Tragedy is that channels like this and Jay Vardhan Singh (History PHD Candidate again) are having less than 25k subscribers but 17 year old teens making Jingoistic Pseudo history shorts with loud music are having 500k subscribers
Yeah only ruchika know every history and no other historian know anything about this. All theories told by ruchika is proved 100% accurate and no contradiction happens. U're fucking blinded by left history
Ohh come on ,, there are many chapri phd like her roaming around , its just that all of them have not started a youtube channel yet , but you will see a lot of them in some time ,,,💘💘
The IVC had a 5 million strong population in 1900bc when in it declined and disappeared. Archeological study confirms that no human remains are found to suggest a violent invasion. It appears that the the IVC was subject to a systematic and strategic evacuation in response to external aggression at the time. The evacuation was followed by migration towards the east and the south.- mixed with hunter gatherers to become the ASI
12:16 Lucent's General knowledge book में History Part के शैव धर्म अध्याय में लिखा है कि "अथर्ववेद में शिव को भव, शर्व, *पशुपति* , भूपति कहा गया है".... Ma'am मैं आपकी बातों से ज्यादा सहमत हूँ.
Madam, girls like you are the hope in a time when political parties, political organizations disseminating false information among masses in order to achieve their socio-political motives. May more and more intelligent and progressive girls of Hindu religion come forward to liberate their people from unawareness and misinformation; and make them rational. Thanks to you.
Regarding saraswathi can it be that the central asian steppe groups(indo arians) have reassigned a “venerable name” to a river(current gagra river) in the area they settled and finally compiled rigveda? Since they have a common origin with indo iranians and share lot of deities and fables with them, isnt it quiet possible that they remember the grand “saraswati” from their previous homeland in lower central asia and upper afganistan and after one or two centuries of migration to new area reassigned the name of their venerable river goddess to a river that is in the new area of settlement. That could explain many contradictions in rigveda regarding saraswati as they might be mixing up their previous “memories and beliefs” and current geographical specifications . Isnt it an important possibility. Names are frequently carried to new places of settlement by groups of people in history often as i understand .
I have heard of this theory as well. It is difficult because the Rigveda and other evidences are mainly poetic, not cartography or literal descriptions. So we have to infer any meaning while understanding this. Others have said that Saraswati is likely just upper reaches of Gaggar-Hakra, and the poetic descriptions like "on rushing, ever flowing" are meant not literally, but as praise. For example if I were to write poem on my wife, I would say things like "most beautiful in the world, radiant, perfect in every way". But if someone found it years later, maybe they will think I literally married some otherworldly beauty? It makes history study more interesting and fun, but probably also more difficult!
Well, it is true that Marshall was not an archeologist, but hey, his works ought not be dismissed so easily or derisively. (I guess I was introduced to Marshall through his Rig Veda Primer many decades ago.. so I feel a little sympathetic hehe). We learn over time and I guess what seemed like the truth at one time might have a different meaning later. (Tilak and his Arctic home theory, for example. We can laugh at it. But hey, we even read Pargiter and we feel ok with his timelines and Kuru dynasty history and all... even HC Roychowdhury quoted heavily from his works.. at least I give credit for the superhuman effort.. ). Look at some of the discoveries by non-historians or non-archeologists.. The Rosetta Stone of India.. Devanagari script deciphered.. and some of the earliest Dravidian dictionaries by Missionaries - Kittel, Manor et al... But what is curious is that in a place where such ancient civilizations existed, there is no formal field of study for Archeology. Isn't it? I am not sure, but I guess there isn't. Even the ASI trains people in rudimentary archeological techniques, I think. Is there even a degree for archeology anywhere in India? I am not sure. I am ignorant about this. Never studied history or archeology, so I am not aware of much of the formal studies or degrees in this field. Lastly, Siva/Pasupati/Rudra debate... I guess it is natural that a superior race in smaller numbers ruling over a large subject populace would in fact embrace local totems, symbols, gods, deities, customs in order to get better assimilated in the region and prevent outright rebellion. At least, that is what I imagine. Someone else commented that the Vedic people eschewed idol worship and snake worship. One cannot be certain about the idol worship aspect, but as for snake worship, it is but natural. Who were the enemies of the Rig Vedic people or even the Puranic ones? The Nagas, amongst others. The snake was their totem. Therefore, it is natural that this hostility shows up in their religious practices as well. Similarly, in the Puranic and later narratives, the main enemies are the dark people (the asuras), the nagas (Uloopi and so on), the yakshas.. The point is, for an alien race, everyone not immediately under their control was the enemy. Is it any wonder that Rama on his search for Sita found only monkeys, demons, and sundry other creatures but not one human being south of the Vindhyas? Someone mentioned Avilokiteshwara as well!!! Alas, I have been trying to fight that concept for a while now. Here, in Mangalore, for instance, there is a famous temple called Kadri Temple. The statue there is of Avilokiteshwara.. this temple was founded by the founder of the mutt of our very dear Mr. Bisht of UP... Gorakhnath.. what existed before was a Jain Temple and before that a Buddhist Vihara that was forcibly turned into a Siva temple. A Jain deity as Siva... fine.. wonderful. There are multiple examples of Jain and Buddhist locations forcibly or violently converted into Hindu temples, but if you even whisper it, there will be a ton of poison thrown at you. Never mind. Thanks for sharing this video. Much appreciated.
Marshall was not an archeologist, so mock him... Meanwhile she is also not one...but her fanboys laughing like hell and thinking of embracing ach and every thing out of her snide mouth
When considering female goddess in Harappa, i remember reading there were ruins of incense and other ritualistic stuffs around female figurines in harappa, hence they were concluded as "Mother Goddess".
