German reacts to Germany vs. Poland - Who wins the war?

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 พ.ย. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 84

  • @twisters999
    @twisters999 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +22

    I live 3km from a German border and I'm a Polish soldier.... I'm extremely happy that YOU have our back like it was during the P-L Commonwealth. Central Europe can be powerfull when We forget stupid things

    • @SupernovaRemodeling
      @SupernovaRemodeling 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

      Nope we can't

    • @AWRUK84
      @AWRUK84 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Stop sucking you know what of germans they have ouer back same like brits and frenchies in1939

  • @damian5499
    @damian5499 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +11

    In my opinion, there is no way that Germany will win because what is very important in the war is the morale of soldiers and civilians, and knowing that it is a war with Germany, Poles will have such morale that there is no option to defeat Poland. Suddenly it will turn out that the Polish army has 10 million people.

  • @leszy7859
    @leszy7859 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +21

    To dolicz ilu Polaków w Niemczech mieszka... Starczy by drugi front otworzyć :)

    • @Darwidx
      @Darwidx 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      Ty właśnie, przecież mamy sabotażystów rozsianych po całej Uni, nigdy o tym nie myślałem.

    • @arkadiuszkrasicki5478
      @arkadiuszkrasicki5478 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      ​@@Darwidx sabotażystów to mało powiedziane, gdyby tak wysłać im broń, mundury i dowódców to mogli być wywalczyć dla nas jakieś odległe terytoria...

    • @Darwidx
      @Darwidx 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@arkadiuszkrasicki5478 3 miesiące i Republika Irlandii staję się kolejnym województwem, XD

  • @grzegorzbaryla88
    @grzegorzbaryla88 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +10

    Brawo za dystans. Dzielą nas tylko politycy

    • @Polexitnatychmiast
      @Polexitnatychmiast 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Chyba nikt cię nie uświadomił jeszcze, że politycy są emanacją społeczeństwa

  • @Ruunawayboy
    @Ruunawayboy 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +16

    You must remember, Chris, that in Germany you have a cultural problem, Uncle Ali will create a brothel and the septic tank will spill out, it will be a failure, if there is no mobilization of more conscripts, in Poland it is a bit different with the newcomers, because they either assimilate, learn the language and become Poles, or they go away, our society is quite harmonious, no. it doesn't matter whether they are black, white or yellow, if you are Polish you know what to do.
    To the last drop of blood

  • @Philip-z4m
    @Philip-z4m 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +10

    According to war simulations Ukraine had no chance to survive Russian attack but they stopped Putin's army march. It's very hard to prepare a good simulation and no simulation knows which countries will support which sides and with how much supplies what is crucial today.

  • @wojtekwosztyl615
    @wojtekwosztyl615 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +17

    Chris, You are a young Man. We, Poles, we hate war, but, if we have to do the war- We do the war.
    And we will die. For our Lands, families and our culture.
    Regards from Poland Chris

  • @imeternalsoul
    @imeternalsoul 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    True, let's hope nothing gets in the way again, it is so much more useful to be allies than enemies, hopefully the past stays in the past.

  • @CZESKI_KOT
    @CZESKI_KOT 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +12

    5:20 in Poland we say Odra

  • @cogoniema
    @cogoniema 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    I have an proposal for all, do not do another war.

  • @kamilpustula2454
    @kamilpustula2454 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +9

    Fun fact, after changes which are happening now, Poland army will be not defensive anymore.

  • @Jarod_Holder
    @Jarod_Holder 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +7

    I think you should do a video trying polish foods stuff like bigos, rosoł, pierogi, zurek, goląpki and pączki.

  • @mikelpajestka1021
    @mikelpajestka1021 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Jest jedno ale w Niemczech około 20% społeczeństwa jest gotowe oddać życie za kraj w Polsce jest to około 40-50% więc realnie kwestie ludzi zdolnych do walki się wyrównują. Sprawa kolejna liczmy, że hipotetycznie taka wojna miała by miejsce np za 3 lata ponieważ wymaga przygotowania, wiec Niemcy co prawda mają sporą przewagę na morzu i niewielką w powietrzu ale w kwesti obrony przeciw lotniczej przeciw pancernej i wojsk lądowych to Polska ma gigantyczną przewagę ilosciową i śmiem twierdzić, że nawet jakosciową na chwilę obecną.

