Appreciate the guest for not getting irritated by her interruptions. He also very patiently answered her jumping interruptions without changing his pace or thought. Real genius. Thank you.
@@av1421the viewers are not some dumb people. The people who will listen to almost a two hour long conversation on archaeology will be those who are ready to listen to an expert and get some in depth information. This is not an interview with some dumb Bollywood guest. She should have just allowed him to complete his sentences and not interrupted his flow of thoughts
The interruptions did get irritating and while I like free flowing interviews it's easy to lose track of your thoughts. Dr. Manjul's clarity in thought process and focus is commendable.
Smita, if you would have allowed him to speak more without interrupting him with questions, we would have gathered more information. A piece of feedback to you: your questions were inspired by discredited theories because of which his answers kept getting derailed. I would recommend that you bring him back to the forum and let him speak more with minimal questions. Please take this as constructive feedback, for I appreciate and applaud the work that you have been doing.
I do agree with you because Smita Prakash has this tendency of derailing the ppl who are nationalists or may have teeny-weeny leanings towards sanatani ideology because she wants to prove to the leftists that she is not a “sanghi” or pro bjp as they give these tags to neutral or centrist journalists to throw them off guard.
It's natural for her to interrupt. Just find her tweets in 2010 and you can find her real source of enrichments.... E.g her tweet 21st September, 2010 at 14:18 hours wrote... Instead of 'bhavya mandir' can we build several bhavya IITs and IIMs? Integrity in character is the foundation of our Dharma... Sometimes it's required to be an excellent listener instead of a verbose speaker.
He also mentioned India 🇮🇳. And let me tell you that Kamarupa (Kamakhya) Region is always called as a part of Bharatvarsh. So consider yourself as Bhartiya (Indian).
@@RaviChaudhary-ys2rebetween 300bc Ashoka and upto about 1100ad south india kings... People only used the name jambudweep for India. If at all, bharatvarsh for india is a name after 1500ad may be.
Real worried about what he is speaking and projecting as expert with his abrahamic though process lens. And expert should talk about evidences presented and not present conjunctures and then pick evidences and try force fit them.
@@VedaSay Evidence is not that important mr stupid. First throw your brain and eyes out and be a bhakt like us and then talk... Everything will make sense then.
Why so concerned with someone's skin colour if their logic is sound I will listen to them. I reject everyone who claims rejec foreigners and only listen to them because they are Indian.
I’m a regular listener of this podcast and I’ve a constructive criticism for Smita ji. Please let the interviewee complete his answer. Making a note of your questions and following up with them would be very much appreciated. Great people are called on this podcast but it would not help if they can’t complete their answers completely. A slower interview with a bit more patience would help.
Exactly. There are so many sentences in this interview that Smitha didn’t allow Sanjay ji to complete. She is constantly interrupting. We have missed out on a lot of information due to these interruptions. Smitha ji, please call him back and allow him to speak
Sahi baat... interesting baat batane jate hai to buch me kudne se wo baat gayab ho gai. Itna interruption joking material jaise Sushant sareen, Abhijeet takla etc ke sath chalta hai lekin jab aap intellectual aur wo bhi Aryan invasion theory ko debunk karne wale ko bulate ho to unko bolne dijiye pura.
same bro same... the scholar was saying so much informative stuff but this women interrupts with the most trivial questions which are so obvious. I m just halfway through, but I am angry at her for being so annoying....
Dhurt Tum log ho brahmanon Ne acchi Shiksha Dene ki koshish ki samaj mein Thode Si bechare Brahman vah Kisi ka Kya Bura kar sakte the thoda dimag se soch liya karo
I found Dr. Sanjay Manjul to be very knowledgeable.... learned a lot today ... we need more experts like him to educate the public. We should stop paying attention to what the "Westerners" say. Most of the Westerners have their own agenda ... and their own self interest...
Over 100 episodes of ANI poadcast but I have to say this us the most educational podcast of ANI till date. The embedded false History of every Indian was evident in Smita ji's questions but the manner and patient by which Dr Sanjay answered and cleared the falsehood around "Eminent Historians " theories was a delight to watch. Thank You ANI for this gem
I was thinking of watching a documentary about the findings of sanauli and rakhigarhi lately and suddenly saw this podcast totally love this and the way Sanjay sir has explained about findings and its correlations. it's a big slap on coffee room historians who were parroting the lines of Britishers. Bharat is the ancient civilization and today's sanatan dharma is a continuation of that civilization, Mahabharat and Ramayan are our history. Thanks a ton for this great insightful podcast with ADG ASI Dr Sanjay sir he's so articulate worth watching 🙏
Difficult thing is Indian history is present at places which are currently lived by many people like dense cities and in some cases it is so much old that many archives may have fully decomposed. It’s still good to see that Indian archival teams are doing independent thinking jobs now, it will help us find better historical perspective.
Madam request you to please give English script . I am sure it will reach many millions more. I live in TN. It seems easier to follow English than Hindi.
Great topic.. thankyou Smita ji for inviting Sanjay Kumar Manjul ji . Now take a minute and reconsider the amount of BS we Indians have been taught in our history books....be it Modern Indian History or Medieval or Ancient. The amount of lies put in our mind and younger generation to make us cripple mentally. Oh God! What kind of sick people we had surrendered our education system to! But thankfully slowly but brightly The Truth is coming out in light for our future generations to see,read and realise the amount of Purusharth our ancestors did. Vande Mataram. Har Har Mahadev 🙏
We think Moenjodaro and Harappa were discovered in the 1920s. This is wrong. It was discovered almost 100 years earlier and the British rushed a team to Iraq (Mesopotamia) as a consequence. When they realised the significance of the findings (out of India) they not only spent the next few decades removing all evidence of the link and then used what remained as ballast for the Lahore-Multan railway, they also partitioned India to keep the sites in the hands of "fellow Abrahamics"! Why was this so important for them? The origins of known civilizations demolished the carefully built narratives around what was projected to be the roots of "Western Christian Identity"! Partition was an elaborate coverup!
Among the best discussions I have seen on this topic. Thank you so much Dr. Sanjay. Smita Ji you played the role of the typical sicular historian, very well ❤
Bahot dino bad kuch asa sunane ko mila ki ye baat our age sunane ko mile Sir ka awaj bhi bahot badiya hai Really it is a nice interview madam ka bahot shukriya
Thank you for this wonderful opportunity to understand the history of our civilisation. I could not understand the whole conversation. May I request an English translation, please. My ancestors left India in 1844. We were colonised my the British and we lost our connection with our family in India. While, we know the Malaya language and Chinese dialects and English we do not know many other languages. Please assist if possible. Thank you Smita. Prakash.
We are always listening to people who speak very well and hence seem to know a lot. Dr. Majul is a true example of how the ' simplest' of explanations hide a genius mind. Thank you Sir for your work for bringing me to my history.
