Time Markers: 0:00 - Let's Hear it for the Booms 1:27 - Jump to Conclusions (The PSA1 is My Favorite) 2:57 - Blue Compass Overview 4:35 - Compass Tension Issues 7:53 - Gator Frameworks Overview 8:41 - Gator Internal XLR Pros & Cons 9:56 - Gator Frameworks' Biggest Weakness 11:31 - Rode PSA1 Conclusion (and Cons) 13:33 - Blue Compass Conclusion 14:25 - Gator Frameworks Conclusion 15:12 - Final Thoughts - You Get What You Pay For
Hey Tom! How did you leave a comment before the video was published? When I schedule my videos, it doesn't let me set a sticky comment in advance. Thanks!
You know, I must have watched 10-15 videos on these arms. This video is by far the best comparison of them (and the gator frameworks which was unknown to me before this video). You researched and covered nearly all aspects of the arms and how to adjust them (specifically for the Compass, something many other videos failed to do) and your honesty with your bias was appreciated. I was leaning towards the compass but you’ve swayed me to save a bit of money and go for the more solid performer over looks. So thank you for your help! 😊
I’m glad to hear it! For what it’s worth, I gave the compass to my wife after this video, but she quickly got annoyed by how difficult it can be to position, so I swapped it with a Rode and she loves it. The ease of use of the Rode really stands out after using another arm. Now I use the Compass as an overhead boom, which works well since it likes to stay high.
For the blue: If you balance the mic with the tension knob the bottom, then adjust the friction points the Blue will stay in whatever position (read: every position) you put it in. It’s in the instructions that came with the arm. Mine is balanced perfectly with a Shure SM7B, which is lighter than your pod mic. Your tension is to tight or your friction is too loose if it springs up in any postion. It took all of 2 minutes to get mine perfect.
I got a Blue Compass. When my mic is stowed away, I want it to be fully folded. When I want to use my mic, I want to pull it toward me and have it positioned at chest height. This type of movement is dead simple with any cheap scissor stand from Amazon but impossible to set up with my Compass, no matter how I adjust the tension or friction...
I have to say my man, I’m glad you are a creator. Every time I have questions about my podcast equipment you always point me in the right direction. Thank you brother! Good luck with everything. If I get a chance I’ll plug your channel.
THANK YOU! This is realyl nice to read. Feel free to let me know if there's ever anything you have a question about- it might be a good idea for a video. 👍
There are two things that always stick out to me about your channel: 1. You have some of the best formatting for these types of videos. Great time stamps, you give a short summary of the outcome before going into the details, and it's broken out really well. 2. Your color palette is really visually appealing. There's a calming blue theme to it. It really sticks out when looking through my subscription list. Keep making great content!
Wow! I'm so glad to hear this! It's easy to feel sort of stuck in your own bubble when making stuff, and I'm happy to know my intentions are making it through to the other side!
I have the Gator Frameworks and the more I use it the more it sucks. Loud, sticky, can’t hinge upward, stoppers at hinges. So many things wrong but it looks sweet on camera. Great work Tom Buck!
I had a blue compass boom arm and it was unable to stay in position and rose/sank as it pleased. The positioning you show in the video worked, but blocked my face for video. The integrated cable clips were also finnicky and eventually warped with usage. It lasted me about 6 months before I ended up throwing it out because of all the faults. The tension was horrible and I'm glad it was addressed in this video. This was well over a year ago and it's disappointing to see they haven't fixed these issues.
I'm now using mine as a boom for my Videomic during videos since I like that to be above the frame and the arm like to stay high. Definitely not ideal in other situations though.
I bought the Gator Boom Arm because it can lock in place. I have a noise shield, pop filter, shock mount and a Shure SM7B microphone attached to the arm and it holds the weight really well. So if you have heavy attachments on the arm be sure to get a boom arm that can support the weight or has a tightening mechanisms on it.
DANGER CHRISTOPHER ROBINSON: Thank you Tom for this. I went with the Rode PSA1 for my Shure SM7B and I am so happy with it. I have one thing to say. If you are ordering from Amazon, make sure that your PSA1 does not ship from Amazon's warehouses but from the seller directly. It's just that if it ships from Amazon, there is a big chance that they have a warehouse process where the middle articulation gets pressured against something and it breaks. I got one like that and it comes with a broken cable plastic router and it squeaked a lot (a metal against metal noise). I had to send it back. I then read a lot of people complaining about the same when getting it directly from Amazon. I ordered on Amazon but I went to "Available from these sellers" and bought one that said "Ships from [seller]" not from Amazon. The second one was bliss.
Wow! How interesting. I've never had the squeaking issue, but after making this video, several people have contacted me saying that they're having the problem. I wonder if that's what it is?
Totally agree! I own a blue arm as well and have the same issues even with the SM7B. Also the desk mount plate broke after only some weeks. Now it sits in a Rode desk mount. Overall the more optically pleasing but very imperfect product.
DAMN. Just damn, this was extremely helpful I was about to pickup a Blue Compass and this video really helped steer me towards the Rode PSA1. I'm really glad I found this video. Big thanks!
I'm so glad to hear that! I hope you like the PSA 1 (I'm sure you will). The Blue has some nice features but if you read through the comments here you'll see quite a few people who had the sam issue that I did.
I was given a Blue compass and it took longer setting up the arm tension than it did to setup the rest of my work from home desk. The arm sits over my laptop and when I need to use it for a call, I can pull the mic down and the arms do not swing back. This took forever to figure out as the arms were swinging all over the place but if you have one of these, definitely put in the time to get the tension setup for what works for you.
