'This War Will End With a Russian Collapse. Donald Trump Will Leave NATO.' | Ep. 25 Jake Broe
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 มิ.ย. 2024
- ➡️ PATREON: / decodinggeopolitics
This is a conversation with Jake Broe, a former Nuclear and Missile Operations Officer and one of the biggest TH-camrs providing daily updates on the war in Ukraine. We talked about why Jake thinks Donald Trump will leave NATO, why the war will end with a political and economic collapse of Russia and much, much more.
0:00 - Intro
1:32 - Jake's Military Background and Journey on TH-cam
6:17 - Public Attitudes to Ukraine in the West
11:54 - Donald Trump - Ukraine & NATO
14:31 - Past 2 Years of the War
17:48 - Incompetency of Russian Military
20:38 - Current State of the War
23:28 - Russian Collapse
29:51 - Russia & Nuclear Weapons
36:11 - What Should the West Do
![แฟนแนวใด๋ - ยูริ โตเกียวมิวสิค [OFFICIAL MUSIC VIDEO ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4_XVMuhhbsU/mqdefault.jpg)
Some of Jake's birthday trucks are already on their way to the frontline in Ukraine. He's one of the few TH-camrs to have a genuine impact on the war.
Think you might be bigging him up a little
@@timothyrussell4445 nah, those supplies will likely go a very long way. With that said, there's alot more people then him chipping him. Or at least a couple more.
@@timothyrussell4445 He collected over $1 MILLION for the trucks in ONE campaign. Which other TH-camrs have done anything close to that? I'd love to know so I can subscribe to their channels, too!
Thanks for having Jake Broe. He’s top notch.
Jake broe will lose
I concur 100%
I completely agree, Jake is great!
I love Jake & I'm pleased to see him here on your channel. Jake's been steadfast in his support for Ukraine & he has my utmost respect.
He "separated" himself from the military???? He sounds like a real snowflakepoosy.
We need to "separate" the heads of the military,.. especially the group that led the incompetent withdrawal from Afghanistan that emboldened putin to attack Ukraine and Iran to attack Israel and china to talk about invading Taiwan.
This guy is a kook if he thinks Trump will get out of NATO.
What he'll do is have them contribute their fair share.
"The price of potatoes in Russia has gone up 46%. Russians are going to feel it at the grocery store" .... and at the liquor store!
Don't forget that the Russians were used to standing in front of empty shelves, which is why they are extremely grateful to Putin and will stand by him for a long time to come.
Soon we are going to get to watch Tucker Carlson smell potatoes in Russia.
Russian/Soviet control over Eastern Europe (1945-1991) was a bizarre anomaly. It is NOT, as Putin mistakenly believes, the natural order of things. Russia could NOT have occupied all of Eastern Europe except that the West was exhausted from WWII and did not go after Stalin and the USSR for war crimes during WWII as one of the instigators of WWII (Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact). Stalin actually caused more deaths than Hitler! Stalin expected to have to barter for control of portions of Europe, and as an experienced barterer asked for way more of Europe than he expected to get at the end of WWII, and to his surprise, and the shame of the West, US and UK agreed to his initial bid without challenge!
The Cold War froze the lines way longer than natural, and it was only a matter of time before Eastern Europe threw off the shackles of Soviet/Russian rule; and with the illusion of super-power shattered, Russia itself had a revolution and changed from the USSR to the Russian Federation.
Today Poland could defeat Russia by itself in a conventional war.
Nukes are an end-of-existence last resort for Russia. Better used as a bargaining chip than actually used.
The RAFs mass bombing campaign was opened up at Stalin's behest to Churchill to take pressure off the Russian front. Thousands of guns and men plus the resources had to be held back to protect Berlin and other German centers.. Harris was the man who made it happen. It cost 10,000 RAF crew lives to rescue Stalins Russia plus the lives of the other allies. There was also the countless sailors that shipped aircraft equipment and vehicles into Archangel via the Artic convoys. And try telling the Seamen awarded the Artic Star what they didn't do.
One final point Churchill was a very ill man who had a heart condition and even had heart attacks .. but at the final Yelta meeting he had to rest ... That left the US president who was no fan of Britain's Empire basically came to a two party agreement... Churchill didn't trust Stalin one bit.
One final point - when the rest of Europe was rebuilt under the Marshal plan GB. was also stuck with WW2 lease lend repayments that were only paid off this century.
European dreams as usual. NATO/US a group of 32 Nations have not been able to defeat Russia since 2014. Russia has even offered them additional 300B. But are still losing in Ukraine.
That's because Roosevelt was weak and sick at that stage so easily taken advantage of by Stalin. Also the Americans were looking for russian support in the war against Japan so Stalin got way more than was justified, the Americans were trying to save their soldiers for the war in the Pacific
@@clivestainlesssteelwomble7665 FYI the WWII RAF Bomber Command's official 'aircrew' KIA losses were just over 57,000 (not '10,000'). And as what I think is a more-important 'nope' correction for you...
When Churchill became PM, Stalin was Hitler's ally. His 'resource-allocation' decisions before June 1941 were what meant that RAF Bomber Command (with all the Allied/Commonwealth units that were joined to it) became the 'nuclear-equivalent' strategic weapon it was in 1944/45. At a guess you've read that the bombing of Dresden in 1945 was related to Stalin asking for Allied assistance (which is true), and have mistakenly extrapolated backwards from that.
Just in case you don't know, the USAAF's B-17s also hit that city as the daylight-raid, sandwich-filler between the RAF's attacks 13-15th February 1945.