Vampanthiyo ne Arya ko bahri batane ke liye pura jivan laga diya jabki Arya hamare hi purvaj the aur ye ek sambhodhan tha jiska matlab gyani, Shrestha hota hai. Aaj bhi Arya bola ja sakta hai jaise mahoday, mahashay bolte hai lekin vampanthiyo aur unke chelo ko koun samjhaye.
People definitely migrated to india. But didn't influence the indian culture and languages but rather got inspired from it and advanced and promoted it more@goddalehundibharathraj4374
@@djsejwal2 the steppe pastoralists have definitely influenced most of North Indian languages. They had no influence on the IVC people, they definitely borrowed many things from IVC but they also bought many new things.
There is no evidence for any Culture or language the steppe people have introduced in India. Only assumptions. The entire backbone of this theory is a bunch of assumptions like a non existant PIE which we have no evidence of. We have no evidence of their Culture. Only some assumptions and whataboutery. Even the paper on AMT itself is shady considering how the calculations for median age was done so that it fits with the timeframe of the aforementioned AMT. If the median age goes up or above by a few digits it become too late or too early for a supposed Aryan Picnic. Not only that the Steppe people had east Asian ancestry. But Indians have no trace of any east Asian. The only logical explanation is that the Shakas/Scythians who show a decreasing gradient of East Asian ancestry from east to west gave us our Steppe Ancestry. Not only that multiple invasions have been recorded in our history such as the Huns, The Scythians, The Greeks etc. Who indeed had steppe ancestry. So it seems more plausible that the aforementioned groups gave us Indians our Steppe ancestry and not the Steppe pastorialists as their number is quite insignificant to introduce steppe ancestry in all of Indians. So this throws out the Idea of yours that Dravidians were the IVC people and Aryans introduced Sanskrit and whatever bs you guys concoct. @@goddalehundibharathraj4374
Thank you Smita ji for bringing Dr. Manjul on the podcast. Now we are uncovering logically with proper evidence of our great heritage. Great learning for us.🎉
Dr. Manjul has excellent knowledge of the subject. He has supported the finding with contents of our Vedic literature, Mahabharat, archeological findings at Harappa, Mesopotamia sites, Bharain sites. Brilliant man, brilliant work. And smart questions from Smita.
@@mindudorjeenaksang3014Lol..even the Western historians put it to 1500BC and you self-proclaimed whatsApp university professor claim it to be of 12th-13th cent AD? 😂
Hi Smitha ,Kindly allow Dr.Sanjay to complete his conversation , during the course of the podcast you literally overwhelmed his conversation & didn't allow him to close the convrersation. But that apart, hats off to you for getting Dr.Sanjay on board for this podcast , it was basically unlearning our rote history taught to us from school history text & now through this podcast we are getting to know the real history ,(loved the gyan about the dark ages btw 800 BC -1200 bc & how we can fiil it up with facts in future)
Should've asked about archeology in southern India. Most of these sites are in the north but we are curious to know what was happening in the south back then
"What an amazing podcast!" I just wanted to say congratulations on producing one of the best episodes to yet. Dr. Sanjay Kumar Manjul's discoveries were very insightful, bringing a level of knowledge that definitely set this episode apart. Special thanks to ANI for organizing such an excellent discussion. Congratulations to the entire staff on generating content that keeps us engaged and informed. I look forward to more wonderful episodes in the future!
Smita My first time listing to your podcast. First of all thank you so much for bringing this podcast. I have been listening to podcasts on this subject but this one is the far BEST. Thank you so much Dr. Sanjay Manjul your way of explaining is very detailed with such calm and sweet voice. Thank you so much . I learned so much from this podcast. And Smita your voice sounds so beautiful and thanks for asking so many intelligent questions. I will have to listen to this again to absorb all the info. THE BEST PODCAST ARCHEOLOGY. 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
आर्कियोलॉजी के field में हमारे मध्यप्रदेश के जबलपुर में डॉ. आर. के . शर्मा जी हैं वे मेरे Guide रहे हैं !!! मैं भी india की ५ collagists में से हूँ !! भोपाल में मेरा महत्वपूर्ण समय बीता है , और चित्रकला की प्रोफेसर होकर रिटायर हुई हूँ !!! आपसे मिलना चाहूँगी !! मैंने डॉ. विष्णु श्रीधर वाकनकर के साथ भी काम किया है !!
सर, बहुत बढ़िया। भाषाई दृष्टिकोण से भी मैं कहता हूँ कि भारतीय पुरातत्व पर आपका दृष्टिकोण तार्किक रूप से सही है। सर, एक बात जो मैं आपकी बातचीत में जोड़ना चाहता हूँ। हमारे पास एक ऐसी भाषा है जो संस्कृत-पूर्व भाषा लगती है। ऐतिहासिक सरस्वती और सिन्धु नाम उपरोक्त भाषा के मूल नाम हैं और मिस्र के पिरामिड के लिपिबद्ध अभिलेखों से यह सिद्ध होता है कि यह भाषा उतनी ही पुरानी है जितनी मिस्र सभ्यता की भाषा पुरानी है।
Because “popular” media is full of s$&t. They are called popular media for a reason because they focus on what the majority want to see and a lot of people don’t care or not interested in anything beyond what affects their lives or celebrity/cricket culture. It’s unfortunate but the truth. Let’s be glad there are parts of podcasts and social media that is working to bring out the truth.
It was really enlightening to know the various techniques and how theories are deduced. Very beautifully explained. Ms. Smita very responsibly brought out the topic alive with apt questions.
From a person born in Rajput family in Pakistan, whose ancestors were from Rajasthan area is deeply interested in ancient civilizations of Subcontinent I am proud to be of this civilization rather than Arab or Turk invaders. I will never know why my ancestors came to this part of this beautiful Subcontinent and will not judge them. Harapa and Mohenjodaro are treasures just like Dholavera and Hiryana ones.
I know bro we the subcontinent people were much advance than contemporary civilization like Mesopotamia and egypt . And as u know Europe then was just barbaric land 😂😂. We subcontinental people should be proud of our ancestors despite difference in religion which really doesn't matter in ethnicity
Abhinandan Dr. Sanjay Kumar Manjul ji your finding and interpretations have negated the Aryan Invasion hypothesis and brought out the truth of Ramayana and Mahabharata. Bharatvarsh is proud of you.
If you do not have pride in your ancestors tgen you are either someone who is afflicted with inferiority complex or someone who's unaware/confused about hos paternity.@@stuv_wx
One of the very informative interviews. Please call many such scientists on the show. Being a doctorate in Chemistry I am very happy to see such eminent scientists on the show. Also please call Nilesh Nilakath Oak who dated Ramayana and Mahabharat. Convey this message to Smita Ju.
Very informative, very scientific and knowledge oriented podcast, I must thank Smitaji for asking right & genuine questions at right moment, kudos & thanks to the guest for answering and sharing very insightful knowledge with us. 👏👏👏👏👏👏👍
This is an interesting and important podcast; unfortunately, for those who don't understand Hindi, there aren't even English sub titles to help them know what is being discussed. This omission excludes them completely.
