Well I Had a Chicken omlette for breakfast which kind of nullifies that point BUT the first smell to come out was definitly egg.......so you still right :)
That is the most unique, and overall the best answer, I have heard XD It was so funny my laughing was making it difficult to tell this to someone else XD
I really hope that it is NOT the case, but your Grandma might be suffering from Dementia or some neurological condition brought on by aging...Please take her to see a professional to be checked out... Good karma unto you and all your loved ones...
Apps came first, remember having phones(not smartphones) and when technology and internet was not developed like it nowadays but you had a calculater app and certain games inbuilt?
Its the app store because of the whole old phone thing and that the app store is an app so yeah. Its apps. The app store is just an app that gives more apps.
Hello everybody! Check out this video on importance of education : th-cam.com/video/bL4GNEcRX-8/w-d-xo.html Sorry for the self promotion but hey, can't blame me right?
it always comes down to the organisms coming before their parts, the egg is part of the chicken so it's like asking which came first your shit or you, you need you first before you can shit!
Well, me, Frodo Baggins existed before _I_ was born, but things were born before I existed, and there were egg laying species, that at one point, gave birth instead of laying an egg, so in that scenario, if I were the said Birthee, then I would have existed before birth.
Hello guys I appreciate your work ,,, But I have a question that according to you guys egg came first but the egg can only continue the process of making body of chick by a process called hatching if egg came first then there is no one hatch egg ......if I am wrong pls correct me
Close. The mutations that put it "over the edge" actually happened before the egg was ever laid. But the mutations didn't make the chick till after the egg was laid since hens don't carry their young inside them like humans do. They spit them out as fast as possible. Sometimes in a single day.
***** Sorry, the bible never says God created all the animals alive today in the beginning. Nor does it say ANYTHING for or against existing species being able to change. Truth is the Bible doesn't say anything that contradicts sciences version of how we, and the other species got here. You would know this if you had taken the time to read the Bible instead of listening to what others told you it all meant. BTW, I do believe in God, but I have also read the entire Bible, multiple times, for myself. And I can tell you science and the Bible do NOT contradict each other at all.
I was looking through the comments section when I realized that people took a video about the old idea of "Which came first, the chicken or the egg?" and turned it into a religious debate in which everyone spews nonsense about things they know hardly anything about. I'm quite glad for the new comments system. Those petty, ignorant arguments get confined in their own little worlds, arguing to their heart's content.
Randies John chapter 2 is the story of Jesus turning 6 stone containers full of water into 6 stone containers full of wine. Then google, 'how much water to make wine', Huffington Post entry, Oct. 13, 2004.
Did you know that Pastafa, the flying spaghetti monster will dip you in a boiling water if you will believe in jesus? Pastafa is the one true god the mighty of all mighty! The flying spaghetti monster. Now prove that the flying spaghetti monster isn't real if you can then you could also prove your god to be real right? I only need 1 evidence that he existed or the miracle of jesus about turning those waters to wine was true
no, now you have the right answer here: Y, thinks about this way. All mothers know how to take care of their young. However, you may be surprised at how much knowledge and care is required to hatch an egg. The right humidity, temperature, and turning at the correct angle - every 3 hours - are all critical to egg care. Not to mention that there are two threads holding the yolk in the middle of the egg white (to keep the yolk in the middle of the egg white). How did it come to be and why are they able to do it? The eggs without mom's hatching is impossible to Now you can buy automatic hatching machines, because people have discovered the chicken's secrets through scientific studies. If scientific studies can help us to get knowledge, then there's no doubt there is “wisdom” in your genes which instruct creatures on when to grow what and even the season, direction, and distance for migratory birds. (Have you ever “cheated” by GPS? Think about it how hard navigating without one is.) If we understand that "genetic code ATCG...TTCCATGGGCCCT....." is "wisdom", then many important mysteries of living creatures can be solved. The wisdom in the genes of the first generation can pass down through the generations, until the present day. If we acknowledge that, then a "wise" programmer is the only answer. How to relate to the thousands of years ago Bible, the only literature in human history with creation record. Then God said, “Let the earth sprout vegetation, plants yielding seed, and fruit trees on the earth bearing fruit after their kind with seed in them”; and it was so. ...every living creature that moves, with which the waters swarmed after their kind, and every winged bird after its kind. Now Gene means: The proposed word traced from the Greek word genos, meaning "birth", offspring and procreation. Are there difference between gene and after its kind? If one doesn't want to accept the existence of a "programmer", then he must accept that everything that happened in this world came about through pure random chance, and that everything is empty and meaningless in the end. Take a minute here: mnfedu.com/%E4%B8%80%E5%88%86%E9%92%9F-%E6%9C%89%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B%E7%9A%84-%E7%94%9F%E5%91%BD%E7%A8%8B%E5%BC%8F%E4%BD%88%E9%81%93%E5%BC%95%E8%A8%80. This message is very powerful.
Imagine the guy that asked "what came first, the egg or the chicken?" Shocked to see that people did all these theories and videos and they're like "**points** I did that-"
Thanks for this nuanced and informative video I personally think the chicken came first and egg can't be described by its content it's just the container, they are two separate things the egg has been made according the the genetic rules of whom made it and the chicken that come out of it can do a completely different egg that then would be called a chicken egg
Y, thinks about this way. All mothers know how to take care of their young. However, you may be surprised at how much knowledge and care is required to hatch an egg. The right humidity, temperature, and turning at the correct angle - every 3 hours - are all critical to egg care. Not to mention that there are two threads holding the yolk in the middle of the egg white (to keep the yolk in the middle of the egg white). How did it come to be and why are they able to do it? The eggs without mom's hatching is impossible to Now you can buy automatic hatching machines, because people have discovered the chicken's secrets through scientific studies. If scientific studies can help us to get knowledge, then there's no doubt there is “wisdom” in your genes which instruct creatures on when to grow what and even the season, direction, and distance for migratory birds. (Have you ever “cheated” by GPS? Think about it how hard navigating without one is.) If we understand that "genetic code ATCG...TTCCATGGGCCCT....." is "wisdom", then many important mysteries of living creatures can be solved. The wisdom in the genes of the first generation can pass down through the generations, until the present day. If we acknowledge that, then a "wise" programmer is the only answer. How to relate to the thousands of years ago Bible, the only literature in human history with creation record. Then God said, “Let the earth sprout vegetation, plants yielding seed, and fruit trees on the earth bearing fruit after their kind with seed in them”; and it was so. ...every living creature that moves, with which the waters swarmed after their kind, and every winged bird after its kind. Now Gene means: The proposed word traced from the Greek word genos, meaning "birth", offspring and procreation. Are there difference between gene and after its kind? If one doesn't want to accept the existence of a "programmer", then he must accept that everything that happened in this world came about through pure random chance, and that everything is empty and meaningless in the end. Take a minute here: mnfedu.com/%E4%B8%80%E5%88%86%E9%92%9F-%E6%9C%89%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B%E7%9A%84-%E7%94%9F%E5%91%BD%E7%A8%8B%E5%BC%8F%E4%BD%88%E9%81%93%E5%BC%95%E8%A8%80. This message is very powerful.
+henrique neto -- Time had to....(possibly in conjunction with space.) Or the Big Bang could never have occurred, correct? Think about it. Whatever "state" the universe was in. If there was NO TIME AT ALL.... How could it EVER change to another "state" without time? It Time didn't exist. How did "whatever" it was form to change state in the first place? Maybe Space and Time were always present and Scientists are wrong? Possible!
+Drew Taormino --- The dinosaur-like egg? The reptilian-like egg? The amphibian-like egg? The fish-like egg? Before this.. I have no clue. Not sure if we know the origin of egg laying creatures.
✦Chicken eggs can only come from chickens due to a specific protein. 00:25 ✦Chicken eggs are eggs laid by chickens. 00:52 ✦Genetic mutations create new species 01:18 ✦Proto-chicken egg hatching is not a new species 01:47 ✦Wolves were domesticated through selective pressures. 02:12 ✦The age-old question of which came first, the chicken or the egg, has been answered. 02:37 ✦The first true chicken came from an egg. 03:02
The original realization that god created reality is that without consciousness, there would be nothing. After all, the only reason why anything exists is because it is processed through our minds in order to exist in reality. That's what it means that god created everything. It's technically true. Unfortunately, people think god is some otherworldly entity, rather than what's deep down inside of us. God has become a kind of joke over the years.
@@samuelfofana9752 I can't say that we're god, because that would be putting it into the wrong mindframe. That would be like saying we are consciousness. But we're not consciousness. Semantics matters. The truth is that we're not anything. Our sense of identity is an illusion. You have to get rid of the sense of self. You have to get rid of the ego. Your name, your nationality, your achievements, whatever it may be... it's a sense of identity. But deep deep down, far far in... none of those things actually define who you are. So when you continue to remove all things not deeply true of who you are, what are you left with? You're left with nothing but observation. Preceding all thought... Just what you see in front of you is what is left. The only thing that exists is awareness. What you see, what you hear, what you feel. No past, no identity. Only the present moment with full consciousness. God is that experience.