All the best to you. Always nice to see that someone-else also likes 'doing History' 🙂
Ja ja nice try WARPIG!! You better be going to the military office bro, they gonna need you
Canadians love Jake he speaks the truth ....
Love listening to Jake- The voice of reason, the voice of sanity, voice of Ukrainian victory
My parents were teenagers when nazi Germany invaded the Netherlands. Their experience was awful but what befell Poland was much, much worse. I was brought up on their experience. The similarities between Germanies attack on Poland and Russia's attack on Ukraine are almost carbon copy. The plight of the Ukrainian people and the vital imperative that Ukraine prevail not just for themselves but for all Europe has me fully engaged every day..
Please people, do not let Trump do his damage.
Absolutely right Mr. John Verkerk! -- Donald "Jesus" Trump & Vladimir Putin are the copycats of one Hitler, one Stalin and one Bandito Musselini.. and they are the only real Nazis with power still alive in this world!
Lest not forget, that Natzi Germany and Russia (who attacked two week later) invaded Poland,
So Russia is responsible for WWII as much as the Natzies.
Thanks for the interview with Jake, brilliant!👏🏻👍🏻💪🇺🇦🇬🇧
🇸🇪🤝🇺🇦
The TH-cam algorithm gods directed me to Jake’s podcast, & IMO, he has, by far, the most comprehensive coverage of the Ukrainian War on any media platform. He puts an enormous amount of work into each podcast, & gathers excellent guests.
He "separated" himself from the military???? He sounds like a real snowflakepoosy.
We need to "separate" the heads of the military,.. especially the group that led the incompetent withdrawal from Afghanistan that emboldened putin to attack Ukraine and Iran to attack Israel and china to talk about invading Taiwan.
This guy is a kook if he thinks Trump will get out of NATO.
What he'll do is have them contribute their fair share.
IF only we had more people like Jake - honest, caring, intelligent, truthful, seeking to understand deeply, a true hero of our time. Thank you for all you are doing, Jake.
Jake Broe has a great channel and provided well over $1 million in aid to Ukraine.
Jake is a hero , thanks for helping Ukraine 🇺🇦
Jake Broe... launched a NAFO fundraiser with a target of $40k for his 40th birthday from his channel (enough for 2 SUVs to be bought and 'battlefield-adapted' in Estonia)... has raised $1,190,047.86 as a result. Absolute rock-star fella, defender of the USA, Ukraine and democracy.
Lol
@@JS-ti8nyyour idol putin is inded a Kremlin clown.
1.3 million
@@JS-ti8ny sure boris. Makes sense you have only insults and little argument. I'd be angry too if my whole life was a lie.
@@JS-ti8ny You shouldn't speak of Putin this way. You might fall out of a window.
Props to Jake for speaking out on politics. He risks alienating some of his channel subscribers by doing so, but he's a veteran who cares too much about his country to stay silent when so much is at stake this November.
Yeah, at least he will know why everybody left.
@@wildwillie6132 - He won't lose anyone important, if they are 'fair weather friends' then they are not much use.
@@WJV9Nope just the important ones that made Trump win.
@@clifflogan7974the likelihood of trump winning is low
@@clifflogan7974remember he lost as an incumbent, that's a feat
Jake FOR PRESIDENT..?!! ❤
Greets from the Netherlands 🇳🇱 I’m around 50 years old and this crazy situation needs to be solved VERY WISE
👍⛅️👌🏼💕
Thank goodness we have Jake discussing the war. He does a great job.
Well... until he pisses everybody off.
Jake Broe is the best Ukraine 🇺🇦 war commentator on TH-cam. He recently raised over $1 million for a charity that provides vehicles for the Ukrainian military 🪖.
Truth
That Jake Broe may be but he shits on America by supporting Biden. China owns Biden and controls him. Biden is a puppet of China.
check out Ben Hodges
Jake's friend named Artur Rehi is also excellent. Similar, but not the same, and they work together on giving big donations to the army of Ukraine. I've watched them both since Putin lost his mind and invaded Ukraine.
I don´t know if he´s "THE" best.
He´s among those for sure, but never forget Perun.
I've followed the war in Ukraine since the very beginning on a hand full of great channels. I've found that i need to take a few days off once in a while, when stress starts to upset my mental health. It can be overwhelming, sad, and all- encompassing. My sense of justice can become so offended. I can take breaks when needed. I wish that Ukrainians could do that, too.
Jake is spot on in what he is saying about the state of the USA and Trump. This is a VERY dangerous time for us USA citizens.
A BRILLIANT interview and as always, an extremely well-spoken Champion of Ukraine - Jake Broe is a pleasure to listen to. I hold Jake Broe in the same leauge as General Ben Hodges in their opinions and analysis of the Ukraine situation. I hope to one day see Jake Broe as the US Ambassador To Ukraine! (I think your video would get more views if 'Jake Broe' showed in the thumbnail!)
@@simonebest6013you are?? Yay, go you ruZki, woohoo 🙌
Agree with you!!
@@simonebest6013 Umm - - that's YOUR thing ivan - not mine.
Slava Ukraini!
Honestly, I have been engaged and emotionally invested every day since 2/24/22. I knew then, clear as day, that the future of my children would be decided in Ukraine. So first thing every morning, I check Ukraine news - (and I always watch Jake). Every weekday night, I fall alseep to "Ukraine the Latest". I'm a NAFO fella. I joined a local ukrainian association. I go to the Ukraine rallies in my capital. I do donation drives. I've now had 2 years of online ukrainian lessons with a tutor (recently reached B1 level, українська мова - солов'їна❤). My friends and family have learned that I will find a way to eventually make any topic of conversation be about Ukraine.
