@tropicaoptica I don't think she was though. She told Beth she was purposely going to mean to her to make her a tough woman. Unfortunately she died before she could see it through long enough for Beth to understand and not be warped by it.
@KadeStringer2.0 it's not abusive. Coddling kids all the time is why this generation is so soft and sensitive about everything. Why they all have a diagnosis of some kind, why the 🔫 up schools, why whenever they're challenged in the slightest and have a real world issue thrown at them, they have a nervous breakdown.
Before my Grandfather died he wanted to ride one more time. Me my Daddy and 2 of my Uncles went to the barn and saddled up one of the sweetest old mares. He was paralyzed on the right side and had been bed ridden for 2 years but he rode her. I still miss him so much. ❤
@@tanyabruce1019 he was one of the best horseman I ever knew. What he and my father and one other old school man taught me helped me train horses. Thank you helped me
She must've been war proof if you trusted her to ride a man on his deathbed. That's a good horse right there. I want one like her for my daughter's first horse.
I’m so sorry you lost your old man, I’m scared to death for that day to come, and it’s coming soon one of these days. My condolences to you and your family.
Ok. the flashback with John and his dad taking that horse ride together just me in the feels partially because it reminds me of grandpa and my mom. I could see her doing something like this and it freakin hits me in the gut
That “hard on your girls” speech is such a crock of shit. The world is hard on us, the world makes us hard, we don’t need our mothers to be hard on us.
The world is hard on you BECAUSE you don't have hard mothers. F-ing DUH! The saying Hard men make soft times, soft times make soft men, soft men make hard times, repeat, applies just as much to women. My mom was a hardass and it made me a better man.
Agreed. That was so ominous. The Evelyn didn’t seem to have educated Beth and the fact she was crying and saying “sorry” was rather telling about the kind of relationship the mother had with Beth. There are better ways to help prepare daughters for the world they will face.
The song playing during the father’s last talk is Daddy Doesn’t Pray Anymore by Chris Stapleton. My father crossed over in ‘98 and my husband in 2019. There are lots of good men over there.💕🦋
Dude jamie literally isn't even his son he sent him to be a lawyer to protect their family and send him tf off.. exactly become something so I can protect this place. Why would he pick a child that wasn't even his to do that?
@beastfam251 he was raised as his own, granted they made that more difficult by hiding it forever. Ultimately people like me who have been raised with a dad and not the biological father leads to a better outcome most of the time. Yeah me and my dad fought and still do sometimes. If you look at how their lifestyle is and how they were raised it was a guaranteed thing of Jamie having a pretty kosher life as long as he didn't get a view of "I'm better than you ". I ain't blood related with my dad's side yet they were a keystone in most of not all of my difficult times of life.
@treycantrell8590 i'm extremely confused by your reply in your comment, you said that "i hope Jamie can recognize that he is the weapon that Yellowstone needs". He is a weapon but not what Yellowstone needs and never really has. He truly is a horrible disgusting person and im glad he's not John Duttons.
Everytime I see see John Dutton with his dad,it makes me tear up or cry,I don’t want that to happen to my dad,but it will,spend time with them and don’t lay around
I cant get over parents who dont prep their daughters and let them think theyre expiring or have failed when their bodies bleed. Its a period and parents and guardians need to lwt their daughters know its going to happwn.
Idk what it's like in the States, but here in Canada, we have at least 5 puberty presentations for both genders since 6th grade. My sister saw all of them and was still scared.
And she should have told her daughter about how not to get pregnant! Using condoms the right way. Taking the pill, emergency after pill. Beth's mother was not a good mother, but an abuser.
The respect shown to the Native Americans in this show is unprecedented. I still hate they cast a half white/half-asian woman as Monica, but I've learned to overlook that in the face of everything else. Really liked the Tim McGraw flashbacks, too. Seeing young John I and Spencer with their parents. Would've like to see the kids return for flashbacks in 1923, but that could still happen with season 2. The flashbacks in general are pretty good. 11:20 tells you everything you need to know about Jamie and John's relationship. Jamie just wanted to be like his Dad; a cowboy and rancher. You could see from his reaction and barrage of questions that he didn't want to be a lawyer. Jamie does what he's told and serves as the family counsel for 20 years only to be mistreated and disrespected by the very man who made him go. The very man who made him into something he didn't even want to be...
I think it's exactly precedented. Someone had to eventually honor Native People and Culture, especially in a show that centers on the land and impacts of oil and cattle. The respect of culture and land, and the relationship with the fact that people were pushed out of their homes and are still is evident, and it's a beautiful thing to see researched and respected here
Agreed. On all fronts. It would have been nice if Elsa and Sam had a kid or two and she wasn't offed so young.... nice to see Kayce, though, echoing his 5 great aunt Elsa in a sense. A Dutton with a First Nations Indigenous spouse, that also has deep ties to the land due to him possibly being the one to inherit the Yellowstone ranch... just sayin', nice tie back to Elsa and the 7th generation prophecy.... And as far as Jamie goes... Man. He should have just been allowed to become a rancher like John. Beth should have gone for that second degree. May have helped even her out. Jaime taking her for that abortion was not great, knowing what he knew about the whole procedure. ALSO, tying back to the respect for the Native American's and problems that no ONE ever talks about... that sterilization but, based on facts as well. Can we just say.... the writers know their stuff! It is quite impressive to see. I find myself going, "OH MY PANCAKES AND SYRUP!!! FINALLY!!! That's factual. THAT'S something too that they don't teach in public school history classes. Nope only if you go digging deeper into the archives or know SOMEONE from the reservation...." it is JUST... well done, all the way around. The good, the bad, and all of it. Either way, Jamie made a HUGE mistake, sadly, with Beth and her abortion. And it's hard telling if he had his own agenda started then, because if she had the first male grand child, out of wedlock or not.... either way, whether it was intentional or unintentional on Jamie's part, fact remains, he robbed her of one of the things she really wanted in life WITHOUT being honest about it. And like John told a young Rip, you can't cry about the consequences AFTER the fact. You should HAVE considered them BEFOREHAND.... damn shame. I hope Jamie gets a bit of a redemption before he goes. HOWEVER... I still feel Beth is correct and Jamie needs to take a ride on the big black train. Though John seems to hesitate, which kinda proves to some degree, that he considers him family/one of his own.....
