I play the game in Polish and it's kinda weird hearing Geralt swear so much in the English version lol, I'm pretty sure in Polish he just said "run you stupid little animal"
To me it's when that random gimp crawls in when speaking with the baron. If you go near the guards you can also pick up a conversation where they say the gimp is sleeping.
In the quest where u destroy the Avallac'h's lab, Yenn stays in character as 'mother' but does actually offschreen paints a mustache on the painting of Avallac'h, you can see this when the camera focusses on her at the end of the cutscene.
Geralt beating the crap out of Whoreson after seeing what he did to those women will forever be one of my favorite character moments. You don't have control over his choices in that moment, but agree with him 100%.
@@thinkingsoutherner9911Absolutely, like if not for him speaking up, Birna would have gotten away with her murder scheme. The entire An Craite clan would have suffered greatly too, Svanrige deserved way better for his bravery.
The writers did Svanrige wrong. He sold his mother out for her actions that he played no part in, and they still banished him when he would have been crowned had he kept his mouth shut? I'm sorry, but that simply does not track. He should have been granted amnesty for his sense of justice.
@@piscessoedroenmoonlight armor looks decent. Undvik's armor looks similiar to Bear school armor. Temerian armor looked decent aswell. Also the nilfgaardian armor that a trader can sell you didnt look bad. Not the heavy armor
I was expecting just a "Geralt would make the morally right choices" kind of video. But you surprised me once again by actually picking the lore accurate choices. Excellent work
In the Witcher there rarely is such a thing as morally right or wrong. After you have made a decision you know deep within your heart that you have made both the right and the wrong decision at the same time.
@@Nubbletech Yeah a lot of what the witcher is known for is Geralt being dragged into fights between a lesser, greater, or middling evil. In the end you find out that choosing any evil is bad even if it is "lesser."
@@WealthyJester98 Ok, I guess there are a few, but what I was trying to say is that a playthrough where you only pick the morally right options would be completely impossible as there usually isn't a clear choice.
I completely understand why you wouldn't want to complete this series, but I have to say, personally, these videos are some of my absolute favorite Witcher videos. But as you said, this is a major beast to attempt to create. Whatever your decision, I believe the people who follow you will understand. And as one final thing to say, holy hell is this video a masterpiece. The way you explain in detail why you made the choices you did, why Geralt would make said choices. Absolute masterpiece.
I with you on this. If Neon Knight isn't getting anything for his work, he shouldn't be forced to continue something that clearly takes months to make. However, these video are some of the best content about the witcher, especially if you learned about witcher through the games rather than the books.
@@TZhekaT well it's been a year since I saw the video so don't recall which ones😅 But like I wrote, it's a matter of personal interpretation, and the video in large is an amazing work
@@yuval_6999 agreed, video has little bit of bias, but holds mostly true. The main issues is the bad design of the base game - I noticed it right away on my 1st playthrough. The sense of urgency really mucks things up in an epic story. I know they tried to do like W1 and their plot but in that one it made senses as the villain required time to slowly advances its villain agenda. So you still had a sense of urgency but not overly pressured to finish ASAP. Speaking of W1, I still hold it as the better game especially how it handles the White Frost (making it a natural occurrence at the end of time space and not an actual antagonistic force) Also why Hearts of Stone and Blood and WIne play more like W1 - play out better Because of this sense of urgency a lot of Book Geralt choices get curb stomped by the senes of urgency of saving Ciri.
"I didn't tell you everything because I wanted something extra that I didn't want you to know about" Should be plastered on Geralts grave stone the amount of times it's happened to him
all the people i can name off the top of my head that have concealed information from Geralt for selfish reasons Triss - her entire romantic relationship with Geralt Gaunter - he's a god, and he needs geralt Yen. for like everything Emhyr? (the only thing Emhyr wanted from Geralt was Ciri, and Emhyr was honest with that) Bloody Baron's questline Keira's quests The Crones Radovid Dikjstra is surprisingly honest with Geralt Phillipa is a scheming bitch but is also pretty honest - her schemes involve ciri and a position within Nilfguard's court, not getting something from Geralt (although she does ask Geralt to take Yen out of the picture) Avalach? Ciri (concealed from Geralt but for selfless reasons)
@@JJ-52 fair point. Well, one of the conditions for the good ending is to read the diary of Sianna entirely as soon as you pick it. But I decided to play authentic and jumped right to the only obviously relevant line. Later, still in the magic world, I read the remaining entries. But when the dialogue with Sianna came I had only the options to lead to the bad endings. I was quite frustrated, given I did absolutely everything else correctly, and knowing everything Geralt would know to have the right options.
While the choice isn’t mentioned within the video since Geralt and Ciri don’t go down the path leading to it, when visiting Emhyr, while Geralt wouldn’t take the money, Ciri would just be like, “give me that!” in accordance with her book character.
When I first played the game, I took the money, thinking I could give it to Ciri afterwards, showing her that it has no meaning for me but I thought I might as well scalp it from Enhyr. Then I saw her reaction and knew, uh oh, not where the scene is going, and had to reload haha
kind of interesting that when i played the witcher 3, I had 0 prior witcher knowledge and chose almost all of the same options you mentioned in your video. to me, this is impressive as hell solely for CDPR for - at least to me - having game Geralt be so close personality wise to book Geralt that I was able to pick up on and make choices based on what I believed his choices would be is pretty damn cool.
SAME! I just commented this. I chalk it up to the main story feeling so urgent, that even though there's no time requirement, it felt like there was, and if you really roleplay as Geralt, you want to get to Ciri. Like you said, CDPR knocked it out of the park
Just finished my first playthough recently, and I chose to let Ciri meet Emyhr because I saw a clip of her reaction when you turn down the gold and I wanted that scene. If i had've known about the book stuff I definitely wouldnt have though, I also never will on future playthroughs based on the book knowledge and how it ends if you go there. I would have figured that wouldn't be the ending you get given how she storms off in that scene but oh well, live and learn
This is one of the best vids I have ever watched on you-tube man. For us fans that got a bit sidetracked playing the game (to say the least, lol) it was so wonderful to get a comprehensive A to Z telling of the story. It really made me want to play the game again. Your explaining how the different characters related to each other was beyond helpful. Thank you so much. Love from Norway.
