Outstanding. Absolutely great. Renata Tebaldi was one of the best if not the best of her generation. Her vocal range was absolutely unbelievable. No singer of today can come even close.
Magnifica voce chiara comprensibile in ogni passaggio, potente e aggraziata dà un piacere immenso nell'ascoltarla. Un bel regalo della natura. Grazie natura.
Ho imparato ad amare la lirica con i dischi della coppia Del Monaco _ Tebaldi, molti anni or sono. Questa voce d angelo mi ha sempre accompagnato durante la mia vita, che sia nei belli momenti che in quelli più tristi. Renata eterna😘💗
she moves the way she sings..... everything she does seems to underline the line of the voice ....focusing the legato...and never visually disturbing the feeling and concentration of the audience! Many artists....even great ones...are so fussy in their movements as to detract from the mood through distracting constantly.....waking the viewer from the state of holding their collective breath in the moment of emotion. Tebaldi....through instinct or design......was never ever guilty of this fault!.......and this in itself could ammount to at least half of her compelling addictive effect!....the other half being her personal beauty and the sheer gorgious sound of that great voice!!
Una vera Voce d'Angelo,la Tebaldi nel ruolo e nell'aria che le stava piu' congeniale. Emoziona da fare accapponare la pelle risentirla.......cosi' sempre emozionante.. Questa e' storia dell'interpretazione.
I am immensely fortunate to have seen live performances of Madama Butterfly with Leontyne Price, Renata Scotto, Yasuko Hayashi... the list goes on. However, this video of Renata Tebaldi is astonishing. Those who fault her as an actress must see this. I was artistic director of a professional regional theater for nearly thirty years and I am here to say that Tebaldi's performance here is not only vocally ravishing, but I have never been so moved by "Un bel di vedremo" as I was watching this video. She is utterly connected with every word, every gesture, every moment. Her "meanings" are perfectly articulated throughout the aria. I have always loved Renata Tebaldi as a singer, but this video reveals a dimension and a depth to her that, frankly, I didn't know existed. Perhaps she simply needed great directors to access all that she had inside. I would do anything to get my hands on the complete opera video, if it exists. I'd appreciate any suggestions. In the meantime, thank you, Renata... this is astounding! It is art in its highest form.
La perfezione di una voce sublime. Mai ascoltata sinora da nessun altra cantante d'opera. Perfezione allo stato puro di fiati legature piani.. Magnificenza
Yes, her voice is one of nature's greatest miracles but listen to what she does with it. It's bright and girlish and dark and angry and hopeful and playful and she is the most sincere actress, this IS Butterfly.
Wir haben sie bewundert und geliebt, Tebaldi, Siepi, Wunderlich und viele mehr. Aber erst heute wissen wir Alten in welcher großartigen Zeit wir damals lebten. Es bleibt uns die Erinnerung.
No doubt about it. Tebaldi had a ravishing vocal endowment and she was a wonderfully disciplined artist. No reason whatsoever to compare her and Maria Callas. Both had different attributes, sought different artistic goals, and really specialized in their own respective repertoires. Both defined a period in Italian opera that we will not likely encounter again. Brava to both of these and sublime goddesses.
Sublime, potente e cristallina nel canto, immaginifica e delicata fino alla pura essenzialità nei gesti e nei movimenti: Cio-cio san è lei, Renata Tebaldi!
@@debbiejohnson2789 Give credit to Puccini to write on this, how many poor japanese women at that time to be in the same boat. Despised by their own family and society, and eventually despised by american society and their american boys in the same time. It is the glory turning point of opera to turn attention from queen king duke prince into oridinary poor and depressed people, Bravo Puccini.
@@debbiejohnson2789 Tebaldi's acting alone deserves gold medal. Not even seen the same from Japanese or Chinese sopranos. Her japanese movements are superb, exact. It cannot be learned or mastered simply by just do it. Shows her devotion to the finest of the finest art, no stone unturned. Shame to those modern over paid stars of casual walk not even 10 % of this version. Not even to go to her voice to be wowed.
Божественный голос у Tebaldi, все-таки. А в данном случае - еще и прекрасная актерская интерпретация, стопроцентное попадание в роль 🎯💯 Талантливейшая работа, просто исключительная Cio-Cio-San!🪷🦋🌸🏯 Блеск 👏
I bought my father the complete recording of "Madame Butterfly" with Renata Tebaldi as Butterfly when I was a little girl (for HIS birthday) but as he was a trombonist and I was a singer guess who the recording was really for....? My father just smiled and I played the recording over again and again. For me Tebaldi is Butterfly - just a perfect rendition of the aria. Sorry Dad !!!!