Genetically it's not too far off. Native Americans are fairly closely related to Asians ancestrally. Sometimes you gotta get people who look like they could be, when you can't find very many people who actually are.
@@sorrenblitz805this is a shit take. By your logic we’re all black because we all come out of Africa and essentially Ehtiopia. They had many indigenous women to pick from yet they chose to get the asian sexy looking “indigenous type”.
@@DianaJG8 I wouldn’t say adopting him was a mistake. It was him sending Jamie to college to be a lawyer that lead Jamie into developing his own motives and agenda of wanting to do certain things the right way. John wasn’t about doing things the right way if situations were serious, their family being threatened. John may be a fault for sending Jamie to college, but he ain’t at fault for what Jamie became when he became a lawyer. That’s all Jamie’s doing, under the influence of others who easily manipulated Jamie by striking at his ego.
@@kjiggidy5719 Well, Jamie never wanted to be a lawyer. Just a rancher. He, ultimately, wants the same thing John does: for the Yellowstone ranch to survive and be inherited by future generations of Duttons. It's just that while Jamie wants to go about it the sensible, beneficial way, John wants to go about it the old school wild west way. It's for this reason the ranch is suffering and why his oldest son is dead. Jamie's really not a bad guy, when you think about it. He's just desperate for acceptance and suffers from a lack of self-confidence. A guy like that, regardless of how smart he is, is bound to make poor choices and some mistakes. Like the rest of his family, he's no angel. But compared to the rest of them, Beth especially, he's a saint...
@@neonrodenson1480 if you believe that then stick with it. We all have our opinions at the end of the day. But he ain’t no saint, none of them are. And that’s the point of the Dutton family, stretching back to James Dutton and the rest of the first generation. None of them were/are saints. Jamie’s not a Dutton, but still being as one; he is far from being a saint. No matter how you slice it and defend it.
@@kjiggidy5719 Most of what I said isn't an opinion. In Seasons 1, 2, and 5, it's explicitly shown or said (or both) more than once and often revisited and echoed between 3-4. And I said he's a saint "by comparison". He's got blood on his hands and did terrible things, too. Just not nearly as much or as comfortably as his family. And blood Dutton or not (I personally believe that online theory that he is), just having the name curses him...
I really, really want to see Jaime redeem himself in some way. I hope we see it… I have a feeling season 5 is going to throw us a lot of curveballs. Especially concerning Jaime.
4:25 I can’t wait to meet John’s father in his younger days in the later upcoming 1944. See his growth to being a rancher and running the ranch after his father, (Jack or Spencer).
@@Th_Ppptmstr that or she might possibly have tuberculosis. When the boat was flipped over by the ghost ship, Alex was thrown from her bed and landed on the Captain’s and hit the pillows that had his blood all around it. She could’ve caught tuberculosis from that. So it’s either or. Guess we’ll see when S2 come out.
I believe it will be Spencer and Alex. Spencer is hard enough to deal with banner. Alex will find him in Montana and be the reason the ranch gets upgraded to the 20th century. To me this is the only way forward but I’m not Taylor s.
Her mom was right about what she said to her in the bathroom. Every single word; about how humanity would end in two generations if they were the ones to deliver babies and how from the moment a girl turns a woman, they will try to make us feel less... that's a real Mom.
The farther you get into the show it almost comes off like the Dutton's care about the land even more than the indigenous do. Even Thomas who constantly fought with John to try and get the land back was taken aback by how far John would go to defend it
When my dad bought our farm in 1961, it was the first time in his life he had a stable place to live, his parents were the type to move yearly or even several times a year, and he grew up hating it. So he stayed there for 62 years now, and I know when his end comes he might say something similar, at the very least don't lose it, don't let it get taken, sell if I want to but make sure you bleed the buyer for every penny it's worth. I've lived there for 40 years, it's my paradise, 100 acres of absolute peace and security and safety that's OURS, free and clear. I don't want to give that up, it's more valuable than money.
Pick up a history book this has been happening for millions of years. It didn't start with this fictitious story. Or with the Americans. Did you know that the Portuguese were the first to the trade S l a ves
I'm not falling for all the sensation lies headlines because behind the scenes nobody has set a damn thing about Kevin leaving. This is all hype to drive people for clicks to their websites.
A real man doesn’t look a a female as weak he sees the most beautiful thing god ever created and she has strength in ways he doesn’t and it deserves to be respected and defended we really need to start watching how we word things to young children
I’m not talking about alpha and beta, and all that bullshit I’m talking about each gender having its purpose and responsibilities, and being special in its own way, and teaching our children, these purpose and responsibilities, instead of trying to teach them that their purpose is to be a millionaire or that their purpose is to constantly compete with the opposite sex
@@jordanzdebski5132 Hmm………..Apparently you’ve not heard about how much Taylor has going on and that he’s the reason for the delays in finishing the second half of season 5. As he hasn’t had the scripts and other necessities ready at the moment filming was to start back. But everyone else was ready. So in my opinion, he’s bitten off more than he can chew. He needs to focus more on his bread and butter show Yellowstone and delegate duties for the other shows to someone else.
I have faith in Sheridan. But I, too, have mixed feelings about season 6 and why it will be the last season. Do you know more about the controversy than I do? Can you explain? so I don’t have to read it on google myself 😂😅 🙂
@@michaelbrant1503 Yeah and from the looks of things part 2 of Season 5 wil be the last season of Yellowstone we'll be getting. Or at the least the last season with John Dutton in it. Though I agree. Sheridan should have first finished Yellowstone (ideally with a 6th and final season). Then he could have gone on to make the prequels.
