War was declared after the events of October 7th. No War was active prior in the region. Words have meanings. English isn't just something you copy and paste on youtube.
He has had constant success for the last 10 months. He’s complicit. His words are weapons to stall any rescuers from intervening on behalf of Palestinians.
@@tellitlikeitis5856 ? I just find it fascinating that IL, treaties, peace agreements are torn up easily along with blatant lying. Whenever these things happen on this scale we have massive wars.
Its an attempt to fatigue the viewers, we're just going to stop looking at need about gaza because of this circus, the atrocities that are committed goes under the radar
Blinken is not a good man. But his hearing in congress has shown, the republican officers and officials are in part right wing israel supporters no matter what. Bliinken had to defend himself not delivering weapons in the time of the rafah offensive. They called it an undetermination of israel support, what is rediculous. Now of course in order to concentrate on the north and iran the US gave the money under blinken. why does he want to finish the deal now? blinkekn is scared of bibi, that could bring the us into conflict with the whole region. But bibi is not mooving. He keeps bitching around puting more obstacles into the deal, even though he is the one in front of the icc and icj. He did the same war crimes as hamas in october 7th, thats a proven fact. only the us can rescue him and thats why he maybe could give in for a deal thats even worse for him and his perpertrators. Hamas will never agress as long as bibi wont give up. I guess bibi is hoping iran will attack so the us have to interfear, whats insane taktik.
@@AmonTheWitch No from the area that the Israel Administration has announced publicly again and again plane to commit Ethnic Cleansing on the basis of "An apartheid state can defend itself" from the people it is subjugating while broadcasting the brutality against children's and the r* of kidnapped men.
First of all ...Hamas is a terrorist organization & I think doesn't represent the whole population of Palestine !!! Secondly : methodically managed to dig& build tunnels deep underground which no bather the attacks , but are the commun people that are miserable & suffered as a result of the bombings !!! Mr.Bliken proposed peace talks & I think that Israel will go ahead with that approach !!! Let's hope so !!!
There was a time when DW called on the expertise of Israeli analyst Mairav Zonszein. Here is her assessment (19 Aug 2024): "The Gaza ceasefire talks are akin to the (long extinct) negotiations for a two state solution: A facade of Israeli intention towards a certain goal through a protracted process that provides it with time to continue determining facts on ground while enjoying benefit of the doubt."
These are outright lies Already ceasefire terms are there now he says something about bridging proposal without knowing the terms of bridging proposal and announced it as Israel accepted so why teams are negotiating in Qatar
What is the so-called "Bridging proposal" that Blinken says Netanyahu accepted? They are keeping that a secret. So, Hamas is supposed to accept the proposal. Okay. How long are they going to keep from the American voters what the bridging proposal is so we can judge its efficacy and fairness? Until we know what the "bridging proposal" is, we don't know anything about this round of talks.
You are a special kind of wild if you think the American voters gets to have an opinion on what Israel and Gaza/Hamas decide what peace looks like. Get over yourself buddy.
@@burns281981 No. We get to have a say where our Billions of Dollars go and where our military assets go. If Israel wants to play Wyatt Erp of the Middle East, they can damn well do it without our money and our aircraft carrier groups! Israel is not entitled to America's treasury.
2:34 - Does she not question which side is not negotiating ? The United States has nothing to gain by pursuing peace, feeding the population, starting negotiations, and building a freaking harbor to get aid in, and yet that's exactly what the US has done
Gerald Feierstein should read the Quran then reconsider his enthusiasm for "an independent Palestinian state" near Israel. Perhaps Alaska would be a good alternative for a Palestinian state.
Why are the palestinians not asked why they support hamas? Or why they allow hamas to operate among the civilian population? Obvious questions being deliberately avoided by your reporters.
Before they had PLA but israel killed PLA leadership after Oslo accord because they were very close to peaceful settlement then they created hamas and funded it to make confusion around the world and halted the peace process. Remember that Original sin is Occupation once it will be free there will be peace and it will happen very soon.
well if you look into the history you would quickly realize why, after hamas' coup of the coalition there was only Israel, who kidnapped/killed your family members without trial or reason or Hamas, who claims to want to free them. not such a hard choice to make, you should ask yourself why any Palestinian would have a positive view of Israel when the leading party doesn't want them to exist
Crazy to see the view of ppl in Gaza.. blaming USA.. no accountability. No laming of Hamas that has rejected evry proposal.. total ignorance.. and victims of their own mentality.
