Ty for all your support, information and requests, we have right now a very long queue (7 months behind) and we get new request everyday, so don't worry we will take all request, but will take some time, if u want to support us and also skip the queue with 2 monthly request who skip all the queue we have a patreon, otherwise have a good day and again ty for all your amazing support: www.patreon.com/CelcaReact
This is the actual recording of the song. There was no auto tune then. When they sing this without instruments they sound exactly the same. They donated everything from this to a children's charity called Unicef. This was in the 70's and it was amazing to live through.
Barry, Robin and Maurice Gibbs are singing this song. Barry is using his stomach breathe to sing in that falsetto voice. Robin and Maurice are deceased now also their baby brother Andy. This song is so beautiful. Nice reaction
Thanks for your reaction! The BeeGees were: the tallest and oldest brother (with the big hair and beard), Barry Gibb, born September 1, 1946, the only surviving Gibb brother. Robin Gibb (with the long hair, no beard), born December 22, 1949-passed away May 20, 2012, and Robin's fraternal twin brother Maurice (the balding brother with the beard, pronounced "Morris") Gibb, born December 22, 1949-passed away January 12, 2003. They also had another, younger, brother Andy Gibb, born March 5, 1958-passed away March 10, 1988. The three oldest brothers were born on the Isle of Man (UK). Oldest brother Barry got seriously burned when he accidentally pulled boiling tea over himself at 18 months old. He was in coma for a while, nearly died and was in hospital for many months. Because of this, he did not learn to talk until after the twins were born. Later the family moved to Manchester and from there they emigrated to Australia in 1958, right after Andy was born. Their musical career, which they had started as little kids, didn't lead to international success so they moved back to the UK in 1966. Then they had a string of big hits, until they temporarily broke up around 1970 for 15 months. Started back up, looking for a new sound which they first found in 1974 with the transitional album "Mr. Natural". After that "Main Course" was the first album that moved them into a new direction: more rhythm&blues, dance music like with great hits like Nights on Broadway and Jive Talkin'. From 1976 on they went all out with falsetto driven dance music which lead to their biggest commercial success as they provided classic songs for the Saturday Night Fever Soundtrack (1977 Stayin' Alive, How Deep is Your Love, Night Fever amongst them). You should react to the 1979 live version of Stayin' Alive, too th-cam.com/video/7niXSh7vWRI/w-d-xo.html Other great songs to analyze: great album tracks from the 1979 Spirits Having Flown album, the title song: th-cam.com/video/WH_j90fCIk4/w-d-xo.html, the outrageously beautiful song Reaching Out th-cam.com/video/vfHUS5Mf00Q/w-d-xo.html. From their Still Waters album, Smoke and MIrrors: th-cam.com/video/MT9vRHSWNbk/w-d-xo.html. From the 1960's I've gotta get a message to you th-cam.com/video/CA4CInDnTk8/w-d-xo.html.
Probably the most successful band of the Disco Era. Also the Bee Gees have donated all the profits from this song to UNICEF. and as of 2022 has raised $11,000,000.00 for that charity.
They don't usually have an orchestra, but it was provided because this night was a charity event for UNICEF. Many bands sang and played and donated whatever they wanted to from the royalties. The Bee Gees gave this song's royalties completely to the charity forever. Also , this was in 1978 during their "Disco" years, with songs like "Staying Alive". But they have been making music since the 60's and have many more songs you should hear like , "Alone", which is from the 90's, after the disco era. Thanks for your review!
The middle guy is Sir Barry Gibb the most talented and successful songwriter and falsetto icon - who ever walked on this planet, 1035 tunes he composed with his brothers 36 #1 allover the world more than 220 million records in more than fifty years and 150 millions additional for other amazing artists, when you don`t know the Brothers Gibb, maybe you had lived under a stone 🔥😆
Their producer wanted a screem for their song Nights on broadway. Barry tried and his falsetto voice was born, He said in an interview that he was astonished by himself what there was coming from his mouth. He has a great vocal range, deep and strong, but also smooth, with vibrato and of course a perfect falsetto. He he uses it depending on the type of song they sing!
All the brothers had pitch perfect voices. They also didn't know how to read music yet wrote so many songs regardless, some even written in a matter of minutes. They always wrote the music first and then lyrics afterwards.
Thanks for this reaction. People don't understand it when I tell them how much I miss the 70's. Music like this was literally everywhere at the time. Songs were written like a personal love letter between two people- not like today when love songs are all about selfishness. There was a fun vibe to the whole decade that you had to experience to understand. I think the best thing about the 70's was the fact that the 80's were just around the corner... :)
The Bee Gees have about a thousand songs that they wrote. During the mid- to late- 70s they often sang in falsetto, but most of their songs are in natural voice and their natural voices are at least as beautiful and often even more so. You can hardly go wrong with any of their songs. "Nights On Broadway" starts with Barry's deep chest voice "To Love Somebody" is also great and features natural voices. "I Started a Joke" features Robin's voice.