A nice slap to historian who always misinterpreted the Indian history. Great respect for people who go on ground for excavation. New ncert syllabus need to remove the aryan invader theory. Now Dravidians will no longer have anything to cry on, how north and south is divided. And how aryan forced their culture on them.
Ms. Smitha Prakash, Your subject video, your choice of the narrator, ie. Shri Sanjay Manjul and your questions put to him are very valid, brilliant and scintillating. It seemed as if I were myself asking questions which has racked my brains for many years. I would like to put my own theory of the Indian civilisation as I see it. There is no doubt that we can trace our ancestry to Africa. But there were two streams, one coming to India via the sea route from Magadascar and the other coming through the land route, from Kenya. At that time the continents had begun to drift apart. The sea route people were short and sturdy while the land route people were tall} and lanky. They maintained different cultural outlook. In Kenya there is s snow covered mountain called Killimanjaro, shortenened Kailas, by the Indians. They worshipped the dead, i.e., ancestral worship. Where the lanscape lacked mountains, they created stone grave edifices. The Pyramids are a replica of the mountains. The Magdascaran people who came by sea, cremated their dead, or put their remains in mud cisterns, buried them underground. You can see such sites in Kerala. The differencec between these two migrators was that the people in the south believed in the soul which returned to earth after a cycle. Hence on one auspicios date they would offer these souls good food, while the Kenyans believed that they would enter snother world and the descendents would would furnish them with food, weaons, servants etc to accompany them in the next world. Such belief gave rise to the gods, Indira, Varuna, Vayu, Agni etc. You can see the connections of words like, Simha, (lion), Shul (spear), Shav (dead body) and Shiv (god) associated with the Kailas mountain. There are many more thoughts to be shared with you, but later.
Smita Ji ko dhanyvad Manjil ji se mulakat karvane ke lea. Ek bahut hi gyanvardhak aur shandar guest Jo Bharat ke shandar atit ko bahar la rahe hain dhanyvad
I urge you to read an article in Swarjyamag. It clearly debunks the entire paper and exposes the shady shit the researchers like Reich and Narasimhan did the push their agenda.
lol he did not even published the study which he was makin statement in the interviews .. !! still that paper did not got published .. !! Why don't invite Dr. david reich to the podcast .. !!!
Excellent presentation by Dr. Manjul. Why don't we start calling these civilizational discoveries as Bharatiya civilization and then divide geographic areas for Harappa, Rakhigarhi, etc.? It will help us and future generations think in a unified way, and also help us set proper correct narrative.
Smita madam , you are now a pioneer. The mainstream media just shut up on this subject.The very prospect of formally challenging the AIT was apparently a no no for the anglicised gentry and public intellectuals which included media , academia and strategic thinkers. It was as though they were kicking the can down the road under the plea that it is early days to conclude anything so why stick our neck out in giving the new thought leaders any chance ? This chapter has to be taken head on. We need massive amounts of multipronged research into archeology , epigraphy , architectural history, metallurgical studies of early bronze age and earlier periods. Now that we are laying a claim to resurrect our collossal civilisation we need hard empirical evidence and ground facts. Govts must be punched into action by mass awareness and pull factor. Please concentrate on a badly neglected subject which is now a policy priority - Indian Knowledge System. Pl interview people like Raghava Krishna founder of Brhat, the Indic reniassance organisation. He is a scintillating intellectual. The pushback against IKS is severe. Pl intervene , bring the subject above the water level. Remember Neera Mishra was solidly prevented from archeologucal excavations in Purana quila for 30 years by the lobby backed by none less than the Aga Khan. They wanted to put the start of the history of Delhi with the Islamic invasions and shut out everything else before that. Please act , you have great credibility. Give the new evidences and scholars a wide berth.
Very good Discussion!. Very true Sundareshan1849. I see wikipedia sinauli site description posted some points which counters this (wikipedia can be disregarded, they have come up with points like cow cart, Aryans migrated earlier etc for 2018 findings ). But a good way should be found by India to publish this finding.
Very beautiful interactive discussion. Dr Sanjay’s narrative on every question raised by Smita ji is to the point, and very convincing. Thanks for this very informative discussion Dr Sanjay and Smita ji.
Well What an proud I was knew it we are the first civilization on the earth 🌎 all credit goes to veda's and Avatar and rishi and scriptures. Thanks to the respectful Sanjay sir Who reminds me Sanjay of Mahabharata who played the same role of the proof 🧾 of Bharat and Mahabharata and our civilization and advanced development and all etc. Kudos and bow down to all above.🙏
खूपच चांगली चर्चा, अर्कालाॅजि डिपार्टमेंटमध्ये कसं काम चालू आहे. आपली रामायण, महाभारत,वेद यांना ईतिहास आहे कि, काल्पनिक? अत्यंत महत्त्वाचे आहे. आभारी आहे.डा.मजूंल यांचे विषेश आभार.
Hi Smitha, Hooe you take this as a constructive criticism but you really need to stop interrupting your guests. The whole point of a podcast is listening to an interview in the long form. The interruptions, even if they are a single word, can break the chain of thought of the guest and puts off the audience as well. You have a great show and a plethora of great guests. Would love to see you make the most of it.
चलिए एक बार को मान लिया कि ईश्वर है, तो फिर सवाल उठता है कि वह सभी धर्मों का एक है या हर धर्म का अलग अलग। अगर हर धर्म का एक अलग ईश्वर है, तो फिर उसका ईश्वरत्व ही सन्देह के दायरे में आ जाता है। और अगर सारे धर्मों का ईश्वर एक है, तो सवाल उठता है कि अलग अलग धर्मों के अपने भक्तों को आपस में लड़ते हुए देखकर वह कुछ करता क्यों नहीं है। दूसरा सवाल यह भी उठता है जीवन, मृत्यु, पुनर्जन्म, आत्मा इत्यादि के बारे में सारे धर्मों के सिद्धान्त एक जैसे क्यों नहीं हैं, जबकि हर धर्म इन से सम्बन्धित अपने सिद्धान्तों को ईश्वरीय ही बताता है। यहाँ हम पुनर्जन्म से सम्बन्धित हिन्दू और इस्लाम धर्मों के सिद्धान्तों को आमने सामने रखकर देखते हैं। हिन्दू धर्म के अनुसार पुनर्जन्म होता है, किन्तु इस्लाम के अनुसार पुनर्जन्म नहीं होता है, जबकि हैं दोनों के सिद्धान्त ईश्वरीय। तो क्या ये बातें यह साबित करने के लिए पर्याप्त नहीं हैं, किये सारे सिद्धान्त ईश्वरीय नहीं बल्कि काल्पनिक हैं और ईश्वर भी ईश्वरीय नहीं बल्कि काल्पनिक है।
Wonderful Smita ji, thanks for this podcast. After all "we are all Harappans" as said by our famous Archeologist Sri Shinde ji. Thanks Dr. SK Manjul ji for sharing great content here. Madam, next plan for a group Podcast with Dr SK Manjul, Dr. Shinde and Ms Rekha Rao?