श्री मति जी आपसे मै एक प्रसन्न पूछना चाहता हूँ की वेदो मे सरस्वती नदी का वर्णन मिलता हैं जो लगभग 5000 से 6000साल पहले सुख गयी लेकिन आप जैसे इतिहासकार कहते हैं की सरस्वती नदी मिथ्या थी तो वर्तमान मे भू गर्भ वैज्ञानिकों ने इसके पुक्ता प्रणाम दिया हैं और इसरो के उपग्रह द्वारा भी इसे चिन्हित किया गया हैं फिर तो आप अपने ही लपेटे मे ही लिपट गये क्यकि सरस्वती नदी का वर्णन वेदो मे रामायण महाभारत मे मिलता हैं एसे मे हड़प्पा रामायण और महाभारत के पश्चात हुवा होगा क्योकि उस समय यह नदी सूख चुकी थी तो आप स्पष्ट कीजिए की सरस्वती नदी किस समय की हैं।
Evidence de usne har ek baat ka evidence diya hai gapod nahi hake hai samasya ye aa gaye hai ke har ek dimag se paidal manush ke pass internet aa gaya or opinion dene ka adhikar To evidence lao
Bc bhr s aake kitabo m copy paste kr lene s tm yha k ho jate? Bc tmhri ramcharitmanas manusmriti hr kitabe cancer fela rhe thi..fr tmne ek Geeta likh k usko hide krne ki koshish kri
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika That was an engaging read. One suggestion I would like to give you is to create content on the eradication of Buddhism from India. Buddhism, indeed, challenged the hegemony of Brahmin religion and presented various critiques. Authors like Uma Chakravarti have extensively written on this topic, and some Bahujan writers have also contributed. Therefore, consider making a video on the extinction of Buddhism-examining whether it occurred naturally or by force.
Mam I watched both of your indusvalley videos, but i still want to know more about "secrets of sinauli" the cart/chariot part is clear but the burial system is it from indus people or the Vedic people? Its a request mam please make a video on the claims of "secrets of sinauli" discovery+🙏 Edit : i also read an article of michel danino about foundings of horse shaped sculpture and spoked wheel toys, it is getting very confusing to me so mam can you please help clarify 🙏♥️
I always find it absurd how Historians seem to ignore the possibility that there might have been more influences the current Shiva than the Vedic Rudra. As I stated in your previous video as well, in the Rig Veda both snake worship and phallic worship is condemned. (EDIT: also idol worship is condemned) So what is the origin of phallic worship of Shiv / Shiv Shakti from the post vedic times. Did they magically appear out of nothing or perhaps the customs of the local peoples that were non or pre vedic inhabitants of India (roughly 70% of the population according to DNA analysis) have an impact on religion, customs and traditions? It's absurd to think that the local population had no impact on tradition custom and religious practices. Proto Shiva is not JUST Rudra. There can be and obviously are more than 1 influence that have been syncretised into the modern or even the Puranic Shiva ( and most other Hindu Gods/Godesses). Edit: This is not to say that it is Pashupatinath or Shivlingam as one would far more concrete proof for such claims. Other than this point I must say I enjoy your videos quite a bit. PS Yagya Havans were supposed to be destroyed/ unassembled post use.
Not sure which historian you've been reading but if course Shiva is an amalgamation of rudra and a local mountain deity, I had looked at Shiva in detail here scroll.in/article/844874/how-shiva-was-transformed-from-a-meat-loving-deity-to-a-vegetarian-god
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika wow kya overconfidence hai , kuch bhi guess work maro aur amalagamation karo aur scroll mei article print krr ke hero bnn jao 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Mam aapake sikhane ka tarika bohotahi acchha hai Kash muze apase face to face padhane ka mauka mil sakata Aap apane pure emotion ke sath sikhate hai isase hame topic acchhe se samajane me madat milati hai
Hello mam, I hope you will make more videos if more evidence emerges even if it is contrary to what you are saying now. Or any new revelation is there. Thanks btw. Nice Video:) Also one suggestion for the next video can be about the so called golden period of Indian history - the Gupta Empire: social organization, myths related to it and reality which should be widely known.
Another juicy topic would be discuss the linguistic history. Myths about Sanskrit as oldest language, comparison to Pali, Tamil. Timeline of rig veda and whether it's really a subcontinent document or imposed on us and came from Tigris or how it misses the key geographical features n biodiversity of the subcontinent which is right side of indus
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika there are around 57 izlmic majority countries, 1.8 billion of them , they dont need an infidel woman supporter , whom they wouldn't hesitate to rpe n mrder But a woman frm India who happens to have hindu name , is working hard to denigrate her own heritage but keeps licking the toilet seat of izlmics
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika even a so called red light area worker is more useful and loyal to their country than filth which crawls out from gutter filled with faeces of desert dwellers , who have wrecked genocide and destruction on any land they set their foot upon None speaks for yezidis , zoroastrians, hindus who faced unimaginable religious persecution But filth speaks for 1.8 billion roaches who need no support , they can wreck any country on will. Europeans have learnt about desert dwelling cockroaches recently and now all right wing parties are getting elected
उगल दिया तेरे टिचर का नाम रोमिला थापर मैं सोच ही रहा था. तुम्हारी बाते तूम्हारी बातो से ही काटी जा सकती है वांगपंती दीदी. तुम्हे पता होकर भी झूठ बोलती हो. और कितने बेबी है तुम्हारे दर्शक जो इतने साफ विरोधाभास को नही पकड सकते
madam! har Indian archaeological surveys me ved, puran, ramayan, mahabharat ko jodne ke piche kiska haath hota hai or iske picche ka maksad kya hai? plz bataiye...
People who are 100% sure of their history are threat to humanity. And you seems one of them. Historical objects need interpretation and historican does that why because there can't be 100% surity of any object.
😂😂😂lol that's call fallacy There are evidence of earliest text had found bodies had found Buddhist stupa and monastery had found but not a shiva penis or shiva ling be found in the whole indus civilization Khali shiv ling ko hi gayab hona tha ha 😂
@@kafka1343 Abey gonchu aadmi shivling like structures mile hai ,, its just that leftists don't say it's shivling , you can see it for yourself ,, by the tuje pata hai na buddhism is dominated by Brahmins also , check the names of Buddhist scholars they are all Brahmins , proud Brahmins tu kham kha buddhism ka chachu na bnnn 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Interesting as always. I have noticed that many channels and podcast that make shows on ‘Debunking Aryan Invasion’ at tactly avoid using the term ‘Aryan Migration’ and prefer ‘Steppe Pastoralist (SP)’. I was listening to Dr. Niraj Rai on TRS and he was confident that Haplogroup R1a (SP Marker) migrated from India to the west. What would you say to that?
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika I could sense something fishy when he deliberately avoided revealing the fact that R1a & ANI is found in higher percentage in upper caste/Indo-European language speaking people and that ASI in lower caste & Dravidian people. I think he did so considering how it is a sensitive subject and the political upheaval it can cause if looked through the lens of caste. Thankfully I got to know about David Reich's research and got an outside perspective.
I dont know that that seal is Pashupati or not but Vedic god Rudra is definitely known as Pashupati. In rudra path kram word Pashupati, Ashvapati come many times.