Falsetto-voices of them. No others can compare at all. But only used under 10 % of their roundabout 1100 songs. To check out their chestvoices, go to songs like 'Words' (Barry), 'And The Sun Will Shine' (Robin) and 'On Time' (Maurice). Harmony-singin' in natural voices at it's best is to hear on 'Lonely Days' and 'Paradise'.
Please do more Bee Gees! Tragedy , New York Mining Disaster, Words , To Love Somebody, I Started A Joke. Ohhhh so many greats to choose from. A Day In The Life from Sgt Pepper!!!
Hello: I've just found you guys today and I enjoyed your reaction. It's good to hear your comments and to see that you have done a little digging yourselves about the group. I am an older Bee Gees fan and I would highly recommend that you check out their songs from 1967 to around 1975. In my opinion, that is when they were putting out their best music.
Fun Fact: Bee Gees' drummer left them in 1970 & formed his own band taking a lead singer from Smile (later known as Queen). That is when Freddie Mercury joined Brian May & Roger Taylor of Smile & changed their name to Queen. The rest is history.
You made a very good point mentioning Bohemian Rhapsody. This track included 27 vocal tracks: Barry on falsetto lead 3 times, falsetto high harmony 3 times, and falsetto low harmony 3 times; Barry on natural voice lead 3 times, high harmony 3 times, and low harmony 3 times; Barry, Robin and Maurice together on lead 3 times, It would be impossible for three singers to come off sounding like this without multiple tracks. I love this song and am in no way criticizing it. I love the result regardless of how they got there.
@Rayce Williams Great info there. I heard an interview with the sound man, who said that Barry once laid down 18 tracks and they were all pitch, note and rhythm perfect.
@Rayce Williams Wow! I have liked, watched and read about Bee Gees for decades but I have never heard about those numbers. May I ask where your facts are from?
@@danielkarlsson258 Karl Richerdson....one of the Bee Gees producers and one of Barry's closets friends. I think it's in the VH1 documentary on TH-cam....that Karl mentions that fact.
The amazing thing is: if you are going to record 27 vocal tracks - many of them unison parts, the pitch and timing had better be damn near perfect or, as in the case of these guys, absolutely perfect. If you want to know how perfect, listen to the last notes of the "waiting in line" and "harder to climb" lines. Their voices are not only pitch perfect, but their three vibratos pulse exactly in time with each other - not an easy thing to do. Particularly when the rhythm of the pulse is actually slowing down the longer the note is held. I'm a firm believer that you have to be siblings to sing this well together: Everly Bros., Beach Boys, Rankins etc. It is so unbelievably hard to do.
Very observant to say instruments were filler. It's especially true for many of Bee Gees songs. Harmonizing at its best and a great variety in songs. Words from 1968 and This is where I came in 2001. So hard to pick suggestions. Great job!
No Auto tune in them times just pure talent, originals 4 brothers but ANDY Gibb died from drug abuse aged 30,they always considered themselves first and foremost song writers before being vocalist, and have written many songs for different artists, Dolly Parton and kenny Rogers, Diana Ross, and many others, An amazing British artists great reaction thanks 🙏
Andy died from myocarditis when an infection affected his heart, not drug abuse. He had a problem, to be sure, but that's not what killed him. Bless his soul, it was just 5 days after his 30th birthday.
Thanx for your perception of their chamber they’re recording in. Also there are 3 guys surrounding one mic. I’m not sure but when Barry the soloist in the middle drops out I believe I still hear three part harmony a man’s high tenor a man’s lead and a man’s alto. I don’t know if I have the right inversion of the chords being sung. But they would have to govern when Barry’s voice was to be heard in the background and when he was singing with them in harmony. And besides that I may not have all the layering of vocals in the background that made them so full. A long time ago sound with sound was used in recording in studios. Then a country and western couple put there background vocals coming out of an amp turned on but the man from a switch on his guitar. That was the first live voices with voices, Then The Carpenters sister on the drums and singing and brother on the piano singing and the layered background vocals out the pa all of it mixed with harmony. But somewhere back then Phil specter messed with background vocals layering a lot of vocals and it was called the wall of sound. To me if the did have backup it was softer than the live vocals. All three of these guys were composers producers, sound engineers, musicians playing a variety of instruments. This recording was done earlier in history before Cher who used it first in her song Believe or her producer gave her the choice to keep it or take it off. But the marvel of The Bee Gees and all those instruments is they did not know music written on sheet music by notes. They knew music by ear. Many of the studio musicians and rock singers had a numbering system used to write the music buy ear.. 1 would be the tonic 1 would also be 4 beats if the song was 4/4 1 would also be the chord the notations or letters would be use like “m” for minor. Doing this number system if a key change was made the new key would be written but the numbers would be the same as the tonic would still be 1 the first position in the new key. When the first probe went on it’s mission out of the solar system music was put in it so if anybody found it music would be heard. Science got it out there but us I tagged along. The Bee Gees did all of that song with a ear for music and no sheet music.
