This song was written by Billy Howerdel with Chester Bennington in mind as the singer. For 'reasons' it didn't get recorded and APC recorded it instead.
@@bluepvp900 no, that's false. The APC song that was supposed to be on a Linkin Park album is called 'Eat The Elephant', and it was written for One More Light (so, years after this performance)
Well, the song "Eat the Elephant" was co-written with Chester before his passing. It was originally going to be a Linkin Park song on "One More Light" but didn´t make the cut, so it was re-worked for the APC album.
th-cam.com/video/1RqZSENSNRs/w-d-xo.htmlsi=WAB0sKaFSBbW4Uez A lot of crown noise, but here's Chester when he was on his own, touring with ashes divide, which is. the guitar player for a perfect circle in the guitar tech for Adam Jones and Tool.
The song "Eat the Elephant" was co-written with Chester before his passing. It was originally going to be a Linkin Park song on "One More Light" but didn´t make the cut, so it was re-worked for the APC album.
Maynard's sense of ebbs and flows in music is second to none in the history of Rock music. That first verse of The Outsider is a fascinating example of it.
Oh my, as someone who used to listen to LP in my early teens and then to Apc/tool etc later in life, this really struck me. Can’t believe I haven’t seen this before. Thank you uploader! RIP Chester.
It's similar to enjoying the time with your current girlfriend, then awkwardly bumping into the previous one. But not only do they get along, they also wanna crank their decibels in your bedroom...Then invite you onstage
This breaks my heart Precious, you knew the song, knew the words, felt the pain, and chose the same, It's taking me all this time to get through the pain and say I miss you.
For everyone bitching and complaining about how "shitty" chester did. Stop and know he did it in his own way. Hes not supposed to be exactly like maynard so calm down. He did an excellent job of covering this.
I'm sorry....My favorite vocalist ever from my favorite band ever singing my favorite song from my favorite A Perfect Circle album in a cover that is not only amazing, but is insanely unique? I just came all over my keyboard. What the fuck can Chester NOT sing?
Feb 2024 and I'm just now seeing it so you beat me 😅 For whatever reason I never listened to much LP. I remember seeing them play OzFest after their first record and I just thought they would be a "one hit wonder". Then I dated a girl who was really into them but we were both in recovery and she started using again so I stopped seeing her. Gonna have to do a deep dive into their music soon. Not really sure where to start.
This is fucking AWESOME one of my favourite singers of all time covering a song by another one of my favourites maynard james keenan R.I.P. chester you are missed!!
This video gives me so many mixed emotions. #1 I had no idea one of my fav vocalist ever covered a song written by another fav vocalist ever of mine. #2 The dude is performing a song about suicide. #3 Their voices sound so similar. I swear to god Maynard sounds just like Chester Fear Innoculum... in the lines 'Immunity, long overdue, contagion, I exhale you". #4 Chester sounds like more powerful version of Maynard in this♥️♥️♥️ #5 I wish he was alive🥺😭🥺😭
Amo a MJK pero la performance de Chester es increible. A la altura de lo que fue, uno de los mejrores vocalistas e interpretes de la musica contemporanea. Te fuiste pero tu legado es invaluable. Siempre te vamos a extrañar.
Chester sounded great! The thing is, he was little off in some parts because it seems like he’s not familiar enough with the song which is totally fine, that’s why he kept looking back at the keyboard/backing vocalist for help and reference, he still did good!
i don't think anyone would argue that chester is a better vocalist than maynard, but he deserves the praise he gets....LP is one of my favorite bands, just behind Tool/APC and a couple others, and i think he did a great job with the song
Didn't know this happened. Always thought it would be cool to hear Chester cover something done by Maynard. They have very similar singing styles. He did pretty good here.. too bad his timing was off.
Um.. no. Not Maynard's. Billy Howerdel is the songwriter for APC. Ashes Divide is Billy's Band. I love Maynard more than most, but credit given where credit is due. Billy was probably honored to mix it up with Chester!