The Indus Valley lay abandoned for 400 years until 1500bc when pastorolist from Europe and Central Asia settled the area bringing new language and the Vedic culture. Other male biased groups entered the indo gangetic plain mixed with the native hunter gatherers giving rise to the ANI
Madam, thanks again for busting the well established myths. I request you to make an elaborate ( if needed ) episode on " Dravidians are pure Indians " / " Dravidian culture has resemblance with Mohenjodaro civilization" / " Aryans drove Indians to the South".
अब एक हड्डी के टुकड़े जीवस्म से ये पता भी लगा लिया जाए की सिंधु घाटी की सभ्यता और वहां के लोगों के अंदर का वातावरण कैसा था तो इससे वर्तमान समाज को क्या मिल जाएगा,,मैडम यूट्यूब मे इसे बड़बड़ाना छोड़ कर मॉडलिंग करो,आप इसी काम के लिए पैदा हुई हो,, श्रृंगार करने वाली देवी🌻
Aap sahi hain Inke Bhagwan AMU ka Midvale history department hai Ye sabhi Mughals ko glorify karti hain Ancient Indian history ko complete mith manti hain aur Naget karti hain Aik mitti ke sikke par tiger aur usse bachta kisan saari raat ke liye Bel fal ke tree par upper baitha dikhai deta hai Aisa alag alag 18 sikkon par same katha nazar aati hai Yeh Labdakh ki katha hai aur isi se inspired ho kar Shiv ratri Ka parb manana shuruaat hui Same isi Labdakh ki carvings indonesia me bhi milti hai Is vital jankari ko mahodaya chhipa gain JNU ki jo hain
Hey mam , I’m population genetic , history and archaeology enthusiast…..My caste is Ror which have highest steppe ancestry in South Asia . I live near Kurukshetra . I wanna share you something important which I observe uh always miss in your video …Vedic land - Haryana Actually, there are more than hundred of archeological site (Painted Grey Ware ) in Kurukshetra Kaithal jind hisar district of Haryana which was also part of kuru kingdom. All those sites has carbon dating on average 1000 BCE . These sites are mostly on palaeochannel of tributaries of Saraswati . One thing which strange about my region is that you will find good quality water in these area …rest of Haryana doesn’t have that much good water table and water quality .You can also check ISRO report for more info .
Dr. Sharma, perhaps you have addressed this in a prior video, but if burial was the customary form of disposal of the dead in Harappa and Mohenjodaro, were those people not precursors of Hindus, who favor cremation?
Ruchi kaun karega ap sey shaadi beta! 😂 ego hurt hojayega! Great work. Highly appreciate the pain and effort that goes behind so much research and swimming against the tide. Bach ke rehna... Shayhar aur gaon mein yehi shor hai "Ayega tho Jahel hee" 😂
@@caa_nrcor star of David lagaye ho to ek baar David or unke senior prophet moses ke polytheist ke liye pyaar dekh lena maja aa jayega 😂😂old testament se
When human race entered into agricultural society leaving hunting gatherer livelihood individual property concept developed. So Harrappan civilization must be economical and social hierchi.
That's a beautiful explanation 😊. But miss can you make video on how Sanskrit is evolves? What's the origin of Sanskrit? Sanskrit ke oldest evidence kya hai? BHS (Buddhist hybrid Sanskrit) oldest hai ki Sanskrit?
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika I am UPSC pass student from 2019 batch aur hamare sir ne khaa thaa ki history ko phir say padhna. It's totally different from the syllabus. Thanks Mam you are helping me so much 🙏🏻..
@@pankajkumarpk4827 I know that brother! Maine research kiye hai Sanskrit pai Rig Veda ki oldest script bhi 1464 AD ki hai I just read that UNESCO research paper. I just want a perfect explanation on this topic..
B&D was epic 😂😂. There one research from a lady she has prove that Minakshi temple’s architecture is same as Mohanjodaro city’s architecture is same. Could you please elaborate on ?
well made video and interesting info. Maam there are some who believe that description of Saraswati as perennial is just poetic hyperbole in Rigveda, not a literal meaning. In the context of how Rigveda is written there is some merit to this, which could still be consistent with the river being Gaggar Hakra, or at least part of it. Do you have any opinion on this?
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika Where does the attribution of the geographical Saraswati come from then? Is it based on any other textual geographic descriptions? Or have we simply guessed that the dried up course of Gaggar-Hakra is the likeliest match of what was once called Saraswati?
@@Anon999-qk3ue scholars have made the comparison based on the description of the river in the rig Veda and of course linguistic similarities in the ancient name of the Helmand river, Haraikhwati
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika and one more question, can you link to any reference regarding the recent genetic studies on Aryan peoples? I think you referenced some significant study with has given insights, but I can't remember that name
I am from Afghanistan. I have been reading about my country’s history and its indigenous people. So far, studies shows that Tajiks are indigenous people of the land but I couldn’t find transcripts about Pashtun or Pathan (Pashtuns way of life is completely different from Tajiks) and Hazaras (Hazaras are in the center of Afghanistan and their facial features aren’t similar to Tajiks and Pashtuns. They look more like Chinese) and also there are Buddha statues in Afghanistan as well as Tajikustan. Does this mean that Tajiks who are aryans were Buddhist or Hindus before? I will be very grateful if you make a video about it.
Areas such as Taxila and Gandhara (modern Kandahar) were under the dominions of kings such as Ashoka, who himself became a Buddhist, doesn't mean everyone living in that area was necessarily a Buddhist. In all probability they were worshipping multiple gods
Regarding Pashtuns or Pathans , there's also a theory that they belong to one of the 12 tribes of Israel. You probably know how Jews witnessed multiple expulsions throughout history
मैडम कृपया आप सनातन समीक्षा चैनल पर जाकर अपने तमाम तथ्यों को विधिवत समीक्षा कर सकती हैं । हमें इन्तजार रहेगा। यदि वास्तव में आप प्रोपोगण्डा नहीं फैला रहीं हैं तो आप अवश्य पधारेंगी , यदि आप नहीं आती तो आपके सारे तथ्य झुठे माने जाएंगे।
Btw I don't if it's your forte or even if you're up for the challenge but would love a more cohesive/ story telling style video covering what we know about IVC both from daily life/ social organisation etc. and also how the civilization kept changing over hundreds of years.