I dont know if it's healthy - probably not - but it doesn't really matter. Ukraine matters. If we dont get this right, we wont like where we end up. We wont like it at all.
Thank you from Denmak Ukraine have to win.
Good on you
you are really an example of an impressionable person. Learning a luangage you do not need and really beliving this mythic conception about ukrainians. Its to 90% myth and not real. I dont want to shit on the ukrainians, i have nothing against them. But you should leanr to be a bit more sceptical.
I'm saying this because I'm not the only one for whom life changed with russias full scale invasion, and I've never seen anything like the response to this war, by millions of people around the world. It matters.
@@medeology4660 and what role does propaganda play in it?
Just occurred to me: The US letting Ukraine use American weapons on Russian soil north of Kharkiv frees up Ukrainian weapons for use on other Russian areas
Yup
Except they don't have that many
So great to see Jake all over the place, on other people's shows too, because his expert analysis is badly needed. I've followed him since this crazy war began, and he does a fantastic job. He's also very involved in helping Ukraine in every way he can.
On Trump pulling the US out of NATO: didn't Congress pass a bill prohibiting the President from doing this unilaterlally without a Senate supermajority or Act of Congress? Didn't hear either one bring this up.
Yes, that's true. However, the USA doesn't have to leave NATO *officially* to render its membership *ineffective* by simply not honoring its obligations the way it's supposed to.
Europe is going to have to step up in a big way either way. Its security order cannot be left up to the American electorate.
Who enforces the laws? The executive branch, trump will be the law.
Doesn't matter. The president as CIC calls the shots about what the military do. Trump will simultaneously destroy NATO and the USA's status on the world stage. The cost to America (never mind the rest of the world) will be huge.
He said that Trump will instantly stop pentagon from providing intelligence, etc instantly after he gets into office. meaning doesn't matter whether US has pulled out of NATO, this crazy 78 year old deranged clown will do whatever his whims, objectively true. Each of statement of Jake are aligned with whats happening on ground today, shocking and yet almost like helpless Russians viewers of their governments actions, we are viewing the show on how Donald has formed his cult
Yes. While Jake has good war coverage he has definitely cranked up the fear mongering for his political agenda. It’s half war coverage and half him spewing political nonsense getting people riled up.
Jake, I only have that much more appreciation and admiration for the information and message you share. Thank you.
Love your passion for Ukraine’s victory Jake.
Hi from Australia👍
Austria needs to join NATO….
@@amywhite752 they said Austra*L*ia (who is already a NATO ally through our ANZUS, AUUKUS and Five Eyes alliances.)
Jake is a top man. Rock of common sense and compassion.
There is a reason why in Finnish verb "Ryssiä" (Muscovy) , roughly meaning "to totally fail something".
Yeah, "to russky something" means f*** up utterly and completely in our grandparents' slang
@@henriikkak2091 And in Russian to be "like a Finn" is to be black out drunk.
@@user-vr5js6nd3w - A very weak attempt at a comeback from a ruZZian troll. The whole world knows that besides sleeping, the second most popular past time of the men in ruZZia is to stay drunk. That's exactly why vodka is so popular. Now, you had better go hide before you're sent to the front lines to become worm food in Ukraine!
@@user-vr5js6nd3w Hi Ivan-troll !
@@bushpocket8619 Hi man! But if I think differently doesn't mean I'm trolling. Not baiting emotion at all, just thought.
two open minded and intelligent men discussing the most important events of our time. so much better than German TV
It’s called critical thinking
Jake is cluless.
@@simonebest6013 Impressive argument. I especially like how you listed all your criticisms and provided proof and evidence to support them. Now I am completely convinced of your side and will not view you as a simple person who follows simple leaders like DT blindly and without questioning wether what they are saying has any basis in objective reality.
While Ukraine is shrinking.
@@simonebest6013 please explain why you think Jake is clueless…
I like Broe's honesty. It would be nice if our politicians could speak directly and honestly, even with humility, as Jake Broe does.
NATO is a treaty. It has been approved by the US Senate by more than the supermajority required for its approval.
Therefore no one man or woman can unilaterally withdraw us from the alliance. We have a president, not a king.
Researching the treaty however, did reveal one thing at its inception. In order to avoid "foreign entanglements" the actual wording of article 5 is designed to make participation in a conflict up to each individual state. Therefore when he says he won't DO anything for Europe, believe him.
bet the half twit's going to try to make himself king.
We have a King here in the UK, but he couldn't pull us out of NATO even if he wanted to. It would require a bill passed by parliament.
Congressional Republicans have demonstrated their servile devotion to Trump over and over again. They are unwilling to fulfill their constitutional obligation as a check and balance to the executive branch of government if Trump is in office
You are wrong because you don't understand how Trump acts and will act. You may have been in a coma for awhile but the GOP and Trump have gone full fascist. No laws, no consitution, no treaties will matter. If you disagree with Trump you will be arrested or thrown out a high window. Many careers will be ended and loyalty trumps all qualifications. The 2025 plan is already in place.
In my opinion Donald Trump tries to take full power I.e. being a “dictator” then he will probably be detained by the “old” generals, the military
Jake is an awesome guy!
Jake's subscribers are awesome people.
Scott Aiden- All The Crew Lived 🤣
Jake if you're reading the comments, your work rate has been huge recently, im glad your birthday fundraiser has put more pep in your step. We all need to dollow your lead and do more
How about another big round of thanks for Jake and all of the wonderful people who turned a birthday wish into a charity phenomenon.