The efforts and quality of this video is amazing. This not only a 2 and a half hour movie of Witcher 3 with lore friendly choices but also can be a great long and detailed summary video if you need it in the future. Props to you for breaking the sweat and covering the entire main game in a video!
Yes it's finally here! Can't wait to see the second half this evening. P.S. I just wanted to say that I really enjoy the long form video format but appreciate how much time and effort it takes, so give yourself a few weeks rest. You've earned it :)
You have made a great piece of art. I was listening to this like an audio book while I was working out. I really appreciate you sharing your perspective as I haven’t read the books and don’t have as much context as I’d like, it makes me really appreciate Geralt’s character. I get it that you don’t want to make another one of these, don’t feel obliged to unless it’s good for you, you’ve already done something great.
This is so cool! I’m on my fifth playthrough and my goal for this one was to be as close as possible to a roleplay like « what would Geralt do ». My line of conduct was directed by what I understood of him (while not knowing every detail like you!). I went as far as trying not to fast travel and ask myself what road to take, what busy area to avoid, when to stop in a village for coins or shelter, etc. It allowed my to also assess if a side quest or contract was « worth it » timewise. I found it soooooo difficult to brace against wanting to complete everything! I love your video because it shows how time is of the essence in the main quest.
@@michaelderflinger5002 I don't remembrer exactly, but I would say around 25 maybe. You barely scape through, always in the orange. It's the hidden difficulty setting hahaha!
i’ve only watched the witcher show and had vague interest in the games, but got this recommended to me. and wow, you didnt lose my attention for a single minute! this was so well written, i love that you included enough background information that i understood everything clearly despite my lack of prior knowledge but you also kept the storytelling of your video moving forward. i loved hearing about all the reasoning behind each choice, backed up by moments from the book and previous games. the amount of time, research, and effort that went into this is apparent. plus, you were very engaging as a narrator, and the jokes you sprinkled in from time to time were great! my hats off to you, not only am i subscribing right away but i’ll be watching any other wwgd videos you have asap! i can only imagine what a time sink this is, but i would love any further videos you put out that are of this genre.
I haven't watched the show but the games are damn good so I'd definitely suggest at least watching a playthrough of the story I've also heard they're a lot closer to the books which I've heard fairly positive things about so I dunno might be more worth it to look into other Witcher related media especially since they're recasting Geralt in the show.
If you like the game, or the books. You won't like the show, or vice versa, at least most likely. The only relevance at this point is literally Geralt. And they are replacing the actor, who literally pushed for this show to happen. They are completely separate things at this point. One is a badly written fan fiction for horny teenage girls or "woke" generic and biased people. The other is... well the reason it was made, and it's in itself it's own thing, and beloved for what it is, not for what it can be used for. I'm not just here trying to shut you down. I'm giving you a heads up that you will not find anything similiar outside of Geralt. Jaskier literally hooked up with medieval fantasy hitler. The Wild hunt makes no sense, and No character does what they would in the books or the game. It's very bizarre. So if you can managed to tolerate the extreme twists and changes made, good for you.
@@theninjamaster67 The first season is good, the second season shits all over the books and games. The first season is a fairly faithful adaptation of the early Witcher short stories (which were later compiled into the first book). The second season is when all the writers suddenly decided that they didn't like the books they were basing their show on and actively made decisions that I can't see as anything other than openly antagonistic against long time fans.
The dedication and hard work committed into this video is insane. I don't think I've ever sat through a video this long and still not got bored. Big respect to you!
I love to see someone with this much love for the Witcher universe, i can only imagine how much time and effort this video took and it's really well done bro, I've been wondering about what garalt would do and finally we have a super detailed video on it. Thanks brother❤ Ps. I love your content, keep it up
Loved the video. I think your reasoning about Geralt's sense of urgency and how it would've driven many of the choices makes a ton of sense. It's too bad the game's design doesn't somehow encourage/reward this line of reasoning more than it does. Also, enjoyed the Megadeth reference!
Yes, in my completionist ways, I had completely forgotten about the urgency of Geralts quest, which really would be a significant motivation in his actions
Oh please do continue if you ever find the time to. I so want to know how Geralt would actually act when faced with someone as seemingly omnipotent as Gaunter o'Dimm. In any case, wonderful video!
Masterworks like this are hard to find. Brought back some of my favourite parts about the books and game, made me question some parts of the game I wouldn't have before and convincingly supported the reasoning for each of the choices shown. Careful balancing of information against exposition and spoilers. All wound together with a combination of inside jokes, dry one liners and a few classics. Exquisite
Very enjoyable video and good character analysis, just like your video 'Witcher 2 - Every Choice GERALT Would Make' ! I loved that you also included stuff from the books to prove some of your points and how much effort you put into the video in generall ! I hope this money will help you make good future content on your channel
Man this game is soooo well written.... the way it side quests off to fill out the story is amazing amd giving back story to soo many other Characters. There isn't another game like it
This might be the best video on your channel so far, which means a lot considering the pure quality of your work. Thank you for all the work necessary to pull of a video like this! :)
I really wanted to write a comment to say how glad I'm that this video's out but I am terrible at this. So just thank you Neon Knight. I hope you know that your work brings a lot of joy to people.
A very well made video Neon Knight! I watched the whole thing, and this must be one of the longest videos that I´ve watched on TH-cam my whole life! I enjoyed every second of it!! Well done, and thanks for the trip down memory lane!!
I can imagine the amount of game play you do to get all this information. Thank you from everyone for putting your time and effort into this, it’s my favorite video so far! This is the best Witcher channel I watch!
Stellar job as always! Thoroughly enjoyed the full 2 and a half hours and I fully agree with your analysis of every choice. Would love to see you do this for side quests and the dlc of course, but I am also very interested in a video about Kingdom Come! That's a great game that I'd love to hear you voice your opinions on :)
I remember the devs saying that they made every decision be between options Geralt would take but then you look at some of the quests like assassinating Radovid. Lets say hypothetically he would be willing to help. The plan goes through and then he is given the choice to betray 3 loyal friends. There is no way of explaining that choice in any way that Geralt would just be okay with friends dying.
Yeah that’s just stupid. Witcher 3 was my first time anything Witcher and when that came up I was like why is he asking me to betray 3 of my friends so HE can become king
That's a super weird quest all around. Like Djkstra surely would never think he can beat Geralt in a fight right? I only read one of the books but he's supposed to be one of the smartest characters
@@pilot3605 I mean he doesnt really think the geralt is on his level even in the books he kinda looks down on geralt which is how he ended up with the limp, he underestimated him when geralt was captured at the conclave coup.