How? I have adjusted literally everything there is to adjust, and it still just swings all over the place. I've adjusted the knobs on each of the joints as well as the tension screw on the bottom. I've literally gone from all the way unscrewed to as far in as it'll go. I've literally spent hours on this thing and it will NOT hold a Blue Yeti, which is driving me nuts. I'm about to just return the thing
@@Austneal honestly I’ve had the compass for a year now and regret not getting the psa 1. The problem with the compass is that you need a heavy ass mic. My mv7 isn’t heavy which is why I bought an extender to keep it down where I want it. It just sucks
As a compass owner, I agree with the initial frustration over figuring out the tension but after an hour or so of trial and error I was able to adjust tension perfectly for use with a Blue Yeti X and have loved the look and function ever since. I found a TH-cam video with instructions how to get tension perfect and I prefer the modern look of the compass.
I'm glad you were able to get yours adjusted well. I watched a lot of videos, spent a lot of time, but didn't get there. My wife is now using it with her Yeti and it works great because she has it positioned higher up.
To fix the drooping issue on the compass u actually need to turn the nob thats nearest to the microphone the one right on top of it and it will fix it.
I have the blue compass and that's not what that knob does. None of the knobs change the spring tension, they only change the friction at each point. His issue was not at the last joint but it was the middle and first joints that were moving when he didn't want them to. Tightening those would help alleviate the issue.
Same, I just picked one up today at Best Buy since I do telework from home, and I upgraded to an XLR setup. I’m literally going to take it back today and just order either a PSA 1 or the Elgato Wave Arm. The Compass is just completely unusable, 0/10 do not recommend.
Ever thought of trying monitor arms? There's a colleague of yours who calls himself DSLR Shooter who demonstrates this rather cleverly. They take much more weight, they come with built-in cable management, they can be pushed out of the way when not in use and they only need a little modification - theoretically.
Yes, I love Caleb's videos! I've been watching him for like 10 years. I've definitely thought about doing a setup like his, but I have all my current arms, so I don't want to be wasteful.
Great view, thank you! PSA: PSA1s are a bit hard to find right now. Be careful because there are some retailers (Helix Camera for instance) obfuscating their stock status. They will charge you then suddenly become hard to get a hold of. I had this experience with them specifically. They list "Available for Purchase" instead of telling you it's backordered.
Great video... love the Rode PS1. The next video you will have to do is how to hide the cable inside the PS1 tube... did this yesterday and it takes the 'look' up to the next level. No more velcro straps and cables hanging off it. Keep up the great work
@@tombuck Simple if you have the tools and know what you are doing 😉. Or for us people who are not technically capable, you pay $24 for your local goto electronic equipment providers to do it for you lol. After its done, it looks great... might be a next video idea for you. Grateful for the personal response
WOW! You really lowered the boom with this video. I was literally on Amazon checking out options for boom arms when I decided to swing over to your channel. Your booming endorsement of the PSA1 has helped me making up my mind. Plus, I have the RODECaster Pro and a Podmic, so..... Thanks!!
I'm glad it was helpful! Hopefully you enjoy the PSA 1 (sorry for the late reply, for some reason this comment ended up in the spam folder 🤷🏻♂️)
3 ปีที่แล้ว +4
Never owned anything but my PSA1, until now, I didn't know how good I actually had it Now I can't stop smiling when I move my microphone around, and it stays exactly where I put it :D
Hey Tom, bit late on commenting but your mention of overtightening the plastic is 100% correct...they do indeed break😓 I have a yeti X in my current setup and that arm just wouldn't stay put. 100% on me for breaking it. Thanks Blue/Logitech for filling the tube with what seems like boom arm Viagra...
All the comments about the Blue Compass are correct , I use a HyperX microphone with the Blue compass and it sucks constantly trying to tighten it. You really need a pair of pliers to get it to stay where you want it, but you then run the risk of cracking the cheap plastic turn knobs.
Pun Comments: that boom ARM pun was "booming!" The brand name puns never get old... The tension jokes are outSTANDing... 🤣🤣🤣 Real life (not pun related) question... Which one of those would you say is the most mobile friendly. (Its not like Im going anywhere anyway 🤣)
I think that people don't understand how to adjust the Blue Compass. Mine's been in service for four months, now, and it's been perfect. I've got a Sterling Audio ST55 condenser mic on it: only 1.2 pounds. What I did was *loosen* (turn counter-clockwise) the tension screw at the base, nearly all the way out. (In fact: all the way out until it actually un-threaded, and then back in until it was just barely threaded.) At that point, I adjusted the pivot tension knobs. It stays exactly where I put it, now, without a single problem. I love it.
First video I’ve ever seen from you - wow. That was awesome. The depth and the analysis and the detail of comparison was incredible. Originally wanted the frameworks and the compass but now I’m sort of leaning towards the PSA to balance my needs. ;) but I guess I need to choose a mic first. I’ve been using the elgato wave 3 but might switch to the shure MV7. Or maybe use that podmic you have. Idk which mic makes me happy yet lol
Dude... just found your video while looking for boom stands. Besides the good review and normally I really dont care at all, but big compliments to you. Its so natural , nice speed, nice sound, nice video quality, nice jokes, everything. Not overloaded like other youtuber who seem to be on coke 24/7. Keep that up! its obvious that you put much love into it ...and therefore success is unquestionable. cheers,
Bought the Frameworks a year ago because the Rode was on backorder for months. Very happy with it, would buy another. My clamp doesn't move. The flat springs are strong on this thing though, so it doesn't appear to be as easily adjustable as your Rode arm. Takes some force to adjust. Great video!
Thanks Tom, I purchased a PSA1. Works better than any boom I've ever had. Stays in place and easily swings out of the way. Would not have made that decision without your help. Third parties were selling them for $149.00 at Amazon. Bezos says he doesn't control third parties; more of his BS. I purchased from Sweetwater Audio for $99.00.
