He just tries to be as objective as possible, which I respect. I do think James White should have been Super Bowl 51 MVP because he was just as instrumental to the comeback as Brady
@Call Me, BLEGH Me, If You Wanna Reach Me to be fair fuckin everyone is on PEDs in american sports lol, i dont think it makes a massive difference. still, fuck tom br*dy
29 rush yards on 6 attempts (4.8 average) 2 TD 110 rec yards on 14 rec. (7.9 average) 1 TD A 2pt conversion on a direct stap. I think any other year, he would be a shoe in for it. It was a great performance.
Don't you just love it when gritty, hard working wide receivers win these SB MVP awards? Lookin at you Julian Edelman and (daughter dater) Cooper Kupp.
@@narufan987 It's like when old ESPN commentators would describe white NFL players as hard working, percivering, and a good person on and off the field. There is a joke about this where people call white NFL players "Someone I would let date ny daughter"
That is impressive but it should be noted that all of those yards, except for 1 catch, came from return yards only. he busted 1 great return which made up almost half of those yards. The rest were from the 6 other returns Jones made which were just your typical average returns that pack up yards as a result of getting alot of returns. And 1 56 yards catch. Jones also had a fumble. Flacco had almost 300 yards, 3 tds and 0 pics and 0 fumbles. The second half they mainly just game managed so he was not putting up stats as much as the first half.
@@jackwilson5152 I agree with this completely. It makes so much sense. Joe played a completely masterful game. Executing offensive attack and then you like said managing in the second half. Couldn’t have played a more perfect game. He was definitely the most valuable player that day. The defense that needed a quarterback. On a side related note, I don’t really remember the full game but in a similar situation I always wondered how Desmond Howard beat out Brett Favre for Super Bowl MVP?
I was honestly expecting Aaron Donald or Von Miller to get MVP in this recent superbowl, but Kupp winning it makes sense considering how clutch he was on that final drive
Aaron Donald deserved it imo, as he pretty much was getting double and triple teamed the whole night and still put up insane numbers, but Kupp got the game winning drive so I don't really mind
Though to be fair, if any quarterback deserved to be carried to a title, it was Peyton Manning. After carrying all of those Colts offenses with little to no payoff, it was nice to see him catch a break.
@@vulcanraven9701 SB48 is a good reason why Peyton deserved to get carried when he carried the 2013 squad to the super bowl with 59 TDs in regular season +2 playoff games, only to have the center to snap the ball over his head and offensive line get beat when he throwing the ball so the tipped ball gets picked for a touchdown- not to mention special teams getting up a TD at the start of the second half
@@vulcanraven9701 "choked badly", yeah totally had nothing to do with the oline giving him half a second to pass, and demaryious dropping and fumbling, and that 19th ranked defense playing like trash, and that 15th ranked run game doing nothing.
I was on this hill in 2017 and I’m still on the hill that James White should have won Super Bowl MVP in Super Bowl 51, he had 139 all purpose yards, 14 catches, and 3 total touchdowns… he also ran in a 2 point conversion and the game winning touchdown
Brady gave his MVP cars in 49 and 51 to Butler and White. Not sure about the Tampa one since by then I was better at tuning out the constant praise for every little thing he ever did.
@@enervat1on Well, how many people start showing their age at 42, show it for most of their age 43 season, and then play like they're ten years younger at age 44 without better living through chemistry? This wasn't the TB12 diet, it was the HGH diet. Hopefully, someone finally catches him.
@Call Me, BLEGH Me, If You Wanna Reach Me The evidence is there. The only question is if the NFL is willing to say it after 20 years of building this guy up.
What I've always loved about Dexter Jackson winning SBMVP was that he will forever be associated with guys from those legendary Bucs defenses, despite not being much but an average role player. I personally would have preferred it go to Brooks... But Jackson winning it shows the romantic side of football... That anyone can show up in the biggest game and be a key contributor.
I wouldn't say the ONLY. If he had put up his usual modest stat lines instead en route to three SB wins, he still gets in because A) QB for three SB champs, and 2) a Dallas Cowboy. Plus he had that no-nonsense demeanor that OG sportswriters orgasmed about.
@@RicardoAGuitar Ok yeah I suppose he could have played a bit worse and still won 3 (probably 2 though; do much less in the 92 NFCCG and they lose that one) and people would treat it the same, as we've seen with Tommy where it doesn't matter how he plays, just that his team wins (also more relevant in CCGs than SBs). But we agree in principle, it just depends on how you read my post lol
@Fries I'm not concerned with his volume stats because, of course, great O-line and possible GOAT RB, you didn't need 300 yards and 4 TDs from Aikman. But with the advantages he had, and the physical gifts that he had, his efficiency should have been MUCH better
I watched Super Bowl 3 and Joe Namath played pretty good even by today standards. He had 3 drops and otherwise was on the money for over 70% of his attempts. He also made some pretty good off platform throws and showcased his strong arm. He had 1 “bad” pass I felt like and 1 really good pass. Most of the plays were easy routes taken because of the way the defense played them.