@nenasiek no.. they don't.. polls show how ignorant ppl in Gaza are. And palastina are highly in favour for Hamas.. again victims of their mentality.. sadly they pay the heaviest price..
The amount of stupidity in the commets is astounding When i am at it u do understand that blinken managed a still lasting support agreement between most UEA, egypt, saudis and more with israel sth thought of impossible
Amrica never ever want cesfire ,because their economy totly stands to sell weapons in world ,when there is much more disturbence n the the it economy will go up & up
Just because Israel now accepts it with the bridging difference, there are questions to be had. Why the sudden change in heart? What were the changes made? What are the penalties if one side breaks the agreement and who will enforce it? I'm pretty sure the US will be happy to enforce it against Hamas, but will they also enforce it against Israel if Israel breaks the agreement?
Well ya, Palestine should stay in power and isreal occupation forces should go to their countries of actual origin as defined by their primary passports.
So, for all the people wanting a cease fire - are you angry with Hamas for delaying this? Hamas has no changing of "winning" this conflict. The best they can hope for is that Israel suddenly stops the conflict. Why do Hamas continue, if they supposedly care about their own people?( Which they don't)
Wow you think the world is fool it's like you kill my dad and than say let's have a peace agreement. Let me take my revenge than we will talk about peace
Jewe playing a Jewe. They'll do whatever they want as they've already demonstrated. I think they want all of Gaza for themselves; to be developed into a paradise.
Crusade war is never over yet. Only forms & battlefields change. USA sales Democracies platform to the state but wouldn't give strategic autonomy. 😂😅 what an irony.
can one really trust natinyaho he seems to let people down every single time hamas have said they are willing to sit down to talk then natinyaho starts bombing every one the man need mental health help.
@@nenasiek I think it was fairly obvious from my comment that I was referring to an interview seeking an expert opinion from a Palestinian analyst/commentator akin to that sought from Gerald Feierstein and Michael Singh over nearly 9 minutes of this 12 minute clip. But perhaps DW is offering us its version of "balance" with this vox pop of two Palestinians in fear of their lives. Is the generous granting of 50 seconds of air-time (without extending them the courtesy of even being named) considered adequate representation by DW? The point is that on the rare occasions when Palestinian commentators are on DW, the report is either spiked or they are treated with condescending hostility by DW "journalists". Here, I'm think of interviews with Ali Abunimah, Yara Hawari and Noura Erekat to name but three. You might want to look those cases up.
Problem is Hamas is to hand over hostages and stop fighting back, but idf gets to continue on finish their current actions. Thats not much of a cease fire.
Thank You President Biden for continuing to work for a ceasefire, and after Harris is elected, she can carry on the effort to secure a Palestinian state.
@@NicolasHaufe Exactly the point. No one can occupy someone else's land. The U.S didn't occupy Japan for 70 years and Japan didn't occupy the U.S fpr 70 years.. No idea what you're even talking about. Same rules for all.
It's dangerous to rock a mustache these days, but Gerald, senior Middle East fellow, is really pushing everyone's girls out here to stay loyal with that old muff duster
The beginning of the video: "Israel has ACCEPTED....Israel REFUSED..." etc. endless repetition
Why did she say the war started on Oct 7th? So no one was fighting before that?
This war started on oct 7th the us was firing at uboats already 1940 but that doesnt mean the us was at war
War was declared after the events of October 7th. No War was active prior in the region.
Words have meanings. English isn't just something you copy and paste on youtube.
Oct 7 was the proximate cause of the war. Hamas miscalculated thus it is to be blamed. Conflicts are won and lost and history is rewritten.
We all know it's all for show. Know the US has not done all that it can.
All the US has to do is stop sending Israel money.
We want the details of the plan. Otherwise I doubt...
Blinken never succeeds. He is a waste of time.
Watch Netinartu renigg on the deal
He has had constant success for the last 10 months. He’s complicit. His words are weapons to stall any rescuers from intervening on behalf of Palestinians.
Blinken never succeeds because he is complicit.
Why not play the part where he is directly & bluntly asked what the changes are and he chokes up.
How do u know that? Did he say that, are u working behind the scenes?
