Some of the new boygroup stans would say “give our idols time. They are just rookies”. Now, this is the rookie era of baekhyun and chen. And they are magnificent already.
True, but tbf these are sm rookies lol! They debut with godly vocals, some company’s wait until they debut to even introduce them to technique unfortunately 😭 I love sm’s vocals
Well, actually there's somes technical details that they improve, maybe It wouldn't have a big difference for us, but for they yes, specially the last high note
Ik, they were very good at that time, but they got better, more in the feeling comfortable while singing, these day, they'd sing this pretty much effortless I think
@@juanimel_b1 it's real the vocals of the new generation are mediocre, now they focus on making music that sounds like a blender, and they only give importance to the dance, saving a few exceptions of course
@@awwing_balantac2549 i really didn't know by lim hee sook
ปีที่แล้ว +197
I keep coming back to this performance every now and then. You can actually see in their eyes that they were mortified and still pulled this off so neatly. I am especially shocked at our Baekhyunie since his emotions play tricks on him during these kind of songs yet he so skillfully managed to control his voice. Two kings.
Remember when Baekhyun and Jongdae met in S.M audition and didn't think they would both get in? Instead they wished each other good luck. Look at them now slaying the stage, just the two of them, purely with their vocals. Proud is an understatement 😢
i dont mean to be offtopic but does any of you know a tool to log back into an Instagram account?? I was stupid forgot the account password. I love any tips you can give me.
와~소름 돋았어;;;;백현이와 종대의 보컬합이 이렇게 슬프도록 아름답다니ㅜ 폭발적인 고음과 섬세한 감정 표현력까지 완벽한 실력자들이니까 sm오디션에서 마지막까지 경쟁하다가 둘이 다 붙었겠지ㅜ ~진짜 다행이야~둘 다 엑소로 데뷔시켜준 슴~ 수만님이 정말 고마울때도 있네 ㅋ 더 인정받는 더 사랑받는 엑소가 되길 항상 응원해♡♡♡
This is really my favourite performance by Baekhyun and Jongdae. Every year I always play it and it still gives me goosebumps every time I hear them sing. Their voices are really out of this world.
Wooow, I got emotional here, Chen and Baekhyun are super talented but what really moved me was Chen, what a fantastic voice, he stands out during the whole performance both in the low notes and (mostly) in the high notes, wonderful Chen, wonderful!!!!
2:19 Chen slayed 2:30 Baekhyun slayed 3:10 Shit slowed down 3:45 They decide to go Ham from then on Baekhyun went ham again on another high note somewhere and so did Chen 0:03 from then on, slayed me
Chen and Baekhyun slayed it. I have watched this video for like a million times but still I haven't get tired of it. They two are such perfect singers. EXO Fighting!!
aguacates de mexico Chen and Baekhyun, they are not all EXO as it is, they are part of EXO and they have talent, as well some other members, but not EXO as a hole group, not everyone has talent
Michelle Flores @ least dey can hit high notes without straining unlike other group dat u stan hahaha😂😂😂 Fyi chen rank # 5 while baekhyun nd d.o is on top 20 out of all male vocals in kpop vocal analysis unlike other group u stan who rank as weak so pity😔😔 u can comeback here nd start crying wen ur faves can hit high notes w/o straining at least give some justice to ur eardrums please hahaha😂😂
Their voices match so well! They are both great singers and I can't really say that one is better than the other but I just have to say that Baekhyun makes me feel things I can't even explain...
The way Baekhyun and Chen never fail to impress us in their vocal skills... They hit the high pitch so well that it doesn't seem out of tune. It is hard to do that and they slayed it all! Well done to all!