If only the colts played Johnny U the whole game and not just the 4th quarter already down 16, he was injured during the season but was cleared to play in the super bowl and by the time he finally got to play he got them to score their only points, and he almost got the same stats as Namath in a quarter of a game, Namath didn’t deserve the mvp and his running back Matt snell should’ve gotten it, Matt snell had 160 all purpose yards against the best defense in football that year, almost as much as namath, and didn’t turn the ball over, Namath is hands down the Worst super bowl mvp ever
@@johnbeck2837 Watch the game, he realistically should’ve had a 70%+ completion with a good amount of yardage. It’s very easy to look at stats but in terms of film and analysis I thought he played pretty good. Certainly nowhere near the worst we’ve seen from a SBMVP. He contributed a good amount on their scoring drives and considering he played in an under center era with minimal spread and quicker pressure which lowers the quality of targets I can say that’s enough. Individually based on games I’ve seen from 60s/70s Quarterbacks he is easily Top 5 for that era.
SB 51 should’ve gone to James White. He had crazy yards, more points scored than any other player in SB history, and single-handedly carried the Patriots to the win. It was a really stupid decision for Brady as MVP, and even Brady himself said that James White should have won it.
I don't know about stupid. Brady broke the records for attempts, completions, and passing yards in that Super Bowl. Yes, he had a pick 6 in the first half, but he later threw for 2 touchdowns, a 2-pt conversion, and White's game-winning touchdown was on a lateral from Brady. I think it was defensible.
@@matthewthayer9316 It was 100% name value. James White set the Super Bowl records for points and receptions, scored the game winning TD that involved going through two guys, and was consistently open throughout the game. It’s also not like Brady was perfect in the second half, as he nearly threw 3 picks in a row on their final scoring drive. It’s kind of a toss up, but I would have given it to White for being the Pats best weapon all game. I wear his jersey with pride
It’s simply insane that Nick apparently just decided that the 2017-18 NFCCG & SBLII were going to be, by far, the two best games of his career. 7 Touchdown’s certainly nice, but the 2013 Raiders sucked all kinds of a••.
Can we just give Bart Starr more credit where credit is due? The guy won 5 Championships in 7 years in an era where QB's could get murdered. I know he won't though because of Lombardi and all the other hall of famers he played with.
It's a cliche but Starr's true value can be found in his leadership and ability to call a game. He was one of the few - maybe even the only - player Lombardi wouldn't chew out (publicly) and he called his own game. This was a man who only lost one post season game in his career as a starter and was so revered by his peers they named the "Good Guy Award" after him.
Dude...you had to be there. Otis Anderson kept the high powered Bills offense off of the field. I think they set a record for the longest drive in SB history. Honestly, the OL should have gotten the award, or Parcells. The game plan was amazing.
That drive is a symbol for what I like in an offensive: a mix of running and passing, clutch in third down, controlling the clock, and ultimately punching it in for six. That along with that defensive performance - it's no wonder why BB's gameplan ended up in Canton.
Ummm Belichick should have gotten the MVP. What that defense did holding that powerful K Gun offense that put up 51 points the previous game in the AFC championship game was phenomenal.
John Stallworth should have won it in SB14. Bradshaw had 3 picks and Stallworth has well over 100 yards, the go ahead touchdown, plus another huge spectacular catch on the game sealing drive
Brady is that guy that found 6 silver dollars and knew to sell them on the internet instead of buy a burger with them to get multiples times the worth in profit.
Barry your standards are too high for RB efficiency...if an RB can average a first down every three carries and sustain that for ~30 carries/~150 yards, that alone will win you the game most of the time, especially in previous eras. Can't ask for much more than that
Malcom Butler should have won mvp for that goal line pick alone. I don’t care how well anyone played. That play won the game on its own in the craziest winning play in any game ever, let alone the Super Bowl
@@nickwright4079 and Brady’s 4 TDs don’t mean anything if Butler doesn’t pick that ball off because it’s a TD (or very likely one as there’s always the chance a WR drops a pass) if Butler doesn’t play it perfectly. Though I also don’t like giving an MVP nod for a game over a single play, even if that play is very hard to top due to how crucial it was at the time.
as theqbschool just pointed out yesterday, nfl quarterbacking is easier in every non personnel aspect... close hashes make short passes really really easy but then u factor in the talent of defenses... qbschool didn't say that exactly, but it's implied
"A classic tom brady performance, he was bad for three qtrs, and then made the plays to win it at the end of the game" this is how I describe Tony Romo and dak Prescott
I remember growing up with people saying that Tony Romo was a choker in clutch situations. I also remember absolutely dreading December because that's where potential playoff seasons went to die under Romo
Shout out to Jake Delhomme in Super Bowl 38. Threw for 3 TD’s no picks and 323 yards in a game where the panthers just came short in a loss that wasnt his fault
Great video, btw video idea: A video on how ridiculous it is to compare Lebron leaving Cleveland to Miami vs KD’s OKC to Golden state situation. I see it so much in basketball circles and when you apply context to it, it’s not even remotely close .