  • @rozaliaroyale
    @rozaliaroyale 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

    wojna pomiędzy naszymi krajami przy obecnej sytuacji geopolitycznej , kompletnie nie miała by sensu , przecież każdy Niemiec może w każdej chwili przenieść się na teren Polski , kupić dom , założyć rodzinę lub przedsiębiorstwo i komunikować się w języku Niemieckim ( czytać Niemiecką prasę , oglądać Niemieckie TV ) - zapewniam cię ,że nikt się tym nie będzie przejmował ...

  • @hatakekakashi7678
    @hatakekakashi7678 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +12

    It would be even worse for germany now :).

  • @jarosawuscinski3017
    @jarosawuscinski3017 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

    Ten film to chyba bardziej rozrywkowy niż analityczny? Autor nie wziął pod uwagę wielu aspektów.
    1) Posiadane uzbrojenie nie jest jednoznaczne z uzbrojeniem gotowym do użycia. Niemcy mają wiele sprzętu ale np. Czołgi są w 70% niesprawne.
    Samoloty to samo. Okręty podwodne 6 w tym tylko jeden sprawny nie nadający się do walki.
    3) Amunicja. Niemiecki rząd przyznał się że amunicji by im starczyło na kilka minut walki.
    4) Wojsko. W Niemczech jest przerost biurokracji. Wojsko w przytłaczającej większości siedzi w biurach.
    5) Niemcy są osłabione przez gangi imigranckie i wewnętrzne niepokoje.
    I tak można wyliczać w nieskończoność.
    Już nawet nie wspomnę o tym że Polska przez te 7 lat mocno się zbroiła a Niemcy nie.
    Na szczęście Polska nie jest drapieżnikiem.
    Pozdrawiam.

    • @askaradzi
      @askaradzi 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Tak to nie jest na powaznie.

  • @crimson5664
    @crimson5664 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    1:25 Poland has a cruise missiles capabilities too both from air and water (Jassm basic missiles on F16 and same swedish RBSs from 3-4 ships)

  • @dawidnazir3390
    @dawidnazir3390 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +22

    Problemem Niemców jest niedocenianie Polaków i zmian jakie w Polsce zostały dokonane. Myślę że na dzień dzisiejszy Polska wygrałaby z Niemcami . Dzisiaj Polska to zupełnie inny kraj niż Niemieckie wyobrażenia.

    • @RIDDICK19902721
      @RIDDICK19902721 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Nie jestem pewien że zaraz po wybuchu wojny rusek skorzysta z okazji tyle że tym razem rozjebał by i polaków i niemców. 2 niemcy mają na tyle mocną gospodarkę że w chwilę dozbroili by się przed wojną z 4 razy bardziej niż my. Więc jedyna opcja to by było zaatakowanie jako pierwsi wtedy mieli byś my jakieś szanse zanim rusek wpadnie.

    • @jarekkociok1463
      @jarekkociok1463 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      Zgadzam się

  • @felix8169
    @felix8169 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

    I find such analyses detrimental, because there may be some jokes, comparisons of potentials, but the leaven of conflict is left in the subconscious. And when does it break out? I am convinced that even if a potential conflict were won by Germany, it would actually lose a lot. Even if a potential conflict were won Poland would actually lose a lot in the long run. First and foremost: we have an opponent in the east who practices aggression and backward thinking, whom every conflict in Europe pleases immensely. Secondly, in the long run: times are changing, no single European state will mean much in the world by itself in the coming future. These are not colonial times. There are several world powers that are rich in surface area, resources, several are also populous, and others will become so. If Europe is to mean something it must speak with one voice - taking into account different currents, different concepts and different national interests. Worked through and with a consensus developed. There is no other option, if only for reasons of geography.