So, it took me a minute to realize how since this was back then, when it took place... Most boys weren't raised up with respect for a women's own body-mind and women were raised up to believe they only had one purpose and that they are just another to get used and knocked up. Boy's not being able to show their tears, that one I'll look past considering WHERE THEY ARE, How they're livin'. Not showing any vulnerable, clowded with emotion minds. They have to stay aware and be prepared.
I think you have that reversed, TODAY kids are raised like you describe, back then you abused a woman you were more likely than not beaten to death by the other local men like John Dutton...He blasted his own son in the face for hitting Beth, his sister, with the admonishment that a man NEVER hits a woman. And sorry to JD, but I'm the only boy of 7 kids, if I wasn't willing to hit a woman i'd have starved to death or died as a little boy lol.
When you let anger overpower you ,you become blindsided, and then there are consequences.The fist can be a dangerous weapon if not controlled,therefore, we must manage our anger issue,preventing fatality.
It would be very disheartening if they canceled the show after season 5 just because Kevin Costner wants to work on another project. There are so many other phenomenal actors that are carrying this show, and for some of them, it's their big break. For others who came on later in the series, they've played standout characters that will be gone before they get the chance to develop further. My suggestion would be to have Jamie and Sarah hire a hitman to kill John and Beth, but someone else gets to John first and he dies. This means Kayce steps up to protect the ranch, Jamie is ridden with guilt over what he was about to do and returns the family, and Beth reeks havoc in an effort to the find the person who did it. The coming together of sides to get justice for their father could finally help to settle the feud between Beth and Jamie. Carter steadily the takes the form of Rip 2.0 for Tate and is accepted as Beth's son. Maybe Jamie dies in some honorable last sacrifice that proves his loyalty to the ranch and Beth takes care of his son, thus fulfilling the Dutton family dream of "having enough sons after all on one road together."
Not bad but Jamie is a full blown narcissist and they never feel remorse. I think Beth should take her father's place as crazy head of the family and Yellowstone. With Rip close to her, there will be a balance 😂 and other stories can go on. John can die tragically on the hands of Jamie because a heart attack would be too natural for people craving drama...I mean everyone 😂... but Beth is the best character to keep the series moving on.
@Lyrielonwind I respectfully disagree. Jamie is a tragic character thrust into villain status by lack of a properly developed story arc, which Taylor Sheridan admits himself. Jamie is remorseful, as seen during the murder of Sara Nyugen at the start of the series. He has a full-fledged panic attack, grief stricken, and full of self-loathing over his actions. He tells Beth during a car ride that he will allow Beth to hate him for everything if it means she stops hating herself, which is about as sacrificial as he can get. He also tells Beth that taking her to get an abortion was the single worst decision of his life. Beth is completely unhinged and sadistic at this point in the story. The only thing standing between her and the abyss is Rip, who she has been lying to for years about the abortion of his child, a situation she completely blames on Jamie even though she, in part, requested it from him. Between her and Jamie, she is the one who takes zero accountability and has no remorse for any actions she takes, always justifying it as "what is necessary for the ranch." Jamie is effectively Frankensteins monster, with John being his maker and potential victim. The only way for the ranch to be saved at this point is if Jamie and Beth move past their trauma and pool their resources.
@@loliver9660 Agree to a certain point; she wanted an abortion, not being unable to ever have children and Jamie didn't tell her but I agree there are far too many unresolved trauma going on. Anyway, I understand you like Jamie more. To me he's a narcissist and Beth is borderline but I still would prefer a Beth than a Jamie in my life if I could choose because Beth might be crazy but she can be the most loyal person in your side. Jamie only cares about his ego and butt. We could be arguing about it for hours but it's not in our hands to give it a way out and have a fair close or end...I don't think it's possible; both have been too damaged.
@mircat28 Agreed, but I guess I wonder why there needs to be a "leader" in any family. True, there is usually an older matriarch/patriarch in the form of a grandparent who provides words of wisdom, but ultimately a family is made up of individual people who create their own special units by getting married and having kids. In the case of the Duttons, Kayce and Monica have their own life away from everyone. Beth has repeatedly said that she would leave as soon as he father dies. Lee is gone, so there is only Jamie left who really wants to be there. Maybe the experience of being turned against by his family will give Jamie the strength he didn't have. He's obviously strong enough to plot a murder at this point. He's slowly becoming his father.
Or….she was wild at heart, a girl with spirit, who needed a steady, strong but kind and attentive mother to help her learn how to best channel her energies in beneficial ways without dimming her spark. It’s just a thought, another way to look at it.
Well I’m waiting on the release of the fifth on disc but I’ll be looking for the 1923 with Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren two greats maybe it’s not available yet don’t know yet for all I know it’s still in production I only heard about it. Btw damn his name just slipped my mind Faith’s husband you couldn’t have picked a better personality for that part he did really well for someone I’ve never seen act before.
The first part of season 5 is available. I’ve been watching the entire series on dvd myself and have been waiting for the second half of season 5 to come out before I buy that season
@@davidpar2 yeah not interested in buying TWO PARTS though I’ll wait for the FULL. I can appreciate there may be more cost involved in two although likely not however I’m practical more than anything and don’t need separate packaging it’s a waste plus storage consideration I only buy them because I don’t watch online.
I have been jumping from one episode to another to finally understand why Rip had no records and couldn't even get close to the courthouse when Beth was jailed after breaking a bottle on that bimbo...I enjoyed the episode although the bimbo wasn't unmasked in front of her husband.
Are you sure you want to see it? The bathtub scene’s ‘now I need to pass it on to you’ speech is on full display. It’s unpleasant (the mother’s treatment of Beth) but is a glimpse into the foundation of Beth’s pain.