Kudos to Dr. Manjul that despite the scarcity of fund available in the last decade to Archaeological Survey of India from the Union Government he had concentrated work in some fronts. There is a huge scarcity of such fund in the North East India.
Very informative podcast. Once all the evidence and archaeological findings are conclusively validated, perhaps the ancient history taught in our schools needs to be revisited altogether. This could help us in challenging the Aryan invasion theory, Dravidian civilization, and all other commonly held beliefs.
Smita, extremely interesting program. Scientific. Incisive. Informative. Looking forward to more such programs that would encourage more research on Bhartiya archaeology. Suggest similar program on South Indian Dravidian archaeology
Really. It’s a great episode, I had too much confusion about our history. I think all the Indian are suffering from it . & Through your program clarity is come in my mind . We can solve contemporary topics after knowing real history of India. This should be broadcast at higher levels
Amazing podcast!! It was extremely informative and an eye-opener session.. Any society can grow organically only if you are rooted with its history and culture. With discoveries like Dholavira, Rakhigarhi and Sinauli, it's time or history is re-wtitten and re-told.. and this time from Indian perspective. Thankyou Smita for bringing to us such a brain-storming couple of hours!! Kudos to ASI and the entire team for such valuable discoveries!!
Madam l am a new follower of your page. My humble request is to restrain yourself from interupting the guests so much. Most of your questions were less constructive and more disruptive. He is an expert of his subject. Let him speak and guide him covering all topics. What a great subject you had in this video yet so poorly treated.
@@prakharshankar3064before Buddha utter vadic Aryan lives and they started to fullow many rituals which make society and religion very complex and that's why Buddha and mahavira and ajevika sect raised against the brahmincal supremacy over society
Itihaas . Documentation.. So the Indian Epics are our Itihaasa n they truly describe the entire gamut of our Hostory, Historical Geography, Knowledge, Scientfic, Technological and Material and Alloys Science.. . and Mathematical . , Caculus, Trigonometry , etc. ( Astronomy and Astrology), Medical Advancements. Architecture, . etc. All these are evidenced in them .
Smitaji, firstly thank you for inviting Dr. Manjul for this extremely informative podcast. But one request; please do not interrupt the guest so much. Allow him to complete his answers. No hard feelings please, this was just constructive feedback 🙏🏼
really smitaji your questioning style and relating to present day events is spectacular and very real as if i'm sitting to question the guest , hats off madam
Appreciate the guest for not getting irritated by her interruptions. He also very patiently answered her jumping interruptions without changing his pace or thought. Real genius. Thank you.
She is asking clarifications, for sake of viewers!
@@av1421the viewers are not some dumb people. The people who will listen to almost a two hour long conversation on archaeology will be those who are ready to listen to an expert and get some in depth information. This is not an interview with some dumb Bollywood guest. She should have just allowed him to complete his sentences and not interrupted his flow of thoughts
"those who are ready to listen to an expert " That is some powerful assumption!!!@@smitas65
@@av1421 How did she ask for clarification when she interrupted his answer on chariots to start talking about the Mahabharata??
The interruptions did get irritating and while I like free flowing interviews it's easy to lose track of your thoughts. Dr. Manjul's clarity in thought process and focus is commendable.
Smita, if you would have allowed him to speak more without interrupting him with questions, we would have gathered more information. A piece of feedback to you: your questions were inspired by discredited theories because of which his answers kept getting derailed. I would recommend that you bring him back to the forum and let him speak more with minimal questions. Please take this as constructive feedback, for I appreciate and applaud the work that you have been doing.
I do agree with you because Smita Prakash has this tendency of derailing the ppl who are nationalists or may have teeny-weeny leanings towards sanatani ideology because she wants to prove to the leftists that she is not a “sanghi” or pro bjp as they give these tags to neutral or centrist journalists to throw them off guard.
You guys need to understand that she is being a devil’s advocate by asking the dumb questions that leftists would ask!
It's natural for her to interrupt. Just find her tweets in 2010 and you can find her real source of enrichments....
E.g her tweet 21st September, 2010 at 14:18 hours wrote...
Instead of 'bhavya mandir' can we build several bhavya IITs and IIMs?
Integrity in character is the foundation of our Dharma...
Sometimes it's required to be an excellent listener instead of a verbose speaker.
Agreed !!
Looks like she is trying to show that she has done some homework 😂...
Please be quiet and let the expert comment 🙏🏼
I'm from the north east, based in Guwahati. I was surprised and thankful for mentioning the archaeology of the NE.
He also mentioned India 🇮🇳. And let me tell you that Kamarupa (Kamakhya) Region is always called as a part of Bharatvarsh. So consider yourself as Bhartiya (Indian).
Kamakhya temple is enough evidence of the ancient history of Assam. Also interesting is the story of Chitrangada
@@RaviChaudhary-ys2rebetween 300bc Ashoka and upto about 1100ad south india kings... People only used the name jambudweep for India. If at all, bharatvarsh for india is a name after 1500ad may be.
@@vijayalakshmiiyerexe4546thats not ancient. NE indigenous tribes may be staying there for 5-10,000 years.
@@goddalehundibharathraj4374 of course they have been. I am talking about the cultural evidence of the sanatani civilization
Proud to be a part of rich Bharat ancient civilization.🎉🎉
This man is brilliant!! He is talking very logical. We trust foreigners more than our home grown experts
Real worried about what he is speaking and projecting as expert with his abrahamic though process lens. And expert should talk about evidences presented and not present conjunctures and then pick evidences and try force fit them.
Ààààààaaàaaàa1qqàawwa@@VedaSay
@@VedaSaygood English, stupid conclusion.... please learn a bit more
@@VedaSay Evidence is not that important mr stupid. First throw your brain and eyes out and be a bhakt like us and then talk... Everything will make sense then.
Why so concerned with someone's skin colour if their logic is sound I will listen to them. I reject everyone who claims rejec foreigners and only listen to them because they are Indian.
I counted 7 times that Smita ji interrupted an answer from the knowledge-filled expert. Please let them finish the thought 🙌
I’m a regular listener of this podcast and I’ve a constructive criticism for Smita ji. Please let the interviewee complete his answer. Making a note of your questions and following up with them would be very much appreciated. Great people are called on this podcast but it would not help if they can’t complete their answers completely. A slower interview with a bit more patience would help.
Exactly. She interrupts so much.
Exactly. There are so many sentences in this interview that Smitha didn’t allow Sanjay ji to complete. She is constantly interrupting. We have missed out on a lot of information due to these interruptions. Smitha ji, please call him back and allow him to speak
Sahi baat... interesting baat batane jate hai to buch me kudne se wo baat gayab ho gai.
