What the China-India Border Dispute is Really About
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 มิ.ย. 2021
- The boundary between China and India represents the longest contested border on the planet. Confrontations between the two sides have turned deadly in recent years, as China becomes increasingly aggressive in the region.
#China+ #India #BloombergQuicktake
--------
Like this video? Subscribe: th-cam.com/users/Bloomberg?sub_...
Become a Quicktake Member for exclusive perks: th-cam.com/users/bloombergjoin
QuickTake Originals is Bloomberg's official premium video channel. We bring you insights and analysis from business, science, and technology experts who are shaping our future. We’re home to Hello World, Giant Leap, Storylines, and the series powering CityLab, Bloomberg Businessweek, Bloomberg Green, and much more.
Subscribe for business news, but not as you've known it: exclusive interviews, fascinating profiles, data-driven analysis, and the latest in tech innovation from around the world.
Visit our partner channel QuickTake News for breaking global news and insight in an instant.
"If it's a border conflict, it's the British. If it's an internal conflict, it's the Americans."
Really? What about all of your dynasties which for thousands of years has been invading it's neighbors? You forgot about that?
@@ParallelComparison I'm neither Chinese, nor Indian, but do tell me more about dynasties invading others!
China has a thousand year history of forcing small states to pay tribute and invading foreign lands. Then when they closed themselves off and missed out on the industrial revolution they started crying because they could no longer be a bully and were forced to suffer the century of humiliation. If China had technology then they would be just as imperialist as the West.
@@smiley4669 Paper dragon will be far more imperialistic. No comparison
@@smiley4669 And not surprisingly, you accept the notion that Since China had fallen behind the industrial revolution and thus being invaded is China’s own fault, you’re basically saying that less developed countries deserves to be beaten and colonized, how chauvinistic is that? You people in the west just don’t change a thing. Get off your high horse.
Behind every conflict in the world a British guy walked away
is that correlation or causation?
@Ayush Nigam which way of causation? The British left because it was problematic or they invented the problem?
@@smoochie3331 They created the problem from the beginning
and leave behind many landmines when they left
Rohingya problem was also created by the Bristish
@@smoochie3331 British colonization and annexation without properly establishing territorial agreements. When the colonization ended, independent countries end up using these British annexations that are not agreed upon by sovereign countries thus causing conflict.
So it's obvious that it's causation
@@unogal5906 those people hated each other before British came and still hate each other after British left centuries ago. Take responsibility and stop blaming other people for your own hatred.
It is surprisingly wise to agree that troops of two nuclear superpowers fight each other with sticks and stones.
It's sensible to do that Because that prevents major escalation
It's because "Bilateral agreements between India and China prevent the use of guns along the line of actual control."
It's because "Bilateral agreements between India and China prevent the use of guns along the line of actual control."
Because they know that if they play with the nuclear, they have no choice but to fight with sticks and stones afterwards.
@@Vincent_de_Paul They know if they fight then America will occupied them again .
10:24 I’m sorry there’s NO WAY you’re telling me they used Tunak Tunak Tun as a taunt😭😭 that’s legendary
For western media, "Old Delhi" is all India.
People living in Gurugram and some other cities be like=Hey BBC(and dw and all)whole of india is not always like that
What's not to love about old Delhi tho. Like I am from Mumbai but I love Old Delhi. It's the essence of India
Yea bro it sucks 😶
So what’s “West for you genius?”
They'll never show the developed regions in India. Don't expect them to .Here, they support India because they want to counter China .Bade harammkhor log hain ye goree angrez .
You know it's bad when you let a British guy involved or let him draw the border
That is part of the problem in the middle east, all of those lines on the map were drawn by the British and French and do not reflect the will, cultures or history of the people that live there.
You know equally bad when someone from the Brooklyn Institute starts to talk geopolitics.
bri*ish 🤢🤢🤢🤢
@@jamesp8459 yep it happened in Afghanistan the people there have no national identity they are more loyal to their tribes than the country
@@jamesp8459 Unfortunately those were done on purpose. They need to create local conflicts and hatred to secure their control.
"First comes one Englishman as a traveller ; then come two and make a map; then comes an army and takes the country. "
I like how India and China military only uses hand to hand combat instead of bullets. Ukraine and Russia can learn from them.
Or china vs Philippines , Indonesia, Taiwan
Rod chines use . Stick also they use . But Chinese small High small people . That's why Indian can handle them easily. Indian hold them in arms
Or USA in Syria, Afghanistan, Iraq, Somalia, Libya, etc.
@@ShreeRam12783 印度人只需要驾驶汽车，就死亡了上百人，而中国顽强的团结意志将弥补所有差距，比如朝鲜战争
@@ShreeRam12783that's why Chinese captured galwan Valley and keep capturing ladakh without fired a single bullet?
Surprised there was no mention of China's planned hydroelectric projects in Tibet, rivers that flow into India.
China has been building hydro in Tibet for decades. It's basically the only reason they want that land. Nothing to do with "historical rights" but simply resources.
I would say that this short documentary is more India-sided.
And bangladesh and particularly it is just one dam that is causing nervousness in bangladesh and India that is on Brahmaputra river. We get enough of the water but if someday the dam fails or collapses, or china releases more water without a warning the towns, villages farmlands downstream in India and Bangladesh will have devastating effects and they will lose thousands of people living in these areas
Onle one river flows from Tibet and that's Brahmaputra river in NE India and Bangladesh.
@@stijnhs Building dams have little to do with border disputes...
When I clicked on this video, I wasn't expecting to see the Tunak Tunak song used as a sort of musical weapon, but here we are now.