  • @kacperdudenko6828
    @kacperdudenko6828 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    We need to take into account that most of German capabilities are on paper, and some of their systems are almost useless in conflict.
    3 pumas had gone through 3 day exercise in battle conditions, on second day none of them worked due to unreliablity

  • @LukNwa
    @LukNwa 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +6

    Its Odra in PL ;)

  • @felix8169
    @felix8169 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    I am not surprised that the authors of the original film are our 'Moscow brothers'. You can see that the film is already several years old, as the data is slightly outdated. Some of the equipment referred to there was given to Ukraine by Poland, and there is no part that has already been purchased. But let's say it's a play on a conflict that took place a few years ago. I just still think that some speculation is harmful.

    • @leno_o17
      @leno_o17 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      That Russian at the beginning put me aback. Leave it to them, to be thinking of war all the time.

  • @crimson5664
    @crimson5664 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    this video is kinda outdated. like a lot changed in last 2-3 years. and video is 7 years old.

  • @Tomasz-
    @Tomasz- 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Equipment doesn't win the wars, alliances and money do ;)

  • @felix8169
    @felix8169 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    I like your final conclusions, but I still think that simulating a war between our countries is more bad than good. To tell you the truth, I would very much not want my country to invade another country and I definitely do not wish us to be invaded. The former is something we have influence over if only during elections, the latter less so - we can only act diplomatically and by developing military capabilities and, if the worst happens, by defending the country.

  • @KqrolTV
    @KqrolTV 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Those statistics are old actually, polish army is now more modern and bigger

  • @MarekAcro
    @MarekAcro 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I'm giving you an interesting video to watch. Title: "How Poland is becoming a military powerhouse" I wonder what you will say after watching it.

  • @bartoszczechowicz4074
    @bartoszczechowicz4074 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    "Oder" ist "Odra" auf polnisch

  • @weikM
    @weikM 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    river oder is just oder but in polish pronouncification

  • @siwy9671
    @siwy9671 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    this is old video from 2017 and now we have a lot more stronger tanks watch this 4 new video you see what we buy and have now
    Poland Is Getting The Two Best Tanks On Earth
    10 Najpotężniejszych broni zamówionych przez Polskę
    Future Weapons of Poland 2023 | Poland be Europe’s new Superpower | Poland Military Modernization
    Polish NEW Combat Vehicle SHOCKED The World!

    • @siwy9671
      @siwy9671 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

      and you can watch this aslo
      Why Is Russia TERRIFIED of Poland’s Military Power

  • @wujekcientariposta
    @wujekcientariposta 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

    yeah doctrinally you need at least 4:1 advantage in an offensive to reasonably ensure victory, because losses in pushing an offensive are typically that much higher, so there's actually almost no chance either would be capable of winning, unless there would be total mobilization and arms race that one would loose critically. And that bikov guy doesnt actually have any idea what he's talking about in any of his materials. It's like he played red alert once and now he's an "expert".

  • @Kamilbasketbol
    @Kamilbasketbol 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

    He is the only german I respect

    • @aryman1877
      @aryman1877 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      I respect all Germans. This one however is likeable ;)

    • @Kamilbasketbol
      @Kamilbasketbol 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@aryman1877 fr, but I mean germans on internet. Most of germans on internet are racist (hate poles)

  • @PrzemysawPustuka
    @PrzemysawPustuka 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    Stupid film (but not the reaction). Old data. Comparing countries in a close alliance is pointless. I don't know what political situation would have to exist for such a conflict to occur. Even then it is not known how other countries would have behaved. Germany and Poland would also build their armed forces differently. Total fiction.

    • @Vengir
      @Vengir 6 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Data was current at the time the video was released. And it's still interesting to see what would happen, even if it is unlikely to occur.

  • @Rapapictures
    @Rapapictures 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    with a Trojan horse in the form of Herr Tüska, it's Germany XD

    • @MrMaterla
      @MrMaterla 6 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Rather Russia with Trojan Horse like Macierewicz. Tusk, whatever he is, is still a better guarantor of Polish's security and development than Kaczyński with his team. But someone who doesn't understand anything and who lacked time to finish his primary school, doesn't understand geopolitics and politics as such.