I think you guys did great. You're just starting out. I'm sure you've played that song a few times this last year because of the vibes it gives you. Can you understand what it means about "To Much Heaven"... We basically don't get as much love as we used to. That's the feeling, at the time that they're singing, of the divide our country and our leaders were going through. Then there was Trump. 😅😅😅 He woke up the world with what's possible if you don't pay attention to your past. Fortunately, us Americans always wake up at the last minute, and save the Day. We make things dramatic. We're addicted to attention. Also congratulations on your journey into TH-cam. It's always interesting deciding what's next. You are past a year and past 3,000.🎉
@@CelcaReact They're mesmerizing or addicting; I'm not sure which. It's just so cool to have somebody feel that same feeling of LOVE; and they've felt they've touched it with their ears that went through their body and into their soul. For some people it was, "Welcome back.😎" For others it was, "Let me introduce myself...🤯"
Take a listen to “You Should Be Dancin’” live performance. They also do sing in their chest voices on some songs. I’ve heard it said that they wrote those more heartfelt songs TO women, rather than ABOUT women. Take a look at the HBO documentary on The Bee Gees. It’s excellent!
They most used the falsetto sound from 1975 to 1979. In 1975 they were making the album "Main Course" (Great album) and on this there is a song called "Nights On broadway". Their producer Arif Mardin asked if one of them could scream in tune and Barry said "I will give it a go" and this was the first time they found out they could sing like that. On the same album is a song called "Fanny (Be Tender With My Love), and on this they really play with the falsetto in the end. But before, from 1958 to 1974 and after from 1980 to 2001 they mostly used their normal voices. This song is from 1978 and was given to the fundraising concert "Music for Unicef: A Gift of Song" for the children of the world. This concert was initiated by The Bee Gees and the song has up til now raised more than 10M dollars to the cause. ABBA, Rod Stewart, Earth Wind & Fire, Olivia Newton John, John Denver, Kris Kristofferson and their little brother Andy Gibb was also part of this concert. Some artist gave the earnings for certain periode of time but The Bee Gees has given all earnings from the sung to the cause. The song can be found on their follow up album to "Saturday Night Fever" called "Spirits Having Flown" and this album only consists of Falsetto songs except the last song "Until" which is song by Barry close to his normal voice. As the last surviving Bee Gee Barry is still making music and his album "Greenfields" from 2021 reach number 1 at UK album charts.
They’re harmonizing is so perfect they sound like one person !! Check out their early stuff ! Words ! I started a joke ! Run to me ! Gotta get a message to you ! So many more
Barry is a very manly looking man, so it's easy to assume he had a very deep voice, but Maurice (the one on the right) had the deepest voice in the group. Barry's speaking voice was sort of mid-range, and smokey. But he actually had three singing voices, at least. this high falsetto, a smokey, mellow soft chest voice, and a very gravelly, meaty, almost rock and roll voice. Check out Nights on Broadway, Wind of Change, and Words to get a better taste of all that Barry could do.
Heck, I'll take Robin any day. We all have our faves. I loved Robin's looks too. He said he "knew I was ugly but I have a characterful face". I disagree with "ugly". His vibrato was inimitable.
Next BeeGees listen: "How Do You Mend A Broken Heart", and/or "How Deep Is Your Love"......(from the BeeGees; the Brothers, Gibb; Left, Robin Gibb; Middle, Barry Gibb; Right, Maurice Gibb. Maurice and Robin are twins. Barry is the oldest.)
A great reaction. The instrument that you're talking about is called a Double Bass. The Bee Gees are brothers, Barry (the lead singer here), Robin and Maurice (the one with the darker hair with the moustache and beard) Gibb, so Brothers Gibb = BGs. Please react to, 'How Deep is Your Love', 'You Should Be Dancing', 'Children of The World' by them.
Nights on Broadway way. Fanny be tender with my love.. tragedy.. you should be dancing all 4 brothers sing the younger brother was a solo singer Andy Gibb he passed a week after his 30 birthday from a heart infection I can't remember the name of the brother that sings high is the oldest and the only one still living the other brothers are twins Robin and Marie they all have songs they sing different parts on.
Bohemian Rhapsody was a famous composition by Queen not the Bee Gees. Yes they are all brothers. They all have unique and excellent voices. They are one of Gods gifts to mankind!! Barry is the only one still living!
The Bee Gees didn't always sing falsetto on their songs of which there are hundreds as well as having hits in every decade from the 60s forward they have also written for mega stars such as Barbara Striesand , Celine Dion ,Dolly Parton, Diana Ross. ECT . The lyrics of their songs are considered by a lot of their fans to be pure poetry to which I agree . I suggest you check out their hits from the 60s and move forward , you can't go wrong . You mentioned that your into Rock , might I suggest youlook into the American family band LILIAC a group of brothers and sisters who are taking the world by storm , you would be doing yourself and your subscribers a favour by reacting to them . New subscriber here .