Exactly 😂
10:22
Tunak Tunak Tun is exactly why no one has gone to war 🤣🤣🤣
15:20
Mumbai!!
dududurdu dududurdu
@@Hanfugirl_Hanzi the country which sends U95 masks even to it's iron brother Paxtan,in a bid to profiteer during the pandemic has no right to pontificate upon others
FYI U95 masks means UNDERWEAR95 masks LoL 😂🤣😝
All conflicts aside, what a fantastically beautiful place.
Yeah the Earth is a wonderful place until some people have to come and ruin it lol
The Chinese are brutal for using loud speakers to play Indian music 🤣🤣🤣
🤣
That song is super popular in China...lol
We are from North east India...we are mostly christian...we look like japanese,korean and chinese but we are very proud Indian....
and the indians are enjoying with your women
Love from Karnataka., Southern India
If you are native there instead of immgrants, it is sad to hear that. These places never belong to India in the history, there are indepent cultures and states, then conquered by British and their indian footman, and the offsprings say themselves are proud of being the part of the invaders.
We are proud of our North eastern people - there love for India is pure and deep within the feeling of mutual respect holds us together as Indians! No other country can break this fabric of unity in diversity! Not a single inch of the extent of our great country India is open to debate as long as the people living there want to be part of this great country!
Same here brother. Separated by language, food, culture, ethnicity. United in being Indian.
Very happy to see the most favorite comment is "British has related to all conflicts around the world". People are really more shrewd and wise than before.
And yet the world still want to live there. Go figure.
@@philm3509 yeah. ya gotta tell me. What's up with that?
@@pikiwiki Well for a start, if those same people have your mindset we don't want them. What you have failed to mention is the fact that many European nations had empires and all ran them in a way that is not acceptable these days. You chose to select the UK because you have a gripe with them is all. Well guess what, it happened a long long time ago. And if you have a problem go talk to the dead because they are long gone and we have moved on, unlike you that is.
@@philm3509 Well Mr Phil. I see you have mistaken the entire thread of my reply. The only entreaty I can offer is that you loosen up, just a little and understand it was made in a spirit of humor. If you can
People are complete idiots. Only Blaming western nations for everything because they became pansies in recent years.
Tibet was a semiautonomous province of Qing Dynasty China. Semiautonomy means you control internal affairs but get no say whatsoever on foreign policy, territory, borders, martial affairs, taxation due the sovereign. So no, Tibet had no right at all to give away one of its counties to India. Complete nonsense.
If people tell we failed it is fine BUT we should not let people tell that we did not try
IM a chinese from a small southern city of china. Many chinese love india and believe two great country can deal well on the border issue. Hope No War between us forever.
Hmmm idk I hope the ccp have the same insights as you do kind sir
CCP is not your father. I think they're not interested in India. just let your kids leave border and go back home.
youtube allowed there ?
Its not About Chinese Its All About CCP vs India
Chinese soldiers will get a bloody nose...be careful..
North Eastern states not provinces..
@Alivin Green did you study at madarasa?
@Alivin Green We dont have provinces "Bruh", we have states.
@Alivin Green you were taught wrong
@Alivin Green bro you are wrong.....Google it.....Google any of the names of the seven sisters.......the results will show you states(not provinces)............no wonder you're weak student.
@Alivin Green yeah...keep living in your dreams
11:12 Correction - "At least 45 Chinese soldiers died"
If two fishes are fighting u know a british guy passed by
Humanity is best bro
Iam indian 🇮🇳
When two fish are fighting in a pond a British must have passed by!!!😑😑😑
I think I’m blessed because if not I wouldn’t have met someone who is as spectacular as expert Mr Hutchinson mark
Yeah you’re right one needs to diversify to have different streams of income
Cannot be more true.
I was an investor of stocks but sold all off and invested on crypto I’ve been doing well.
I’m a living testimony of Expert Mr Hutchinson mark he has changed my financial status for the best.
10:23 Clearly Tunak Tunak is the musical hydrogen bomb, it will be used by both sides in case of a musical battle.
I cannot explain how much this comment made me laugh
bro you made my day.
@@almostcertainlynotapotato6528 I think Indian forget that these soldiers are not Bangladesh, Bhutan,Nepal or Srilankan army...............
@@alexooi1016 I think Indian forget that these soldiers are not Bangladesh, Bhutan,Nepal or Srilankan army...............
Ask 5 person same story , all five will have different one
Thank you for your insightful presentation.
As observation ,it could be about control of the water sources that flows both ways into India and China. Just observation from a Canadian.
Naah it have little to do with water most of important indian rivers ganga yamuna originates on indian side of himalya , other is indus but its more important for pakistan then india so china wont harm its ally and as for bhramaputra its 70% of water in india gets via indian tributaries and monsoon but as this whole area recieves lot of rain china could use dams to flood indian sides or regulate quantity of water as they want but indian govt is already building big reserviors so it wont be problem as it will affect myanmar and bangladesh as it will affect india , so in the end its all about power struggle tp show who is the boss and immediate result of internal politics in china
@@navneetparmar3632 Many thanks for your insight from this canuck
Most possibly yes. In 2000-01, India carried out a survey about the rivers of Arunachal Pradesh and found that source of more than 80% water of the river Brahmaputra comes from the mountain ranges of Arunachal Pradesh and since then the Chinese started claiming Arunachal Pradesh.
India's biggest river Brahmaputra feeds entire most of Northeast India and Bangladesh(Although the most important is the Ganges, it is not the biggest). During the 1962 war China captured the state Arunachal Pradesh and Aksai Chin but Arunachal Pradesh was freed by the Indian Army. China called for ceasefire and India agreed. They captured Aksai Chin (so the de facto border is not the International border, it is called LAC, a ceasefire line). China accepted Arunachal as a part of India then, for which India accepted Tibet as a part of China officially first time.
