I can't understand how Jim Beam can charge 90 bucks for a regularly inconsistent product like Booker's, which is usually 6 years old, but knob creek single barrel reserve is 9 years and never disappoints at 60 bucks. 🥃
The price keeps going up, it keeps selling out. I don't get it either. It sounds like this batch should sit on the shelf and collect dust, but the taters around me won't do their research and will buy it all instantly.
I've nearly ALWAYS felt the same. There are VERY few Beam products (including Bookers) that trump Knob Creek. Especially considering the price mark up. Thanks for the heads-up, boys. Another hard pass from Bookers.
@@cjackson3479i havent tried charlies batch, but i have the kentucky tea batch and thats really good. My brother got this apprentice batch, i dont like it. My brother does, and the ppl he opened the bottle with amd drank half of it liked it. I dont see it.
I picked up a bottle a few weeks back and didn't like it initially. Had an extremely strong peanut oil taste on open and it just drowned out everything else. Now that it's been open about 3 weeks the sweetness is coming out and the nut taste is much tamer. I recommend trying it again after it's been open a bit.
I am a novice bourbon drinker and I had an opportunity to try some of this last night. I loved it. Sweet and smooth with no strong burn for me, for a cask strength bourbon. Aroma of both carmel and vanilla. The sweetness was very unique, not over powering, and made it very easy to drink. Some oak, but not too much. Added a few drops of water and it smoothed it out even more. I had to remind myself several times that this was cask strength. Found it locally for $99 and probably will purchase a bottle this week. I am a fan of Knob Creek Single Barrel Select (Barrel Pick) and i enjoy that also, but i found the Booker's to be smoother to me. Keep up the good work guys.
Same lol they released an article in Dec 2016 saying they were going to stop producing so much if it and the price would nearly double from the usual $55 a fifth
Have to disagree. Just cracked the bottle, poured myself a 2 oz dram and thoroughly enjoyed the ensuing hour. Butter, vanilla, waffles... Wife got some cinnamon... Good stuff
Your right on about knob creek 120 proof, always great, and the store picks even better. Bookers has just gotten too expensive, $110 here, where a knob creek 120 is $49.99 here. Bookers is to hit or miss for the price. Great review, thanks
Every Knob 120 is amazing, mostly consistent considering being single barrel. Store picks usually are good. Though I think that could pick better barrels,that being said ,everyone has a different pallet and will pick up on different nuances of the juice.
I enjoy this batch. Buttered popcorn with Tabasco sauce. For me, it drinks below its proof. Maybe there is variation among bottles. Found it at my local Costco. I think it was about 80.
Oh man, we were just on the bourbon trail and I got 2 of these Booker’s Apprentice! Just went for it as I haven’t bought a Booker’s in maybe 10 years….hopefully it will get a little better after opening
I got a bottle for Father's Day and I actually really liked it. I'm usually turned off by big oak but it wasn't overpowering at all and thought it drank way under it's proof. Maybe I got lucky with my bottle. Also this is my first bottle of bookers
My brother has it, i wasnt a big fan of it. He drank half the bottle the day he bought with 3-4 other ppl and they all liked it. I tried after he had a a week or so, so it even had time and room in the bottle to open up, but i still wasnt a fan. Especially compared to the kentucky tea batch i have, which was the one before charlies batch
I just picked up a bottle of the Bookers Apprentice this week and my bottle is actually delicious. Sweet, viscous, mouth coating, no bitterness, and a beautiful nose that goes on for days. But considering all the negative comments and reviews, I don’t think I’ll take the chance on buying a second bottle of this batch.
@@writterttc everyone has a different palate. We all like different things, and we all taste things differently. Obviously different batches are going to taste widely different, but i dont think different bottles from the same batch will taste all that much different, if at all
Your assessment aligns with a few other reviews so it sounds like the Apprentice needs to finish it's apprenticeship. Perhaps the next release will be a Journeyman edition and meet it's price point in value !? Thanks for sacrificing the $90 for our benefit! Always an honest review with SLB Find your Charlie's batch which got excellent reviews even from Bookers skeptics!