This video is almost 10 years old, and my emotions are still the same. Their voices can really carry the emotion of the song well. Baekhyun and Chen will always be the vocal standards for my bias
첸!!!! ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ와 첸 진짜 잘한다!! 백현도 잘했지만 진짜 첸이...대박임 되게 안정적이면서 표현력도 좋음 ㅠㅠㅠ 최애 시우민인데 첸진짜 반하겠음엑소에서 없으면 큰일날존재... 메보님 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 체니첸~~ 그리고 노래 편곡도 드라마 ost 처럼 너무 잘됬음 ㅎㅎㅎ노래좋아요
I get why people in this comment area put quotation marks around the song's name to emphasize it's a title. Otherwise we'd have conversations like: What song is this? Really I didn't know. You didn't know? But now you do? What is it? The song's name, really I didn't know. SO WHAT IS IT?
wish to see them singing this again.. as rookies they were already so good, but can't deny their techniques and voice improved so much over the years. pls make it happen :')
i wish that rookie vocalists would still be classically trained. even if it’s not their personal style, they would all benefit from proper vocal technique
Xiumin says you must sing well, because no matter how good you dance if u can't sing well..... i agree because having good vocals is hard to learn and execute well while dancing just practice and u can dance.
They are not just anybody. They are EXO!!! Gosh their vocal line are soooo fantastic. I cried though i dont understand the lyrics obviously. I will love exo forever!!!
Until now I really love this song and I always watch this kind of performance so cool and unbelievable!..I'm very amaze for there performance! Love it!!😍good combination 👏👏👏👏
i cant believe that ive been coming back to this song year after year after year... its almost been 10 years now oh my. still a masterpiece in my opinion, one of their best live performances
They sang like that 7 years ago🤯??????? Oh my god...I wonder how good they would sound if they sing this again now when they both are acknowledged as two of the best vocalists of kpop????
I wish they would do things like this again. I miss seeing vocalists like Chen, Baekhyun, Kyuhyun, Yesung, Ryeowook, Max, Taeyeon, Onew, Wendy and Seulgi absolutely SLAYING it on live vocal shows.
even i do'nt understand this song, i really feel it the deliver of this two guys beakyun and chen, perfect combination and i really like them, good job guys 👍🤝😘
![[HIT] 불후의 명곡2-EXO - 아직도 어두운 밤인가 봐.20130831](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DBqQRem2MP0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[HIT] 불후의 명곡2-EXO - 아직도 어두운 밤인가 봐.20130831](/img/tr.png)
Some of the new boygroup stans would say “give our idols time. They are just rookies”. Now, this is the rookie era of baekhyun and chen. And they are magnificent already.
Frrrr
True, but tbf these are sm rookies lol! They debut with godly vocals, some company’s wait until they debut to even introduce them to technique unfortunately 😭 I love sm’s vocals
Keep in mind companies hardly do stuff like this anymore…times have changed tremendously.
Whos here in 2024
Meeee
meee
Meeee
And me
Meeee
They really dont make rookies like this anymore.
Make or find?
@@iamagoodboy5672 both
@@iamagoodboy5672it’s a saying…
@@iamagoodboy5672 labels trains idols, so yeah "make" is somewhat a correct term
They do, they just don’t do many things like this anymore. There are so many new idols with beautiful soulful voices
I wish they can sing this again now and see how much they have improved
l wish too..
For me, theres nothing to improve because this performance is already perfect..
So amazing...
Well, actually there's somes technical details that they improve, maybe It wouldn't have a big difference for us, but for they yes, specially the last high note
Yes but I think they don't change too much. I mean their vocal have already good since along time
Ik, they were very good at that time, but they got better, more in the feeling comfortable while singing, these day, they'd sing this pretty much effortless
I think
New kpopers don’t understand what real vocal is!!!!!
Trueee
Wtf
@@juanimel_b1 it's real the vocals of the new generation are mediocre, now they focus on making music that sounds like a blender, and they only give importance to the dance, saving a few exceptions of course
@@jiminkook2287 no xDDDD
@@juanimel_b1 yes, tell me the duo vocal of a group of the new generation that is at the level of baekhyun and chen?
come from jan 2024 to give update that no idol till now can outperform this stage
From March 2024, yeah I agree.
From May 2024, still agree, 인정👍
confirming for June 2024, this is still relevant
Sm idols are just built different lol
September 2024, still havent seen it
I seriously need them to cover this again especially after how much they’ve improved
Yessss
What is the English title of the song?
@@awwing_balantac2549 i really didn't know by lim hee sook
I keep coming back to this performance every now and then. You can actually see in their eyes that they were mortified and still pulled this off so neatly. I am especially shocked at our Baekhyunie since his emotions play tricks on him during these kind of songs yet he so skillfully managed to control his voice. Two kings.