How can any straight woman look at Barry, and not swoon? Barry (middle) oozes sex appeal. The Bee Gees aka Brother's Gibb. All real brothers: The brothers on the end are twins. L to R Robin, Barry, and Maurice. They sing perfect harmony together, yet, all stand out. That's a lot of singing together, which they've done since they were children. I Love the Bee Gees, this being my favorite song by them. When Barry, says, "Oh, you and me, girl." OMG! 🤸♀️ [Swoon] lol
Pls react to this 14yrs old girl named CHARILOU OF THE FRANZ RYTHM BAND RENDITION OF HER OWN COMPOSITION TITLED UNSPOKEN THOUGHT MORE POWER TO UR CHANNEL GUYS 🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭
The Bee Gees is one of the greatest singing group ever. They are brothers from Australia that became famous all over the world. Sorry but I tried to find out where the two of you from because usually many youtubers are from America but I observe that you two have accents that are European (non-English native speakers); I tried to find out where the name Celca originally from (google) but it is a generic female name and I saw what the guy is drinking, Amper Energy drink which is manufactured from Poland. So, I assume you two are Polish. Correct me if I am wrong. I am not stalking or anything. I am not a danger for the both of you but I am a new subscriber from the Philippines practicing my investigative skills everywhere I could. Plus I have been to Warsaw, Poland for more than 2 weeks and I love the place. More power for the two of you and good luck.
Sorry to burst your bubble but The Bee Gees are not from Australia there from the uk 🇬🇧 also there mum and dad and younger brother Andy were born in Manchester England 🏴 only did they move to Australia 🇦🇺 same with Olivia newton John born in London England
Ja, dette blev optaget live, og ekstra numre blev tilføjet senere til singlen, der skulle udgives. Barrys vokal er også live - for eksempel kl. 7.41 synger Barry "and the tears we had to cry" - ordet "cry" er afkortet, fordi han skal trække vejret ind til næste sætning. I optagestudiet behøver du ikke klippe et ord kort. Et andet stort hit, som de synger med normal stemme, er 'How Deep is Your Love'
![Couple First Reaction To - Bee Gees - Tragedy [Live]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/oJVcUuO4f-c/mqdefault.jpg)
![Couple First Reaction To - Bee Gees - Tragedy [Live]](/img/tr.png)
![Couple First Reaction To - Angelina Jordan: Suspicious Minds [Elvis Presley Cover]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/P4sV0k-cMDc/mqdefault.jpg)
Ty for all your support, information and requests, we have right now a very long queue (7 months behind) and we get new request everyday, so don't worry we will take all request, but will take some time, if u want to support us and also skip the queue with 2 monthly request who skip all the queue we have a patreon, otherwise have a good day and again ty for all your amazing support: www.patreon.com/CelcaReact
This is the actual recording of the song. There was no auto tune then. When they sing this without instruments they sound exactly the same. They donated everything from this to a children's charity called Unicef. This was in the 70's and it was amazing to live through.
Greatest trio ever assembled in music history
Barry, Robin and Maurice Gibbs are singing this song. Barry is using his stomach breathe to sing in that falsetto voice. Robin and Maurice are deceased now also their baby brother Andy. This song is so beautiful. Nice reaction
I would say that the song is about the struggle to find, have and constant struggle to keep love in a relationship through life.
It’s their real voices they were recording. They didn’t have all that stuff to fix your voices back then. All natural voices
bee gees love you inside out
I believe the orchestra is the German Philharmonic...great harmonies, beautiful voices.
Wind of Change / Nights on Broadway / How Deep is Your Love / Tragedy / For Whom the Bell Tolls
Thanks for your reaction! The BeeGees were: the tallest and oldest brother (with the big hair and beard), Barry Gibb, born September 1, 1946, the only surviving Gibb brother. Robin Gibb (with the long hair, no beard), born December 22, 1949-passed away May 20, 2012, and Robin's fraternal twin brother Maurice (the balding brother with the beard, pronounced "Morris") Gibb, born December 22, 1949-passed away January 12, 2003. They also had another, younger, brother Andy Gibb, born March 5, 1958-passed away March 10, 1988. The three oldest brothers were born on the Isle of Man (UK). Oldest brother Barry got seriously burned when he accidentally pulled boiling tea over himself at 18 months old. He was in coma for a while, nearly died and was in hospital for many months. Because of this, he did not learn to talk until after the twins were born. Later the family moved to Manchester and from there they emigrated to Australia in 1958, right after Andy was born. Their musical career, which they had started as little kids, didn't lead to international success so they moved back to the UK in 1966. Then they had a string of big hits, until they temporarily broke up around 1970 for 15 months. Started back up, looking for a new sound which they first found in 1974 with the transitional album "Mr. Natural". After that "Main Course" was the first album that moved them into a new direction: more rhythm&blues, dance music like with great hits like Nights on Broadway and Jive Talkin'. From 1976 on they went all out with falsetto driven dance music which lead to their biggest commercial success as they provided classic songs for the Saturday Night Fever Soundtrack (1977 Stayin' Alive, How Deep is Your Love, Night Fever amongst them). You should react to the 1979 live version of Stayin' Alive, too th-cam.com/video/7niXSh7vWRI/w-d-xo.html Other great songs to analyze: great album tracks from the 1979 Spirits Having Flown album, the title song: th-cam.com/video/WH_j90fCIk4/w-d-xo.html, the outrageously beautiful song Reaching Out th-cam.com/video/vfHUS5Mf00Q/w-d-xo.html. From their Still Waters album, Smoke and MIrrors: th-cam.com/video/MT9vRHSWNbk/w-d-xo.html. From the 1960's I've gotta get a message to you th-cam.com/video/CA4CInDnTk8/w-d-xo.html.
