I just saw them in new orleans and I think he gave us everything he had. His voice was so powerful and it literally had me in a trance. So glad I got to see them at least once.
If the guitars were up a bit, it would make Maynard's job SO much easier. It's very difficult to stay in pitch as only BASS as a reference point for most people. Even Maynard, as great as he is.
@@Parrish_Muhoberac There is absolutely no way of knowing what Maynard's in ear mix was for this performance. The mix we're hearing is no indication of what he's working with. Great performance all the way around, he and the band are killing it.
@@ChadHuskey Yeah, definitely, Chad. I should have known, as I've been a sound engineer for 30 years. But I was actually coming to Maynard's defence, because asI mentioned, coming from 42 years of professional singing, it takes a lot of control to have a 5 octave range like Maynard does, and sing high As all the time without your voice breaking. Hope I didn't come across the wrong way.
Keep holding on, those thoughts have infected me for several long periods in my life. If you knew someone who verbalized those same thoughts about themselves, you would tell them they are believing lies, because all but the psychopaths can recognize the intrinsic worth in every human being. So you should never believe those lies about yourself either.
@@sideshowblob hey,the version live on Conan or jay Leno or letterman is way way better. He REALLY nails the vocal. Plus h Es wearing a white t shirt says "I love Brad Wilk"
@@Parrish_Muhoberac Still think Stone and Echo is better as a whole. Sure, Maynards vocals might be a bit better on the Tonight Show version but the whole band sounds unbelievable on the Stone and Echo version.
SO looking forward to hearing that scream in October at ATL Fox. (edit) and they didn't play it ... A great show despite sound problems with the guitars for the first few songs. Fantastic light work
I was mostly looking forward I The Outsider and By & Down when I saw them at Red Rocks and they didn't play either! Buuuuttt they pulled out a surprise performance of Judith where Maynard nailed the scream, and had 0 tech or vocal problems the entire show, so they more than made up for it
Has anyone here remembered he's like 55 years old? Also, high Ab notes are very hard to continuously sing throughout a whole set without ruining your voice. TOOL played in Sydney, Australia, recently.. They DIDN'T play 7empest! however, they DID play a very long version of "PART OF ME" from OPIATE EP... and he SCREAMED his lungs out through the whole thing. Then, next, they played "DESCENDING"...and through that 10 minute version of total manic screams, he sang Descending PERFECTLY... So, I'm hoping people will agree with this idea... Every Tool album sends a message. This one is just as unique as their others. So what is the point of SCREECHING, yelling, etc, when the message doesn't warrant it? It would equate to singing a death metal style of "Happy Birthday" to your 3 year old child. Also, hey, I've been a professional singer worldwide for 40 years. As SIMPLE as these melodies on Fear Inoculum may seem, believe me. IT ISN'T. Takes a lot of control.
the main trick is not to actually scream, but to learn how to immitate a scream at normal volume, then let the amps do the rest. Turn off the PA and you wouldn't be able to hear MJK's 'scream' from the other side of the stage. New vocalists who do not learn this early, tend to lose their voices a lot trying to actually scream through every gig. ;)
@@railgap Hi there, Railgap.. yes, you have a very good point. I've been a professional singer/guitar/bassist/drummer/producer for 30 years.. and you're totally right. Microphone distance, and having a pro engineer live is EXACTLY how it works. Chino Moreno from Deftones is a great example of what you said. Their first 2 albums he was really SCREAMING into a Shure Beta 87 and 58 mic. He went through surgery cos his vocal cords were Wrecked, Then went through some vocal coaching before doing the White Pony album, where his "Screams" became very controlled. Dont ask me how I know this, all I can say is it's TRUE, and you made a very good call in pointing it out. I do some insane controlled screaming that goes for 32 bars, it's online if you're interested in hearing it, crossed with Tuvan Throat Singing! Haha.. deftones cover!