Itna interruption joking material jaise Sushant sareen, Abhijeet takla etc ke sath chalta hai lekin jab aap intellectual aur wo bhi Aryan invasion theory ko debunk karne wale ko bulate ho to unko bolne dijiye pura.
Smita, Please stop interrupting. And in this podcast it seems you want to somehow prove the western narrative 😊
same bro same... the scholar was saying so much informative stuff but this women interrupts with the most trivial questions which are so obvious. I m just halfway through, but I am angry at her for being so annoying....
नमन ह श्री मान संजय मंजुल जी आप को जो आप हमारे इतिहास को सामने ला रहे है और जोजो जुटी बाते पढ़ाई गई है उनकी सचाई को बताने का समय आ गया है |
Kisne padhai zuthi bate mulniwasi ya dhurt bramhan
Dhurt Tum log ho brahmanon Ne acchi Shiksha Dene ki koshish ki samaj mein
Thode Si bechare Brahman vah Kisi ka Kya Bura kar sakte the thoda dimag se soch liya karo
I found Dr. Sanjay Manjul to be very knowledgeable.... learned a lot today ... we need more experts like him to educate the public. We should stop paying attention to what the "Westerners" say. Most of the Westerners have their own agenda ... and their own self interest...
Thanks!
Please bring more such Personalities, so that we can gain more knowledge about our past.❤❤❤❤❤
Over 100 episodes of ANI poadcast but I have to say this us the most educational podcast of ANI till date. The embedded false History of every Indian was evident in Smita ji's questions but the manner and patient by which Dr Sanjay answered and cleared the falsehood around "Eminent Historians " theories was a delight to watch. Thank You ANI for this gem
I was thinking of watching a documentary about the findings of sanauli and rakhigarhi lately and suddenly saw this podcast totally love this and the way Sanjay sir has explained about findings and its correlations. it's a big slap on coffee room historians who were parroting the lines of Britishers. Bharat is the ancient civilization and today's sanatan dharma is a continuation of that civilization, Mahabharat and Ramayan are our history. Thanks a ton for this great insightful podcast with ADG ASI Dr Sanjay sir he's so articulate worth watching 🙏
All we need to do is decolonize our own minds and quit doing business/patronizing those that mock our ways and history.
Best non noisy interview I ever seen, thanks to host and guest. Very informative.
Difficult thing is Indian history is present at places which are currently lived by many people like dense cities and in some cases it is so much old that many archives may have fully decomposed. It’s still good to see that Indian archival teams are doing independent thinking jobs now, it will help us find better historical perspective.
Totally agree.
And burst the proselytising colonisers narratives peddled as 'Indian History'.
जय श्री राम 💐🌹🙏
Madam request you to please give English script . I am sure it will reach many millions more. I live in TN. It seems easier to follow English than Hindi.
Great topic.. thankyou Smita ji for inviting Sanjay Kumar Manjul ji .
Now take a minute and reconsider the amount of BS we Indians have been taught in our history books....be it Modern Indian History or Medieval or Ancient. The amount of lies put in our mind and younger generation to make us cripple mentally. Oh God! What kind of sick people we had surrendered our education system to!
But thankfully slowly but brightly The Truth is coming out in light for our future generations to see,read and realise the amount of Purusharth our ancestors did. Vande Mataram. Har Har Mahadev 🙏
Namah Parvati Pataiye Har Har Har Mahadev
We think Moenjodaro and Harappa were discovered in the 1920s. This is wrong. It was discovered almost 100 years earlier and the British rushed a team to Iraq (Mesopotamia) as a consequence. When they realised the significance of the findings (out of India) they not only spent the next few decades removing all evidence of the link and then used what remained as ballast for the Lahore-Multan railway, they also partitioned India to keep the sites in the hands of "fellow Abrahamics"! Why was this so important for them? The origins of known civilizations demolished the carefully built narratives around what was projected to be the roots of "Western Christian Identity"! Partition was an elaborate coverup!
💯% agree, the East Europeans took wrong panga with their Indian fathers 🗿
Do you have any evidence of what you said or any authentic source. It may be a hypothesis
Jo bhakt hota hai woh whatsapp padhta hai…wohi source hai
@@tommythomsen2507 Aur jo Church ka ghulam hota hai, woh ek number ka vadwa hota hai.
Ddacfweds@@NativeVsColonial
Among the best discussions I have seen on this topic.
Thank you so much Dr. Sanjay.
Smita Ji you played the role of the typical sicular historian, very well ❤
This is not new for her. She is Totally leftist.
Bahot dino bad kuch asa sunane ko mila ki ye baat our age sunane ko mile Sir ka awaj bhi bahot badiya hai Really it is a nice interview madam ka bahot shukriya
Smitaji lots of love for making this possible. Thank you very much for inviting Manjul Sir.
Dr. Manjul, so learned, soft and well spoken gentleman.
Please invite Dr Niraj Rai and prof Vasant Shinde in this series. Both of them can take this conversation forward. Thanks.
Thank you for this wonderful opportunity to understand the history of our civilisation. I could not understand the whole conversation. May I request an English translation, please. My ancestors left India in 1844. We were colonised my the British and we lost our connection with our family in India. While, we know the Malaya language and Chinese dialects and English we do not know many other languages. Please assist if possible. Thank you Smita. Prakash.
We are always listening to people who speak very well and hence seem to know a lot. Dr. Majul is a true example of how the ' simplest' of explanations hide a genius mind. Thank you Sir for your work for bringing me to my history.
Dr. Manjul is simply amazing! Great interview. Thanks.
Best dialogue of the podcast: "Aap Aryans naam ko bhool jaayiye pehle"
Vampanthiyo ne Arya ko bahri batane ke liye pura jivan laga diya jabki Arya hamare hi purvaj the aur ye ek sambhodhan tha jiska matlab gyani, Shrestha hota hai.
Aaj bhi Arya bola ja sakta hai jaise mahoday, mahashay bolte hai lekin vampanthiyo aur unke chelo ko koun samjhaye.
Harappan Dravidians were the original Aryans. Steppe pastoralists who came with indo-european languages picked up that term here.
People definitely migrated to india. But didn't influence the indian culture and languages but rather got inspired from it and advanced and promoted it more@goddalehundibharathraj4374
@@djsejwal2 the steppe pastoralists have definitely influenced most of North Indian languages. They had no influence on the IVC people, they definitely borrowed many things from IVC but they also bought many new things.