Thanks for the information; really thought they were originally from Manchester all along.
Probably the most successful band of the Disco Era. Also the Bee Gees have donated all the profits from this song to UNICEF. and as of 2022 has raised $11,000,000.00 for that charity.
Their range, harmony and song writing skills are second to none. The Brothers Brilliant never disappoint!
Keep up the great & honest reactions....as lots of Bee Gees fans out here👍!!
They don't usually have an orchestra, but it was provided because this night was a charity event for UNICEF. Many bands sang and played and donated whatever they wanted to from the royalties. The Bee Gees gave this song's royalties completely to the charity forever.
Also , this was in 1978 during their "Disco" years, with songs like "Staying Alive". But they have been making music since the 60's and have many more songs you should hear like , "Alone", which is from the 90's, after the disco era.
Thanks for your review!
This is a great Song to react to. The Bee Gees donated this Song to Charity[
Beautiful , like them , their music will live forever, just like them. Listen to them every single day x
The middle guy is Sir Barry Gibb the most talented and successful songwriter and falsetto icon - who ever walked on this planet, 1035 tunes he composed with his brothers 36 #1 allover the world more than 220 million records in more than fifty years and 150 millions additional for other amazing artists, when you don`t know the Brothers Gibb, maybe you had lived under a stone 🔥😆
ty for sharing ya maybe we had, could also be our young age idk, we TRUELY are mindblow by them so far! :)
@@CelcaReact Truly, your knowledge and command of English are truly impressive!
Next should be "How deep is your love" and then "You should be dancing"
Goosebumps ever time I hear the fabulous three ♥️
Their producer wanted a screem for their song Nights on broadway. Barry tried and his falsetto voice was born, He said in an interview that he was astonished by himself what there was coming from his mouth. He has a great vocal range, deep and strong, but also smooth, with vibrato and of course a perfect falsetto. He he uses it depending on the type of song they sing!
All the brothers had pitch perfect voices. They also didn't know how to read music yet wrote so many songs regardless, some even written in a matter of minutes. They always wrote the music first and then lyrics afterwards.
Only way to describe their harmonizing is perfection !!!
Great presentation, thank you.
listen to me ....and believe me....nobody is better than them....no one....they are gods of music, and without supporter of media (like other bands) .
IT'S PURE SOUL MUSIC
Great review! God Bless you both!
If you listen to their 60s songs. You will hear their regular voices. So beautiful. They got into disco music in the70s. I suggest "To Love Somebody".
Thanks for this reaction. People don't understand it when I tell them how much I miss the 70's. Music like this was literally everywhere at the time. Songs were written like a personal love letter between two people- not like today when love songs are all about selfishness. There was a fun vibe to the whole decade that you had to experience to understand.
I think the best thing about the 70's was the fact that the 80's were just around the corner... :)
The Bee Gees are legends - do react to more of their music
The Bee Gees have about a thousand songs that they wrote. During the mid- to late- 70s they often sang in falsetto, but most of their songs are in natural voice and their natural voices are at least as beautiful and often even more so. You can hardly go wrong with any of their songs. "Nights On Broadway" starts with Barry's deep chest voice "To Love Somebody" is also great and features natural voices. "I Started a Joke" features Robin's voice.
Love your Honest Reactions
Falsetto-voices of them. No others can compare at all. But only used under 10 % of their roundabout 1100 songs. To check out their chestvoices, go to songs like 'Words' (Barry), 'And The Sun Will Shine' (Robin) and 'On Time' (Maurice). Harmony-singin' in natural voices at it's best is to hear on 'Lonely Days' and 'Paradise'.
Yes it real and done in One Take. Amazing.
I own one of their greatest hits CD's, 1969.
They wrote this song in one afternoon...and donated all rights and royalties to charity!
