Why do you like VisualPolitik? For what I've seen (mainly in the Spanish version), they aren't doing anything new or innovative. Their perspective is pretty much identical to that of the Economist and other mainstream western media outlets. Not that there is anything wrong with that per se, but, given that there are already a thousand others informing from the same POV... I just find them uninteresting. One of the reasons I love your show is precisely that, you add a novel perspective on global affairs.
I am from Siliguri, and honestly, this piece of land is of strategic interest like no other place. From my house, its 1 hour to Bangladesh, 30 minutes to Nepal, 1 hour to Bhutan, 3.5 hours to China, and the sole road entry to the entire north-east India.
Huh!! That's it?!! According to some ancient maps, milky way was a province of china and soon enough they will reclaim it......even if some external terrestrial beings come in the way
To those saying it is a Bhutan China dispute, Bhutan uses India for military protection in fact Bhutan doesn't have even a Chinese embassy, it deals with China through India. The Bhutanese govt asked India ro intervene and India did, straight and simple.
Ken Yes let's do that! Even if India loses badly it's China that has it worse because guess who will be seen as a bully! China! Bid farewell to OBOR and your economy after those sanctions!
AIIUserNamesInvalid they can because the Chinese government is not on good terms with southeast Asian countries whilst India is and India already has a naval base in Singapore and there Chinese navy is not allowed there because of the escalating tensions between those nations
AIIUserNamesInvalid is see what you mean but I’m not talking about singnapore I mean Malaysia,Philippines,Indonesia,Vietnam,and Taiwan and Japan all are on bad conditions with China and together they could match the Chinese navy along with the India navy And add to that that China doesn’t have an aircraft carrier whilst India has one and the Chinese navy is one of the most corrupt forces in the world and the Chinese military even said a statement that said China’s war efforts will be severely harmed by rampant corruption amongst officers and soldiers in navy, and army And the Chinese navy has a lot of bad equipment and the Indian navy has a lot of world class equipment fit for western nations And India’s bhramos missile which is the worlds fastest missile could intercept any Chinese naval force and not face a single threat by the conventional designs of Chinese ships And Singapore probably not even do anything I’m just saying that cuz China doesn’t have any naval bases in that area of the ocean while India could quickly mobilize the ships there And to top it all off there is massive Indian population in Singapore and most of Singapore’s Chinese are refugees or people who fled China in the 20th century and have not affiliation with China while most of the Indians are expats who have lots of family in India and have some sort of patriotism to India And India can choke the supplies because China has no reliable naval assets close to the Indian Ocean and the Indian navy is by a long shot the strongest force in the Indian Ocean and no every single island landmass and country in it and add to that the fact that India also has an advanced warning communication and radar network throughout the ocean that can warn them of Chinese whereabouts So there Indian navy could counter it and also many southeast Asian nations have been starting to look away from China especially because they wanna stay on America’s good side and China and America are in an economic war right now. So that ”Indian pipe dream" can easily be turned into a reality so shut up and get your facts right
AIIUserNamesInvalid dude you do realize that no one cares about proper punctuation in the TH-cam comments section And also most of China’s submarines are tiny Soviet era subs And also you do realize that I have nothing against the Chinese navy but they don’t have the power to extend into the Indian Ocean to defend their trade routes there. To top that most of those Southeast Asian countries would be willing to go to war if somebody were to back them up. And your also forgetting that in the event of a war the USA would probably support India and it’s allies that way it can get rid of its debt to China. And I’m not Indian, I American And the Indian navy is not weak like you say it can hold its own against all but a few navies. And your forgetting that China lacks a supersonic cruse missile effective and accurate enough to pose a threat. I respect China but they really are bullies and have turned a lot of countries against themselves. And also running China would mean these countries would become debt free to the Chinese and what happened in Sri Lanka wouldn’t be repeated again. You seem to be a very well educated person and I respect your argument with upmost honor. Thanks.
But it is amazing how fast China has replaced Pakistan as no.1 rival in the minds of the Indian public, especially the youth. Gone are the days of Hindi chini bhai bhai. Asia will be the center of the next cold war and geopolitical struggle between the 2 Asian giants, India and China.
It won't be the next cold war per se - the gap between China and India is too big compared to the US/USSR. And in the next generation it will only increase. Though India can align with other countries fearing China like Japan, South Korea etc.
+Austin Hughes and yet Trump asked us to impose strict ban on all exports to North Korea !! Also, US now sees more active roe of India in Afghanistan !! Do you think we r fool to step in war trap ? China is doing its propaganda and so r we
Austin Hughes After 300 years of western loots, we still reached here with a size of 1.3 BN ppl. Show me a western or eastern nation who has this sort of capacity. It's easier to point fingers when you are born with a silver spoon. Indians are not aggressive, else China and Pakistan shouldn't have existed the way they are.
razpor exactly man，what i just hope is please staying two more months in China my Indian friends，cause after that you wont even want to look at your bloody dirty country
蔡英文中華民國總統 I can send you some more videos.. It's okay you don't want to see I know. India's problem is its huge population and there are some cities which are highly developed and some cities are in the process of transformation... I do like Taiwan, it's awesome.
From UK? Lol you are joking right? The British colonization in India caused the country long term destruction. Britain hasn't pay the price for the destruction been done in India yet.
What will happen? Read the post by username Guest on this link:- defenceforumindia.com/forum/threads/tracking-indian-economy-till-general-elections-2019.79864/page-11#post-1359428 Its post number #203.
No solution, no end in sight -- that is an astute conclusion. The geo-political situation is more complex than mentioned. India opposes China's South China Sea claims, India has naval docking faclities in VietNam. India is selling arms to VietNam. India is pushing China our of Sri Lanka, and Myanmar. Kashmir has gotten more tense. Lastly, the reports assertion that China has a game winning military advantage is wrong. China's military is weaker than it likes to admit. China would have great difficulty supporting a protracted conflict in Bhutan or Nepal.
While it is true that China doesn't send its soldiers on UN peacekeeping missions, primarily out of a lack of confidence that the establishment has in its military, they have overcompensated with a rapid military modernization, the likes of which, I haven't yet seen.
@@ashutoshsharmash The Chinese soldiers in South Sudan on UN peacekeeping mission abandoned their post, weapons, and innocent Sudanese civilians at the mercy of Islamists in 2016. If not for Indian Peacekeepers a lot of men, children would have been killed and women would have been raped. The Chinese lost to Vietnam in 70s even after outnumbering them in terms of weapons and soldiers. China lacks battle experience which cannot be compensated with any amount of money.
It is funny how china acknowledges Calcutta convention but acts like it doesn't care about the decisions of the west when it comes to demarcing the Mc Mohan line. Basically it is doing what it does because it can
Dude...dude, I don't know who told you that we want independence. My state of Kerala, in the south has one of the highest percentage of people serving in the armed forces.
thetruereality China never accepts international law, case in point South China Sea, but they do pick and choose the ones they like and reject others. They are also one of the signatories of NPT but at the same they are also one of the leading proliferators but nobody bats an eyelid about it, funny how things work.
The answer to your question is in the word "unbiased", the really popular channels typically have a bias and most people involved in political discussions want something that confirms their biases.
