Strap in. I have theories. I think the one in the box was a different clone. She didn't want current clone to end up like that, so she helped him escape. (Note Military Jeff has shorter hair as box clone is taken away.) Now, Military Jeff is trying to get back to normal life with his wife, but she's depressed about the escaped clone. Then Clone Jeff writes to her, and she writes back, and Military Husband Jeff sees them. He goes off by himself. She shows up, and he confronts her and then cries on her (bonfire scene). Later, we see Clone Jeff come back passing Military Jeff's grave (confirming that this takes place in the future. The dates are 2054 - 2143.) New pictures on the wall. She's old now too. He stats with her until she dies and then burries her too. He doesn't age cause he's a clone. A yellow leaf is a dead leaf. And now all he has is a mind full of memories... ghosts, as he goes on by himself. Those are my thoughts, anyway. Also, JEFF WHAT THE HELL???!!!
Adding on to this I feel that yellow leaf is a symbolism of his eternal love because leaves fall, the tree grows new leaves, and they fall again, which continues until the tree dies, and trees live for much longer than humans do. He goes through seasons, ups and downs, all those years, but his love for her never dies.
She didn't fall out of love with her husband. She just couldn't reconcile that she loves other Jeff too. She stayed with Military Jeff for the rest of his life because they DID still love each other. They just had to work through their issues. He died in his 80s. That's a picture of HER as an astronaut, btw. Clone Jeff came back now cause she's dying now, too. That's HER grave at the end. It may be the same horse, depending on how young it was at the beginning. Horses live about 30 years. Then again, it probably wouldn't be in any condition to make a long journey at 30. The end of the video is about 30 to 40 years after the end of Ghost.
I can't work out what the story is here, but it really doesn't matter to me. The song is almost unbearably sad and brings me to tears when I listen and watch the MV. Such talent to invoke that sort of emotion. Jeff's an incredibly gifted artist.
I've watched your video again just because I love how you analyze this video in each part. Thank you for your awesome reactions about Jeff's art!! ❤ I love this ❤
@marcogennuso you should react to the previous works of Jeff. I reccomend you, "Dum Dum" official music video in Thai version and the English version of Dum Dum (unchained live version) Also, I would like to see your reactions on his "Complicated" music video or maybe, the song "Steal the show" with Shaun and Jeff or, "Far" from Jeff and Silvy 🫰🏻🫵🏻❤
Jeff doesn't know who to blame. Since the clone is him but it's not him. He had left her alone with his clone for too long. The couple had too much time together. If we look at the first part, the seeds that were planted turned into a grove of flowers. This love has no way to go.
For clone Jeff's organ in the box, I think they have many spare clones for experiment. About the horse, Jeff said in his IG live that if they can cloning human maybe they do it with the horse too. I think the one who married the wife is clone Jeff. Because clone Jeff always wear silver earrings while the real Jeff never wear earrings but silver ring. Jeff in "Ghost" wedding scene wear silver earrings and they play hide and seek after their wedding. After real Jeff found out about their letters and wedding picture. The wife look more sad and depressed while real Jeff burn everything with the bonfire then they started argued. But the wife still chose living with real Jeff until he dead at age 89. Jeff said in interview that he chose number 8 from when he start to be singer when he's 18. And 9 from 1+8 = new beginning. So it's 89. The wife always wear the silver ring after real Jeff come back. Even though they're not happy and argued with each other. But until the last moment of her life, she still wearing that silver ring. Then clone Jeff come back to meet her again after the real Jeff dead. The wife live with real Jeff but her heart still be with clone Jeff. She keep a huge pile of clone Jeff's letter on the bed next to her pillow and still well keep his wood ring and their wedding picture. Clone Jeff happily look at that picture as it's his most happiness memory when they lived together. "Ghost", "Yellow Leaf" and "Space Shuttle No.8" was made by the same director. They said it's all connected. So I think after "Yellow Leaf" clone Jeff is the one who go to the train to Saturn. Because he wear the same silver earrings.