SLB Classics 0:38 Trenton doesn’t leave an expensive whiskey in a hot car SHOCKER 1:02 Crown Apple 23 strikes again 1:56 Homework completed in time 2:05 Trenton knows the alphabet, WHEW 2:50 Trenton may still be learning days of the week 3:05 Kurt treats Trenton so well (rolling the whiskey for him) 3:27 Dirty dish rag note returns 3:59 Kurt’s nose surgery saga continues 4:18 Great La Croix joke 5:55 Full send on the nose 😂 7:22 Asphalt note is what we were waiting for 7:30 lol oak splinter notes 7:36 Lmao 🤣🤣🤣 oaky joke went WAAY over Trenton’s head 8:22 NEVER BUY SUGAR FREE SYRUP 8:52 100% agree Trenton, syrup needs sugar 9:24 Aged in a log cabin note 10:57 Kurt is always prepared with the JIC bottle 12:04 Trenton is willing to bathe in it 12:54 Money bowling lol
I was able pick up a bottle of this last week… to your credit, your “oaky” and “asphalt” notes, corresponded to a a smoky charred oak note for me. I found that this particular Bookers pairs excellent with some smoked meat/BBQ. It has been one of my less favorite releases from them, however. Here’s hoping the bottle will open up some in time! Cheers! 🥃
Sometimes. Bookers needs a couple months to open up. I had the Lumberyard batch and at first I thought it was too hot and oaky. Then I let it sit for a while and came back to it. Totally changed up. Add a couple drops of water too.
I wonder how this made it out the door? Jason at the mash and drum thought it was bad too. So how does quality control not catch this? You would think they would be concerned with damaging the Bookers brand?
4:09 I actually like la croix, but the la croix mean tweets get me every time! If you haven’t ever seen them, please go read them. They are hilarious! One of my favorites is “La Croix taste like if you were drinking carbonated water and someone screamed out loud the name of a specific fruit in the other room” 😂
Appreciate you guys being honest. That Bookers was the shortest review Jason on Mash & Drum has done, Ever! Also, I am one of those people who loves KC SBR 120 proof but I love the 9yr 100 proof too.
I tried this at the distillery and it was good. I bought a bottle. One review I read captured this better. It seems a chaotic collection of flavors that just appear and disappear. Not for someone who is expecting a pattern of flavors. I like it because it is so different than typical bourbon. It drinks well below its proof and the spice at the end tastes very different from the spice you get from a Knob Creek.
OK, just tasted it again. It's a chameleon. With a bottle that's been opened for a while, pour it in the glass and take a sip. Warm thick feel, vanilla, brown sugar etc. and flavors that flash past, fruits, spearmint. After a while you begin to get an ethanol chemical taste on the finish. Put it down. Pick it up after a few minutes, the chemical taste is gone and it has more flavors with an earthy vanilla finish with just a bit of of spice, stays kind of that way to the end of the glass. Seems a lot of work for a good pour but it's worth it. If you pick it up and taste it once at any point in its journey you get just one part of the elephant. IMHO.
I have the last 4 batches of Bookers. I did a taste test (not blinded which would have to be the next step to rule out any recency or conformational bias) and this one came in second for me. My results were 22-03, 23-02, 23-01 and 22-04. I actually got most of the same notes in the 23 year releases but my 02 was much easier to drink and I didn’t get the ethanol burn which is what put it ahead for me. I know 23-01 was met with a lot of positive remarks but my bottles it was worse than 23-02.
My brother has this apprentice batch. Though it does drink below its proof, the flavor just wasnt there for me. And that was after he drank half a bottle and a week or so after opening it. I compared it to my kentucky tea batch, which did drink a little hotter, but had way more and way better flavor, to me anyways.
This review makes me very happy that I passed on the new Booker’s when I saw it on the shelf recently in favor of a Baker’s 7 Single Barrel (actual age of the batch is 8 years & 10 months).