A mixture of topic (geopolitics is large and VERY complicated so while most people should care few do), dynamic (hasn't landed a viral hit yet) and the lack of any obvious bias you mentioned. Reality is that while everybody politely agrees that reporting should be unbiased many have grown up and live with certain political realitis that don't necissarily hold up on a global scale. But many still (sometimes even without their direct knowledge) just want their political views afirmed and not actual accurate reporting that might force them to imagine different world views that might clash with their reality!
It's really sad and unfair in a way. But it's all good. All you have to do is share a few of these videos. If your friends watch it then good. If not, then you did what you could. Caspian Report is absolutely one of my main channels for news purely because he focuses on being as unbiased as possible.
The author seems under estimates China's seriousness about this situation. When Indian sent troops to territory that doesn't belong to India and not leaving after so many warnings, what do you think China will do? Also, a territory treaty is a territory treaty (Convention of Calcutta). You can't randomly find any excuse and say I think the treaty is imperfect thus we don't follow it. There are so many international border treaties in the world. I believe every single treaty is imperfect to some people's interest. If everyone doesn't like the treaty can deny it freely, then the world would descend into chaos. Why an author w/ the insights to so many geopolitical issues he claims, doesn't even understand the fundamental value of international treaties? And if Doklam was not Chinese territory at 1890, why do you think the British would sign the Convention of Calcutta treaty w/ Beijing and not some other governments? BTW, by the time the British finally came to the region, the government in Beijing (no matter Yuan, Ming or Qing dynasty) already been controlling the region in one way or another for a few hundred years. India simply makes a claim of Chinese hundred years old territory (in this case, India doesn't even have any excuse to make that claim so it just force some country never got involved in this matter and thus signs no treaty w/ China to make the claim) out of nowhere then send troops into the region saying it's become disputed territory because of the claim. This is pure invasion. And the Author is making the same tricks in his video which is also shameful. And the claim of the border between China and India is following the highest altitude is a lie. In Aksai Chin, India is pushing the border over the Karakoram Mountain range. Also, there is no treaty or any kind of agreement ever exists between China, British or India saying the only principle of the border line drawing is altitude. The history, ethical, geopolitical effects cannot be wiped out by a single sentence. Can you redraw the border between the US and Mexico or border between Russia and Ukraine saying I think the border should follow the highest altitude or following some river? That's insane. Is the author @CaspianReport really this naive about international borders, or he is trying to mislead the audience w/ his obviously biased narrative?
Although part of me is Chinese. I will always stay loyal to Malaysia. If I am loyal to Malaysia, I am against China in the South China Sea dispute and all the investment in Malaysia as they want to start a ethnic dispute which I will stop at all cost. That means I am with India.
India have its own principles, keep its principles, and its not greedy but just defend its border, and will not stop. We are calm but dont dare inviting the anger of the oldest civilization of the world,. it is obvious we dont step back an inch or even a centimeter. We keep our border. So step off China
@Antony your first world countries don't even have guts to stand against CCP regime but a third world country like India stands tall in doklam, galwan ,chola n rezang la lol
OrangeDude: Really? So when India decides to defend its borders and not let China invade our territory, and when Indian patriots defend their actions in virtual reality? Then you define that as hate? Just because we stand up for ourselves? Well we don't give a fuck and we're never going to stop supporting our soldiers and our right to sovereignty! We don't try and bully the smaller "S.E.A" nations like China does by stealing their resources and then pumping their Chinese money into their economy! China won't be able to fuck with other people for very much longer.
Vinny Sharma Hate is a negative emotion/attitude. You can justify it with patriotism which is an ideology and a reason for hate, but hate is still hate. Same thing can be said about China, too.
wisdomleader2017: Thank you brother, I understand what you're saying. I will listen. Sorry brother, I'm not usually such a fiery Micrhi but I was just feeling passionate. Because you advised me with such patience and respect? and because you didn't use any profanity against me? I will happily listen to whatever you have to say.
Vinny Sharma You're welcome. The world would be a better place if we all can look at and think about things from different people's perspectives and stay rational.
Finally I can understand more of the conflict, thank you CR!!!! 3rd time editing. Seriously. I can't get enough of your content. I keep notes on the videos and keep track of events and base them off the videos. Keeping a timeline of it all. Thank you for everything you do! Keep it up!
India had been trying to demarcate the border with Aggressive and Oppressive Regime, CCP, but it actually favours CCP'S Agenda of border is left undemarcated because it has been increasing its claims onto Indian and Bhutanese territory.
you are really an unlucky TH-camr... you deserve far more subscribers.and yeah from a long time I'm a subscriber of both Caspanreport, visual Politik en as well as foreign chronicles...
Jigar Thakkar bro read the line first he was saying India will avenge 1962 ie badla most probably he is Indian the guy you just abused. You should apologise
China has border conflicts with 35 countries !!! It is more than the number of countries it shares its border with. Problem is that China tries to muscle it neighbour since it is most strong but it did not expect India to challenge its authority by entering into Bhutan and deploying military to stop constructing a road in Dokhlam.
choking silguri point would only make NE inaccessible by road from rest of india , but india has potent airforce which can mobilize troops as soon as they get a threat of invasion . Moreover , NE is militarized enough to defend itself for atleast a month.
Honestly, This is too complex for me to even have an opinion. I can't even tell who's to blame. but there's way too much going on in the world right now for these senseless conflicts.
HyacinthMacaw 1962 war had nothing to do with doklam plateau,skkim was not even a part of india during that period. You clearly lack basic historical knowledge.
I don't think anyone is "correct". Just large countries fighting over a mountain to geographically checkmate each other's ambitions. I've heard of other cases where countries fight over tiny pieces of land based of 2 hundred year old poorly written treaties.
The stand-off is actually because china breached the status-quo and started building a road on the plateau . A disputed piece of land overnight became a 'sovereign territory of china'. A simple solution would be for both countries to back-off and return to status-quo ,before the dispute blows out of proportion. But then again its quite impossible considering the fact that china and to some extent india are currently running high on nationalism.
ninmachine109 Even without watching the video to can tell it's China, China has a history of claiming/conquering everything claimable/conquerable : 1. Mongolia 2. Manchuria 3.Inner Mongolia 4.Xinjiang 5.Tibet 6.Hong Kong 7. Macau 8. Taiwan 9. 90% of South China sea 10. They have squabbles with Bhutan (edited), yes......with TINY Bhutan (edited) Why do they make these claim....."historical reasons"... China is a very aggressive nation. I'm confident that if they were the most powerful nation on earth they would be (edited) way worse than USA....actually never mind they won't, they won't have any allies, they'll just turn out like Nazi Germany. DID YOU KNOW? China believes they are at the centre of the world? DID YOU KNOW? China believes China deserves to be #1?
xiaotian Yang: FAMILY DON'T STOP OTHER FAMILY MEMBERS FROM GETTING A POSITION ON THE "N.S.G" AND A PERMANENT SEAT ON THE "G.S.C" FAMILY ALSO DONT SUPPORT AND ENDORSE STATE SPONSORED TERRORISM BETWEEN ITS OTHER BROTHERS!!!!!
Your reports are very well researched and studied. Thank you for doing this excellent work. I hope VisualPolitik will also put some more efforts to study facts like yours.