Incredible video. Especially because I just finished my 14th playthrough and there's decisions I never thought could ever have a massive impact on a lot of characters
I can’t really tell if this is a joke or not since the Witcher 3 is that good of a game that 14 playthroughs is actually kinda believable nearly a decade after its release
@@jenjoe4359I've done the same including DLC each time (trying to work new mods into playthrough 15). I'm physically disabled so my free time is pretty extensive 😅
I had no intention of watching a 2 and half hour long video about a series whose lore I’ve already thoroughly consumed, but your pacing and choices were just so tightly done I couldn’t look away. Brevity is the heart of wit and any number of these choices could’ve easily droned on a moment too long and have me click away but you timed it perfectly. I hope you get the support needed to continue. This was fantastic.
Cannot wait to watch this! Been hyping this video for so long. You're solidifying yourself as one of the platform's best Witcher 3 content creators with every new video. We appreciate all the hard work you do to make a huge project such as this!
This is amazing, I‘ve been waiting for this ever since I saw your post announcing it, and it more than lived up to my expectations. Kerp up the great work
Love the switch to Fergus when mentioning the lack of competence😂 I never thought about Triss being in full control with the Menge scene, such a good angle. The scene with Junior is one of the most intense ones in the game for me, the exhaustion and shock and anger Geralt feels in that moment are so well portrayed. 100% agree that there is no way Geralt would let him stay alive not only for Ciri but also for the threat he poses to any woman. Completely agree that the third act is so rushed. It has some amazing scenes but I remember questioning on the first playthrough if I really did all the quests. Thescene with Sile was surprisinglyvery emotional. But I liked it. Also would agree that Geralt would go with Xiri to the lodge. Though the scene in which Geralt and Yen are spying is quite cute, I definetly think it's more natural that he offers to go with her especially with Philippa being involved. All in all great summary of Geralt's choices, really enjoyed watching it and would definetly love to see more videos like this but also get that's it requires an insane amout of work
Geralt always gives me protective Papa Bear vibes, but he never felt overprotective to me so it makes sense in my opinion that he offers Ciri to accompany her but also would be fine with her going alone. Which in general is why to me it feels like he would always want to make sure that Ciri knows as much about a situation as possible (Emhyr's true agenda, what Phillipa is actually like...) before she makes **her** own choice. He knows that Ciri went through more than what most people will experience over their lifetime so controlling her choices just becomes absurd as she clearly isn't a helpless idiot.
I could barely finish the mission with Triss being tortured... I couldn't bare to hear the screams. And seeing the blood on her hands after made me glad i sliced Menge to bits.
Thank you for this amazing and high quality video. Thank you for the amount of time dedicated to this project. It definitely worth the time. It's wonderful how we still can learn new things about The Witcher 3 and it's been 8 years since released. Hope you can do that video of the Witcher contracts but I'll understand that could take a lot of time and you need to rest. You have a fan here in Mexico waiting for your content 💙🇲🇽.
Thanks so much for this video! There really are two perspectives you could have gone with: what would Geralt do in the moment or what would Geralt do in this situation. Doing the in the moment one was totally legit, however that also made us miss out on the some super cool side quests. Would love to see that coverage as well! Great job!
Excellent job, as someone in video production I know that every video you create (and truly care about) becomes a passion project and that really came through in this video. No corners cut here, you did an excellent job! Replaced or someone can go and read more about your production process? The s software you use, how you lay in the VO, etc.
Unbelievable job mate! So entertaining and everything made perfect sense. No idea how you managed to get an almost 3 hour video to flow so easy too. The hard work you put into this definitely shows.
Just finished this BEAST of a video. What a gift to the Witcher community, can only imagine the work this took. Awesome job man. I can see this going viral again once the next Witcher game drops also 👀
The video is amazing, loved every second of it, and almost three hours went by like a couple of minutes - very much alike to the actual game. Your Witcher content is absolutely top-notch, and I would love to see more of it should you have time and inspiration to continue this series. Thank you!
I've had this video opened as a tab since it was released, as I got really excited when you said in your TW2 video that you'd be doing this. I've only just gotten time today to watch the whole thing, and I was not at all disappointed. I appreciate the effort you put into this, man. All nearly 3 hours was absolutely worth it. Now I feel like I need to do a "what would Geralt do" playthrough where I keep the fact that Geralt is focused on Ciri in mind. The one thing I will say is that despite it not making sense, unless there is something I missed, the Keira questline with Fyke Isle should still be played earlier just so that it doesn't make absolutely no sense for Geralt to sleep with Keira after sleeping with Yennefer twice in quick succession and professing his love. That just doesn't sit right for me, and I feel like Geralt wouldn't do that when he just put so much effort into securing things with Yennefer. The only other thing I can justify Geralt going out of his way to do is to take the House of Reardon contract just because it ensures that Letho ends up in Kaer Morhen if you play your cards right, and also because if Geralt thought Letho was around, which he starts to suspect basically as soon as he gets to the property, he probably would have gone after him to see what he is doing. I can justify Geralt having to pass by the area of that quest just to get some coin for his later endeavors in finding Ciri. I hope you get the resources to do follow-up videos on TW3! This was a great one!
This video is bonkers, only found your channel like a month ago, still amazed that even though we are coming up on a decade after W3 was released people are still making absolute banger videos on it
This isn't what this video is about, but the summary you gave of the story was amazing! It's been more than 6 years since I last played The Witcher 3, so my memory of the main quest and the lore-accurate sidequests Geralt would do was a little hazy. Having the story retold in this format with added information from the books and previous games etc. made me gain a whole new appreciation for the game. Like damn the story up until the last parts of the game is way better than I remembered! Thank you for the video!
It took me three days to get through this video, because I wanted to have time to focus and really enjoy it. Very worthwhile! I echo all the positive things I’ve seen in the comments already. Plus I love your deadpan delivery of some comedic points. “You must be doing a ‘bad choices’ playthrough.” Fabulous work, and I hope you are favored by the almighty algorithm!
Video Very Good!!! Seriously though, I love the interaction of someone informed about the books with the game. The books are so amazing and they don’t get enough youtube press, of great quality, since the games are so much more popular and visually stimulating.