Madam hme b history janne ki icha hai pr agr koi sach btaye to pr me 1 aur channel hai jinki video dekhta hu pr unhone apko fake historian btaya abi samaj hi nhi aata kiski sune halanki Hadapa pr unki rai aur apki rai similar hi hai muje lagta hai pehle ap historian logo me apas me debate honi chahiye jo jeete uski sunni chahiye fr hi hmare jaise log jinko history ki knowledge nhi kus payenge nhi to bekar hai sab
Was saraswati haraxavati? No Publishing in 20th November 2019 A paper titled"on the existence of a perenial river in the harappan heartland" has proved beyond doubt that ghagra hakkar was indeed saraswati. Now coming to why rigvedic description of saraswati is given as mighty raging river.The answer is simple: exaggeration This is the reasoning that proffesor stephanie jamison agrees too in her book
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika search the title I have given it. Article number 17221 Authors: anirban chatterjee, anil d shukla, kanchan pande Published in nature.
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika no proof helmand was saraswati either. The more mainstream view correlates saraswati with ghaggar harka paleo channel. This view was also well accepted by mueller.
@@anchitbose4151 lol, Mueller! Yes there's immense proof that Helmand was Saraswati, not only is Helmand still alive (perenniality beyond a doubt) but also the linguistic similarity between Haraikhwati and Saraswati, in fact Thapar et al have done an excellent job of connecting the two. You may want to read that instead of random correlations
Harrpa civilization agr naturae calamity s hua toh y kitabe kse bch gye? Bc itne bde bde mndir bch gye or itni purani civilization jo ek alg he level ki thi vo khtm jo gye hian?..or itni sari kitabe kosne bhgwn n likh di?..they came & destroyed great harrpa civilization y kitna v bche but such yhi rhega
That study on bone tissue analysis was so brilliant, this is why I love this channel. Always helps me learn something completely new even on a topic that I know a lot about
Didi apne joo babri masjid pee video ,banaya tha usspe kuch counter points hee .. App ekbar - *soch by mohak , *Nitish Rajput inn dono kaa Ram mandir kaa video dekh liye ,22 /1/24 koo same day par released huya hee , AP kaa counter point kee liye community post pee wait karung gaa
You mean to say arya invasion theory is true, When India came to India, why didn't they rule? After the arrival of Aryan Buddhism spread throughout India for two thousand years. This is called Arya invasion theory or Buddha invasion theory.
Tragedy is that channels like this and Jay Vardhan Singh (History PHD Candidate again) are having less than 25k subscribers but 17 year old teens making Jingoistic Pseudo history shorts with loud music are having 500k subscribers
Sed lyf 😞
Yeah only ruchika know every history and no other historian know anything about this. All theories told by ruchika is proved 100% accurate and no contradiction happens.
U're fucking blinded by left history
Ohh come on ,, there are many chapri phd like her roaming around , its just that all of them have not started a youtube channel yet , but you will see a lot of them in some time ,,,💘💘
@@caa_nrc let him SIMP some, some of his brain cells have died and grown up somewhere
@@caa_nrccry harder, while your pseudo history gets destroyed here every week
Thanks
Thanks
Thanks!
Thanks
As usual, a great video...I think you should hold nationwide lectures...over years, people would finally acknowledge your efforts...
👍👍 you are a mythbuster
Thank you!
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchikach ti ya au rat
@@--GhostofSparta--lol 🤣
Kash aap jaisi teacher kabhi school m milti toh history padhne m maza aata hain teacher se ne pdaya toh bas syllabus cover karwane ke liye
Thank you!
Sanatan sameeksha ki latest video dekho in madam ko expose kar diya hai😂
The IVC had a 5 million strong population in 1900bc when in it declined and disappeared. Archeological study confirms that no human remains are found to suggest a violent invasion.
It appears that the the IVC was subject to a systematic and strategic evacuation in response to external aggression at the time. The evacuation was followed by migration towards the east and the south.- mixed with hunter gatherers to become the ASI
12:16 Lucent's General knowledge book में History Part के शैव धर्म अध्याय में लिखा है कि "अथर्ववेद में शिव को भव, शर्व, *पशुपति* , भूपति कहा गया है"....
Ma'am मैं आपकी बातों से ज्यादा सहमत हूँ.
you explain very well Ma'am.. I also mention references given by you in the class... Thank you
Keep going... you are absolutely on right track.. take care your self as well ❤
Thanks
Madam, girls like you are the hope in a time when political parties, political organizations disseminating false information among masses in order to achieve their socio-political motives. May more and more intelligent and progressive girls of Hindu religion come forward to liberate their people from unawareness and misinformation; and make them rational. Thanks to you.
You have an inimitable style of presenting history. Kudos
Sanatan sameeksha ki latest video dekho in madam ko expose kar diya hai😂
Can you analyse Ramayan the way you’ve analysed Mahabharat?
Regarding saraswathi can it be that the central asian steppe groups(indo arians) have reassigned a “venerable name” to a river(current gagra river) in the area they settled and finally compiled rigveda? Since they have a common origin with indo iranians and share lot of deities and fables with them, isnt it quiet possible that they remember the grand “saraswati” from their previous homeland in lower central asia and upper afganistan and after one or two centuries of migration to new area reassigned the name of their venerable river goddess to a river that is in the new area of settlement. That could explain many contradictions in rigveda regarding saraswati as they might be mixing up their previous “memories and beliefs” and current geographical specifications .
Isnt it an important possibility. Names are frequently carried to new places of settlement by groups of people in history often as i understand .
I have heard of this theory as well. It is difficult because the Rigveda and other evidences are mainly poetic, not cartography or literal descriptions. So we have to infer any meaning while understanding this. Others have said that Saraswati is likely just upper reaches of Gaggar-Hakra, and the poetic descriptions like "on rushing, ever flowing" are meant not literally, but as praise. For example if I were to write poem on my wife, I would say things like "most beautiful in the world, radiant, perfect in every way". But if someone found it years later, maybe they will think I literally married some otherworldly beauty? It makes history study more interesting and fun, but probably also more difficult!
Well, it is true that Marshall was not an archeologist, but hey, his works ought not be dismissed so easily or derisively. (I guess I was introduced to Marshall through his Rig Veda Primer many decades ago.. so I feel a little sympathetic hehe). We learn over time and I guess what seemed like the truth at one time might have a different meaning later. (Tilak and his Arctic home theory, for example. We can laugh at it. But hey, we even read Pargiter and we feel ok with his timelines and Kuru dynasty history and all... even HC Roychowdhury quoted heavily from his works.. at least I give credit for the superhuman effort.. ).
Look at some of the discoveries by non-historians or non-archeologists.. The Rosetta Stone of India.. Devanagari script deciphered.. and some of the earliest Dravidian dictionaries by Missionaries - Kittel, Manor et al...