Absolutely. When you consider his three touchdowns, that crucial 2pt conversion, and the fact he had over 100 yards receiving, James White was the unsung hero of that game
@@Ultimatecheezeburger Lmfao White broke and tied multiple SB records that game - Most receiving yds for an RB - Broke Thomas’ record for most receptions - Tied record for most TDs along with Terrell Davis - Tied for most receptions in a game in NFL playoff history (not just SB) Quit forgetting what non QBs do. Shit like this is why Barry’s channel exists
Imagine having two pick 6's in a Superbowl and not being the MVP. Both Malcolm Butler and Brady should of been SB MVP in that game against Seattle cause Brady did dice up the LOB in that 4th quarter.
You definitely underrate OJ Anderson and Desmond Howard’s performances. I guess sometimes you have to see the full game and understand the circumstances to appreciate what happened.
Barry Kudos to you for being able to accurately grade Brady’s accomplishments notwithstanding your undying love for the guy. Originally I said to myself here we go again and notwithstanding the constant flow of derogative commentary the grades were pretty much on point and in line with other grades that were given to other recipients of the trophy. I know you will never reconcile with the guy but I had to salute the effort of being objective in your grading and ignoring how you feel about the player.
Prior to getting to the SB, Flacco's playoff run was memorable and rather bizarre on a few levels so getting SB MVP makes sense though it should've went to Jacoby Jones. Not complaining tho, a win's a win
1 catch for a 56 yard td, and a fumble should have gotten super bowl mvp? Lol what? Flacco had 3 tds 0 pics. Also was not bizarre, Flacco was dominant in playoffs in 2010, 2011, 2012 and 2014.
For Super Bowl 41 the MVP should’ve been Colts Safety Bob Sanders who had a Forced Fumble and Int. Both of which were huge plays that got the Colts extra opportunities on Offense.
3:11 I would’ve given it to Art Shell The raiders O line handling the purple people eaters was why Davis and Stabler shined. Shell specifically shut Jim Marshall down to the point that Marshall did not get a single tackle the entire game.
They jumped the gun and awarded Dexter Jackson MVP before the end of the game. Almost exactly after they announced it, Dwight smith had his second pick six of the game. He probably would have won MVP if they waited until the game was over
I’ll vouch for Super Bowl 12. That game was absolutely DOMINATED by the Dallas Defense. That’s an A+ there. Also for Super Bowl 22? Timmy Smith ran for over 200 yards in that one. Probably should’ve gone to the entire offensive line.
I still say Super Bowl 42 MVP should've been Justin Tuck that whole d-line dominated but Tuck was the star performer and didn't let Brady as much as breathe all day
I experienced my first migraine a while back and I couldn’t have any lights on for a good part of the day Bc of how bad it hurt. It feels like your head getting ripped open. Now imagine that playing in the biggest game of the year and getting hit haha
Kupp should have gotten a better rating. He was legit getting triple teamed at points and still managed to carry the offense when it mattered the most. Absolute animal
Can't believe James White wasn't mentioned in the SB 51 part. Brady was obviously good that game (well, the second half), but White should've won MVP. One of the best Super Bowl performances ever.
102 yards on 21 carries (almost 5 yards per carry) and a TD, no turnovers, in a game where owning 40 minutes of the clock won the Giants the game is a D+? Sure Thomas was more talented, but Anderson lead drives of 9+ minutes by constantly moving the chains on the ground. I'm not saying it's an A, but it's better than a D+.
@@RicardoAGuitar Fine, I'm not arguing he didn't. Thomas played phenomenal, but he lost. Anderson was still a HUGE part of the Giants' offense and strategy of dominating the clock and he played very well himself. Lesser performances were given better grades.
The weirdest thing about that Super Bowl is that it is incredibly underrated as a well played game. No turnovers on either side. Not that many flags. Both teams played their style on offense. Playmakers made plays. Very well coached game. A backup, game manager QB played mostly mistake free, including several huge 3rd down completions and a big TD right before the half. But it's remembered for exactly one thing and that thing doesn't fit that narrative.
Since I am a total Tom Brady Homer I was interested to see how you would rank him, so I watched this. Soon it became clear you do not like Tom Brady so then I wanted to see how objective you could be. I would like to sincerely congratulate you on you objective, mature, fair and honest assessment of his MVPs. You could've mentioned that he gave Malcolm Butler the truck from his Superbowl 49 MVP, thus making it clear even Brady didn't think he deserved that. Still a fair assessment. I am now subscribed.
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 79 | คู่เอก "ก้องชัย vs อาเมียร์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/WfPSA1A0NHc/mqdefault.jpg)
Barry having to give Tom brady multiple a grades for super bowl mvps must be excruciating.
He just tries to be as objective as possible, which I respect. I do think James White should have been Super Bowl 51 MVP because he was just as instrumental to the comeback as Brady
@Call Me, BLEGH Me, If You Wanna Reach Me LOL you're very objective there
I think the problem is there’s many games where they would have similar games to Brady yet Brady would get A.