By far one of the "walkthroughs" of the game. I finished witcher multiple times years ago. It's a great video, makes me want to play more. You're a great creator i would love to see more. Congratulations on making one of the best witcher videos out there. Much love and admiration.
Thank you very much for this amazing video. Well crafted and a joy to watch for almost three hours. And i think i'm not the only one who'd like future videos for secondary quests, witcher contracts, heart of stone and blood and wine.
The wait is finally over, I can't wait to watch all of this. I had a feeling it would release today, exactly a year after the 10 Choices Geralt Would Never Take.
I would love to see more choices videos on side quests and DLCs! But i understand that it's exhausting. Thanks for this video! And i couldnt agree more with the Bart choice. If you kill Bart, you're inhuman.
Amazing analysis! While it’s a shame to think Geralt would miss out on things such as assassinating Radovid and seeing Letho again (especially after your compelling argument that Geralt would definitely save him) I loved the breakdown of reasoning you gave as to each choice. I’d love to do a playthroughs mirroring these choices to experience how they play out in real time. I really hope this video does well for you because it absolutely deserves all the fan attention, and I definitely want to see at least a “WWGD” video on the two expansions, if not soon then hopefully later on down the road. In general I love the content and hope to continue to see more, whether is long analyses like this or otherwise!
Saw interesting video, clicked the thumbnail, didn't regret spending 2,5h watching this. I couldn't move from the couch. You, sir, have done a masterpiece.
I'm glad you did this because it was eye opening for me. I am a naïve player and jump at the chance of helping anyone whom I come across. Example, I was so shocked by the gruesome death of Annabelle that I completely dismissed the queues that she wasn't being completely honest. Great video! Joy to watch!
I really hope the support from your viewers is strong enough for you to continue this series. I loved this entry and I wish you the best of luck with all that you do!
This was spectacular! Would love to see more content like this. Absolutely love your sense of humor. Thank you for all the hard work you poured into making this ❤
Amazing work sir ! It's realy nice to have a comparison ton our own choices we made in game ^^ Also you show so much love and dedication toward the game and us. Thx
![Witcher 3 - The Choices GERALT Would Make [Hearts of Stone]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/k33LQB5IuQQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![Witcher 3 - The Choices GERALT Would Make [Hearts of Stone]](/img/tr.png)
![Witcher 2 - Every Choice GERALT Would Make [All Quests]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Cygl7BWGUto/mqdefault.jpg)
I laughed so hard when finding the pellars goat and the bear shows up and geralt says "run you stupid piece of shit." Hahaha
I play the game in Polish and it's kinda weird hearing Geralt swear so much in the English version lol, I'm pretty sure in Polish he just said "run you stupid little animal"
Favorite line in the game 😂 you really feel it in a new playthrough.
To me it's when that random gimp crawls in when speaking with the baron. If you go near the guards you can also pick up a conversation where they say the gimp is sleeping.
In the quest where u destroy the Avallac'h's lab, Yenn stays in character as 'mother' but does actually offschreen paints a mustache on the painting of Avallac'h, you can see this when the camera focusses on her at the end of the cutscene.
Yeah, I always liked that detail
Yen is just as rambunctious as Ciri and Geralt. She's just more subtle about it.
Lol never noticed that
Yessss, love that detail! Sad Neon didn't show it but ah well:p
_"offschreen"_
Is this intentional, lol?
Geralt beating the crap out of Whoreson after seeing what he did to those women will forever be one of my favorite character moments. You don't have control over his choices in that moment, but agree with him 100%.
Gerald simp of rivia
@@CosmicVoid_119I don't think that word means what you think it means
@@CosmicVoid_119 of course with that name comes with a bad opinion
@@aiden4112Cry some more Obsidian boy
@@twinzzlers They aren't crying though......
You didn’t mention the most important reason Geralt would side with Cerys:
There’s a place of power that cannot otherwise be obtained
Where is that place ? :-0
@@michellem1485it appears when you run through the secret exit with cerys after the fire starts if I remember correctly
@@alpertutum9205how tho? The entrance, room, and exit are all fully inside kaer trolde
@@piscessoedroenoh so that's why a place has to be reached through some difficult jumping techniques, now i see
💯
Svanrige standing up to his mother at the cost of his honor was actually the most honorable thing he could have done
Poor guy definitely deserved better. He never asked for that
@@thinkingsoutherner9911Absolutely, like if not for him speaking up, Birna would have gotten away with her murder scheme. The entire An Craite clan would have suffered greatly too, Svanrige deserved way better for his bravery.
I actually did a playthrough where Svanrige becomes the king of Skellige. I was not greatly pleased or displeased with the option.
@@loganmaddocks4703 just like the cutscene after svanrige becomes king, he was the most mid of all, but he did the thing
The writers did Svanrige wrong. He sold his mother out for her actions that he played no part in, and they still banished him when he would have been crowned had he kept his mouth shut?
I'm sorry, but that simply does not track. He should have been granted amnesty for his sense of justice.
thank you for not only documenting geralts choices, but also giving us a geralt fashion show
Drippy Geralt 😎
fr i never switched out from kaer morhen/warrior armor until i got a nice witcher set as i always see other armors as awkward for geralt
@@piscessoedroenmoonlight armor looks decent. Undvik's armor looks similiar to Bear school armor. Temerian armor looked decent aswell. Also the nilfgaardian armor that a trader can sell you didnt look bad. Not the heavy armor
I was expecting just a "Geralt would make the morally right choices" kind of video. But you surprised me once again by actually picking the lore accurate choices. Excellent work
In the Witcher there rarely is such a thing as morally right or wrong. After you have made a decision you know deep within your heart that you have made both the right and the wrong decision at the same time.
@@NubbletechI disagree. In the game there are a lot of black and white decisions. "help your friend or don't" are most of those
@@Nubbletech Yeah a lot of what the witcher is known for is Geralt being dragged into fights between a lesser, greater, or middling evil. In the end you find out that choosing any evil is bad even if it is "lesser."
@@WealthyJester98 Ok, I guess there are a few, but what I was trying to say is that a playthrough where you only pick the morally right options would be completely impossible as there usually isn't a clear choice.