Claudio Persi Non ci sono più perché negli ultimi 40 anni le donne, in Italia e nell’Europa benestante, si sono emancipate da ogni ruolo “femminile” e femminilizzante. Parlano con voci un’ottava o due ottave sotto, tenorili. Fumano come camionisti e tutto il resto. Bisogna trovare quelle “vocine” nell’Est Europa o nel quarto mondo ancora patriarcale. È politicamente scorretto ma è la realtà. In compenso...in Italia è tutto un fiorire di controtenori e Haute-contre...chissà come mai...
@@johnareiter73 ¡ Never ! Callas was not and never will be Butterfly. Callas was a product of marketing. Her voice, metallic, out of pitch will never reach the beauty of Tebaldi, Moffo, Caballé, Tomowa Sintow and many others. Callas was a great actress, I agree, but, opera needs singers with beatiful voices, not actresses, and Callas voice was not beautiful. When I was young I thought Callas was the number one and the only one in the planet, but, as I grew up, I realised that I was wrong. After many years of listening and going to recitals, concerts and operas, I realised what I am telling you. Callas was not the star that many people think she was. I invite you to listen carefully, without knowing who is singing.
Tibaldi is Butterfly this brings me to tears every time! to be so in love with an character from an opera for half my life now...... Bless your Soul Renetta Tibaldi and thank you, in Jesus Holy name Amen
OMG! I have to say one of the best butterflies i have ever heard and seen acted splendidly... Voice soo warm and emotions very well understood. What I also very much liked is that Tebaldi actually acts like a Japanese woman...with the etiquitte and everything....the way she moves her hands, the way she walks, her restricted movement, her shy character, everything! Officially the perfect Butterfly!
Perfetta la Tebaldi, come del resto sempre , non a caso mio nonno che amava la lirica, la preferiva a tutte le cantanti della storia, anche alla stessa Callas.
This work by Puccini is a masterpiece of creative genius. He has revealed to us what it is to love another person with all your soul. This love is beautiful and pure. Puccini shows how we should live to give all to the beloved. This is to my mind the highest purpose of the true art. I cannot praise this performance enough. Thank you for the posting.
I totally disagree with your conclusion. She lost all, not only her life, also her child, and her tradition and her ancestor, relative's connection. It is the very most sacrifice, most tragic of the saddest thing on earth. No one should live as she did.
Duh! In case you hadn't noticed it's a tragedy (as are most Puccini's opera's) He usually deals with flawed love and his heroines almost invariably are poorly treated and die a tragic death. Puccini certainly didn't see his female leads love in the way your suggesting.
Per emissione, timbro privilegiato, cavata e fermezza dei suoni (senza sottintenderne la forza dell'interpretazione stilizzatissima), la Tebaldi è qui ineguagliabile. Mi piacerebbe approfondire le motivazioni che hanno basato i 50 bastian-contrari del "pollice verso"...
evidentemente guardano questi video senza capirne nulla ma vogliono lo stesso lasciare un segno facendo una figuraccia comunque anche essendo digiuni di musica lirica non si puo non apprezzare la perfezione di questa interpretazione
+giò lupo sono già 147 intenditori che non apprezzano questa interpretazione sublime della Tebaldi. la ragione ? la scarsa registrazione che non ha niente à vedere con la verità artistica. questa interpretazione meravigliosa della Tebaldi può essere apprezzata soltanto dei professionisti e quelli che conoscano la vera arte lirica. per il resto del mondo la bassissima qualità di questa registrazione è la ''prova'' che La Tebaldi aveva poca voce. di più la sua voce in questo video non è neanche l'ombra alla voce che aveva dal vivo La Tebaldi. non è la colpa del pubblico ma dei tecnici del suono che non hanno riuscito di fare una registrazione degna di questa voce divina. io la penso così.
I watched Tebaldi sing Butterfly high up in the gallery of the Rome opera house, and found her magical in expression. Every word could be understood. I am English but speak Italian, and there were no translations then.