Winning this possible war, whatever the size of it, hugely beneficial to India. First, it shows the world that China is not super power as many politicians thought and bowing to China. Second, all these South-Asian countries welcome an India which just showed its strength. Third, as a result, India will take a huge step to become a new world power, now it is just a regional power. A negative consequence would be Pakistan, which will move even closer to China, but this is what is happening already. To sum up, India got a great chance.
India is not Japan or Vietnam Chinese must know that we are religious father of yours ji ja juu sui sa Wang haaa Chinese are as funny as their language haa
It seems like India should have annexed the Rangpur division of Bangladesh in 1971 as a thanks for fighting their liberation war for them, now India would have a wider land corridor to NE India and would not have such a sensitive geographical chokepoint.
I LIKE CASPIAN REPORT AND NEVER MISS A SINGLE VIDEO YOU UPLOAD..! it gives me a very UNBIASED understanding of GEOPOLITICS of the world..!! Your work is GREAT...!!
Sir you have explanation for dokhlam issue which, as per Bhutan government, is Bhutanese area and not property of china or british colony. however, I am interested in issues regarding south china seas and Chinese illegal occupation, illegal Tibet occupation, illegal occupying land area of india, and named it as aksai chin, and Chinese illegal claims related to land areas of other neighbouring and distant countries, other water areas etc. will you please give details of Chinese expansionist policies.
Even Chinese people who know the outside world and read outside sources (not the Big Brother-esque style Chinese sources) know very well that this is a clearly Chinese aggression. For more information read : www.quora.com/What-is-happening-at-China-India-border/answer/Wenshao-Zhang-1 Good luck.
The 50c army doesn't work outside of China you morons. They only do propaganda within China on Chinese websites in Chinese. This is confirmed by a Harvard report. Fun fact - the whole 50cent per post thing is fake. I hate China as well but you guys must be morons to believe propaganda shit like China Uncensored. gking.harvard.edu/files/gking/files/50c.pdf
How about we STOP Chinese and Indian users from commenting and ask objective third parties how they view the situation? Like, how about we ask people from Germany or Russia or Turkey which side is right?
Apparently the internet decided it hates China sines the last time I blinked. I don't remember anti Chinese comments being a big thing before (including one videos about China). I personally side with India on this issue, but seriously anti-Chinese sentiment is pointless.
Here is the crux of the situation. China in an effort to steal land from a small country are quoting a piece of inaccurate geographical treaty. The treaty which itself was designed by the English who have mapped borders and caused stife all over the world. Classic Brits. But the Chinese never expected India to actually defend Bhutan, because well, the Chinese have in the past quoted inaccurate non-facts to bully other smaller nations and steal their land and India backed by pussy ass regimes have not always responded. But no, not this time, India was direct and its government under more decisive leaders and more belief in its military decided to intervene and the Chinese are flabbergasted coz now they are stuck between a rock and a hard place, they expected an easy land grab and now are facing an experienced and a battle hardened military who have defeated them twice while CCP leadership events in China are a coming and Xi Jinping and his cronies have to show something out of this bullying tactic. But unfortunately for the Chinese, the Indian army are not even remotely similar to escaping unarmed Tibetans who can be shot easily by untrained chinese. Their unwilling conscripted chinese soldiers who serve for hardly a few years and are probably a result of the Chinese 'One Child Policy' know that if they die, their whole bloodline ends on that very spot. They do not want to even participate in a skirmish with a volunteer Indian army where soldiers serve for decades on end and have the experience of recent mountain warfares and in Doklam have the advantage of terrain.
There is no way any nation can cater Chinese endless territorial demands and claims .any one who knows the chinese claim of entire south china sea by a silly 9 dash line would know that .here Bhutan is a very small country with just half a million population with no army at all .they dont even have the means to maintain embassy in foreign countries .only option for them is take help from India or else become the next Tibet
Both countries should stop fighting. People stop being so racist. This is over a road and territory in the mountains. Everyone should be ashamed of themselves. Solution would be for the Chinese to move the road further north and blast a hole through the mountains from the north side. Indian troops then can withdrawal. Extreme Nationalism from India and China is ridiculous. When I was in college. I met a Chinese and Indian guy. They were both ultra nationalistic as fuck. Indian guy wanted Pakistan to be with India. Chinese guy wanted Tibet and Taiwan to be with China. Yea, being a Chinese descendant from Singapore, these disputes are so silly. Everyone is fighting in South China Sea and fighting over silly mountain borders. Human greed is ugly.
wktjan4286 yaaa man. China should not built the road there bcoz it's the main way to connect with the north east part of India. And building road is initial part of capturing parts of any country for China.
No the road goes to Bhutan not India. Haven't you read the reports? Indians trespassed into Chinese territory to stop road construction into Bhutan. Idnians don't want to see their sphere of influence of Bhutan falling under Chinese economic domination. They don't want Nepal and Bhutan falling under Beijing's sphere of influence. The whole thing is a political game.
No. The road goes towards Bhutan, not towards India. Indians have concerns that the road is too close to them. They apparently do not like strong countries building roads close to their border because they are afraid of invasion.
india see bhutan as "brothers" so as big brother at least, they do not want to see china's influence in bhutan. further than that, they might want make bhutan a second sikkim. it is politics people are talking about here. it is clear indian do not care about bhutan people. after all, they just want the land, there are tooo many indians.
I'm so tired of nations claiming land... Land is not yours to take... there was a time when Chinese people understood this, which is why Chinese property law differs from Western property laws... But they forgot... It's sad...
The fact is that +CaspianReport will pin my comment for no reason at all, and will make a video of the greatest superpower in the history of this planet, Finland.
Nice unbiased video! A few more points... 1. Although Chinese military is stronger, Indian military is currently on higher ground. A skirmish will cause heavy loss on Chinese side, even though they are more likely to win. 2. Winter would start soon and then it becomes very difficult to fight in Himalayas. So both sides are trying best to force other to back off before snowfall begins.
Hey caspian report, you always show the map of china as Including disputed territories such as Taiwan. Whereas you show the map of india without POK and AKSAI CHIN. Do you mind explaining why that is ?
India is not a saint here.. It has disputes with all its neighbours.. India supported Tamil Insurgency in Sirlanka to make the small country its vassel state while Sirlanka asked Pakistan to help them.. India recognized the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan while whole world opposed it, Soviets were killing anything that moves or anything that goes against them in Afghanistan. Indian was a Soviet Union ally in South Asia while USA, China and Pakistan were against them... India has imposed a blockade on Nepal which has caused a big food crisis in the poor country which is landlocked... There are 5 different seperated insurgencies in India like Kashmir, Nagaland, Assam and Khalistan in which they have killed millions of people... In 1971 India imposed a blockade on East Pakistan which is present day Bangladesh which caused a massive famine and the people turned refugees went to Indian border for help, India help them but also armed and directed them to go back and fight for a seperate state, this caused a civil war in East Pakistan(bangladesh).... INDIA'S ROLE IS SAME LIKE THAT OF RUSSIA AND CHINA WHO ARE AGGRESSORS!!!
angel Talib Well if India blocked access and caused famine how the Bengalis came to India. I appreciate your effort to hide the incompetency of Zulfikar Ali Bhuto and Yahya Khan If both of them allowed Sheik Mujibur Rehman form the Government there wouldn't be Bangladesh today so Don't read history in Your country, History lessons in Pakistan is just a lies to support the Army to show India as Enemy, As for as Insurgency Kashmir is the only problem but that too caused by the Pakistani involvement of your Incompetent ISI and Moronic army
Acharya Chanakya Neeti would be so fucking disappointed that pretty much ALL the work he did to unite India and create AKHAND BHARAT was pretty much all in vain as these bastards didn't respect his honour and all that he built during his tenure as Maurya's minister. Fucking disrespectful corrupted turncoat sons-of-bitches! Happy NOW? We've lost AKAND BHARAT to these passive overly loving yet corrupted fucking CUNTS!!! Who would sell their own grandmother down the river to our enemies and also fuck their own people over to appease the foreigner!!! FUCK YOU!!!