@@JodiLeaSnakeQueen I assume you haven’t had a chance to watch the series? If you get the answers, it will contain spoilers. At minimum, with out too many spoilers, Rip has no records due to his family situation - he ran away from a terrible family situation, documents were either not available or possibly destroyed (accidentally? purposely?). It remains unstated whether Rip’s lack of docs was lost during his ‘traumatic family event’ or if John ensured he didn’t have records for Rip’s own protection from the law or if John saw a long term use for Rip as the Ranch’s fixer and having no papers was helpful to that end.
Also last one that was self defense like wtf 😳 again 😅 dude got a knife immediately has no one ever seen what a knife can do? It can kill . Very fast …..
Um… duh? This was not an extremely uncommon thing… by this time we had completely invaded their land; and most did pick up on English. For many many different reasons. Safety, survival, etc. Not an uncommon or unrealistic thing at all.
I work in a very large state park in the west, with a river running through it. It is not uncommon here that visitors will slip on rocks along the river and hit their head and pass away before they can be flown to a hospital. So yes, someone most certainly can die from being hit in the head too much. Happens all the time. Just sayin'.
Love the flashbacks with Rip. This show is the best. Please don’t end it.
TV shows that are great always end.
Not enough of them tho.
I'd rather see it end than be brought down by others trying to ruin it.
@@SuperNASCARrocks better to end , than to slide into a desperate attempt for content.
A strong woman holds a family together. The look of happiness when Mrs Dutton was still alive is indescribable.
Mrs. Dutton was abusive
@tropicaoptica I don't think she was though. She told Beth she was purposely going to mean to her to make her a tough woman. Unfortunately she died before she could see it through long enough for Beth to understand and not be warped by it.
@@toniemosley5694that’s abuse
@KadeStringer2.0 it's not abusive. Coddling kids all the time is why this generation is so soft and sensitive about everything. Why they all have a diagnosis of some kind, why the 🔫 up schools, why whenever they're challenged in the slightest and have a real world issue thrown at them, they have a nervous breakdown.
Love the care and love he gives his dad on his last day 😢
It makes me cry
@blueequine572 me too😢
Before my Grandfather died he wanted to ride one more time. Me my Daddy and 2 of my Uncles went to the barn and saddled up one of the sweetest old mares. He was paralyzed on the right side and had been bed ridden for 2 years but he rode her. I still miss him so much. ❤
Beautiful I bet he was a happy man
He must have been a special man.
And what he taught you and left
you in example will help take you through life..
@@tanyabruce1019 he was one of the best horseman I ever knew. What he and my father and one other old school man taught me helped me train horses. Thank you
helped me
@@maryannschlear5161 it helped me go far training horses. Thank you for your words
She must've been war proof if you trusted her to ride a man on his deathbed. That's a good horse right there. I want one like her for my daughter's first horse.
Shit I still haven't even watched this show and that scene with his Dad tore my heart right the hell out.
I've watched a few episodes and clips from the algorithm but old people get me EVERY TIME 😢
Every time, the scene John with his dad spending time for the last time hurts me because I miss my old man every day 😢
I miss my grandfather. He was the only father I knew and he loved me unconditionally. I'll carry that with me for the rest of my life...
I missed that one completely
I’m so sorry you lost your old man, I’m scared to death for that day to come, and it’s coming soon one of these days. My condolences to you and your family.
That’s what I would do 100 times twice on Sunday for my father. This son get me because it matches my childhood to a tee, i cry to this day ❤❤
I wish I had that pain. I really do
Ok. the flashback with John and his dad taking that horse ride together just me in the feels partially because it reminds me of grandpa and my mom. I could see her doing something like this and it freakin hits me in the gut
They did a good job of showing where Beth gets her affect in speech from, you can hear the same low and elongated tones when her mother speaks.
That “hard on your girls” speech is such a crock of shit. The world is hard on us, the world makes us hard, we don’t need our mothers to be hard on us.
The world is hard on you BECAUSE you don't have hard mothers. F-ing DUH!
The saying Hard men make soft times, soft times make soft men, soft men make hard times, repeat, applies just as much to women. My mom was a hardass and it made me a better man.
we really don't but teach us to be strong and independent . That's all we needed
Agreed. That was so ominous. The Evelyn didn’t seem to have educated Beth and the fact she was crying and saying “sorry” was rather telling about the kind of relationship the mother had with Beth. There are better ways to help prepare daughters for the world they will face.
The first of many cracks to show in an other wise " perfect" family.
@@ginao6810 life is full of speed-bumps , booze is like volunteering to add more speed-bumps , pot-holes, and a wedge between loved ones
The song playing during the father’s last talk is Daddy Doesn’t Pray Anymore by Chris Stapleton. My father crossed over in ‘98 and my husband in 2019. There are lots of good men over there.💕🦋
Lost my husband in 2019, too. Yes, there are, in fact, many good men over there
May the Lord Bless you both.
"Lawers are the sword of this century" one of the best lines ever. I hope Jaimie can recognize that he's the weapon yellowstone needs
Dude jamie literally isn't even his son he sent him to be a lawyer to protect their family and send him tf off.. exactly become something so I can protect this place. Why would he pick a child that wasn't even his to do that?
@beastfam251 he was raised as his own, granted they made that more difficult by hiding it forever. Ultimately people like me who have been raised with a dad and not the biological father leads to a better outcome most of the time. Yeah me and my dad fought and still do sometimes. If you look at how their lifestyle is and how they were raised it was a guaranteed thing of Jamie having a pretty kosher life as long as he didn't get a view of "I'm better than you ". I ain't blood related with my dad's side yet they were a keystone in most of not all of my difficult times of life.
@treycantrell8590 i'm extremely confused by your reply in your comment, you said that "i hope Jamie can recognize that he is the weapon that Yellowstone needs". He is a weapon but not what Yellowstone needs and never really has. He truly is a horrible disgusting person and im glad he's not John Duttons.
This is why I love the stories of Yellowstone. 😢
10:40 that tonal shift in the music gives me chills. Suddenly, a really sweet mother-daughter bonding moment becomes almost menacing
Josh Lucas plays such a great young version of John Dutton. Would love to see them do a show with him as John.