The "old-fashioned acting" is magnificent! The gestures were specially learned by Tebaldi from the director Yoshio Aoyama when Tebaldi sang her first Butterflys at the Met. They are so expressive and touching.. And then, the singing is so rich and beautiful, and NOBODY gives more innocent heart to phrases such as "Chi sara? Chi sara? E come sara giunto?"
she moves the way she sings..... everything she does seems to underline the line of the voice ....focusing the legato...and never visually disturbing the feeling and concentration of the audience! Many artists....even great ones...are so fussy in thier movements as to detract from the mood through distracting constantly.....waking the viewer from the state of holding their collective breath in the moment of emotion. Tebaldi....through instinct or design......was never ever guilty of this fault!.......and this in itself could ammount to at least half of her compelling addictive effect!....the other half being her personal beauty and the sheer gorgious sound of that great voice!!
Opera has been described as the most difficult art and I wholeheartedly agree. Put some middle aged people on stage, wearing pancake make up, playing other races, singing and performing a piece that has been played 1,000 times, and et with all th3 artifice one can suspend disbelief and be moved by the incredible voice and music, moving grown up folks who may have seen the same opera a dozen times to tears. That's an incredible feat.
e comunque grazie davvero.❤
Sarà stata pure “Voce D’Angelo” ma possedeva una gran voce… Potente Profonda con note e fraseggio perfetti… Formidabile
She was the only ONE.
The silkiness, the velvety of Her voice is incredible
Singing and acting of the highest quality. Overwhelming.
Renata Tebaldi was born to sing Puccini
She is my favorite. The voice is rich and smooth.
Sublime. La perfezione di questa interpretazione è un portento dell'arte del canto.
Meravigliosa Voce!!
Roberto la Tebaldi è’ meglio della Callas
Roberto ti amo tantissimo amore mio
No one does it like CALLAS! NO COMPARISON!
One of the best unforgetable emotional Aria... Reneta Tebaldi is singing so beautifully ... touching your heart... 😍🙏❤️💐
В этой опере Рената божественна! Каждая нота каждый жест отточенные! Непревзойденное исполнение!
Just astounding, that performance, both visually and aurally. Stirs something inside the listener that is close to sublime.
La voce piu bella del mondo.
Bravissima. In questa aria penso sia stata una delle migliori in assoluto. Una vera emozione.
Vedere la Tebaldi cantare e muoversi è di una bellezza autentica
Si vede che ha studiato i movimenti delle geisha, come muove le mani. Stupenda.
Vero
davvero! sono d'accordo
Hello pretty lady 💖
Ehhhh....nel podio delle migliori.... delle eccezionali !!!
Riguardo spesso questo video ed ogni volta mi commuovo fino alle lacrime. Meravigliosa Butterfly, grande la Tebaldi. Numero uno.
In questo 'opera si , è insuperabile 🌹✨✨✨
The best Mdme Butterfly ever. Period
Lo stesso effetto fa anche a me......interpretazione impressionante ❤❤
Outstanding. Absolutely great. Renata Tebaldi was one of the best if not the best of her generation. Her vocal range was absolutely unbelievable. No singer of today can come even close.
I agree. Heavenly voice, heavenly performance, so breath taking and that white kimono was perfection.
Il ne faudrait pas oublier MARIA CALLAS
How do you feel about Leontyne Price???? Priceless?
⁶⁶@@maryleone2023
Magnifica voce chiara comprensibile in ogni passaggio, potente e aggraziata dà un piacere immenso nell'ascoltarla. Un bel regalo della natura. Grazie natura.
😊0ttisimo
Natura ,sentimento , tecnica sublime ,meravigliosa ❤️
Une Tebaldi émouvante dans Madame Butterfly ! Bravissima Renata ....le désespoir d'une mère qui me bouleverse toujours...merci
Ho imparato ad amare la lirica con i dischi della coppia Del Monaco _ Tebaldi, molti anni or sono.
Questa voce d angelo mi ha sempre accompagnato durante la mia vita, che sia nei belli momenti che in quelli più tristi.
Renata eterna😘💗
I am touched to tears whenever I view this aria.
That's why I am a big fan in S. Korea of Renata Tebaldi.
Interprétation exemplaire, tout commentaire est superflu. - Il fallait le dire.
Grand. Most beautiful performance. It is golden operatic era. Glorious, thank u!
They are all great. Renata Tebaldi' s voice sounds like coming from the skies.
Maria Callas' voice sounds like coming from deep earth.