He "separated" himself from the military???? He sounds like a real snowflakepoosy.
We need to "separate" the heads of the military,.. especially the group that led the incompetent withdrawal from Afghanistan that emboldened putin to attack Ukraine and Iran to attack Israel and china to talk about invading Taiwan.
This guy is a kook if he thinks Trump will get out of NATO.
What he'll do is have them contribute their fair share.
Great guest, thank you for inviting Jake Broe, he’s a great friend of Ukraine and freedom and democracy.
Slava Ukraini !
Please, dear American friends, vote like it’s the last time you vote, because it may be.
Hugs from Romania ❤
He "separated" himself from the military???? He sounds like a real snowflakepoosy.
We need to "separate" the heads of the military,.. especially the group that led the incompetent withdrawal from Afghanistan that emboldened putin to attack Ukraine and Iran to attack Israel and china to talk about invading Taiwan.
This guy is a kook if he thinks Trump will get out of NATO.
What he'll do is have them contribute their fair share.
Ukrainian democracy? You are funnier than Steve Kolbert!
Thanks Jake
Fascinating. Jake is so articulate. Good content.
You are a first class information officer now..
This is amazing
Jake Broe - much much respect!
That was a quick 42 minutes. I can listen to Jake talk about issues around this war all day.
Dominik should invite Jake again.
Fantasy land too bad its all lies
Use common sense russia losing to uckraine that's sounds right to u
@@johnr2111 Yes.
The bots are being drawn to this section like moths to a flame.
😂😂😂 yep
Focus: algorithms either push or block. No one is being drawn except... whoever developed the algorithm?
On a different note, the video reminded me of a great line frome MiB: "Congratulations gentlemen: you're everything we've come to expect from years of government service".
Mm I've seen worse
They are everywhere now on every video. CNN, USA Today, Newsweek...etc I assume they have tripled their operations. TH-cam needs to do something about it.
@@flinch622 No, it looks much more nefarious than some kind of algorithm. Someone is specifically targetting this video with AI chatbots spitting out prompts about this guy and his Laurels in the area of Ukraine, I'm gonna copy paste a few for you:
@jajabez8379
1 day ago
Jake Broe... launched a NAFO fundraiser with a target of $40k for his 40th birthday from his channel (enough for 2 SUVs to be bought and 'battlefield-adapted' in Estonia)... has raised $1,190,047.86 as a result. Absolute rock-star fella, defender of the USA, Ukraine and democracy.
@melissawilliamson8871
1 day ago
Jake Broe is the best Ukraine 🇺🇦 war commentator on TH-cam. He recently raised over $1 million for a charity that provides vehicles for the Ukrainian military 🪖.
@bc-guy852
1 day ago
A BRILLIANT interview and as always, an extremely well-spoken Champion of Ukraine - Jake Broe is a pleasure to listen to. I hold Jake Broe in the same leauge as General Ben Hodges in their opinions and analysis of the Ukraine situation. I hope to one day see Jake Broe as the US Ambassador To Ukraine! (I think your video would get more views if 'Jake Broe' showed in the thumbnail!)
@jeremyallard7015
1 day ago
Jake Broe is a fabulous guest, he speaks from the heart with compassion and common sense. I can't understand why Trump hasn't been Indicted by the Court of Human Rights. The US can't stand Idly by and watch with Risk.
@simondalzell5635
1 day ago
Jake Broe. The most Honest, Intelligent War commentator. No Question.
There's like 6. I think these are obvious bots using AI chat to spit out short prompts on this guy, just read this shit... Like what the fuck man... putting down his exact fundraising number down to the cent? Look at this "dude" referring to him by his full name like 5 times over in the same comment, one of the times it literally puts the his fucking name in quotations. Look at the commenters names and how almost all of them are in the exact same format, full name followed by four numbers... This is a fucking bot farm. This channel has less than 40k subs and this video blew through 200k views, in a day? What's really scary about it is where this dude comes from. His background is a nuclear key-holder? Can you imagine the level of clearance you'd have to have? The kind of scrutiny used in selecting people for that job? He went through all the trouble and then became a fucking youtuber? This is a joke. This dude is a plant and someone has bought and paid for some kind of viewership/glazing farm to prop him up. We're looking at our 3-letter agencies in action here. Absolutely wild.
Very interesting and very informative conversation jake 👍...GOD BLESS YOU FROM THE REPUBLIC OF IRELAND 🇮🇪 🙏
I'm one of Jake's followers and I dare say Jake was wrong about one thing. His followers are inseparable from the Ukraine war -- day in and day out. We can't lose interest because this became a part of us at the onset. Jake may not realize our dedication because he's not with us all for the 12 hours a day we're on it. We've been with each other for over 2 years now, all day long. The Ukraine TH-camrs have created a real community -- a community that continues outside of YT now. Jake is one of our heroes, and he's walked us through this war. Thank you for featuring him in this video. He's a natural at this.
They've also warped his objectivity and now the war has turned into a fantasy where every narrative he supposes has no relation to the empirical battlefield and economic facts. Russia is now the 4th largest economy as of Monday, they're winning, China and Russia are creating their own version of nato, and as much as I want to beat russia, with the current strategy it's not gonna happen
Jake is even more impressive as a guest than as a presenter on his own channel.
hahha ^^ just got here and read your comment. Indeed, my thoughts exactly :)
Not a fan -- has a Rock Degree (Geology) -- why our Government would hire a Donkey like him, is beyond me.