I have the shure mv7 with the blue compass and that thing that happens at 04:55 is one of my pet peeves with the blue. I’ve already played with the tension screw at the bottom, but it still does that annoying pop-up thing. Ughhhh. It’s really beautiful, but it does annoy me! (I have PSA1 envy right now).
@@tombuck I've been having a blast recording just random things with it so far, I do need to up my boom arm game though. I don't have a Neewer, but an innogear, which looks like the PSA-1 but feels way more stiff.
Wow you were so right. I bought the Gator Framework and a better clamp thinking I would get the best of both worlds. It worked but I didn't like the limitations on the rotation at the end of the arm. I bought the PSA1 to compare and it immediately got me with build quality and ease of positioning and how compact it can fold up. Its simple and it works great. Thanks for the in depth review!
Glad it helped! I have the Blue Compass to my wife, but she got tired of it and I traded her for one of the PSA1's and she immediately loved it. It's a great arm!
Thank you for giving an honest review on all three of the boom arms. You don’t realize how much your followers appreciate the information. I’ve bought things from your assessment of equipment. I’m a beginning podcaster. Still trying to decide what camera to buy.
I really appreciate that! These videos are always just my opinion, but I try and keep them as objective and down-to-earth as possible. Good luck with your podcast!
Wow thank you so much for this video. I was actually gonna buy the Blue Compass over the PSA1 but you pointed out the main problem with it. You’ve helped me out a ton :)
OK Boomer! That settles it, getting another PSA1, was thinking of the Blue Compass, and definitely don't want to spend get the Yellowtec Mika! (which I would get if it weren't so darn expensive!) www.yellowtec.com/mika.html
Ok I literally L'd out L at the boomer joke. Bravo, bravo. Those Mika arms are pricey, but it looks like you could really go crazy with building a custom setup.
@@tombuck I was waiting all video for you calling yourself a boomer 🤣 - it was a great comparison and great to see the pain points for the different booms!
I've honestly learned so much since first arriving here to watch a Podmic video once 'upun' a time. And I bought three, with a Rodecaster Pro, as a result (fourth pending, per aesthetic necessity). These days, I still learn a lot, but I admit I almost tune in as much, just for the cacophony of counting how many times you try (and mostly succeed) to be punny. It's a (mostly) productive and always positive part of my day.
Trying is what counts the most right? 😁 Thanks for sticking around so long! Feel free to send ideas my way if there’s something you think would be helpful for where you’re at in your podcast journey now.
You come close to what product designers mostly forget to take in account, the hufterproof rating. Great review on handling the products and its quirks.
I have found a great middle-ground for me. I use the Tonor T30. It's got great reach, and the clamp is huge, providing a headphone holder on the bottom. It is definitely more of a retro-vibe, closer in appearance to the PSA1. In fact, on the T30 (and its smaller cousin, the T20), the bottom section consists of 3 beams in a canteliever system. The arm is solid and stays exactly where I want it whether I extend it out far, leave the mic up high when not in use, or have it in the optimal speaking position just off of my mouth. I use mine with a Behringer XM8500 dynamic mic, but it will supposedly even hold the Blue Yeti, one of the heaviest mics around. The T20 is $40, and the T30 is $60, generally, and they include the arm, wire wraps for routing the XLR or USB cable, a foam windscreen, and a pop filter. I can't recommend them enough for the value.
oh my god right before I start the video I saw an ad for the gator frameworks boom arm and now out of nowhere i am seeing it that's an amazing coincidence
That's pretty bizarre haha! Since making this video, I've been noticing them a lot more in people's videos and podcasts. I guess I just wasn't aware of it before 🤷🏻♂️
Tom, I'd love to see you review the Joby Wavo boomarm. I've seen a number of reviews, but none very in-depth, certainly not the Tom Buck treatment. The one standout in all these reviews is the Joby arm stays put wherever you place, just like the PSA1/1+ and unlike most boom arms I've seen reviewed lately including the Blue. Very solid/stable looking in every video I've seen. The only caveat I've noticed in these reviews is that the swivel has a bit of play in it and when the arms are closed all the way there seems to be a bind, but that's all the way closed which would not be a common position I'd go into or start out of (save for initial use).
Oh wow, I didn't even know this existed! Looks pretty interesting. I'm still waiting for an arm that genuinely gets the mounting point right. The Joby looks to have a lot of flexibility though, which is great.
100% Agree. I had the Blue Compass paired with a yeti for 2 years and all I did every day was adjust it. Eventually the plastic tensioning nuts, broke off and it became unusable. I replaced both the boom arm and mic with a Rode PSA1 and Rode Procaster. Have not had a problem since. Too bad for the Gator frameworks arm, I liked the Big tensioning knobs which are what the Compass needed. They definitely need to work on the desk mount and beef it up.
Oh no, that's a frustrating experience for sure! I contacted Rode's support and they sent me a PSA1 desk clamp to use with the Gator arm, and now it works great.
Im not sure if anyone pointed it out yet but when you said "the PSA-1 is the road (Rode *wink*) you wanna go down" was a real nice line. Thought I'd mention it
I may have missed it but I think you missed a crucial juxtaposition between the plastic and metal boom arm for the rare occasions when those of us have to choose which is best suited for use in a place that's not grounded. Many metal boom arms cause slight feedback and tinny sounds especially when attached to a desk with metal thus a plastic boom arm is best to overcome that issue. That aside, thank you for another great video.
I really appreciate reviews like this. I was originally going to buy the Blue Compass just because it was expensive, and I wanted something top tier. However, after watching many reviews I have come to find out the Rode PSA1 is actually a much better engineered mic arm. Hence saving me some money because it is cheaper than the Blue Compass but works perfectly right out of the box.