@@samuelfofana9752 God is, perhaps, experience itself, in the purest sense. It is the existence of reality. Without perception, there is lack of reality. There can be no reality without this underlying experience of existence. There is a book called the Power of Now that calls it "Being." Oriental/Eastern philosophical outlooks call it by varying names. And the Hindus have countless delineations between different kinds of concepts for it. Point being, the westerner's idea of "god" is less fundamental in comparison to easterners'. To think that God is some supernatural entity somewhere external out there in the world... well, the concept is scientifically mute. As horrible as it may first seem to be... the truth is, there is no reason why I am here. Maybe you can watch this, and decide for yourself: th-cam.com/video/21RwqnB8GrE/w-d-xo.html
@@samuelfofana9752 We don't know when the idea came to be, but we have to take into consideration just how old we are. Take a look at this: www.google.com/search?q=how+long+is+humanity&oq=how+long+is+humanity&aqs=chrome..69i57j0l5.5599j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 Anatomically modern humans have been around for 200,000 years. When you look at that, our past 2,000 years is like a blink of an eye by comparison. 2,000 years is only 1% of 200,000. *One percent.* Whatever the idea of god is, I doubt it's been here for very long. I'd say it's rather new. And I do think that there were people in the past who were also very smart and had great ideas, kind of like the legendary Lao Tzu. But a lot of the genius of humanity has been buried to time.
liberate my mind. Thor, Huizilopoxtli, Tlaloc, etc,etc, etc,etc, on to or close, dang near close to infinity naming all the gods and goddesses from all over the world..... Just which "god, or goddess" are you referring to please???.....Ps.. !!!! CHECK IT OUT !!!!! ... NEVERMIND YOU MISSED THE INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION AS IT FLEW BY😖😖😖😖😖😖😖
Chicken eggs are eggs laid by chickens but don’t necessarily contain chickens (we eat the ones with no chickens) On the other hand, chickens are from chicken eggs but don’t necessarily lay eggs (roosters don’t lay eggs)
And this ^ is why this is a totally ambigious question. When someone says : ".. the chicken or the egg?" -you assume that it is implied > "..the chicken or the 'chicken'-egg". If we are to assume that it's "..the chicken or any egg, not just chicken-eggs", then the question is flat-out just a troll. Which is why I don't like the question, since people will have long discussions about it, when in reality, it comes down to specifying different things from the question, in order to remove every bit of ambigious information. And, as they mention in the video, there couldn't have been a point in history (based on our definitions) where two birds mated and it produced a new species. So, if we're going by "..the chicken or the (chicken)-egg", the chicken would've come first. That chicken would reproduce with another bird of its species, and so evolution would continue to evolve it to the chickens we have today.
*Before watching this video i was confused that what came first chicken or an egg* *_But Now_* *I am confused that i came from an human Beings'body or an animal's* Damn it, it converted my brain into something out of the world
Chicken or egg: egg THE egg came from another animal who evolved into the chicken, but all the genetic variation happens when the egg is made, so the egg chicken or chicken egg: Chicken Since the egg came first but the chicken egg has to be laid by a chicken, the chicken came first. Thanks for coming to my Ted talk.
Oh, neither. *Cookies started it all.* And BTW, if you believe in god, think about this: *What created God?* If you don't, *What started the big bang?* Yeah, I have no idea either.
Now you have the right answer. Y, thinks about this way. All mothers know how to take care of their young. However, you may be surprised at how much knowledge and care is required to hatch an egg. The right humidity, temperature, and turning at the correct angle - every 3 hours - are all critical to egg care. Not to mention that there are two threads holding the yolk in the middle of the egg white (to keep the yolk in the middle of the egg white). How did it come to be and why are they able to do it? The eggs without mom's hatching is impossible to Now you can buy automatic hatching machines, because people have discovered the chicken's secrets through scientific studies. If scientific studies can help us to get knowledge, then there's no doubt there is “wisdom” in your genes which instruct creatures on when to grow what and even the season, direction, and distance for migratory birds. (Have you ever “cheated” by GPS? Think about it how hard navigating without one is.) If we understand that "genetic code ATCG...TTCCATGGGCCCT....." is "wisdom", then many important mysteries of living creatures can be solved. The wisdom in the genes of the first generation can pass down through the generations, until the present day. If we acknowledge that, then a "wise" programmer is the only answer. How to relate to the thousands of years ago Bible, the only literature in human history with creation record. Then God said, “Let the earth sprout vegetation, plants yielding seed, and fruit trees on the earth bearing fruit after their kind with seed in them”; and it was so. ...every living creature that moves, with which the waters swarmed after their kind, and every winged bird after its kind. Now Gene means: The proposed word traced from the Greek word genos, meaning "birth", offspring and procreation. Are there difference between gene and after its kind? If one doesn't want to accept the existence of a "programmer", then he must accept that everything that happened in this world came about through pure random chance, and that everything is empty and meaningless in the end. Take a minute here: mnfedu.com/%E4%B8%80%E5%88%86%E9%92%9F-%E6%9C%89%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B%E7%9A%84-%E7%94%9F%E5%91%BD%E7%A8%8B%E5%BC%8F%E4%BD%88%E9%81%93%E5%BC%95%E8%A8%80. This message is very powerful.
the chicken came first cuz if the egg came first the egg will not be able to be hatched without a chicken. the chicken came first that gave birth to eggs the eggs hatched and BOOM chickens.
Y, thinks about this way. All mothers know how to take care of their young. However, you may be surprised at how much knowledge and care is required to hatch an egg. The right humidity, temperature, and turning at the correct angle - every 3 hours - are all critical to egg care. Not to mention that there are two threads holding the yolk in the middle of the egg white (to keep the yolk in the middle of the egg white). How did it come to be and why are they able to do it? The eggs without mom's hatching is impossible to Now you can buy automatic hatching machines, because people have discovered the chicken's secrets through scientific studies. If scientific studies can help us to get knowledge, then there's no doubt there is “wisdom” in your genes which instruct creatures on when to grow what and even the season, direction, and distance for migratory birds. (Have you ever “cheated” by GPS? Think about it how hard navigating without one is.) If we understand that "genetic code ATCG...TTCCATGGGCCCT....." is "wisdom", then many important mysteries of living creatures can be solved. The wisdom in the genes of the first generation can pass down through the generations, until the present day. If we acknowledge that, then a "wise" programmer is the only answer. How to relate to the thousands of years ago Bible, the only literature in human history with creation record. Then God said, “Let the earth sprout vegetation, plants yielding seed, and fruit trees on the earth bearing fruit after their kind with seed in them”; and it was so. ...every living creature that moves, with which the waters swarmed after their kind, and every winged bird after its kind. Now Gene means: The proposed word traced from the Greek word genos, meaning "birth", offspring and procreation. Are there difference between gene and after its kind? If one doesn't want to accept the existence of a "programmer", then he must accept that everything that happened in this world came about through pure random chance, and that everything is empty and meaningless in the end. Take a minute here: mnfedu.com/%E4%B8%80%E5%88%86%E9%92%9F-%E6%9C%89%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B%E7%9A%84-%E7%94%9F%E5%91%BD%E7%A8%8B%E5%BC%8F%E4%BD%88%E9%81%93%E5%BC%95%E8%A8%80. This message is very powerful.
Pretty sure that’s wrong man, it’s a gene mutation between the same birds that happens to get passed down and selectively breed. Like the definition of a species is pretty much anything that can successfully mate together. I think there have been a few rare examples of sterile interspecies.
gyrex God made the first organism,if you think about it,there will always be a greater being,and somehow it will be linked to "God".Even if life was an accident,someone must have made something,like an organism,all god has to do is add a void and an organism and a few planets,that is all god has to do,then,zither magic happens.
As a religious person with lack of science knowledge, in my religion it didn't mentioned clearly but it mentioned everything is created in a pair. So to my own understanding I would prefer chicken come first as a pair, and the hen laid eggs. "How did the chicken come to existence without an egg?" this is rather a stupid question tbh unless you want a scientific explanation then you might go deep in early stage of existence. Otherwise, the question is actually provocative since if God is able to bring something into existence it's easy for Him to create pair of chickens out of thin air. Note: Religion is neither go against science 100% or supporting it 100%. In religious perspective, science would be explanation of how some things happening and why is it happening in logical ways. While at the same time, religion in general already make things simpler for us so that we could balanced things even better. It's not wrong to study science in general in fact there are many religious people become scientist.
@@midnight_mocha9659The egg came first. Hard external eggs that can be laid on land, known as amniotic eggs, were a significant development for vertebrates. These types of eggs evolved around 325 million years ago, long before true birds appeared in the fossil record. While chickens likely evolved from red jungle fowl around 50 million years ago, the first chicken egg would have been laid by an ancestor of modern chickens after genetic differences accumulated during the domestication process.
No facts to support evolution at all, just a theory and before you go to try and tell me that a theory is backed up by facts, it isn't. A theory is actually backed up behind perception of opinion. Theory of Evolution has been proven wrong and will continue to be, cause it is an opinion with no facts to support. God created everything, this isn't opinion, but fact, whether you chose to believe it or not is your choice.