Taylor did a phenomenal job casting him as a younger John Dutton. When the younger John said,"Words are weapons now." Great line.
The actual ranch were it’s filmed is breathtaking!
The original ranch?
@@Ragitsu yes! The chief Joseph ranch
@user-nw7om2br5cprob Montana or Utah
I love the flashback scene with beth and her mother
Sometimes i wonder how well Rip would have gotten along with his mother in law if Beth’s mom hadn’t died.
Yea, but what was she talking about giving her...what now?
Great example of parental skills that have been forgotten and respect for your elders. That’s why this show hit close to home. 🇨🇦💝🇺🇸🙏👍
Everytime I see see John Dutton with his dad,it makes me tear up or cry,I don’t want that to happen to my dad,but it will,spend time with them and don’t lay around
"This ranch is the only family I've got." ❤❤
I cant get over parents who dont prep their daughters and let them think theyre expiring or have failed when their bodies bleed. Its a period and parents and guardians need to lwt their daughters know its going to happwn.
I wish your mother had taught you how to spell.
I know someone now who wasn’t told. You would think everyone these days is given info but nope
Idk what it's like in the States, but here in Canada, we have at least 5 puberty presentations for both genders since 6th grade. My sister saw all of them and was still scared.
@@reinmarren9959we used to have sex education but for some reason it was taken out of school
And she should have told her daughter about how not to get pregnant! Using condoms the right way. Taking the pill, emergency after pill. Beth's mother was not a good mother, but an abuser.
The respect shown to the Native Americans in this show is unprecedented. I still hate they cast a half white/half-asian woman as Monica, but I've learned to overlook that in the face of everything else.
Really liked the Tim McGraw flashbacks, too. Seeing young John I and Spencer with their parents. Would've like to see the kids return for flashbacks in 1923, but that could still happen with season 2.
The flashbacks in general are pretty good. 11:20 tells you everything you need to know about Jamie and John's relationship. Jamie just wanted to be like his Dad; a cowboy and rancher. You could see from his reaction and barrage of questions that he didn't want to be a lawyer. Jamie does what he's told and serves as the family counsel for 20 years only to be mistreated and disrespected by the very man who made him go. The very man who made him into something he didn't even want to be...
I think it's exactly precedented. Someone had to eventually honor Native People and Culture, especially in a show that centers on the land and impacts of oil and cattle. The respect of culture and land, and the relationship with the fact that people were pushed out of their homes and are still is evident, and it's a beautiful thing to see researched and respected here
I agree with you 100% about Jamie. He did everything his dad wanted and still that wasn’t enough. I honestly would just give up trying 🤷🏼♀️
Agreed. On all fronts. It would have been nice if Elsa and Sam had a kid or two and she wasn't offed so young.... nice to see Kayce, though, echoing his 5 great aunt Elsa in a sense. A Dutton with a First Nations Indigenous spouse, that also has deep ties to the land due to him possibly being the one to inherit the Yellowstone ranch... just sayin', nice tie back to Elsa and the 7th generation prophecy....
And as far as Jamie goes... Man. He should have just been allowed to become a rancher like John. Beth should have gone for that second degree. May have helped even her out. Jaime taking her for that abortion was not great, knowing what he knew about the whole procedure. ALSO, tying back to the respect for the Native American's and problems that no ONE ever talks about... that sterilization but, based on facts as well. Can we just say.... the writers know their stuff! It is quite impressive to see. I find myself going, "OH MY PANCAKES AND SYRUP!!! FINALLY!!! That's factual. THAT'S something too that they don't teach in public school history classes. Nope only if you go digging deeper into the archives or know SOMEONE from the reservation...." it is JUST... well done, all the way around. The good, the bad, and all of it.
Either way, Jamie made a HUGE mistake, sadly, with Beth and her abortion. And it's hard telling if he had his own agenda started then, because if she had the first male grand child, out of wedlock or not.... either way, whether it was intentional or unintentional on Jamie's part, fact remains, he robbed her of one of the things she really wanted in life WITHOUT being honest about it. And like John told a young Rip, you can't cry about the consequences AFTER the fact. You should HAVE considered them BEFOREHAND.... damn shame. I hope Jamie gets a bit of a redemption before he goes. HOWEVER... I still feel Beth is correct and Jamie needs to take a ride on the big black train. Though John seems to hesitate, which kinda proves to some degree, that he considers him family/one of his own.....
Genetically it's not too far off. Native Americans are fairly closely related to Asians ancestrally. Sometimes you gotta get people who look like they could be, when you can't find very many people who actually are.
@@sorrenblitz805this is a shit take. By your logic we’re all black because we all come out of Africa and essentially Ehtiopia. They had many indigenous women to pick from yet they chose to get the asian sexy looking “indigenous type”.
My family are ranchers. The part with John and his dad had my father and I balling.
I shoot hoops when I'm feeling down too
Me too.
which state in the US have most ranches and cowboys?
@@freidapaynor1641 Texas
@@freidapaynor1641 Texas
3:38. That, let's go, son, look. I've seen the look 1,000 times. I've given that look 1,000 times. Well done.
Biggest mistake John made was sending Jami to college to become a lawyer.
Or - adopting him in the first place... 🤷♀️
@@DianaJG8 I wouldn’t say adopting him was a mistake. It was him sending Jamie to college to be a lawyer that lead Jamie into developing his own motives and agenda of wanting to do certain things the right way. John wasn’t about doing things the right way if situations were serious, their family being threatened. John may be a fault for sending Jamie to college, but he ain’t at fault for what Jamie became when he became a lawyer. That’s all Jamie’s doing, under the influence of others who easily manipulated Jamie by striking at his ego.