But what is curious is that in a place where such ancient civilizations existed, there is no formal field of study for Archeology. Isn't it? I am not sure, but I guess there isn't. Even the ASI trains people in rudimentary archeological techniques, I think. Is there even a degree for archeology anywhere in India? I am not sure. I am ignorant about this. Never studied history or archeology, so I am not aware of much of the formal studies or degrees in this field.
Lastly, Siva/Pasupati/Rudra debate... I guess it is natural that a superior race in smaller numbers ruling over a large subject populace would in fact embrace local totems, symbols, gods, deities, customs in order to get better assimilated in the region and prevent outright rebellion. At least, that is what I imagine.
Someone else commented that the Vedic people eschewed idol worship and snake worship. One cannot be certain about the idol worship aspect, but as for snake worship, it is but natural. Who were the enemies of the Rig Vedic people or even the Puranic ones? The Nagas, amongst others. The snake was their totem. Therefore, it is natural that this hostility shows up in their religious practices as well. Similarly, in the Puranic and later narratives, the main enemies are the dark people (the asuras), the nagas (Uloopi and so on), the yakshas.. The point is, for an alien race, everyone not immediately under their control was the enemy. Is it any wonder that Rama on his search for Sita found only monkeys, demons, and sundry other creatures but not one human being south of the Vindhyas?
Someone mentioned Avilokiteshwara as well!!! Alas, I have been trying to fight that concept for a while now. Here, in Mangalore, for instance, there is a famous temple called Kadri Temple. The statue there is of Avilokiteshwara.. this temple was founded by the founder of the mutt of our very dear Mr. Bisht of UP... Gorakhnath.. what existed before was a Jain Temple and before that a Buddhist Vihara that was forcibly turned into a Siva temple. A Jain deity as Siva... fine.. wonderful. There are multiple examples of Jain and Buddhist locations forcibly or violently converted into Hindu temples, but if you even whisper it, there will be a ton of poison thrown at you. Never mind.
Thanks for sharing this video. Much appreciated.
Marshall was not an archeologist, so mock him...
Meanwhile she is also not one...but her fanboys laughing like hell and thinking of embracing ach and every thing out of her snide mouth
When considering female goddess in Harappa, i remember reading there were ruins of incense and other ritualistic stuffs around female figurines in harappa, hence they were concluded as "Mother Goddess".
Chanced upon you , fascinated by both , discussion and the style of delivery .
Subscribed!
Thank you
th-cam.com/video/N3E534MpkHU/w-d-xo.htmlsi=MtxwuP3OOGqGyxDU
mam i think you should write a book on myths of Harappan civilisation...
Thanks for the suggestion
@Dr Ruchika Sharma
. My point is those arrows and knives were for protection from wild animals. Can you prove me wrong? Kindly clear my doubt.
Mp / rajasthan/ chattisgarh ------- maalish krr ke rakho , abba jaan aa rahe hai 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Yes mam
Sanatan sameeksha ki latest video dekho in madam ko expose kar diya hai😂
श्री मति जी आपसे मै एक प्रसन्न पूछना चाहता हूँ की वेदो मे सरस्वती नदी का वर्णन मिलता हैं जो लगभग 5000 से 6000साल पहले सुख गयी लेकिन आप जैसे इतिहासकार कहते हैं की सरस्वती नदी मिथ्या थी तो वर्तमान मे भू गर्भ वैज्ञानिकों ने इसके पुक्ता प्रणाम दिया हैं और इसरो के उपग्रह द्वारा भी इसे चिन्हित किया गया हैं फिर तो आप अपने ही लपेटे मे ही लिपट गये क्यकि सरस्वती नदी का वर्णन वेदो मे रामायण महाभारत मे मिलता हैं एसे मे हड़प्पा रामायण और महाभारत के पश्चात हुवा होगा क्योकि उस समय यह नदी सूख चुकी थी तो आप स्पष्ट कीजिए की सरस्वती नदी किस समय की हैं।
Evidence de usne har ek baat ka evidence diya hai gapod nahi hake hai samasya ye aa gaye hai ke har ek dimag se paidal manush ke pass internet aa gaya or opinion dene ka adhikar
To evidence lao
Bc bhr s aake kitabo m copy paste kr lene s tm yha k ho jate?
Bc tmhri ramcharitmanas manusmriti hr kitabe cancer fela rhe thi..fr tmne ek Geeta likh k usko hide krne ki koshish kri
सरस्वती नदी ईरान में बहती थी जो सुख गई थी।
Have you read Suvira Jaiswal's book 'The Making of Brahmanic Hegemony'? If yes, what are your views on it? By the way, I love your work!
Thank you, I have read Jaiswal on the origins of Vaishnavism and I thought it was an excellent read
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika That was an engaging read. One suggestion I would like to give you is to create content on the eradication of Buddhism from India. Buddhism, indeed, challenged the hegemony of Brahmin religion and presented various critiques. Authors like Uma Chakravarti have extensively written on this topic, and some Bahujan writers have also contributed. Therefore, consider making a video on the extinction of Buddhism-examining whether it occurred naturally or by force.
@@Garvitb19 thanks for the suggestion
Which religion people of harappa follow?
You always bring some new research to the fore front. Very impressed by you and your work.
Thank you
Mam I watched both of your indusvalley videos, but i still want to know more about "secrets of sinauli" the cart/chariot part is clear but the burial system is it from indus people or the Vedic people?
Its a request mam please make a video on the claims of "secrets of sinauli" discovery+🙏
Edit : i also read an article of michel danino about foundings of horse shaped sculpture and spoked wheel toys, it is getting very confusing to me so mam can you please help clarify 🙏♥️
I always find it absurd how Historians seem to ignore the possibility that there might have been more influences the current Shiva than the Vedic Rudra.
As I stated in your previous video as well, in the Rig Veda both snake worship and phallic worship is condemned. (EDIT: also idol worship is condemned) So what is the origin of phallic worship of Shiv / Shiv Shakti from the post vedic times. Did they magically appear out of nothing or perhaps the customs of the local peoples that were non or pre vedic inhabitants of India (roughly 70% of the population according to DNA analysis) have an impact on religion, customs and traditions? It's absurd to think that the local population had no impact on tradition custom and religious practices.
Proto Shiva is not JUST Rudra. There can be and obviously are more than 1 influence that have been syncretised into the modern or even the Puranic Shiva ( and most other Hindu Gods/Godesses). Edit: This is not to say that it is Pashupatinath or Shivlingam as one would far more concrete proof for such claims.
Other than this point I must say I enjoy your videos quite a bit.
PS Yagya Havans were supposed to be destroyed/ unassembled post use.
