This was based on the demo session which Victoria missed the recording due to a wedding. Her vocals for the chorus were added later for the studio version, same as for Mama and 2 Become 1 (both for single versions). This statement was confirmed by both Matt Rowe and her.
@@murilo_channel1:39 this is the demo version. Victoria was around with the other four in the studio. For the studio album recording, Victoria wasn't around with the other four when Wannabe, 2 Become 1, Mama & Something Kinda Funny. Victoria's vocal was only added separately once the four songs were recorded. In addition, for the single version, 2 Become 1, Victoria replaced/sang Geri's line, because they think Victoria sang better in that line than Geri. And one more thing, in the demo version, Mel B's solo line in the song was originally sung by Victoria ✌️✌️✌️🇬🇧🇬🇧❤️❤️❤️
Sorry for comment late but she wasn’t at the studio while recording so production needed to scramble her in some lyrics that’s why she doesn’t sing as much
Victoria said she only recorded the backvocals because all the lines were already recorded by the other girls. Yes, she sang "Are you for real." And some of the low notes in the chorus (that she can't sing live so she sings along with Geri's harmonies because Geri also has a hard time remembering her part of the harmony.)
@@pauljetThe lead voice in the chorus of Wannabe is Mel C, in Say You'll be there is Mel B, in 2 Become 1 is Emma/Mel C/Mel B, in Who Do You Think You Are is Mel B, in Mama is Emma. In Spice up your life is Emma/Mel C, in holler is Mel B, in Goodbye is Mel C/Emma/Mel C again etc etc. So not every chorus. Also counting all 3 albums Mel B is the lead in most of the songs and yes Mel C is the voice of the spice girls
@@pauljet Her voice IS CLEARLY the most hearable in the chorus of Wannabe, goodbye, naked 😂 and in just every chorus in which she was lead or sang solo. She was also the only one to sing solo in a bunch of choruses, all the more reason Mel C is the voice of the spice girls
It's Mel B's laugh, there is an interview where she almost does the same laugh... it was early days and they sing wannabe acapella. They even used her laugh in the celebrity juice episodes when she was a teamcaptain.
@@murilo_channel yes just like she was in « Wannabe » and « 2 become 1 » 😂🤣🤣 I’m not saying she’s not singing for sure on SKF but I wouldn’t be surprised if she doesn’t either
Esque a Victoria en realidad no la esperaron para componer y grabar esta canción esta más que sabido eso. Pero me parece bien mala onda de parte de las otras 4 queriendo sobresalir ante todo. En fin ahora podemos ver quién es la más importante y popular entre las 5 🤭
Ella es influyente ahora porque pertenece a otra industria. Ella se dedico a hacer su marca y trabajar en moda, sus esfuerzos dieron buenos resultados, pero fue solo porque se dedicó a otra área. En Spice Girls como girl band todas destacaban a su modo y si no mal recuerdo la gloria y majestad de ese apogeo musical se fue derrumbando poco a poco por que geri la cara de Spice Girls se marchó. De otro modo Spice Girls seguirían muy vigentes. Ahora que volvieron y nos dan luces de regreso es completamente entendíble que vic no quiera o no pueda seguir con la gira o futuros planes Spice. Ella mal que mal ha consolidado bastante bien su futuro, pero no por eso es la que le ha ido mejor o más conocida o famosa, no se puede comparar porque migro a otra industria distinta a la música.
Yo siempre quise que Victoria cantara al menos la partes que Mel B canta en las estrofas, ya que la negrura es la reina del color así que esas partes le correspondían a Victoria
@@bittergeorge si lo merece porque fue y es una Spice girl más como las otras 4 e hizo y pasó el casting como laa otras y de hecho fue de las primeras en ser elegida. Así es que te guste o no si se lo merece.
@@evangeline310 Victoria and Emma sing the half of the chorus Posh does the low voice Baby does the falsetto voice If you wanna be my lover Make it last forever If you wanna be my lover Taking this too easy
It's okay if Victoria's part is only Are you for real? Because she owns LOVE THING & SPICE UP YOUR LIFE and also in FEED YOUR LOVE, Vic is the lead singer💓
Okay? She has one line, if we can even call it that, in their debut song and barely sings in most tracks of their debut album, how is this okay? Feed Your Love and Love Thing are songs that most people don't even know of, while Spice Up Your Life they basically sing in unisson, the fact that she receives more lines in these songs doesn't make her the Lead Singer.
Are you sure she even sings the chorus of the others songs on the first album? She barely sings in Wannabe and If You Can't Dance, doesn't sing at all in 2 become 1. I wouldn't be surprised If they didn't add her voice in some others songs too.
