for me !
Valery Gergiev. He is one of the best Orchestra Directors. Congratulations. Magnificent
I have been listening to this for almost 50 tears. But, Gergiev is just a whole new experience. The BEST RENDITION OF TCHAIVOSKY I'VE EVER HEARD.
It is a very good performance, you should try Bernard Haitink aproach
@@punxk077 Oh my was he great! R.I.P Maestro !!!!!
Gergiev, friend and ally monster Putin, lacks the moral authority to conduct music by anyone.
tears ?
I have been listening for 65 years and totally agree..
참으로 멋지고 아름다운 영상입니다~!!
DAYUMN.
I Haven't Heard This Before Until Now It Was Almost Like Bernstein But EVEN BETTER.
BRAVI !!!!
Simplemente espectacular
La mejor versión que se hizo hasta ahora!!
Hasta las lágrimas de Gergiev,impresionan.
Splendid performance. BRAVO ! Thank you all. 🌷🌷🌷 (Netherlands 2024)
Absolutely wonderful!
Incredibly beautiful ⚘️
....simplemente hermoso y las lágrimas del director impresionan más aún,Gergiev es el que interpreta y comprende mejor a Tchaikovsky...2021 Agosto Sábado 7 Santiago de Chile.
Thank you! Excellent performance! Great audio and video work too!
Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky - Symphony No. 5 in E minor, Op. 64
0:00 Intro
1:05 I. Andante: Allegro con anima
17:48 II. Andante cantabile con alguna licenza
33:50 III. Valse. Allegro moderato
39:42 IV. Finale. Andante maestoso. Allegro vivace (Alla breve)
Браво!!!❤
45:32 Por dios, cómo te amo Tchaikovsky ❤️, y mis respetos a tremendo director. Quiero ir a San Petersburgo para agradecer frente a tu sepultura todo lo que me hiciste emocionar 😭
I actually did it, it was a wonderful experience!
@@fredrickroll06 💙
Who can match Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky for heartbreaking melodies?
No one.
Quite probably the most thrilling version of the 5th I have ever heard.
Terrific performance!
Valery Gergiev, I believe to be one of the top conductors of our times if not the best. However, I heard that his is begin censored because of his support of Putin and Soviet era imperialism. Although, if those re his his personal ideas and I disagree with his views, art is art and should be kept out of politics. Tchaikovsky's 5th under his direction is masterful!
Great conductor Valery G.!!!!
..i don't normally like when pieces speed up and slow down more than i'm used to.. but mr gergiev is superb, i can take his interpretations all day.. first heard him at the proms playing Scheherazade.. just the best.. then a few years ago he came to my small city, Cardiff.. to the college of music and drama, playing Stravinsky, Shostakovich and Tchaikovsky, works for string orchestra.. just blew me away.. so good.. thankyou mr gergiev and all involved.. 🙂
Спасибо! Дирижёр, оркестр, дивный П. И. Чайковский. Лучше не бывает. Слушаю уже 3раз
💐🙏❤🙌🌲brilliant
Wooow 👏👏👏superrrr❣
Mr. Gergiev has all the magnificence of a Furtwaengler without any of the political misfortune.
I love the liberties Gergiev takes with the tempi here - "re-composing" the music, as it were, exactly to my personal taste! (Could the physiognomy presented at 4:14 count as "the quintessential Russian woman?" That is the way I feel about her - she is so beautiful!)
she's beautiful, but Russian ? Don't really think so - looks more like Caucasian, maybe mixed ? You can't really find pure Russians in the country, where over 100 nations live . And at that day there was a lot of beautiful girls, who were missing there ( I'm from Saint-Petersburg, and know many musicians from this orchestra, some of them even personally ).
Amazing af
JUNTAMENTE COM A QUARTA E SEXTA SINFONIA, ESTA SINFONIA No. 5 CONSOLIDOU O PRESTÍGIO DE TCHAIKOVSKY COMO GRANDE SINFONISTA. ESTA INTERPRETAÇÃO PRIMOROSA COM GERGIEV E A ORQUESTRA DO TEATRO MARIINSKY, ERIGIRAM UM MAGNÍFICO MONUMENTO SONORO. GLÓRIA ETERNA À TCHAIKOVSKY.
духовые как всегда на высоте!
Ага ,особенно,во 2 ч соло валторны)))
Dondequiera que estés, maldito, muchas gracias.
