John Bercow accused of bullying staff member - BBC Newsnight
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.ย. 2024
- Angus Sinclair, John Bercow's former private secretary, has accused the Speaker of bullying.
Mr Sinclair said the bullying included angry outbursts, obscene language and mimicry.
John Bercow denies the allegations.
Newsnight is the BBC's flagship news and current affairs TV programme - with analysis, debate, exclusives, and robust interviews.
Website: www.bbc.co.uk/...
Twitter: / bbcnewsnight
Facebook: / bbcnewsnight
![[LIVE] MCHOICE & MINT AWARDS 2024 at TRUE ICON HALL, ICONSIAM](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wMewUeT5nbY/mqdefault.jpg)
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA Finals D1 | Fall | ยิงต้องโหด ให้เหมือนโกรธกันมาก่อน](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/OnTdfGySmds/mqdefault.jpg)
so when he signed the NDA it was not in the public interest for him to disclose, and now it is?
It's typical corrupt WASP behavior...
Credit to him for speaking out about the bullying that he endured. Disgraceful behavior from Bercow.
a former Royal Navy Submariner..the best of the best, yet the Speaker talked down to him.. Bercow should be sent to the House of Lords as a tea boy
A former submariner who feels he has to go onto the media and cry about the shouty, sweary little toad, aye 🙄 Politics can weaken and corrupt even the most experienced warriors, they belittle themselves by serving these MPs in the first place. He signed an NDA fs, he isnt the first veteran to work for a boss who feels threatened by their experience, knowledge and most likely here, how their collegues trust them or follow their advice. PTSD from working for Bercow? Whatever idiot claims this..... she needs to get a grip or a therapist. Definately a case of small man syndrome which happens everywhere, on every fucking ship! Imagine being paid a bung when you sign the OSA......everyone in the westminster machinery needs a reality check. Disgusts me that the people we've had in that place sent so many young people to war, people their grandkids age who had better values and standards and a religious commitment to "public service" and and loyalty. Such a pantomime.
not interested in people chuntering from a sedentary position ineloquently for no obvious purpose
This is a man who has faced danger in the service of the navy, and has held positions of great responsibility. He is totally believable. While bullying is intolerable and should be dealt with promptly, on the other hand one can only imagine the stresses of the office of Speaker. This does not mean behaviour alleged against him should be condoned, but perhaps there may be ways of reducing that stress for future incumbents of the office.
Berco is gonna burst a bloody vessel
Excuses.
One Astral "man" defending another Astral "man". A world full of sissy thoughtforms...
Bercow isn’t british.
Honestly this story stinks. WHy speak up now that Bercow could become a Lord?! Why didn't Sinclair break his non disclosure agreement before when, as he himself says, other people were suffering from the same circumstances and he could have avoided that pain??Never trust these people that suddenly and conveniently remember they were abused 10-20- 30 years prior. And then you dig a little bit and voila, you find out they got a big fat cheque along the line. Disgraceful - this is the world we live in.
100% -- The Lords hate him and they created a propaganda campaign.
You are kidding right? Watch Bercow talk to his parliamentary colleagues. His nasty, hateful, taunting insults to his fellow members was unprecedented. I can't imagine working for such a sociopath. I am amazed that people still defend him. A decade of chaos under Bercow's rule disgraced the House of Commons.
@@douglasclouatre165 I've watched hours and hours of footage from the House of Commons with Bercow as speaker, and have not found one word of hatespeech, not one insult uttered by the gentleman.
@@blablubb4553 Hear, hear!
Wait so allegations three years ago is resurfacing in 2022 and JB has been banned from Parliament.
Remember when Sir Robert Rogers (now Baron Lisvane) had to "retire" early as clerk of the house in 2014. MPs reported, even then, bully-Bercow had forced him out with expletives.
Kate Emms appeared in a documentary about the House of Commons. She bought chocolates for back benchers who were trying to craft private member's bills. If anyone had a problem with her, without question, it would have been their own fault.