@Call Me, BLEGH Me, If You Wanna Reach Me to be fair fuckin everyone is on PEDs in american sports lol, i dont think it makes a massive difference. still, fuck tom br*dy
@@josephhanicak7922 He gave him a D for SB36? Back then he was a nobody who beat an all time great Rams team.
I’m convinced we all collectively imagined Flacco’s 2012 post season
just like everyone said 2012 would be the end of the world.
Will always love Flacco here in Baltimore. 💜
That man is
E
L
I
T
E
Even as a ravens fan, that run feels like it was a mirage
I was thinking of what he would rate the many of Tom Brady's MVPs
Ravens fan, we overpaid tf outta him
When I saw this I dropped everything, no offense to Jaquiski Tartt
just like Julio jones when hes near the endzone
@@enervat1on (channeling my best Coach 30 impression): The moment was too big, not really an ath-a-lete, just gon’ piss down my leg. 😂
Stop 😢
Or Nelson Agholor
Brady himself so strongly believed that James White deserved to win Super Bowl 51 MVP that he even gave the truck he won as a MVP prize to White.
29 rush yards on 6 attempts (4.8 average) 2 TD
110 rec yards on 14 rec. (7.9 average) 1 TD
A 2pt conversion on a direct stap.
I think any other year, he would be a shoe in for it. It was a great performance.
Who to choose for MVP? The Michigan man who’s the face of the NFL? or the Wisconsin running back? Easy decision for the NFl
Don't you just love it when gritty, hard working wide receivers win these SB MVP awards? Lookin at you Julian Edelman and (daughter dater) Cooper Kupp.
Don't forget about the OG Fred Biletnikoff
Real lunchbox players
High motor high energy
I never got the daughter dater joke, mind explaining?
@@narufan987 It's like when old ESPN commentators would describe white NFL players as hard working, percivering, and a good person on and off the field. There is a joke about this where people call white NFL players "Someone I would let date ny daughter"
Jacoby Jones had the most all purpose yards in SuperBowl history. Flacco had a great game but Jones had a record breaking night and should've won MVP
True
That is impressive but it should be noted that all of those yards, except for 1 catch, came from return yards only. he busted 1 great return which made up almost half of those yards. The rest were from the 6 other returns Jones made which were just your typical average returns that pack up yards as a result of getting alot of returns. And 1 56 yards catch.
Jones also had a fumble.
Flacco had almost 300 yards, 3 tds and 0 pics and 0 fumbles. The second half they mainly just game managed so he was not putting up stats as much as the first half.
@@jackwilson5152 I agree with this completely. It makes so much sense. Joe played a completely masterful game. Executing offensive attack and then you like said managing in the second half. Couldn’t have played a more perfect game. He was definitely the most valuable player that day. The defense that needed a quarterback.
On a side related note, I don’t really remember the full game but in a similar situation I always wondered how Desmond Howard beat out Brett Favre for Super Bowl MVP?
8:29 "a very good outing that falls short of legendary"
his grade: *B-*
Lol fr
That’s what I’m saying
that’s actually hilarious
B- is above average
@@Rekcha an outing that falls short of legendary isnt “barely above average” lol
I was honestly expecting Aaron Donald or Von Miller to get MVP in this recent superbowl, but Kupp winning it makes sense considering how clutch he was on that final drive
He deserved it for all his clutch performances in the season. He carried that team so hard.
All due respect did Von really due anything this last superbowl?
Aaron Donald deserved it imo, as he pretty much was getting double and triple teamed the whole night and still put up insane numbers, but Kupp got the game winning drive so I don't really mind
@@Coy_Koi he just casually had 2 sacks. Nothing much bro
@@Coy_Koi Miller had two sacks. He has like 4 in superbowl history. He's amazing
''QB by default'' > pretty much the NFL awards in a nutshell
2 outa 3 of Mahomes Super Bowl mvps lol
“…To help carry Peyton Manning’s corpse to his second ring” 😂😂😂
Though to be fair, if any quarterback deserved to be carried to a title, it was Peyton Manning. After carrying all of those Colts offenses with little to no payoff, it was nice to see him catch a break.
@@vulcanraven9701 So you’re saying you’d rather have another Dan Marino? Literally nobody would agree with you there
@@vulcanraven9701 SB48 is a good reason why Peyton deserved to get carried when he carried the 2013 squad to the super bowl with 59 TDs in regular season +2 playoff games, only to have the center to snap the ball over his head and offensive line get beat when he throwing the ball so the tipped ball gets picked for a touchdown- not to mention special teams getting up a TD at the start of the second half
@@vulcanraven9701 "choked badly", yeah totally had nothing to do with the oline giving him half a second to pass, and demaryious dropping and fumbling, and that 19th ranked defense playing like trash, and that 15th ranked run game doing nothing.
I was on this hill in 2017 and I’m still on the hill that James White should have won Super Bowl MVP in Super Bowl 51, he had 139 all purpose yards, 14 catches, and 3 total touchdowns… he also ran in a 2 point conversion and the game winning touchdown
Brady gave his MVP cars in 49 and 51 to Butler and White. Not sure about the Tampa one since by then I was better at tuning out the constant praise for every little thing he ever did.