Imagine having a war in the highest mountain in the world
Nepal is not a part of this clash
@@aagamanpokhrel4113 So he didn't even say anything about nepal.
He just said what if this clash happened in nepal.
It's like Avengers vs Thanos army clash in wakanda.
Italy and Austrio-Hungaria：First time？
It will like the Eastern front but way worse
Happened already . It's called Siachen battlefield happened between India pakistan
Fighting for water resources that is actually comes from Tibet.
India treats water with no respect
Same with Kashmir.. Rivers in kashmir that then run through pakistan originate from Tibet. Water is one of the main points in the conflict, yet almost never gets mentioned.
India isn't actually that worse off. The source of Ganga, and rivers of Punjab all originate from glaciers in Uttarakhand/Himachal Pradesh/Jammu, all himalayan regions within India serving the Indo-Gangetic Plains, which is the jugular of India. If China turns the tap off on Indus or Brahmaputra, that'll only impact Kashmir, Pakistan, and Far Eastern/NE India. Not much impact on mainland India.
@@rodrozil6544 Correct your facts instead it's India that treats river like the Ganges as Gods and Godesses.
@@dannyduds1058 Most rivers you are talking about actually originate or flow through Jammu and ladakh . We have Kashmir because it's historically ours .Arabs have settled there ,this doesn't mean Pakistan will have it .Kashmir is an ancient Hindu/Buddhist city ,it never belonged to Arabian or their culture.
Even our first prime Minister was a Kashmiri and Indira Gandhi too was a Kashmiri .After independence, half of India's PM were either Kashmiri or of Kashmiri origin.
Soldiers can’t resist music from loud speakers 😂😂
People here talk about border between India and China. Actually there is no border between India and China, in fact the border is between India and Tibet through out history. That the Chinese have illegally occupied Tibet in 1950 is what many people have forgotten.
It seems India got the better part of the deal...... India got couple of million of people in Arunachal Pradesh while China got two snow leopards in Aksai chin.....
@Charlie Zelenoff Arunachal Pradesh is way bigger than switzerland with natural resources. The state density is 12 person per sq km. Too less pop to feed. No worry
If you know the geopolitics, Aksai Chin is way more important to both China and India. If you check the maps, you will realize how close from Aksai Chin to New Delhi. Also, it is the path that China can connect to Pakistan occupied Kashmir.
@@gy7592 Know very little about the precise situation. I vaguely remember Aksai chin being important because of some road connecting Xinjiang and Tibet. Except the aforementioned snow leopards nothing of value there...
Hahaha 🤣 hi this is from aruncahal
@@alexlazar4738 nothing of value in arunachel pradesh either?
Before the British came along, the Indians lived on their side of the mountains and the Chinese on theirs. The border that China recognises is the first British created and published border which is on the China side of the mountains which were formally no man land. China was busy fighting Japan at the time. Subsequently, the British adjusted the border twice without consultation. India recognises this amendment but China doesn't.
This is a much better explanation than what was provided in the video report. Thanks.
The East India company had economic interests at the border- tea. China is naturally butthurt about that history.
India behaves no better today, aggressively defending British era borders while claiming cultural nationalism.
Thanks to the British ofc
@@USAlove.tsmc.NotYou
The Indian government is not better than the Brits. They know the Brits were bandits but why are they using the maps from the bandits to negotiate with China? Because the Indian government believe that India became the Brits bandits after 1948. That was how the 1962 war started. Listen to many supposedly educated Indians' views of the Sino-Indian conflict, 90% of them will repeat the same story. Demarcate the border between China and India according to the bandits. China needs to be militarily strong, if not, India will not hesitate to use force against China, similar to what they did in 1962.
@@USAlove.tsmc.NotYou
The heart of Silicon Valley, CA, USA
ok imma tell the truth that tunak tunak music is the reason of no new fight on borders
Just what the British wanted. Split the Indian colony into Hindu, Islamic, Buddhist pieces, fighting over the largest watershed river-systems of the world. Rule by divide and conquer.
The video purposely didn’t specify the fact who carried out the “advancing policy” and triggered the 1962 war between the two sides
pretend to be unbias？ I guess
Mao
Mao
Mao, China claims territory unethically. These regions have always belonged to India since ancient times.
@@PriyaSharma29 there was not a country called India until 1947. You were just different tribes. You should thank the British to unite those tribes.
First off all India China don't have a border. INDIA had border with Tibbet which China occupied Tibbet.Then they started claiming Indian territory as Chinese.
You should ask the Mongols that Tibet was beaten down and forced to be given to us. Of course, that was a long time ago, much earlier than India became a country.
@@snakereal7545 There was no CHina too during that Time. Also there was alwasy civil war going on in china. and Mongols did some bad things to CHina. but past is past.
There was also no India until Britain artificially created the country. Based on your logic, India should be balkanized into many seperate kingdoms.
@@dgcu-t96 Before Britain India was even bigger. from Afghanisthan to Pakisthan all were under Indian Asoka , Maruya Empire Rule.
@@whocares3132 By country, I mean modern nation state with mostly homogenous population (france, germany and etc). I don't think you will consider Alexander's empire or Rome as a modern nation state by any means.
Additionally, neither Maruya nor Mughal had control over seven sister states or south Tibet, and it was only after the british conquest did the british raj acquire the territory.