He gets better and better and is less worried about being politically correct than in the past!
@@NightOwlinNewOrleans Yep, that's what I thought too. He isn't afraid to call out the MAGA nutjobs anymore.
Jake "Thanks for bringing" your HOST a American/Ukraine/NATO Military "Reality Check" Jake you are a American Asset.
The Sanity of Jake Broe is Unsurpast !! ❤❤ from ZA 🇿🇦
That Ukraine has performed beyond all expectations only makes sense to me based on one thing: They rightly see Russia as a mortal threat. And if you need some chills along your spine to get you going right now, consider this: If they were seen as such a mortal threat in the beginning of the war, what are they going to be like if they manage to take over? After they've been getting the crap kicked out of them for three or four years, if they end up prevailing, how are they going to behave then? This cannot be allowed to happen. The US electorate, most of all, needs to wake the hell up. The Europeans, less so, as they're closer to the action and presumably have fewer illusions.
My Reagan Republican party has been overrun by MAGA bullies.
Reagan's been the same.
Sad I wish to get back to the same rich people first of the Regan Republicans. At least they lived in some sort of reality. MAGA is a lot more worst.
The sad part is that rank and file "American Values and Integrity" members won't fix their party because they need the: unhinged-burn everything anti (insert whatever makes you donate money) voters.
It's truly a sad irony. The republican party doesn't feel they can win unless they pander to the conspiracy nuts, racist nuts, anarchist nuts, authoritarian nuts, and so on.
And the worst part is, they see Trump pulling in millions and millions from suckers in campaign financing. So with few exceptions, they'll continue their "if you cant beat him, join him" strategy with the next cult leader that can get enough sheep to tip the scale for them.
This, "we need to stick together" bullshit doesn't work when the side you're sticking to is Dictatorship and Greed.
Then, vote blue and help Ukraine.
I'm with you! I hate that my republican party has become a group of unhinged bullies who refuse to look beyond the garbage they are fed. If they did their own research about what is being said they would lose the scales on their eyes.
Jake's TH-cam channel is one of the several that I view for credible updates and commentary on the Ukraine-Russia war. Good interview Dominik. Thumbs up and subscribed.
Nice discussion - Jake is Spot On.. Thanks, gentlemen.. Do this again, when your schedules permit..
As a Cold War veteran who served in the Air Force, l feel for the kiddos who currently serve. I was Security with many 16 hour shifts and I struggled to never fall asleep! I loved Europe and picked up a taste for international metal music from Germany, Norway, Finland, and Germany with bands such as LaCuna Coil, Nightwish
Sergey Mardan, Russian media presenter announced that Russia is a military empire that considers it mission to be the subjugation of neighboring countries. He included China in the list of neighboring countries to be subjugated. It may have been meant for Russian audiences but it went mainstream in China. Clever move.
Russia can't even handle Ukraine - or "take back" Alaska - but it's nice of the Russians to voice what they would do if they could. Good things to know.
Xi Jing must be "ecstatic" after hearing this. 😅
@@arashkhoshghadamnia376 I'm sure he is....NOT
I dont think by my standards i have missed one day of watching this war unfold to the present day, it is important to every country and the world , Dictators need to be frozen out and Jake promotes this narrative . Great work Jake as ever XX
Love Jake’s podcast 👍he’s not an armchair general,he’s to the point and very objective 😊👍
Absolutely right!
Moscow horde´s war record :-
1856 defeated by Britain and France
1905 defeated by Japan
1917 defeated by Germany
1920 defeated by Poland, Finland, Estonia and all Baltic states
1939 defeated by Finland
1969 defeated by China
1989 defeated by Afghanistan
1989 defeated in the Cold War.
1996 defeated by Chechnya
2022 defeated by Ukraine
WW2 won USA/Britain , meanwhile Stalin's officers were shot or sent to the Gulags. Millions went to the Gulags, including Solzhenitsyn
Moscow's only victories come from invading smaller countries :-
a) Hungary 1956
b) Czechoslovakia 1968
c) Moldova 1992
d) Georgia 2008
🤡
A little correction.
1812 won over Napoleon, who took all the Europe before that
1939 won over Finland, took 11% of its land
1945 won over Hitler, who took all the Europe before that
1946 won over Japan, took back Kuril islands
2001 Chechnya is still Russian republic and provides most fierce soldiers to combat Ukraine
2008 won over Georgia, who attacked Russia according to UN investigation results
Dude Russia may lose a battle, may have failed operations but it never lost a war. Russia always comes back. It's unbeatable, face it. Small Ukraine is being gently disarmed just to keep Russia's allies calm and losses minimal possible. Ukraine is in chokehold and Putin will keep strangling until it surrenders. Or dies.
@@user-vr5js6nd3w That Russia is unbeatable is not true, they lost plenty of wars just like everyone else. Russia is very old so obviously they got defeated more than once. But this doesnt mean that Ukraine can win this. Stop being as delusional as these propagandists.
@@user-vr5js6nd3w So what happened 1856, 1905, 1917 and so on? Stop being delusional. No nation is unbeatable, including russia and ukraine.
@@user-vr5js6nd3w A little correction.