Youve been proved right, Lisvane has now come out and totally validated what you said.
so the Remainer's hero is the Weinstein of Parliament :D
Weinstein blackmailed women into sexual acts by threatening their careers, did we watch the same video?
The People Who YELL the Loudest Are Usually HIDING the Most!
I think this guy is telling the truth. Bercow seems like a horrid little man.
i think that he is telling the truth..
however - this guy is getting a very easy ride compared with those at the bottom of the pile - who get worse shit than this, have no one to turn to for help and don't know when they are going to be sacked and replaced by another psychic punch-bag..
Can't argue with that. Bercow seems to be flat out denying what this chap is saying though, which makes me think Bercow is a liar. Also Bercow used to be part of the Monday Club & expressed some pretty racist views in his younger days. Makes you wonder if he still believes that shit.
John Bernie is an intolerable little man.
Maybe Sinclair was just bad at his job and Bercow liked him and expected more out of him.
Based on what?
I were a coach driver to the Royal Navy Fleet Head Quarters Mr Sinclair is indeed a True gentleman i were proud to know him. It takes a lot of guts to stand up to a proven bully John Bercow Well done Angus regards Terry Russell.
"Proven bully". Words that were interestingly never heard in the 20th century when there were standards in the world and people had to act like adults (something Bercow spent hours requesting that other adult children do), SUCK IT UP and deal with conflicting personalities. The softness of today is sickening. A man acts like a man and his whole life can now be ruined due to you fruits. Maybe you're intimidated by his bloodline? Right, maybe if folks like you stop eating so much wheat and soy and start eating eggs and meat you'd grow a pair and your member would dislodge from being stuck within. Because for one, none of you ever seem to speak with any eloquence or grace whatsoever, so your brain isn't all there.
Bully? You've never seen a bully, pal. When you deal with a real "bully" (aka sociopath, narcissist) , you'll realize that half your problem is they expertly conceal their behavior behind professional excuses, "ethics" and "rules". And the other half is they are protected by their employer/locale (police, judges, etc.), so you'll NEVER get support from anyone when you complain about their behavior. You'll go insane if you haven't learned how to be your own man, yet.
Bercow is the same ilk as Simon Harris from Southend. Evil bully who hates the white British
I first met Angus in 1975 when he joined the Royal Navy. We were good friends. I am glad to see that he has the same honesty, credibility and integrity that I well remember him for
LOL!!! What a joke. Hope you've got a nice cozy political position too!!
Bercow has no manners. I feel bad for this guy. Shame on his defenders
@@KingMacintosh2 I don't actually . I live in the Caribbean in a two-room apartment. But from your distasteful comment, I can only guess that you lick the buttocks of those same politicians, or perhaps did not have the benefit of education.
It looks like it was pretty standard mockery. Some people get a great deal of pleasure out of bullying other people. They replenish their internal energy with this.
Bully Bercow .. about time he had his comeuppance.
Mr Sinclair said the bullying included angry outbursts, obscene language and mimicry......this is not bullying!
@Open Paranormal one persons sensitivity being different to another's for political reasons that might have upended the changes that Bercow was trying to put through the house. Bullying can be at the whim of anyone to say to another that they are being picked on, but as this man was part of the Navy Im sure he was shouted out and heard expletives and did not think he was being bullied by his commanding officers.
Agreed, not bullying. That's called a rough day a work. But softies don't work, so...
Full respect for Mr Bercow, proper man. He doesn’t allow any rubbish from anyone
LESHeLI said the remain voter
Respect?? The mans an arsehole.
@@Rob-cy8xc if you're using "remain voter" as an insult, the joke's on you. Greetings from Germany.
Perhaps the way Bercow treats people is due to him not having succeeded as a parliamentarian. A frustrated journeyman, if you will. Now his peerage is out of the question can you imagine his anger?