Saw some Bookers on the shelf Saturday afternoon. Don't know what batch it was because when the store told me the price was $130 you couldn't have found interest in me with an electron microscope. The whiskey gods made up for this about 1/2 hour later when I found ECBP A123 for $65. Life is good!😀
Ok so I pick up a coco chocolate note and a hint of a citrus and tea on the nose.. the nice heat from the proof… palate I do get the bitter note more like a black tea and slight lemon or orange peel kind of note but not unpleasant.. this was my first bookers and thought it was good. My wife gets the same coco notes as well.
😂😂😂 You might have to check my throat for splinters. Trent leans over and looks perplexed looking at Kurt's throat. Then the line came. 😂😂 You got him good, Kurt. He'll get you back for that. Great job guys. I appreciate finding the positives with a Caveat attached to it. Thank you for the review. I'll sabe my money on this one.
The issue with Bookers is that, from what I have read, is that these releases may not be the same here in Canada as in the US. For example the first release is numbered as 2023-1E which I have been told means Export. Apparently ABV and age statements may vary slightly from what is known as Charlie's Batch though the ones where I live match.🎉
I was given a bottle of Little Book 2022 Chapter 6; To The Finish for Father’s Day. Curious what you guys think about the Freddie Noe take off on Booker’s. 117 proof 3 Blended whiskeys in various Barrel finishes plus a bourbon thrown in. Interesting cereal, syrup and sweet wood that sounds a lot better than what you guys just tasted. Unfortunately >$125 here in CA.
I very much so enjoyed this release, and I think 23-01 and 23-02 r more like older releases than most of the more recent releases. Definitely think yall need to revisit.
I would have to disagree with this review 100%. I just finished a bottle of this and it definitely grew after it was opened. The closer it got to the bottom, the better it got. I've had the Lumberyard as well. At first the Lumberyard was better, but after a couple months sitting on my shelf, the Apprentice batch shined far above.
When I find a usually good bottle gone wrong, I put it in the cocktail only cabinet. That is a shame. I’m a little immune, I rarely spend motor than $65 for any bottle.
Dang. I heard the 2023-01 “Charlie’s batch” was really good. Heard some local stores had bookers a couple weeks ago so ran out and found one. But it was this 2023-02 “Apprentice”. Paid $99 for it. Haven’t opened it yet. Was hoping it was going to be good but sounds like I gambled and lost. Thanks for your honest review.
Booker's is one of those small batch bourdons that is truly like wine. You never know what you are going to get year to year. The problem is the price you pay if it isn't to your liking. Other small batch bourdons or barrel proof bourdons, the distillers, if it taste too far from the brand taste, they will send that barrel to be batch blended in there other brands.
Opened mine today to share for thanksgiving and no one liked it. I’m not sure what they were thinking with this one. This was my first bookers so I’m kind of put off on trying another. We’ll see.
My brother got this apprentice batch and he likes it. He bought it on the way to a friends house and drank probably half the bottle with 3-4 ppl and they all liked it. When i tried it, i didnt like it at all. Seemed very bland. Especially compared to the kentucky tea batch i have that i like a lot.
Bookers is my favorite whiskey. I find it “interesting” how everyone always drink it neat. Damn right it’s hot, it’s 125-130 proof. I always pour it on ice and won’t touch it for about 10 minutes. It’s a different drink when you do this…Very different. Only way to figure out what your whiskey is to try everything you can.
I’m not as offended by this as you. Had the bottle for a couple weeks and took my time trying it because of bad reviews. It doesn’t drink like a $90 bottle but it’s ok. I get that green apple slightly sour taste but it’s not awful. It’s too bad you lost the other bottle of bookers. I absolutely loved Charlie’s batch
win some, ya loose some.... Trenton lost a bottle... why don't I remember hearing about that... ohh well, that Knob Creek is a pretty solid dram for sure......
I think it’s the 2- batches have been bad! I got Ronnie’s 2-2022 last year, which was my 1st bottle of Booker’s I pulled the trigger on.. was not impressed at all! Haven’t bought one since!
I have never had Booker's, and I never plan on buying a bottle. The value just isn't there for me, especially with the increasing price. Knob Creek is a better buy all day long.