Not sure which historian you've been reading but if course Shiva is an amalgamation of rudra and a local mountain deity, I had looked at Shiva in detail here scroll.in/article/844874/how-shiva-was-transformed-from-a-meat-loving-deity-to-a-vegetarian-god
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika wow kya overconfidence hai , kuch bhi guess work maro aur amalagamation karo aur scroll mei article print krr ke hero bnn jao 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Very few channels like you are advocating truth, otherwise har taraf Jhoot ka bol baala hai aaj kal to.😊
Mam aapake sikhane ka tarika bohotahi acchha hai
Kash muze apase face to face padhane ka mauka mil sakata
Aap apane pure emotion ke sath sikhate hai isase hame topic acchhe se samajane me madat milati hai
Shukriya
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchikaaap college professor ho ya school teacher??
@@Playerone1287 ye Delhi University me assistant professor hai
Great job again! Keep them coming. 👍👍👍
Thanks
Keep your papers ready termite
Very nice 👌👍👏😀Dr. Ruchika Sharma 😘 Guruji Bless you always 😘 🙏 ❤ ♥ 💖 💕
Thank you!
Baaji aap mujhe bht psnd hain, Allah paak aapke ilm mein bht tarkki de...
Aameen ❤
🙏🏻🙏🏻
Madam if there is any lectures or classes for public please let it be known in advance so that i can attend. Like to meet you.
Hello mam, I hope you will make more videos if more evidence emerges even if it is contrary to what you are saying now. Or any new revelation is there. Thanks btw. Nice Video:)
Also one suggestion for the next video can be about the so called golden period of Indian history - the Gupta Empire: social organization, myths related to it and reality which should be widely known.
Thanks for the suggestion
Sanatan sameeksha ki latest video dekho in madam ko expose kar diya hai😂
Very informative with supporting links to the sources.
Thanks
Another juicy topic would be discuss the linguistic history. Myths about Sanskrit as oldest language, comparison to Pali, Tamil. Timeline of rig veda and whether it's really a subcontinent document or imposed on us and came from Tigris or how it misses the key geographical features n biodiversity of the subcontinent which is right side of indus
Thanks for the suggestion
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika there are around 57 izlmic majority countries, 1.8 billion of them , they dont need an infidel woman supporter , whom they wouldn't hesitate to rpe n mrder
But a woman frm India who happens to have hindu name , is working hard to denigrate her own heritage but keeps licking the toilet seat of izlmics
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika even a so called red light area worker is more useful and loyal to their country than filth which crawls out from gutter filled with faeces of desert dwellers , who have wrecked genocide and destruction on any land they set their foot upon
None speaks for yezidis , zoroastrians, hindus who faced unimaginable religious persecution
But filth speaks for 1.8 billion roaches who need no support , they can wreck any country on will.
Europeans have learnt about desert dwelling cockroaches recently and now all right wing parties are getting elected
@@ameykazo4194 Go watch BeerBiceps for your history lesson.
Mohenjodaro me audi car bhi mili chhupa kyu rahe ho!!!!!!!!!!
😢😢
Good to see the 4 Myth busted effectively👍. The memes concept in this video was hilarious especially Modiji crying 😂
Hehe, thanks! :)
Thanks 🙏 🥰 good knowledge
उगल दिया तेरे टिचर का नाम रोमिला थापर मैं सोच ही रहा था. तुम्हारी बाते तूम्हारी बातो से ही काटी जा सकती है वांगपंती दीदी. तुम्हे पता होकर भी झूठ बोलती हो. और कितने बेबी है तुम्हारे दर्शक जो इतने साफ विरोधाभास को नही पकड सकते
Thank you for sharing this topic.
Hello madam, isn't easter island's undeciphered script similiar to indus script...
Plz make video on history and authenticity of puranas
Thank you 🙌🏻 for busting myths 🔥
Thanks for watching
Ma'am please make playlist according to topic . thank you.
I have made many playlists according to topic, you can check them in playlist section. I will add this to Indus valley playlist soon
madam! har Indian archaeological surveys me ved, puran, ramayan, mahabharat ko jodne ke piche kiska haath hota hai or iske picche ka maksad kya hai? plz bataiye...
Iska jawab Maine ek aur video mein Diya hai, ye raha th-cam.com/video/tEDzd7jxQV0/w-d-xo.html
Truth loving people are beyond religious biases. Subscribed the channel.❤
Lovely episode...extra ordinary...in the end, you sound like amin sayani ..jee haa, bhaiyon aur behno...😂
Congratulations for 10 k suscribe well done
Well do you really think over such a long time span objects would remain intact at their place ( be it shivling or any other object ) ????
People who are 100% sure of their history are threat to humanity. And you seems one of them. Historical objects need interpretation and historican does that why because there can't be 100% surity of any object.
😂😂😂lol that's call fallacy
There are evidence of earliest text had found bodies had found Buddhist stupa and monastery had found but not a shiva penis or shiva ling be found in the whole indus civilization
Khali shiv ling ko hi gayab hona tha ha 😂
@@kafka1343 Abey gonchu aadmi shivling like structures mile hai ,, its just that leftists don't say it's shivling , you can see it for yourself ,, by the tuje pata hai na buddhism is dominated by Brahmins also , check the names of Buddhist scholars they are all Brahmins , proud Brahmins tu kham kha buddhism ka chachu na bnnn 😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@kafka1343😂 lol that buddhist stupa was made by kanishka every historians said that 😂
Very informative video.... Please keep it on
Excellent work. Thank you!
Interesting as always. I have noticed that many channels and podcast that make shows on ‘Debunking Aryan Invasion’ at tactly avoid using the term ‘Aryan Migration’ and prefer ‘Steppe Pastoralist (SP)’. I was listening to Dr. Niraj Rai on TRS and he was confident that Haplogroup R1a (SP Marker) migrated from India to the west. What would you say to that?
Niraj's own paper in Science contradicts that, please ask Neeraj to get his name removed from that paper and then we'll talk
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika I could sense something fishy when he deliberately avoided revealing the fact that R1a & ANI is found in higher percentage in upper caste/Indo-European language speaking people and that ASI in lower caste & Dravidian people. I think he did so considering how it is a sensitive subject and the political upheaval it can cause if looked through the lens of caste. Thankfully I got to know about David Reich's research and got an outside perspective.
I dont know that that seal is Pashupati or not but Vedic god Rudra is definitely known as Pashupati. In rudra path kram word Pashupati, Ashvapati come many times.