KOSTAS TRENT
Diciamo tanto della Callas ma avevamo ed abbiamo(xche' x me è sempre e tale rimarrà) una cantante lirica al disopra di tutti che è Renata Tebaldi
Hello pretty lady 💖
A great artist! When I play Madama Butterfly, the natural stage movements and the vocal elegance of Renata Tebaldi are always great lessons for me
Non ci sono parole, la commozione mi 8mpefisxe di parlare: eccezionale Renata
she moves the way she sings..... everything she does seems to underline the line of the voice ....focusing the legato...and never visually disturbing the feeling and concentration of the audience!
Many artists....even great ones...are so fussy in their movements as to detract from the mood through distracting constantly.....waking the viewer from the state of holding their collective breath in the moment of emotion.
Tebaldi....through instinct or design......was never ever guilty of this fault!.......and this in itself could ammount to at least half of her compelling addictive effect!....the other half being her personal beauty and the sheer gorgious sound of that great voice!!
Una vera Voce d'Angelo,la Tebaldi nel ruolo e nell'aria che le stava piu' congeniale.
Emoziona da fare accapponare la pelle risentirla.......cosi' sempre emozionante..
Questa e' storia dell'interpretazione.
Marvelous, celestial!!!!!
No one like her. This is the must beautiful performance of Madam butterfly.
Hello pretty lady 💖
This aria is the most beautiful ever written.
I am immensely fortunate to have seen live performances of Madama Butterfly with Leontyne Price, Renata Scotto, Yasuko Hayashi... the list goes on. However, this video of Renata Tebaldi is astonishing. Those who fault her as an actress must see this. I was artistic director of a professional regional theater for nearly thirty years and I am here to say that Tebaldi's performance here is not only vocally ravishing, but I have never been so moved by "Un bel di vedremo" as I was watching this video. She is utterly connected with every word, every gesture, every moment. Her "meanings" are perfectly articulated throughout the aria. I have always loved Renata Tebaldi as a singer, but this video reveals a dimension and a depth to her that, frankly, I didn't know existed. Perhaps she simply needed great directors to access all that she had inside. I would do anything to get my hands on the complete opera video, if it exists. I'd appreciate any suggestions. In the meantime, thank you, Renata... this is astounding! It is art in its highest form.
A question for you Steve: You are very competent in Opera and what do you think about Dal Monte? i mean "la Toti"
Antonello Bada' I’m sorry, but I’m not familiar with the artist you mention. Please tell me more!
@@stevecampo1618 thanks for answering back. Toti dal Monte was a Soprano in the 20's to 40's she was Toscanini's favourite.
Antonello Bada' Sorry for my slow response. I will search for recordings of the singer you mention and let you know what I come up with. Thanks!
Inpresionante
Voce llimpida,cristallina,dolce,ma nello stesso tempo drammatica e potente.
La perfezione di una voce sublime. Mai ascoltata sinora da nessun altra cantante d'opera. Perfezione allo stato puro di fiati legature piani.. Magnificenza
Yes, her voice is one of nature's greatest miracles but listen to what she does with it. It's bright and girlish and dark and angry and hopeful and playful and she is the most sincere actress, this IS Butterfly.
Very insightful commentary.
Orfeus80 Yes, very well said, completely true
After Callas this is my favorite.
Wir haben sie bewundert und geliebt, Tebaldi, Siepi, Wunderlich und viele mehr. Aber erst heute wissen wir Alten in welcher großartigen Zeit wir damals lebten. Es bleibt uns die Erinnerung.
Absolutely !!!!!
Grandiosa da brividi , ricordo mia madre che mi parlava della sua bravura 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
No doubt about it. Tebaldi had a ravishing vocal endowment and she was a wonderfully disciplined artist. No reason whatsoever to compare her and Maria Callas. Both had different attributes, sought different artistic goals, and really specialized in their own respective repertoires. Both defined a period in Italian opera that we will not likely encounter again.
Brava to both of these and sublime goddesses.
+Larry Mitchell Sooooooo well said. Bravo to you.
+Larry Mitchell So perfectly said
Larry Mitchell nilla pizzinonpass0
di apprendimento
non passa piunilla piz
I totally agree!!!
Well said and I do so agree.
Sublime, potente e cristallina nel canto, immaginifica e delicata fino alla pura essenzialità nei gesti e nei movimenti: Cio-cio san è lei, Renata Tebaldi!
Renata Tebaldi riesce sempre ad emozionarmi con questa stupenda interpretazione!
grande la nostra renata.