"Theory of Evolution has been proven wrong and will continue to be, cause it is an opinion with no facts to support. God created everything, this isn't opinion, but fact, whether you chose to believe it or not is your choice." => You made my day xD BTW, I'm christian.
The problem with this question is that there can't be a first chicken. Evolution states that over time, changes accumulate, but, there is no exact moment when a proto-chicken turns into a chicken.
If you go back pre pre pre pre proto chicken. There was no egg. No brainer. Chicken mutated from something with no eggs, to a species that needed hard shell eggs for protection. Chicken came first.
Y, thinks about this way. All mothers know how to take care of their young. However, you may be surprised at how much knowledge and care is required to hatch an egg. The right humidity, temperature, and turning at the correct angle - every 3 hours - are all critical to egg care. Not to mention that there are two threads holding the yolk in the middle of the egg white (to keep the yolk in the middle of the egg white). How did it come to be and why are they able to do it? The eggs without mom's hatching is impossible to Now you can buy automatic hatching machines, because people have discovered the chicken's secrets through scientific studies. If scientific studies can help us to get knowledge, then there's no doubt there is “wisdom” in your genes which instruct creatures on when to grow what and even the season, direction, and distance for migratory birds. (Have you ever “cheated” by GPS? Think about it how hard navigating without one is.) If we understand that "genetic code ATCG...TTCCATGGGCCCT....." is "wisdom", then many important mysteries of living creatures can be solved. The wisdom in the genes of the first generation can pass down through the generations, until the present day. If we acknowledge that, then a "wise" programmer is the only answer. How to relate to the thousands of years ago Bible, the only literature in human history with creation record. Then God said, “Let the earth sprout vegetation, plants yielding seed, and fruit trees on the earth bearing fruit after their kind with seed in them”; and it was so. ...every living creature that moves, with which the waters swarmed after their kind, and every winged bird after its kind. Now Gene means: The proposed word traced from the Greek word genos, meaning "birth", offspring and procreation. Are there difference between gene and after its kind? If one doesn't want to accept the existence of a "programmer", then he must accept that everything that happened in this world came about through pure random chance, and that everything is empty and meaningless in the end. Take a minute here: mnfedu.com/%E4%B8%80%E5%88%86%E9%92%9F-%E6%9C%89%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B%E7%9A%84-%E7%94%9F%E5%91%BD%E7%A8%8B%E5%BC%8F%E4%BD%88%E9%81%93%E5%BC%95%E8%A8%80. This message is very powerful.
PEDRO 21 Sunday is the first day of the week and it is not the part of the weekend .-. Saturday is the only weekend SINCE its singular😂😂😂But if you say weekends Friday and Saturday are it.
Let's say we go a few million years back : a couple of two primitive birds create, fertilize and lay an egg, but a genetic mutation occured during the development of the egg. Due to this, once it hatches, the bird is one step closer to a modern chicken. Therefore, applying this process of though to the following mutations that will lead to the modern chicken, the egg obviously came first, as the birds which created it cannot be called chickens yet
But chicken have been around for only 1000 year because chicken is domestic bird . They are here because lot of selective breeding that why we have problem deciding where they come from
What happens if you go back pass the couple of birds? They become species that don’t pay hard shell eggs. Then the chicken would be first. But to think of the exact timing of when a proto chicken was inside a Porto chicken egg. The Porto chicken mutated in a chicken. The proto chicken egg came before the chicken. But the chicken came before the chicken eggs.
Imagine a guy X, the only son of his parents, with mother and father named A and B respectively goes back into the past. He marries A and later have a child { which is ultimately X } Does that mean the son was his own father? Well , according to me, time does not move from PAST TO PRESENT TO FUTURE. Time moves in a loop, a circular and hence, an endless loop. So to answer this question, I would say that egg was the reason that the chicken came while the chicken was the reason the egg came. Nothing among these 2 came first
Y, thinks about this way. All mothers know how to take care of their young. However, you may be surprised at how much knowledge and care is required to hatch an egg. The right humidity, temperature, and turning at the correct angle - every 3 hours - are all critical to egg care. Not to mention that there are two threads holding the yolk in the middle of the egg white (to keep the yolk in the middle of the egg white). How did it come to be and why are they able to do it? The eggs without mom's hatching is impossible to Now you can buy automatic hatching machines, because people have discovered the chicken's secrets through scientific studies. If scientific studies can help us to get knowledge, then there's no doubt there is “wisdom” in your genes which instruct creatures on when to grow what and even the season, direction, and distance for migratory birds. (Have you ever “cheated” by GPS? Think about it how hard navigating without one is.) If we understand that "genetic code ATCG...TTCCATGGGCCCT....." is "wisdom", then many important mysteries of living creatures can be solved. The wisdom in the genes of the first generation can pass down through the generations, until the present day. If we acknowledge that, then a "wise" programmer is the only answer. How to relate to the thousands of years ago Bible, the only literature in human history with creation record. Then God said, “Let the earth sprout vegetation, plants yielding seed, and fruit trees on the earth bearing fruit after their kind with seed in them”; and it was so. ...every living creature that moves, with which the waters swarmed after their kind, and every winged bird after its kind. Now Gene means: The proposed word traced from the Greek word genos, meaning "birth", offspring and procreation. Are there difference between gene and after its kind? If one doesn't want to accept the existence of a "programmer", then he must accept that everything that happened in this world came about through pure random chance, and that everything is empty and meaningless in the end. Take a minute here: mnfedu.com/%E4%B8%80%E5%88%86%E9%92%9F-%E6%9C%89%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B%E7%9A%84-%E7%94%9F%E5%91%BD%E7%A8%8B%E5%BC%8F%E4%BD%88%E9%81%93%E5%BC%95%E8%A8%80. This message is very powerful.
This video just left an even bigger question unanswered. Which was the first egg in the evoltion timeline of chickens and where did that egg come from?
Y, thinks about this way. All mothers know how to take care of their young. However, you may be surprised at how much knowledge and care is required to hatch an egg. The right humidity, temperature, and turning at the correct angle - every 3 hours - are all critical to egg care. Not to mention that there are two threads holding the yolk in the middle of the egg white (to keep the yolk in the middle of the egg white). How did it come to be and why are they able to do it? The eggs without mom's hatching is impossible to Now you can buy automatic hatching machines, because people have discovered the chicken's secrets through scientific studies. If scientific studies can help us to get knowledge, then there's no doubt there is “wisdom” in your genes which instruct creatures on when to grow what and even the season, direction, and distance for migratory birds. (Have you ever “cheated” by GPS? Think about it how hard navigating without one is.) If we understand that "genetic code ATCG...TTCCATGGGCCCT....." is "wisdom", then many important mysteries of living creatures can be solved. The wisdom in the genes of the first generation can pass down through the generations, until the present day. If we acknowledge that, then a "wise" programmer is the only answer. How to relate to the thousands of years ago Bible, the only literature in human history with creation record. Then God said, “Let the earth sprout vegetation, plants yielding seed, and fruit trees on the earth bearing fruit after their kind with seed in them”; and it was so. ...every living creature that moves, with which the waters swarmed after their kind, and every winged bird after its kind. Now Gene means: The proposed word traced from the Greek word genos, meaning "birth", offspring and procreation. Are there difference between gene and after its kind? If one doesn't want to accept the existence of a "programmer", then he must accept that everything that happened in this world came about through pure random chance, and that everything is empty and meaningless in the end. Take a minute here: mnfedu.com/%E4%B8%80%E5%88%86%E9%92%9F-%E6%9C%89%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B%E7%9A%84-%E7%94%9F%E5%91%BD%E7%A8%8B%E5%BC%8F%E4%BD%88%E9%81%93%E5%BC%95%E8%A8%80. This message is very powerful.
The egg came first because you eat eggs for breakfast and chicken for dinner :P
Ma nigga.
Ha ha
But how do we know that day came before night
*****
what if the plants grew after the night did you think about that smartie.
Well I Had a Chicken omlette for breakfast which kind of nullifies that point BUT the first smell to come out was definitly egg.......so you still right :)
I've just been on Amazon and ordered both a chicken and an egg....
I'll let you know...
That
is the most unique, and overall the best answer, I have heard XD It was so funny my laughing was making it difficult to tell this to someone else XD
did they come...
Michael Smith lol
So which came first ?? 0.0
So I probably thought about this more than I needed to but uh do u mean wich came in the mail first or wich laid an egg first or hatched first???
‘Both, the chicken was inside of the egg’
-NigaHiga
Which video does nigahiga say it?
@@kostard.verchiom1173 ehtj
This is life changing, no sarcasm, thank you.
Kostar D.Verchiom “Chicken or the Egg? (Dear Ryan)”
Cool you watch him too
These are the type of questions that I ask my self when high
Literally
NO
But then we are left with a new question “what came first the proto chicken or the proto chicken egg?”
And now, we're doing formal papers proving different theories. It is so hard.
Also who came first....man or woman??
Which came first, The chicken or the egg?