There is no evidence for any Culture or language the steppe people have introduced in India. Only assumptions. The entire backbone of this theory is a bunch of assumptions like a non existant PIE which we have no evidence of. We have no evidence of their Culture. Only some assumptions and whataboutery. Even the paper on AMT itself is shady considering how the calculations for median age was done so that it fits with the timeframe of the aforementioned AMT. If the median age goes up or above by a few digits it become too late or too early for a supposed Aryan Picnic. Not only that the Steppe people had east Asian ancestry. But Indians have no trace of any east Asian. The only logical explanation is that the Shakas/Scythians who show a decreasing gradient of East Asian ancestry from east to west gave us our Steppe Ancestry. Not only that multiple invasions have been recorded in our history such as the Huns, The Scythians, The Greeks etc. Who indeed had steppe ancestry. So it seems more plausible that the aforementioned groups gave us Indians our Steppe ancestry and not the Steppe pastorialists as their number is quite insignificant to introduce steppe ancestry in all of Indians. So this throws out the Idea of yours that Dravidians were the IVC people and Aryans introduced Sanskrit and whatever bs you guys concoct. @@goddalehundibharathraj4374
कितनी भी तारीफ की जाए कम है प्रेजेंटेशन देने वाले मंजूर sir का एवं होस्ट मैडम का
Thank you Smita ji for bringing Dr. Manjul on the podcast. Now we are uncovering logically with proper evidence of our great heritage. Great learning for us.🎉
Listening to this conversation was a most fulfilling experience. Thank you so much. 👌👌👌♥️
Dr. Manjul has excellent knowledge of the subject. He has supported the finding with contents of our Vedic literature, Mahabharat, archeological findings at Harappa, Mesopotamia sites, Bharain sites.
Brilliant man, brilliant work. And smart questions from Smita.
But too much of interruptions
Pls dont try to put vedas in everything..the vedas was just composed in 12-13th century AD
@@mindudorjeenaksang3014Lol..even the Western historians put it to 1500BC and you self-proclaimed whatsApp university professor claim it to be of 12th-13th cent AD? 😂
Vedas were composed 5000 years ago not 14 th century @@mindudorjeenaksang3014
Hi Smitha ,Kindly allow Dr.Sanjay to complete his conversation , during the course of the podcast you literally overwhelmed his conversation & didn't allow him to close the convrersation.
But that apart, hats off to you for getting Dr.Sanjay on board for this podcast , it was basically unlearning our rote history taught to us from school history text & now through this podcast we are getting to know the real history ,(loved the gyan about the dark ages btw 800 BC -1200 bc & how we can fiil it up with facts in future)
Agreed
Should've asked about archeology in southern India. Most of these sites are in the north but we are curious to know what was happening in the south back then
Correct, I have same question
Yes! That would be so interesting!
On Rakhigarhi, DNA scientist Dr. Niraj Rai is the best on world scale.
Dr. Sanjay Manjul is really brilliant Scientist and he replied very well to thorny questions.
Wow such a good podcast. History is such a beautiful subject.
Our school books made sure that history studying was as boring as possible.
Idea: can archaeology be taught in schools and high schools, as part of history? Will it not make history interesting?
@@girishshah8929Yes. But the distorians who used to write put textbooks has made it so that we get bored to death while reading Indian history.
@@buddha9715and we get filled with inferiority complex too...
"What an amazing podcast!" I just wanted to say congratulations on producing one of the best episodes to yet. Dr. Sanjay Kumar Manjul's discoveries were very insightful, bringing a level of knowledge that definitely set this episode apart. Special thanks to ANI for organizing such an excellent discussion. Congratulations to the entire staff on generating content that keeps us engaged and informed. I look forward to more wonderful episodes in the future!
My God So much wealth of Experience and Knowledge. Thank you Smita ji for a wonderful episode
Smita My first time listing to your podcast.
First of all thank you so much for bringing this podcast. I have been listening to podcasts on this subject but this one is the far BEST. Thank you so much Dr. Sanjay Manjul your way of explaining is very detailed with such calm and sweet voice.
Thank you so much . I learned so much from this podcast. And Smita your voice sounds so beautiful and thanks for asking so many intelligent questions. I will have to listen to this again to absorb all the info.
THE BEST PODCAST ARCHEOLOGY. 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
This podcast needs to be watched by every History student.
How many people are really interested in the subject?
आर्कियोलॉजी के field में हमारे मध्यप्रदेश के जबलपुर में डॉ. आर. के . शर्मा जी हैं वे मेरे Guide रहे हैं !!! मैं भी india की ५ collagists में से हूँ !! भोपाल में मेरा महत्वपूर्ण समय बीता है , और चित्रकला की प्रोफेसर होकर रिटायर हुई हूँ !!!
आपसे मिलना चाहूँगी !!
मैंने डॉ. विष्णु श्रीधर वाकनकर के साथ भी काम किया है !!
Amazing findings--👏👏👏👏🙏
सर, बहुत बढ़िया। भाषाई दृष्टिकोण से भी मैं कहता हूँ कि भारतीय पुरातत्व पर आपका दृष्टिकोण तार्किक रूप से सही है।
सर, एक बात जो मैं आपकी बातचीत में जोड़ना चाहता हूँ। हमारे पास एक ऐसी भाषा है जो संस्कृत-पूर्व भाषा लगती है। ऐतिहासिक सरस्वती और सिन्धु नाम उपरोक्त भाषा के मूल नाम हैं और मिस्र के पिरामिड के लिपिबद्ध अभिलेखों से यह सिद्ध होता है कि यह भाषा उतनी ही पुरानी है जितनी मिस्र सभ्यता की भाषा पुरानी है।
Why this knowledge is not in popular media
Because “popular” media is full of s$&t. They are called popular media for a reason because they focus on what the majority want to see and a lot of people don’t care or not interested in anything beyond what affects their lives or celebrity/cricket culture. It’s unfortunate but the truth. Let’s be glad there are parts of podcasts and social media that is working to bring out the truth.
Popular ho jayega to aryan inversion theory ka phir kya hoga jo jame padaya gaya hai
Love the knowledge that I got it about archeology and findings ❤👍👍
It was really enlightening to know the various techniques and how theories are deduced. Very beautifully explained. Ms. Smita very responsibly brought out the topic alive with apt questions.
From a person born in Rajput family in Pakistan, whose ancestors were from Rajasthan area is deeply interested in ancient civilizations of Subcontinent I am proud to be of this civilization rather than Arab or Turk invaders. I will never know why my ancestors came to this part of this beautiful Subcontinent and will not judge them. Harapa and Mohenjodaro are treasures just like Dholavera and Hiryana ones.
Good thought
Rakhigarhi and sinauli bhirana bro
I know bro we the subcontinent people were much advance than contemporary civilization like Mesopotamia and egypt . And as u know Europe then was just barbaric land 😂😂. We subcontinental people should be proud of our ancestors despite difference in religion which really doesn't matter in ethnicity
Thank you. I showed this to my children as well so that their knowledge of bharatiya history is correct.
Loved it, great questions, Smitha. And Guest was patient enough to answer every question. Thanks!
From first 5 mins it looks the 2005-2006 findings were either kept under carpet or a wrong narrative was created..