India occupies the territory of China. The first reason was to protect Bhutan's territory, but later Bhutan claimed the territory belonged to China. Now India is not going to pull out because it would be humiliating and not daring to go to war, knowing that it would be a terrible thing to die
if only this could be mainstream. the fact that this channel is so unbiased and sticks to the facts and logical opinions is amazing, seeing all other YT channel is buried under BS. including VP mentioned in the end. I hope this channel do not change because of donor's bias.
I highly recommend subscribing to VisualPolitik for additional content on geopolitical matters:
th-cam.com/channels/T3v6vL2H5HK4loLMc8pmCw.html
Why do you like VisualPolitik? For what I've seen (mainly in the Spanish version), they aren't doing anything new or innovative. Their perspective is pretty much identical to that of the Economist and other mainstream western media outlets. Not that there is anything wrong with that per se, but, given that there are already a thousand others informing from the same POV... I just find them uninteresting. One of the reasons I love your show is precisely that, you add a novel perspective on global affairs.
I find VisualPolitik kinda biased
*Visualpolitik is clearly running CIA propaganda narrative*
VisualPolitik is absolutely atrocious for geopolitics. They are just regurgitating MSM.
Why tho? It comes off as stale to me
Chinese army : we can simply
take over bhutan..
its too small😂
Bhutanese : hold INDIAN ARMY
I am from Siliguri, and honestly, this piece of land is of strategic interest like no other place. From my house, its 1 hour to Bangladesh, 30 minutes to Nepal, 1 hour to Bhutan, 3.5 hours to China, and the sole road entry to the entire north-east India.
so, bro u can do world tour in just one day 😂😂
Hehe amio,, loo
@@sawankumararun9989 😂😂😂
It's weird how Chinese claim this region. According to them you, my Uncle everyone there is Chinese XD
@A Mukherjee Bengalis unfortunately don't join the army in enough amount to influence the structure.
There is a 200 year old Chinese dry cleaning shop in southern California. USA is now officially Chinese territory.
really ?? older than canada...lol
Tom Righfully so, the Chinese in US has been oppressed for so long. They arrived in 1800. Just 100 years after the british
Huh!! That's it?!! According to some ancient maps, milky way was a province of china and soon enough they will reclaim it......even if some external terrestrial beings come in the way
@@crystalball020 Others arrived thousands of years before either of them.
😂 😄😄😄😄😄😄
To those saying it is a Bhutan China dispute, Bhutan uses India for military protection in fact Bhutan doesn't have even a Chinese embassy, it deals with China through India. The Bhutanese govt asked India ro intervene and India did, straight and simple.
*Then go have the war - real war not some children youtube war.*
Ken Yes let's do that! Even if India loses badly it's China that has it worse because guess who will be seen as a bully! China! Bid farewell to OBOR and your economy after those sanctions!
Ken Cool down now. Go and collect your 50 cents.
Oh! Another 50 cent troll. Must be my lucky day.
Prasanth Valsan lol, what?
Strait of Malacca is India advantage over China. 85% of China trade economic route. India can choke it
Namo string of pearl.
Not after CPEC though😞
AIIUserNamesInvalid they can because the Chinese government is not on good terms with southeast Asian countries whilst India is and India already has a naval base in Singapore and there Chinese navy is not allowed there because of the escalating tensions between those nations
AIIUserNamesInvalid is see what you mean but I’m not talking about singnapore I mean Malaysia,Philippines,Indonesia,Vietnam,and Taiwan and Japan all are on bad conditions with China and together they could match the Chinese navy along with the India navy
And add to that that China doesn’t have an aircraft carrier whilst India has one and the Chinese navy is one of the most corrupt forces in the world and the Chinese military even said a statement that said China’s war efforts will be severely harmed by rampant corruption amongst officers and soldiers in navy, and army
And the Chinese navy has a lot of bad equipment and the Indian navy has a lot of world class equipment fit for western nations
And India’s bhramos missile which is the worlds fastest missile could intercept any Chinese naval force and not face a single threat by the conventional designs of Chinese ships
And Singapore probably not even do anything I’m just saying that cuz China doesn’t have any naval bases in that area of the ocean while India could quickly mobilize the ships there
And to top it all off there is massive Indian population in Singapore and most of Singapore’s Chinese are refugees or people who fled China in the 20th century and have not affiliation with China while most of the Indians are expats who have lots of family in India and have some sort of patriotism to India
And India can choke the supplies because China has no reliable naval assets close to the Indian Ocean and the Indian navy is by a long shot the strongest force in the Indian Ocean and no every single island landmass and country in it and add to that the fact that India also has an advanced warning communication and radar network throughout the ocean that can warn them of Chinese whereabouts
So there Indian navy could counter it and also many southeast Asian nations have been starting to look away from China especially because they wanna stay on America’s good side and China and America are in an economic war right now.
So that ”Indian pipe dream" can easily be turned into a reality so shut up and get your facts right
AIIUserNamesInvalid dude you do realize that no one cares about proper punctuation in the TH-cam comments section
And also most of China’s submarines are tiny Soviet era subs
And also you do realize that I have nothing against the Chinese navy but they don’t have the power to extend into the Indian Ocean to defend their trade routes there.
To top that most of those Southeast Asian countries would be willing to go to war if somebody were to back them up.
And your also forgetting that in the event of a war the USA would probably support India and it’s allies that way it can get rid of its debt to China.
And I’m not Indian, I American
And the Indian navy is not weak like you say it can hold its own against all but a few navies.
And your forgetting that China lacks a supersonic cruse missile effective and accurate enough to pose a threat.
I respect China but they really are bullies and have turned a lot of countries against themselves. And also running China would mean these countries would become debt free to the Chinese and what happened in Sri Lanka wouldn’t be repeated again.
You seem to be a very well educated person and I respect your argument with upmost honor.
Thanks.
But it is amazing how fast China has replaced Pakistan as no.1 rival in the minds of the Indian public, especially the youth. Gone are the days of Hindi chini bhai bhai. Asia will be the center of the next cold war and geopolitical struggle between the 2 Asian giants, India and China.
It won't be the next cold war per se - the gap between China and India is too big compared to the US/USSR. And in the next generation it will only increase. Though India can align with other countries fearing China like Japan, South Korea etc.
India is a joke compared to China. This century is about US and China. India has a chance in the 22nd century.