*Drumrolls*
The Chegg
Lol XD~
Short term Memory Loss FBI OPEN UP
Egg
Dada dada daaadaaa
Noice
According to Luna Lovegood in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows:
"A circle has no beginning."
Warriors?!!!!! Yeeeee
Yay potterheads
Potterhead rules
Siri M the eagle Knocker says , " Which came first,the phoenix or the flame "
The egg is an oval
The egg came first because you eat eggs for breakfast and chicken for dinner
Clever...
Stealing it
Well, women are made for cooking, milk and eggs, AHHH!! There I said it.
Wow, how ironic? Wow, how ironic.
***** but that chicken was born in an EGG 🍳
*Random* *Disturbing* *Thought* : Man time traveled back in time with a pregnant chicken to start it’s existence.
Lol😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣
Nice theory tho🙄🙄🤭🤭😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣👍👍
😂
Its a paradox then
But then we are left with a new question “what came first the proto chicken or the proto chicken egg?”
But how did the man get the chicken??
Granma: how did world war three start
Me: this video
@Mallory Moore Yes!
I really hope that it is NOT the case, but your Grandma might be suffering from Dementia or some neurological condition brought on by aging...Please take her to see a professional to be checked out... Good karma unto you and all your loved ones...
@@communistjesus goodness it's a joke.
Mallory Moore T-series won
@@communistjesus r/woooosh
Whoa! Whoa! Whoa! Who gives a **** about chickens or eggs. I want to know more about the Elephant that lays eggs that hatch into lions.
**?
+Mr. Divery im crying:)
Oh my goodness 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
lol
Which came first the App Store or the apps
Omg, best question ever!
I think is App, because old phones didn't had AppStore yet before the new technology was developed.
Apps came first, remember having phones(not smartphones) and when technology and internet was not developed like it nowadays but you had a calculater app and certain games inbuilt?
well if the app store is an app devolped by the developers and automatically placed on your phone means that the app came first
et
Its the app store because of the whole old phone thing and that the app store is an app so yeah. Its apps. The app store is just an app that gives more apps.
ENTIRE WORLD: WHO CAME FIRST, CHICKEN OR EGG.
ME: IT DEPENDS ON WHAT WE ORDER 'FIRST'
The entire world : NO IT DEPENDS ON THE EVOLUTION OF THE CREATURE
Just ordered a chicken and an egg on Ebay... ill let you know.
Haha. Take my like.
take my like too
Shove my like up your ass
ya talk dirty to me ^
Champagne Showers hows the egg
last time I checked elephants don't lay eggs
maybe proto elephants did
Lol
hahahaha😂
Last time I checked, it was an exaggerated example to demonstrate their point more vividly.
Last time I checked, I got banned from the zoo.
The answer is both. The Chicken was in the egg
+The Real Sandwitch Mind.Blown. :0
MAAAAAAAAAGIK
I say thta to everyone but they so no
O ya an d both didnt because chicken wasnt form
Your comment was in a nigahiga video 😱😱😱😱😱😱
Egg 🐣: tastes good
Chicken 🍗 : delicious!
I don't care about which came first.
Oh
@Night shade I do poultry at my home, which helps me to eradicate this issue that you mentioned above.
Hello everybody!
Check out this video on importance of education : th-cam.com/video/bL4GNEcRX-8/w-d-xo.html
Sorry for the self promotion but hey, can't blame me right?
You racist
after done eating the egg and chicken: 💩
One question remains unanswered though... Who came first: the proto-chicken or the proto-egg ? 🤔
Boltimer Brahms well, the proto-proto chicken came first...
@@crescentx3 then who came first? The proto- proto chicken or the proto- proto chicken Egg?
NO
Ah shit, here we go again
It's always egg untill you go all the way back to the single celled organism
Here’s some advice:
It’s bedtime.
@@jujupoop yeeaahh!! its my bedtime too!!
helpful advice, will sure follow it lol
pizza time
@@VortechBirb lol 😂
Sophie Daisy no u
I was born from a proto human egg.
I'm a yolk.
***** OMG ITS YOU!
JOHNNY GAT i was a sperm...whale
***** I WAS BORN FROM A VIKING ROBBAZ
I born from a kerbal egg.
Did you come here because of Splatoon's splatfest remake?
Now that I'm educated I will choose-- CHICKEN #whiteInkLooksCool
bruh- just make a private server and go crazy with the colors if thats your whole reason i-
@@heart8che It's memes. I'm quite aware of the turf war splatfest mode
@Antony Poulton no. bad
Same, I investigated before but now that the splatfest theme is this topic, I'll go back to my research 😊
Yellow ink is cooler
Anybody watching in the July of 2019
Ps. Im editing it evry month
April
Definitely not.
*sarcasm*
Got em
he edited it to april lol
Yes
My brain took a looooong fart throughout this all.
+Ishika Jha watch harry potter & let your brain fart, piss, shit etc.. Shouldnt be watching somethn meaningful if its beyond you
Jai Bajrang Bali I have watched, read and cried over Harry Potter multiple times, thank you very much.
STFU!!!
loda lega ???
Ishika Jha you really need to shut up ishika jhaat!!!
T H E C H E G G
love that meem
seal
Or is it the eggin
Think about that
bamboozled
I know i think its egg because of DNA crap... 2 "odd" chickens bred and layed a chicken egg....
LOLOLOOOLOLLOOL TROLOLOL
the egg is first because the chicken didn’t just spawn, two ancestors came together to breed that egg and then the chicken came out of that egg.
exactly
but really the process was so long that as much as there were proto chickens there were proto chicken eggs for millenia
A circle has no beginning
-Luna Lovegood
Bellatrix LeStrange but this is a changing circle not a pefrwfct circle.
Perfect that's what I meant.
kaicraft network you mean Looney Lovegood?
Bellatrix LeStrange 69th like😏
Jayze Pickle you can edit your comment
I wrote a poem.
I had a question
I thought the video was gonna answer
But instead, I'm more confused than ever
Where's the poem?
#Meow from “I had a question" till “more confused than ever”
@@anxietyatitsfinest286 lol
Welcome to the doki doki litature club
Yeah same...
Why is Monday so far away from Friday but Friday is close to Monday
because
ancient greeks made it
Stupid Ancient Greeks. Wait, I take that back; without the greeks, we wouldn't have Percy Jackson
AzizKing TV sigh .....it's the way of life
that's just how the week is dumbfuck
Retarded Sonic well aren't you just a ray of sunshine
Question: WHAT IS LOVE! Baby don’t hurt me! DONT HURT MEEEE! No more
Love is an Emotion
Love is a emotion that you feel when you like someone a lot.
The time when you wish you had time travel
Yes i wish too that we have time travel
Given the theories on time travel, I'd rather not doom the universe by messing with time
SnapClapplePop hhhhh
Yes, but I'd only do it if I could hurtle through times dimensions in an egg shaped Tardis.
Me too😢
Which came fist the proto chicken or the proto chicken egg?
Jack L the microscopic spec came first
Lol
it always comes down to the organisms coming before their parts, the egg is part of the chicken so it's like asking which came first your shit or you, you need you first before you can shit!
Cory Louis who's to say they always laid eggs though?
Jack L I came first
Which came first you or birth.
Anas saleh obviously the first
your mom
Well, me, Frodo Baggins existed before _I_ was born, but things were born before I existed, and there were egg laying species, that at one point, gave birth instead of laying an egg, so in that scenario, if I were the said Birthee, then I would have existed before birth.
The answer is simple but not to an atheist chicken came first of course god created them like human but to an atheist that means nothing.
You, because the sperm reaches the egg before birth.
Literally here just so I can decide on a Splatoon 2 Splatfest team
T E A M E G G
Team Chicken
I’m going Team Egg!
@@theals9605 GOOD.
*h u e v o*
I learn better in this than my school
ivan25 jr cuz you never listen....
Ikr In my lessons they just drag on about constantly repeated areas in topics that we have already recoded like 200 times
You also play Growtopia? Same here dude! Didn’t expect to find another player here....
ivan25 jr ME TOO :) :)
True to that
Me: **about to go to sleep**
My TH-cam recommendations:
I swear yes
Sameee
They were both first. The chicken was inside the egg.
#Higa2016
But which was created first the egg or chicken?
DasA Bucket! Both
+Michael Johnson makes sense
i cant have an argument against this
***** I actually think that the chicken came first. I was just making a joke.
You are on the egg team right? Well what incubates the egg then?
Hello guys I appreciate your work ,,, But I have a question that according to you guys egg came first but the egg can only continue the process of making body of chick by a process called hatching if egg came first then there is no one hatch egg ......if I am wrong pls correct me
Yes exactly how will the egg hstch if there is no chicken to hatch it
My dad says that The egg came first, because after the bird layed the egg, the chick in the egg mutated and became a chicken
Uh, well that is one way to put it. Birds evolved from dinosaurs, who laid eggs. Chickens evolved from non chicken birds.
Close. The mutations that put it "over the edge" actually happened before the egg was ever laid. But the mutations didn't make the chick till after the egg was laid since hens don't carry their young inside them like humans do. They spit them out as fast as possible. Sometimes in a single day.