  • @MateuszSuchodolski
    @MateuszSuchodolski 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Poland people dont wont to fight but cant luck on suffer other people without reaction

  • @MichaelWittmann268
    @MichaelWittmann268 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    We say ODRA

  • @MichaelWittmann268
    @MichaelWittmann268 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    AWACS is flying radar Bro

  • @aryman1877
    @aryman1877 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

    In the potential conflict between Germany and Poland I must admit... that Germany would win. I say that as a Pole. U got a far stronger economy, industries and bigger population. Not to mention high tech technologies. And U would have the support of the United States cause if I remember well in the end of XIX century the 1/3 of the US population was either German or had some roots in Germany. So Germany would win... 100%

  • @imeternalsoul
    @imeternalsoul 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Hypothetically if it was slow yes, but the Poles are like the Ukranians a) probably if once again we got advanced warning this time mass production would come into play, b) he forgot to look at the history the Poles would most likely not rest and go into full uprising mode, plus I would be interested in the gurilla wars which the Poles which would have ammunition dumps would most likely push the Germans multiple times out of the cities so even if it would give the Poles enough time to mass produce and go in the way of the Russians in WWII, quantity over quality so the Polish civilians wouldn't let it happen again, but he's talking about a static war not in actuality, most likely any success which would be made would be pushed back because the Poles would never surrender, plus like I said any advantage they would originally have would long be gone by the time the war finishes. Hypothetically speaking that is. We have two types of soldier the full gear, and the plain clothes, the full gear is your typical soldier, the plain clothes is the civilian which is only counted in Poland thanks to history.

  • @cogoniema
    @cogoniema 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

    And how many of us know we didn't have any wars against German states for ages? ls it like 600 years? Correct me please. I do not take into account the Teutonic Knitghts because in my opinion they were not the same. The situation of Pomerania would also be disputable. Pomerania was for some ages a Polish feud but nothing more. The western Polish border was a border of peace. We had two German kings. Yes, it is true that that Germany did us horrible things during WWII. Now I am waiting for some hate.

  • @szymonpotocki7290
    @szymonpotocki7290 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Na szczęście nie mamy żadnych krwiożerczych zamiarów.

  • @piotrjabonski1859
    @piotrjabonski1859 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Odra r is strong

  • @tomorrowneverdies567
    @tomorrowneverdies567 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    Does anyone understand why Ukraine should be supported? The people in eastern Ukraine voted in favor of becoming annexed by Russia.

  • @maciejgajoch1774
    @maciejgajoch1774 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    This is already not actual.

  • @Rutek_nightcore
    @Rutek_nightcore 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Out of date and unreliable consequently I don't approve this content but you're doing a good job Chriss.

  • @niesiej
    @niesiej 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I do not agree with this. The Polish army has more combat experience. We will have two spy satellites by 2027. Today, Poland has 631 operational tanks and combat machines of various types produced by the company. Germany only 300 and half of them are not functional as of today. German aviation is a tragedy, from what I have read, 60% are unable to perform combat tasks. Even though we donated quite a lot of tanks to Ukraine, we have quite a lot of them, but we also bought newer ones in the latest versions from the USA and Korea. Poles have one of the best anti-aircraft defenses. In addition, the best GROM units and, importantly, territorial defense. // Nie zgadzam się z tym Polskie wojsko ma większe doświadczenie bojowe. Dwie satelity szpiegowskie bedziemy mieć do 2027 roku. Na Dzień dzisiejszy Polska posiada 631 sprawnych maszyn czołgów plus maszyny bojowe własnej produkcji róznego Typu. Niemcy tylk 300 i połowa z nich jest nie sprawne na dzisiejszy stan. Lotnictwo Niemiec to tragedia z tego co czytałem to 60% nie jest zdolnych do wykonywania zadań bojowych. Mimo że podarowaliśmy Ukrainie dość dużo czołgów mamy ich dość sporo to jeszcze dokupiliśmy nowsze w najnowszej wersji z USA i Korei. Polacy mają jedną z najlepszych obron przeciwlotniczych. W dodatku najlepsze jednostki GROM i co ważne obrone terytorialną. ps.my English is poor, sorry for any mistakes