Usually Maynard does lyrics and Billy does music, but for Thirteenth Step Maynard took on a lot of the music songwriting as well. That said, it's still very much Billy's Baby
@XIIIBW many singers forget lyrics at times, so its not as bad as you make it out to be. stuff happens. watch the unedited version of alice in chains unplugged. poor layne staley mixed up the lyrics to sludge factory. no one dissed that performance.
Thank you. I'm usually critical of Chester being pitchy live, and thought it was him, but you're right about that (which I typed as he says "they were right about you", weird), and that scream towards the end blew Maynard's outta the mer.
I can't believe to see Chester sing an A Perfect Circle's song.
This song was written by Billy Howerdel with Chester Bennington in mind as the singer. For 'reasons' it didn't get recorded and APC recorded it instead.
I’m really surprised found this 2022
me too 😲😲
me too
😭🙏
@@bluepvp900 no, that's false.
The APC song that was supposed to be on a Linkin Park album is called 'Eat The Elephant', and it was written for One More Light (so, years after this performance)
One of my favorite vocalists covering a song originally sung by my absolutely favorite vocalists? Orgasm.
Hi
Absolutely
Correction! Not orgasm... EARGASm
Can't believe it took me 12 years to discover this.
13 years to me
14 for me
15 for me!
@@KayVee87same ..
TH-cam works in mysterious ways
It would have been great to see Maynard and Chester on the same stage. R.I.P... We still feel your existence.
Well, the song "Eat the Elephant" was co-written with Chester before his passing. It was originally going to be a Linkin Park song on "One More Light" but didn´t make the cut, so it was re-worked for the APC album.
th-cam.com/video/1RqZSENSNRs/w-d-xo.htmlsi=WAB0sKaFSBbW4Uez A lot of crown noise, but here's Chester when he was on his own, touring with ashes divide, which is. the guitar player for a perfect circle in the guitar tech for Adam Jones and Tool.
Crazy to hear Chester sing a song bout suicide. RIP man.
The song "Eat the Elephant" was co-written with Chester before his passing. It was originally going to be a Linkin Park song on "One More Light" but didn´t make the cut, so it was re-worked for the APC album.
Really ı never heard
Interesting. Not my favorite but it does fit with older lp stuff
Any evidence of this? Not saying it is not true but I've never heard anything about it and can't find any reference ever besides this comment.
@@RobotSnake You can Google Chester Bennington and Eat the Elephant, and you'll see the full story
what irony listen chester singing this song :(
Most people struggling internally are quite self aware of their mental circumstances. I'm sure the irony wasn't lost on Chester at the time
😭
Damn..
Had the same thought, he didn't just play this for fun, in hindsight, there were so many cries for help in his performances and lyrics, tragic :(
@@burieddeepbetween wouldn’t have been irony, but understanding that wasn’t lost on him.
If Maynard and Chester only have made a song together it would have been the best song in the world.
Well, I have Chester singing the outsider A lot of crowd noise. but still it's great. th-cam.com/video/1RqZSENSNRs/w-d-xo.htmlsi=WAB0sKaFSBbW4Uez
R.I.P Chester..
he sang that probably from the heart
like so many other songs.
i cant believe he is singing this song about how bad it is to commit suicide and a song that is mocking that act, yet he still did it...
this or Gravity, I wished he would have surrendered to the gravity and the unknown
@@Cymanytb He didn't want to be suicidal
Chris kept him from doing it much earlier. Then when Chris did it ,,, you know the rest
@@Cymanytb The song isn't mocking the act. It's more to show that the singer or the narrator is the ass hole.
This truly makes me realize how great maynard is. Chester is one of the greatest singers to ever live and this is a beast of a vocal test for him
Maynard's sense of ebbs and flows in music is second to none in the history of Rock music. That first verse of The Outsider is a fascinating example of it.
I just seen this 15 years later today. Hell yes ! Chester is freaking awesome !
I wasn’t aware of how well Chester could sing. He nailed it!
Oh my, as someone who used to listen to LP in my early teens and then to Apc/tool etc later in life, this really struck me. Can’t believe I haven’t seen this before. Thank you uploader! RIP Chester.