1812 won over Napoleon, the only reason Russia won was winter and Napoleon's arrogance assumed the war would end before winter, so the war was won by the forces of nature, not the tsar's armed forces
1939 a battle victory for Finland, Finland literally fought against more than a tenfold superiority alone without the support of foreign countries, and despite that you did not accomplish anything in the war, even the territories Finland lost only in the peace treaty and not by combat operations, on the contrary, the Red Army was considered one of the strongest armies in the world and the result of the war was 126,875 casualties, Losses in Finland 25,904, lol once again mass tactics because you don't know anything else, and despite that you didn't even get territories with combat actions, but the result of a peace agreement, because we didn't get help from foreign countries like Ukraine now, so we had to agree to completely ridiculous conditions the purpose of the war was to conquer all of Finland and subjugate Finland to the Soviet Union, this did not happen but Finland was factually the only country in World War II that the Red Army attacked but could not conquer and Finland maintained its independence,
1945 won over Germany, and the only reason for the victory was the Western invasion and the US land lease program, without which you would have lost the war already in 1941
1946 won over Japan, took back the Kuril islands, so you won Japan, which the USA had already rendered incapable of combat
2001 Chechnya the only reason you won the bloody battle was mass superiority again
2008 Georia, same explanation as in Tsetsenian war
management conclusion, you have not actually won a single war with your own sea tactics, but the only reason for these "victories" has been "mass superiority, as well as the support of other states and simultaneous military actions.. So you haven't won anything,ever the forces of nature have done it for you sometimes, sometimes the actions of the allies have done it, and sometimes just the fact that your mass has brought the other war party to the brink of bankruptcy only and only because you have material and man superiority, equal you cowards don't even dare to go to war against a strong opponent, and even from smaller countries you usually get a bloody nose.. a three-day special operation now going on day number 842.. But in contrast to Finland in the winter war, this time your opponent gets support and Russia literally has not reached even one of your self-declared goals implemented, you haven't even gained control of those oblasts that you already illegally annexed to yourself-. ... So little dear Igor, go to the vodka store Learn historical facts and get used to the fact that in a few months even toilet paper will be worth more than rubles
the whole so-called Russian military success is nothing but self-praise and taking credit for the actions of others and the use of mass superiority and glorified bullshit, well luckily this war is the last because the whole bankrupt country will collapse every single weapon system of yours has been revealed as a mere bs paper tiger, the s-400 systems are literally incapable of countering missiles containing technology from the 70s like older ATACMS.. Your hypersonic missiles which were supposed to be impossible to counter have been countered by the patriot pac1 missile as well. LOL and LOL
Hi Dominik, thank you for doing this excellent interview with Jake. All your questions were spot on, and as always, Jake is extremely well formulated and thoughtfull in his comments about the Ukraine war. A pleasure to watch!
as a former Gropo i heard our allies all say about the same thing, usually something along the lines of. the U.S. soldier is more than trustworthy and reliable in a fight. your political leaders not so much.
Will not vote for trump this time around . Ukraine has every right to remain Ukraine . Nato needs to be there to protect Europe .
Thank you from a Brit. I'm terrified that he'll get in.
Thank you from Australia, and pls take a mate or 5 with you when you go 👍🥳
Democracy over Autocracy, watching from afar is terrifying
Cheers 🍻
Totally agree with you. Trump is insane!! The expansion of Russia is putting in danger almost every country!!
@@its_Today_Agreed. Terrifying. As an Australian I'm disguised with our government and our military.
@@olatron And yet you are not terrified of what's getting in across the channel every day?
So important, this message
iv been watching jake for over a year hes a top guy and very inteligant
Thank you we appreciate you taking the opportunity to chat with Jake on his insights and thoughts, Jake has a wealth of information and his followers continue to grow as many are interested in his knowledge and work. We are seeing the battle of dark and light playing out around our planet🌍 today and with this the evil that some dictators are willing to use and putin being one while needing the darker energies of other such dictators to support him in his dark war in Ukraine. When people finally realise they all have an Internal Power within that isn’t dictated to out of fear and control from others, they can use their own power to walk in their own inner strength and find their own inner peace that doesn’t want Wars, Evil, Corrupted Dictators or Greed to run your nations. The likes of putin and trump show us we clearly don’t want these greedy and very corrupted bullies to ever be the voices for nations, they are lost to their darkness that belong to the past, putin and his criminal gang are dragging the Russian nation/people down a very dark path that will take centuries to recover if ever!!! Stand against the dark and evil energies and Shine your own light over this evil darkness and NEVER vote for trump, he is nothing more than a loud mouth bully and puppet to the darkness he hides in.
Man, such a great interview. Jake Broe is so competent, educated, experienced in what he talks about.
Jake is great other than his TDS.
@@ThorIsBoss People believing and supporting a rich, orange liar with a deep narcissistic personality disorder, and simply ignoring this fact about him are the ones with Trump Derangement Syndrom.
You Trump-zombies have the habit of pointing the finger at others and blaming them for anything/everything, but you never look inwards... into yourself and ask yourself... what the fuck am I believing? How did I get here?
He has his head up his ass
Looks like he's a comic as is Zelensky 😂
@@erikt.9422 How's the cult today?
Best summary statements on the subject I've heard so far. Right to the point.
Your sarcasm is outstanding
@@mikejess04 How will you buy potatoes and vodka in the future, when the value of the ruble starts to be worth toilet paper?
@@Finnishguy777 yawn, come up with another idiotic insult. nafo have been spewing that nonsense since 2022.