No tengo palabras
Quand'ero piu giovane ora ho 70 anni vidi la Tebaldi a Pesaro STRAORDINARIA
Miss Tebaldi💖 is extraordinary. Marvelous soprano🌟. One of the best ever🌹. So lovely and sophisticated.☀️
I love your word, sophisticated. She does have the hightest music IQ, to me.
Extremely beautiful rendition . Voice has the emotion! She was a tall and classy. lady!
Heartbreaking aria. Damn Pinkerton for breaking her heart!
@@debbiejohnson2789 Give credit to Puccini to write on this, how many poor japanese women at that time to be in the same boat. Despised by their own family and society, and eventually despised by american society and their american boys in the same time.
It is the glory turning point of opera to turn attention from queen king duke prince into oridinary poor and depressed people, Bravo Puccini.
@@debbiejohnson2789 Tebaldi's acting alone deserves gold medal. Not even seen the same from Japanese or Chinese sopranos. Her japanese movements are superb, exact. It cannot be learned or mastered simply by just do it. Shows her devotion to the finest of the finest art, no stone unturned. Shame to those modern over paid stars of casual walk not even 10 % of this version. Not even to go to her voice to be wowed.
Questa interpretazione dopo anni mi emoziona sempre. La migliore Madame Butterfly ❤
Es impresionante cómo une una preciosa voz a una intensidad y capacidad dramática extraordinarias. Emocionante, perfecta, grandiosa.
her voice is really amazing!
Божественный голос у Tebaldi, все-таки.
А в данном случае - еще и прекрасная актерская интерпретация, стопроцентное попадание в роль 🎯💯
Талантливейшая работа, просто исключительная Cio-Cio-San!🪷🦋🌸🏯
Блеск 👏
Tebaldi’s sound rolls over you like intense sunlight emerging from the clouds.
Ebbene sì... è la centesima volta che la sento, ma Renata riesce a farmi COMMUOVERE!
Absolutely flawless.... Sheer perfection. Can't get any better than that 😍😍😍😍
Toscanini che se ne intendeva l'ha definita voce d angelo
Grazie Renata immensa.
So gorgeous, and her gorgeous hands!!
Outstanding !!!
fantastica: bellezza di suono, di legato, di sfumature, di accenti....un lento avvicinarsi di onde emozionali ripetute
La Tebaldi , La Magnificent.💚⭐
even after all this time, her voice rings out and touches my soul.
fnikitathomas
She, callas and sutherland are the only ones that literally bring me tears
fnikitathomas Vera Galupe Borszk brings me to tears - of laughter.
👍👍
What can you say . exquisite and superb performance ❤
No one can sing this moving aria like this lady, also the genius of Puccini is stunning
Grande voce che ha anche il pregio di farsi capire.
Callas' Butterfly never made me close to tears, as Tebaldi does here.
Concordo
I agree. For me, Callas' voice was more suited to the heavier dramatic roles like Tosca.
Tebaldi was Madame Butterfly here.
Absolutely beautiful.
@@philipr1567There is a reason why Madama butterfly was one of the Tebaldi’s main repertoires while it was not for Callas.
I bought my father the complete recording of "Madame Butterfly" with Renata Tebaldi as Butterfly when I was a little girl (for HIS birthday) but as he was a trombonist and I was a singer guess who the recording was really for....? My father just smiled and I played the recording over again and again. For me Tebaldi is Butterfly - just a perfect rendition of the aria. Sorry Dad !!!!
Her diction is so clear yet she is doing so much with the music. This is superb.
Dove sono oggi queste fantastiche voci? RENATA indimenticabile!!!
Claudio Persi Non ci sono più perché negli ultimi 40 anni le donne, in Italia e nell’Europa benestante, si sono emancipate da ogni ruolo “femminile” e femminilizzante. Parlano con voci un’ottava o due ottave sotto, tenorili. Fumano come camionisti e tutto il resto. Bisogna trovare quelle “vocine” nell’Est Europa o nel quarto mondo ancora patriarcale. È politicamente scorretto ma è la realtà. In compenso...in Italia è tutto un fiorire di controtenori e Haute-contre...chissà come mai...
My teacher's mentor saw Tebaldi live and said that when she sang it was like pure gold came out of her mouth and showerwed over the audience.