Short man syndrome
Bercow has a charismatic facade, but beneath is clearly something nasty
I know. Masculinity, it burns. Please dear lord, please continue to make everything woman-like.
Like a smiling snake he is…
Sounds like Malcolm Tucker
What the heck! They left the comments ON!!
Come on!!! Angus was in the Navy and was bullied. That doesn't fly (swim in this case). In the Navy, your superior owns you. You see that in Captain Bligh, the archetypal Tory. Note that all Tories are terrible bullies. The bottom line is that if a bully crosses the line (puts you in mortal danger, example, threatens to keelhaul or hang or flog you), it is YOU or HIM. Then, you must set out to DESTROY him. Best way is to hire a Private Investigator. Once you have the dirt on him, pass it anonymously to his enemies. Make sure the police are involved too. Sneak some dirt to the media.
Cases like these go unreported for fear of revenge and humiliation
Some people leave if they feel like they not like the personally of their boss. Why did he stay?
Nice bit of victim blaming there.
Grow a spine. You're not at school.
Politics is quite like a schoolyard
Grow up mate. You’re not a superhero.
Isn't it incredible how spineless they are? Take bribes, signs an NDA (AT HIS OWN WILL) and then waits to team up and join in on a gang attack. And then you have people who back this behavior up.
Doesn't surprise me. Bercow always struck me as being so full of shit his eyes were brown, but he was the darling of the media and the house. The English always love self-regarding Harry Flashman types like Bercow. They can do no wrong. It seems to be a national trait amongst them.
The evil doctor from the movie 'the burbs' has come so far:,) I'm so proud of him!#sexybercow
he wouldnt last 1 minute in the actual military if he thinks this is bullying. I think this shows a case of someone expecting formalities and not getting it.
The accusations against Bercow are unbelievably petty. This guy is lucky he got any money. Bercow"s a soft touch.
Bercow got attacked by a bunch of whiny, wimpy WASPs, afraid of his ethnicity, masculinity and intelligence. How an account by a man who by his own admission took money could be taken seriously by anyone is laughable. Right at 0:00, the first frame of this video, I see those smug evil eyes. I wouldn't trust ol' blue-eyes with a 1000 foot pole.
Take a nap
I think he needs to give back the 86000 pounds now that hes broken the NDA though
Sorry Sir but you've encountered this sort of bullying in the service I'm sure and managed to deal with it assertively as taught to without the media, so are we supposed to feel sorry for yae for letting a wee toad treat you with such disrespect? Many veterans have come across such behaviour from bosses in civvy st who feel the need to dominate thinking that your military childhood means you are used to being shouted at or abused. If you keep your mouth shut to keep your position, and sign an NDA it says more about your command decision at the time than the wee man. I also wonder how much compensation your collegue has received having claimed PTSD for her experiences working in Westminster? Again, are we supposed to feel sorry for you? You serve MPs yet expect them to have the values and standards that we do? I thought leadership went beyond rank and included being the steady voice to step in when those with less experience make mistakes or adversely affect the welfare of your people?
Boy do I hope sissies like this never have to work for the equivalent of an American or Canadian employer, LOL...
I always thought Bercow was a good Speaker so these allegations are very unfortunate. He must be held to account and resign.
Wrong. A bunch of whiny, racist WASPs ganged up on a Jewish man using hearsay and cherrypicked "evidence". If you'd listen to his account, some admitted as such.
The speaker is the speaker, he can do no wrong by definition, thank you
JR R stupid comment
Okay but did anyone's gender get offended?
Let's not assume Angus' gender...
This little man is a Humphrey Appleby. "Boohoo, he hurt my feelings". Angus should have been fired for obstructing democracy.
Bercow!!! ......A jumped up biased little bully!!! Whoever would've thought it 🤣🤣
Notice the red book on the shelf over the interviewees right shoulder... 👀
The only thing Bercow is interested in is his self , power and wealth . its all so pathetic.