@@mikejess04 well, this nonsense was already close to reality two nights ago when the value of the ruble was even 2c more than the cheapest toilet in Russia, look when you can follow the exchange rate of the ruble on the internet, you don't need to invent lies when the facts are available dear Ivan. and you yourself have been talking same BS about this three-day special operation for 842 days now, so it's been quite a long three-day war, you've also been cheering on Ukraine's defeat after every little battle you've won, how has it gone, do you think Ukraine has surrendered 😅 And idiots like you have have been spewing that Ukraine is done for nonsense since 2022. 3 days operation has lastet 842 days lol apparently it is a completely unknown fact to you that the exchange rates and value of currencies of different countries can be followed almost in real time, you're also hard at blaming others for strokes even though every single comment you've made has been repeating the same bs, besides that, you know how to throw emoticons like my 6-year-old daughter, with the difference that my 6-year-old daughter can justify her position more thoroughly and with more facts than you will ever be able to, but I think I'm giving you too much credit, in reality even cats and dogs get more facts than you
@@mikejess04now you know how everyone else feels about Russia’s stupid shovel jokes.
Political system in the US is just so obsolete! How can you let all that power in the hands of a single man?
No president can unilaterally end the US commitment to NATO. If he had the power to do it, he would have done it when he was in office. Thanks for your service, I spent over 30 years in the AF. I have over 10,000 flying hours on the C-5.
Funny, Americans LOVE LOVE LOVE to point out how they are Irish, English, German, Dutch, Austrian, Italian, what have you. How they are European! And then they are willing to agree with Trumputin abandoning NATO and leaving Europe to Russia (they wish)? How Irish, English, German, Dutch, Austrian and Italian are they then??
Well said. It’s time Trump was no longer with us!
Great point!
Well, they suddenly would say their cowboys and gold diggers/miners were Russian. Although I won't be surprised that the people who are serious about their cultural identity aren't part of the Trump cult.
It is also funny to point out in this context how embarrassed most people here in Germany are when they are reminded that Trump has German ancestors, so they find it somewhat of a relief that at least the other guy we feel ashamed of was actually Austrian.
You cannot lump 330M people together and claim they support any political party or leader. There are bitter divisions in the USA and even within the Republican Party.
And, sadly, the average US citizen is very poorly educated about anything beyond their own borders. I believe the statistic is that fewer than half even have a passport. The USA is the only superpower and the centre of modern culture. Their population is generally disinterested - compared to other modern democracies - in events happening beyond their own borders.
Thank you Jake love your content and love your channel ❤ Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦
Someone can look smart and get delusional at the same time.
Excellent interview.
Excellent insights.
Best quote: "Russia starts using nukes there's no reason to keep him [Vladolf Pitler] alive anymore - that's a cleanup scenario that we're trying to avoid"
Excellent interview, Jake is fantastic to listen to, he should definitely be influential in US politics.
Thanks for the update and views 🇺🇲🇺🇦
Oklahoma USA 🇺🇦🇺🇲
Excellent Interview. Good job in setting up the questions for Jake. His knowledge and common sense are invaluable.
ORANGE MAN BAD
@@bencoldwell4609 I mean, yes? Saying that a convicted felon is not a good choice for president is an easy thing to say, even before you get into the sedition and 100k dead due to incompetence and lies. But that was only a small part of the discussion.
@@bencoldwell4609 You can read the blueprint for Trump's re-election created by Republicans that they call 'Project 2025' and if you don't think it's a recipe for a fascist coup from within (based on how close Jan 6th was to succeeding) you're either a supporter of the project or you've drunk the koolaid.
@@bencoldwell4609 Yep, Jake drinkin da Koolaide.
Scott Aiden- All The Crew Lived 😂
Actually, in the next church service in my Catholic church,we will be praying for ALL the victims in Ukraine
From Nepal, Africa, Asia, Ukraine and Russia
I watch you everyday. You are very informative and I my resolve in support of Ukraine will never waiver. Slava Ukraine!!
Jake Broe. The most Honest, Intelligent War commentator. No Question.
bot?
Jake Broe is a fabulous guest, he speaks from the heart with compassion and common sense. I can't understand why Trump hasn't been Indicted by the Court of Human Rights. The US can't stand Idly by and watch with Risk.
Agree, We should be indiciting for dangerous thought crimes ASAP.
Even if He didn't say it and smarter people in charge say he did.
@@simonebest6013 I agree Simone, Trump & Co in my opinion aided and abetted Putin by holding up Military Aid to Ukraine, Does he have Blood on his hands?
bot?
I truly thank you all for such an in depth discussion & all the important information shared,, It definitely helps us all to have a more full/total understanding.
Great guest and very interesting conversation, thank you both 👍
I love Jake’s podcasts!
Trump is like a second Caligula totaly unpredictable💙💛💪👍
Yes DT is Captain bone spurs. He's got no business being commander in chief. He never was in the army. Thank you 💛
It's truly perplexing to see a faction of MAGA Republicans, many of whom lived through the Cold War, now showing support for Russia and opposing Ukraine. During the Cold War, Russia represented ideologies and governance that starkly contrasted with American values. This shift in perspective seems to align more with support for authoritarian figures rather than democratic principles.
Jake, your video sheds light on this puzzling phenomenon. It raises critical questions about how and why these individuals have gravitated towards supporting dictatorships, seemingly abandoning the democratic ideals that the U.S. stands for. This change in allegiance is concerning and warrants deeper reflection on the influences and motivations behind it.
Thank you for your insightful analysis and for prompting these important discussions.
The support for Russia and Putin, while remaining bellicose against China and Xi, is very perplexing. Logic has left the debate.
They are showing support for Russia and opposing Ukraine. Because they use the internet to RESEARCH STUFF......