4:18 1962 war Aksai Chin
5:00 areas of contention
5:20 British lines
14:00
In 1967 india won in indo china war
What is the dispute all about;
Chinese hegemony and their assertion that they own Asia
water, saved you 20 minutes.
thats just one aspect of it...its more of an attempt to stop india from improving its navy as indian navy can be a potential threat to chinese export ships at malacca strait and arabian sea...shift its focus to the northern borders.
TD
Ans land too
Never knew we had provinces in India..I thought we only had states and union territories.
did you expect the msm to do a proper fact check?
it's all the same from an outside look, I even call US states provinces. if my country is divided into provinces I will call all other division inside countries provinces serves the exact same purpose. in the same way, meet many Americans that call every division inside any country state. is just more simple than learning about how each country wants its divisions to be called.
@@lucaskp16 I love seraphine artwork...just amazing..
😍😍
Though in-game not so much only her passive music when her teammates are with her..
@Truth Comes I think you are just too brainwashed mate lol. My dad lives in Shanghai, he told me the strict gov measure meant Covid was brought under control APril LAST YEAR... Scary mate the sort of propaganda youve been fed
@Truth Comes yup they didnt even enclosed there covid numbers and death
It was India doing the "Salami Slicing".
where are the references? i would like to cite but i didnt see anywhere you put the references
China has lost the opportunity of the century to capture a huge market in India where people started loving their products.
Not love but compromise for the price, rather than quality.
Depends how China acts. If they can control Indonesia, Singapore, Malaysia, and Egypt they can force India to become a Chinese client state. Once that happends India will be forced to give China their claimed territory and be forced to buy Chinese products.
Lol everyone in India still uses lots of Chinese products. Which world do you live in?!
@@vatsalnahata9560 LOL 2021! And you?
@@vatsalnahata9560 Nope. There is a significant drop in China originated goods. There were several articles about this.
By Covid and Galwan clash, China shot itself on the foot.
India is truly something different...
why
Yea but in a bad way
@@igbc176 why in a bad way... because these guys show most of our country as slums and poverty...no offence poverty does exist in this country but it is sometimes projected to extremes...and it pisses me off
@@bibaswanmukherjee7237 great, for me indians are the most bravest peoples also a shameless..yeah, no one knows about Sikkim, goa, Hyderabad, Jammu Kashmir many more. And with thoes opportunistic mentality whoever ask help india helped them all by captured them. but with those blunderous history brave indians rising voice for Tibet,Taiwan, Hong Kong...👏👏👏👏👏
@@nomoretears...3239 ok first of....who captured what ....we could easily have captured Sikkim and Kashmir... pakistan attacked kashmir and we weren't even bothered...maharaja of Kashmir himself approached us and we signed the treaty or referendum recognising kashmir as a part of India...as for Sikkim...it was a similar case...Sikkim allowed its own annexation to act as a buffer against china...and goa was our territory captured by Portugese....we simply went there and the Portugese surrendered...india has already lost enough land in wars and disputes...still we don't reply or rebuke against smaller nations by snatching Sovereignty away from them...if we had really done so.. nobody from Nepal or Bhutan would freely text against India expressing their views and opinions.. secondly...don't let propaganda blind you that India is still one of the kindest countries on earth that are big in size and have power but never flex it that way...so yeah....your regional sovereignty deserves for you to be congratulated...but always remember us when you fall in trouble... cause we will be the only ones there
This two country are the real beast when it comes to future's economy
thanks for the explanation.. 😊
I lost it at tunak-tunak,Made me lol
So true🤣
the Chinese blaring Tunak Tunak is lowkey the best thing to happen in warfare
That's why depending on one stream of income had never made any millionaire and earning check doesn't put you in Forbes 🤷
@@juliegary5168 😂😂
Interesting most people don't understand the market moves and tend to be mislead in facts like this and depend on money in the bank. Very bad idea
DRDO should start research on how to fully utilise Daler Mehndi's military potentials. Lol
😂😂😂
Lol.indian
Why would you say 20 Indian soldiers and only 4 Chinese soldiers died? This is simply illogical and buttressing the Chinese Government.
Two great countries has been bullied by western countries, don't let outsiders to interfere our future.
Hopefully through diologue for the mutual benefit of two countries, we are responsible for our own actions.
I have been to 10 states of India including of whole Kshmir. Indian n Chinese are lovely people,
Two Great Indian Master traveled n taught the dharma in White Horse Temple, Luoyang Henan China,
Both of their graves are respected in the temple, Chinese virtue cultivation emphesis in Buddha, Confucius and Laozi.
In this world hatred can never be appeased by hatred. Hatred can only be appeased by love.
This is the external law ....Buddha
你是佛教徒。
So true
yet the chinese goverment that chinese people have allowed to remain in power is actively trying to destroy the buddhist religeon and culture, hence the occupation of tibet to build damns, concentration camps religeous people are sent to and the eviction of the dahli lama
😅India and China never share border in history
There is Tibet😇 in between
Which occupied by China 😑
Tibetian president Dalai Lama is in India as refugee 🙏
Sorry
as Indian family part😇
@@Nope-111 they have been during the Qing dynasty. Any country has annexed land so saying China is at fault is a weak argument IMHO.
A conflict in Asia? Looks like the British had passed by.
Lucky they did, and the US, or your army wouldn't have any weapons or training.
This is the one time they didn't
@@thealexanderbond hmm not really? India owned 25% of the economic wealth in the world before the British invaded, they would’ve quickly industrialised without the British.
@@airconditioning4290Well you can speculate, but that's it.
It's impossible to imagine an India without all the foreign influence over the centuries.
As to the OP's point, just count up all the conflicts there have been in Asia over the millennia, and the British were involved in maybe 5%,
so that's an extremely inaccurate sterotype.