You angry coz Akbar is a joke
@@tellitlikeitis5856 ? I just find it fascinating that IL, treaties, peace agreements are torn up easily along with blatant lying. Whenever these things happen on this scale we have massive wars.
@@KashifKhanZa Islam is the problem
@@tellitlikeitis5856 that’s a bigoted response.
Trying the same thing again and again, expecting different results.
Its an attempt to fatigue the viewers, we're just going to stop looking at need about gaza because of this circus, the atrocities that are committed goes under the radar
This a show before elections
Blinken is not a good man. But his hearing in congress has shown, the republican officers and officials are in part right wing israel supporters no matter what. Bliinken had to defend himself not delivering weapons in the time of the rafah offensive. They called it an undetermination of israel support, what is rediculous. Now of course in order to concentrate on the north and iran the US gave the money under blinken. why does he want to finish the deal now? blinkekn is scared of bibi, that could bring the us into conflict with the whole region. But bibi is not mooving. He keeps bitching around puting more obstacles into the deal, even though he is the one in front of the icc and icj. He did the same war crimes as hamas in october 7th, thats a proven fact. only the us can rescue him and thats why he maybe could give in for a deal thats even worse for him and his perpertrators. Hamas will never agress as long as bibi wont give up. I guess bibi is hoping iran will attack so the us have to interfear, whats insane taktik.
Israel accepts the US plan, while the US accepts the Israeli plan. Hamas isnt taking part in negotiation though.
I heard that actually they can not pull out from Gaza because of having to defend the area and the Gazans will not take care of themselves...
Because they killed the negotiator of Hamas.
@@IsaHaPeace having to defend the area from what? the civilians they knowingly use as human shields?
@@AmonTheWitch No from the area that the Israel Administration has announced publicly again and again plane to commit Ethnic Cleansing on the basis of "An apartheid state can defend itself" from the people it is subjugating while broadcasting the brutality against children's and the r* of kidnapped men.
Blinken is a liar. Hamas accepted the deal weeks ago. Israel added more conditions, with Blinken's blessing.
This guy has said the same several times and he's untrustworthy now
First of all ...Hamas is a terrorist organization & I think doesn't represent the whole population of Palestine !!! Secondly : methodically managed to dig& build tunnels deep underground which no bather the attacks , but are the commun people that are miserable & suffered as a result of the bombings !!! Mr.Bliken proposed peace talks & I think that Israel will go ahead with that approach !!! Let's hope so !!!
There was a time when DW called on the expertise of Israeli analyst Mairav Zonszein. Here is her assessment (19 Aug 2024):
"The Gaza ceasefire talks are akin to the (long extinct) negotiations for a two state solution: A facade of Israeli intention towards a certain goal through a protracted process that provides it with time to continue determining facts on ground while enjoying benefit of the doubt."
You can't negotiate with war criminals.
😛😛😛😛😛😛 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Which ones?
@@burns281981 Hamas and Gaza voters who voted terrorism
Exactly, we can't trust Israel.
No, but Israel wants the hostages they are holding so there’s not much choice.
*Blinken travel around the world. but, nothing gets done. like USA congress, only talks BLA BLA 😅*
War criminals
These are outright lies
Already ceasefire terms are there now he says something about bridging proposal without knowing the terms of bridging proposal and announced it as Israel accepted so why teams are negotiating in Qatar
Blinken robot of Iseral government
He cant stop lying to himself and to the whole world... what a bunch of BS
What is the so-called "Bridging proposal" that Blinken says Netanyahu accepted? They are keeping that a secret. So, Hamas is supposed to accept the proposal. Okay. How long are they going to keep from the American voters what the bridging proposal is so we can judge its efficacy and fairness? Until we know what the "bridging proposal" is, we don't know anything about this round of talks.
You don't have to guess much. It's probably the one where they can continue the war after the first phase of hostage release.
bridging means no instant failure at negotatiation
You are a special kind of wild if you think the American voters gets to have an opinion on what Israel and Gaza/Hamas decide what peace looks like.
Get over yourself buddy.
@@burns281981 No. We get to have a say where our Billions of Dollars go and where our military assets go. If Israel wants to play Wyatt Erp of the Middle East, they can damn well do it without our money and our aircraft carrier groups! Israel is not entitled to America's treasury.