+Austin Hughes and yet Trump asked us to impose strict ban on all exports to North Korea !! Also, US now sees more active roe of India in Afghanistan !!
Do you think we r fool to step in war trap ? China is doing its propaganda and so r we
Austin Hughes After 300 years of western loots, we still reached here with a size of 1.3 BN ppl. Show me a western or eastern nation who has this sort of capacity. It's easier to point fingers when you are born with a silver spoon. Indians are not aggressive, else China and Pakistan shouldn't have existed the way they are.
Gazoline Gaz My my, someone is butthurt that a country is not rolling over to China
China: I am going to count from 1..10 and you need to withdraw and surrender
India: If I don't?
China: I am warning you and I am going to count again
razpor exactly man，what i just hope is please staying two more months in China my Indian friends，cause after that you wont even want to look at your bloody dirty country
蔡英文中華民國總統 how come you are using TH-cam in your clean country, where every source of information againt the regime is wiped clean.
蔡英文中華民國總統 please visit out country. It is very clean now a days. I promise you will like it so much you wont want to go back home.
蔡英文中華民國總統 I can send you some more videos..
It's okay you don't want to see I know.
India's problem is its huge population and there are some cities which are highly developed and some cities are in the process of transformation...
I do like Taiwan, it's awesome.
*pakistan hiding behind china waiting to throw a punch.
Full support toward India from the UK, US and i'd say the whole of Nato.
Its no longer UK, it's Islamic Republic of UK. Greetings from India as well.
lol
support from japan too we hate china !
From UK? Lol you are joking right? The British colonization in India caused the country long term destruction. Britain hasn't pay the price for the destruction been done in India yet.
Death to China
"Our words are backed with nuclear weapons" - M.Gandhi
"Our words are not backed by even common sense" -Rahul Gandhi
Hope that f***er is not elected as Prime minister in 2019. Bloody traitor.
What will happen?
Read the post by username Guest on this link:-
defenceforumindia.com/forum/threads/tracking-indian-economy-till-general-elections-2019.79864/page-11#post-1359428
Its post number #203.
@X-Ray Crystallography google Gandhi civ 5 memes
Gandhi didn't say that
Nuclear Gandhi**
Don't read any comments, they are pure armchair general nonsense.
lol
rook to e8
buffydaslaya: Yeah, including your one too...
These types of videos are arm chair generals
I want a video about my arm chair, so that the comments from armchair generals will be comments about a specific armchair.
No solution, no end in sight -- that is an astute conclusion.
The geo-political situation is more complex than mentioned. India opposes China's South China Sea claims, India has naval docking faclities in VietNam. India is selling arms to VietNam. India is pushing China our of Sri Lanka, and Myanmar. Kashmir has gotten more tense.
Lastly, the reports assertion that China has a game winning military advantage is wrong. China's military is weaker than it likes to admit. China would have great difficulty supporting a protracted conflict in Bhutan or Nepal.
While it is true that China doesn't send its soldiers on UN peacekeeping missions, primarily out of a lack of confidence that the establishment has in its military, they have overcompensated with a rapid military modernization, the likes of which, I haven't yet seen.
Well, China didn't belong in Sri Lanka or Myanmar in the first place
@@ashutoshsharmash The Chinese soldiers in South Sudan on UN peacekeeping mission abandoned their post, weapons, and innocent Sudanese civilians at the mercy of Islamists in 2016. If not for Indian Peacekeepers a lot of men, children would have been killed and women would have been raped. The Chinese lost to Vietnam in 70s even after outnumbering them in terms of weapons and soldiers. China lacks battle experience which cannot be compensated with any amount of money.
It is funny how china acknowledges Calcutta convention but acts like it doesn't care about the decisions of the west when it comes to demarcing the Mc Mohan line. Basically it is doing what it does because it can
thetruereality China is (more or less) sensitive of all western influences since fall of Qing.
You are trying to equate 2 completely different things, pretending that they are the same. They are not.
One is a treaty between China and the UK, the other is just a line drawn by the UK without the concent of anyone. They're not the same.
Dude...dude, I don't know who told you that we want independence. My state of Kerala, in the south has one of the highest percentage of people serving in the armed forces.
thetruereality China never accepts international law, case in point South China Sea, but they do pick and choose the ones they like and reject others. They are also one of the signatories of NPT but at the same they are also one of the leading proliferators but nobody bats an eyelid about it, funny how things work.
I don't understand the reason you have low subscriber number.
You make an excellent content with accurate and unbiased information.
The Under Network - Main JewTube?
It's more like SJWTube.
The answer to your question is in the word "unbiased", the really popular channels typically have a bias and most people involved in political discussions want something that confirms their biases.
A mixture of topic (geopolitics is large and VERY complicated so while most people should care few do), dynamic (hasn't landed a viral hit yet) and the lack of any obvious bias you mentioned. Reality is that while everybody politely agrees that reporting should be unbiased many have grown up and live with certain political realitis that don't necissarily hold up on a global scale. But many still (sometimes even without their direct knowledge) just want their political views afirmed and not actual accurate reporting that might force them to imagine different world views that might clash with their reality!
It's really sad and unfair in a way. But it's all good. All you have to do is share a few of these videos. If your friends watch it then good. If not, then you did what you could.
Caspian Report is absolutely one of my main channels for news purely because he focuses on being as unbiased as possible.
The author seems under estimates China's seriousness about this situation. When Indian sent troops to territory that doesn't belong to India and not leaving after so many warnings, what do you think China will do? Also, a territory treaty is a territory treaty (Convention of Calcutta). You can't randomly find any excuse and say I think the treaty is imperfect thus we don't follow it. There are so many international border treaties in the world. I believe every single treaty is imperfect to some people's interest. If everyone doesn't like the treaty can deny it freely, then the world would descend into chaos. Why an author w/ the insights to so many geopolitical issues he claims, doesn't even understand the fundamental value of international treaties?
And if Doklam was not Chinese territory at 1890, why do you think the British would sign the Convention of Calcutta treaty w/ Beijing and not some other governments? BTW, by the time the British finally came to the region, the government in Beijing (no matter Yuan, Ming or Qing dynasty) already been controlling the region in one way or another for a few hundred years. India simply makes a claim of Chinese hundred years old territory (in this case, India doesn't even have any excuse to make that claim so it just force some country never got involved in this matter and thus signs no treaty w/ China to make the claim) out of nowhere then send troops into the region saying it's become disputed territory because of the claim. This is pure invasion. And the Author is making the same tricks in his video which is also shameful.
And the claim of the border between China and India is following the highest altitude is a lie. In Aksai Chin, India is pushing the border over the Karakoram Mountain range. Also, there is no treaty or any kind of agreement ever exists between China, British or India saying the only principle of the border line drawing is altitude. The history, ethical, geopolitical effects cannot be wiped out by a single sentence. Can you redraw the border between the US and Mexico or border between Russia and Ukraine saying I think the border should follow the highest altitude or following some river? That's insane. Is the author @CaspianReport really this naive about international borders, or he is trying to mislead the audience w/ his obviously biased narrative?