Please do more Bee Gees! Tragedy , New York Mining Disaster, Words , To Love Somebody, I Started A Joke. Ohhhh so many greats to choose from. A Day In The Life from Sgt Pepper!!!
You are the only reaction that caught the change in the key and the 2 Brothers voices are just as powerful.
I love watching young adults reacting and learning music that I grew up on...
Wake up! this song is a masterpiece!
pop ballad. They were experts at the pop ballad
You have thousands of songs to react to, from The Bee Gees and the many songs from many artists who sang their songs. Enjoy them all!!
It was before you were born..
they wrote tragedy and too much heaven in the same afternoon
And wrote shadow dancing in that evening!
Three men singing creating one voice
Hello: I've just found you guys today and I enjoyed your reaction. It's good to hear your comments and to see that you have done a little digging yourselves about the group. I am an older Bee Gees fan and I would highly recommend that you check out their songs from 1967 to around 1975. In my opinion, that is when they were putting out their best music.
Fun Fact: Bee Gees' drummer left them in 1970 & formed his own band taking a lead singer from Smile (later known as Queen). That is when Freddie Mercury joined Brian May & Roger Taylor of Smile & changed their name to Queen. The rest is history.
You can hear Barry's natural voice in interviews...
You made a very good point mentioning Bohemian Rhapsody. This track included 27 vocal tracks: Barry on falsetto lead 3 times, falsetto high harmony 3 times, and falsetto low harmony 3 times; Barry on natural voice lead 3 times, high harmony 3 times, and low harmony 3 times; Barry, Robin and Maurice together on lead 3 times, It would be impossible for three singers to come off sounding like this without multiple tracks. I love this song and am in no way criticizing it. I love the result regardless of how they got there.
@Rayce Williams Great info there. I heard an interview with the sound man, who said that Barry once laid down 18 tracks and they were all pitch, note and rhythm perfect.
@Rayce Williams Wow! I have liked, watched and read about Bee Gees for decades but I have never heard about those numbers. May I ask where your facts are from?
@@danielkarlsson258 Karl Richerdson....one of the Bee Gees producers and one of Barry's closets friends. I think it's in the VH1 documentary on TH-cam....that Karl mentions that fact.
This was made before auto tune was even invented. It’s all them - bravo Bee Gees.
The amazing thing is: if you are going to record 27 vocal tracks - many of them unison parts, the pitch and timing had better be damn near perfect or, as in the case of these guys, absolutely perfect. If you want to know how perfect, listen to the last notes of the "waiting in line" and "harder to climb" lines. Their voices are not only pitch perfect, but their three vibratos pulse exactly in time with each other - not an easy thing to do. Particularly when the rhythm of the pulse is actually slowing down the longer the note is held. I'm a firm believer that you have to be siblings to sing this well together: Everly Bros., Beach Boys, Rankins etc. It is so unbelievably hard to do.
Very observant to say instruments were filler. It's especially true for many of Bee Gees songs. Harmonizing at its best and a great variety in songs. Words from 1968 and This is where I came in 2001. So hard to pick suggestions. Great job!
Great Reaction and Good Luck as you cut down on the analysis DURING the song. Always try to let it flow, my friends...
No Auto tune in them times just pure talent, originals 4 brothers but ANDY Gibb died from drug abuse aged 30,they always considered themselves first and foremost song writers before being vocalist, and have written many songs for different artists, Dolly Parton and kenny Rogers, Diana Ross, and many others, An amazing British artists great reaction thanks 🙏
Andy died from myocarditis when an infection affected his heart, not drug abuse. He had a problem, to be sure, but that's not what killed him. Bless his soul, it was just 5 days after his 30th birthday.
Please react to HOW DEEP IS YOUR LOVE BY THE BEEGEES THANKS
bons commentaires de monsieur, à priori impressionné par la prestation. madame ?!...
Thanx for your perception of their chamber they’re recording in. Also there are 3 guys surrounding one mic. I’m not sure but when Barry the soloist in the middle drops out I believe I still hear three part harmony a man’s high tenor a man’s lead and a man’s alto. I don’t know if I have the right inversion of the chords being sung. But they would have to govern when Barry’s voice was to be heard in the background and when he was singing with them in harmony. And besides that I may not have all the layering of vocals in the background that made them so full. A long time ago sound with sound was used in recording in studios. Then a country and western couple put there background vocals coming out of an amp turned on but the man from a switch on his guitar. That was the first live voices with voices, Then The Carpenters sister on the drums and singing and brother on the piano singing and the layered background vocals out the pa all of it mixed with harmony. But somewhere back then Phil specter messed with background vocals layering a lot of vocals and it was called the wall of sound. To me if the did have backup it was softer than the live vocals. All three of these guys were composers producers, sound engineers, musicians playing a variety of instruments. This recording was done earlier in history before Cher who used it first in her song Believe or her producer gave her the choice to keep it or take it off. But the marvel of The Bee Gees and all those instruments is they did not know music written on sheet music by notes. They knew music by ear. Many of the studio musicians and rock singers had a numbering system used to write the music buy ear.. 1 would be the tonic 1 would also be 4 beats if the song was 4/4 1 would also be the chord the notations or letters would be use like “m” for minor. Doing this number system if a key change was made the new key would be written but the numbers would be the same as the tonic would still be 1 the first position in the new key. When the first probe went on it’s mission out of the solar system music was put in it so if anybody found it music would be heard. Science got it out there but us I tagged along. The Bee Gees did all of that song with a ear for music and no sheet music.