Ты права.Два короля.
Who's watching this with me? It's 2022 yet I'm still shock with this performance.
Me
I'm still watching this everyday..I even save this so that I can watch it always their voice is so powerful and I love it so much ..
Still watching here 😍, good performance, nice voice, amazing vocal, this video should keep replay ❤️❤️❤️
Meeeee
Me
첸 고음 들으면 내 가슴이 뻥 뚫린 느낌,, 겁나 시원하게 불러
BaekHyun's voice always make me so emotional
Same :")
best kpop vocals. nobody can beat them
E tabii
데뷔 이년차일때고, 둘이 연습생 젤 짧게했다고 들었는데 이거들을때마다 몰입해서 보게된다
저희 애들 이쁘게 봐주셔서 감사합니다ㅎ😄
Chen is absolutely incredible. his voice just pierces through you.
헐 이거 풀렸구나.. 맨날 유튜브에 음원만 따놓은 거 찾아서 들었는데 ㅠㅠ
고음도 고음인데 감성표현 넘 잘한다 데뷔초부터 완성형 가수 첸 근데 그뒤로도 더잘해서 놀라워
Remember when Baekhyun and Jongdae met in S.M audition and didn't think they would both get in? Instead they wished each other good luck. Look at them now slaying the stage, just the two of them, purely with their vocals. Proud is an understatement 😢
i dont mean to be offtopic but does any of you know a tool to log back into an Instagram account??
I was stupid forgot the account password. I love any tips you can give me.
@@ignacioleonardo8500 try log in with user name phone number or email n click forgot the password ..
경수씨 반가워요 백일의낭군님ㅎ 경수씨가 부르는줄 알았네요 ~~
Amazing. Brutal. I enjoy their excelents voices.
🤍✨
와~소름 돋았어;;;;백현이와 종대의 보컬합이 이렇게 슬프도록 아름답다니ㅜ 폭발적인 고음과 섬세한 감정 표현력까지 완벽한 실력자들이니까 sm오디션에서 마지막까지 경쟁하다가 둘이 다 붙었겠지ㅜ ~진짜 다행이야~둘 다 엑소로 데뷔시켜준 슴~ 수만님이 정말 고마울때도 있네 ㅋ 더 인정받는 더 사랑받는 엑소가 되길 항상 응원해♡♡♡
역시 악플 없네ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 이거보니 실력으론 못까겠지... 그나저나 얘네 솔로 기다리려면 얼마나 기다려야 할끄아ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 백현목소리진짜ㅠㅠ
조선영 존버 성공하셨네요 !
축하해여 ㅎㅎ
존버 성공!!!!!!
This is really my favourite performance by Baekhyun and Jongdae. Every year I always play it and it still gives me goosebumps every time I hear them sing. Their voices are really out of this world.
It brings tears to my eyes and I don't understand Korean, but as they say music is a universal language.
둘이 목소리가 너무 잘 어울린다 엑소엘은 아니고 무무지만 노래는 엑소 노래 꽤 많이 듣는 편... 얘네 좀 예뻐해 줘요
감사합니다ㅠㅠ오늘 솔라 짱예뻤어요
+슈웅 오늘 종대 멋있었어요 ㅠㅠㅠ 고음 장난 없음...
진짜 가끔가다 생각나서 들어와서 보고 듣지만
언제나 노래하나는 진짜 잘부른다…서로 음색이 다른데도 다른데로도 좋고ㅠㅠㅠ그립고 보고싶다 ㅠㅠ
오랜만에 들으러왔다ㅜㅜㅜ벌써 6년전란게 믿기지않는다 예전이나 지금이나 탄탄한 보컬 너무 자랑스러움
I can't believe it was almost 10 years ago...this iconic perfect vocal performance... I still show this as an example of PERFECT VOCAL SKILL
Y la verdad es que debieron haber ganado esa competencia. Ellos son maravillosos cantantes y su interpretación fue genial.❤
makes me cry everytimee
백현잘했다,첸잘했다로 나눌수는없는것같고 두사람 모두 노래 잘한다
타팬이봐도 정말 노래 잘하는것같네
감사합니다~
감사합니다!!