Same!
definitely this
It's similar to enjoying the time with your current girlfriend, then awkwardly bumping into the previous one. But not only do they get along, they also wanna crank their decibels in your bedroom...Then invite you onstage
This song is a cry for help. Pay attention to the lyrics.
@@BearArmsChannel Then you fail to understand what the true meaning is behind this song
He actually did an excellent job on this. Wasn't expecting this, but it is very true to the original.
Definitely discovered a gem on the internet finding this today.
This breaks my heart Precious, you knew the song, knew the words, felt the pain, and chose the same, It's taking me all this time to get through the pain and say I miss you.
I have reached Maynard thanks to this song. Now I am a big fan of him. Thank you Chester , awesome job in this one.
For everyone bitching and complaining about how "shitty" chester did. Stop and know he did it in his own way. Hes not supposed to be exactly like maynard so calm down. He did an excellent job of covering this.
He's pitchy in everything live he's done.
2:55 Chester era incrível.
I'm sorry....My favorite vocalist ever from my favorite band ever singing my favorite song from my favorite A Perfect Circle album in a cover that is not only amazing, but is insanely unique?
I just came all over my keyboard.
What the fuck can Chester NOT sing?
Holy shit. December 2022 and just stumbled across this. RIP Chester. 😥 This is so bad ass. 👍
Feb 2024 and I'm just now seeing it so you beat me 😅 For whatever reason I never listened to much LP. I remember seeing them play OzFest after their first record and I just thought they would be a "one hit wonder". Then I dated a girl who was really into them but we were both in recovery and she started using again so I stopped seeing her. Gonna have to do a deep dive into their music soon. Not really sure where to start.
This is fucking AWESOME one of my favourite singers of all time covering a song by another one of my favourites maynard james keenan R.I.P. chester you are missed!!
Can't believe it took me 15* years to discover this. I love it!
Me too! It came from Reddit.
omg i was love that song before watching it and i watch it, i am loving this song much more. chester can sing everysong o.O
Thank you for posting this! I had no idea Chester played with them, this song worked so well for his voice.
RIP my first ever musical influence.
Chester was so damn good. It's so sad he's gone.
Incredible!!!! Love Chester Bennington's voice!
Wow.... Just.... WOW. One of my favorite singers singing one of my favorite songs.
This video gives me so many mixed emotions.
#1 I had no idea one of my fav vocalist ever covered a song written by another fav vocalist ever of mine.
#2 The dude is performing a song about suicide.
#3 Their voices sound so similar. I swear to god Maynard sounds just like Chester Fear Innoculum... in the lines 'Immunity, long overdue, contagion, I exhale you".
#4 Chester sounds like more powerful version of Maynard in this♥️♥️♥️
#5 I wish he was alive🥺😭🥺😭
agree to all of the above. i had no idea too. it's haunting to see it now.
I saw this live in Kansas City it blew me away.
What an incredible Rockstar he was r.i.p
Goddamn, is there anything Chester couldn’t sing? I miss him.
Holy crap! This video is a gem!! 💎
I like Chester, awesome voice. He should have listened to this song!!
FYI…Billy Howerdel
“What Normal Was”
Released June 2022
Best off!! Thanks for all Chester, rest in peace.
I think I just found gold!
Amo a MJK pero la performance de Chester es increible. A la altura de lo que fue, uno de los mejrores vocalistas e interpretes de la musica contemporanea.
Te fuiste pero tu legado es invaluable. Siempre te vamos a extrañar.
Chester sounded great! The thing is, he was little off in some parts because it seems like he’s not familiar enough with the song which is totally fine, that’s why he kept looking back at the keyboard/backing vocalist for help and reference, he still did good!
Im watching the video from México..ashes divide one of the my favorites bands🤘🤘🤘
RIP Chester! You nailed it!🙏💪
Get it Billy!
That is billy so it's a perfect circle and Chester not
That’s cool
Chills through the whole song. Thanks OP
Great version of a great song
Cara hoje estou conhecendo essa versao com o Chester,realmente emocional e perfeita,poderiam ter feito outras versões juntos.