  • @MarekAcro
    @MarekAcro 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I'm sending you an interesting video to watch. Title: "How Poland becomes a military power" from the MilitaryRated channel. /not to be confused with a video from a year ago with the same title from another channel. Remember from the Military Rated channel. Not from another. There you will have a comparison of the armed forces, including: Poland and Germany/.
    I wonder what you will say after watching it.
    In addition, I propose two other films.
    1. Can Poland's Army STOP Russian Invasion? from The Military Show channel /it's not so optimistic anymore/
    2. If NATO and RUSSIA Go To War, Who Loses (Hour by Hour) from the same channel
    And finally, a little lesson. If you want to read Polish texts correctly, I recommend the video How to read Polish or something from the HowtoPolish channel

  • @LOKOsSaviour
    @LOKOsSaviour 18 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Bro this is a 7 year old move your commenting.... Poland will have far better military soon and is number 3 in nato right now, after USA and Turkey

  • @wojtekmlody437
    @wojtekmlody437 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    llu jest rosian a ilu Ukrainców przewaga ok 7-1 a tak nie dają rady liczy się sprzęt i waleczność a nie chowanie sie za Amerykanami

  • @lasken13
    @lasken13 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Another one. Why are we analyzing the miitary potential? The truth is - Germans wanted to conquer Polish land. Simple as that - do we need to justify it in he German way? Germans had more fighters, tanks and other machinery of war. It doesn't justify the way of thinking. Poland is not the land to be taken - it is the independend country. The sooner Yoy will understand - the better.

  • @przemoziolkowski958
    @przemoziolkowski958 6 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Are you use ai?

  • @marekkonieczny2316
    @marekkonieczny2316 6 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Polska dopiero się zbroi
    Niedługo będziemy mieć 1000 czołgów k2 i 350 abramsów
    500 heimars i czunmho
    100 apache i F 35
    I jeszcze długo by tak wymieniać

    • @askaradzi
      @askaradzi 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

      A bedzie to jechac i dzialac. Bo bez atestow to bedzie tylko stalo i rdzewialo a jak juz nam dosla atesty to gwarancja na ich serwis sie skonczy. Ale fakt bedziemy miec. 😂

  • @tomasztomass
    @tomasztomass 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

    na dzien dobry wpierdol bedzie .........................................

  • @Polish_Napoleon
    @Polish_Napoleon 6 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Wojnę wygra Rosja

    • @RIDDICK19902721
      @RIDDICK19902721 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Dokładnie pewnie by wykorzystali to że się bijemy i wbili by od drugiej strony, a że pamiętają iż Niemcy wyruchali ich w WW2 to może zatrzymali by się dopiero na zachodniej granicy Niemiec, patrząc nawet czy nie dojść Atlantyku.

  • @JarrowJR
    @JarrowJR 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Lector of this movie is outdated (This is not his fault, he is only lector). Most of German tanks, planes and other military vehicles are not operational.Military exercises that took place 2 years ago at the training ground in Drawsko Pomorskie showed that not a single German plane took part in them because they were broken. When the Polish F-16 arrived at the military base in Ramstien, the German pilots were shocked that we had the latest versions of this aircraft.Flight controllers in the control tower couldn't believe that these were Polish planes. Later it turned out that only Polish and Dutch planes had any meaning during the entire exercise. Disappointed Germans returned from training on trailers or called service teams to return home. That's the true but the things like this you don't find on YT. Even a tabloid like the DailyMail wrote an article about this event.The war in Ukraine showed that German tanks are simply worthless and not adapted to the modern battlefield, only worthy on training grounds.

  • @mortenlexi
    @mortenlexi 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Bundeskhalifat deutschland (Germanistan 🧕) vs Poland

    • @Philip-z4m
      @Philip-z4m 6 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Just 3,7% of German population is Muslim so no.

  • @zeus2zeus2zeus2
    @zeus2zeus2zeus2 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    przestarzałe dane