The Indus Valley lay abandoned for 400 years until 1500bc when pastorolist from Europe and Central Asia settled the area bringing new language and the Vedic culture. Other male biased groups entered the indo gangetic plain mixed with the native hunter gatherers giving rise to the ANI
Very nice video. Keep doing the work
Madam, thanks again for busting the well established myths. I request you to make an elaborate ( if needed ) episode on " Dravidians are pure Indians " / " Dravidian culture has resemblance with Mohenjodaro civilization" / " Aryans drove Indians to the South".
अब एक हड्डी के टुकड़े जीवस्म से ये पता भी लगा लिया जाए की सिंधु घाटी की सभ्यता और वहां के लोगों के अंदर का वातावरण कैसा था तो इससे वर्तमान समाज को क्या मिल जाएगा,,मैडम यूट्यूब मे इसे बड़बड़ाना छोड़ कर मॉडलिंग करो,आप इसी काम के लिए पैदा हुई हो,, श्रृंगार करने वाली देवी🌻
Aap sahi hain
Inke Bhagwan AMU ka Midvale history department hai
Ye sabhi Mughals ko glorify karti hain
Ancient Indian history ko complete mith manti hain aur
Naget karti hain
Aik mitti ke sikke par tiger aur usse bachta kisan saari raat ke liye Bel fal ke tree par upper baitha dikhai deta hai
Aisa alag alag 18 sikkon par same katha nazar aati hai
Yeh Labdakh ki katha hai aur isi se inspired ho kar Shiv ratri
Ka parb manana shuruaat hui
Same isi Labdakh ki carvings indonesia me bhi milti hai
Is vital jankari ko mahodaya chhipa gain
JNU ki jo hain
Hey mam , I’m population genetic , history and archaeology enthusiast…..My caste is Ror which have highest steppe ancestry in South Asia . I live near Kurukshetra .
I wanna share you something important which I observe uh always miss in your video …Vedic land - Haryana
Actually, there are more than hundred of archeological site (Painted Grey Ware ) in Kurukshetra Kaithal jind hisar district of Haryana which was also part of kuru kingdom.
All those sites has carbon dating on average 1000 BCE .
These sites are mostly on palaeochannel of tributaries of Saraswati . One thing which strange about my region is that you will find good quality water in these area …rest of Haryana doesn’t have that much good water table and water quality .You can also check ISRO report for more info .
What do u want to say?
@@amkai2928 I can’t explain everything in single comment …
I am not able to view this episode beyond 4 mins.. It’s not an internet problem. The video is getting stuck..
Is it just me?
Tell us about mystery of chandragupta maurya caste and his mother's origins
क्या कोई अपने परिवार के पूरे इतिहास को पूर्णतः जानता है? 🤔
वक़्त के साथ है मिट्टी का सफ़र सदियों से
किस को मालूम कहाँ के हैं किधर के हम हैं-निदा फ़ाज़ली
Secret of sainauli k upar ak video plz.... 🙏🏻
Debate करना है तुमसे खुले मंच पर इतिहास पर बोलो करोगी वहा मेरे साथ पुरातत्व विभाग के लोग रहेंगे।
Dr. Sharma, perhaps you have addressed this in a prior video, but if burial was the customary form of disposal of the dead in Harappa and Mohenjodaro, were those people not precursors of Hindus, who favor cremation?
Obviously, they had very little to do with the Vedic people that came from the Steppes 500 years after IVC's decline
stepps 😂 😂 jnu se aishehi jhoote historian aate hai
@@ajitskar586At least better then Godi Tubers & WhatsApp Universities😂😂😂😂
@@raksshitom2699
Ye historian whatapp university graduate se worst hai 😂 😂
Ruchi kaun karega ap sey shaadi beta! 😂 ego hurt hojayega!
Great work. Highly appreciate the pain and effort that goes behind so much research and swimming against the tide.
Bach ke rehna... Shayhar aur gaon mein yehi shor hai "Ayega tho Jahel hee" 😂
Thanks
Mp / rajasthan / chattisgarh ---- tel ki maalish krr lo ,,, abba jaan aa rahe hai 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@caa_nrcgaye bachao 😂😂ja ke tere abbu niptane wale hai
😂😂
@@caa_nrcor star of David lagaye ho to ek baar David or unke senior prophet moses ke polytheist ke liye pyaar dekh lena maja aa jayega 😂😂old testament se
@@caa_nrcLindu
When human race entered into agricultural society leaving hunting gatherer livelihood individual property concept developed. So Harrappan civilization must be economical and social hierchi.
Liked for Sakhi Shahbaz Qalandar and the research work you put ❤🎉
Please talk about Mehergarh and it's connections with Persia and Mesopotamia and Indus Valley Civilization
What about lajja gouri found in harappa
Can you add english subtitles
Yes will be up by tomorrow evening
That's a beautiful explanation 😊. But miss can you make video on
how Sanskrit is evolves?
What's the origin of Sanskrit?
Sanskrit ke oldest evidence kya hai?
BHS (Buddhist hybrid Sanskrit) oldest hai ki Sanskrit?
Thanks for the suggestion
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika I am UPSC pass student from 2019 batch aur hamare sir ne khaa thaa ki history ko phir say padhna. It's totally different from the syllabus. Thanks Mam you are helping me so much 🙏🏻..
@@pankajkumarpk4827 I never said Sanskrit is the oldest 🤷🏻♀️
@@pankajkumarpk4827 I know that brother! Maine research kiye hai Sanskrit pai Rig Veda ki oldest script bhi 1464 AD ki hai I just read that UNESCO research paper. I just want a perfect explanation on this topic..
Buddhist hybrib sanskrit 😂😂😂😂😂😂 teri mummy ne banayi thi ya papa ne
Nice आपका video देखकर इतिहास की झुठ बाते हम सच मानते थे thanks madem
Please make vidio on end of ivs
Thanks for the suggestion
B&D was epic 😂😂. There one research from a lady she has prove that Minakshi temple’s architecture is same as Mohanjodaro city’s architecture is same. Could you please elaborate on ?
Aap bhi multitasking at its best hain ma'am 😊
well made video and interesting info. Maam there are some who believe that description of Saraswati as perennial is just poetic hyperbole in Rigveda, not a literal meaning. In the context of how Rigveda is written there is some merit to this, which could still be consistent with the river being Gaggar Hakra, or at least part of it. Do you have any opinion on this?
Yes Saraswati could possibly be just a mythical river
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika Where does the attribution of the geographical Saraswati come from then? Is it based on any other textual geographic descriptions? Or have we simply guessed that the dried up course of Gaggar-Hakra is the likeliest match of what was once called Saraswati?