@@kjiggidy5719 Well, Jamie never wanted to be a lawyer. Just a rancher. He, ultimately, wants the same thing John does: for the Yellowstone ranch to survive and be inherited by future generations of Duttons. It's just that while Jamie wants to go about it the sensible, beneficial way, John wants to go about it the old school wild west way. It's for this reason the ranch is suffering and why his oldest son is dead.
Jamie's really not a bad guy, when you think about it. He's just desperate for acceptance and suffers from a lack of self-confidence. A guy like that, regardless of how smart he is, is bound to make poor choices and some mistakes. Like the rest of his family, he's no angel. But compared to the rest of them, Beth especially, he's a saint...
@@neonrodenson1480 if you believe that then stick with it. We all have our opinions at the end of the day. But he ain’t no saint, none of them are. And that’s the point of the Dutton family, stretching back to James Dutton and the rest of the first generation. None of them were/are saints. Jamie’s not a Dutton, but still being as one; he is far from being a saint. No matter how you slice it and defend it.
@@kjiggidy5719 Most of what I said isn't an opinion. In Seasons 1, 2, and 5, it's explicitly shown or said (or both) more than once and often revisited and echoed between 3-4.
And I said he's a saint "by comparison". He's got blood on his hands and did terrible things, too. Just not nearly as much or as comfortably as his family. And blood Dutton or not (I personally believe that online theory that he is), just having the name curses him...
I really, really want to see Jaime redeem himself in some way. I hope we see it… I have a feeling season 5 is going to throw us a lot of curveballs. Especially concerning Jaime.
In a way I don't blame him, Beth can drive someone to kill.
4:25 I can’t wait to meet John’s father in his younger days in the later upcoming 1944. See his growth to being a rancher and running the ranch after his father, (Jack or Spencer).
I'm betting its Spencer. IMO, Alex on the boat was suffering from morning sickness and not boat sickness, she had a different glow.
@@Th_Ppptmstr that or she might possibly have tuberculosis. When the boat was flipped over by the ghost ship, Alex was thrown from her bed and landed on the Captain’s and hit the pillows that had his blood all around it. She could’ve caught tuberculosis from that. So it’s either or. Guess we’ll see when S2 come out.
Is it going to be Matthew McConaughey?
I believe it will be Spencer and Alex. Spencer is hard enough to deal with banner. Alex will find him in Montana and be the reason the ranch gets upgraded to the 20th century. To me this is the only way forward but I’m not Taylor s.
@@DianaJG8 that’s what I heard. It would make sense, Spencer is 37 years old in 1923. When it’s 1944, it’ll be 21 years later. He’ll be like 58.
i wish there were more flashbacks with Evelyn
That scene with his old dad .. moving.
This actually made me cry 😢i miss my dad so much 😢 watched him lay in bed for days or sit up in bed cause the cancer hurt him so bad 😢😢😢😢
Lost an uncle this week.. Found out he was way more than just a great guy... His obit. read like a resume for a man of "exceptional character:"
Everyone knows John Dutton’s favorite Child is the Yellowstone
Anyone else wish we could have gotten a Yellowstone 90s miniseries featuring this family when they were young?
Beth’s mother did her a disservice.
Beth sounds just like her mom. 😢
Her mom was right about what she said to her in the bathroom. Every single word; about how humanity would end in two generations if they were the ones to deliver babies and how from the moment a girl turns a woman, they will try to make us feel less... that's a real Mom.
(Beth's Mom wanted to toughen her daughter up as she had 3 brothers to deal with when growing up..! Horses & Ranching
It is so impressive how these flashback's actors looks like the main actors that some times I suspect that they are using AI to make them younger.
Okay I guess I’m crying today
"Horses can graze here."
Foot o' snow on the ground 🤦♂️
And there's grass underneath. Quit complaining.
Tell us you don't own horses without telling us 🤦♂️@@shiloh2735
To quote Jurassic Park, life finds a way. Horses have delt with snow for thousands of years. They'll find their food underneath it all.
How to say I'm ignorant of horses,with out actually saying so!!😅😅😅
The honesty that came from the young man , apologizing to the chief. You don't hear that kind of respect from kids there days
The farther you get into the show it almost comes off like the Dutton's care about the land even more than the indigenous do. Even Thomas who constantly fought with John to try and get the land back was taken aback by how far John would go to defend it
When your pop's dying words are "don't give them an inch" that's why lol.
When my dad bought our farm in 1961, it was the first time in his life he had a stable place to live, his parents were the type to move yearly or even several times a year, and he grew up hating it. So he stayed there for 62 years now, and I know when his end comes he might say something similar, at the very least don't lose it, don't let it get taken, sell if I want to but make sure you bleed the buyer for every penny it's worth. I've lived there for 40 years, it's my paradise, 100 acres of absolute peace and security and safety that's OURS, free and clear. I don't want to give that up, it's more valuable than money.
Pick up a history book this has been happening for millions of years. It didn't start with this fictitious story. Or with the Americans. Did you know that the Portuguese were the first to the trade S l a ves
@@FicklePickleJar bro. I'm talking about the show only. Get off your high horse
Even when he was young, Rip was quite the badass
The writing in this show js amazing (from what I’ve seen on youtube shorts).
Kevin don't leave us yet!!!
I'm not falling for all the sensation lies headlines because behind the scenes nobody has set a damn thing about Kevin leaving. This is all hype to drive people for clicks to their websites.
@@jhamptonjr yeah that's what I thought, no official comment from Mr Dutton himself
A real man doesn’t look a a female as weak he sees the most beautiful thing god ever created and she has strength in ways he doesn’t and it deserves to be respected and defended we really need to start watching how we word things to young children
And how many real men are out there?
If we raise our children right they’ll be more
Simp
😂
I’m not talking about alpha and beta, and all that bullshit I’m talking about each gender having its purpose and responsibilities, and being special in its own way, and teaching our children, these purpose and responsibilities, instead of trying to teach them that their purpose is to be a millionaire or that their purpose is to constantly compete with the opposite sex
Taylor has bitten off more than he could chew and us fans are and will suffer for it.
what do u mean?