I agree with josh f
ElevatorLiker#1 VGCP You may agree with whomever you wish. However, facts are facts.
*****
Sorry, the bible never says God created all the animals alive today in the beginning. Nor does it say ANYTHING for or against existing species being able to change. Truth is the Bible doesn't say anything that contradicts sciences version of how we, and the other species got here. You would know this if you had taken the time to read the Bible instead of listening to what others told you it all meant. BTW, I do believe in God, but I have also read the entire Bible, multiple times, for myself. And I can tell you science and the Bible do NOT contradict each other at all.
Like: Egg first
Comment: Chicken first
Rando Avocado chicken
I
No clue tbh just going with chicken for the sake of it
What if I comment like
replies have a max capacity
*My brain is like chicken thicken phicken jhicken shicken*
Aman Pannu so many kens
Veronica Sandoval 😂😂
Aman Pannu 😉
Veronica Sandoval 🤔😉😀
Aman Pannu call in the potato army
its been 8 years i still not sure what to pick
I was looking through the comments section when I realized that people took a video about the old idea of "Which came first, the chicken or the egg?" and turned it into a religious debate in which everyone spews nonsense about things they know hardly anything about.
I'm quite glad for the new comments system. Those petty, ignorant arguments get confined in their own little worlds, arguing to their heart's content.
Obviously the chicken. Getting chicken eggs in Minecraft is only possible through creative mode.
Unless a mod creates a command block or places eggs in a dispenser. (IDK I haven't played Proto Fortnight since 2010)
Except that no one has ever asked _"Did the chicken or the _*_chicken egg_*_ come first?"_
Pillage the village
Yeah but what about the egg you can find in tutorials?
No? Regular minecraft eggs used for cake have a chance of spawning a baby chicken when you throw it
they said Jesus can walk on water.
watermelon is 92% water which means, if I stand on a watermelon I'm basically 92% Jesus. WOW!!!!
Lol can you please give me the source of the "replicating jesus' wine"????
Randies John chapter 2 is the story of Jesus turning 6 stone containers full of water into 6 stone containers full of wine. Then google, 'how much water to make wine', Huffington Post entry, Oct. 13, 2004.
Lol ofcourse you would believe the bible that was written 2000 years ago by the uneducated disiples
Did you know that Pastafa, the flying spaghetti monster will dip you in a boiling water if you will believe in jesus? Pastafa is the one true god the mighty of all mighty! The flying spaghetti monster. Now prove that the flying spaghetti monster isn't real if you can then you could also prove your god to be real right? I only need 1 evidence that he existed or the miracle of jesus about turning those waters to wine was true
And not just a made up fairy tale
After my 50 years of research and studies I finally got to know that the first person who thought this question came first :)
no, now you have the right answer here: Y, thinks about this way. All mothers know how to take care of their young. However, you may be surprised at how much knowledge and care is required to hatch an egg. The right humidity, temperature, and turning at the correct angle - every 3 hours - are all critical to egg care. Not to mention that there are two threads holding the yolk in the middle of the egg white (to keep the yolk in the middle of the egg white). How did it come to be and why are they able to do it? The eggs without mom's hatching is impossible to
Now you can buy automatic hatching machines, because people have discovered the chicken's secrets through scientific studies. If scientific studies can help us to get knowledge, then there's no doubt there is “wisdom” in your genes which instruct creatures on when to grow what and even the season, direction, and distance for migratory birds. (Have you ever “cheated” by GPS? Think about it how hard navigating without one is.)
If we understand that "genetic code ATCG...TTCCATGGGCCCT....." is "wisdom", then many important mysteries of living creatures can be solved. The wisdom in the genes of the first generation can pass down through the generations, until the present day. If we acknowledge that, then a "wise" programmer is the only answer.
How to relate to the thousands of years ago Bible, the only literature in human history with creation record. Then God said, “Let the earth sprout vegetation, plants yielding seed, and fruit trees on the earth bearing fruit after their kind with seed in them”; and it was so. ...every living creature that moves, with which the waters swarmed after their kind, and every winged bird after its kind.
Now Gene means: The proposed word traced from the Greek word genos, meaning "birth", offspring and procreation. Are there difference between gene and after its kind?
If one doesn't want to accept the existence of a "programmer", then he must accept that everything that happened in this world came about through pure random chance, and that everything is empty and meaningless in the end.
Take a minute here: mnfedu.com/%E4%B8%80%E5%88%86%E9%92%9F-%E6%9C%89%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B%E7%9A%84-%E7%94%9F%E5%91%BD%E7%A8%8B%E5%BC%8F%E4%BD%88%E9%81%93%E5%BC%95%E8%A8%80. This message is very powerful.
what came first the chicken or the egg?
Video: *yEs*
It literally says egg at the end
Yeah
Watch till the end. It's literally obvious there is the answer on the vid
I don't understand what does this yes mean?
Sharath Nair, yes = none
*The Chegg*
(Wonder how many people have made that joke)
Dakila Lozano true
**intensive screeching**
dakotah mcfreakout PLENTY
This comment is now a meme on Splatoon. Congrats. 🦑
Thanks Goldi
Obviously the rooster came first duh :P
(I think) I see what you did there ; ^ )
No a chegg
but he came on an egg
Wooooooow...
Chicken!
Imagine the guy that asked "what came first, the egg or the chicken?"
Shocked to see that people did all these theories and videos and they're like "**points** I did that-"
But then we are left with a new question “what came first the proto chicken or the proto chicken egg?”
@@yokayk4698
The guy also: **chuckles** I did that too--
@@yokayk4698 Uh no, the answer still the same, the egg, because animal evolve over time
He said "chicken" 42 times.
Hanna lol
41 you counted wrong
|-/
Hanna I was joking bro....
And i think you are too
He said chicken before he said egg, the chicken came first ⁽ᴵⁿ ᵗʰᵉ ᵛᶦᵈᵉᵒ⁾
I haven't heard the words "chicken" and "egg" so much in my life
Note to self: never thank people for likes
You ever listened to a vegan?
th-cam.com/video/VxThhSsSjGM/w-d-xo.html
See this
WoAh! 300
Let's help to 1k
@@7ytMo sorry im a her🤣
a chicken and a hen randomly spawned and chicken layed an egg
*XxchickenxX has logged on*
ElvizNation lokloolol
A hen is a female
r\whoosh
Minecraft
Thanks for this nuanced and informative video I personally think the chicken came first and egg can't be described by its content it's just the container, they are two separate things the egg has been made according the the genetic rules of whom made it and the chicken that come out of it can do a completely different egg that then would be called a chicken egg
Y, thinks about this way. All mothers know how to take care of their young. However, you may be surprised at how much knowledge and care is required to hatch an egg. The right humidity, temperature, and turning at the correct angle - every 3 hours - are all critical to egg care. Not to mention that there are two threads holding the yolk in the middle of the egg white (to keep the yolk in the middle of the egg white). How did it come to be and why are they able to do it? The eggs without mom's hatching is impossible to
Now you can buy automatic hatching machines, because people have discovered the chicken's secrets through scientific studies. If scientific studies can help us to get knowledge, then there's no doubt there is “wisdom” in your genes which instruct creatures on when to grow what and even the season, direction, and distance for migratory birds. (Have you ever “cheated” by GPS? Think about it how hard navigating without one is.)
If we understand that "genetic code ATCG...TTCCATGGGCCCT....." is "wisdom", then many important mysteries of living creatures can be solved. The wisdom in the genes of the first generation can pass down through the generations, until the present day. If we acknowledge that, then a "wise" programmer is the only answer.
How to relate to the thousands of years ago Bible, the only literature in human history with creation record. Then God said, “Let the earth sprout vegetation, plants yielding seed, and fruit trees on the earth bearing fruit after their kind with seed in them”; and it was so. ...every living creature that moves, with which the waters swarmed after their kind, and every winged bird after its kind.
Now Gene means: The proposed word traced from the Greek word genos, meaning "birth", offspring and procreation. Are there difference between gene and after its kind?
If one doesn't want to accept the existence of a "programmer", then he must accept that everything that happened in this world came about through pure random chance, and that everything is empty and meaningless in the end.
Take a minute here: mnfedu.com/%E4%B8%80%E5%88%86%E9%92%9F-%E6%9C%89%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B%E7%9A%84-%E7%94%9F%E5%91%BD%E7%A8%8B%E5%BC%8F%E4%BD%88%E9%81%93%E5%BC%95%E8%A8%80. This message is very powerful.
Obviously the Chegg
Robert Tyll, no! It's the egen
a. naveed o
Yasmia Kiedis AIC is great
Peroxides Poisons CHEGG CHEGG CHEGG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I love how enthusiastic you are about this
what came first, the prehistoric chicken, or prehistoric chicken egg?
+Drew Taormino What came first space or matter?
+henrique neto --
Time had to....(possibly in conjunction with space.)
Or the Big Bang could never have occurred, correct?
Think about it.
Whatever "state" the universe was in. If there was NO TIME AT ALL....
How could it EVER change to another "state" without time?