@@Jenna_Talia yes
I completely understand why you wouldn't want to complete this series, but I have to say, personally, these videos are some of my absolute favorite Witcher videos. But as you said, this is a major beast to attempt to create. Whatever your decision, I believe the people who follow you will understand. And as one final thing to say, holy hell is this video a masterpiece. The way you explain in detail why you made the choices you did, why Geralt would make said choices. Absolute masterpiece.
Genuinely such top tier content on TH-cam from a guy who's clearly so passionate. I really hope he finishes the series.
Agreed
I with you on this. If Neon Knight isn't getting anything for his work, he shouldn't be forced to continue something that clearly takes months to make. However, these video are some of the best content about the witcher, especially if you learned about witcher through the games rather than the books.
Agreed. You have a viewer in me if you do.
He should do the Witcher 1 next but I do understand if he wants to wait for the remake because it can be a real headache to play nowadays.
As a book reader myself, I have to say I think this is a great analysis. I agreed with almost all your choices
Almost? Which ones you disagreed with?
@@TZhekaT well it's been a year since I saw the video so don't recall which ones😅
But like I wrote, it's a matter of personal interpretation, and the video in large is an amazing work
@@yuval_6999 agreed, video has little bit of bias, but holds mostly true. The main issues is the bad design of the base game - I noticed it right away on my 1st playthrough. The sense of urgency really mucks things up in an epic story. I know they tried to do like W1 and their plot but in that one it made senses as the villain required time to slowly advances its villain agenda. So you still had a sense of urgency but not overly pressured to finish ASAP. Speaking of W1, I still hold it as the better game especially how it handles the White Frost (making it a natural occurrence at the end of time space and not an actual antagonistic force) Also why Hearts of Stone and Blood and WIne play more like W1 - play out better
Because of this sense of urgency a lot of Book Geralt choices get curb stomped by the senes of urgency of saving Ciri.
Good that you agreed, now i can sleep in peace.
There's more effort put in this video than the netflix witcher show
This video of movie proportions have more views than Netflix's
“It’s beyond the normal amount of biting your own leg off pain that most of us are familiar with” had me laughing far more than it maybe should have.
When we needed him the most he came back😤
and didn’t dissapoint
I only found this channel last week when I decided to replay the Witcher. I've binged most video's this week and then I saw this pop up. So damn lucky
@@freekmulder3662lucky man. I've been checking repeatedly for 5 months.
@@freekmulder3662perfect timing for you
@@mz655 we need to you sod off
"I didn't tell you everything because I wanted something extra that I didn't want you to know about" Should be plastered on Geralts grave stone the amount of times it's happened to him
all the people i can name off the top of my head that have concealed information from Geralt for selfish reasons
Triss - her entire romantic relationship with Geralt
Gaunter - he's a god, and he needs geralt
Yen. for like everything
Emhyr? (the only thing Emhyr wanted from Geralt was Ciri, and Emhyr was honest with that)
Bloody Baron's questline
Keira's quests
The Crones
Radovid
Dikjstra is surprisingly honest with Geralt
Phillipa is a scheming bitch but is also pretty honest - her schemes involve ciri and a position within Nilfguard's court, not getting something from Geralt (although she does ask Geralt to take Yen out of the picture)
Avalach?
Ciri (concealed from Geralt but for selfless reasons)
the breakdown of Blood and Wine would be great to watch as there are some interesting choices Geralt has to make, especially toward the end
I loved Blood and Wine but there's one slight moment that almost ruined the for me completely. Sadly I cannot explain it spoiler-free
@@alcedob.5850 EXPLAIN
@@alcedob.5850It is years old. You don't need to worry about spoilers. This video is full of spoilers.
@@JJ-52 fair point. Well, one of the conditions for the good ending is to read the diary of Sianna entirely as soon as you pick it. But I decided to play authentic and jumped right to the only obviously relevant line. Later, still in the magic world, I read the remaining entries. But when the dialogue with Sianna came I had only the options to lead to the bad endings. I was quite frustrated, given I did absolutely everything else correctly, and knowing everything Geralt would know to have the right options.
@@alcedob.5850 If you decide to play authentic you have to take the consequences of not getting a fairy tale ending
Absolute masterpiece of a video! I'm grateful that you made this. What an amazing story with great characters, told with the justice it deserves.
thank you Mila!
While the choice isn’t mentioned within the video since Geralt and Ciri don’t go down the path leading to it, when visiting Emhyr, while Geralt wouldn’t take the money, Ciri would just be like, “give me that!” in accordance with her book character.
Taking the money while wearing the professor's spectacles and donkey ears is the most in-character choice.
@@insane_troll Xletalis would be proud
I love me some Ciri selling
When I first played the game, I took the money, thinking I could give it to Ciri afterwards, showing her that it has no meaning for me but I thought I might as well scalp it from Enhyr. Then I saw her reaction and knew, uh oh, not where the scene is going, and had to reload haha
@@minaermelyn this actually would've been a good option that makes sense, never even thought of that
Massive , precious work for a game that really has no opponents, thank you Neon Knight !
true
kind of interesting that when i played the witcher 3, I had 0 prior witcher knowledge and chose almost all of the same options you mentioned in your video. to me, this is impressive as hell solely for CDPR for - at least to me - having game Geralt be so close personality wise to book Geralt that I was able to pick up on and make choices based on what I believed his choices would be is pretty damn cool.
SAME! I just commented this. I chalk it up to the main story feeling so urgent, that even though there's no time requirement, it felt like there was, and if you really roleplay as Geralt, you want to get to Ciri. Like you said, CDPR knocked it out of the park
Just finished my first playthough recently, and I chose to let Ciri meet Emyhr because I saw a clip of her reaction when you turn down the gold and I wanted that scene. If i had've known about the book stuff I definitely wouldnt have though, I also never will on future playthroughs based on the book knowledge and how it ends if you go there. I would have figured that wouldn't be the ending you get given how she storms off in that scene but oh well, live and learn
This is one of the best vids I have ever watched on you-tube man. For us fans that got a bit sidetracked playing the game (to say the least, lol) it was so wonderful to get a comprehensive A to Z telling of the story. It really made me want to play the game again. Your explaining how the different characters related to each other was beyond helpful. Thank you so much. Love from Norway.
Cerys was my favorite character in W3. She was so competent that i trusted her with the baby too. Im happy she became ruler in my first play through.
Is that why you used quen on the baby?
@@DarkMAGABurt pretty sure Geralt used quen on the oven so it couldnt be opened.
She was too competent and clearly the best choice.