@@jordanzdebski5132
Hmm………..Apparently you’ve not heard about how much Taylor has going on and that he’s the reason for the delays in finishing the second half of season 5. As he hasn’t had the scripts and other necessities ready at the moment filming was to start back. But everyone else was ready. So in my opinion, he’s bitten off more than he can chew. He needs to focus more on his bread and butter show Yellowstone and delegate duties for the other shows to someone else.
@@michaelbrant1503 It's also why the last season of Yellowstone was so lackluster
I have faith in Sheridan. But I, too, have mixed feelings about season 6 and why it will be the last season.
Do you know more about the controversy than I do? Can you explain? so I don’t have to read it on google myself 😂😅
🙂
@@michaelbrant1503 Yeah and from the looks of things part 2 of Season 5 wil be the last season of Yellowstone we'll be getting. Or at the least the last season with John Dutton in it. Though I agree. Sheridan should have first finished Yellowstone (ideally with a 6th and final season). Then he could have gone on to make the prequels.
So, it took me a minute to realize how since this was back then, when it took place... Most boys weren't raised up with respect for a women's own body-mind and women were raised up to believe they only had one purpose and that they are just another to get used and knocked up. Boy's not being able to show their tears, that one I'll look past considering WHERE THEY ARE, How they're livin'. Not showing any vulnerable, clowded with emotion minds. They have to stay aware and be prepared.
I think you have that reversed, TODAY kids are raised like you describe, back then you abused a woman you were more likely than not beaten to death by the other local men like John Dutton...He blasted his own son in the face for hitting Beth, his sister, with the admonishment that a man NEVER hits a woman.
And sorry to JD, but I'm the only boy of 7 kids, if I wasn't willing to hit a woman i'd have starved to death or died as a little boy lol.
"Don't mess with Beth."
When you let anger overpower you ,you become blindsided, and then there are consequences.The fist can be a dangerous weapon if not controlled,therefore, we must manage our anger issue,preventing fatality.
The new post he stuck in the ground was the same depth as the one he had just finished driving in.
It was lower on the hill. I had to look back at it too.
What about the Tribes they took it from as well as the tribes they in turn took it from. This is the history of the native people.
I wonder when we will get a Flashback that is focused on Kayce ?
Evelyn Dutton was toxic as a mother but the actress is excellent in her flashbacks
The one dislike is from Jamie
Please don’t let season 5 be the last season
Honestly, I think that'd be for the best. It's starting to peak...
@@neonrodenson1480been peaked
How cool to of lived back then.
We are going to to use that euphemism from now on: that person is going to the train station. Hahaha!!
So you dont have to be hard on your daughters because they get their periods. Jesus.
Omg I have to see this show
13:01
Wow…
He kinda messed Jaime up come to think of it…
Someone knows the song name? 3:20😢
Chris Stapleton- Daddy Doesn’t Pray Anymore.
Don't end Yellowstone
Dammit, who's cutting onions in here??
It would be very disheartening if they canceled the show after season 5 just because Kevin Costner wants to work on another project. There are so many other phenomenal actors that are carrying this show, and for some of them, it's their big break. For others who came on later in the series, they've played standout characters that will be gone before they get the chance to develop further.
My suggestion would be to have Jamie and Sarah hire a hitman to kill John and Beth, but someone else gets to John first and he dies. This means Kayce steps up to protect the ranch, Jamie is ridden with guilt over what he was about to do and returns the family, and Beth reeks havoc in an effort to the find the person who did it. The coming together of sides to get justice for their father could finally help to settle the feud between Beth and Jamie. Carter steadily the takes the form of Rip 2.0 for Tate and is accepted as Beth's son. Maybe Jamie dies in some honorable last sacrifice that proves his loyalty to the ranch and Beth takes care of his son, thus fulfilling the Dutton family dream of "having enough sons after all on one road together."
Not bad but Jamie is a full blown narcissist and they never feel remorse. I think Beth should take her father's place as crazy head of the family and Yellowstone. With Rip close to her, there will be a balance 😂 and other stories can go on. John can die tragically on the hands of Jamie because a heart attack would be too natural for people craving drama...I mean everyone 😂... but Beth is the best character to keep the series moving on.
@Lyrielonwind I respectfully disagree. Jamie is a tragic character thrust into villain status by lack of a properly developed story arc, which Taylor Sheridan admits himself. Jamie is remorseful, as seen during the murder of Sara Nyugen at the start of the series. He has a full-fledged panic attack, grief stricken, and full of self-loathing over his actions. He tells Beth during a car ride that he will allow Beth to hate him for everything if it means she stops hating herself, which is about as sacrificial as he can get. He also tells Beth that taking her to get an abortion was the single worst decision of his life. Beth is completely unhinged and sadistic at this point in the story. The only thing standing between her and the abyss is Rip, who she has been lying to for years about the abortion of his child, a situation she completely blames on Jamie even though she, in part, requested it from him. Between her and Jamie, she is the one who takes zero accountability and has no remorse for any actions she takes, always justifying it as "what is necessary for the ranch." Jamie is effectively Frankensteins monster, with John being his maker and potential victim. The only way for the ranch to be saved at this point is if Jamie and Beth move past their trauma and pool their resources.
@@loliver9660
Agree to a certain point; she wanted an abortion, not being unable to ever have children and Jamie didn't tell her but I agree there are far too many unresolved trauma going on. Anyway, I understand you like Jamie more. To me he's a narcissist and Beth is borderline but I still would prefer a Beth than a Jamie in my life if I could choose because Beth might be crazy but she can be the most loyal person in your side. Jamie only cares about his ego and butt.
We could be arguing about it for hours but it's not in our hands to give it a way out and have a fair close or end...I don't think it's possible; both have been too damaged.
Jamie’s character doesn’t have the strength to lead the family.