It Time didn't exist.
How did "whatever" it was form to change state in the first place?
Maybe Space and Time were always present and Scientists are wrong?
Possible!
+Drew Taormino ---
The dinosaur-like egg?
The reptilian-like egg?
The amphibian-like egg?
The fish-like egg?
Before this.. I have no clue. Not sure if we know the origin of egg laying creatures.
+Drew Taormino -_-
+henrique neto time,space,matter and energy all came at once.
“Chicken or egg, which came first?”
Ion know, I’m too hungry.
✦Chicken eggs can only come from chickens due to a specific protein. 00:25
✦Chicken eggs are eggs laid by chickens. 00:52
✦Genetic mutations create new species 01:18
✦Proto-chicken egg hatching is not a new species 01:47
✦Wolves were domesticated through selective pressures. 02:12
✦The age-old question of which came first, the chicken or the egg, has been answered. 02:37
✦The first true chicken came from an egg. 03:02
The real question is
*Why did the chicken cross the road?*
To go to Geico so they can save money on their car insurance
Because it was depressed so it-
To get to the idiot's house. Knock knock.
To get to the other side
@@c_cubed Who's there?
Howtobasic came first
Your comment made my day XD
keep Me ikr! 😉
keep Me lol
keep Me true XD
we have a genius on our hands
God: *creates something*
Human: is it an egg? Or a chicken?
God: am I joke to u?
The original realization that god created reality is that without consciousness, there would be nothing. After all, the only reason why anything exists is because it is processed through our minds in order to exist in reality. That's what it means that god created everything. It's technically true. Unfortunately, people think god is some otherworldly entity, rather than what's deep down inside of us.
God has become a kind of joke over the years.
@@samuelfofana9752 I can't say that we're god, because that would be putting it into the wrong mindframe. That would be like saying we are consciousness. But we're not consciousness. Semantics matters.
The truth is that we're not anything. Our sense of identity is an illusion. You have to get rid of the sense of self. You have to get rid of the ego. Your name, your nationality, your achievements, whatever it may be... it's a sense of identity. But deep deep down, far far in... none of those things actually define who you are.
So when you continue to remove all things not deeply true of who you are, what are you left with? You're left with nothing but observation. Preceding all thought... Just what you see in front of you is what is left. The only thing that exists is awareness. What you see, what you hear, what you feel. No past, no identity. Only the present moment with full consciousness. God is that experience.
@@samuelfofana9752
God is, perhaps, experience itself, in the purest sense. It is the existence of reality. Without perception, there is lack of reality. There can be no reality without this underlying experience of existence.
There is a book called the Power of Now that calls it "Being." Oriental/Eastern philosophical outlooks call it by varying names. And the Hindus have countless delineations between different kinds of concepts for it. Point being, the westerner's idea of "god" is less fundamental in comparison to easterners'. To think that God is some supernatural entity somewhere external out there in the world... well, the concept is scientifically mute.
As horrible as it may first seem to be... the truth is, there is no reason why I am here. Maybe you can watch this, and decide for yourself: th-cam.com/video/21RwqnB8GrE/w-d-xo.html
@@samuelfofana9752 We don't know when the idea came to be, but we have to take into consideration just how old we are.
Take a look at this: www.google.com/search?q=how+long+is+humanity&oq=how+long+is+humanity&aqs=chrome..69i57j0l5.5599j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8
Anatomically modern humans have been around for 200,000 years. When you look at that, our past 2,000 years is like a blink of an eye by comparison. 2,000 years is only 1% of 200,000. *One percent.*
Whatever the idea of god is, I doubt it's been here for very long. I'd say it's rather new. And I do think that there were people in the past who were also very smart and had great ideas, kind of like the legendary Lao Tzu. But a lot of the genius of humanity has been buried to time.
liberate my mind. Thor, Huizilopoxtli, Tlaloc, etc,etc, etc,etc, on to or close, dang near close to infinity naming all the gods and goddesses from all over the world..... Just which "god, or goddess" are you referring to please???.....Ps.. !!!! CHECK IT OUT !!!!! ... NEVERMIND YOU MISSED THE INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION AS IT FLEW BY😖😖😖😖😖😖😖
Chicken eggs are eggs laid by chickens but don’t necessarily contain chickens (we eat the ones with no chickens)
On the other hand, chickens are from chicken eggs but don’t necessarily lay eggs (roosters don’t lay eggs)
And this ^ is why this is a totally ambigious question.
When someone says : ".. the chicken or the egg?" -you assume that it is implied > "..the chicken or the 'chicken'-egg".
If we are to assume that it's "..the chicken or any egg, not just chicken-eggs", then the question is flat-out just a troll. Which is why I don't like the question, since people will have long discussions about it, when in reality, it comes down to specifying different things from the question, in order to remove every bit of ambigious information.
And, as they mention in the video, there couldn't have been a point in history (based on our definitions) where two birds mated and it produced a new species. So, if we're going by "..the chicken or the (chicken)-egg", the chicken would've come first. That chicken would reproduce with another bird of its species, and so evolution would continue to evolve it to the chickens we have today.
Well every eggs will give birth to a child (accept they are consumed by humans)
@@trantri7265 No, only fertilized eggs hatch, unfertilized ones don't
@lesleyjaneuk the rooster
seeds V.S plants... which came first?🤔🤔🤔
Proto-plants XD
Plants, they evolved for a long time to be able to have seeds
But how did they multiply in the first place in order to evolve if they didn't have seeds
Caitlin Prichett ever heard of seedless plants?
Caitlin Prichett get your middle school biology textbook...
Drinking game:
Take a shot every time he says chicken
Snebby I’m ok
Lol
Lol yee
I'm dead XD
Ok
*Before watching this video i was confused that what came first chicken or an egg*
*_But Now_*
*I am confused that i came from an human Beings'body or an animal's*
Damn it, it converted my brain into something out of the world
Yash jaiN both a human is an animal
Mammal.
Your profile picture made me thought I had a hair on my screen 😂
Anonymous You must have a sad life to direct this question to any religion that believes in god.
I've been scrolling through the comments for a good while now, and there's plenty of religious people and religion-hating people here.
Chicken or egg: egg
THE egg came from another animal who evolved into the chicken, but all the genetic variation happens when the egg is made, so the egg
chicken or chicken egg: Chicken
Since the egg came first but the chicken egg has to be laid by a chicken, the chicken came first.
Thanks for coming to my Ted talk.
Oh, neither. *Cookies started it all.*
And BTW, if you believe in god, think about this:
*What created God?*
If you don't,
*What started the big bang?*
Yeah, I have no idea either.
I think one possibility for the big bang is the recurring universe theory.
MrHax22 That is indeed true, god was always there.
Viridiel Lorael He was saying he disagreed with it.
The God I worship is not created, He's eternal
***** Cookies don't need to be baked
PROVE THAT THE EARTH IS ROUND NOT FLAT
lol
Crafty xz hahahahahha
Wth? The earth is a cylinder.....
Earth is a doughnut
lol
6 years ago !
Still I am watching it 😀
Cheeks Mohan yeah man!
Now you have the right answer. Y, thinks about this way. All mothers know how to take care of their young. However, you may be surprised at how much knowledge and care is required to hatch an egg. The right humidity, temperature, and turning at the correct angle - every 3 hours - are all critical to egg care. Not to mention that there are two threads holding the yolk in the middle of the egg white (to keep the yolk in the middle of the egg white). How did it come to be and why are they able to do it? The eggs without mom's hatching is impossible to
Now you can buy automatic hatching machines, because people have discovered the chicken's secrets through scientific studies. If scientific studies can help us to get knowledge, then there's no doubt there is “wisdom” in your genes which instruct creatures on when to grow what and even the season, direction, and distance for migratory birds. (Have you ever “cheated” by GPS? Think about it how hard navigating without one is.)
If we understand that "genetic code ATCG...TTCCATGGGCCCT....." is "wisdom", then many important mysteries of living creatures can be solved. The wisdom in the genes of the first generation can pass down through the generations, until the present day. If we acknowledge that, then a "wise" programmer is the only answer.
How to relate to the thousands of years ago Bible, the only literature in human history with creation record. Then God said, “Let the earth sprout vegetation, plants yielding seed, and fruit trees on the earth bearing fruit after their kind with seed in them”; and it was so. ...every living creature that moves, with which the waters swarmed after their kind, and every winged bird after its kind.
Now Gene means: The proposed word traced from the Greek word genos, meaning "birth", offspring and procreation. Are there difference between gene and after its kind?
If one doesn't want to accept the existence of a "programmer", then he must accept that everything that happened in this world came about through pure random chance, and that everything is empty and meaningless in the end.
Take a minute here: mnfedu.com/%E4%B8%80%E5%88%86%E9%92%9F-%E6%9C%89%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B%E7%9A%84-%E7%94%9F%E5%91%BD%E7%A8%8B%E5%BC%8F%E4%BD%88%E9%81%93%E5%BC%95%E8%A8%80. This message is very powerful.