@@railgap hey look up soundcloud "covering our asses" rocket skates.. its a cover. I do vocals.. lots of "controlled screaming" like you mentioned, but also "Tuvan Throat Singing" in the bridge (singing 3 notes at once), 16 bars without a breath.
@Jennifer Lee Hi Jennifer, I didn't mean that. I too, hardly talk unless necessary but for 30 years as soon as I am on stage, all these emotions come out in my voice. It shocks the people I know so well. I'm saying he's RESERVED until the RIGHT TIME! doesn't that make sense? I would never criticise Maynard, as he is responsible for being the musician I am today. And, I'm a very good one.
Jennifer Lee and it is an a solute MYRIAD of things to think about at once to be a professional performer. Trust me. I'd never criticiE Maynard. I was sticking up for him. Is like an idol to me. This is why having autism sucks. Can't find the words, and when I do ), it cokes across wrong way. Please read my responses. Maybe I got it right this time.
@@JuampiManuale but on the other hand i recommend you to watch Aftershock CA 2016... AMAZING. they got third eye as opening and he acreamed the shit out of it. Also they got sweat, Parabola and Jambi. All of them amazing. Justin fucking owned it
I knew of Tool for years but never really got into them. I heard APC first only a few months ago on a random Spotify playlist and haven't stopped listening since.
Cara, ele ja nao não é tão novo,e soltar um grito desses não é pra qualquer um. Qualquer um que não se cuida,ele sabe ter auto cuidado, ou seria apenas mais um vocal de rock velho e acabado.
Huge Maynard fan, but the comments are full of tonedeaf people. This was not a good performance at all. He was flat most of the song. Scream was good thouhgh.
A 50+ years old man singing such a difficult song is absolutely incredible!
I just saw them in new orleans and I think he gave us everything he had. His voice was so powerful and it literally had me in a trance. So glad I got to see them at least once.
@@Spagetti0101 I was there too! The whole band gave an amazing performance. I think that was the best Tool show I’ve seen!
This song is not difficult to sing lol
Ok, Maynard's vocals are incredible here. How clear and strong!
If the guitars were up a bit, it would make Maynard's job SO much easier. It's very difficult to stay in pitch as only BASS as a reference point for most people. Even Maynard, as great as he is.
@@Parrish_Muhoberac There is absolutely no way of knowing what Maynard's in ear mix was for this performance. The mix we're hearing is no indication of what he's working with. Great performance all the way around, he and the band are killing it.
@@ChadHuskey Yeah, definitely, Chad. I should have known, as I've been a sound engineer for 30 years. But I was actually coming to Maynard's defence, because asI mentioned, coming from 42 years of professional singing, it takes a lot of control to have a 5 octave range like Maynard does, and sing high As all the time without your voice breaking. Hope I didn't come across the wrong way.
@@Parrish_Muhoberac oh no worries! BTW, I looked at your channel. You have a great voice 👍
DISCO NECT AND SELF DE STRUCT
ONE BUL LET AT A TIME
WHATS YOUR RUSH NOW
EVERY ONE WILL HAVE HIS DAY TO DIE!!
Utter chills I love it
Honestly, anything Maynard touches turns to gold. The talent is astounding.
For someone who always has suicidal thoughts, this is one of the songs that help me pull away from it. Thanks, APC
Wishing you the best, I’ve been there and have had those feelings. Stay strong and keep moving forward.
Keep holding on, those thoughts have infected me for several long periods in my life. If you knew someone who verbalized those same thoughts about themselves, you would tell them they are believing lies, because all but the psychopaths can recognize the intrinsic worth in every human being. So you should never believe those lies about yourself either.
Holy shit he screamed omg now I'm even more excited to see him with tool at the epicenter festival
God Damn it it got rained out
Obviously this particular comment didn’t age too well...
@@anthonyloris2769 why?
MESSIAH completely stormed out and they left. No one got to see the last four bands perform.
The one they did in David Letterman where Maynard is wearing an "I LOVE BRAD WILK" t shirt is even better.