I recommend you react to Jeff's presentations on Call Me by Fire (a Chinese music program where Jeff participates and is one of the winners) he has some super good presentations❤❤❤
The one in the box is the robot jeff when he was just getting assembled in the farm early in the story to keep the fiancee company.(or also could be a new robot which got rejected by fiancee), but definitely not human because head and hands are detached, the box is not a coffin for the prestige human jeff and human jeff remained married to wife for a long time(even though he's aware of her affair, he is seen peeking through the door at 3:46) until he died (J.S. human tomb at 4:29) and she's old. the one in the top hat and 4 connecters on his back is robot jeff after he got away and settled in a barn, he had been writing letters and keeping contact with the fiancee after he escaped. Once the human mortal jeff dies of old age, robot jeff returns to fiancee and realise she had kept his wooden ring all this time and spend her last days together with him.
There are no other animals in the world. My theory is that the experiments started with creating the horse. When that worked, they moved on to creating the humanoid biomechanical robot. Neither can age because they're not actually alive. For me this is solidified by the body parts in boxes. As though you need to assemble him. My other theory is that robot Jeff was brought out everytime military/space Jeff had to go on a long term mission. They would get months or years together only for robot Jeff to be dismantled and returned to storage when not needed. I think in Ghost Military/Space Jeff was home for good, so they were going to completely wipe or destroy robot Jeff, so she helped him escape. Except now the relationship between Wife and Military/Space Jeff is almost that of strangers. The person she loves and can share her life with is someone she know she can't be with (I figure he is an expensive bit of government hardware and he is not just hinding from Military/Space Jeff, and also Space Jeff would report him so fast that all robot Jeff could risk visiting for longer than dropping off and picking up the letters), so over the years they share their lives together through their letters until he can finally come back after Space Jeff dies (maybe divorce isn’t possible in this weirdly distopian future), he can finally return to her side only to be in time to say his final farewell in person.
Also, I think that garden wedding photo is with Robot Jeff, not Space Jeff. If it were a real wedding, why were there no guests? No officiant? Why was there laundry hanging on the line. I think it was a romantic thing the did while Space Jeff was off being a storm trooper or something!
@@marcogennusoclone horse. That’s why the horse was IN THE house at the beginning. It was assembled in the house waiting for the clone Jeff. Expensive piece of machinery/bioorganism. That’s why it was inside. Like the wife, the horse was ready. Notice there’s no other animals? Farms have abundance of animals but this one didn’t? They had to have a horse for him so…. At least the clone and the horse will have eternity together.
เป็นไปได้ไหม ที่ real Jeff กระตุ้น clone Jeff กับมาใหม่ (หลังจากทีมนักวิทยาศาสตร์ไปตาม clone Jeff กลับมาได้และปิด Project ไป และ ทีมเก็บร่าง clone ไว้ที่ barn) real Jeff รู้ว่าภรรยารัก clone Jeff มาก จึงยอม activate clone Jeff ให้มีชีวิตขึ้นมาใหม่ และเขียนจดหมายถึงนางเอกตลอดเวลา เป็นการเสียสละและยอมเจ็บปวดอย่างมากของ real Jeff
Strap in. I have theories. I think the one in the box was a different clone. She didn't want current clone to end up like that, so she helped him escape. (Note Military Jeff has shorter hair as box clone is taken away.) Now, Military Jeff is trying to get back to normal life with his wife, but she's depressed about the escaped clone. Then Clone Jeff writes to her, and she writes back, and Military Husband Jeff sees them. He goes off by himself. She shows up, and he confronts her and then cries on her (bonfire scene). Later, we see Clone Jeff come back passing Military Jeff's grave (confirming that this takes place in the future. The dates are 2054 - 2143.) New pictures on the wall. She's old now too. He stats with her until she dies and then burries her too. He doesn't age cause he's a clone. A yellow leaf is a dead leaf. And now all he has is a mind full of memories... ghosts, as he goes on by himself. Those are my thoughts, anyway. Also, JEFF WHAT THE HELL???!!!