It's nice to witness a masterpiece, isn't it?
They donated the profits from this song to UNICEF, reported to be 11 million dollars
Great ballad🎶
Thank you guys for sharing this music with us. Check out "How Deep is You're Love" by The Bee Gees !!!
You dont know what you are talking about. They recorded live . They have God given. Talent with out todays gimmicks.
Queen love of my life & ABBA dancing queen
Thank you for the like have a nice day
This IS a live recorded track . No auto tune , recorded in either 1978 or 1979. Las Vegas show for UNICEF.super!!
Try Wind of Change, live or studio version. Please!!!
I think you guys did great. You're just starting out. I'm sure you've played that song a few times this last year because of the vibes it gives you. Can you understand what it means about "To Much Heaven"... We basically don't get as much love as we used to. That's the feeling, at the time that they're singing, of the divide our country and our leaders were going through.
Then there was Trump. 😅😅😅
He woke up the world with what's possible if you don't pay attention to your past.
Fortunately, us Americans always wake up at the last minute, and save the Day. We make things dramatic. We're addicted to attention.
Also congratulations on your journey into TH-cam. It's always interesting deciding what's next. You are past a year and past 3,000.🎉
@@RockPowerUSA ty, yes we have re watched this song and also the other songs we reacted to. Bee Gees are really interesting to be honest. Ty
@@CelcaReact They're mesmerizing or addicting; I'm not sure which. It's just so cool to have somebody feel that same feeling of LOVE; and they've felt they've touched it with their ears that went through their body and into their soul. For some people it was,
"Welcome back.😎"
For others it was,
"Let me introduce myself...🤯"
Take a listen to “You Should Be Dancin’” live performance. They also do sing in their chest voices on some songs. I’ve heard it said that they wrote those more heartfelt songs TO women, rather than ABOUT women. Take a look at the HBO documentary on The Bee Gees. It’s excellent!
You should listen to 'Night Fever' by them - it's AWESOME! Even their video for the song is cool...
They most used the falsetto sound from 1975 to 1979. In 1975 they were making the album "Main Course" (Great album) and on this there is a song called "Nights On broadway". Their producer Arif Mardin asked if one of them could scream in tune and Barry said "I will give it a go" and this was the first time they found out they could sing like that. On the same album is a song called "Fanny (Be Tender With My Love), and on this they really play with the falsetto in the end.
But before, from 1958 to 1974 and after from 1980 to 2001 they mostly used their normal voices.
This song is from 1978 and was given to the fundraising concert "Music for Unicef: A Gift of Song" for the children of the world. This concert was initiated by The Bee Gees and the song has up til now raised more than 10M dollars to the cause. ABBA, Rod Stewart, Earth Wind & Fire, Olivia Newton John, John Denver, Kris Kristofferson and their little brother Andy Gibb was also part of this concert.
Some artist gave the earnings for certain periode of time but The Bee Gees has given all earnings from the sung to the cause.
The song can be found on their follow up album to "Saturday Night Fever" called "Spirits Having Flown" and this album only consists of Falsetto songs except the last song "Until" which is song by Barry close to his normal voice.
As the last surviving Bee Gee Barry is still making music and his album "Greenfields" from 2021 reach number 1 at UK album charts.
They’re harmonizing is so perfect they sound like one person !! Check out their early stuff ! Words ! I started a joke ! Run to me ! Gotta get a message to you ! So many more
Oh my lord,. You two need to let yourselfs go.. it's as if your watching paint dry,. These guys, bee gees. Are so incredible.
Barry is a very manly looking man, so it's easy to assume he had a very deep voice, but Maurice (the one on the right) had the deepest voice in the group. Barry's speaking voice was sort of mid-range, and smokey. But he actually had three singing voices, at least. this high falsetto, a smokey, mellow soft chest voice, and a very gravelly, meaty, almost rock and roll voice. Check out Nights on Broadway, Wind of Change, and Words to get a better taste of all that Barry could do.
Heck, I'll take Robin any day. We all have our faves. I loved Robin's looks too. He said he "knew I was ugly but I have a characterful face". I disagree with "ugly". His vibrato was inimitable.
When music was real music with talent and love......first they sing "normal" and later on with the high tones.....