Who ever mic'd those drums is a hero. Well done who ever you are!!
im 68 years old...how can you not love this...
Ever see them live?
I am 63 and the next live concert is mine
Vocals are ON.POINT.
Pitch is flat for a lot of it. Great energy though.
People must be tone deaf to think its on point. Worst ive ever heard him.
His voice live has always been like on the albums of Tool and other bands, he's a great singer.
Best. Version. Ever
The stone and echo performance is better than this imo
@@sideshowblob nel Tonight version is better
@@sideshowblob hey,the version live on Conan or jay Leno or letterman is way way better. He REALLY nails the vocal. Plus h Es wearing a white t shirt says "I love Brad Wilk"
@@McLeonVP absolutely right!!!!
@@Parrish_Muhoberac Still think Stone and Echo is better as a whole. Sure, Maynards vocals might be a bit better on the Tonight Show version but the whole band sounds unbelievable on the Stone and Echo version.
Maynard incredible’s voice.
SO looking forward to hearing that scream in October at ATL Fox.
(edit) and they didn't play it ...
A great show despite sound problems with the guitars for the first few songs. Fantastic light work
I was mostly looking forward I The Outsider and By & Down when I saw them at Red Rocks and they didn't play either! Buuuuttt they pulled out a surprise performance of Judith where Maynard nailed the scream, and had 0 tech or vocal problems the entire show, so they more than made up for it
Demasiada genialidad en un solo espacio, la última súper band.
incredible performance. maynard is just unreal !
one if not the best rock song ever
Has anyone here remembered he's like 55 years old? Also, high Ab notes are very hard to continuously sing throughout a whole set without ruining your voice. TOOL played in Sydney, Australia, recently.. They DIDN'T play 7empest! however, they DID play a very long version of "PART OF ME" from OPIATE EP... and he SCREAMED his lungs out through the whole thing. Then, next, they played "DESCENDING"...and through that 10 minute version of total manic screams, he sang Descending PERFECTLY... So, I'm hoping people will agree with this idea... Every Tool album sends a message. This one is just as unique as their others. So what is the point of SCREECHING, yelling, etc, when the message doesn't warrant it? It would equate to singing a death metal style of "Happy Birthday" to your 3 year old child. Also, hey, I've been a professional singer worldwide for 40 years. As SIMPLE as these melodies on Fear Inoculum may seem, believe me. IT ISN'T. Takes a lot of control.
the main trick is not to actually scream, but to learn how to immitate a scream at normal volume, then let the amps do the rest. Turn off the PA and you wouldn't be able to hear MJK's 'scream' from the other side of the stage. New vocalists who do not learn this early, tend to lose their voices a lot trying to actually scream through every gig. ;)
@@railgap Hi there, Railgap.. yes, you have a very good point. I've been a professional singer/guitar/bassist/drummer/producer for 30 years.. and you're totally right. Microphone distance, and having a pro engineer live is EXACTLY how it works. Chino Moreno from Deftones is a great example of what you said. Their first 2 albums he was really SCREAMING into a Shure Beta 87 and 58 mic. He went through surgery cos his vocal cords were Wrecked, Then went through some vocal coaching before doing the White Pony album, where his "Screams" became very controlled. Dont ask me how I know this, all I can say is it's TRUE, and you made a very good call in pointing it out. I do some insane controlled screaming that goes for 32 bars, it's online if you're interested in hearing it, crossed with Tuvan Throat Singing! Haha.. deftones cover!
@@railgap hey look up soundcloud "covering our asses" rocket skates.. its a cover. I do vocals.. lots of "controlled screaming" like you mentioned, but also "Tuvan Throat Singing" in the bridge (singing 3 notes at once), 16 bars without a breath.
@Jennifer Lee Hi Jennifer, I didn't mean that. I too, hardly talk unless necessary but for 30 years as soon as I am on stage, all these emotions come out in my voice. It shocks the people I know so well. I'm saying he's RESERVED until the RIGHT TIME! doesn't that make sense? I would never criticise Maynard, as he is responsible for being the musician I am today. And, I'm a very good one.