Thank you so much for this in-depth comparison video. I almost got a Blue Compass but thought to myself: "I already try my best to have the camera focus on me, not my mic or boom arm". I prefer functionality over looks. Granted, the Blue Compass looks gorgeous but I think the angles you get with the PSA1 is a lot more useful to me. Thanks again. I subscribed to your channel and liked the video
I own a few PSA1s, and I’ve had a few people ask me if they can mount them on IKEA tables. And it’s yes, sort of. Ikea’s desks are often hollow, and can break up if you screw the clamp too tight. But if you can put something between the bottom of the clamp and the underside of the desk to distribute the pressure, you shouldn’t have any problem. Try something solid and strong - I’m using a dead 2.5” hard drive, but most folks won’t have one of them lying around, so I’d suggest something made of wood, thick plastic or metal, and at least around the size of a pack of cards. The top of the clamp is large and padded, so it should be fine.
I love the old hard drive as a mounting solution option! These clamps are definitely tough enough to damage a cheap table. My old Home Depot work benches work great!
You can actually mount a cable inside the rode arm. Though it is necessary to remove one of the connectors of the xlr cable to route it through the channel.
![ปฏิเสธไม่ไหว (Crush on you) - LIPTA feat. No One Else [TEASER MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VC689EgdSIw/mqdefault.jpg)
Time Markers:
0:00 - Let's Hear it for the Booms
1:27 - Jump to Conclusions (The PSA1 is My Favorite)
2:57 - Blue Compass Overview
4:35 - Compass Tension Issues
7:53 - Gator Frameworks Overview
8:41 - Gator Internal XLR Pros & Cons
9:56 - Gator Frameworks' Biggest Weakness
11:31 - Rode PSA1 Conclusion (and Cons)
13:33 - Blue Compass Conclusion
14:25 - Gator Frameworks Conclusion
15:12 - Final Thoughts - You Get What You Pay For
I have two Rode PSA1 and fixed the cables inside! I really like it! The looks of the others are awesome!
Hey Tom! How did you leave a comment before the video was published?
When I schedule my videos, it doesn't let me set a sticky comment in advance.
Thanks!
@@maxvcollenburg You could make your video unlisted, write your comments, then manually release the video.
@@ogviolinist8954 ah, that makes sense. Thanks!
@@maxvcollenburg You are welcome!
i just got the blue compass and even after adjusting everything i can, it still sling my mic and put a dent in my ceiling
I feel your pain.
But the mic survived? Cool. :-)
How heavy is your microphone?
Nokia makes microphones now?
You know, I must have watched 10-15 videos on these arms. This video is by far the best comparison of them (and the gator frameworks which was unknown to me before this video). You researched and covered nearly all aspects of the arms and how to adjust them (specifically for the Compass, something many other videos failed to do) and your honesty with your bias was appreciated. I was leaning towards the compass but you’ve swayed me to save a bit of money and go for the more solid performer over looks. So thank you for your help! 😊
I’m glad to hear it! For what it’s worth, I gave the compass to my wife after this video, but she quickly got annoyed by how difficult it can be to position, so I swapped it with a Rode and she loves it. The ease of use of the Rode really stands out after using another arm.
Now I use the Compass as an overhead boom, which works well since it likes to stay high.
For the blue: If you balance the mic with the tension knob the bottom, then adjust the friction points the Blue will stay in whatever position (read: every position) you put it in. It’s in the instructions that came with the arm. Mine is balanced perfectly with a Shure SM7B, which is lighter than your pod mic. Your tension is to tight or your friction is too loose if it springs up in any postion. It took all of 2 minutes to get mine perfect.
I was about to comment this-- the adjustmet is at the bottom.. but he actually did it-- maybe the mic's just too light
@@TheJeffyyyyy I have the same problem with this boom. Your solution does not work for me!
I got a Blue Compass. When my mic is stowed away, I want it to be fully folded. When I want to use my mic, I want to pull it toward me and have it positioned at chest height. This type of movement is dead simple with any cheap scissor stand from Amazon but impossible to set up with my Compass, no matter how I adjust the tension or friction...
@@WestonVierregger and weight to it like a pop filter
@@TheJeffyyyyy the mic is 2.1 pounds, def not too light.
I have to say my man, I’m glad you are a creator. Every time I have questions about my podcast equipment you always point me in the right direction. Thank you brother! Good luck with everything. If I get a chance I’ll plug your channel.
THANK YOU! This is realyl nice to read. Feel free to let me know if there's ever anything you have a question about- it might be a good idea for a video. 👍
My god, the puns are just 👌🔥
The corny jokes were priceless as well 🤦🏽♂️😆
There are two things that always stick out to me about your channel:
1. You have some of the best formatting for these types of videos. Great time stamps, you give a short summary of the outcome before going into the details, and it's broken out really well.
2. Your color palette is really visually appealing. There's a calming blue theme to it. It really sticks out when looking through my subscription list.
Keep making great content!
Wow! I'm so glad to hear this! It's easy to feel sort of stuck in your own bubble when making stuff, and I'm happy to know my intentions are making it through to the other side!
I have the Gator Frameworks and the more I use it the more it sucks. Loud, sticky, can’t hinge upward, stoppers at hinges. So many things wrong but it looks sweet on camera. Great work Tom Buck!
That's a bummer to hear, but thanks for letting us know!
You just convinced me to go with the PSA1. Thank you! And amazing B-roll, by the way. Beautiful shots!
Just make sure your order is not fulfilled by Amazon, but from the seller so that it comes in one piece. See my comment above.
I've watched about 20 videos to help me decide between which boom arm I want and this is the very best video review. THANK YOU!