Adding on to this I feel that yellow leaf is a symbolism of his eternal love because leaves fall, the tree grows new leaves, and they fall again, which continues until the tree dies, and trees live for much longer than humans do. He goes through seasons, ups and downs, all those years, but his love for her never dies.
She didn't fall out of love with her husband. She just couldn't reconcile that she loves other Jeff too. She stayed with Military Jeff for the rest of his life because they DID still love each other. They just had to work through their issues. He died in his 80s. That's a picture of HER as an astronaut, btw. Clone Jeff came back now cause she's dying now, too. That's HER grave at the end. It may be the same horse, depending on how young it was at the beginning. Horses live about 30 years. Then again, it probably wouldn't be in any condition to make a long journey at 30. The end of the video is about 30 to 40 years after the end of Ghost.
I can't work out what the story is here, but it really doesn't matter to me. The song is almost unbearably sad and brings me to tears when I listen and watch the MV. Such talent to invoke that sort of emotion. Jeff's an incredibly gifted artist.
I've watched your video again just because I love how you analyze this video in each part. Thank you for your awesome reactions about Jeff's art!! ❤ I love this ❤
I appreciate the kind words, thank you so much!! 🥹💜🙏🏻
@marcogennuso you should react to the previous works of Jeff. I reccomend you, "Dum Dum" official music video in Thai version and the English version of Dum Dum (unchained live version)
Also, I would like to see your reactions on his "Complicated" music video or maybe, the song "Steal the show" with Shaun and Jeff or, "Far" from Jeff and Silvy 🫰🏻🫵🏻❤
Thanks a lot. Watching your reactions to Jeff's songs is so nice. 💛
whenever there is a deeper voice its the military jeff and when the vocals r high or falsetto, its the clone jeff
So beautiful and sorrowful 😔
i love your reaction, it's so on point 👏👏👏 thanks
Thank you! 🤗
Jeff doesn't know who to blame. Since the clone is him but it's not him. He had left her alone with his clone for too long. The couple had too much time together. If we look at the first part, the seeds that were planted turned into a grove of flowers. This love has no way to go.
For clone Jeff's organ in the box, I think they have many spare clones for experiment.
About the horse, Jeff said in his IG live that if they can cloning human maybe they do it with the horse too.
I think the one who married the wife is clone Jeff. Because clone Jeff always wear silver earrings while the real Jeff never wear earrings but silver ring.
Jeff in "Ghost" wedding scene wear silver earrings and they play hide and seek after their wedding. After real Jeff found out about their letters and wedding picture. The wife look more sad and depressed while real Jeff burn everything with the bonfire then they started argued.
But the wife still chose living with real Jeff until he dead at age 89. Jeff said in interview that he chose number 8 from when he start to be singer when he's 18. And 9 from 1+8 = new beginning. So it's 89.
The wife always wear the silver ring after real Jeff come back. Even though they're not happy and argued with each other. But until the last moment of her life, she still wearing that silver ring.
Then clone Jeff come back to meet her again after the real Jeff dead.
The wife live with real Jeff but her heart still be with clone Jeff. She keep a huge pile of clone Jeff's letter on the bed next to her pillow and still well keep his wood ring and their wedding picture. Clone Jeff happily look at that picture as it's his most happiness memory when they lived together.
"Ghost", "Yellow Leaf" and "Space Shuttle No.8" was made by the same director. They said it's all connected.
So I think after "Yellow Leaf" clone Jeff is the one who go to the train to Saturn. Because he wear the same silver earrings.