4 years comment ha?
the chicken came first cuz if the egg came first the egg will not be able to be hatched without a chicken. the chicken came first that gave birth to eggs the eggs hatched and BOOM chickens.
1930s people: well find out how to make life on earth.
2019: ”did the chicken or the egg come first”
A&A TH-cam there was life on earth way before 1930 I doubt that’s something 1930s people wanted for the future if was already there
Isn’t it 2013?
The and egg
2013* B)
2013?
Which came first the chicken or the egg??
Chicken ➕ Egg equals the Chigg
Chigga
Wrong. Bean
Gaming Land lol
Nah Chegg is the way
Literally the whole video:CHICKEN CHICKEN CHICKEN CHICKEN CHICKEN CHICKEN CHICKEN CHICKEN CHICKEN CHICKEN CHICKEN 🐔🐣EGG EGG EGG EGG EGG EGG EGG EGG EGG EGG EGG EGG EGG EGG
Tenth liek lel xd rawer
Krypto Chris
no.. just no
No it’s the chegg
╔┓┏╦━━╦┓╔┓╔━━╗
║┗┛║┗━╣┃║┃║ X X ║
║┏┓║┏━╣┗╣┗╣╰╯║
╚┛┗╩━━╩━╩━╩━━╝
tradewise wow how did you type that?
This are the type of question I always thought 3:00 in the morning, and still can't get over it.
Y, thinks about this way. All mothers know how to take care of their young. However, you may be surprised at how much knowledge and care is required to hatch an egg. The right humidity, temperature, and turning at the correct angle - every 3 hours - are all critical to egg care. Not to mention that there are two threads holding the yolk in the middle of the egg white (to keep the yolk in the middle of the egg white). How did it come to be and why are they able to do it? The eggs without mom's hatching is impossible to
Now you can buy automatic hatching machines, because people have discovered the chicken's secrets through scientific studies. If scientific studies can help us to get knowledge, then there's no doubt there is “wisdom” in your genes which instruct creatures on when to grow what and even the season, direction, and distance for migratory birds. (Have you ever “cheated” by GPS? Think about it how hard navigating without one is.)
If we understand that "genetic code ATCG...TTCCATGGGCCCT....." is "wisdom", then many important mysteries of living creatures can be solved. The wisdom in the genes of the first generation can pass down through the generations, until the present day. If we acknowledge that, then a "wise" programmer is the only answer.
How to relate to the thousands of years ago Bible, the only literature in human history with creation record. Then God said, “Let the earth sprout vegetation, plants yielding seed, and fruit trees on the earth bearing fruit after their kind with seed in them”; and it was so. ...every living creature that moves, with which the waters swarmed after their kind, and every winged bird after its kind.
Now Gene means: The proposed word traced from the Greek word genos, meaning "birth", offspring and procreation. Are there difference between gene and after its kind?
If one doesn't want to accept the existence of a "programmer", then he must accept that everything that happened in this world came about through pure random chance, and that everything is empty and meaningless in the end.
Take a minute here: mnfedu.com/%E4%B8%80%E5%88%86%E9%92%9F-%E6%9C%89%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B%E7%9A%84-%E7%94%9F%E5%91%BD%E7%A8%8B%E5%BC%8F%E4%BD%88%E9%81%93%E5%BC%95%E8%A8%80. This message is very powerful.
Q: Which came first, the 'chicken' or the 'egg'?
Me an intellectual: The Proto-Rooster came first
Me an intelectual: How can a rooster lays an egg?
@@roelsvideosandstuffs1513 Ikr right? Roosters are men
Y’all don’t get it 😂😂😂 it “came” first
@@meowkai3255 what dies CAMEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEÈEEEEÈEÈEÈÈÈEEÈEEEEEEE
@@meowkai3255 haahahaha... im comiiiiing...
*Me:* Egg came first!
*Friend:* Where did the egg come from?
*Me:* TESCOOO
So funny xD
Chicken came first cause God created animals not eggs therefor god created a chicken not an egg
DJ.W god and science dont mix, in many cases is ilogic
Daniel Bernal Cordoba Hehe..Am agree with you bruh✌
DJ.W actually god did not just create animals....He created all living first ;)
A circle has no beginning...
That's craziness. Every natural circle (there are basically none) slowly developed into a circle, it had to start somewhere.
Easier explanation: 2 different birds mated and "accidentally" laid a chicken egg.
So those bird came from egg only .. so egg came first. :) :)
Pretty sure that’s wrong man, it’s a gene mutation between the same birds that happens to get passed down and selectively breed. Like the definition of a species is pretty much anything that can successfully mate together. I think there have been a few rare examples of sterile interspecies.
@@monhi64 that definition is not fully correct and only reason it is still used is because it is easier for newbies and normal people.
The *CHEGG*
Hello Random Person Looking Through The Comments hahaha you are so funny 😂😂😂😭😭😭
FBI OPEN UP! Elon ??
👌👌👌
The *EGGCKIN*
And Splatoon 2 is having a splatfest on this
Arilio me too
Arilio me too
I just wanted answers for the teams, im on team egg
meme_star T_T I think splatfest should now be called smarties VS dummies
Same, team egg
But who made the Egg?? (mysterious music in the background)
Pedro Santana, proto chicken. Did you even watch the video?
Lionel Vonk dude i said it because of the video !! because there's one part when he said, so who made the egg
DA CHICEN FROM DA FUTURE
Pedro Fit science (evolution) made the egg
gyrex God made the first organism,if you think about it,there will always be a greater being,and somehow it will be linked to "God".Even if life was an accident,someone must have made something,like an organism,all god has to do is add a void and an organism and a few planets,that is all god has to do,then,zither magic happens.
IF you just say "egg" then an "egg" hatched the first "chicken" BUT only a CHICKEN can lay a "Chicken" egg
The answer is 42
jollow250 That Is The Answer To Everything!
No the answer is "A"
Impossible Quiz Reference
LiamGC Gaming no.. it's a reference to the hitchhiker's guide to the universe (or something like that)
always :)
Finally I can die in peace
Ronseru Bhandari Hey i saw now the video and thats what i wanted to say!!!
And it was this day, that the splatoon 2 community flooded this comment section
"The omelette came first, the omelette is the reason the chicken and the egg exist."
-Happy Chaos
this vid made my brain hurt
ihascupquake candy cool
no, isn't
mistyhart then go watch nigahiga's video on this, if you're a super logical person it will make your brain hurt even more… cuz he uses algibrian 😂
Pablo Martinez Treat people how you want to be treated
me too.#team chicken first
TH-cam algorithm be like:
2013: nah
2014: ehhh
2015: nope
2016: nuh uh
2017: hmmm
2018: almost there...
2019: NOW!!! EXPLODE THESE MORTAL’S MINDS
So dead
Unoriginal. Not funny
Telx I never said it was original 😂 I see these comments everywhere
@@briezyx2929 we know its not original but saying it makes the chat more boring
BriezyX always happens to me
Science: egg, bc dinosaurs laid eggs,
Religion: Prob. Chicken
As a religious person with lack of science knowledge, in my religion it didn't mentioned clearly but it mentioned everything is created in a pair.
So to my own understanding I would prefer chicken come first as a pair, and the hen laid eggs.
"How did the chicken come to existence without an egg?" this is rather a stupid question tbh unless you want a scientific explanation then you might go deep in early stage of existence.
Otherwise, the question is actually provocative since if God is able to bring something into existence it's easy for Him to create pair of chickens out of thin air.
Note: Religion is neither go against science 100% or supporting it 100%. In religious perspective, science would be explanation of how some things happening and why is it happening in logical ways. While at the same time, religion in general already make things simpler for us so that we could balanced things even better. It's not wrong to study science in general in fact there are many religious people become scientist.
I agree with you.
CookieeMonstarr666 True very true I agree
@@lifeisshortdontwasteitread2830 Well, you probably haven't study Islam I guess.
But then we are left with a new question “what came first the proto chicken or the proto chicken egg?”
I thought the egg came first bcus it was form by the atoms and molecules in the air.
It should be chicken because religiously, according to the bible, the chicken was first
@@midnight_mocha9659The egg came first. Hard external eggs that can be laid on land, known as amniotic eggs, were a significant development for vertebrates. These types of eggs evolved around 325 million years ago, long before true birds appeared in the fossil record. While chickens likely evolved from red jungle fowl around 50 million years ago, the first chicken egg would have been laid by an ancestor of modern chickens after genetic differences accumulated during the domestication process.
oh
Why do people deny evolution? The facts are there, the scientific proof is there. Why do people insist it doesn't exist?
No facts to support evolution at all, just a theory and before you go to try and tell me that a theory is backed up by facts, it isn't. A theory is actually backed up behind perception of opinion. Theory of Evolution has been proven wrong and will continue to be, cause it is an opinion with no facts to support. God created everything, this isn't opinion, but fact, whether you chose to believe it or not is your choice.
VinnyPepeTV And is God backed by facts? No. In fact, the existence of God has much LESS evidence than evolution.
VinnyPepeTV And there is countless pieces of evidence for evolution. Obviously, you require education.