I’m so glad to hear that! Hope you get the one that’s right for you 👍
I had a blue compass boom arm and it was unable to stay in position and rose/sank as it pleased. The positioning you show in the video worked, but blocked my face for video. The integrated cable clips were also finnicky and eventually warped with usage. It lasted me about 6 months before I ended up throwing it out because of all the faults. The tension was horrible and I'm glad it was addressed in this video. This was well over a year ago and it's disappointing to see they haven't fixed these issues.
I'm now using mine as a boom for my Videomic during videos since I like that to be above the frame and the arm like to stay high. Definitely not ideal in other situations though.
You always make the right videos at the right time! I've been looking for a new boom arm and this answered all the questions I've had.
I'm so glad to hear it! I must be psychic 🤔
Really good review. Before this video I had no clue wich one was the best for me.
It makes me really happy to hear this! Hopefully you get one that's right for you 👍
I bought the Gator Boom Arm because it can lock in place. I have a noise shield, pop filter, shock mount and a Shure SM7B microphone attached to the arm and it holds the weight really well. So if you have heavy attachments on the arm be sure to get a boom arm that can support the weight or has a tightening mechanisms on it.
Really happy to hear the Gator is working for you!
DANGER CHRISTOPHER ROBINSON: Thank you Tom for this. I went with the Rode PSA1 for my Shure SM7B and I am so happy with it. I have one thing to say. If you are ordering from Amazon, make sure that your PSA1 does not ship from Amazon's warehouses but from the seller directly. It's just that if it ships from Amazon, there is a big chance that they have a warehouse process where the middle articulation gets pressured against something and it breaks. I got one like that and it comes with a broken cable plastic router and it squeaked a lot (a metal against metal noise). I had to send it back. I then read a lot of people complaining about the same when getting it directly from Amazon. I ordered on Amazon but I went to "Available from these sellers" and bought one that said "Ships from [seller]" not from Amazon. The second one was bliss.
Wow! How interesting. I've never had the squeaking issue, but after making this video, several people have contacted me saying that they're having the problem. I wonder if that's what it is?
Totally agree! I own a blue arm as well and have the same issues even with the SM7B. Also the desk mount plate broke after only some weeks. Now it sits in a Rode desk mount. Overall the more optically pleasing but very imperfect product.
Interesting. Seems like the Rode desk clamp is the most reliable.
Super helpful comparison, Tom! Thanks! And thanks for all the puns!
Thanks Curtis! I've got the new Rode PSA1+ here now, so I'll be doing another video on that one. 👍
So many puns! This one was so informative, thanks for the time and effort you put into your channel.
Thank you! I tried to pack this one full of puns haha
DAMN. Just damn, this was extremely helpful I was about to pickup a Blue Compass and this video really helped steer me towards the Rode PSA1. I'm really glad I found this video. Big thanks!
I'm so glad to hear that! I hope you like the PSA 1 (I'm sure you will). The Blue has some nice features but if you read through the comments here you'll see quite a few people who had the sam issue that I did.
Best review i have ever seen for these products, period! Subscribed brother, thanks so much 👊🏻
Thank you! Wow- I really appreciate that 🙏
Thanks again Tom! Going to check out the podcast playlist now!
"...just like I do"
Smooth, very smooth 😆
Great straightforward presentation and review, Thank-you
I was given a Blue compass and it took longer setting up the arm tension than it did to setup the rest of my work from home desk. The arm sits over my laptop and when I need to use it for a call, I can pull the mic down and the arms do not swing back. This took forever to figure out as the arms were swinging all over the place but if you have one of these, definitely put in the time to get the tension setup for what works for you.
I'm really happy to hear you were able to get it to work! Time and patience really are the solution to many problems.
How? I have adjusted literally everything there is to adjust, and it still just swings all over the place. I've adjusted the knobs on each of the joints as well as the tension screw on the bottom. I've literally gone from all the way unscrewed to as far in as it'll go. I've literally spent hours on this thing and it will NOT hold a Blue Yeti, which is driving me nuts. I'm about to just return the thing
@@Austneal honestly I’ve had the compass for a year now and regret not getting the psa 1. The problem with the compass is that you need a heavy ass mic. My mv7 isn’t heavy which is why I bought an extender to keep it down where I want it. It just sucks
This is one of the best breakdowns ive seen. Fantastic
Thank you! It means a lot to hear that 💥💪
This was incredibly informative and exactly what I needed. Thank you so much! PS(A) you sold me on the Rode PSA1!
Nice! I’m so glad to hear it! Hopefully you enjoy the Rode 👍
As a compass owner, I agree with the initial frustration over figuring out the tension but after an hour or so of trial and error I was able to adjust tension perfectly for use with a Blue Yeti X and have loved the look and function ever since. I found a TH-cam video with instructions how to get tension perfect and I prefer the modern look of the compass.
I'm glad you were able to get yours adjusted well. I watched a lot of videos, spent a lot of time, but didn't get there. My wife is now using it with her Yeti and it works great because she has it positioned higher up.
Why dont you share such video link pls?
To fix the drooping issue on the compass u actually need to turn the nob thats nearest to the microphone the one right on top of it and it will fix it.
Fr I got mine perfect an I have a pretty heavy mice
I have the blue compass and that's not what that knob does. None of the knobs change the spring tension, they only change the friction at each point. His issue was not at the last joint but it was the middle and first joints that were moving when he didn't want them to. Tightening those would help alleviate the issue.
Really wish I watched this before I bought the Blue Compass...Best review I've watched, and I've watched a lot...
I’m glad it helped…even if not as soon as it could have 😬
Same, I just picked one up today at Best Buy since I do telework from home, and I upgraded to an XLR setup. I’m literally going to take it back today and just order either a PSA 1 or the Elgato Wave Arm. The Compass is just completely unusable, 0/10 do not recommend.