Deliberately mis-interpreted under political pressure😂
Abhinandan Dr. Sanjay Kumar Manjul ji your finding and interpretations have negated the Aryan Invasion hypothesis and brought out the truth of Ramayana and Mahabharata. Bharatvarsh is proud of you.
This should go viral.
Badiya 👌👌🔥
Very informative 💯
Dhanyawad Dr.Manjul sahab , ANI Team 🙏
Very authentic & enlightening discussion Thank you so much
बहुत ही रोचक और ज्ञानवर्धक पॉडकास्ट था, स्मिता जी। Thanks. 🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️
Thankyou Sir,
Proud of my Hindu Sanatan ancestors.
I believe in my Vedas & Hindu scriptures.
@@stuv_wxi have logic that's why I am feeling proud of my history
If you do not have pride in your ancestors tgen you are either someone who is afflicted with inferiority complex or someone who's unaware/confused about hos paternity.@@stuv_wx
Freeloader says a commie atheist whose entire ideology is based on freeloading@@stuv_wx
@@stuv_wxAnd you are even worse for hoarding hate and contempt for people taking pride in their history.
@@stuv_wxwhy? Any reason that he shouldn't be proud?
One of the very informative interviews. Please call many such scientists on the show. Being a doctorate in Chemistry I am very happy to see such eminent scientists on the show. Also please call Nilesh Nilakath Oak who dated Ramayana and Mahabharat. Convey this message to Smita Ju.
Very informative, very scientific and knowledge oriented podcast, I must thank Smitaji for asking right & genuine questions at right moment, kudos & thanks to the guest for answering and sharing very insightful knowledge with us. 👏👏👏👏👏👏👍
This is one of my favorite posdcast of ANI. Thanks smita ji for bringing genuine scholars
Kya Bataya hai isme
Excellent topic .....long overdue guest,Smita👌👌👌👋👋👋🌹💐🌹💐🌹
This is an interesting and important podcast; unfortunately, for those who don't understand Hindi, there aren't even English sub titles to help them know what is being discussed.
This omission excludes them completely.
A nice slap to historian who always misinterpreted the Indian history. Great respect for people who go on ground for excavation. New ncert syllabus need to remove the aryan invader theory. Now Dravidians will no longer have anything to cry on, how north and south is divided. And how aryan forced their culture on them.
Already delayed...it has t b done ASAP
@@lakshmivenkatrangan129 I know but they still shout the same
@@nikitajha6500then why Aryan write the wars with native dasus
Ms. Smitha Prakash,
Your subject video, your choice of the narrator, ie. Shri Sanjay Manjul and your questions put to him are very valid, brilliant and scintillating. It seemed as if I were myself asking questions which has racked my brains for many years.
I would like to put my own theory of the Indian civilisation as I see it. There is no doubt that we can trace our ancestry to Africa. But there were two streams, one coming to India via the sea route from Magadascar and the other coming through the land route, from Kenya. At that time the continents had begun to drift apart. The sea route people were short and sturdy while the land route people were tall} and lanky. They maintained different cultural outlook. In Kenya there is s snow covered mountain called Killimanjaro, shortenened Kailas, by the Indians. They worshipped the dead, i.e., ancestral worship. Where the lanscape lacked mountains, they created stone grave edifices. The Pyramids are a replica of the mountains. The Magdascaran people who came by sea, cremated their dead, or put their remains in mud cisterns, buried them underground. You can see such sites in Kerala. The differencec between these two migrators was that the people in the south believed in the soul which returned to earth after a cycle. Hence on one auspicios date they would offer these souls good food, while the Kenyans believed that they would enter snother world and the descendents would would furnish them with food, weaons, servants etc to accompany them in the next world. Such belief gave rise to the gods, Indira, Varuna, Vayu, Agni etc. You can see the connections of words like, Simha, (lion), Shul (spear), Shav (dead body) and Shiv (god) associated with the Kailas mountain. There are many more thoughts to be shared with you, but later.
Right question asked. Thank you ma'am, as always it was awesome.🙏
Smita Ji ko dhanyvad Manjil ji se mulakat karvane ke lea.
Ek bahut hi gyanvardhak aur shandar guest Jo Bharat ke shandar atit ko bahar la rahe hain dhanyvad
Deciphering the Indus script, I would have liked to know the challenge and updates on ongoing work / effort of ASI
*रामायण आणि महाभारत हे भारतभूमी चे इतिहास आहे🎉*
Must have invited Dr Niraj Rai DNA scientist also in this episode.Dna studies and Archeology are best combination to debunk Aryan invasion theory.
Excellent idea
I urge you to read an article in Swarjyamag. It clearly debunks the entire paper and exposes the shady shit the researchers like Reich and Narasimhan did the push their agenda.
Already done❤
@@Amit0828 were
lol he did not even published the study which he was makin statement in the interviews .. !! still that paper did not got published .. !!
Why don't invite Dr. david reich to the podcast .. !!!
Excellent presentation by Dr. Manjul. Why don't we start calling these civilizational discoveries as Bharatiya civilization and then divide geographic areas for Harappa, Rakhigarhi, etc.? It will help us and future generations think in a unified way, and also help us set proper correct narrative.
Smita madam , you are now a pioneer. The mainstream media just shut up on this subject.The very prospect of formally challenging the AIT was apparently a no no for the anglicised gentry and public intellectuals which included media , academia and strategic thinkers. It was as though they were kicking the can down the road under the plea that it is early days to conclude anything so why stick our neck out in giving the new thought leaders any chance ? This chapter has to be taken head on. We need massive amounts of multipronged research into archeology , epigraphy , architectural history, metallurgical studies of early bronze age and earlier periods. Now that we are laying a claim to resurrect our collossal civilisation we need hard empirical evidence and ground facts. Govts must be punched into action by mass awareness and pull factor. Please concentrate on a badly neglected subject which is now a policy priority - Indian Knowledge System. Pl interview people like Raghava Krishna founder of Brhat, the Indic reniassance organisation. He is a scintillating intellectual. The pushback against IKS is severe. Pl intervene , bring the subject above the water level. Remember Neera Mishra was solidly prevented from archeologucal excavations in Purana quila for 30 years by the lobby backed by none less than the Aga Khan. They wanted to put the start of the history of Delhi with the Islamic invasions and shut out everything else before that. Please act , you have great credibility. Give the new evidences and scholars a wide berth.
Very good Discussion!. Very true Sundareshan1849. I see wikipedia sinauli site description posted some points which counters this (wikipedia can be disregarded, they have come up with points like cow cart, Aryans migrated earlier etc for 2018 findings ). But a good way should be found by India to publish this finding.
Very beautiful interactive discussion. Dr Sanjay’s narrative on every question raised by Smita ji is to the point, and very convincing. Thanks for this very informative discussion Dr Sanjay and Smita ji.
Well What an proud I was knew it we are the first civilization on the earth 🌎 all credit goes to veda's and Avatar and rishi and scriptures.