Calm down, it was only in the Biffco tracks. I wish they or their team would acknowledge this in public though. As far as album recordings go, she's not in Wannabe, Mama, 2 Become 1 and IUCD but at the same time she is present in the 2B1 and IUCD demos; as for Wannabe they would need to extract the vocal stems to see if she's in it.
![Spice Girls - Wannabe (Vocal Analysis) ["Unmixed" Chorus]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wXqgwt0xEFI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ไฮไลต์] เจ้าฟ่าง ธีรพงศ์ ศิลาชัย "คว้าเหรียญเงิน" ยกน้ำหนักชาย รุ่น 61kg | โอลิมปิก 2024](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/981lYv1AwKk/mqdefault.jpg)
This was based on the demo session which Victoria missed the recording due to a wedding. Her vocals for the chorus were added later for the studio version, same as for Mama and 2 Become 1 (both for single versions). This statement was confirmed by both Matt Rowe and her.
What about 1:39?
@@murilo_channel1:39 this is the demo version. Victoria was around with the other four in the studio. For the studio album recording, Victoria wasn't around with the other four when Wannabe, 2 Become 1, Mama & Something Kinda Funny. Victoria's vocal was only added separately once the four songs were recorded. In addition, for the single version, 2 Become 1, Victoria replaced/sang Geri's line, because they think Victoria sang better in that line than Geri. And one more thing, in the demo version, Mel B's solo line in the song was originally sung by Victoria ✌️✌️✌️🇬🇧🇬🇧❤️❤️❤️
I am in shock, poor Victoria 😭
So, Victoria only sings the "Are you for real?" and, maybe, the "Slam your body down" part
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Sorry for comment late but she wasn’t at the studio while recording so production needed to scramble her in some lyrics that’s why she doesn’t sing as much
Victoria said she only recorded the backvocals because all the lines were already recorded by the other girls. Yes, she sang "Are you for real." And some of the low notes in the chorus (that she can't sing live so she sings along with Geri's harmonies because Geri also has a hard time remembering her part of the harmony.)
Victoria: Are You For Real.... that's my only line???
victoria wasn't at the recording of wannabe, her vocals were added later
Nooo otra vez pobre victoria 😔
I love the Emma/ Geri chorus! Minute 0:22
I love the vocal stems of Mel C she is really the voice of Spice Girls🧡🧡🧡
no mel b on "you got to give"
Emma, you meant. All the choruses are her.
@@pauljetThe lead voice in the chorus of Wannabe is Mel C, in Say You'll be there is Mel B, in 2 Become 1 is Emma/Mel C/Mel B, in Who Do You Think You Are is Mel B, in Mama is Emma. In Spice up your life is Emma/Mel C, in holler is Mel B, in Goodbye is Mel C/Emma/Mel C again etc etc. So not every chorus. Also counting all 3 albums Mel B is the lead in most of the songs and yes Mel C is the voice of the spice girls
@@Alejandro-cl7gg her rancid voice is barely hearable in the choruses then 😂
@@pauljet Her voice IS CLEARLY the most hearable in the chorus of Wannabe, goodbye, naked 😂 and in just every chorus in which she was lead or sang solo. She was also the only one to sing solo in a bunch of choruses, all the more reason Mel C is the voice of the spice girls
QUE CARAJOS ????? 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 VICTORIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
QUE ASCOOOOOO. Pobre Victoria ❣
La verdad es que lo de que la voz baja era Victoria era cuestión de fe... No había pruebas... Hasta ahora 😐
victoria no cantaba nada, hacia coros nada mas, era un 3 % de un tema, cuando se fue de solista recien empezo a cantar ella.
So it was Ginger's laugh
no it's Mel B's laugh
@@schrettarichie3927 no
@@Cloudetower it sounds like Mel B than Geri
It's Mel B's laugh, there is an interview where she almost does the same laugh... it was early days and they sing wannabe acapella. They even used her laugh in the celebrity juice episodes when she was a teamcaptain.
@@XanArt21 i don't know why people saying it's Geri
Well if she don't make low notes on chorus, she don't in slam your body too
It's Mel B
But if we base it on the demo version.. She probably never sang on it
And since they used remix version(remix in most demo vocal) it's difficult to know if they single in final cut or not
Thanks for sharing!
Knowing that, who knows if she really sings in "Something Kinda Funny" or "Last Time Lover" since she has no parts in those songs either.
She clearly sing in something kinda funny, not the pre chorus tho, its mel b with emma
@@murilo_channel « clearly » really ? How ?
@@MichyaFromSweden the chorus, she is audible.