Jennifer Lee and it is an a solute MYRIAD of things to think about at once to be a professional performer. Trust me. I'd never criticiE Maynard. I was sticking up for him. Is like an idol to me. This is why having autism sucks. Can't find the words, and when I do ), it cokes across wrong way. Please read my responses. Maybe I got it right this time.
This vocal performance is amazing!
The scream here rivals Stone and Echo! Hot damn!
Nah, stone and echo was higher and longer. This one is still a badass scream tho
@@JuampiManuale SaE scream was more technical and this was more feral. Both work wonderfully
Crazy I've been listening to this band since outsider was first made and now i am as old as maynard was when he made the song...
Kick ass rock music!!!
This maybe my favorite song ever
Zenda pieza !!! Haha pedazo e tema increíble.. grande..
What a great song...damn...
how is possible that this guy sounds better live than on the records.. very talanted
ドラム神ってる。
全員神ってるけど特に
so good
What does it take to get through to you precious!!!
Girl on 3:20,you best.спасиБо из России!
Everthing on point …the tempos hahhhhhhh 🤘🏾🤘🏾🤘🏾
no puedo creer con este temazo que sea un público tan pecho frio
Now i got salty bc here he screams perfectly but in tool not even a lil bit of screeeeech ;_;
I thought the same thing, but I guess that tool songs are harder and in apc or puscifer it's not really hard
@@JuampiManuale i guess but man the outsider pushes the boundaries of his vocal chords just like the pot or sweat
@@JuampiManuale but on the other hand i recommend you to watch Aftershock CA 2016... AMAZING. they got third eye as opening and he acreamed the shit out of it. Also they got sweat, Parabola and Jambi. All of them amazing. Justin fucking owned it
Always saw it as in APC most of the songs aren’t requiring him to scream while in Tool almost in every song he has to.
For real. This proves he could totally still do that scream in The Grudge, but for the last decade he's chosen not to
Dis nigga still got it
I wish I could be there
Resident Evil vibe here!
I noticed that resident evil version is quite different,
Holy shit he still sounds so good. I wish Manson still gave a shit.
Manson is trash
Half step back on vocal scream, nonetheless superbly executed!!! 😱😱😱😱😱
Maynard is the sh*t!
well and i missed rock am ring 2018 fuck
Is there anybody that was introduced to Tool through APC? Just wondering.
Me.. I don't care much about Tool, I like APC tho.
Aidan R I knew about Tool before APC but never enjoyed their music before listening to APC. Now I love both bands.
Other way around for me
I knew of Tool for years but never really got into them. I heard APC first only a few months ago on a random Spotify playlist and haven't stopped listening since.
other way around... with tool you experience...with apc you relate
How fukin good is that
Even better then the studio version
westworld
Kakav Isus.
Bizarre..MAYNARD bordering on ALICE COOPER 😂
Something wrong with the pitch.
lame audience
Got to agree here! Having seen Tool live this reaction from what I’ve experienced is weak!
impossible
I cant see his face..its all dark
that’s the point with james
3:20 he's becoming Super Saiyan. Maynard isn't God, he's Goku!
Love this band, but I wouldn’t pay to “see” them because you can’t. Might as well sing from backstage.
is this skrillex brother lol
Cara, ele ja nao não é tão novo,e soltar um grito desses não é pra qualquer um. Qualquer um que não se cuida,ele sabe ter auto cuidado, ou seria apenas mais um vocal de rock velho e acabado.
doesnt sound as good as in the recorded version.
No way Sherlock
crowds are so awful now days... these 20 year olds dont know what they are suppose to do. its sad hahaha
The old lineup was so much better. Eat the elephant sucked and their new lineup is ruining the old songs. Lame
Huge Maynard fan, but the comments are full of tonedeaf people. This was not a good performance at all. He was flat most of the song. Scream was good thouhgh.