그냥 둘이 호흡이 너무나 잘맞는것같아요 고음과 저음을 이렇게 환상적으로 표현하다뇨 완벽하단말밖에 할말이없어요 이둘의 가창력은 이미 완성도를 뛰어넘어 신급이라봄
그러니까요.. 저음 고음 진성 가성 반가성 넘나 들면서.. 목소리를 자유자재로 가지고 노는.. 보컬을 컨트롤하는.. 우리 가수ㅠ
Wooow, I got emotional here, Chen and Baekhyun are super talented but what really moved me was Chen, what a fantastic voice, he stands out during the whole performance both in the low notes and (mostly) in the high notes, wonderful Chen, wonderful!!!!
👍👍👏👏👏🎤🎤💞❤️
2:19 Chen slayed
2:30 Baekhyun slayed
3:10 Shit slowed down
3:45 They decide to go Ham from then on
Baekhyun went ham again on another high note somewhere and so did Chen
0:03 from then on, slayed me
*3:35
i still watch this until now, and i believe they really have superpower, i mean, power for any talent
me too
Thanks to you, I knew which one was chen and baekhyun
과거에도 현재에도 미래에도 노래 저렇게 부르는 2년차 아이돌은 없을 듯
ㄹㅇ인정!!!!!
동방신기?
Facts!
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
ㅇㅈ
Chen and Baekhyun slayed it. I have watched this video for like a million times but still I haven't get tired of it. They two are such perfect singers. EXO Fighting!!
Baekhyun I love you
Yeah!
👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼💘👑✨❤️
엑소 실력은 이때도 레전드,,
they don’t debut like this anymore
I can't believe it was almost 10 years ago...this iconic perfect vocal performance... I still show this as an example of PERFECT VOCAL SKILL
Fr😭
how can anyone come for EXO and say they can't sing when this exists
aguacates de mexico i think no one said that
aguacates de mexico
Chen and Baekhyun, they are not all EXO as it is, they are part of EXO and they have talent, as well some other members, but not EXO as a hole group, not everyone has talent
Michelle Flores not everyone has talent, you drunk 😂
Michelle Flores @ least dey can hit high notes without straining unlike other group dat u stan hahaha😂😂😂
Fyi chen rank # 5 while baekhyun nd d.o is on top 20 out of all male vocals in kpop vocal analysis unlike other group u stan who rank as weak so pity😔😔
u can comeback here nd start crying wen ur faves can hit high notes w/o straining at least give some justice to ur eardrums please hahaha😂😂
I live only for EXO woah your English is REALLY BAD, where are you from?
울 애들 실력으로 논하면 죽인다 진짜 이 때 절대 못 잊어버림 ㅜㅜ 레전드
Chen was 20 here, with all this vocal power, he was already singing better than many famous people in their 40s who don't even know what pitch is.
Baekhyun & Chen will always be the blueprint. Literally the top vocalist of their generation. And the fact that it’s live.
아무리생각해도 이때가 제일 그립다
그니까요
그러게요
그러니깐요
인정합니다
이건 정말 진실
첸은 정말 독보적인 가창력의 소유자입니다.
Their voices match so well! They are both great singers and I can't really say that one is better than the other but I just have to say that Baekhyun makes me feel things I can't even explain...
Youssra Naim true
다시봐도 너무 놀랍다 정말... 둘다 보컬의 탄탄한 실력이 갖고있음👍🏻👍🏻역시 엑소... 과거에도 완벽하니까 여전히 완벽하지ㅎㅎ👍🏻👍🏻
The way Baekhyun and Chen never fail to impress us in their vocal skills... They hit the high pitch so well that it doesn't seem out of tune. It is hard to do that and they slayed it all! Well done to all!
Gives you goose bumps!!
Yup! Sure does. I'm proud to be an EXO-L
Dream Angels for me it's easy to hit the high notes like seriously. No joke, I'm not joking.
Iceblazer 1000 yeah. I'm not saying it isn't possible but it takes a lot of work and it is also rarely seen amongst many males.
Yeah true , when I first did the high notes they did, I did it perfectly which surprised me to death.