War is generally bad for business, and business was the main point of it all.
@@thealexanderbond
I wouldn’t say speculation, more like a definite thing that was going to happen, like I said, india were the richest, they definitely had the ability to industrialise.
hmm I’m not entirely sure by what u mean with foreign influence, but India heavily influenced south east Asia with the chola dynasty, also Buddhism spread from south india to japan and also to other countries along the way.
When india was at its prime trading with people it spread influence to east Africa, and ofc Europe as they were one of the main trading groups - they would’ve definitely seen the industrial revolution and have followed along with their own revolution.
And tbh your last point is wrong as well, war isn’t terrible especially when u get lots of resources and money at the end. For example the Middle East has lots of oil. Africa has lots of everything. And india has spices and also lots of resources like Africa.
The only reason the British invaded were for these resources and when they left or were pushed out, they gave way to partition in South Asia. The civil war in Nigeria.
The Israel Palestine conflict. The China India border conflict, I could go on and on
It’s called the salami slicing pieces of other countries off hoping that no one will call their bluff!
Being bullies While asking no one else to Bully them
You mean like Syria Venezuela Iraq Libya Bolivia Haiti Columbia 😁 and creating terrorism to do it.
"Salami Slicing" was Hitler's thing. China is just borrowing it.
Like Israel is slicing off pieces of the Mid East for Greater Israel
They most have learned that move from the West.
In reality, this is not a border between India and China, but a border between India and Tibet. Tibet being a whole country that was stolen by China. China also wiped out one third of the Tibetan population the same way they are exterminating the Uighurs today. China even claims that all of South-East Asia is Chinese, but it does not stop there because some Chinese also say that Japan is really originally Chinese. I do not know a single neighbor that they have that trusts them and that includes even North Korea, but you got to love the Chinese because they are causing everyone to love them.
The elaborate temple shown clinging to the side of a mountain may be :"Tiger's Nest." I don't remember Taxine or tigers nest t being nestled against the mountain on the back side. But tigers nest was burned it down during a robbery and rebuilt so maybe this is not exactly a copy of the original. I struggled to reach a path on an adjoining mountain there was directly across from tigers nest, but as I sat down to rest there under a tree, several other more healthy hikers past me going up I later learned that from the point where I stopped the path went downward and over toward the temple. The day I was there and the day my friend had walked on all the way to the front gate of the temple, he discovered the temple was closed to all visitors that day.
... This is the location where padmasalvadora road on the back of a tiger to come in to Bhutan and bring some teaching. That is why it is called tigers nest.
if you want have a border conflict ,let the British draw the border line .
😂
I guess south china sea territory is also drawn by englishmen
Border line syndrome genetically predisposed? Any pun intended. Love, peace and justice.
* want to *
@@Fatez thank you - I do not own a keyboard
India should also start clamming additional 500 km from Arunachal pradesh toward china to keep them occupied.... we should give them a taste of their own medicine..
Day dreaming. South Tibet is part of China wrongly occupied by India. Read the history of the McMahon line unilaterally drawn up by India's Colonial Master. Khasmir is the same as it is part of Pakistan. Until these borders are resolved, India can never be truly sovereign as it will have to depend on outsiders for support. Perhaps once a colony always a colony?
@@xrc5540 well if that's the case the whole Pakistan is a part of India ... and the whole Tibet is an independent sovereign nation illegally occupied by China... and tibet has no problem in recognizing McMohan line.....
@@rs9226 Tibet has always been part of China. A lot has already been covered by other commentators here. There was colonisation on both sides of the border- India by Britain and China by Western powers and Japan in the past. Only by understanding this recent history can a way be found. Not by more neo-colonisation. I have no wish to argue with anyone about who’s right and wrong. Just resolve and live in Peace.
@Instagram Ahmed abe pakistani, kaahe gaali khaane aya hai
@@xrc5540 OMG, South tibet is a part of china? I am pretty sure you are a pakistani who is okay to be misled by anything that you have been taught.
The British stirred things up between China and India, they also did so between Israel and Palestine(i am aware some may argue that Israel is not a country) and multiple crazy border disputes in the African continent. I am really speechless about this whole colonialism thing.
The British and the US are the nations always use the "divide and conquer" strategy to stir up wars between nations so they can make arms, sell arms and make a lots of money.
Israel owns the west.
the west is owned by bankers. and most bankers are zionists.
this is why the west grovels to israel. the west is the dog, and israel is its master.
😅India and China never share border in history
There is Tibet😇 in between
Which occupied by China 😑
Tibetian president Dalai Lama is in India as refugee 🙏
Sorry
as Indian family part😇
Both China and India are pillars of Eastern civilization and have shared prosperity for thousands of years. Suddenly the westerners come and both China and India become poor countries and then they are taught that they are each other's enemies, it seems that some people are afraid that China and India will unite and restore their former glory.
China occupied Tibet which gave it the border with India. Let's say it how it is. The fighting - that's between China and India. Don't blame the British. The fact that India and China would rather fight over remote areas with sticks and stones than negotiate borders should demonstrate to you how difficult it is to draw borders as a colonial power between people that are in conflict. Sometimes those borders were drawn for economic gain for the colonial power but just as often it was for practical reasons and a lot of the time they didn't know how to do it because the locals disputed the territories themselves and were fighting over it long before colonialists arrived.
Now China generates border conflicts throughout the South China Sea, ignoring international dispute resolution mechanisms and going so far as to construct artificial islands to claim de facto control over regions of ocean. This is a side effect of its rise in power, its greed and inability for smaller countries to stand against China. The same selfish motives are in action as were in the day of colonialism so pretending to be "shocked by colonialism" is really a denial of what continues to go on today.