BRAVO, BRAVO, BRAVO!
4楽章の最後、攻撃的でいい感じ！
P R E C I O S O gracias.
太棒了
OMG!!!
Я не знаю никого, кто подходил бы к любимому композитору Чайковскому так, как вы, Маэстро. Вы руководите каждым произведением, докапываясь до корня каждой ноты, заставляя всех нас пройти через сердце жизни, которую он прожил, выполняя его наследие. Это нет. 5, как Вы его направляете, "блестит" и победоносно раскрывает великий дух и страсть русского народа! Это не скоро забудется.
When i was growing up in the late 80's I first heard this symphony on an old decca recording, with the then New Philharmonia, under Leopold Stokowski, the horn solo was wonderfully performed by Alan Civil. This performance is just as great.
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Video shot like an action movie
FIRST HEARD THIS SYMPHONY WHEN 12 YRS OLD IN THE FILM / 100 MEN AND A GIRL / THEN A CONERT IN GRIMSBY BY LONDON SYMPHONY ORCHESRTA CONDUCTED BY DR MALCOLM SEARGENT A FANTASTIC ROUSING LAST MOVEMENT =/ EDDIE EDWARDS 91 YRS YOUNG FEB 2022
Saw part of this many years ago. Wasn’t the girl a rival of Judy Garland? I thought Stokowski was the conductor.
@@srothbardt you are right it was stokowski in the film
❤
Leader of the Orchestra clearly enjoying himself (51:06) - and why not?
В этом месте начинается последняя страница нот у первых скрипок. Он счастлив и горд за оркестр
@@user-fp9ww1le8n И правильно!
Magnificent. Gergiev may be to everyone's taste. But this performance is heartfelt, emotional and completely captivating. The only other performance that might be more ideal is the 1944 recording by Koussevitzky and the Boston Symphony. Too bad that one suffers from antiquated sonic technology.
Russian composer, Russian orchestra, Russian conductor. Wonderful performance. There is some woodwind muddiness here and there caused by a microphone location issue, as when the winds are featured, the playing is excellent. Initially, I thought the horn solo in the 2nd movement was a bit slow, but as I listened, it struck me that this is the right tempo, as Tchaikovsky probably intended. It sounds so right. Also, the horn's timber is so warm and pure, so unlike many double horns today that verge on sounding like trombones as they move up the horn's range. In the 4th movement at 44:18, notice the double bass, or should I say bass viol in this case? I've never noticed a 5-string double bass before. Is this a historical instrument? The player with this instrument is ont the right in the 1st row of basses. All the other basses appear to be the standard 4-string basses. What a treat! It would be nice to hear it by itself to see if the timber is different from the usual 4-string bass. Maestro Gergiev always gives a very intense performance. I have to say that the Mariinsky Theater Orchestra is definitely up to music and the conductor. Again, excellent performance.
Who can play Russian music? A Russian orchestra. You need a big soul, one of which you can still find in Russia.
yes sometimes double basses are five stringed
@@paulbizard3493 Love the Russians!
4:16
Описание необходимо поправить. "Зимние грезы" это симфония № 1.
Il faut vraiment être russe pour comprendre et interpréter Tchaïkovski comme il convient ... toute force déployée, tout "pudeur" musicalement correcte abolie ... lors qu'elle n'est QUE TROP l'apanage de tant et tant d'interprétations "à l'occidentale" selon lesquelles tout DOIT être "retenu", quasi "dévirilisé" (la culture du "beau son", du fondu des registres orchestraux pratiqués par Karajan et ses Berlinois sont bien "oubliés", abolis qu'ils ont été par l'hégémonie des relectures "historiquement informées" ou prétendues telles) !!! Valery Gergiev et son orchestre du Mariinski de Saint Pétersbourg livrent ici, en ce concert de 2010 en la Salle Pleyel de Paris, une version que je n'hésite pas à qualifier d'anthologique !!! Et le public ne s'y est pas trompé qui applaudit à tout rompre à peine une seconde après l'extinction des "feux" tant la tension déployée dans le Finale est extrême !!!