담담하게 이별을 받아들이는 상남자들의 서글픈 마음을 잘 표현하셨습니다. 두 분다 뛰어난 가창력을 가지고 계시네요.
Im here in 2019 but im still shocked! Their voices are the greatest thing
yes, this is EXO
And here is oct 20 but i'm still shocked! 😂😂
i'm even here un 2021 and probably going to be here even in 50 years
2022 and still will shocked
2022 feb 14.. Valentine ❤️
둘 다 보컬이 엄청 늘어서 지금 버전으로 한번 더 보고싶다 진짜... 얼마나 좋을까
They've improved much more they gonna rock if they perform now
진짜 과소평가되는 보컬 갑
The talent Chen has is incredible, I understand why he is nicknamed the vocal king
아 진짜 백현이랑 종대 노래 정말 잘해ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
매번 느끼지만.. 들을때마다 소름...ㄷㄷㄷ
엑소 사랑하자!!♥
This video is almost 10 years old, and my emotions are still the same. Their voices can really carry the emotion of the song well. Baekhyun and Chen will always be the vocal standards for my bias
#BRINGBACKBAEKHYUNSFOREHEAD
Your picture is literally my favorite thing in the world.
every time someone says about new idols: "they're just rookies"
i comeback to this video
They dont make em like this anymore, its all about visuals and height now 😢
진짜 눈에 띄는 보컬탄탄한 그룹 ,,,,, 엑소 ,,,,
저때 고작 22살이었는데 22살의 감성이 아니다.. 진짜 너무 대단함
첸!!!! ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ와 첸 진짜 잘한다!! 백현도 잘했지만 진짜 첸이...대박임
되게 안정적이면서 표현력도 좋음 ㅠㅠㅠ 최애 시우민인데 첸진짜 반하겠음엑소에서 없으면 큰일날존재... 메보님 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
체니첸~~ 그리고 노래 편곡도 드라마 ost 처럼 너무 잘됬음 ㅎㅎㅎ노래좋아요
샤이니 종현ㆍ엑소 백현ㆍ종대ㆍ비투비 서은광
레알 넘사들~~~♡
백현ㆍ종대 듀엣곡 나왔음 좋겠당~♡
I get why people in this comment area put quotation marks around the song's name to emphasize it's a title. Otherwise we'd have conversations like:
What song is this?
Really I didn't know.
You didn't know? But now you do? What is it?
The song's name, really I didn't know.
SO WHAT IS IT?
😂
LOL!
Lmaoooo
THEY DON'T MAKE IDOLS LIKE THIS ANYMORE!!! WHAT HAPPENED TO K-POP?
Chanyeols shocked face 😆😆😆
Raven love haha
Lol yes
이번 무대는 볼 때마다 첸백의 보컬 파워에 감탄을 금할 수 없다 아직 초창기임에도 불구하고 그들의 능력은 놀랍고 훌륭합니다. 그야말로 엑소는 초창기부터 현재까지 부동의 보컬왕이다. 참고: 저는 이 공연을 조금도 지루함 없이 100번 정도 봤습니다.
Okay, I stan the right group. Not that I needed any confirmation, but I am even more sure of that now. So. Much. Talent.
i would do anything for them to perform this song again
I hope they can cover this song again as a single, because when they sing it is amazing with a beautiful and cool improve...
i know right
What is name of this song?
@@vanidara2837 really i didn't know
wish to see them singing this again.. as rookies they were already so good, but can't deny their techniques and voice improved so much over the years. pls make it happen :')
i wish that rookie vocalists would still be classically trained. even if it’s not their personal style, they would all benefit from proper vocal technique
이때 엑소에 미쳤었는데 ... 이 영상을 하루에 몇번씩이나보고 ㅠㅠ 진짜 내 세상이었는데 추억이구먼
백현이 진짜 잘한다.백현이 음색 진짜 쩐다..첸은 가창력 고음이 와..진짜 넋놓고 봄..진짜 내가 에리인게 자랑스럽다♥
Still now 2021 I got goosebumps when listen to these young boys, wish they will sing song again in the near future! Fan from the Netherlands!!