I can only agree 1000 % , The Schneider-Siemssen Family was always a close personal Friend to her. Vocie Di Angeli :-)
After Callas she is my favorite.
So you're saying she gave the audience a golden shower? ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
@@johnareiter73 Callas as Butterfly???
@@johnareiter73 ¡ Never ! Callas was not and never will be Butterfly. Callas was a product of marketing. Her voice, metallic, out of pitch will never reach the beauty of Tebaldi, Moffo, Caballé, Tomowa Sintow and many others. Callas was a great actress, I agree, but, opera needs singers with beatiful voices, not actresses, and Callas voice was not beautiful. When I was young I thought Callas was the number one and the only one in the planet, but, as I grew up, I realised that I was wrong. After many years of listening and going to recitals, concerts and operas, I realised what I am telling you. Callas was not the star that many people think she was. I invite you to listen carefully, without knowing who is singing.
Tibaldi is Butterfly this brings me to tears every time! to be so in love with an character from an opera for half my life now...... Bless your Soul Renetta Tibaldi and thank you, in Jesus Holy name Amen
OMG! I have to say one of the best butterflies i have ever heard and seen acted splendidly... Voice soo warm and emotions very well understood. What I also very much liked is that Tebaldi actually acts like a Japanese woman...with the etiquitte and everything....the way she moves her hands, the way she walks, her restricted movement, her shy character, everything! Officially the perfect Butterfly!
Perfetta la Tebaldi, come del resto sempre , non a caso mio nonno che amava la lirica, la preferiva a tutte le cantanti della storia, anche alla stessa Callas.
Immensa Tebaldi, il colore della sua voce il più bello di tutti i tempi!
This work by Puccini is a masterpiece of creative genius. He has revealed to us what it is to love another person with all your soul. This love is beautiful and pure. Puccini shows how we should live to give all to the beloved. This is to my mind the highest purpose of the true art. I cannot praise this performance enough. Thank you for the posting.
I totally disagree with your conclusion. She lost all, not only her life, also her child, and her tradition and her ancestor, relative's connection. It is the very most sacrifice, most tragic of the saddest thing on earth. No one should live as she did.
Duh! In case you hadn't noticed it's a tragedy (as are most Puccini's opera's) He usually deals with flawed love and his heroines almost invariably are poorly treated and die a tragic death. Puccini certainly didn't see his female leads love in the way your suggesting.
Bravissima Tebaldi! Che voce, che viso .. sarò sempre apassionato di lei. Riposa in pace dolcissimo angelo.
Che colore meraviglioso e che voce salda e luminosa...👏👏👏👏
Extraordinary acting adds to her legendary voice to bring the character to life.
Per emissione, timbro privilegiato, cavata e fermezza dei suoni (senza sottintenderne la forza dell'interpretazione stilizzatissima), la Tebaldi è qui ineguagliabile. Mi piacerebbe approfondire le motivazioni che hanno basato i 50 bastian-contrari del "pollice verso"...
Emissione. Cavata del suono. Timbro privilegiato. Interpretazione stilizzatissima.
Lei, signore, possiede un'invidiabile capacità di sintesi. :)
Sono da sempre un fan di Maria. Ma qui siamo alla perfezione, nessun tremolio, nessuna sbavatura. Dizione perfetta, potente. Ma solo Maria è divina.
evidentemente guardano questi video senza capirne nulla ma vogliono lo stesso lasciare un segno facendo una figuraccia comunque anche essendo digiuni di musica lirica non si puo non apprezzare la perfezione di questa interpretazione
Grazie! Osservazione più che logica!
+giò lupo
sono già 147 intenditori che non apprezzano questa interpretazione sublime della Tebaldi.
la ragione ?
la scarsa registrazione che non ha niente à vedere con la verità artistica.
questa interpretazione meravigliosa della Tebaldi può essere apprezzata soltanto dei professionisti e quelli che conoscano la vera arte lirica.
per il resto del mondo la bassissima qualità di questa registrazione è la ''prova'' che La Tebaldi aveva poca voce.
di più la sua voce in questo video non è neanche l'ombra alla voce che aveva dal vivo La Tebaldi.
non è la colpa del pubblico ma dei tecnici del suono che non hanno riuscito di fare una registrazione degna di questa voce divina.
io la penso così.
Superb! She was magnificent!
Pochi come lei. A 84 anni mi mette ancora i brividi. Grazie per quello che mi dai ancora
Exquisita interpretación de La Gran RENATA TEBALDI !