His ultra remain fans don’t care. I don’t like brexit one but but they are ridiculous. He’s a bully.
Sounds to me like this guy was incompetent and was jeopordising bercows ability to do his job. He was on the receiving end of angry frustration because he was not fulfilling the requirements of the role he was tasked to do and as a result the knock on effect is the speaker then has his abilities to carry out his duties diminished and his own reputation and integrity bought into question.
In short. He wasn't up to it. He shouldve resigned. Not waited to get wait untill he got pushed out.
taking 80k as a sweetener to smooth it over Is questionable , but to then go crying to the press about bullying, well, he should have some self respect to be honest.
That's three people who were inadequate wow bercow is fantastic at finding these poor staff. Congratulations Mr bercow at weeding out these very poor staff in your book!
BULLY BOY BERCOW ,ITS QUITE CLEAR JUST LOOKING AND LISTING TO BERCOW THATS HES A COMPLETE GOBBY BULLY,
I think it's clear that if you go back and look at Bercow's reputation in the 1990s, and then add on stories like this to what you saw in the House of Commons when he was speaker, he definitely had a nasty side to his personality..........he got a lot of good press for taking on the Tories and appearing fair as Speaker, but there was a nastier side to him as well.
This guy needs to stop wining and watch Dan Pena's videos on YT
Wow if only they acted then we might be out of the EU by now, ! How can one insignificant man hold so much power, has pretty much single handedly destroyed democracy in the UK sending UK politics in to melt down while doing so. Before remainers start, I voted remain, I also voted for democracy I was out voted by the leavers, I accept that vote and want to leave the EU ASAP, deal or no deal, believe me no deal is better than a bad deal, the EU are not going to give us anything other than a bad deal, it’s time to pull up our trousers, tighten our belts and get on with it, it’s time labour, Lib Dem’s and SNP accepted what the public want, to be honest give us another vote as many who I know voted remain now wish to leave just because of what has happened in the House of Commons. It’s all one big joke all the people holding the process up are crippling the UK far more than any no deal exit.
It's always flabbergasting as a German to read such words from British people whose government was one of the worst members of the EU ever. Always taking every advantage they could get, always shirking their obligations as members whenever they could. And then to complain about the EU "only providing shoddy deals". Whow. The sheer arrogance and self centered entitlement.... good fucking riddance. No rejoining efforts, please, the EU is better without Britain.
RN personnel are usually quite robust individuals. Having served in submarines throughout his career and for the complete term, it would be surprising if he was not telling the truth. Bercow is clearly a robust individual, demonstrates political bias and lacks neutrality. We have seen a disrespect towards people like Trump shows strong leanings towards the left. Regrettably he does not show the qualities that you would expect from his position.
The Civil Service and politicians have a culture of bullying. I rather suspect that this man is telling the truth. The fact that other members of Bercows team have had problems rather supports his statements.
Today David Leakey (a respected military man), who was Black Rod accused Mr Bercow of “intolerable” rudeness and “explosive” behaviour which left his subordinates terrified. www.thetimes.co.uk/article/bercow-unworthy-of-office-says-former-black-rod-david-leakey-kvkt7jvmq.
That is three of his staff who have now come forward with similar stories.
This clip demonstrates Bercows behaviour th-cam.com/video/UOZidiWwwz0/w-d-xo.html. He is very pompous.
Liar. Nobody could bully him. Really? What's your motive Sinclair??
He could get a job a the bbc he would love all them young men
Who is this foo ?
This mirrors what Blackrod General Lt Leakey said about Bercow. You only have to see how Bercow treated MPs during debates to realise this is most likely an accurate portrayal of Bercow. Thank God he didn’t get a peerage.
Bercow should be a comedian, not a Speaker. (Hey, he already has the ethnicity for it!)
And he has the "right" political views for comedy also..
Bercow likes controversy. He doesnt . He wants his dignity.