"Theory of Evolution has been proven wrong and will continue to be, cause it is an opinion with no facts to support. God created everything, this isn't opinion, but fact, whether you chose to believe it or not is your choice." => You made my day xD
BTW, I'm christian.
The Guy NONE of you have given ANY evidence for the existence of God.
The problem with this question is that there can't be a first chicken. Evolution states that over time, changes accumulate, but, there is no exact moment when a proto-chicken turns into a chicken.
If you go back pre pre pre pre proto chicken. There was no egg. No brainer. Chicken mutated from something with no eggs, to a species that needed hard shell eggs for protection. Chicken came first.
@Armadale Garbo | Environment & Gameplay Somehow this type question just straight up ignoring the existence of god.
@@paralyzer2304 god is fake (most likely)
@@paralyzer2304 cause he’s not real.
@@reynarocha6607 And what about your science? Could your science discover how humans are created?
1:05 Our world has evolved... Even elephants lay egg and lions come out of eggs 🤣🤣
Y, thinks about this way. All mothers know how to take care of their young. However, you may be surprised at how much knowledge and care is required to hatch an egg. The right humidity, temperature, and turning at the correct angle - every 3 hours - are all critical to egg care. Not to mention that there are two threads holding the yolk in the middle of the egg white (to keep the yolk in the middle of the egg white). How did it come to be and why are they able to do it? The eggs without mom's hatching is impossible to
Now you can buy automatic hatching machines, because people have discovered the chicken's secrets through scientific studies. If scientific studies can help us to get knowledge, then there's no doubt there is “wisdom” in your genes which instruct creatures on when to grow what and even the season, direction, and distance for migratory birds. (Have you ever “cheated” by GPS? Think about it how hard navigating without one is.)
If we understand that "genetic code ATCG...TTCCATGGGCCCT....." is "wisdom", then many important mysteries of living creatures can be solved. The wisdom in the genes of the first generation can pass down through the generations, until the present day. If we acknowledge that, then a "wise" programmer is the only answer.
How to relate to the thousands of years ago Bible, the only literature in human history with creation record. Then God said, “Let the earth sprout vegetation, plants yielding seed, and fruit trees on the earth bearing fruit after their kind with seed in them”; and it was so. ...every living creature that moves, with which the waters swarmed after their kind, and every winged bird after its kind.
Now Gene means: The proposed word traced from the Greek word genos, meaning "birth", offspring and procreation. Are there difference between gene and after its kind?
If one doesn't want to accept the existence of a "programmer", then he must accept that everything that happened in this world came about through pure random chance, and that everything is empty and meaningless in the end.
Take a minute here: mnfedu.com/%E4%B8%80%E5%88%86%E9%92%9F-%E6%9C%89%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B%E7%9A%84-%E7%94%9F%E5%91%BD%E7%A8%8B%E5%BC%8F%E4%BD%88%E9%81%93%E5%BC%95%E8%A8%80. This message is very powerful.
C H E G G
_C H E G G I N_
E C H
hahaha you are so funny 😂😂😂😭😭😭
What came first 😂 or 👌
Did anyone else came from the Splatfeast in Splatoon 2
Chicken Boiiis! Where y’all at
Me! Team Egg!
Me i am also team egg
Littleshroomer
Me!
BTW friend me!
- DatBoi33:)
#TeamEgg
Yep
How has Vsauce not made a video about this
is Sunday the first day of the week or Monday
PEDRO 21 Sunday is the first day of the week and it is not the part of the weekend .-. Saturday is the only weekend SINCE its singular😂😂😂But if you say weekends Friday and Saturday are it.
PEDRO 21 depends on the country and the calendar
Oh, monday is just the first day of hell.
Monday is the first WORK day of the week
PEDRO 21 sunday
I’ve literally only come here so I can choose the scientifically correct answer for March’s Splatfest.
Your Friend Joe :0 Lmao same
Who came here for the answer to the splatoon 2 splatfest
Let's say we go a few million years back : a couple of two primitive birds create, fertilize and lay an egg, but a genetic mutation occured during the development of the egg. Due to this, once it hatches, the bird is one step closer to a modern chicken.
Therefore, applying this process of though to the following mutations that will lead to the modern chicken, the egg obviously came first, as the birds which created it cannot be called chickens yet
But chicken have been around for only 1000 year because chicken is domestic bird . They are here because lot of selective breeding that why we have problem deciding where they come from
I hella agree with you
What happens if you go back pass the couple of birds? They become species that don’t pay hard shell eggs. Then the chicken would be first. But to think of the exact timing of when a proto chicken was inside a Porto chicken egg. The Porto chicken mutated in a chicken. The proto chicken egg came before the chicken. But the chicken came before the chicken eggs.
Imagine a guy X, the only son of his parents, with mother and father named A and B respectively goes back into the past. He marries A and later have a child { which is ultimately X }
Does that mean the son was his own father? Well , according to me, time does not move from PAST TO PRESENT TO FUTURE. Time moves in a loop, a circular and hence, an endless loop.
So to answer this question, I would say that egg was the reason that the chicken came while the chicken was the reason the egg came. Nothing among these 2 came first
Y, thinks about this way. All mothers know how to take care of their young. However, you may be surprised at how much knowledge and care is required to hatch an egg. The right humidity, temperature, and turning at the correct angle - every 3 hours - are all critical to egg care. Not to mention that there are two threads holding the yolk in the middle of the egg white (to keep the yolk in the middle of the egg white). How did it come to be and why are they able to do it? The eggs without mom's hatching is impossible to
Now you can buy automatic hatching machines, because people have discovered the chicken's secrets through scientific studies. If scientific studies can help us to get knowledge, then there's no doubt there is “wisdom” in your genes which instruct creatures on when to grow what and even the season, direction, and distance for migratory birds. (Have you ever “cheated” by GPS? Think about it how hard navigating without one is.)
If we understand that "genetic code ATCG...TTCCATGGGCCCT....." is "wisdom", then many important mysteries of living creatures can be solved. The wisdom in the genes of the first generation can pass down through the generations, until the present day. If we acknowledge that, then a "wise" programmer is the only answer.
How to relate to the thousands of years ago Bible, the only literature in human history with creation record. Then God said, “Let the earth sprout vegetation, plants yielding seed, and fruit trees on the earth bearing fruit after their kind with seed in them”; and it was so. ...every living creature that moves, with which the waters swarmed after their kind, and every winged bird after its kind.
Now Gene means: The proposed word traced from the Greek word genos, meaning "birth", offspring and procreation. Are there difference between gene and after its kind?
If one doesn't want to accept the existence of a "programmer", then he must accept that everything that happened in this world came about through pure random chance, and that everything is empty and meaningless in the end.
Take a minute here: mnfedu.com/%E4%B8%80%E5%88%86%E9%92%9F-%E6%9C%89%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B%E7%9A%84-%E7%94%9F%E5%91%BD%E7%A8%8B%E5%BC%8F%E4%BD%88%E9%81%93%E5%BC%95%E8%A8%80. This message is very powerful.
This video just left an even bigger question unanswered. Which was the first egg in the evoltion timeline of chickens and where did that egg come from?
Y, thinks about this way. All mothers know how to take care of their young. However, you may be surprised at how much knowledge and care is required to hatch an egg. The right humidity, temperature, and turning at the correct angle - every 3 hours - are all critical to egg care. Not to mention that there are two threads holding the yolk in the middle of the egg white (to keep the yolk in the middle of the egg white). How did it come to be and why are they able to do it? The eggs without mom's hatching is impossible to
Now you can buy automatic hatching machines, because people have discovered the chicken's secrets through scientific studies. If scientific studies can help us to get knowledge, then there's no doubt there is “wisdom” in your genes which instruct creatures on when to grow what and even the season, direction, and distance for migratory birds. (Have you ever “cheated” by GPS? Think about it how hard navigating without one is.)
If we understand that "genetic code ATCG...TTCCATGGGCCCT....." is "wisdom", then many important mysteries of living creatures can be solved. The wisdom in the genes of the first generation can pass down through the generations, until the present day. If we acknowledge that, then a "wise" programmer is the only answer.
How to relate to the thousands of years ago Bible, the only literature in human history with creation record. Then God said, “Let the earth sprout vegetation, plants yielding seed, and fruit trees on the earth bearing fruit after their kind with seed in them”; and it was so. ...every living creature that moves, with which the waters swarmed after their kind, and every winged bird after its kind.
Now Gene means: The proposed word traced from the Greek word genos, meaning "birth", offspring and procreation. Are there difference between gene and after its kind?
If one doesn't want to accept the existence of a "programmer", then he must accept that everything that happened in this world came about through pure random chance, and that everything is empty and meaningless in the end.
Take a minute here: mnfedu.com/%E4%B8%80%E5%88%86%E9%92%9F-%E6%9C%89%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B%E7%9A%84-%E7%94%9F%E5%91%BD%E7%A8%8B%E5%BC%8F%E4%BD%88%E9%81%93%E5%BC%95%E8%A8%80. This message is very powerful.
Or just take the harry potter approach: "A circle has no beginning/end"
Sweetie Paw
But everything must have a beginning.