Although part of me is Chinese. I will always stay loyal to Malaysia. If I am loyal to Malaysia, I am against China in the South China Sea dispute and all the investment in Malaysia as they want to start a ethnic dispute which I will stop at all cost. That means I am with India.
India have its own principles, keep its principles, and its not greedy but just defend its border, and will not stop. We are calm but dont dare inviting the anger of the oldest civilization of the world,. it is obvious we dont step back an inch or even a centimeter. We keep our border. So step off China
@Antony do not irritate them
@Antony your first world countries don't even have guts to stand against CCP regime but a third world country like India stands tall in doklam, galwan ,chola n rezang la lol
That's why they have occupied 65 thousand hectares land of nepal which is twice the size of maldives.
I support India!
0:41 love you Indo Tibetan Border Police.
Me and my friends a
In public after 12
Himalaya is very beautiful!!!
Yes sir it is :)
India will tolerate Pakistan but it can not and will not ignore china. Too bigger risk as both have nukes
Doesn't pakistan nukes too?
But Pakistan has nukes too...
The comment section is what you what expect it to be. People hating each other.
yes, sadly so
OrangeDude: Really? So when India decides to defend its borders and not let China invade our territory, and when Indian patriots defend their actions in virtual reality? Then you define that as hate? Just because we stand up for ourselves? Well we don't give a fuck and we're never going to stop supporting our soldiers and our right to sovereignty! We don't try and bully the smaller "S.E.A" nations like China does by stealing their resources and then pumping their Chinese money into their economy! China won't be able to fuck with other people for very much longer.
Vinny Sharma
Hate is a negative emotion/attitude. You can justify it with patriotism which is an ideology and a reason for hate, but hate is still hate. Same thing can be said about China, too.
wisdomleader2017: Thank you brother, I understand what you're saying. I will listen. Sorry brother, I'm not usually such a fiery Micrhi but I was just feeling passionate. Because you advised me with such patience and respect? and because you didn't use any profanity against me? I will happily listen to whatever you have to say.
Vinny Sharma
You're welcome. The world would be a better place if we all can look at and think about things from different people's perspectives and stay rational.
A reason for Bhutan having no ties and treaty is Bhutan's discontent for Chinese annexation of Tibet. To which Bhutan is cultural attached.
Finally I can understand more of the conflict, thank you CR!!!!
3rd time editing. Seriously. I can't get enough of your content. I keep notes on the videos and keep track of events and base them off the videos. Keeping a timeline of it all.
Thank you for everything you do! Keep it up!
"Our words are backed with nuclear weapons !"- M.Gandhi
India doesnt have Nuclear weapons when Great Gandhi was Alive
@@DARKKNIGHT-ur7uz maybe its a civ quote?
@@DARKKNIGHT-ur7uz it's a Civ 5 quote
2020 and the situation is taking shape of your analysis Great Shirvan.
Stop the road building take soldiers back from both sides. Diplomacy.
The jews won´t allow it. Catch up.
Rafael Lastra com Jews are responsible for everything?
Hey
The anti-semites are partly right, the weapons companies are friendly with the Likudi Greater Israel Project guys
mayank sharma
Diplomacy?Dunno what that supposed to mean.You mean war?
India had been trying to demarcate the border with Aggressive and Oppressive Regime, CCP, but it actually favours CCP'S Agenda of border is left undemarcated because it has been increasing its claims onto Indian and Bhutanese territory.
you are really an unlucky TH-camr... you deserve far more subscribers.and yeah from a long time I'm a subscriber of both Caspanreport, visual Politik en as well as foreign chronicles...
TH-cam doesn't support educational channels. They only support clickbait.
The UN security council needs to make india a permanet member to counter balance china
Nope, USA& BRITS are enough
Good video. Great info. This video deserves 10 times the views
Thanks for the great report Shirvan!
I'll be sure to check out VisualPolitik
Use correct map of India in the future.
India will avenge 1962 inshallah
Jigar Thakkar bro read the line first he was saying India will avenge 1962 ie badla most probably he is Indian the guy you just abused. You should apologise
If a war breaks out , the only ones to suffer will be the normal working class ppl.
+Jigar Thakkar...dude, he is an indian. read properly before commenting.
Inshasatan, it will.
tod bob we did in 67 look it up
Well India won, Chinese lost at Doklam!
Shirwan your work is amazing. Thank you for being one of the best news channels on TH-cam.
In Sri Lanka there are many chinese fast food shops.
Its chinese territory now 🙂😂
China has border conflicts with 35 countries !!! It is more than the number of countries it shares its border with. Problem is that China tries to muscle it neighbour since it is most strong but it did not expect India to challenge its authority by entering into Bhutan and deploying military to stop constructing a road in Dokhlam.
choking silguri point would only make NE inaccessible by road from rest of india , but india has potent airforce which can mobilize troops as soon as they get a threat of invasion . Moreover , NE is militarized enough to defend itself for atleast a month.
Most accurate coverage on this issue, thanks for sharing
This mapworks is incredible. Thanks so much
Honestly, This is too complex for me to even have an opinion. I can't even tell who's to blame. but there's way too much going on in the world right now for these senseless conflicts.
HyacinthMacaw 1962 war had nothing to do with doklam plateau,skkim was not even a part of india during that period. You clearly lack basic historical knowledge.
I'm taking notes over here lol. Thanks for the history lesson
I don't think anyone is "correct". Just large countries fighting over a mountain to geographically checkmate each other's ambitions. I've heard of other cases where countries fight over tiny pieces of land based of 2 hundred year old poorly written treaties.
The stand-off is actually because china breached the status-quo and started building a road on the plateau . A disputed piece of land overnight became a 'sovereign territory of china'. A simple solution would be for both countries to back-off and return to status-quo ,before the dispute blows out of proportion. But then again its quite impossible considering the fact that china and to some extent india are currently running high on nationalism.
ninmachine109 Even without watching the video to can tell it's China, China has a history of claiming/conquering everything claimable/conquerable :
1. Mongolia
2. Manchuria
3.Inner Mongolia
4.Xinjiang
5.Tibet
6.Hong Kong
7. Macau
8. Taiwan
9. 90% of South China sea
10. They have squabbles with Bhutan (edited), yes......with TINY Bhutan (edited)
Why do they make these claim....."historical reasons"... China is a very aggressive nation. I'm confident that if they were the most powerful nation on earth they would be (edited) way worse than USA....actually never mind they won't, they won't have any allies, they'll just turn out like Nazi Germany.
DID YOU KNOW? China believes they are at the centre of the world?
DID YOU KNOW? China believes China deserves to be #1?
看完了，我觉得印度和中国不应该打仗，都没好处。不如发展经济造福民众。both india and china can not fight each other,we are family！
xiaotian Yang yeah I mean personally respect chinese people and have no issues but the chinese government is fucking around
xiaotian Yang: FAMILY DON'T STOP OTHER FAMILY MEMBERS FROM GETTING A POSITION ON THE "N.S.G" AND A PERMANENT SEAT ON THE "G.S.C" FAMILY ALSO DONT SUPPORT AND ENDORSE STATE SPONSORED TERRORISM BETWEEN ITS OTHER BROTHERS!!!!!
xiaotian Yang we dont think so
Its in best interest of both our countries 🍻
This guy does amazing research. Hats off!!