Ever thought of trying monitor arms? There's a colleague of yours who calls himself DSLR Shooter who demonstrates this rather cleverly. They take much more weight, they come with built-in cable management, they can be pushed out of the way when not in use and they only need a little modification - theoretically.
Yes, I love Caleb's videos! I've been watching him for like 10 years. I've definitely thought about doing a setup like his, but I have all my current arms, so I don't want to be wasteful.
Slick, well presented in granular detail & therefore super informative-thanks Tom
This is really nice to hear, thanks so much Steve!
I’m ready to spring into action.
Nice.
Ok, Boomer! 😬
Great view, thank you!
PSA: PSA1s are a bit hard to find right now. Be careful because there are some retailers (Helix Camera for instance) obfuscating their stock status. They will charge you then suddenly become hard to get a hold of. I had this experience with them specifically. They list "Available for Purchase" instead of telling you it's backordered.
Great video... love the Rode PS1. The next video you will have to do is how to hide the cable inside the PS1 tube... did this yesterday and it takes the 'look' up to the next level. No more velcro straps and cables hanging off it. Keep up the great work
I've seen people do that and I've heard that I've heard that the cable soldering required is pretty simple.
@@tombuck Simple if you have the tools and know what you are doing 😉. Or for us people who are not technically capable, you pay $24 for your local goto electronic equipment providers to do it for you lol.
After its done, it looks great... might be a next video idea for you.
Grateful for the personal response
Thank You for review, Tom! I bought PSA1 for my MV7 after reading customers reviews about compass.. It's simple and solid.
I use that same combo for all of my online classes and it works really well. The MV7 is a great sounding mic!
1:16 - 6/10
1:19 - 4/10
1:25 - 7/10 made me chuckle
2:59 - 6/10 unexpected
6:20 - 4/10
7:55 - 5/10
16:23 - 6/10
Good video!
I tried to give you a lot to grade this week. 😁
WOW! You really lowered the boom with this video. I was literally on Amazon checking out options for boom arms when I decided to swing over to your channel. Your booming endorsement of the PSA1 has helped me making up my mind. Plus, I have the RODECaster Pro and a Podmic, so..... Thanks!!
I'm glad it was helpful! Hopefully you enjoy the PSA 1 (sorry for the late reply, for some reason this comment ended up in the spam folder 🤷🏻♂️)
Never owned anything but my PSA1, until now, I didn't know how good I actually had it
Now I can't stop smiling when I move my microphone around, and it stays exactly where I put it :D
You don't know what you've got til it's gone 😉
Agreed. And the beauty of a parallelogram must be in the eye of the beholder. I think the PSA-1 is the best, no fuss, home option.
The best comparison of the two that I've seen on YT!!
Thank you so much!
I thought my Blue Compass was broken!! Thank you 🙏🏾😂😂
It is broken from a design perspective.
Hey Tom, bit late on commenting but your mention of overtightening the plastic is 100% correct...they do indeed break😓 I have a yeti X in my current setup and that arm just wouldn't stay put. 100% on me for breaking it. Thanks Blue/Logitech for filling the tube with what seems like boom arm Viagra...
i love how the blue looks so much but it not staying at a certain angle makes me not get it thanks
All the comments about the Blue Compass are
correct , I use a HyperX microphone with the Blue compass and it sucks constantly trying to tighten it. You really need a pair of pliers to get it to stay where you want it, but you then run the risk of cracking the cheap plastic turn knobs.
Man has 3 podmics and then there’s me dreaming of having one
Perhaps the best review I've seen so far!
Thank you! 🙏
Pun Comments: that boom ARM pun was "booming!" The brand name puns never get old... The tension jokes are outSTANDing... 🤣🤣🤣
Real life (not pun related) question... Which one of those would you say is the most mobile friendly. (Its not like Im going anywhere anyway 🤣)
Probably the Rode. You will need some sort of strap to keep it folded so the springs don't pop it open, but it gets pretty compact.
@@tombuck is the psa1 best for hitting the rode?
I think that people don't understand how to adjust the Blue Compass. Mine's been in service for four months, now, and it's been perfect.
I've got a Sterling Audio ST55 condenser mic on it: only 1.2 pounds. What I did was *loosen* (turn counter-clockwise) the tension screw at the base, nearly all the way out. (In fact: all the way out until it actually un-threaded, and then back in until it was just barely threaded.) At that point, I adjusted the pivot tension knobs.
It stays exactly where I put it, now, without a single problem. I love it.
I tried that with mine, but still now luck. It's a great tip though and maybe someone else will be able to get their working with your advice!
First video I’ve ever seen from you - wow. That was awesome. The depth and the analysis and the detail of comparison was incredible. Originally wanted the frameworks and the compass but now I’m sort of leaning towards the PSA to balance my needs. ;) but I guess I need to choose a mic first. I’ve been using the elgato wave 3 but might switch to the shure MV7. Or maybe use that podmic you have. Idk which mic makes me happy yet lol
Thanks for the kind words! And hey, there's nothing wrong with having a rotating lineup of mics if you have the budget for it 😁
Dude...
just found your video while looking for boom stands.
Besides the good review and normally I really dont care at all, but big compliments to you.
Its so natural , nice speed, nice sound, nice video quality, nice jokes, everything.
Not overloaded like other youtuber who seem to be on coke 24/7.
Keep that up! its obvious that you put much love into it ...and therefore success is unquestionable.
cheers,
Thank you! I’m sorry I missed this when you first posted.
Now I see why the rode podmic has been on back order and I can't get one for the last month.
Bought the Frameworks a year ago because the Rode was on backorder for months. Very happy with it, would buy another. My clamp doesn't move. The flat springs are strong on this thing though, so it doesn't appear to be as easily adjustable as your Rode arm. Takes some force to adjust. Great video!