@@Anon999-qk3ue scholars have made the comparison based on the description of the river in the rig Veda and of course linguistic similarities in the ancient name of the Helmand river, Haraikhwati
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika and one more question, can you link to any reference regarding the recent genetic studies on Aryan peoples? I think you referenced some significant study with has given insights, but I can't remember that name
@@Anon999-qk3ue the studies and their links are mentioned in the description box of this episode th-cam.com/video/EpR9FAcsReM/w-d-xo.html
Superb analysis,,,,
Mam can you please discuss about Graham Hancock works.
No evidence of Swasrati river.
Beautiful and great research madam,
Greetings from Pakistan.
I am from Afghanistan. I have been reading about my country’s history and its indigenous people. So far, studies shows that Tajiks are indigenous people of the land but I couldn’t find transcripts about Pashtun or Pathan (Pashtuns way of life is completely different from Tajiks) and Hazaras (Hazaras are in the center of Afghanistan and their facial features aren’t similar to Tajiks and Pashtuns. They look more like Chinese) and also there are Buddha statues in Afghanistan as well as Tajikustan. Does this mean that Tajiks who are aryans were Buddhist or Hindus before? I will be very grateful if you make a video about it.
Areas such as Taxila and Gandhara (modern Kandahar) were under the dominions of kings such as Ashoka, who himself became a Buddhist, doesn't mean everyone living in that area was necessarily a Buddhist. In all probability they were worshipping multiple gods
Regarding Pashtuns or Pathans , there's also a theory that they belong to one of the 12 tribes of Israel. You probably know how Jews witnessed multiple expulsions throughout history
मैडम कृपया आप सनातन समीक्षा चैनल पर जाकर अपने तमाम तथ्यों को विधिवत समीक्षा कर सकती हैं । हमें इन्तजार रहेगा। यदि वास्तव में आप प्रोपोगण्डा नहीं फैला रहीं हैं तो आप अवश्य पधारेंगी , यदि आप नहीं आती तो आपके सारे तथ्य झुठे माने जाएंगे।
13:02 Shivling
Vary nice mam❤
Naliyo mai nhi mile kitni jhute hote hai leftist yar puri vdo m jhut hi bola h, isne unhi itihaaskaar ko coat kiya h jo leftist hai,
Naliyon mein mile hai yeh baat archaeologist HD Sankalia ne kahi thi, imagine calling Sankalia leftist 🤣🤣
Btw I don't if it's your forte or even if you're up for the challenge but would love a more cohesive/ story telling style video covering what we know about IVC both from daily life/ social organisation etc. and also how the civilization kept changing over hundreds of years.
Thanks for the suggestion
To madam John Marshall and B Lal ko sikha rhi hai archaeology 😂😂 lamdi
Angrez Pooja kahin aur jakar karein, John Marshall ke fan
Hahaha😂 Jin JNU professors ki aap Pooja karti hain wo unhi angrezo ke sajde karte hain😂
Sorry for watching it after 4 days
Madam hme b history janne ki icha hai pr agr koi sach btaye to pr me 1 aur channel hai jinki video dekhta hu pr unhone apko fake historian btaya abi samaj hi nhi aata kiski sune halanki Hadapa pr unki rai aur apki rai similar hi hai muje lagta hai pehle ap historian logo me apas me debate honi chahiye jo jeete uski sunni chahiye fr hi hmare jaise log jinko history ki knowledge nhi kus payenge nhi to bekar hai sab
Lol, kaunsa channel hai ye? Kya woh channel historian chala Raha hai, jiske paas history ki degree ho?
mughal shabd ka history ke bare mein bhi bataien
True and genuine...
Hello Ruchika. I read a claim somewhere that caste system began in IVC. Is this true or false? Please suggest some readings on this. Thanks in advance
There is no caste system available in indus velley civilization
Was saraswati haraxavati? No
Publishing in 20th November 2019
A paper titled"on the existence of a perenial river in the harappan heartland" has proved beyond doubt that ghagra hakkar was indeed saraswati.
Now coming to why rigvedic description of saraswati is given as mighty raging river.The answer is simple: exaggeration
This is the reasoning that proffesor stephanie jamison agrees too in her book
Absolutely incorrect, theres no such paper that proves that. Do tell us the link/author name of this fanciful paper, lol
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika search the title I have given it.
Article number 17221
Authors: anirban chatterjee, anil d shukla, kanchan pande
Published in nature.
@@anchitbose4151 that paper says "can be correlated with Saraswati" 🤦🏻♀️ thats not proof that it was Saraswati
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika no proof helmand was saraswati either. The more mainstream view correlates saraswati with ghaggar harka paleo channel. This view was also well accepted by mueller.
@@anchitbose4151 lol, Mueller! Yes there's immense proof that Helmand was Saraswati, not only is Helmand still alive (perenniality beyond a doubt) but also the linguistic similarity between Haraikhwati and Saraswati, in fact Thapar et al have done an excellent job of connecting the two. You may want to read that instead of random correlations
Harrpa civilization agr naturae calamity s hua toh y kitabe kse bch gye? Bc itne bde bde mndir bch gye or itni purani civilization jo ek alg he level ki thi vo khtm jo gye hian?..or itni sari kitabe kosne bhgwn n likh di?..they came & destroyed great harrpa civilization y kitna v bche but such yhi rhega
Aap Jaisi teacher hoo toh main toh extra class bhi lunga( vaise i am a history lover, bass apne husan ki tarif kar raha tha 😅😅)
That study on bone tissue analysis was so brilliant, this is why I love this channel. Always helps me learn something completely new even on a topic that I know a lot about
Thank you!
" that I know alot about" nothing more hilarious than this
Please make video on which evidence rigveda is considered 1500 bce
And video was funny that pheko pheko 😂
Hehe, thank you for the suggestion
All your verdicts are based on assumption too ....
For instance please share any link to the scientific evidence that shows the epidemic please
Didi apne joo babri masjid pee video ,banaya tha usspe kuch counter points hee ..
App ekbar - *soch by mohak , *Nitish Rajput inn dono kaa Ram mandir kaa video dekh liye ,22 /1/24 koo same day par released huya hee ,
AP kaa counter point kee liye community post pee wait karung gaa
Thanks
Thanks
You mean to say arya invasion theory is true, When India came to India, why didn't they rule? After the arrival of Aryan Buddhism spread throughout India for two thousand years. This is called Arya invasion theory or Buddha invasion theory.
Maybe Aryans threw those shivlings on drainage as they disapprove of phallus worship