China and India "becoming poor" is not the right choice of words. Rather, they fell behind an explosion in cultural and scientific innovation that occurred in Europe.
Neither of current India or China existed when these lines were drawn. Very smart move by the British. All it had to do was draw some lines on a map, and later generations will fight with blood.😂
It's all about shifting indian expenditure from naval assets to ground assets, stronger Indian navy hampers china ambitions in africa and Indian Ocean
India hamper China? For real? Are you aware of China's African footprint extent? Jeez dude
Navy's too expensive to expand. We don't worry about the the Indian Ocean and South China sea too much tho , the NATO , japan , korea have it covered
re-read your comment, it should have been shifting from ground assets to naval, then the rest of the comment would make sense
@@Klopp2543 Malaca Chokepoint moment.
Singapore is a Chinese naval base. If anything happen in Melaka straits, China can easily mobilize 4 million Chinese in Singapore to attack India.
For Western world
China : communist dragon
India: many slums
😂
😂 you are right! I’m Chinese and they think we are curry and fried rice
@@Neyobe Without curry British dish is just star-gazing pieeeeee lol.
@@xtzhao2196 haha
Yeah that sums it up.... I was in New Delhi in 2013 that's the capital. It looked like a total slum with minimal infrastructure, shoddy electrical wires dangling very low, many unpaved roads and people defecating in the street. The whole city smells like diesel exhaust mixed with feces and exotic spices/foods. Things might have changed over the last 9 years but I doubt they changed radically. That's the capital. Obviously it's logical to conclude that poorer cities must be worse no?
I don't even understand how an economy the size of india can't clean up it's capital. It's only one city. It should represent your country.
@@Shattered-Realm no one in india says Delhi is the ideal city to visit. Neither is mumbai. If you judge based on 2 cities. You know nothing. Those are big cities because it has more population+more opportunities for job. Otherwise Delhi is one of the most polluted city and needs many things to change. But the Delhi which you are referring to is old Delhi not new Delhi again.
And for the fact:- whole asia's most clean village is in india too. So there are many diverse places in india. You may find very amazing natural beauty with too cleanliness. You may also find poor and dirt places. Sometime even in same cities. Have a visit in southern states of India or north eastern parts of india. They are less congested and less slum.
Homage to Mother India...Kuan Yin encourages and thanks India
A war lasts for days making relation sour for decades and hamper development for years.
The major thing that started all these conflicts: the addiction and thirst for POWER, RESOURCE, CONTROL.
Get your meddles out lads, it’s captain obvious.
Correction* The major thing that started all these conflicts: China and its addiction and thirst for POWER, RESOURCE, CONTROL.
@@kancer5990 Correction** The major thing that started all these conflicts: the type of dogshit chauvinism that you believe in and think is fine just because you have a democracy, a toxic thing exists in both of our countries, and the addiction and thirst for POWER, RESOURCE, CONTROL.
China already destroyed half of our world! And world leaders are freaking blind!
China must be nuked!
@Kitty Cat wow so clever. You stop blowing your cousin to think and type that out?
Western media's 1 think is common india never fight against China without Western support 😂😂
India always prepared for 2 front war
India declined the help of USA in border conflict with china
india can't war with China
@@-bbc3848 lol. Haka noodles
20 vs 45
Brainwashed by Winnie the pooh Media
Next joke please 😂 😂
@@txabishmoor922 you have only one father
The biggest nightmare for Indian people is that China owns Tibet. Tibet is so close to India's most populous Ganga region that Chinese hypersonic nuclear missles launch from Tibet just need several minutes to hit India, there won't be enough time for Indian to hide underground, while China's populous region is much farther away from India. Even Indian nuclear missles retaliate, they need to fly too long time to reach China's populous region due to numerous Chinese anti-air missle intercepting.
@上官 竹喧 幼稚可笑，你真的以为中国控制西藏是为了发展高原旅游业？你真的以为三哥支持达赖喇嘛是为了宗教自由？西藏的直接经济价值几乎为零是明摆的事，中央每年在西藏的净财政收入为负数。西藏是亚洲水塔，控制西藏就是控制亚洲各国的大动脉，同时大大缩短战时打击印度的距离。一旦两国发生冲突，中国有能力瞬间毁灭印度核心地区。而西方国家和印度都不希望中国有这种地理优势，所以才会支持达赖喇嘛进行藏独。
Thank you for acknowledging that those territories do not belong to India
I think you don't understand English.
Using pop music to assault the ears of your enemies is the most Indian thing I’ve ever heard.
That was done by the Chinese, not the Indians.
The US prefers to use Heavy Metal. 😈
@@ycplum7062 They used Nancy Sinatra on David Koresh.
chinese used it on their forward posts, in what seems to be an attempt to appear as indian forces.
@@aashmanjoshi313 nope, the Chinese played it thinking that soldiers of Sikh regiment where deployed there, sadly they weren't deployed
If something happen something to any Muslim or Islam in India or around the world Pakistan would react but never spoken a word against China.
indiya best contry in wurd
what word do you mean?
@@chekweitanHe meant about Uyghur Muslims..
57 Muslim countries cannot stand against China 😂
Blame the then British government for including parts of northeast India which asked for independence from British like India but it was incorporated with India without concent
Please make videos on Nepal India border dispute also.
China is also using these border disputes to draw India's attention away from the Andaman and Nicobar Islands. Which could be used to block China's access to oil through the Malacca Straight.
That would be an act of war. Not just border disputes.
it isn't a viable option since it would also block Chinese exports from reaching the middle east and other parts of Europe. And much of these countries' economy depends upon the trade with China.