Yea to not even mention White in the video was a huge oversight
@@NoJobRob that’s exactly what I was saying, i was surprised when he didn’t mention him
20 points by one player - sb record!
MY MAN!! Been saying it for years and it’s why I bought a James White jersey
It’s not a joke huh. Barry with the character development, I’m here for it
he's trying to conjure up a Brady scandal with this continued praise
It's not development. It's regression
@@enervat1on Brady retired. The work is done.
@@enervat1on Well, how many people start showing their age at 42, show it for most of their age 43 season, and then play like they're ten years younger at age 44 without better living through chemistry? This wasn't the TB12 diet, it was the HGH diet. Hopefully, someone finally catches him.
@Call Me, BLEGH Me, If You Wanna Reach Me The evidence is there. The only question is if the NFL is willing to say it after 20 years of building this guy up.
What I've always loved about Dexter Jackson winning SBMVP was that he will forever be associated with guys from those legendary Bucs defenses, despite not being much but an average role player. I personally would have preferred it go to Brooks... But Jackson winning it shows the romantic side of football... That anyone can show up in the biggest game and be a key contributor.
Yea it’s pretty cool seeing no-names go above and beyond
Is Aikman's 1992-95 playoff run really underrated when it's the ONLY reason he's in the Hall of Fame?
I wouldn't say the ONLY. If he had put up his usual modest stat lines instead en route to three SB wins, he still gets in because A) QB for three SB champs, and 2) a Dallas Cowboy. Plus he had that no-nonsense demeanor that OG sportswriters orgasmed about.
@@RicardoAGuitar Ok yeah I suppose he could have played a bit worse and still won 3 (probably 2 though; do much less in the 92 NFCCG and they lose that one) and people would treat it the same, as we've seen with Tommy where it doesn't matter how he plays, just that his team wins (also more relevant in CCGs than SBs). But we agree in principle, it just depends on how you read my post lol
@Fries I'm not concerned with his volume stats because, of course, great O-line and possible GOAT RB, you didn't need 300 yards and 4 TDs from Aikman.
But with the advantages he had, and the physical gifts that he had, his efficiency should have been MUCH better
I watched Super Bowl 3 and Joe Namath played pretty good even by today standards. He had 3 drops and otherwise was on the money for over 70% of his attempts. He also made some pretty good off platform throws and showcased his strong arm. He had 1 “bad” pass I felt like and 1 really good pass. Most of the plays were easy routes taken because of the way the defense played them.
If only the colts played Johnny U the whole game and not just the 4th quarter already down 16, he was injured during the season but was cleared to play in the super bowl and by the time he finally got to play he got them to score their only points, and he almost got the same stats as Namath in a quarter of a game, Namath didn’t deserve the mvp and his running back Matt snell should’ve gotten it, Matt snell had 160 all purpose yards against the best defense in football that year, almost as much as namath, and didn’t turn the ball over, Namath is hands down the Worst super bowl mvp ever
@@johnbeck2837
Watch the game, he realistically should’ve had a 70%+ completion with a good amount of yardage. It’s very easy to look at stats but in terms of film and analysis I thought he played pretty good. Certainly nowhere near the worst we’ve seen from a SBMVP. He contributed a good amount on their scoring drives and considering he played in an under center era with minimal spread and quicker pressure which lowers the quality of targets I can say that’s enough. Individually based on games I’ve seen from 60s/70s Quarterbacks he is easily Top 5 for that era.
By today standards it still would’ve been boring
He perfectly managed that game and out guessed the Colts defense all day long.
I love how you get angrier and angrier the closer you get to the end.😂
That's because that was when Brady won it so much 😄
@@sam25669 Lol I know. I was waiting for it.
@@josephhanicak7922 You say that like it's a bad thing.
SB 51 should’ve gone to James White. He had crazy yards, more points scored than any other player in SB history, and single-handedly carried the Patriots to the win. It was a really stupid decision for Brady as MVP, and even Brady himself said that James White should have won it.
yup
No love for Wisconsin football players
I don't know about stupid. Brady broke the records for attempts, completions, and passing yards in that Super Bowl. Yes, he had a pick 6 in the first half, but he later threw for 2 touchdowns, a 2-pt conversion, and White's game-winning touchdown was on a lateral from Brady. I think it was defensible.
@@matthewthayer9316 It was 100% name value. James White set the Super Bowl records for points and receptions, scored the game winning TD that involved going through two guys, and was consistently open throughout the game. It’s also not like Brady was perfect in the second half, as he nearly threw 3 picks in a row on their final scoring drive. It’s kind of a toss up, but I would have given it to White for being the Pats best weapon all game. I wear his jersey with pride
Nick Foles really had the best SuperBowl performance ever.
Steve Young*
@@quantrellbishop9263 Almost as good as Tom Brady did that same game!