That’s sounds disappointing, maybe it’ll get better after being opened for a while. Charlie’s is pretty good, hopefully you’ll find your bottle. I’m sure my wife will still get it anyway, she likes her Bookers. Cheers
I recently acquired a Charlies Batch Bookers but I haven't tried it yet. For the money, the 9 yr old small batch Knob Creek is hard to beat and the 12 yr old is spectacular.
Charlie's Batch was really good. It was my first Booker's experience, so I can't compare it to other releases, but I would buy it again. You are the second review I've seen that panned this one, and the honest review is appreciated.
I actually liked it. I’m not good with all that nose palate, pumper nickel burn asphalt B S. I didn’t feel the burn and felt it was smooth. All the other bookers I used for cocktails. Which were delicious
For Bookers fans, there will never be a terrible batch. Only ones that are better than others….but never terrible. For those who don’t like Bookers, it’s hard enough to find as it is and they disappear quickly, so please leave them for us fans.
Hold on. Wait a minute? $85 for a Booker’s? Buy me that is pre 2020 pricing. I just saw this at my l local store for $110. No way in hell I’m buying these anymore.
I think that the best part of this channel is to see a father and son interact with each other. Keep it up guys.
I can't understand how Jim Beam can charge 90 bucks for a regularly inconsistent product like Booker's, which is usually 6 years old, but knob creek single barrel reserve is 9 years and never disappoints at 60 bucks. 🥃
I agree, I get 9 year single barrel Knob that are amazing .
Probably just a marketing gimmick to fool the people with money to blow lol.
The price keeps going up, it keeps selling out. I don't get it either. It sounds like this batch should sit on the shelf and collect dust, but the taters around me won't do their research and will buy it all instantly.
I've nearly ALWAYS felt the same. There are VERY few Beam products (including Bookers) that trump Knob Creek. Especially considering the price mark up. Thanks for the heads-up, boys. Another hard pass from Bookers.
In my olde age, I have grown weary of questing for $100 - $120 STRONG Peanut juice.
Trenton not getting the “oak splinters” joke was absolutely hilarious 😂 love you guys.
I remember when a bottle was $45 and saying "Who would pay that for a bottle of Bourbon" LOL😂
DUDE for real. In 2016 when I was staying pretty hammered all the time, bookers was my go to and it was $55 a fifth lol
You know, this statement hits the feels hard. But Charlie's batch is absolutely fantastic btw.
@@cjackson3479i havent tried charlies batch, but i have the kentucky tea batch and thats really good. My brother got this apprentice batch, i dont like it. My brother does, and the ppl he opened the bottle with amd drank half of it liked it. I dont see it.
Love it! Yes... IT'S HORRIBLE! Leave that mess on the shelf for me to dispose of for you!
Lol of course the first bottle of Bookers I spring for is deemed “the worst of all time”. 😂
This was also the first Bookers I've ever purchased. I didn't love it but it's not terrible..
I picked up a bottle a few weeks back and didn't like it initially. Had an extremely strong peanut oil taste on open and it just drowned out everything else. Now that it's been open about 3 weeks the sweetness is coming out and the nut taste is much tamer. I recommend trying it again after it's been open a bit.
I am a novice bourbon drinker and I had an opportunity to try some of this last night. I loved it. Sweet and smooth with no strong burn for me, for a cask strength bourbon. Aroma of both carmel and vanilla. The sweetness was very unique, not over powering, and made it very easy to drink. Some oak, but not too much. Added a few drops of water and it smoothed it out even more. I had to remind myself several times that this was cask strength. Found it locally for $99 and probably will purchase a bottle this week.
I am a fan of Knob Creek Single Barrel Select (Barrel Pick) and i enjoy that also, but i found the Booker's to be smoother to me.
Keep up the good work guys.
I used to enjoy Bookers when it was $45 - $50. Haven't bought a bottle since the prices went nuts (many years).
Same lol they released an article in Dec 2016 saying they were going to stop producing so much if it and the price would nearly double from the usual $55 a fifth
Same here. I could get it for $60 up to a few years ago. Now it's $100. I just walk right past it and get the SB Knob Creek.