Probably not relevant, when China has access through Afghanistan to Iranian, Syrian(if they can get the US out) and Iraqi oil, the Andaman and Nicobar Islands won't be an issue, why ship by sea when you can use a pipeline or trains.
@陳臨淵 Calm down bro you think any media of any country will say wrong about their own country ..Just peace
@male princess Never knew that bots also reply
5：15 the old India map show that Arunachal Pradesh belong to China.🤣
Couple of possible explanations of China's motivation in provoking India-China border disbute in this video are NOT quite logic. China's focus has been always the South China sea and the US-China relation, NOT India at all. the China-India border has much less value comparing to its East Coast.
Who were the bad guy to create the border conflict, ordinary citizen from both side never gonna know the true stories. US wants to alliance with India to win its own geo-political and security contest over China. they would blindly side with India no matter what.
China was having a lot of troubles such as fierce US-China trade war and Hongkong protest and Xinjiang problem and Covid 19... A logical assumption would be that India wanted to take advantage of this time window by taking actions at the india-China border, and hoping China wouldn't react as China was too busy dealing with the US trade war and many more.
The Indians are too blind to see the reason and are brainwashed by their government.
I think all fault is of India not china
Indians are famous for speculation. But China has the strength to handle multiple conflicts. The Indians miscalculated. Next time Indians provoke, I want to see PLA tanks on the streets of New Delhi.
If you look at the video of the latest conflict, it is the Indian soldiers crossing the river to the Chinese side, is it not?
@@jademoon1530Ok Chinese bot we all agree with your agenda driven false narrative but can you explain why your corona virus🦠😷 country oh sorry china 😊 has so many border disputes with so many nations if you are so innocent 😂😂😂😂
Imagine acting like children and blaring loud sounds at each other but it’s not grade school it’s their militaries😂😂
I thought they did that so that India have to focus more on it border instead of those island near the Malacca Strait where India could blockage Chinese shipping ships
Nay, the Straits of Malacca is patrol by the navies of Indonesia, Malaysia, and Singapore. India doesn't get to blockage it.
@@nutayahoo5000 they can cuz they own andaman and nicobar islands.
They did because China is invading Taiwan but India to save Taiwan started deploying more offensive troops along China border.
@@PrashantKumar-nw1hm I highly doubt that china could invade Taiwan. There's like no actual benefits to it other than starting a war with the west which isn't beneficial.
@@PrashantKumar-nw1hm lol it will be a massacre and only US can protect Taiwan
India will have to face china today or tomorrow. Quad is the right step in that direction.
As per russian and US sources china face heavy casualties in that hand to hand combat
我们这边报道4名军人死亡，印度有20人死亡
@@genyo6506 omg what language is this buddy😄
@@genyo6506 okay brainwashed chinese
This video doesn't actually touch on what the border dispute is REALLY about, at the heart of the current dispute is over water resources, China is facing a water shortage in the highly populated Northeast region, so they have been creating dozens of dams and water pipeline in the water-rich mountainous regions in the Southwest, quite a few are near the disputed territories.
This would impact the water supply for nearly 1/3 of the Indian population, which is obviously very significant for India. If India is not able to resolve this issue and allow China to control the flow of water, then they will be much less capable of resisting Chinese influence in the future.
I don't think this will lead to full-blown war, but there will be ongoing negotiations and disputes over these areas for years to come.
What goes around comes around. India has been incredibly unfair with Bangladesh when it comes to water distribution. India hasn't implemented a deal signed in 1973 to this day.
Even if there was no water issue and just empty air, China would try to claim that too.
@@sheefatrabbi7382 it's one state in India that hasn't accepted it, West Bengal, the BJP government is extremely frinedly towards Bangladesh.
@@sheefatrabbi7382 Do you know that India and Bangladesh together are objecting China's dam construction?
I think China will just built the dam on bhramaputra and Indians will be just talking among themselves about it and by the time it will be finished Indians will just start crying about its government.
China can do whatever it want, we Indians can only think about it (we can't do anything)
now i know why brexit is so messed up...sorry EU not your fault it is just that you are dealing with brits :)
Not really but sure.
It is because Britain will create CANZUK. Consisting of nations like Canada, New Zealand, Australia, and UK. Britain also hasn't been benefiting from the EU. Nations holding the EU together are/were the UK, France, and Germany. If they leave the EU will fall apart.
@@PabloGonzalez-qh6ii COPIUM
really ironic that the first to leave the EU is also an union of countries.
@@PabloGonzalez-qh6ii scotish independence and north ireland annexation is much easier than british empire part deux lite
Tibet India border not China, China illegally occupied Tibet in 1959.
so basically China (that has colonized Tibet) is claiming all territory along Tibets border with India is theirs? sounds legit.
Just like U.S colonized the entire Pacific ocean & claims it as American soil?
I've always found China to be a very audacious country. "How dare you accept the Dalai Lama?"
how dare cpc capture Tibat?
@@Riyabsb right?
@@yokokoko9748 it's funny that the western states of China were once sovereign nations that helped China proper to fend off enemies over the centuries, and China pays them back by subjugating them. What a bunch of DICKS!
@@MrTaxiRob What are you referring to by "enemies"? Enemies from the "west" didn't really exist due to the geographic barriers of the Tibetan plateau. And China was conquered by Mongolians and Manchurians. A major adversary group was the Xiongnu (a broad term for the nomads that included the Mongols), which was actually to the north of Han territories.
@@momoware you're right, that's what I was thinking of.
11:14 Atleast 4 soldiers🤣, their country people don't believe those numbers.. See latest news they jailed one for asking it.