Bellissimo filmato e mi piace lei scenicamente. Subito nei preferiti!!!!!
Voce celestiale, straordinaria interpretazione, impeccabile gestualità e delicata bellezza. Semplicemente favolosa.
Vero, non solo la voce è incredibilmente emozionante, anche le movenze sono molto eleganti.
Roberto ti aspettero’.
Non la ricordano mai. Bravissima!
La migliore interpretazione di tutti i tempi!!!!Da brividi!!!!!!!👍👍👍
Best voice Renata tebaldy beatifull opera
A beautiful opera and Diva Tebaldi interprets Butterfly exquisitely! The hand movements and kimono work are perfect.
every move is finely crafted and tuned, just as her voice and singing. Great demo of her perfection on every tinny little thing.
I watched Tebaldi sing Butterfly high up in the gallery of the Rome opera house, and found her magical in expression. Every word could be understood. I am English but speak Italian, and there were no translations then.
This is one of my favorite arias and I've never heard anyone do it as well as Tebaldi.
GermanOperaSinger Gracias por subir este video! te amo dich lieben
Thank you for putting this up , beautiful just beautiful
La migliore interpretazione di tutti i tempi , impossibile fare meglio
Sono senza parole e
Di una bravura aldisopra a
Ogni livello!!!!!!
Che interpretazione,che voce!!!!!!!Tebaldi,la migliore Butterfly di sempre!!!!!!!
Si, para mí también Renata Tebaldi es Batterfly.
I think Scotto is also a great butterfly
Che meraviglia!
Sono daccordo la migliore in assoluto!!!
Piango
The "old-fashioned acting" is magnificent! The gestures were specially learned by Tebaldi from the director Yoshio Aoyama when Tebaldi sang her first Butterflys at the Met. They are so expressive and touching.. And then, the singing is so rich and beautiful, and NOBODY gives more innocent heart to phrases such as "Chi sara? Chi sara? E come sara giunto?"
she moves the way she sings..... everything she does seems to underline the line of the voice ....focusing the legato...and never visually disturbing the feeling and concentration of the audience!
Many artists....even great ones...are so fussy in thier movements as to detract from the mood through distracting constantly.....waking the viewer from the state of holding their collective breath in the moment of emotion.
Tebaldi....through instinct or design......was never ever guilty of this fault!.......and this in itself could ammount to at least half of her compelling addictive effect!....the other half being her personal beauty and the sheer gorgious sound of that great voice!!
@@luigicorvi1661 beautifully written and very true.
I met Madame Tibaldi at a bank in Fort Lauderdale, in 1968. Very nice person
I met her backstage at the Met after Andrea Chenier. She was very sweet and gracious.
She brings such emotion in her voice she's amazing ❤️
What a glorious artist. And what an utterly gleaming and seamless sound.
Superb. What a beautiful voice. So much feeling. Sends chills all through me.
Non ho parole per esprimere la bellezza della sua interpretazione , della sua voce
Opera has been described as the most difficult art and I wholeheartedly agree. Put some middle aged people on stage, wearing pancake make up, playing other races, singing and performing a piece that has been played 1,000 times, and et with all th3 artifice one can suspend disbelief and be moved by the incredible voice and music, moving grown up folks who may have seen the same opera a dozen times to tears. That's an incredible feat.
Try Cardi B, I am sure you will enjoy.
le premier opéra que j'ai vus avec mon grand père à 12 ans ,j'ai pleuré à l'infini ce soir là avec lui.
Hello pretty lady 💖
So wonderful... She " felt" the song.. greetings from 🇩🇪
After so long time any time I hear her voice the emotion is so strong that my eyes are unable to remain dry. Mrs Tedaldi driver me in the opera havens
A magnificent Italian soprano voice. Brava Renata for such compelling and moving Cio Cio San
to the annals of great voices just superb
Wow! Wow! Wow! I am speechless, so beautiful and hurtful!
Wow. Just magnificent. I have never seen a more moving performance. Poor butterfly.
This is too beautiful for words.
My gracious. I feel her version is certainly one of the very best ever.
Questa voce è un lenimento per l' anima!
sublime , jamais la Tebaldi n'a été aussi inspirée tant par la voix que par sa gestuelle.Difficile d'oublier
I have nothing to say. Is it a person? I'm touched. Tears of emotion are shed in a small mountain in Korea. Thank you.