@@burns281981 well they don't get to decide because us is simply not a democracy. Quite simple
Go to gaza and see how people and children suffer😭😭😭😭😭😭
Fight and win or lose one side should surrender. That is already a war started on 7th October with no rules no negotiations.
2:34 - Does she not question which side is not negotiating ? The United States has nothing to gain by pursuing peace, feeding the population, starting negotiations, and building a freaking harbor to get aid in, and yet that's exactly what the US has done
Blinken must be the most ineffective US Secretary of State in living memory.
Your comment implies that Blinken pursues his publically stated goals, which is not always the case
Who was your favourite and why?
Blinken is a liar.
@@oasisneko1 name one of his lies. The bots really need to learn that statements aren't worth much.
So.... is this a religious war?
If Netanyahu is ousted , it will be an easier struggle for US government. Or else, the world doubts......????!!!
How many more people will have to die
Wht happened to the previous proposal wic he said was an Israel proposal and Natanyahu rejected it,..Blinken is jst an Israel PA....
Gerald Feierstein should read the Quran then reconsider his enthusiasm for "an independent Palestinian state" near Israel. Perhaps Alaska would be a good alternative for a Palestinian state.
Or for Israel? Since they are the ones invading.
I've read the Qur'an so what utter BS complete
It’s an impossible task because he thinks they are tired of war. Do they seem like they are tired of war?
8:06 wtf is cutter, do you mean Qatar?!🙂↔️🚶🏽♀️
Accept the deal which for sure not going to be accepted by both sides and pat yourself on back is quite a talent.
Why are the palestinians not asked why they support hamas? Or why they allow hamas to operate among the civilian population? Obvious questions being deliberately avoided by your reporters.
Before they had PLA but israel killed PLA leadership after Oslo accord because they were very close to peaceful settlement then they created hamas and funded it to make confusion around the world and halted the peace process.
Remember that Original sin is Occupation once it will be free there will be peace and it will happen very soon.
well if you look into the history you would quickly realize why, after hamas' coup of the coalition there was only Israel, who kidnapped/killed your family members without trial or reason or Hamas, who claims to want to free them.
not such a hard choice to make, you should ask yourself why any Palestinian would have a positive view of Israel when the leading party doesn't want them to exist
@@AmonTheWitchexactly
He is collecting his cash there only.
Blinken want hamas to sign the peace deal which says hamas will be completeley eleminated after the deal.😅
Crazy to see the view of ppl in Gaza.. blaming USA.. no accountability. No laming of Hamas that has rejected evry proposal.. total ignorance.. and victims of their own mentality.
Hamas accepted a US proposal in May and Israel changed the terms of the deal afterwards.
The majority of gazans dont want hamas anymore..
@nenasiek no.. they don't.. polls show how ignorant ppl in Gaza are. And palastina are highly in favour for Hamas.. again victims of their mentality.. sadly they pay the heaviest price..
The truth is not in Blinken.
Short lived!
Never happen
A bunch of lies !!!
Does anyone ask the Palestinians how they feel about Hamas? Why isn’t always the responsibility of the US to bring about a deal
DW stop being bias, you know exactly what is happening in gaza
After 40k + innocent lives, can't trust perpetrators.
@@zw9802 Yes, defenseless children and women.
All started 76yrs ago...
The amount of stupidity in the commets is astounding
When i am at it u do understand that blinken managed a still lasting support agreement between most UEA, egypt, saudis and more with israel sth thought of impossible
Amrica never ever want cesfire ,because their economy totly stands to sell weapons in world ,when there is much more disturbence n the the it economy will go up & up
Just because Israel now accepts it with the bridging difference, there are questions to be had. Why the sudden change in heart? What were the changes made? What are the penalties if one side breaks the agreement and who will enforce it? I'm pretty sure the US will be happy to enforce it against Hamas, but will they also enforce it against Israel if Israel breaks the agreement?
It's been years NW Palestine can't be over thrown
After the agreement the war in Gaza shifted to the border with Lebanon and to the Golan resuming the original conflict.
Blinkken is bullshirter, Period
Watch Netinartu pull out of the deal
Blinken = incompetence
This is a sham ..free Palestine 🇵🇸
They were free what's your problem
Lies Lies Lies 😴 😒
Well ya, Palestine should stay in power and isreal occupation forces should go to their countries of actual origin as defined by their primary passports.