Would have been nicer to make the other options more palatable imo
The efforts and quality of this video is amazing. This not only a 2 and a half hour movie of Witcher 3 with lore friendly choices but also can be a great long and detailed summary video if you need it in the future. Props to you for breaking the sweat and covering the entire main game in a video!
I know this was hard for you, but just know you did a phenomenal job.
Yes it's finally here! Can't wait to see the second half this evening. P.S. I just wanted to say that I really enjoy the long form video format but appreciate how much time and effort it takes, so give yourself a few weeks rest. You've earned it :)
You have made a great piece of art. I was listening to this like an audio book while I was working out. I really appreciate you sharing your perspective as I haven’t read the books and don’t have as much context as I’d like, it makes me really appreciate Geralt’s character.
I get it that you don’t want to make another one of these, don’t feel obliged to unless it’s good for you, you’ve already done something great.
Very great video! Although you did forget one of the most important choices. Would Geralt bow to Emhyr the first time at the palace?
This is so cool!
I’m on my fifth playthrough and my goal for this one was to be as close as possible to a roleplay like « what would Geralt do ».
My line of conduct was directed by what I understood of him (while not knowing every detail like you!). I went as far as trying not to fast travel and ask myself what road to take, what busy area to avoid, when to stop in a village for coins or shelter, etc. It allowed my to also assess if a side quest or contract was « worth it » timewise.
I found it soooooo difficult to brace against wanting to complete everything! I love your video because it shows how time is of the essence in the main quest.
What Level are you if you, when you finish the game this way?
@@michaelderflinger5002 I don't remembrer exactly, but I would say around 25 maybe. You barely scape through, always in the orange. It's the hidden difficulty setting hahaha!
@@justineprevost3398 He might still do some contracts for boat money. So you might be able to stretch it to 30.
i’ve only watched the witcher show and had vague interest in the games, but got this recommended to me. and wow, you didnt lose my attention for a single minute! this was so well written, i love that you included enough background information that i understood everything clearly despite my lack of prior knowledge but you also kept the storytelling of your video moving forward. i loved hearing about all the reasoning behind each choice, backed up by moments from the book and previous games. the amount of time, research, and effort that went into this is apparent. plus, you were very engaging as a narrator, and the jokes you sprinkled in from time to time were great! my hats off to you, not only am i subscribing right away but i’ll be watching any other wwgd videos you have asap! i can only imagine what a time sink this is, but i would love any further videos you put out that are of this genre.
I haven't watched the show but the games are damn good so I'd definitely suggest at least watching a playthrough of the story I've also heard they're a lot closer to the books which I've heard fairly positive things about so I dunno might be more worth it to look into other Witcher related media especially since they're recasting Geralt in the show.
If you like the game, or the books. You won't like the show, or vice versa, at least most likely. The only relevance at this point is literally Geralt. And they are replacing the actor, who literally pushed for this show to happen.
They are completely separate things at this point. One is a badly written fan fiction for horny teenage girls or "woke" generic and biased people. The other is... well the reason it was made, and it's in itself it's own thing, and beloved for what it is, not for what it can be used for.
I'm not just here trying to shut you down. I'm giving you a heads up that you will not find anything similiar outside of Geralt. Jaskier literally hooked up with medieval fantasy hitler. The Wild hunt makes no sense, and No character does what they would in the books or the game. It's very bizarre. So if you can managed to tolerate the extreme twists and changes made, good for you.
> only watched the show
Yeah you lost us right there
@@Samuel-lq7kpdon’t be rude
@@theninjamaster67 The first season is good, the second season shits all over the books and games. The first season is a fairly faithful adaptation of the early Witcher short stories (which were later compiled into the first book). The second season is when all the writers suddenly decided that they didn't like the books they were basing their show on and actively made decisions that I can't see as anything other than openly antagonistic against long time fans.
The dedication and hard work committed into this video is insane. I don't think I've ever sat through a video this long and still not got bored. Big respect to you!
I love to see someone with this much love for the Witcher universe, i can only imagine how much time and effort this video took and it's really well done bro, I've been wondering about what garalt would do and finally we have a super detailed video on it.
Thanks brother❤
Ps. I love your content, keep it up
Very well put together. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
Thank you, Markus
I’ve always liked the way this guy articulates and how he presents his thought process
Loved the video. I think your reasoning about Geralt's sense of urgency and how it would've driven many of the choices makes a ton of sense. It's too bad the game's design doesn't somehow encourage/reward this line of reasoning more than it does. Also, enjoyed the Megadeth reference!
Yes, in my completionist ways, I had completely forgotten about the urgency of Geralts quest, which really would be a significant motivation in his actions
Oh please do continue if you ever find the time to. I so want to know how Geralt would actually act when faced with someone as seemingly omnipotent as Gaunter o'Dimm. In any case, wonderful video!
Masterworks like this are hard to find. Brought back some of my favourite parts about the books and game, made me question some parts of the game I wouldn't have before and convincingly supported the reasoning for each of the choices shown. Careful balancing of information against exposition and spoilers. All wound together with a combination of inside jokes, dry one liners and a few classics. Exquisite
Thanks for all the work, for all the great hours, for helping me without knowing it during some of my worst months.
The time has come!! Let’s see this masterpiece!
Congrats Knight on finally publishing this!
Very enjoyable video and good character analysis, just like your video 'Witcher 2 - Every Choice GERALT Would Make' ! I loved that you also included stuff from the books to prove some of your points and how much effort you put into the video in generall ! I hope this money will help you make good future content on your channel
thank you so much, Valentin :D
@@NeonKnight Congrats on the 100k subs, you deserve it and hard work always pays of! I always enjoy your videos and keep up the great work!
Man this game is soooo well written.... the way it side quests off to fill out the story is amazing amd giving back story to soo many other Characters. There isn't another game like it
This might be the best video on your channel so far, which means a lot considering the pure quality of your work. Thank you for all the work necessary to pull of a video like this! :)
Great video, like so many of your other videos!
Im a little late watching this, but its some of the best "The Witcher" content I've seen. Thank you for doing this. You obviously put a lot into it.
I really wanted to write a comment to say how glad I'm that this video's out but I am terrible at this. So just thank you Neon Knight. I hope you know that your work brings a lot of joy to people.
Just want to say I absolutely love these videos not a lot of Witcher book discussion on TH-cam so I really appreciate you making these videos!