It’s simply insane that Nick apparently just decided that the 2017-18 NFCCG & SBLII were going to be, by far, the two best games of his career. 7 Touchdown’s certainly nice, but the 2013 Raiders sucked all kinds of a••.
not better than Steve Young
@@B-Mag better than Steve Young. Nick Foles SB goat
Can we just give Bart Starr more credit where credit is due? The guy won 5 Championships in 7 years in an era where QB's could get murdered. I know he won't though because of Lombardi and all the other hall of famers he played with.
He's in the HoF, which is no joke. It's hard to compare eras, but like much that happened long ago, he likely doesn't get the credit he deserves.
It's a cliche but Starr's true value can be found in his leadership and ability to call a game. He was one of the few - maybe even the only - player Lombardi wouldn't chew out (publicly) and he called his own game. This was a man who only lost one post season game in his career as a starter and was so revered by his peers they named the "Good Guy Award" after him.
I think he's mostly ignored because of the supporting cast he had. He had a team full of HOFers, similar to the celtics at that time.
Larry Fitz was 45 seconds away from getting a SB MVP and ring😭
The greatest playoff performer of all time never got the hardware he deserved 💔
that shit pisses me off forever
“No offense to Michael Vick” 😂😂
If Scott Norwood was more accurate my dad wouldn't have beaten me
Tough scene
I lost it on the edelman description “gritty and sneaky athletic” lmao great stuff
Malcolm Smith really peaked in that one Super Bowl and just became forgotten immediately
The Super Bowl MVP award is meaningless until Kirk Cousins wins it
you know he never plays good when the game is being watched by more than 20 people
So….Terrell Davis 150 yards 3 TDs gets the same grade as Eli in SB42? Wtf?
I actually agree with it, Eli beat goliath with clutch throws and memorable moments.
@@ryanallen9830 yeah so they should both be in the A range
It’s really because Eli beat Brady ,and we know this guy really hates Brady
@@ryanallen9830 TD playing with no sight and a migraine on top of huge stats. That’s A+.
Now I’m even more getting eager for more nba videos from Barry
No brainer selection no offense to Kim kardashian 😂
What.
White deserved the 51 MVP, he carried the team in the 4th quarter
Fr without White, the pats lose.
White had like 14 catches and the GW touchdown run. He definitely should’ve been MVP.
Dude...you had to be there. Otis Anderson kept the high powered Bills offense off of the field. I think they set a record for the longest drive in SB history. Honestly, the OL should have gotten the award, or Parcells. The game plan was amazing.
That drive is a symbol for what I like in an offensive: a mix of running and passing, clutch in third down, controlling the clock, and ultimately punching it in for six. That along with that defensive performance - it's no wonder why BB's gameplan ended up in Canton.
Ummm Belichick should have gotten the MVP. What that defense did holding that powerful K Gun offense that put up 51 points the previous game in the AFC championship game was phenomenal.
Exactly. There’s more to a performance than stats. Players can impact games and sway the outcome without looking amazing on paper
I'm glad someone else would give SB 11 mvp to a different player. I would go with Stabler myself
John Stallworth should have won it in SB14. Bradshaw had 3 picks and Stallworth has well over 100 yards, the go ahead touchdown, plus another huge spectacular catch on the game sealing drive
Absolutely Ty Law should have got MVP over Brady in Super Bowl XXXVI. I've said that for years. The Pats defense won that game.
Facts
Barry PLEASE troll somebody again. Let us all relive your prime again
Fax
Barry sneaking in that past tense verbage on Rodgers lmao
4:24 made me laugh so much
I will stand by the fact Brady is the luckiest QB to ever live and his success will never be replicated.
But he took advantage of those opportunities when they where given to him
Brady is that guy that found 6 silver dollars and knew to sell them on the internet instead of buy a burger with them to get multiples times the worth in profit.
Barry your standards are too high for RB efficiency...if an RB can average a first down every three carries and sustain that for ~30 carries/~150 yards, that alone will win you the game most of the time, especially in previous eras. Can't ask for much more than that
6:18 That 150.9 passer rating tho
PEYTON MANNINGS CORPSE LMFAO
Malcom smith won super bowl mvp then never did anything of note again
Malcom Butler should have won mvp for that goal line pick alone. I don’t care how well anyone played. That play won the game on its own in the craziest winning play in any game ever, let alone the Super Bowl
The "let's start voting for MVP the instant the coin flip is over" nonsense is, indeed, quite stupid.
Sure but his pick means nothing if Brady doesn’t throw 4 TDS
@@nickwright4079 and Brady’s 4 TDs don’t mean anything if Butler doesn’t pick that ball off because it’s a TD (or very likely one as there’s always the chance a WR drops a pass) if Butler doesn’t play it perfectly. Though I also don’t like giving an MVP nod for a game over a single play, even if that play is very hard to top due to how crucial it was at the time.
as theqbschool just pointed out yesterday, nfl quarterbacking is easier in every non personnel aspect... close hashes make short passes really really easy
but then u factor in the talent of defenses... qbschool didn't say that exactly, but it's implied
"A classic tom brady performance, he was bad for three qtrs, and then made the plays to win it at the end of the game" this is how I describe Tony Romo and dak Prescott
why? romo and dak don't make the plays to win at the end of the game
@@omar9987 Exactly. Although, I don't agree with the Tony Romo take, Dak Prescott is terrible when the game is close.