Plus que la précédente 4ème, la 5ème symphonie relève d'une bien plus authentique logique dans l'expression du "Fatum", qu'exprime d'emblée le sombre et presque déjà funèbre exposé, dans le grave des clarinettes et des bassons, du thème du Fatum "renouvelé" par l'interruption de dix ans entre les deux symphonies : « Introduction : Soumission totale devant le destin ou, ce qui revient au même, devant la prédestination inéluctable de la Providence. Allegro : I. Murmures, doutes, plaintes, reproches à… II. Ne vaut-il pas mieux se jeter à corps perdu dans la foi ? Le programme est excellent, pourvu que j'arrive à le réaliser. » Ce thème du Destin, Tchaïkovski l'utilise cette fois comme une idée fixe à la manière de Berlioz ... C'est ainsi qu'il revient réduire à néant la contemplation de l'Andante (nanti d'un des plus beaux solo de cor de toute la littérature symphonique) et "l'aristocratique" et contrastante Valse avant de dominer entièrement un Finale ... en fait faussement triomphal (écrit en Mi Majeur, relatif du sombre mi mineur initial) ... C'est que le thème principal de ce Final (APRÈS l'introduction en Majeur du "Fatum") est totalement fondé sur le motif descendant de ladite "idée fixe" ... Et le ... "triomphe" apparent de la Coda finale (avec le thème original du mouvement initial ... en Majeur qui plus est) nous paraît bien plus célébrer l'essence inéluctable de cette "prédestination de la Providence" ... C'est ce qui a égaré maints commentateurs, condamnant ce "triomphe" forcé ... cette nouvelle "cinquième à la Beethoven" ...
Ce qui est tout particulièrement audible (et assure l'efficacité des climax dramatiques ou faussement triomphaux), c'est la puissance sans retenue que Gergiev autorise tout particulièrement à l'ensemble des cuivres (on n'entend JAMAIS une telle "liberté" par chez nous où tout est fait pour rendre le son "aimable" ... "retenu" ... musicalement "correct" !) ... C'est aussi la recherche d'un sostenuto perpétuel (l'expression du son jusqu'au bout de lui-même, fut-il seulement réduit à une croche !) ... d'un rubato expressif ... tout cela, à nouveau à l'opposé de ce qui se fait par chez nous, conséquence de la "révolution baroque" qui, se refusant à demeurer fixée dans le siècle du même nom, a désormais corrompu l'esthétique classique, romantique et même moderne, INTERDISANT un legato qui unifie et égalise la ligne musicale en gommant toute aspérité et SURTOUT le vibrato des cordes !!!
Gardons précieusement cette version de la 5ème symphonie (comme d'ailleurs du cycle des symphonies que Gergiev et les Mariinski ont livré en 2010 ... Car, soyons certains qu'en raison de l'HYSTERIE russophobique (pour ne pas dire la HAINE de tout ce qui "russe") devenue force de "loi" et EMPOISONNANT la conscience occidentale ... en raison du TSUNAMI de "sanctions" absolument INEDIT dans l'Histoire, PLUS JAMAIS nous n'aurons le privilège et le bonheur d'entendre Gergiev (frappé d'OSTRACISME HAINEUX pour s'être refusé de désavouer Vladimir Poutine en son entreprise de LIBERATION des RUSSES de la Novorossya "ukrainisés" depuis 1922 par la volonté de Lénine ... c'est-à-dire TRAHIR sa Patrie russe) et l'orchestre du Mariinski ...
Гербер фон Караян был членом нацистской партии Германии. Я русская и его музыкальному гению я простила всё.
А вы?
Вы отменили Чайковского, Достоевского, вы запретили Гергиева в ваших театрах!!!
Вам бы лучше помнить о ваших режимах фашизации Европы :
Адольф Гитлер в Германии,
Нрансиско Франко в Испании
Бенито Муссолини в Италии.
26 миллионов мы потеряли в войне с фашистской Европой.
Не Вам нас судить. Русский Донбасс бомбили восемь лет,в Одессе народ жгли живьём, в Киеве снайперы убивали людей на Майдане - гибли мирные люди. Ничего не сделала Европа для прекращения гражданской войны на Украине, взяв на себя обязательства гаранта по минским соглашениям(Германия и Франция).Теперь вы поставляет оружие нацисту Зеленскому. Вперёд ребята, итог будет как в 1945 no pasaran!!!
Не вам нас судить!!!!!