@@chinmayapradhan305 He was refusing it because it was lost in 2013 under Congress government. Accepting that would be like shooting himself in the foot. And nobody in India was punished for questioning India's response to China. What are you smoking dude?
the korean war
@@ashishvaidya2003 You cannot get things if you have opposition everywhere. That is why India is still third world while China is at second world status.
@@VanaeCavae That terminology of rated world's was coined by west and if you don't know the reason why then don't use it m8,
It doesn't have any thing to do superiority but choosing factions in the cold war.
Well... Atleast is sort of use as minimum. So, the narrator is implying that there are minimum 4 chinese died, there could more... they just dont have data.....
After one-year, and considering emerging events...opine, China-India Border Dispute is never going away but in times progressively & increasingly aggressive and even another open Conflict & War is most likely possible. Why is the China and India fighting over a complete un-inhabitable, desolate freezing cold mountainous region...i think the answer is : FreshWater Supply.
And also mineral resources.
From where did the British get the Right to draw boundary lines unilaterally ?
As such where does these lines get their legitimate authority ?
The video is exactly 19:47 min long...is it just a coincidence😂😂
most of these border and territorial disputes go back to colonial control. The boundaries between India and China were drawn by the British. either country could make a tactical mistake leading to a full blown war.
Why would or should China allow the British to draw its borders? Ridiculous.
@@ktchong4395 'It's' borders? Not one of those borders touches Chinese land. All of India's border meet with Tibet.
@@colejones6312 it's Tibetan land ,before india swallow a country called sikkim there was no way to reach to.arunanchal I guess .....
@@sarojrajsatyal3736 incorrect. Siliguri corridor maybe beside sikkim but has no relation with the latter to connect to North eastern states. The corridor has always been part of India even before annexation of Sikkim.
My hometown is Siliguri and I live and work in Sikkim. 😅
The border was not delineated and British didn't impose on anyone, Burma and Pakistan realigned with China. Only India ambitiously claimed everything, even region not controlled by British, bearing in mind that British recognized Tibet as part of China. The dispute is entirely India's own doing.
There were more than 40 Chinese casualties in the hand-to-hand combat fight in 2021.
Hand to hand combat is the most important form of combat.
India is the best at hand to hand combat so they are winners
China will one day claim Andromeda galaxy as its borders somehow touch them.
What are you talking about interstellar space is China's territory and Voyager 1 is it's air space violating it's air space... They are on their way to shoot it just like America shot their spy balloon...
There are no provinces or UTs in North East India, only states. I dont think there are any provinces in India. Please get your basics right if you want credibility.
10:23, the funniest thing ever
aa
I thought the beat was lit 🔥
I can't stop clicking....party on
the Chinese blaring Tunak Tunak is lowkey the best thing to happen in warfare
Lol
Anyone know where I can find the song that plays right after the 10:00 minute mark?
Tunuk tunuk by Daler Mehndi
@6:19 Well, this scene is just like anything you'd see in Malaysia and Singapore, where Indians and Chinese have been living together like brothers for centuries. 🙂
Short answer: British
Shorter answer: China
@@TJ-vl1fflonger answer: British has a long history of play divide and conquer, you have the blood of the ppl of all colonized nations in your hand, shame on you, pay the price!
@@alee2204 Do you say the same thing to modern Mongols? They colonized everybody. The Persians did, the Arabs did, the Japanese did, everybody colonized everybody but you single out white people because you hate us. Thats fine though, we dont need you. You need us. And your hate will unite us.
1 million Indians in the UK with their lovely passports. 1 million Pakistanis in the UK with their lovely passport.
They obviously feel the same as you. LOL
@@TJ-vl1ff "You" need us ... but how did u know his ethnicity and country 🙄🙄
Its your everyday conflict between two powers who dont want to talk, but also dont want to attack. Lets just hope it stays that way and countries talk, instead of war
The countries want to talk, and they do. There was the 13th Corps-commander level meeting held recently between India-China. Right after that China has started deploying their new Multi Rocket Launching System (MRLS) near the border. The talks mean nothing.
@@artwizardsam3238 关键印度野心太大,本来就没有什么边界线一直有一条习惯线，印度总以为他的爸爸侵占了什么，他就可以得到什么但他没意识到一个问题那不是他爸爸是他的主子
@@pingranjiang9063 You guys withdrew from the pangong tso sectors as well as the finger 3 and 4 of the range. So how exactly did china teach us a lesson?
Today how far India built roads to the border belongs to India and how far china has built roads are belong to China....so in between whoever built first that belongs to them no confusion......
Not the fault of the British for actually defining borders that before then were extremely vague. the only problem is that China didn;t recognise the borders because the treaty was made with independent Tibet and not with Beijing directly.
British law on the border of India and China 😂😂😂
10:23 I was expecting fake explosive sound, but Tanuk Tanuk lol.
I was expecting the Soviet national anthem.
Need to hear from two sides.
China is positioning itself militarily for when the war starts. And they need a lot of key positions on the Indian border because as they know India will be an ally of the west in that war.
Now that was a manly fight. Just sticks and stones along with that song on the loud speakers. 🔊👍
@TH-cam Ban you are ignorant. Read history from different sources, Indian troops from Punjab, Gorkha, Naga, Maratha, Ralput , Grenadier regiment are known to have taken more enemies than their numbers.
@@spaul6066 Every military can say that.
That's just crazy chasing all those little f****** around with sticks and stones... I'm exhausted just thinking about it. Thank the Almighty for modern munitions.
@@kirkmarch4713 Bro there's a treaty between India and china not to use weapons in border, to prevent war situations.
Tunak Tunak Tun is exactly why no one has gone to war 🤣🤣🤣