Listen to:
TRADEGY
STAYING ALIVE
Next BeeGees listen: "How Do You Mend A Broken Heart", and/or "How Deep Is Your Love"......(from the BeeGees; the Brothers, Gibb; Left, Robin Gibb; Middle, Barry Gibb; Right, Maurice Gibb. Maurice and Robin are twins. Barry is the oldest.)
A great reaction. The instrument that you're talking about is called a Double Bass. The Bee Gees are brothers, Barry (the lead singer here), Robin and Maurice (the one with the darker hair with the moustache and beard) Gibb, so Brothers Gibb = BGs. Please react to, 'How Deep is Your Love', 'You Should Be Dancing', 'Children of The World' by them.
EMERGENCY...HELLO FROM CROATIA ❤️
Nights on Broadway way. Fanny be tender with my love.. tragedy.. you should be dancing all 4 brothers sing the younger brother was a solo singer Andy Gibb he passed a week after his 30 birthday from a heart infection I can't remember the name of the brother that sings high is the oldest and the only one still living the other brothers are twins Robin and Marie they all have songs they sing different parts on.
you must listen to Dimash SOS 2021. you will be suprise ,,,,,,,
Bohemian Rhapsody was a famous composition by Queen not the Bee Gees. Yes they are all brothers. They all have unique and excellent voices. They are one of Gods gifts to mankind!! Barry is the only one still living!
Wake up you two ( interesting, different) they are superb, no one can touch them, read about their music please !
This is Disco music.But yeah it's Rock.
I call it GOOD music.
❤😂❤😮❤😊❤😅
👏👏👍
The Bee Gees didn't always sing falsetto on their songs of which there are hundreds as well as having hits in every decade from the 60s forward they have also written for mega stars such as Barbara Striesand , Celine Dion ,Dolly Parton, Diana Ross. ECT . The lyrics of their songs are considered by a lot of their fans to be pure poetry to which I agree . I suggest you check out their hits from the 60s and move forward , you can't go wrong . You mentioned that your into Rock , might I suggest youlook into the American family band LILIAC a group of brothers and sisters who are taking the world by storm , you would be doing yourself and your subscribers a favour by reacting to them . New subscriber here .
You better check her for a pulse. She may be dead.
How can any straight woman look at Barry, and not swoon? Barry (middle) oozes sex appeal. The Bee Gees aka Brother's Gibb.
All real brothers: The brothers on the end are twins. L to R Robin, Barry, and Maurice.
They sing perfect harmony together, yet, all stand out. That's a lot of singing together, which they've done since they were children.
I Love the Bee Gees, this being my favorite song by them. When Barry, says, "Oh, you and me, girl."
OMG! 🤸♀️
[Swoon] lol
Pls react to this 14yrs old girl named CHARILOU OF THE FRANZ RYTHM BAND RENDITION OF HER OWN COMPOSITION TITLED UNSPOKEN THOUGHT MORE POWER TO UR CHANNEL GUYS 🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭
The Bee Gees is one of the greatest singing group ever. They are brothers from Australia that became famous all over the world. Sorry but I tried to find out where the two of you from because usually many youtubers are from America but I observe that you two have accents that are European (non-English native speakers); I tried to find out where the name Celca originally from (google) but it is a generic female name and I saw what the guy is drinking, Amper Energy drink which is manufactured from Poland. So, I assume you two are Polish. Correct me if I am wrong. I am not stalking or anything. I am not a danger for the both of you but I am a new subscriber from the Philippines practicing my investigative skills everywhere I could. Plus I have been to Warsaw, Poland for more than 2 weeks and I love the place. More power for the two of you and good luck.
Denmark
Sorry to burst your bubble but The Bee Gees are not from Australia there from the uk 🇬🇧 also there mum and dad and younger brother Andy were born in Manchester England 🏴 only did they move to Australia 🇦🇺 same with Olivia newton John born in London England
Ja, dette blev optaget live, og ekstra numre blev tilføjet senere til singlen, der skulle udgives. Barrys vokal er også live - for eksempel kl. 7.41 synger Barry "and the tears we had to cry" - ordet "cry" er afkortet, fordi han skal trække vejret ind til næste sætning. I optagestudiet behøver du ikke klippe et ord kort. Et andet stort hit, som de synger med normal stemme, er 'How Deep is Your Love'
Live track 1978
Are these two alive? How can you listen to this song with no reaction?
She needs to express more.
Hi Ya'll Love the Honest Reactions, could you Please check out Billy Lord "ENDLESSLY" BEAUTIFUL Song for those who Love each other THANK YOU
Its called a falsetto
The big bass is a double bass
ty ya thats right
Can you please react to
You win again by the Bee gees
Please
Could you Please React to Billy Lord "SECTION 318" TY
Can you please react to
The shade by Metric
Please
Zero reacts.....kkkkk....só bad......u are so cold
He seems to be enjoying this romantic song, but whats wrong with her!
Do you have any idea who that is!¡
Wake up!