You are a real gem of Witcher community! keep up the good work .
I waited 4 months for the right evening to watch this. This evening is that evening.
A very well made video Neon Knight! I watched the whole thing, and this must be one of the longest videos that I´ve watched on TH-cam my whole life!
I enjoyed every second of it!! Well done, and thanks for the trip down memory lane!!
I can imagine the amount of game play you do to get all this information. Thank you from everyone for putting your time and effort into this, it’s my favorite video so far! This is the best Witcher channel I watch!
Stellar job as always! Thoroughly enjoyed the full 2 and a half hours and I fully agree with your analysis of every choice. Would love to see you do this for side quests and the dlc of course, but I am also very interested in a video about Kingdom Come! That's a great game that I'd love to hear you voice your opinions on :)
I remember the devs saying that they made every decision be between options Geralt would take but then you look at some of the quests like assassinating Radovid. Lets say hypothetically he would be willing to help. The plan goes through and then he is given the choice to betray 3 loyal friends. There is no way of explaining that choice in any way that Geralt would just be okay with friends dying.
Yeah that’s just stupid. Witcher 3 was my first time anything Witcher and when that came up I was like why is he asking me to betray 3 of my friends so HE can become king
That's a super weird quest all around. Like Djkstra surely would never think he can beat Geralt in a fight right? I only read one of the books but he's supposed to be one of the smartest characters
@@pilot3605 I mean he doesnt really think the geralt is on his level even in the books he kinda looks down on geralt which is how he ended up with the limp, he underestimated him when geralt was captured at the conclave coup.
It’s a shame bc Djikstra is the best ending. I always sacrifice Roche and Thaler idc
@@kingt0295 L
"If you killed Bart you make me sick!"🤣
Shows a clip of Geralt standing over a dead Bart.
Witcher 4 news brought me back to your channel. Now im finding witcher 3 videos interesting again despite it being years since my last playthrough.
Incredible video. Especially because I just finished my 14th playthrough and there's decisions I never thought could ever have a massive impact on a lot of characters
I can’t really tell if this is a joke or not since the Witcher 3 is that good of a game that 14 playthroughs is actually kinda believable nearly a decade after its release
@@jenjoe4359I've done the same including DLC each time (trying to work new mods into playthrough 15). I'm physically disabled so my free time is pretty extensive 😅
@@LadyAhro good for you(not the physically disabled part but everything else)
I had no intention of watching a 2 and half hour long video about a series whose lore I’ve already thoroughly consumed, but your pacing and choices were just so tightly done I couldn’t look away. Brevity is the heart of wit and any number of these choices could’ve easily droned on a moment too long and have me click away but you timed it perfectly. I hope you get the support needed to continue. This was fantastic.
this is crazy i can’t imagine how long this took thank you i can’t wait to watch keep up the good work
He said on patrion about 8 to 10 months.
@@12345....... thats so crazy i remember when he first announced it
The Witcher 3 is my all time favourite game and this video was so incredible, super well explained, love the dives into the lore
¡Gracias!
Cannot wait to watch this! Been hyping this video for so long. You're solidifying yourself as one of the platform's best Witcher 3 content creators with every new video. We appreciate all the hard work you do to make a huge project such as this!
This is amazing, I‘ve been waiting for this ever since I saw your post announcing it, and it more than lived up to my expectations. Kerp up the great work
Love the switch to Fergus when mentioning the lack of competence😂
I never thought about Triss being in full control with the Menge scene, such a good angle.
The scene with Junior is one of the most intense ones in the game for me, the exhaustion and shock and anger Geralt feels in that moment are so well portrayed. 100% agree that there is no way Geralt would let him stay alive not only for Ciri but also for the threat he poses to any woman.
Completely agree that the third act is so rushed. It has some amazing scenes but I remember questioning on the first playthrough if I really did all the quests. Thescene with Sile was surprisinglyvery emotional. But I liked it.
Also would agree that Geralt would go with Xiri to the lodge. Though the scene in which Geralt and Yen are spying is quite cute, I definetly think it's more natural that he offers to go with her especially with Philippa being involved.
All in all great summary of Geralt's choices, really enjoyed watching it and would definetly love to see more videos like this but also get that's it requires an insane amout of work
Geralt always gives me protective Papa Bear vibes, but he never felt overprotective to me so it makes sense in my opinion that he offers Ciri to accompany her but also would be fine with her going alone.
Which in general is why to me it feels like he would always want to make sure that Ciri knows as much about a situation as possible (Emhyr's true agenda, what Phillipa is actually like...) before she makes **her** own choice.
He knows that Ciri went through more than what most people will experience over their lifetime so controlling her choices just becomes absurd as she clearly isn't a helpless idiot.
I could barely finish the mission with Triss being tortured... I couldn't bare to hear the screams. And seeing the blood on her hands after made me glad i sliced Menge to bits.
Incredible video, man. Thanks for taking the time to do this. It was very entertaining!
Fantastic series. I finished it recently as my first instalment and introduction. I got the bad ending. I was shattered. This is cathartic 😂
The "best" ending...just cos it's aligned in how TW world truly works🥺 (thanx the Gods I didn't get that one tho😁)
This is a masterpiece. Thanks for taking the time to do this, I (we?) have been excited for this since the Witcher 2 WWGD.
Thank you for this amazing and high quality video. Thank you for the amount of time dedicated to this project. It definitely worth the time.
It's wonderful how we still can learn new things about The Witcher 3 and it's been 8 years since released.
Hope you can do that video of the Witcher contracts but I'll understand that could take a lot of time and you need to rest.
You have a fan here in Mexico waiting for your content 💙🇲🇽.
Incredible video. I barely realized it was so long, just auto-played after another video of yours and ended up sitting through the whole thing.
Thanks so much for this video! There really are two perspectives you could have gone with: what would Geralt do in the moment or what would Geralt do in this situation.
Doing the in the moment one was totally legit, however that also made us miss out on the some super cool side quests. Would love to see that coverage as well!
Great job!
Excellent job, as someone in video production I know that every video you create (and truly care about) becomes a passion project and that really came through in this video. No corners cut here, you did an excellent job! Replaced or someone can go and read more about your production process? The s software you use, how you lay in the VO, etc.
Unbelievable job mate! So entertaining and everything made perfect sense. No idea how you managed to get an almost 3 hour video to flow so easy too.