@@murilo_channel yes just like she was in « Wannabe » and « 2 become 1 » 😂🤣🤣
I’m not saying she’s not singing for sure on SKF but I wouldn’t be surprised if she doesn’t either
You can hear Posh' vocal in chorus of SKF in this link: m.th-cam.com/video/MynOUR4-p0U/w-d-xo.html
Omg, paso lo mismo que con 2 Become 1. Y no me sorprendería que con otras también. Que sad 😪
MMM QUE FUERTE! Como hicisteis todo esto? Se filtraron los stems??? Maravilloso video 😊✨
I hope you can check again the line distribution in "Feed your love",
I think Emma also sing "Cause I need to know that you care" with Vic & Mel B
Esque a Victoria en realidad no la esperaron para componer y grabar esta canción esta más que sabido eso. Pero me parece bien mala onda de parte de las otras 4 queriendo sobresalir ante todo. En fin ahora podemos ver quién es la más importante y popular entre las 5 🤭
Ella es influyente ahora porque pertenece a otra industria. Ella se dedico a hacer su marca y trabajar en moda, sus esfuerzos dieron buenos resultados, pero fue solo porque se dedicó a otra área. En Spice Girls como girl band todas destacaban a su modo y si no mal recuerdo la gloria y majestad de ese apogeo musical se fue derrumbando poco a poco por que geri la cara de Spice Girls se marchó. De otro modo Spice Girls seguirían muy vigentes. Ahora que volvieron y nos dan luces de regreso es completamente entendíble que vic no quiera o no pueda seguir con la gira o futuros planes Spice. Ella mal que mal ha consolidado bastante bien su futuro, pero no por eso es la que le ha ido mejor o más conocida o famosa, no se puede comparar porque migro a otra industria distinta a la música.
Yo siempre quise que Victoria cantara al menos la partes que Mel B canta en las estrofas, ya que la negrura es la reina del color así que esas partes le correspondían a Victoria
@@ionathanmraz como sabes que victoria si tenía un solo?
O es solo una imaginación tuya?
Un día como hoy que bueno que no metieron a Victoria ! No lo merece !
@@bittergeorge si lo merece porque fue y es una Spice girl más como las otras 4 e hizo y pasó el casting como laa otras y de hecho fue de las primeras en ser elegida. Así es que te guste o no si se lo merece.
Even if it was after the first recording how hard would it have been to let her have more then that? That's ridiculous.
Me encanta el video de spice girls
Oh god, poor Posh 😑😑😑
Which voice is more deeper on low harmony,I mean about all discography are Mel B or Victoria,anyone knows how to explain?
0:43
Plss do outer space girls 🥺🥺
in the chorus I thought the low voice was Victoria
it is her lines are :
'if you wanna be my lover'
'Make it last forever'
If you wanna be my lover'
'Taking this too easy'
@@evangeline310 Victoria and Emma sing the half of the chorus
Posh does the low voice
Baby does the falsetto voice
If you wanna be my lover
Make it last forever
If you wanna be my lover
Taking this too easy
@@lorettarichie157 yeah, that's what I meant
😩😩
At least Victoria is more lucky than Jessica, Kimberly and Ashley
😱
But in Lovr versions you can hear her low harmony which is needed since Mel B sings the middle
Victoria 😞
It's okay if Victoria's part is only Are you for real? Because she owns LOVE THING & SPICE UP YOUR LIFE and also in FEED YOUR LOVE, Vic is the lead singer💓
Okay? She has one line, if we can even call it that, in their debut song and barely sings in most tracks of their debut album, how is this okay?
Feed Your Love and Love Thing are songs that most people don't even know of, while Spice Up Your Life they basically sing in unisson, the fact that she receives more lines in these songs doesn't make her the Lead Singer.
Mel B is the lead on feed your love.
Are you sure she even sings the chorus of the others songs on the first album? She barely sings in Wannabe and If You Can't Dance, doesn't sing at all in 2 become 1. I wouldn't be surprised If they didn't add her voice in some others songs too.
I doubt that Posh didn't sing the chorus in "Denying" & "Mama", because the low note in those chorus looked like a man, not like her
Calm down, it was only in the Biffco tracks. I wish they or their team would acknowledge this in public though. As far as album recordings go, she's not in Wannabe, Mama, 2 Become 1 and IUCD but at the same time she is present in the 2B1 and IUCD demos; as for Wannabe they would need to extract the vocal stems to see if she's in it.
She sings in 2 become 1. Victoria may not sing "as well" as the others but she was and still is an icon.
Biffco team didn’t like Vic voice at the time but she sings a lot with the Absolute team, that’s all.
@@DDDNat Funny how things changed for the SW album, Goodbye, and Headlines.
Not accurate though. It was mel B's laugh, confirmed
Now I see why she hates singing this song.
Poor Victoria 🙁. Now she’s probably gonna barely sing for 5 seconds.
0:44