Read the article, bought 2 and that was the last time
Have to disagree. Just cracked the bottle, poured myself a 2 oz dram and thoroughly enjoyed the ensuing hour. Butter, vanilla, waffles... Wife got some cinnamon... Good stuff
“Life is like a bottle of Booker's; you never know what you're going to get.” Easy Pass as this must have been blended by an "Apprentice".
Your right on about knob creek 120 proof, always great, and the store picks even better. Bookers has just gotten too expensive, $110 here, where a knob creek 120 is $49.99 here. Bookers is to hit or miss for the price. Great review, thanks
Thx for the warning
Every Knob 120 is amazing, mostly consistent considering being single barrel. Store picks usually are good. Though I think that could pick better barrels,that being said ,everyone has a different pallet and will pick up on different nuances of the juice.
I enjoy this batch. Buttered popcorn with Tabasco sauce. For me, it drinks below its proof. Maybe there is variation among bottles. Found it at my local Costco. I think it was about 80.
Oh man, we were just on the bourbon trail and I got 2 of these Booker’s Apprentice! Just went for it as I haven’t bought a Booker’s in maybe 10 years….hopefully it will get a little better after opening
I got a bottle for Father's Day and I actually really liked it. I'm usually turned off by big oak but it wasn't overpowering at all and thought it drank way under it's proof. Maybe I got lucky with my bottle. Also this is my first bottle of bookers
I think ur dead on the mark, and not just lucky with your bottle. I think maybe they need to revisit with a fresh palate.
I enjoyed mine as well.
My brother has it, i wasnt a big fan of it. He drank half the bottle the day he bought with 3-4 other ppl and they all liked it. I tried after he had a a week or so, so it even had time and room in the bottle to open up, but i still wasnt a fan. Especially compared to the kentucky tea batch i have, which was the one before charlies batch
I just picked up a bottle of the Bookers Apprentice this week and my bottle is actually delicious. Sweet, viscous, mouth coating, no bitterness, and a beautiful nose that goes on for days. But considering all the negative comments and reviews, I don’t think I’ll take the chance on buying a second bottle of this batch.
@@writterttc everyone has a different palate. We all like different things, and we all taste things differently. Obviously different batches are going to taste widely different, but i dont think different bottles from the same batch will taste all that much different, if at all
Since Booker’s has gotten to $130 in my area, I’m passing on them all. Booker’s ain’t that good.
They’ve raised the price WAY to high on Bookers…..isn’t worth the money or effort 👎🏼
Your assessment aligns with a few other reviews so it sounds like the Apprentice needs to finish it's apprenticeship. Perhaps the next release will be a Journeyman edition and meet it's price point in value !?
Thanks for sacrificing the $90 for our benefit!
Always an honest review with SLB
Find your Charlie's batch which got excellent reviews even from Bookers skeptics!
SLB Classics
0:38 Trenton doesn’t leave an expensive whiskey in a hot car SHOCKER
1:02 Crown Apple 23 strikes again
1:56 Homework completed in time
2:05 Trenton knows the alphabet, WHEW
2:50 Trenton may still be learning days of the week
3:05 Kurt treats Trenton so well (rolling the whiskey for him)
3:27 Dirty dish rag note returns
3:59 Kurt’s nose surgery saga continues
4:18 Great La Croix joke
5:55 Full send on the nose 😂
7:22 Asphalt note is what we were waiting for
7:30 lol oak splinter notes
7:36 Lmao 🤣🤣🤣 oaky joke went WAAY over Trenton’s head
8:22 NEVER BUY SUGAR FREE SYRUP
8:52 100% agree Trenton, syrup needs sugar
9:24 Aged in a log cabin note
10:57 Kurt is always prepared with the JIC bottle
12:04 Trenton is willing to bathe in it
12:54 Money bowling lol
This was, by far, your funniest breakdown!!
I was able pick up a bottle of this last week… to your credit, your “oaky” and “asphalt” notes, corresponded to a a smoky charred oak note for me. I found that this particular Bookers pairs excellent with some smoked meat/BBQ. It has been one of my less favorite releases from them, however. Here’s hoping the bottle will open up some in time! Cheers! 🥃
Damn. I just bought this 30 minutes ago and then I saw your review. I'm hoping I got a good bottle. Fingers crossed.