The hard work you put into this definitely shows.
Just finished this BEAST of a video. What a gift to the Witcher community, can only imagine the work this took. Awesome job man. I can see this going viral again once the next Witcher game drops also 👀
The video is amazing, loved every second of it, and almost three hours went by like a couple of minutes - very much alike to the actual game. Your Witcher content is absolutely top-notch, and I would love to see more of it should you have time and inspiration to continue this series. Thank you!
I've had this video opened as a tab since it was released, as I got really excited when you said in your TW2 video that you'd be doing this. I've only just gotten time today to watch the whole thing, and I was not at all disappointed. I appreciate the effort you put into this, man. All nearly 3 hours was absolutely worth it.
Now I feel like I need to do a "what would Geralt do" playthrough where I keep the fact that Geralt is focused on Ciri in mind.
The one thing I will say is that despite it not making sense, unless there is something I missed, the Keira questline with Fyke Isle should still be played earlier just so that it doesn't make absolutely no sense for Geralt to sleep with Keira after sleeping with Yennefer twice in quick succession and professing his love. That just doesn't sit right for me, and I feel like Geralt wouldn't do that when he just put so much effort into securing things with Yennefer.
The only other thing I can justify Geralt going out of his way to do is to take the House of Reardon contract just because it ensures that Letho ends up in Kaer Morhen if you play your cards right, and also because if Geralt thought Letho was around, which he starts to suspect basically as soon as he gets to the property, he probably would have gone after him to see what he is doing. I can justify Geralt having to pass by the area of that quest just to get some coin for his later endeavors in finding Ciri.
I hope you get the resources to do follow-up videos on TW3! This was a great one!
You don’t have to sleep with Keira you can tell her that there is someone else and she will call Geralt old fashioned.
I can’t wait for the DLC versions and other side quests if you’ve planned them. I’m hoping to join your patreon soon. Great work as always.
This video is bonkers, only found your channel like a month ago, still amazed that even though we are coming up on a decade after W3 was released people are still making absolute banger videos on it
This isn't what this video is about, but the summary you gave of the story was amazing! It's been more than 6 years since I last played The Witcher 3, so my memory of the main quest and the lore-accurate sidequests Geralt would do was a little hazy. Having the story retold in this format with added information from the books and previous games etc. made me gain a whole new appreciation for the game. Like damn the story up until the last parts of the game is way better than I remembered! Thank you for the video!
It took me three days to get through this video, because I wanted to have time to focus and really enjoy it. Very worthwhile! I echo all the positive things I’ve seen in the comments already. Plus I love your deadpan delivery of some comedic points. “You must be doing a ‘bad choices’ playthrough.” Fabulous work, and I hope you are favored by the almighty algorithm!
Video Very Good!!! Seriously though, I love the interaction of someone informed about the books with the game. The books are so amazing and they don’t get enough youtube press, of great quality, since the games are so much more popular and visually stimulating.
By far one of the "walkthroughs" of the game. I finished witcher multiple times years ago. It's a great video, makes me want to play more. You're a great creator i would love to see more. Congratulations on making one of the best witcher videos out there. Much love and admiration.
Thank you very much for this amazing video. Well crafted and a joy to watch for almost three hours.
And i think i'm not the only one who'd like future videos for secondary quests, witcher contracts, heart of stone and blood and wine.
The wait is finally over, I can't wait to watch all of this.
I had a feeling it would release today, exactly a year after the 10 Choices Geralt Would Never Take.
I got chills when you said “Whoreson dies every time.” 👏
I really appreciate a video that allows me reexperience the game without starting a complete playthrough. Thanks so much!!!!!
The scope of this video was insane, thank you for making it! It made work today a little more bearable with something interesting to listen to
I would love to see more choices videos on side quests and DLCs! But i understand that it's exhausting. Thanks for this video! And i couldnt agree more with the Bart choice. If you kill Bart, you're inhuman.
Amazing analysis! While it’s a shame to think Geralt would miss out on things such as assassinating Radovid and seeing Letho again (especially after your compelling argument that Geralt would definitely save him) I loved the breakdown of reasoning you gave as to each choice. I’d love to do a playthroughs mirroring these choices to experience how they play out in real time.
I really hope this video does well for you because it absolutely deserves all the fan attention, and I definitely want to see at least a “WWGD” video on the two expansions, if not soon then hopefully later on down the road. In general I love the content and hope to continue to see more, whether is long analyses like this or otherwise!
Yes! So happy you've finally completed this! I really love your format and appreciate the work you had to put in to make this!
This is such an awesome video.
Saw interesting video, clicked the thumbnail, didn't regret spending 2,5h watching this.
I couldn't move from the couch. You, sir, have done a masterpiece.
This was epic! Really appreciate the hard work. This must've been a daunting task. Very well done.
I'm glad you did this because it was eye opening for me. I am a naïve player and jump at the chance of helping anyone whom I come across. Example, I was so shocked by the gruesome death of Annabelle that I completely dismissed the queues that she wasn't being completely honest. Great video! Joy to watch!
Got through Velen and so far it’s perfect in decisions and editing/delivery. Liked and will finish later today. Great job!
this 3 hour video deserves so much more than just a like and subscribe
no way bro said megadeth style, i love that. great videos about witcher and also knows Megadeth 11/10 love this guy.
Holy moly please continue this series, this might be the best w3 video i've ever seen, such a phenomenal job my guy, you've earned a subscriber.
Watched this for the second time. It’s just so good. The production. The quality. Just amazing.
I really hope the support from your viewers is strong enough for you to continue this series. I loved this entry and I wish you the best of luck with all that you do!
This was an extremely well written and edited video, and it would be very cool if you were to continue this series.
i really enjoy these videos, i have all 3 in a playlist and fall asleep to it every night. i’m just really happy this exist
What a masterpiece,I really hope you can manage to continue this series, absolutely love every second of it!
An absolutely impeccable description of the choices that Geralt would make in the game and thanks for the additional lore!
This was spectacular! Would love to see more content like this. Absolutely love your sense of humor. Thank you for all the hard work you poured into making this ❤
Amazing work sir ! It's realy nice to have a comparison ton our own choices we made in game ^^ Also you show so much love and dedication toward the game and us. Thx
Bro, I like all your videos on this game but this one is your best. I’m sure this took a ton of time to make, keep up the good work 👍🏻