@@yonder8287 romo is a choke artist
You’re not wrong. How often does dak lead a GW drive anymore.?
I remember growing up with people saying that Tony Romo was a choker in clutch situations. I also remember absolutely dreading December because that's where potential playoff seasons went to die under Romo
Shout out to Jake Delhomme in Super Bowl 38. Threw for 3 TD’s no picks and 323 yards in a game where the panthers just came short in a loss that wasnt his fault
Yep and people still give him shit like it was. I’m a Pats fan and that dude did everything he could to will that team to victory.
Doug Williams deserved that MVP but so did Timmy Smith he still holds the rushing record for a SB with 204 yards.
Great video, btw video idea:
A video on how ridiculous it is to compare Lebron leaving Cleveland to Miami vs KD’s OKC to Golden state situation. I see it so much in basketball circles and when you apply context to it, it’s not even remotely close .
Those people will never understand the difference unfortunately
Idk if u done this already but can u grade every regular season mvp 1990-2021
Ty Law definitely deserved MVP. 7 tackles and a pick 6? Rodney Harrison too. Defense mostly gets overlooked anymore.
“No offense to Michael Vick” absolutely fucking sent me
Great video, Barry. I would love to see your list of biggest bust in nfl history or ranking the worst ref calls in history
His biggest bust would be Tom Brady.
James White 1000% deserved the SB MVP. Even Brady admitted he deserved to win it over him
Absolutely. When you consider his three touchdowns, that crucial 2pt conversion, and the fact he had over 100 yards receiving, James White was the unsung hero of that game
I don’t think they could do it since brady broke like every passing record in that game
No he didn't lol. That comeback doesn't happen without Brady there's a reason they always give the award to QBs
@@Ultimatecheezeburger Lmfao White broke and tied multiple SB records that game
- Most receiving yds for an RB
- Broke Thomas’ record for most receptions
- Tied record for most TDs along with Terrell Davis
- Tied for most receptions in a game in NFL playoff history (not just SB)
Quit forgetting what non QBs do. Shit like this is why Barry’s channel exists
@@LessGo7921 Lmfao all that shit is volume stats because it went to OT. Brady broke 3 records too so that's a bad argument.
Jacoby Jones in 2012. That kick return for a TD caused them to have to turn out the lights to try and beat them.
They should have an MVP on offence and defence, Donald and kupp both were invaluable in the game
Imagine having two pick 6's in a Superbowl and not being the MVP. Both Malcolm Butler and Brady should of been SB MVP in that game against Seattle cause Brady did dice up the LOB in that 4th quarter.
Hank Stram's voice should've won super bowl IV mvp, it's 99% of the highlights after all
this is a certified hood classic
What an epic run Flacco had, still annoyed he chucked up that interception to New England in 2014...
Well he did put up TWO separate 14 point leads in that game that the defense blew….so there’s that.
You definitely underrate OJ Anderson and Desmond Howard’s performances. I guess sometimes you have to see the full game and understand the circumstances to appreciate what happened.
Now grade every nba finals mvp
Super Bowl LI I could’ve argued James White:
14 rec, 110 yds, TD (2 rushing TD)
20 pts scored
Can’t believe you didn’t mention damien williams over mahomes, he literally had 130 all purpose yrds and two very important touchdowns
Agreed, he should have gotten the nod.
Barry Kudos to you for being able to accurately grade Brady’s accomplishments notwithstanding your undying love for the guy. Originally I said to myself here we go again and notwithstanding the constant flow of derogative commentary the grades were pretty much on point and in line with other grades that were given to other recipients of the trophy. I know you will never reconcile with the guy but I had to salute the effort of being objective in your grading and ignoring how you feel about the player.
Do a video on the best player at every position. I’m sure it won’t be controversial at all
QB: Brady
RB: Brady
FB: Brady
WR: Brady
TE: Brady
OL: Brady
DE: Brady
DT: Brady
MLB: Brady
OLB: Brady
CB: Brady
FS: Brady
SS: Brady
K: Brady
P: Brady
LS: Brady
there u go
@@enervat1on don't forget kick and punt returner.
Manny Fernandez should’ve been MVP of SB VII. He had 22 tackles and played the entire game in the Washington backfield
Foles, Legend. A+
Prior to getting to the SB, Flacco's playoff run was memorable and rather bizarre on a few levels so getting SB MVP makes sense though it should've went to Jacoby Jones.
Not complaining tho, a win's a win
@Fries no, it would go to the refs almost every year
So was Rodgers and Eli Manning. All of their SB runs were that of a bottom seed winning the big game.
1 catch for a 56 yard td, and a fumble should have gotten super bowl mvp? Lol what? Flacco had 3 tds 0 pics.
Also was not bizarre, Flacco was dominant in playoffs in 2010, 2011, 2012 and 2014.
I still think the MVP for Super Bowl 53 should have been a punter.