I love Billy Howerdel how He plays
Why am I just finding this now, lol, so good
i don't think anyone would argue that chester is a better vocalist than maynard, but he deserves the praise he gets....LP is one of my favorite bands, just behind Tool/APC and a couple others, and i think he did a great job with the song
amazing!
Ohhhh myyyy Goooood what did i just watch???????😮
God that was awesome
Wow the first time I have heard Chester sing in tune live.. Well done!!
OMG LOVEYOU CHESTERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
YOUR THE SICKNESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
Amazing voice !!
WOW
seeing this in 2022.. gold!
after 2.40 chester found himself and that was good.
I'M TAKING THIS. THANK YOU.
who said anything about chester trying to be like maynard? he put his own twist to it with his own vocals. sounds good to me
Yeah. Chester didn't need to be someone else. He could sing everything and been perfectly cool. I miss him.
F awesome. Greatest loss ever.
Didn't know this happened. Always thought it would be cool to hear Chester cover something done by Maynard. They have very similar singing styles. He did pretty good here.. too bad his timing was off.
Best cover ever!!!
Damn...... Awesome!!
my god this is music history
Brilliant!
I like your videos.
How am I just seeing this now
Wow holy shit, i've always wanted to see this happen! THANKS FOR POSTING!
esta de lujo
oh Chester.. what a shame.. I miss you bud
Lyrics rough , god miss you why couldn't you see you the way we did ? 😢
メイナードもいいけどチェスターもいいな。どっちが上手いとかじゃなくてもう好みの領域。
Que triste que haya olvidado las letras
Little would they know that this is now 3/5s of APC as it exists now
This is irony in its purest form
HOLY SHIT WHY I JUST CAME ACROSS THIS
Nailed it!!!!!!!!!
Chester
Um.. no. Not Maynard's. Billy Howerdel is the songwriter for APC. Ashes Divide is Billy's Band. I love Maynard more than most, but credit given where credit is due. Billy was probably honored to mix it up with Chester!
James Cheney they are both songwriters for apc. Not only Howerdel.
Usually Maynard does lyrics and Billy does music, but for Thirteenth Step Maynard took on a lot of the music songwriting as well. That said, it's still very much Billy's Baby
Didn’t know this existed!
I THANK Chester for introducing me to Maynard James Keenan.
I never knew Slenderman played the guitar?
that made me laugh so hard, thank you
Power combo: Ashes Divide doing APC with Chester Bennington. Rock is pleased.
@XIIIBW Totally!!, at 1.23 Chester is like "shut up dude! im the star here!"
Awesome
The Legend
Never a fan of linkin park or chester, but this is damn good!
Who didn't work with him ? He did a great job covering songs always did his best and sounded and looked cool doing it .
why y'all hating on Chester? He doesn't sound bad at all
john doe Lotta haters
john doe he’s certainly no Maynard...
Who wants him to be maynard? We have a maynard....I wish we still had a chester.
Because of the stupid teenager fans. Hate will lose stupids.
Never really listen to Linkin Park but Chester is definitely a better overall singer than Maynard
Strange song of choice rip chester
Chester could’ve misused this superpower to get away with doing bad things, but he never did. HE NEVER DID.
Best than original
Goddamn, he rocked it!
@XIIIBW many singers forget lyrics at times, so its not as bad as you make it out to be. stuff happens. watch the unedited version of alice in chains unplugged. poor layne staley mixed up the lyrics to sludge factory. no one dissed that performance.
Brutal!
Legend
Chester fricking Bennington covering Perfect fucking Circle ah!!!!!
Chester nailed it. The back up singer/keyboard player was a half step out most of the time.
Thank you. I'm usually critical of Chester being pitchy live, and thought it was him, but you're right about that (which I typed as he says "they were right about you", weird), and that scream towards the end blew Maynard's outta the mer.
I don't care who you are Maynard's vocals are hard to follow; No matter who you are.>
Does anyone have the audio of this song in high quality?