Este Gergiev que dirigía de memoria tenía un nivel de profundidad que creo que ha perdido últimamente. Excelente interpretación ¿Muchas exigencias y poco tiempo para estudiar las partituras? El afán de hacerle producir dinero mata al artista
Casi ni miraba la partitura o no la tenía 10 años atrás
Que mire o no la partitura noes lo más importante en una sinfonía tan larga como esta. Yo creo que no tiene un pero. La orquesta y el director son maravillosos
@@anabadrinas3991 Ana: coincido con vos qué saber de memoria la partitura no es lo más relevante pero me parece que tenerla en mente ayuda mucho a ser más expresivo y revela un nivel de compenetración mayor. Y Gergiev años atrás memorizaba, y ahora no, y lo noto más rutinario en los fraseos. Pienso en Abbado, en Celibidache o en Baremboim con su memoria prodigiosa y veo que son como actores que tienen el personaje en la cabeza y no en el papel, aunque reconozco que grandes batutas necesitaron siempre de la partitura como Boulez
@@anabadrinas3991 Las orquestas rusas son a mi entender de las mejores, son sonido mate, nada brillante y espectacular sino profundo. Admiro a Mravinsky, Roszhdestvensky y Kondrashin
Memoria o non memoria, per il repertorio russo Gergiev è grandissimo! il resto sono chiacchiere inutili.
Tchaikovsky's symphonies must be played by a Russian orchestra and conducted by a Russian conductor. I have seen the shadow of Mravinsky's recording here.
Dear Maestro Gergiev, It is very regrettable that some of Your Colleagues have censured Your right to hold an opinion. May beauty one day, triumph over tyranny. Psalms 146:3-6; 72:6-8.
DA! Those fools are being found out.
С их лгк
Gergiev with orchestra is wonderful in all russian repertoire but I haven't completely enjoyed the first movement
Тяжело слушать такие резкие переходы в темпе
화질이 안 좋아요.!
Идиотизм и срам такую музыку прерывать рекламой. Позор ютубу, каждый день изощряющемуся в очередной похабщине.
Gergiev is a great director but I don't like him in Tchaikovsky
早くプーチンと縁を切って、西側の演奏会に来て下さい！
Россия , Русская культура , Путин и фашизм несовместимы
Gergiev sure knows how to make Russian music sound great. Shame he supports Putin.
If the Russian regime would be half as good as Russian music, Russia would be a fantastic country.
When people write comments like this… I feel sorry for them. Deeply and profoundly. Because it shows how thoroughly their brains have been washed and rinsed by their country’s leading media companies highjacked by the global neoliberals. Not to get into any political discussions inappropriate here, I’d only say this…. The only nation that ever birthed such geniuses of a human condition as Tchaikovsky or Dostoevsky is Russia. Don’t you for a second - at least a split second - come to wonder that perhaps everything you hear might be untrue and you’re doing yourself a disservice by buying into the globalists’ narrative?.. again, deeply sorry.
My friend, the Russian regime is better than you can imagine. Come visit, I will show you our life, but remember, Russia is so big that one human life is not enough to visit the most interesting places.
And in order to understand the Russian soul, three generations are not enough.
And to understand this music, you need to understand the Russian soul.
Welcome!
Great music of Tchaikovsky
Светланов прекрасный советский дирижер, но с силу то-ли своей фамилии, то-ли партийных установок все его варианты симфоний Чайковского звучат оптимистично: где у Чайковского трагизм, у Светланова драма, где у Чайковского драма, у Светланова меланхолия, где меланхолия у Светланова победа социализма. Как в СССР "не было секса", так, похоже, не было и трагизма.. Хотя в :6-й симфонии он в конце погасил свет в зале, но государственная комиссия наверное решила, что это для рациональной экономии советского электричества. (Я люблю СССР, я родом оттуда). Но истинное понимание Чайковского только у Гергиева, он пропускает через свое сердце каждый звук и наполняет его тем смыслом, какой вкладывал в него Чайковский. Вот родственные души, во славу России. Две великие души, два великих таланта, два бриллианта в короне русского искусства. А 6=я симфония Чайковского у Гергиева слабонервных может довести до инфаркта, до такой степени ощущения реального процесса умирания человека отточен каждый звук, боль, страдание, переосмысление прожитого, гнев, бессилие, ужас приближающегося, отчаяние и ...смирение, наконец принятие неизбежного в кротости и вере в благую волю Бога для верующей души. Чайковский бал верующим. Гергиев не имеет себе равных, это наше русское достояние. Низкий ему поклон и пожелания здоровья и долголетия. И какое счастье, что в барахолке интернета сохранено и лучшее, что создано человеком. Счастья Гергиеву.