Sometimes. Bookers needs a couple months to open up. I had the Lumberyard batch and at first I thought it was too hot and oaky. Then I let it sit for a while and came back to it. Totally changed up. Add a couple drops of water too.
Trenton is on it.
Thanks fellas…
Blessings from Gettysburg Pa…..
My son picked up a bottle. We did it head to head with Charlie's batch. Apprentice wasn't horrible, but definitely didn't beat Charlie's.
I wonder how this made it out the door? Jason at the mash and drum thought it was bad too. So how does quality control not catch this? You would think they would be concerned with damaging the Bookers brand?
Did you guys get a chance to try the Kentucky tea batch? It’s a great one
Sounds like the Apprentice needs to go back to school.
4:09 I actually like la croix, but the la croix mean tweets get me every time! If you haven’t ever seen them, please go read them. They are hilarious! One of my favorites is “La Croix taste like if you were drinking carbonated water and someone screamed out
loud the name of a specific fruit in the other room” 😂
Appreciate you guys being honest. That Bookers was the shortest review Jason on Mash & Drum has done, Ever! Also, I am one of those people who loves KC SBR 120 proof but I love the 9yr 100 proof too.
Thank you Guys.
I tried this at the distillery and it was good. I bought a bottle. One review I read captured this better. It seems a chaotic collection of flavors that just appear and disappear. Not for someone who is expecting a pattern of flavors. I like it because it is so different than typical bourbon. It drinks well below its proof and the spice at the end tastes very different from the spice you get from a Knob Creek.
OK, just tasted it again. It's a chameleon. With a bottle that's been opened for a while, pour it in the glass and take a sip. Warm thick feel, vanilla, brown sugar etc. and flavors that flash past, fruits, spearmint. After a while you begin to get an ethanol chemical taste on the finish. Put it down. Pick it up after a few minutes, the chemical taste is gone and it has more flavors with an earthy vanilla finish with just a bit of of spice, stays kind of that way to the end of the glass. Seems a lot of work for a good pour but it's worth it. If you pick it up and taste it once at any point in its journey you get just one part of the elephant. IMHO.
I have the last 4 batches of Bookers. I did a taste test (not blinded which would have to be the next step to rule out any recency or conformational bias) and this one came in second for me. My results were 22-03, 23-02, 23-01 and 22-04. I actually got most of the same notes in the 23 year releases but my 02 was much easier to drink and I didn’t get the ethanol burn which is what put it ahead for me. I know 23-01 was met with a lot of positive remarks but my bottles it was worse than 23-02.
My brother has this apprentice batch. Though it does drink below its proof, the flavor just wasnt there for me. And that was after he drank half a bottle and a week or so after opening it. I compared it to my kentucky tea batch, which did drink a little hotter, but had way more and way better flavor, to me anyways.
Knob Creek single barrel is one of the best deals for 120 proof bourbons. I'm kicking myself now for not getting a bottle of it today...
So what will you guys do with that bottle now? Would you use it for mixes? or keep it as a sipper?
I'd send it to the back of the shelf for a few months and come back to it later.
Have you guys tried Baker's 7 Yr Single Barrel yet? Just picked up a bottle last night off of a recommendation, but haven't cracked the bottle yet.
Wow. I liked it so much. I bought a second bottle. Difference in palates.
This review makes me very happy that I passed on the new Booker’s when I saw it on the shelf recently in favor of a Baker’s 7 Single Barrel (actual age of the batch is 8 years & 10 months).
Saw some Bookers on the shelf Saturday afternoon. Don't know what batch it was because when the store told me the price was $130 you couldn't have found interest in me with an electron microscope. The whiskey gods made up for this about 1/2 hour later when I found ECBP A123 for $65. Life is good!😀
My Sam’s Club has the A123 for $53 and it’s abundantly supplied, I guess it’s invisible to other customers. lol
More for me👍
@@bradstrickland3978 Lucky Dog ! My Sam's doesn't even know Elijah Craig exists.
What sams club?!