임정희 선배님, 김연우 선배님, 려욱 선배님 등 선배님들이 백현이 노래 실력을 칭찬한 이유는 다 있다 진짜 ...
마쟈여ㅠ♡
노래잘부르고 고음잘되는 2인방이 나오넼ㅋ넘사다..
I feel proud every time I watch this video
My biggest dream: i hope Baekhyun and Chen sing that song again
Xiumin says you must sing well, because no matter how good you dance if u can't sing well..... i agree because having good vocals is hard to learn and execute well while dancing just practice and u can dance.
No one can beat them in vocals in the k-industry
They are not just anybody. They are EXO!!! Gosh their vocal line are soooo fantastic. I cried though i dont understand the lyrics obviously. I will love exo forever!!!
When you can read the lyrics, the song are more emotionally and sadly :'/
첸이 목소리 진짜... 레전드.. 보고싶다 종대야 ㅜㅜ
I'm still mad that they did not win this.
years later, and this is still one of the most beautiful performances ever sung by kpop idols
이 노래 진짜 오랜만..
Until now I really love this song and I always watch this kind of performance so cool and unbelievable!..I'm very amaze for there performance! Love it!!😍good combination 👏👏👏👏
Deym Exo-L glad to see new comments. that means i'm not the only one missing them. you guys are the og 😭
이때 엑소 다 씹어 먹던 시절 우리 국어쌤이 이거 불후의 명곡 보고 와서 요새 애들 모르는데 엑소는 노래 잘하더라 라고 하신게 아직도 기억남
Exo's vocals are no joke. This video sent me the chills
True
What I'm looking for isn't popularity but what I'm looking for quality like them
...엑셀인게 자랑스럽다
와 마지막에 소름 쫙 끼치네 ㅠㅠ 김종대 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
인정이요👍🏻👍🏻 진심 소름 쫙 돋아요🤍🤍
i cant believe that ive been coming back to this song year after year after year... its almost been 10 years now oh my. still a masterpiece in my opinion, one of their best live performances
Same
I love this performance, because it is so clean and I pick up zero auto tune used. They're my bias for a reason. 1000% talent
I become obssesed by this performance
They are both insane
Wow emotional delivery by Jongdae , his high notes goosebumps
They sang like that 7 years ago🤯??????? Oh my god...I wonder how good they would sound if they sing this again now when they both are acknowledged as two of the best vocalists of kpop????
다시들어도 백현 첸 노랠 너무 잘하네...
매력적인 중저음....
듣는사람이 부담없이 깔끔한 고음처리...
호소력있는 목소리....백배 공감입니다.
I wish they would do things like this again. I miss seeing vocalists like Chen, Baekhyun, Kyuhyun, Yesung, Ryeowook, Max, Taeyeon, Onew, Wendy and Seulgi absolutely SLAYING it on live vocal shows.
What should we do to see these to perform this song again in 2024, after years of life experience?
엑소를 이걸로 더 자세하게 알앗지 내가 ..
아이돌이라고 별 관심없엇는데 불후의명곡보고 생각바뀜 ㅠㅁㅜ
진정난몰랏네 중에 이게 제일 듣기좋고
한 서려 있어서 좋아
진짜말이 안나와...고음클라스 ㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷ
배쿄니 종대 유닛 해랏!!!!!♡♡♡엑소흥해랑♡♡♡
are you alive
우리첸백시로~~🤍🤍 유닛하죠~~😘😘
오늘 갑자기 엑소를 많이 생각했다
우리 다 진짜 많이 변했고 많이 커지고
이 무대 다시 보고싶어졌어
슬프다
even i do'nt understand this song, i really feel it the deliver of this two guys beakyun and chen, perfect combination and i really like them, good job guys 👍🤝😘
I WOULD LIKE THEM TO SING THIS AGAIN PLEASE
아니 첸백 제대로 된 듀엣곡 발라드 평생을 기다렸는데 결국엔 매년 이거 들으러 오네 에휴ㅠ
아직도 찾아들음,,, 너무 좋음 진짜
빌보드 1위했다면서 실력은 개판인 옆 동네랑 비교 되네^^ 역시 엑소 실력파❤️
그러지좀마세요 왜 시비를거는거;;