Thanks to the respectful Sanjay sir
Who reminds me Sanjay of Mahabharata who played the same role of the proof 🧾 of Bharat and Mahabharata and our civilization and advanced development and all etc.
Kudos and bow down to all above.🙏
खूपच चांगली चर्चा, अर्कालाॅजि डिपार्टमेंटमध्ये कसं काम चालू आहे. आपली रामायण, महाभारत,वेद यांना ईतिहास आहे कि, काल्पनिक? अत्यंत महत्त्वाचे आहे. आभारी आहे.डा.मजूंल यांचे विषेश आभार.
Hi Smitha,
Hooe you take this as a constructive criticism but you really need to stop interrupting your guests. The whole point of a podcast is listening to an interview in the long form. The interruptions, even if they are a single word, can break the chain of thought of the guest and puts off the audience as well.
You have a great show and a plethora of great guests. Would love to see you make the most of it.
Wonderful and very relevant discussion. ❤
चलिए एक बार को मान लिया कि ईश्वर है, तो फिर सवाल उठता है कि वह सभी धर्मों का एक है या हर धर्म का अलग अलग। अगर हर धर्म का एक अलग ईश्वर है, तो फिर उसका ईश्वरत्व ही सन्देह के दायरे में आ जाता है। और अगर सारे धर्मों का ईश्वर एक है, तो सवाल उठता है कि अलग अलग धर्मों के अपने भक्तों को आपस में लड़ते हुए देखकर वह कुछ करता क्यों नहीं है। दूसरा सवाल यह भी उठता है जीवन, मृत्यु, पुनर्जन्म, आत्मा इत्यादि के बारे में सारे धर्मों के सिद्धान्त एक जैसे क्यों नहीं हैं, जबकि हर धर्म इन से सम्बन्धित अपने सिद्धान्तों को ईश्वरीय ही बताता है। यहाँ हम पुनर्जन्म से सम्बन्धित हिन्दू और इस्लाम धर्मों के सिद्धान्तों को आमने सामने रखकर देखते हैं। हिन्दू धर्म के अनुसार पुनर्जन्म होता है, किन्तु इस्लाम के अनुसार पुनर्जन्म नहीं होता है, जबकि हैं दोनों के सिद्धान्त ईश्वरीय। तो क्या ये बातें यह साबित करने के लिए पर्याप्त नहीं हैं, किये सारे सिद्धान्त ईश्वरीय नहीं बल्कि काल्पनिक हैं और ईश्वर भी ईश्वरीय नहीं बल्कि काल्पनिक है।
Wonderful Smita ji, thanks for this podcast. After all "we are all Harappans" as said by our famous Archeologist Sri Shinde ji. Thanks Dr. SK Manjul ji for sharing great content here. Madam, next plan for a group Podcast with Dr SK Manjul, Dr. Shinde and Ms Rekha Rao?
Kudos to Dr. Manjul that despite the scarcity of fund available in the last decade to Archaeological Survey of India from the Union Government he had concentrated work in some fronts. There is a huge scarcity of such fund in the North East India.
Very informative podcast. Once all the evidence and archaeological findings are conclusively validated, perhaps the ancient history taught in our schools needs to be revisited altogether. This could help us in challenging the Aryan invasion theory, Dravidian civilization, and all other commonly held beliefs.
Whole Dr Manjul family is contributing greatly to NATIONAL ARCHAEOLOGY.
Thanks a ton ❤❤❤
Why is ASI not using ground penetrating radar and other tech used in the west extensively?
They do use it, though they are highly under funded
Excellent discussion, Dr Sanjay has worked on the ground and has a treasure of archeological knowledge
Smita, extremely interesting program. Scientific. Incisive. Informative. Looking forward to more such programs that would encourage more research on Bhartiya archaeology.
Suggest similar program on South Indian Dravidian archaeology
She should listen more without interrupting again& again. She should learn how to take serious interviews ..
Really. It’s a great episode, I had too much confusion about our history. I think all the Indian are suffering from it . & Through your program clarity is come in my mind . We can solve contemporary topics after knowing real history of India. This should be broadcast at higher levels
Amazing podcast!! It was extremely informative and an eye-opener session.. Any society can grow organically only if you are rooted with its history and culture. With discoveries like Dholavira, Rakhigarhi and Sinauli, it's time or history is re-wtitten and re-told.. and this time from Indian perspective. Thankyou Smita for bringing to us such a brain-storming couple of hours!! Kudos to ASI and the entire team for such valuable discoveries!!
Very good information by Dr. Sanjay Manjul.Kudos
Excellent episode, we want many of such high quality episodes 🙏🏼🕉️🙏🏼🇮🇳🙏🏼
Madam l am a new follower of your page. My humble request is to restrain yourself from interupting the guests so much. Most of your questions were less constructive and more disruptive. He is an expert of his subject. Let him speak and guide him covering all topics.
What a great subject you had in this video yet so poorly treated.
It's amazing,archeological discussion without Buddhist and Jainist history of India. It's impossible.
Boudh 2700 year old. Sinoli 4000 year old 😅 Jain 1st tirthankar boudh time + around 1200 year old 4000 year old
Bhai...they are discussing older times than era you mentioned.
Khan se aate hain aise log.
😂
@@prakharshankar3064how can you say Buddha is 2700 years old,he was born 540 years before Isha was born, who count those 540 years
@@prakharshankar3064before Buddha utter vadic Aryan lives and they started to fullow many rituals which make society and religion very complex and that's why Buddha and mahavira and ajevika sect raised against the brahmincal supremacy over society
Excellent interview. Thank you for covering this topic. Shri Manjul has done a great national service by excavating an epoch making site in Sinauli.
Both Smita ji and Manjul ji were superb
This is a marvellous report and amazing podcast. Really loved it please make more of these.❤
amazing talk ..Sanjay ji is so knowledgable. One request Smitaji - dont call it 'Mythology' .. its history not mythology ...
Phli bar mene ANI ka cmplt podcast dekha....
Itihaas .
Documentation..
So the Indian Epics are our Itihaasa n they truly describe the entire gamut of our Hostory, Historical Geography, Knowledge, Scientfic, Technological and Material and Alloys Science.. . and Mathematical . , Caculus, Trigonometry , etc. ( Astronomy and Astrology), Medical Advancements. Architecture, . etc.
All these are evidenced in them .
Smitaji, firstly thank you for inviting Dr. Manjul for this extremely informative podcast. But one request; please do not interrupt the guest so much. Allow him to complete his answers. No hard feelings please, this was just constructive feedback 🙏🏼
What an amazing podcast!! Massive respect for Dr.Sanjay Manjul.
Great Dr Saheb, depth of your knowledge and defence of it is marvellous. I am impressed.
Another proof of the continued civilization ❤😊 12:50
really smitaji your questioning style and relating to present day events is spectacular and very real as if i'm sitting to question the guest , hats off madam