Northwest Indiana. Merriville Sam’s
Trenton really thought he had oak splinters😂
Ok so I pick up a coco chocolate note and a hint of a citrus and tea on the nose.. the nice heat from the proof… palate I do get the bitter note more like a black tea and slight lemon or orange peel kind of note but not unpleasant.. this was my first bookers and thought it was good. My wife gets the same coco notes as well.
I’d love to see you guys track down another bottle of 2023-01 Charlie’s batch to review. I don’t think you’d regret it. Absolutely amazing.
I got this batch and I think it's pretty good. It isn't as good as Kentucky Tea or Charlie's, but it's a good batch in my opinion.
Honesty is greatly appreciated
😂😂😂 You might have to check my throat for splinters.
Trent leans over and looks perplexed looking at Kurt's throat.
Then the line came. 😂😂
You got him good, Kurt.
He'll get you back for that.
Great job guys. I appreciate finding the positives with a Caveat attached to it. Thank you for the review. I'll sabe my money on this one.
Now I know why I was able to find a bottle of this for $84
The issue with Bookers is that, from what I have read, is that these releases may not be the same here in Canada as in the US. For example the first release is numbered as 2023-1E which I have been told means Export. Apparently ABV and age statements may vary slightly from what is known as Charlie's Batch though the ones where I live match.🎉
I bought one just to use as trade leverage when I got home. Got a Weller 107 for it
I was given a bottle of Little Book 2022 Chapter 6; To The Finish for Father’s Day. Curious what you guys think about the Freddie Noe take off on Booker’s. 117 proof 3 Blended whiskeys in various Barrel finishes plus a bourbon thrown in. Interesting cereal, syrup and sweet wood that sounds a lot better than what you guys just tasted. Unfortunately >$125 here in CA.
I stopped buying Booker’s at the big price jump. Can’t justify paying that much for a 6-7 year product!
Great review guys! I think I'll break out the Knob Creek Cask Strength 127 proof! Cheers!
I very much so enjoyed this release, and I think 23-01 and 23-02 r more like older releases than most of the more recent releases. Definitely think yall need to revisit.
So agree
I would have to disagree with this review 100%. I just finished a bottle of this and it definitely grew after it was opened. The closer it got to the bottom, the better it got. I've had the Lumberyard as well. At first the Lumberyard was better, but after a couple months sitting on my shelf, the Apprentice batch shined far above.
When I find a usually good bottle gone wrong, I put it in the cocktail only cabinet. That is a shame. I’m a little immune, I rarely spend motor than $65 for any bottle.
Sounds like the Apprentice actually made this batch without the Master’s help😃 I really enjoy the Charlie’s batch! Bought a back up of it already!
Thanks y’all; I like that you pulled out the quick comparison. Try to do that more often!
I was very disappointed in this bottle. TONS of black pepper!
Dang. I heard the 2023-01 “Charlie’s batch” was really good. Heard some local stores had bookers a couple weeks ago so ran out and found one. But it was this 2023-02 “Apprentice”. Paid $99 for it. Haven’t opened it yet. Was hoping it was going to be good but sounds like I gambled and lost.
Thanks for your honest review.
Charlie's Batch is very good.
Charlie’s Batch is excellent
If this bottle was $49 would you think it was a better value? Or is the juice still not worth it?
was the 2023 01e any good?
“Take a bath in that” 😂😂😂
Booker's is one of those small batch bourdons that is truly like wine. You never know what you are going to get year to year. The problem is the price you pay if it isn't to your liking. Other small batch bourdons or barrel proof bourdons, the distillers, if it taste too far from the brand taste, they will send that barrel to be batch blended in there other brands.
Opened mine today to share for thanksgiving and no one liked it. I’m not sure what they were thinking with this one. This was my first bookers so I’m kind of put off on trying another. We’ll see.
Did y’all change your camera? Am I going crazy or does the video quality look crazy nice rn
I'm still buying it!
I saw a Bookers at Target but passed for $95. I have tried it and don’t find the value there.
i stop buying bookers since 2016 price hike --- just let the band wagon of hype go ... LET IT GO !
2019-03 was my last batch.