We want peace and friendship between India and China! 🇮🇳❤🇨🇳
Your reports are very well researched and studied. Thank you for doing this excellent work.
I hope VisualPolitik will also put some more efforts to study facts like yours.
Nice storytelling. Thank you!
Winning this possible war, whatever the size of it, hugely beneficial to India. First, it shows the world that China is not super power as many politicians thought and bowing to China. Second, all these South-Asian countries welcome an India which just showed its strength. Third, as a result, India will take a huge step to become a new world power, now it is just a regional power. A negative consequence would be Pakistan, which will move even closer to China, but this is what is happening already. To sum up, India got a great chance.
India is not Japan or Vietnam
Chinese must know that we are religious father of yours
ji ja juu sui sa Wang
haaa Chinese are as funny as their language haa
Omprakash kennedy Dude We have military that's bigger then uk and France combined, u should research first before commenting about japan
India has so many internal conflict...it will collapse itself.
Nameless9635 the communist Chinese will collapse because of their internal conflicts and external conflicts with other 😂
@@hikayuinoue5366 you had biggest military since ancient times but you got your ass kicked badly by the Japanese a small island nation
It seems like India should have annexed the Rangpur division of Bangladesh in 1971 as a thanks for fighting their liberation war for them, now India would have a wider land corridor to NE India and would not have such a sensitive geographical chokepoint.
One dislike for India's wrong map.
Been waiting for this! Can't find an unbiased source on YT on this issue at all.
It's so stupid of China asking to withdraw Indian troops when Indian troops are actually in Bhutan territory under Bhutan's request.
Love your shoutout to visual politik. I listen to it everyday when commuting to work.
I LIKE CASPIAN REPORT AND NEVER MISS A SINGLE VIDEO YOU UPLOAD..! it gives me a very UNBIASED understanding of GEOPOLITICS of the world..!! Your work is GREAT...!!
I follow both Visualpolitik and CaspianReport, huge fan!
fuck I wish china didn't ban youtube, this comment section would be world war 3. xD
subscribed right away....................... how did i miss this channel
extremely unbiased video..
appreciated..!!
I love it when two of my favorite channels turn out to be friends
I like how the CCP cherry picks the British era treaties; either have a firm stance on all (Arunachal Pradesh) or on none.
Sir you have explanation for dokhlam issue which, as per Bhutan government, is Bhutanese area and not property of china or british colony. however, I am interested in issues regarding south china seas and Chinese illegal occupation, illegal Tibet occupation, illegal occupying land area of india, and named it as aksai chin, and Chinese illegal claims related to land areas of other neighbouring and distant countries, other water areas etc. will you please give details of Chinese expansionist policies.
debasish chatterjee it is interested to everybody how India occupied other small neighbors
Yay thanks for the video on doklam
Ah, using the Indian spelling. Courageous.
Well, honestly, the region is known by numerous names but ‘Doklam’ is the most used. It would only be confusing to juggle with the names.
I was waiting for this video shirvan...... yes the region is known by other names also but that's not the point. Right?
@Luke He will use whatever the fcuk spelling he wants. You don't like it?? Make your own channel.
CaspianReport what about the map you used for the Pak India border? It shows the disputed territory of Kashmir as Indian same as the Indian maps.
Hamza Saleemi butthurt?
Very thorough video!! Props, always looking forward to your vids!
Huh. Bro, the video in starting is many years old, it's not of doklam.
What an amazingly informative video.Thank you Caspian report and keep it up!RESPECT!
Even Chinese people who know the outside world and read outside sources (not the Big Brother-esque style Chinese sources) know very well that this is a clearly Chinese aggression.
For more information read :
www.quora.com/What-is-happening-at-China-India-border/answer/Wenshao-Zhang-1
Good luck.
*Anyone can write in Quora. Looks like CIA is not paying top dollar for trolling.:)*
Also Ken, no one can educate ignorant fool like yourself.
Yes. They have a Wikipedia entry to their credit. ;-)
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party
Thanks. I'll check.
The 50c army doesn't work outside of China you morons. They only do propaganda within China on Chinese websites in Chinese. This is confirmed by a Harvard report. Fun fact -
the whole 50cent per post thing is fake. I hate China as well but you guys must be morons to believe propaganda shit like China Uncensored. gking.harvard.edu/files/gking/files/50c.pdf
Waited for this video
Fragments of Europeanism into Asian nations contributed one undesirable event that'll occur eventually.
Brilliant explanation balanced and surprisingly accurate.keeo up the excellent work. Respects from India.
India had never witnessed this tough stand before
Its because of PM modi only
Africa and china has three alphabets in similar.. now China claim Africa as it's territory
Free Tibet
Free Thailand
Leave Bhutan alone
Sandeep ...India leave bhutan alone...
What about Taiwan?😕
Taiwanese want freedom from fking Chinese
How about we STOP Chinese and Indian users from commenting and ask objective third parties how they view the situation? Like, how about we ask people from Germany or Russia or Turkey which side is right?
Apparently the internet decided it hates China sines the last time I blinked. I don't remember anti Chinese comments being a big thing before (including one videos about China). I personally side with India on this issue, but seriously anti-Chinese sentiment is pointless.
Here is the crux of the situation.
China in an effort to steal land from a small country are quoting a piece of inaccurate geographical treaty.
The treaty which itself was designed by the English who have mapped borders and caused stife all over the world. Classic Brits.
But the Chinese never expected India to actually defend Bhutan, because well, the Chinese have in the past quoted inaccurate non-facts to bully other smaller nations and steal their land and India backed by pussy ass regimes have not always responded.
But no, not this time, India was direct and its government under more decisive leaders and more belief in its military decided to intervene and the Chinese are flabbergasted coz now they are stuck between a rock and a hard place, they expected an easy land grab and now are facing an experienced and a battle hardened military who have defeated them twice while CCP leadership events in China are a coming and Xi Jinping and his cronies have to show something out of this bullying tactic.
But unfortunately for the Chinese, the Indian army are not even remotely similar to escaping unarmed Tibetans who can be shot easily by untrained chinese.
Their unwilling conscripted chinese soldiers who serve for hardly a few years and are probably a result of the Chinese 'One Child Policy' know that if they die, their whole bloodline ends on that very spot. They do not want to even participate in a skirmish with a volunteer Indian army where soldiers serve for decades on end and have the experience of recent mountain warfares and in Doklam have the advantage of terrain.
Jai hind
There is no way any nation can cater Chinese endless territorial demands and claims .any one who knows the chinese claim of entire south china sea by a silly 9 dash line would know that .here Bhutan is a very small country with just half a million population with no army at all .they dont even have the means to maintain embassy in foreign countries .only option for them is take help from India or else become the next Tibet
Both countries should stop fighting. People stop being so racist. This is over a road and territory in the mountains. Everyone should be ashamed of themselves. Solution would be for the Chinese to move the road further north and blast a hole through the mountains from the north side. Indian troops then can withdrawal. Extreme Nationalism from India and China is ridiculous. When I was in college. I met a Chinese and Indian guy. They were both ultra nationalistic as fuck. Indian guy wanted Pakistan to be with India. Chinese guy wanted Tibet and Taiwan to be with China. Yea, being a Chinese descendant from Singapore, these disputes are so silly. Everyone is fighting in South China Sea and fighting over silly mountain borders. Human greed is ugly.
wktjan4286 yaaa man.