Who are hostages? The Gazans or people in West Bank? Or the captured on both sides?
So confusing to me.
He was spreading petrol on the fire of the gaza. And behaving as a peace kipper.
So, for all the people wanting a cease fire - are you angry with Hamas for delaying this? Hamas has no changing of "winning" this conflict. The best they can hope for is that Israel suddenly stops the conflict. Why do Hamas continue, if they supposedly care about their own people?( Which they don't)
Wow you think the world is fool it's like you kill my dad and than say let's have a peace agreement. Let me take my revenge than we will talk about peace
Blinken is a head of Criminal
Will Hammas hold up there end
What is sign/symbol of life 🤔
Jewe playing a Jewe. They'll do whatever they want as they've already demonstrated. I think they want all of Gaza for themselves; to be developed into a paradise.
Crusade war is never over yet. Only forms & battlefields change. USA sales Democracies platform to the state but wouldn't give strategic autonomy. 😂😅 what an irony.
can one really trust natinyaho he seems to let people down every single time hamas have said they are willing to sit down to talk then natinyaho starts bombing every one the man need mental health help.
2 peas in a pod
DW says "We spoke to Gerald Feierstein and Michael Singh".
Just as a matter of interest Deutsche Welle, when did you last speak to a Palestinian?
It was in the start of the vid, civilians talking to a camera crew.
@@nenasiek I think it was fairly obvious from my comment that I was referring to an interview seeking an expert opinion from a Palestinian analyst/commentator akin to that sought from Gerald Feierstein and Michael Singh over nearly 9 minutes of this 12 minute clip.
But perhaps DW is offering us its version of "balance" with this vox pop of two Palestinians in fear of their lives. Is the generous granting of 50 seconds of air-time (without extending them the courtesy of even being named) considered adequate representation by DW?
The point is that on the rare occasions when Palestinian commentators are on DW, the report is either spiked or they are treated with condescending hostility by DW "journalists". Here, I'm think of interviews with Ali Abunimah, Yara Hawari and Noura Erekat to name but three. You might want to look those cases up.
Blinken is liar
Prayers for Israel 🇮🇱 from Ireland 🇮🇪. ❤❤
Trust Shylocks? Don't be fooled by what they say.
The sticking point is that after Israel got their hostages back they will resume the war and will have control Philadelphia and Netzarim corridors
Fanatics on both sides!
2 Face America
La c u soon
Bots are all over your comments. I’m all for Palestine and Americans are hoping for a peace plan.
LIAR!
🙏🕍📯🖖🙌🤲👍
最新のホラー映画：イスラエルの兵士がアメリカの武器でアラブの女性と子供を殺害するイベント
TINA LOUISE BOOK SUNDAY IN GERM A NY
Free palestine inconditianal
Problem is Hamas is to hand over hostages and stop fighting back, but idf gets to continue on finish their current actions. Thats not much of a cease fire.
Any deal that leaves Hamas in power over Gaza once the hostages are released will Never be acceptable to Israel after Oct 07th.
Iran wants to blame others for colonizing while they colonize.
despite the other comments, thanks DW for covering this -- US media has lost its way since that orange thing came along
Blinken lier we know who holds his leash.
Perez Susan Hernandez Angela Robinson Lisa
Thank You President Biden for continuing to work for a ceasefire, and after Harris is elected, she can carry on the effort to secure a Palestinian state.
Criminals
😂😂😂😂
Can Hamas have troops in Israels land too or different rules for different races eh..?
Hamas is the colonizer just like hezbollah in Lebanon.
thats Like saying the us should let the Japanese occupy them during ww2 🤦
@@NicolasHaufe Exactly the point. No one can occupy someone else's land. The U.S didn't occupy Japan for 70 years and Japan didn't occupy the U.S fpr 70 years.. No idea what you're even talking about. Same rules for all.
@@jonny5714 weird that an occupied place Had 3000 Rockets dont you think?
😏😭😫
It's dangerous to rock a mustache these days, but Gerald, senior Middle East fellow, is really pushing everyone's girls out here to stay loyal with that old muff duster
😂😂😂😂😂 what is written in proposal ??
Blinken is a very worthless diplomat.
We don't think he will succeed to end the war in Gaza.