My brother got this apprentice batch and he likes it. He bought it on the way to a friends house and drank probably half the bottle with 3-4 ppl and they all liked it. When i tried it, i didnt like it at all. Seemed very bland. Especially compared to the kentucky tea batch i have that i like a lot.
There is a reason the master distiller is the master and the apprentice is the apprentice?
Bummer. 2021 Bookers release is still one of my all time favorite. Haven’t been able to replicate that magic over last couple releases.
Bookers is my favorite whiskey. I find it “interesting” how everyone always drink it neat. Damn right it’s hot, it’s 125-130 proof. I always pour it on ice and won’t touch it for about 10 minutes. It’s a different drink when you do this…Very different. Only way to figure out what your whiskey is to try everything you can.
I won’t buy ANY pricey bottle without a few reviews first. Store picks are an exception.
Yeah, I paid 129 bucks for the Pinkys batch.😢
Charlie's was awesome, bought a bunch of spares for a great price in Canada, thanks for the heads up on this one will steer clear.
As a typical Bookers fan, thanks for the heads up guys...don't know that I've ever had a bad pour of KC
Picked up a Charlie’s batch today and this scared me until I double checked it was Charlie’s not apprentice
Thanks for saving me the 90 bucks! I’ll just buy two bottles of rare breed now 😊
I saw Booker’s Charlie’s Batch for $125 and passed. Have not seen a positive review on Apprentice, so will not be picking it up. 🥃
I’m not as offended by this as you. Had the bottle for a couple weeks and took my time trying it because of bad reviews. It doesn’t drink like a $90 bottle but it’s ok. I get that green apple slightly sour taste but it’s not awful. It’s too bad you lost the other bottle of bookers. I absolutely loved Charlie’s batch
Thanks for the review on this. If the Apprentice shows up on the allocated shelf at my local store I will be sure to pass on it.
win some, ya loose some.... Trenton lost a bottle... why don't I remember hearing about that... ohh well,
that Knob Creek is a pretty solid dram for sure......
I think it’s the 2- batches have been bad! I got Ronnie’s 2-2022 last year, which was my 1st bottle of Booker’s I pulled the trigger on.. was not impressed at all! Haven’t bought one since!
GREAT UNFILTERED REVIEW!!! This is what its about guys!!
I have never had Booker's, and I never plan on buying a bottle. The value just isn't there for me, especially with the increasing price. Knob Creek is a better buy all day long.
Bookers brand is damaged in my opinion. The inconsistent batches turned me off when they went to 90+ srp now.
How is the Bookers 30th?
Neck pour and cask strength…needs a few weeks maybe
That’s sounds disappointing, maybe it’ll get better after being opened for a while. Charlie’s is pretty good, hopefully you’ll find your bottle. I’m sure my wife will still get it anyway, she likes her Bookers. Cheers
Just grabbed a bottle of Bookers Mighty Fine batch. I hear good things
I recently acquired a Charlies Batch Bookers but I haven't tried it yet. For the money, the 9 yr old small batch Knob Creek is hard to beat and the 12 yr old is spectacular.
My market is $120-150 and decided not to hunt Booker's anymore. 2022 batches are good, but not great and IMHO not worth a money. Cheers.
Trenton and Kurton laying down facts
Charlie's Batch was really good. It was my first Booker's experience, so I can't compare it to other releases, but I would buy it again. You are the second review I've seen that panned this one, and the honest review is appreciated.
I actually liked it. I’m not good with all that nose palate, pumper nickel burn asphalt B S. I didn’t feel the burn and felt it was smooth. All the other bookers I used for cocktails. Which were delicious
$85 Elijah Craig Barrel Proof is looking not so bad now. At least it's delicious.
Oh great just bought a bottle of this… dang it
For Bookers fans, there will never be a terrible batch. Only ones that are better than others….but never terrible. For those who don’t like Bookers, it’s hard enough to find as it is and they disappear quickly, so please leave them for us fans.
Hold on. Wait a minute? $85 for a Booker’s? Buy me that is pre 2020 pricing. I just saw this at my l local store for $110. No way in hell I’m buying these anymore.
This batch is still on the shelf at my local store. Goin nowhere! 😂