13:14 im dead 😂😂 a piece of gum
For 1 year Joe Flacco was god and it was amazing to watch
For Super Bowl 41 the MVP should’ve been Colts Safety Bob Sanders who had a Forced Fumble and Int. Both of which were huge plays that got the Colts extra opportunities on Offense.
That’s why they call you boy instead of man.
When I saw this while walking down a dark alley by myself I let my whole guard down, no offense to Eli Apple
This year's SB MVP gets an F. It should have gone to Johnny Hekker for his insane pass in the big game
I still have nightmares of Marcus Allen destroying my Skins in that Super Bowl
These grading vids are my favorite vids of urs, roasting random shit is hilarious every time
3:11 I would’ve given it to Art Shell
The raiders O line handling the purple people eaters was why Davis and Stabler shined. Shell specifically shut Jim Marshall down to the point that Marshall did not get a single tackle the entire game.
I would have given Super Bowl 39 MVP to Terrell Owens. 9 catches 122 yards on one leg? Once in a lifetime performance
They jumped the gun and awarded Dexter Jackson MVP before the end of the game. Almost exactly after they announced it, Dwight smith had his second pick six of the game. He probably would have won MVP if they waited until the game was over
Do you guys remember when Barry said he would kiss stafford on the lips if he beat brady in the playoffs? 👀
He better post it on his onlyfans
I’ll vouch for Super Bowl 12. That game was absolutely DOMINATED by the Dallas Defense.
That’s an A+ there.
Also for Super Bowl 22? Timmy Smith ran for over 200 yards in that one. Probably should’ve gone to the entire offensive line.
as a Pats fan I love how begrudgingly you rate Brady's MVPs, lol
Thurman Thomas should have won the SB 25 MVP even in defeat.
He was the best player on the field that night, and the margin of victory was one point. This was not garbage time stat-padding.
As a cardinals fan I hate Cooper Kupp yet I had him as a fifth rounder in a fantasy of 8 people and think he should’ve been regular season MVP.
Brady is such a game manager lol 😂
I still say Super Bowl 42 MVP should've been Justin Tuck that whole d-line dominated but Tuck was the star performer and didn't let Brady as much as breathe all day
Terrell Davis must be higher. The man put the team on his back while he was literally blind
I experienced my first migraine a while back and I couldn’t have any lights on for a good part of the day Bc of how bad it hurt. It feels like your head getting ripped open. Now imagine that playing in the biggest game of the year and getting hit haha
Kupp should have gotten a better rating. He was legit getting triple teamed at points and still managed to carry the offense when it mattered the most. Absolute animal
Love your videos. keep up the good work. i think you’ll get 1M at some point
Agreed
Can't believe James White wasn't mentioned in the SB 51 part. Brady was obviously good that game (well, the second half), but White should've won MVP. One of the best Super Bowl performances ever.
Love the research that you put into this. Keep up the great work.
Laughingat the Brady parts 😂😂
102 yards on 21 carries (almost 5 yards per carry) and a TD, no turnovers, in a game where owning 40 minutes of the clock won the Giants the game is a D+? Sure Thomas was more talented, but Anderson lead drives of 9+ minutes by constantly moving the chains on the ground. I'm not saying it's an A, but it's better than a D+.
It wasn't that Thomas was more talented, it's that he played better
@@RicardoAGuitar Fine, I'm not arguing he didn't. Thomas played phenomenal, but he lost. Anderson was still a HUGE part of the Giants' offense and strategy of dominating the clock and he played very well himself. Lesser performances were given better grades.
The weirdest thing about that Super Bowl is that it is incredibly underrated as a well played game. No turnovers on either side. Not that many flags. Both teams played their style on offense. Playmakers made plays. Very well coached game. A backup, game manager QB played mostly mistake free, including several huge 3rd down completions and a big TD right before the half. But it's remembered for exactly one thing and that thing doesn't fit that narrative.
Hahahaa you’re surprisingly funny man, had me cracking up 😄
If there was an award for grittiest super bowl mvp cooper kupp would win it by a landslide
NO IT WOULDVE BEEN HARD WORKING SNEAKY ATHLETIC JULIAN EDELMAN
If you think that's crazy, Imagine who would win it if it were the grittiest player award.
1:16 Chuck Howley may be the only Super Bowl MVP from a losing team, but you can't deny the fact that 2 was his lucky number that day.
Damien Williams and James White got robbed, I was definitely expecting a mention on those guys
I have a feeling Barry gave Nick Foles an A+ for beating Brady.
Since I am a total Tom Brady Homer I was interested to see how you would rank him, so I watched this. Soon it became clear you do not like Tom Brady so then I wanted to see how objective you could be. I would like to sincerely congratulate you on you objective, mature, fair and honest assessment of his MVPs. You could've mentioned that he gave Malcolm Butler the truck from his Superbowl 49 MVP, thus making it clear even Brady didn't think he deserved that. Still a fair assessment. I am now subscribed.
He gave James White the truck too
Damien Williams should have won super bowl LIV mvp
17:18 lmao ESPN level commentary