I really like it overall! Super sturdy.
holy smokes, all the puns are on point
Thanks Tom,
I purchased a PSA1. Works better than any boom I've ever had. Stays in place and easily swings out of the way. Would not have made that decision without your help.
Third parties were selling them for $149.00 at Amazon. Bezos says he doesn't control third parties; more of his BS. I purchased from Sweetwater Audio for $99.00.
Sweetwater is awesome. I'm pretty sure their service is unbeatable!
I have the shure mv7 with the blue compass and that thing that happens at 04:55 is one of my pet peeves with the blue. I’ve already played with the tension screw at the bottom, but it still does that annoying pop-up thing. Ughhhh. It’s really beautiful, but it does annoy me! (I have PSA1 envy right now).
The Blue is working great for my wife’s setup with a higher positioned mic, but yeah, I love the Rode.
It's because of you I bought my first Podmic. It just came in last night and I fell in love with it.
I'm so glad to hear it! I think it's an outstanding mic.
@@tombuck I've been having a blast recording just random things with it so far, I do need to up my boom arm game though. I don't have a Neewer, but an innogear, which looks like the PSA-1 but feels way more stiff.
i want to let everyone know..spend the money RODE PSA1 is the best boom arm.
have to disagree, I've tested mine for a few weeks now, and i'm not happy.
@@TheLazyP same for me. For some reason, over time, the metal started to bend and now makes insane squeeky noices. Really annoying...
Soooooo good! Thanks for a thorough look at the little things that matter in selecting a boom arm for the long-term.
The little things can make the biggest difference for sure.
dam those puns are smooth
😎
Wow you were so right. I bought the Gator Framework and a better clamp thinking I would get the best of both worlds. It worked but I didn't like the limitations on the rotation at the end of the arm. I bought the PSA1 to compare and it immediately got me with build quality and ease of positioning and how compact it can fold up. Its simple and it works great. Thanks for the in depth review!
Glad it helped! I have the Blue Compass to my wife, but she got tired of it and I traded her for one of the PSA1's and she immediately loved it. It's a great arm!
I’m not going to lie, I hate that I can’t get my compass situated where I want it.
I took a piece of paracord and tied the arm down cause mine never gets low enough.
Thank you for giving an honest review on all three of the boom arms. You don’t realize how much your followers appreciate the information. I’ve bought things from your assessment of equipment. I’m a beginning podcaster. Still trying to decide what camera to buy.
I really appreciate that! These videos are always just my opinion, but I try and keep them as objective and down-to-earth as possible. Good luck with your podcast!
I LOVE THIS SWEATER ON YOU DARLING! 😘😘
Thank you! 🥰
Awesome video. Love all the angles you are getting for your reviews. The extra work does not go unnoticed!
Thank you! I had to call in the probe lens for a few of these.
Sticking with my PSA1’s
Just what i needed to know about these arms! Thanks.
I'm happy to hear that!
That was Boomiful 🤪
Wow thank you so much for this video. I was actually gonna buy the Blue Compass over the PSA1 but you pointed out the main problem with it. You’ve helped me out a ton :)
I'm happy to hear it! Hopefully you get what's right for you.
OK Boomer! That settles it, getting another PSA1, was thinking of the Blue Compass, and definitely don't want to spend get the Yellowtec Mika! (which I would get if it weren't so darn expensive!) www.yellowtec.com/mika.html
Ok I literally L'd out L at the boomer joke. Bravo, bravo. Those Mika arms are pricey, but it looks like you could really go crazy with building a custom setup.
@@tombuck I was waiting all video for you calling yourself a boomer 🤣 - it was a great comparison and great to see the pain points for the different booms!
What's that link
This is exactly what I was looking for! thank you so much! Awesome video.
I'm glad to hear that! Hopefully it helps you find the arm that works best for your setup 👍
I think the PSA1 is the rode I’m gonna stay on 😂😂 damn these jokes
I've honestly learned so much since first arriving here to watch a Podmic video once 'upun' a time. And I bought three, with a Rodecaster Pro, as a result (fourth pending, per aesthetic necessity). These days, I still learn a lot, but I admit I almost tune in as much, just for the cacophony of counting how many times you try (and mostly succeed) to be punny. It's a (mostly) productive and always positive part of my day.
Trying is what counts the most right? 😁
Thanks for sticking around so long! Feel free to send ideas my way if there’s something you think would be helpful for where you’re at in your podcast journey now.
Extra helpful vid, one of the few where I got the impression you actually thoroughly tried all options. Also, you seem like a nice guy.
Thank you! I really appreciate this. 🙏
You come close to what product designers mostly forget to take in account, the hufterproof rating. Great review on handling the products and its quirks.
I've never heard of the hufterproof rating, but you're 100% right. Especially when I was using equipment with students, that was a _huge_ factor.
very detail oriented. touches all the real user concerns. great job
Thank you! I really appreciate the kind words 🙏
Great video round up Tom. You kept my atTension for the entire video. Looking forward to the next one.
Haha, thank you!
This perfectly answered my question of which to get. Thanks!
So glad it helped!
Great demonstration and review of all three podcast arms. Thank you very much for this information!
Glad it was helpful!
I got mine RODE PSA1, thanks for recommendation Tom!
Woo hoo! Glad you're liking it.
I have found a great middle-ground for me. I use the Tonor T30. It's got great reach, and the clamp is huge, providing a headphone holder on the bottom. It is definitely more of a retro-vibe, closer in appearance to the PSA1. In fact, on the T30 (and its smaller cousin, the T20), the bottom section consists of 3 beams in a canteliever system. The arm is solid and stays exactly where I want it whether I extend it out far, leave the mic up high when not in use, or have it in the optimal speaking position just off of my mouth. I use mine with a Behringer XM8500 dynamic mic, but it will supposedly even hold the Blue Yeti, one of the heaviest mics around. The T20 is $40, and the T30 is $60, generally, and they include the arm, wire wraps for routing the XLR or USB cable, a foam windscreen, and a pop filter. I can't recommend them enough for the value.