@mircat28 Agreed, but I guess I wonder why there needs to be a "leader" in any family. True, there is usually an older matriarch/patriarch in the form of a grandparent who provides words of wisdom, but ultimately a family is made up of individual people who create their own special units by getting married and having kids. In the case of the Duttons, Kayce and Monica have their own life away from everyone. Beth has repeatedly said that she would leave as soon as he father dies. Lee is gone, so there is only Jamie left who really wants to be there. Maybe the experience of being turned against by his family will give Jamie the strength he didn't have. He's obviously strong enough to plot a murder at this point. He's slowly becoming his father.
I don't understand her mom being nice to her, her mother hated her
John should have never interfered in his children's futures.
Jeez what a monster Beth's mom was. Terrorizing her own daughter wit her "you are less" speech. And Beth turned out to be a angry train wreck too.
Johns dad went out the best way
7:37 Christmas at the Dutton's
So sad to see the show demise like this .
It’s crazy how nuts Beth has always been
Or….she was wild at heart, a girl with spirit, who needed a steady, strong but kind and attentive mother to help her learn how to best channel her energies in beneficial ways without dimming her spark. It’s just a thought, another way to look at it.
Bad gyal Beth is my favorite character on Yellowstone. She's such a beyotch and gives zero effs!😂
What episode is this
A powerful story! Nuf sed.
Like these flashbacks
@7:38 aye my first Christmas! I was just a little over a month old
LUKE FLANIGAN WOULD LOVE THIS SHOW ! ❤
John made mistakes, but none of them were bigger then sending Jamie to Harvard.
6:04 “only took 90 years.” 🥲🥹
We lost Dabney Coleman last week
All I can think at 13:10 is “Ugh, here comes this annoying bish”
Well I’m waiting on the release of the fifth on disc but I’ll be looking for the 1923 with Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren two greats maybe it’s not available yet don’t know yet for all I know it’s still in production I only heard about it. Btw damn his name just slipped my mind Faith’s husband you couldn’t have picked a better personality for that part he did really well for someone I’ve never seen act before.
Tim Mc Graw
@@virginiadaneke2362 yes that’s it thank you he did really well he showed a character in control of himself making his own way
John's wife don't seem to have that motherly nature like the others. Like she want to be meaner than the world already is.
The first part of season 5 is available. I’ve been watching the entire series on dvd myself and have been waiting for the second half of season 5 to come out before I buy that season
@@davidpar2 yeah not interested in buying TWO PARTS though I’ll wait for the FULL. I can appreciate there may be more cost involved in two although likely not however I’m practical more than anything and don’t need separate packaging it’s a waste plus storage consideration I only buy them because I don’t watch online.
Noticeably Beth is wearing inappropriate clothing AGAIN. "how to make money off of other people's money".
Still can't find the one where Beth's mother died.
I have been jumping from one episode to another to finally understand why Rip had no records and couldn't even get close to the courthouse when Beth was jailed after breaking a bottle on that bimbo...I enjoyed the episode although the bimbo wasn't unmasked in front of her husband.
@Lyrielonwind did you find out why rip doesn't have records?
Because I can't unfortunately
Are you sure you want to see it? The bathtub scene’s ‘now I need to pass it on to you’ speech is on full display. It’s unpleasant (the mother’s treatment of Beth) but is a glimpse into the foundation of Beth’s pain.
@@JodiLeaSnakeQueen I assume you haven’t had a chance to watch the series? If you get the answers, it will contain spoilers. At minimum, with out too many spoilers, Rip has no records due to his family situation - he ran away from a terrible family situation, documents were either not available or possibly destroyed (accidentally? purposely?). It remains unstated whether Rip’s lack of docs was lost during his ‘traumatic family event’ or if John ensured he didn’t have records for Rip’s own protection from the law or if John saw a long term use for Rip as the Ranch’s fixer and having no papers was helpful to that end.
th-cam.com/video/0qMCgYr4RcE/w-d-xo.htmlsi=jSFSPFxINoGVZ5o5
@10:57 shes actually wrong
Kevin Cosner my crush 😍😍😍😍😘😘😘
So whoever lives or gets to the land first owns it? I guess the US owns the moon and Mars now. Huh?
You watch, eventually we will
How old was lee in this flashback?
Those poles will be crooked ah.
Season 5 pt II getting released in 2030
Your date is very wrong
What about the flashback where Beth has an abortion
Also last one that was self defense like wtf 😳 again 😅 dude got a knife immediately has no one ever seen what a knife can do? It can kill . Very fast …..
I’m midway but damn the period one is a little harsh !!?? Like WTF 😳
9:07 heating pad
Too many ads! Couldn't watch
Was this Tim McGraw in the beginning of the scene?
Yes from 1888
Death is the only fren you have.... damm
With all his family has done for the Native Americans I don't understand why all seem to initially have contempt for him.
I’m pretty sure that this series has ran its course. They should have ended it after season 4
Amazing how in the first scene all the Native Americans just happen to speak perfect American English...
Um… duh?
This was not an extremely uncommon thing… by this time we had completely invaded their land; and most did pick up on English. For many many different reasons. Safety, survival, etc.
Not an uncommon or unrealistic thing at all.
Lol they were captured and put into camps and boarding schools .....so they were forced to learn to study up please 😮
Watch 1923
Did you want subtitles?
Are you saying Native Americans are uneducated savages, incapable of conversing in multiple languages?
That's not the best bias to hold.
People don't die like that. Lol.
They certainly can if a fractured skull with bleeding and/or swelling of the brain.
@@rowanaforrest9792 thank you lol somebody with a brain
John's dad and Emmett both died a cowboys way.
Ah, yes they do. My Dad passed in March, you obviously missed an opportunity to learn.
I work in a very large state park in the west, with a river running through it. It is not uncommon here that visitors will slip on rocks along the river and hit their head and pass away before they can be flown to a hospital. So yes, someone most certainly can die from being hit in the head too much. Happens all the time. Just sayin'.
Bad parenting programming right there