This is so well detailed, I like it so much
Wohhhh I never thought about the horse not aging too… danggg
I recommend you react to Jeff's presentations on Call Me by Fire (a Chinese music program where Jeff participates and is one of the winners) he has some super good presentations❤❤❤
The one in the box is the robot jeff when he was just getting assembled in the farm early in the story to keep the fiancee company.(or also could be a new robot which got rejected by fiancee), but definitely not human because head and hands are detached, the box is not a coffin for the prestige human jeff and human jeff remained married to wife for a long time(even though he's aware of her affair, he is seen peeking through the door at 3:46) until he died (J.S. human tomb at 4:29) and she's old. the one in the top hat and 4 connecters on his back is robot jeff after he got away and settled in a barn, he had been writing letters and keeping contact with the fiancee after he escaped. Once the human mortal jeff dies of old age, robot jeff returns to fiancee and realise she had kept his wooden ring all this time and spend her last days together with him.
the horse doesn't age because it's also a robot. robots don't die and get buried
That scene I think she made a fake clone Jeff to help him run away and make sure no one’s after him / other scene I agree w you.
I agree with you.
There are no other animals in the world. My theory is that the experiments started with creating the horse. When that worked, they moved on to creating the humanoid biomechanical robot. Neither can age because they're not actually alive. For me this is solidified by the body parts in boxes. As though you need to assemble him. My other theory is that robot Jeff was brought out everytime military/space Jeff had to go on a long term mission. They would get months or years together only for robot Jeff to be dismantled and returned to storage when not needed. I think in Ghost Military/Space Jeff was home for good, so they were going to completely wipe or destroy robot Jeff, so she helped him escape. Except now the relationship between Wife and Military/Space Jeff is almost that of strangers. The person she loves and can share her life with is someone she know she can't be with (I figure he is an expensive bit of government hardware and he is not just hinding from Military/Space Jeff, and also Space Jeff would report him so fast that all robot Jeff could risk visiting for longer than dropping off and picking up the letters), so over the years they share their lives together through their letters until he can finally come back after Space Jeff dies (maybe divorce isn’t possible in this weirdly distopian future), he can finally return to her side only to be in time to say his final farewell in person.
Also, I think that garden wedding photo is with Robot Jeff, not Space Jeff. If it were a real wedding, why were there no guests? No officiant? Why was there laundry hanging on the line. I think it was a romantic thing the did while Space Jeff was off being a storm trooper or something!
I think, Jeff's ai robot.
Time passes. OG Jeff dies. She ages. Clone Jeff comes back one last time still loves her. Buries her. He doesn’t age cause he’s a clone
And the horse?? 😭😭😂
Yeah. Got me on that one
Thank you for simplifying it for me though!! 😂💜🙏🏻
@@marcogennusoclone horse. That’s why the horse was IN THE house at the beginning. It was assembled in the house waiting for the clone Jeff. Expensive piece of machinery/bioorganism. That’s why it was inside. Like the wife, the horse was ready. Notice there’s no other animals? Farms have abundance of animals but this one didn’t? They had to have a horse for him so…. At least the clone and the horse will have eternity together.
those years on the grave are according to thai calender. which is 534 years ahead:)
เป็นไปได้ไหม ที่ real Jeff กระตุ้น clone Jeff กับมาใหม่ (หลังจากทีมนักวิทยาศาสตร์ไปตาม clone Jeff กลับมาได้และปิด Project ไป และ ทีมเก็บร่าง clone ไว้ที่ barn) real Jeff รู้ว่าภรรยารัก clone Jeff มาก จึงยอม activate clone Jeff ให้มีชีวิตขึ้นมาใหม่ และเขียนจดหมายถึงนางเอกตลอดเวลา เป็นการเสียสละและยอมเจ็บปวดอย่างมากของ real Jeff
ดูมีเหตุผลครับ ตอนแรกผมคิดว่าที่นางเอกเครียดแล้วดื่มเพราะเจฟจริงตุย แต่มาคิดจากที่คุณบอกอาจจะเป็นเครียดเพราะเจฟโคลนถูกเก็บไปในกล่อง ซึ่งเจฟจริงสังเกตุมาตลอด(จากที่แอบดูตรงประตู)เลยปลุกเจฟโคลนขึ้นมาให้นางเอกอาการดีขึ้น
I think she fell out of love with her real husband and he tried to clone himself again for her, but it went wrong and he died.