Try using the internet for more than Fakebook Twits and INSTApersonalGRAMification... You have the largest Library in the world in the palm of your hand... USE IT.. research "something.." anything for that matter... We have entered into the biggest economic and social collapse in recorded History... and you are going to get caught with no Oil in your lamp.... now get to it.. research research research... I cannot help you any further.
Well, now Russia represents what are core American values and current US government represents communist values
It’s the idea of America meddling in the politics of the governments of Ukraine and Georgia that has Russia saying no to the extent that Russia has to step in to keep America from encroaching on its border with the intention of taking on the status of Russia. As an American I think America is messing with Russia because of BRICS and their idea of floating their own currency and putting Americas almighty dollar in jeopardy. You saw what happened to Qaddafi when he tried to float his currency.
@@tsubadaikhan6332 Yes still they hate "Communism". It is really just dumb cult people repeating what their dear orange leader says.. No matter how insane it is.
Spot on Jake.
Jake is a good guest too! Thanks for this interview (Y)
Historical facts, Rus, Russia, Sviet Union and Russian Federation lost many wors in th past and recent century. B) Russian society is suffering from "Slavery Gen" it's been proven, they feen much betetr and secure being slaves, without any initiative, freedom movement, oppostion llike in developed countries, or even historically (220 years of Mongolian occupation od Rus) it changed totally the way Russia ios ruled, and managed politically. The title of Tsar comes from Ghan.
Thank you for your awesome reporting! Glory to Ukraine 🇺🇦.
Jake are the real deal👍
Thanks Dominik
Fascinating discussion many thanks. Keep up the good work both of you 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Jake has the most sober view on the situation and do a fantastic job trying to connect the dots. Inspiring talk/interview. Keep up the good work!
Always good to hear from Jake
Scott Aiden -All The Crew Lived 😂😂🤣🤣
The real geopolitical questions are what happens when Russia collapses?
* Specifically, what happens when Russia collapses with a Biden administration leading the USA?
* and what happens when Russia collapses with a Trump or Trump-like administration leading the USA?
* how will Hungary, Slovakia, and Turkey react to a Russian collapse?
* how will China react to a Russian collapse?
I love your videos I'm 50 Russian and 40 Slavic and 10 percent swedish
My parents fled the former Yugoslavia and Stalin and I ended up in the USA orphanages when Catholic Charities took me out of a refugee camp in nurnberg Germany to save My life. It took me 30 years to finally find out some information and found a brother and sister that I spent a month with. I've studied so much history but it is my feelings and love for were I actually come from Don't ask me why
I've had such strong feelings for Ukraine and it's people. If I was young I would be there and live in Europe but I raised 5 sons alone which took so much time and energy so My dreams are just that I love the people of Ukraine and I am on their side but my son's grandchildren and great grandchildren are here and I must fight for the family I was able to make and my brother and sister have died. So yes the fight continues but thank you so much because I always keep a eye on Ukraine and send my love to them
I follow Jake Broe everywhere he goes… whatever channel he’s talking on, such an amazingperson. Yeah I guess you could say I’m a fan boy, but I was watching his channel when he was doing financial analysis.
Jake runs the most competent, credible, mature, and intellectually honest Ukraine news channel on TH-cam. No BS, no political tribalism, and nothing but truth.
Pssttt! Are you his brother?
@SuiGenerisMan I like Jake and was watching his videos before the Ukraine war when he did finance videos. But how can you say no political tribalism? Hard to find videos where he does not go off on Trump and Republicans, Just look at this clip. He says Trump can't form a complete sentence but not a word about Biden who REALLY can't complete a sentence and is senile.
@@ThorIsBosssure Biden is old but Trump is a dictator. It’s a very easy choice. I’m a republican btw. Donald Trump and MAGA are not republicans no matter what Fox News says. Joe Biden is expotentially closer to Reagan than Trump will ever be or has ever been.
Yes, he's excellent. Denys Davidov is Ukrainian Pilot, provides first class info daily.
@@marioformosa4259putler supporter🤮
Thank you for your service.
Just heard the first lines so far, I just hope that Americans are not so stupid as to elect him .
Tragically, US politics is global geopolitics... the tragedy is that puts the fate of people all over the world in the hands of corrupt US politicians elected by a largely uninterested small pool of America citizen voters who have been chosen by the very politicians running for office. Yes there are pockets of absolute brilliance in the USA, but the system was designed in the 18th century to dodge real democracy and give too much power to slave-holders (who don't have slaves anymore, but the same group of wealthy white men continue to have way more power than their voting base and demographic would legitimately give them).
Jake is absolutely correct though, Trump will, as a VATNIK do what Putin wants; and it does not matter, Ukraine will still defeat Russia regardless of who wins the US election. It is just a matter of time; quicker if a Russian agent does not win, slower if a Russian agent does win.
Russia's victories have to include manipulating US and UK elections via misinformation and social media (Brexit, 2016 US election). Since 2014 Russia has been waging a soft war on the West very effectively and we are only catching on now.
Russia's losses are about to include the 2014 and now 2022 invasions of Ukraine, as they are about to run out of tanks, armored vehicles, air craft (through maintenance failures as much as being shot down), and their economy is about to collapse.
You literally ignored the fact the system was designed to adapt to the times, the constitution is allowed to be amended. The original system no longer exist, you don't have to be a landowning man to vote. Americans currently do not care enough to change the electoral system and benefits of the current electoral system where states retain a good deal of power under a federated system outweighs the negatives. You obviously have an agenda and is blinded by it.
I am from europe, i am dayly waiting for more positive support to ua always. They have to win, or democracy loses. It is nr1 on our mind.