Ahh, I've seen the T30 in other people's setups but I didn't know what it was. Thanks for pointing it out!
I’ve tried a bunch of these and was unhappy with all of them.
The Gator is a beast and perfect for the SM7B. I find it to be a perfect combination.
I'm so glad it's working out for you!
oh my god right before I start the video I saw an ad for the gator frameworks boom arm and now out of nowhere i am seeing it that's an amazing coincidence
That's pretty bizarre haha! Since making this video, I've been noticing them a lot more in people's videos and podcasts. I guess I just wasn't aware of it before 🤷🏻♂️
I will be going with the compass. Great review helped me decide.
Glad to hear it! Hope you enjoy the arm!
Tom, I needed this video right now. I knew you would have it too before I even looked. Thank you!
Mans got a mic for each stand, money aint a question no more
The true measure of wealth 🎩
Tom, I'd love to see you review the Joby Wavo boomarm.
I've seen a number of reviews, but none very in-depth, certainly not the Tom Buck treatment. The one standout in all these reviews is the Joby arm stays put wherever you place, just like the PSA1/1+ and unlike most boom arms I've seen reviewed lately including the Blue. Very solid/stable looking in every video I've seen. The only caveat I've noticed in these reviews is that the swivel has a bit of play in it and when the arms are closed all the way there seems to be a bind, but that's all the way closed which would not be a common position I'd go into or start out of (save for initial use).
Oh wow, I didn't even know this existed! Looks pretty interesting. I'm still waiting for an arm that genuinely gets the mounting point right. The Joby looks to have a lot of flexibility though, which is great.
Tom you are literally the best when it comes to these equipment reviews!
Thank you! That really means a lot to me.
100% Agree. I had the Blue Compass paired with a yeti for 2 years and all I did every day was adjust it. Eventually the plastic tensioning nuts, broke off and it became unusable. I replaced both the boom arm and mic with a Rode PSA1 and Rode Procaster. Have not had a problem since.
Too bad for the Gator frameworks arm, I liked the Big tensioning knobs which are what the Compass needed. They definitely need to work on the desk mount and beef it up.
Oh no, that's a frustrating experience for sure! I contacted Rode's support and they sent me a PSA1 desk clamp to use with the Gator arm, and now it works great.
Im not sure if anyone pointed it out yet but when you said "the PSA-1 is the road (Rode *wink*) you wanna go down" was a real nice line. Thought I'd mention it
I appreciate your appreciation 😁
I may have missed it but I think you missed a crucial juxtaposition between the plastic and metal boom arm for the rare occasions when those of us have to choose which is best suited for use in a place that's not grounded. Many metal boom arms cause slight feedback and tinny sounds especially when attached to a desk with metal thus a plastic boom arm is best to overcome that issue. That aside, thank you for another great video.
That’s a good point that I didn’t even think of. I’ve always looked for metal arms for durability 🤔
I really appreciate reviews like this. I was originally going to buy the Blue Compass just because it was expensive, and I wanted something top tier. However, after watching many reviews I have come to find out the Rode PSA1 is actually a much better engineered mic arm. Hence saving me some money because it is cheaper than the Blue Compass but works perfectly right out of the box.
Glad it was helpful! The Rode arms are tried and true. 💪
FANTASTIC WORK! ⭐
Thank you so much for this in-depth comparison video. I almost got a Blue Compass but thought to myself: "I already try my best to have the camera focus on me, not my mic or boom arm". I prefer functionality over looks. Granted, the Blue Compass looks gorgeous but I think the angles you get with the PSA1 is a lot more useful to me. Thanks again. I subscribed to your channel and liked the video
Thank you! The PSA 1 is far and away the most functional. 👍
I own a few PSA1s, and I’ve had a few people ask me if they can mount them on IKEA tables. And it’s yes, sort of.
Ikea’s desks are often hollow, and can break up if you screw the clamp too tight. But if you can put something between the bottom of the clamp and the underside of the desk to distribute the pressure, you shouldn’t have any problem.
Try something solid and strong - I’m using a dead 2.5” hard drive, but most folks won’t have one of them lying around, so I’d suggest something made of wood, thick plastic or metal, and at least around the size of a pack of cards. The top of the clamp is large and padded, so it should be fine.
I love the old hard drive as a mounting solution option! These clamps are definitely tough enough to damage a cheap table. My old Home Depot work benches work great!
I’m still jealous of those desks. I’ve been trying to find something similar here but no luck. I don’t really want to have to make one myself…
I bought the elgato boom arm about 6 months ago and it’s amazing. They must have looked at all these when designing it. No compromises.
Awesome to hear! Thanks for the more long term review!
Built in xlr cable is a no go I’m afraid. I expected more from the blue compass, well now I know I made the right choice getting the psa1.
You can actually mount a cable inside the rode arm. Though it is necessary to remove one of the connectors of the xlr cable to route it through the channel.
I’ve seen people do this and it looks very slick 👍
I love the look of blue, I have the cheap boom arm right now that came free with my SM7B purchase, so now I know which one to pick when I upgrade
Glad it helped! The Blue is very clean looking.
Cable can be routed internally through the Rode PSA1 too! However you have to clip the plug off to slide it through, then re-solder. ugh
I've own the PSA1 since 2018 and it is now that I know I can adjust the tension. Christ I have to stop throwing away the instruction manual. Thanks.
Haha, I know I recently started actually reading more manuals. It really does help 🤷🏻♂️