China should not built the road there bcoz it's the main way to connect with the north east part of India.
And building road is initial part of capturing parts of any country for China.
No the road goes to Bhutan not India. Haven't you read the reports? Indians trespassed into Chinese territory to stop road construction into Bhutan. Idnians don't want to see their sphere of influence of Bhutan falling under Chinese economic domination. They don't want Nepal and Bhutan falling under Beijing's sphere of influence. The whole thing is a political game.
No. The road goes towards Bhutan, not towards India. Indians have concerns that the road is too close to them. They apparently do not like strong countries building roads close to their border because they are afraid of invasion.
india see bhutan as "brothers" so as big brother at least, they do not want to see china's influence in bhutan. further than that, they might want make bhutan a second sikkim. it is politics people are talking about here. it is clear indian do not care about bhutan people. after all, they just want the land, there are tooo many indians.
I'm so tired of nations claiming land... Land is not yours to take... there was a time when Chinese people understood this, which is why Chinese property law differs from Western property laws... But they forgot... It's sad...
I know it's been a couple of years...but I'm just reflecting over the last decade of China's nonsense.
This is what happens when a country is Run by engineers... They destroy humanity
Thank you for posting this video!
The fact is that +CaspianReport will pin my comment for no reason at all, and will make a video of the greatest superpower in the history of this planet, Finland.
Russian Empire with Putin Khan is reincarnation of Ghengiz Khan's Mongol Empire.
Bogadile you guys aren't jews, and have very little influence on the world outside of reddit. So I guess he'll make a 3-part series.
Bogadile No need to feel bad bro. He'll probably pin it next month. BTW I respect Simo Häyhä. Love from India.
Perkele
What a surprise, CaspianReport talking about something else than ME! Who would've thought.
JUST DON'T SAY CHINA DIDN'T WARN U. PERIOD.
Fck China's warning! How many deadlines you got?
China wrned and warned and warned. For 3 effin months. Then went chickensht.
Nice unbiased video!
A few more points...
1. Although Chinese military is stronger, Indian military is currently on higher ground. A skirmish will cause heavy loss on Chinese side, even though they are more likely to win.
2. Winter would start soon and then it becomes very difficult to fight in Himalayas. So both sides are trying best to force other to back off before snowfall begins.
This was really hard to follow.
Wait till he comes out with a video on Kashmir dispute. *XD*
How do you put 10 Chinese people inside a four wheeler car?????
By telling them the car doesn't belong to them 😂😂😝😝
滑稽
Hey caspian report, you always show the map of china as Including disputed territories such as Taiwan. Whereas you show the map of india without POK and AKSAI CHIN.
Do you mind explaining why that is ?
Because POK is controlled by Pakistan and Aksai Chin by China 🙄
@@xyz-fq5nm exaclty
next time show right map get it
Indian, arent you?
PORN BRAZZERS where do i get the right map?
Wasif Jalal
there is no right map
i know, was tryna being sarcastic, wanted him to blurt out Kashmir is india
India: OK I have this area here, Thats butans, and That over there is yours
China: No
India: Ok, u gotta better idea?
China: ALL OF THIS IS MINE!
And if you switch China and India around in the statement, it will work as well.
@Луис Л no not rly India doesn’t have a expansionistic doctrine in there foreign policy
@@jayy7842
Well, sikkim?
@@ЛуисЛу-ъ4я Im pretty sure that the UK not India. Sikkim has nothing to do with India Foreign Policy.
@@jayy7842
Well, I can research a bit more into this but from outside of the world, India took over sikkim.
so both countries violated Bhutans integrity
I don't see a treaty between Bhutan and China so how exactly has India violated anything?
Idiot!!! The author specifically mentioned that they didn't.
Luscious Lucius Bhutan wants India there.
guess so
China has claims more area disputed than it's own area.
I have nothing against Chinese people but their govt. is immature at times
During the standoff Chinese troops weren't even able to stand still for 30 minutes. They were taking regular breaks for smoking.
India is not a saint here.. It has disputes with all its neighbours.. India supported Tamil Insurgency in Sirlanka to make the small country its vassel state while Sirlanka asked Pakistan to help them.. India recognized the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan while whole world opposed it, Soviets were killing anything that moves or anything that goes against them in Afghanistan. Indian was a Soviet Union ally in South Asia while USA, China and Pakistan were against them... India has imposed a blockade on Nepal which has caused a big food crisis in the poor country which is landlocked... There are 5 different seperated insurgencies in India like Kashmir, Nagaland, Assam and Khalistan in which they have killed millions of people... In 1971 India imposed a blockade on East Pakistan which is present day Bangladesh which caused a massive famine and the people turned refugees went to Indian border for help, India help them but also armed and directed them to go back and fight for a seperate state, this caused a civil war in East Pakistan(bangladesh).... INDIA'S ROLE IS SAME LIKE THAT OF RUSSIA AND CHINA WHO ARE AGGRESSORS!!!
angel Talib why would bengalis fight for Indian cause when as per your comment india created a famine in their country??
Indoctrinated Zombie Pakistani keyboard warrior detected. Avoid this post if you want to not get infected.
India is always the saint, you osama hiding bastard
angel Talib Well if India blocked access and caused famine how the Bengalis came to India. I appreciate your effort to hide the incompetency of Zulfikar Ali Bhuto and Yahya Khan If both of them allowed Sheik Mujibur Rehman form the Government there wouldn't be Bangladesh today so Don't read history in Your country, History lessons in Pakistan is just a lies to support the Army to show India as Enemy, As for as Insurgency Kashmir is the only problem but that too caused by the Pakistani involvement of your Incompetent ISI and Moronic army
Acharya Chanakya Neeti would be so fucking disappointed that pretty much ALL the work he did to unite India and create AKHAND BHARAT was pretty much all in vain as these bastards didn't respect his honour and all that he built during his tenure as Maurya's minister. Fucking disrespectful corrupted turncoat sons-of-bitches! Happy NOW? We've lost AKAND BHARAT to these passive overly loving yet corrupted fucking CUNTS!!! Who would sell their own grandmother down the river to our enemies and also fuck their own people over to appease the foreigner!!! FUCK YOU!!!
Bhutan and Nepal pls Join India and become one of our states...
India occupies the territory of China. The first reason was to protect Bhutan's territory, but later Bhutan claimed the territory belonged to China. Now India is not going to pull out because it would be humiliating and not daring to go to war, knowing that it would be a terrible thing to die
if only this could be mainstream. the fact that this channel is so unbiased and sticks to the facts and logical opinions is amazing, seeing all other YT channel is buried under BS. including VP mentioned in the end. I hope this channel do not change because of donor's bias.
Support China from Pakistan
Defence Gamer
Lol.
Ok sister.
Your support scares us
Jehadi commie alliance is fun to see
Defence Gamer you are a true Asian. A true Asian don't support China.
Defence Gamer lol the last thing china wants is ur support.... Just try to py the debt it will be ok
fuck Pakistan from USA....
I think it the best analysis so far. Good. I subscribe yr channel.