Rewatching this and when Morgan Night is testifying AH is hot pissed. She didn't think anyone would show up to refute her story of that night and she is big mad that he is there.
Emily, I just won my jury trial with a very difficult client!!! To be honest, I learned a lot from just watching this trial and your comments. My objections during the trial were on point! Thanks to AH attnys what-not-to-do performance!
1,043,075 views. There’s a reason why we’re all listening on Emily’s channel. It’s nice to have an attorney that talks to us laymen in terms that we can understand and comprehend. Thank you Emily. 🙏🏻🥰❤
Thank you Elaine for reminding us she pledged 3.5 million. The problem is she lied IN PUBLIC saying she paid already in interview to dutch TV and to the U.K. court as well. I sent a check to the Children's Hospital in Johnny Depp's name.
@@thatsclassicher1149 plus that heavily influenced the judgement in her favor during the UK trial. The judge ignored all of Johnnys evidence and even stated his decision was based on that “donating 7 million dollars, is not the actions of a gold digger”. He basically made up his mind from her lies about her donating her entire divorce settlement! I wish Johnny could go back and appeal that judgement even further because it was won based on lies and bias.
JD paid $100K to each to the ACLU and LA Children Hospital. The just over $1million paid to the ACLU in AH's name was 100% paid by ELON. AH has not given ANY money to the charities.
Yeah she was really mean and it didn’t seem needed. He is just a normal guy. I get she needs to do her job but she doesn’t have to be rude. Also, I bet the jury liked him so being rude wouldn’t look good.
Elaine did Amber NO FAVORS by her behavior toward Mr. Knight. However, we see this again, and again, from Amber's side. Amber AND her attorneys are extremely demeaning & rude. It's a bad look and it WILL hurt them with the jury, no doubt.
Dr. Shaw is really pleasant to listen to and a breath of fresh air in this trial. His demeanor is respectful, responsible and direct. No stupid flippant exclamation, no digs at anyone, just candid and insightful. He really engaged me and I learned a few new things too. Fabulous witness. 😊👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Coherent and concise is what Depp's team have brought forward with their witnesses. Convoluted , contradicted AND confrontational is all I've taken from Heards team.
This is also what I have observed. It is striking to me how arrogant Heard’s psy eval witnesses had been. Polar opposite of team Depp’s who are calm and collected with affable demeanor-and clearly knows their stuff.
Exactly & these Experts have bulldozed thru for Elaine's wins prior, probably pre-trial settlements! Has anyone Ever Taken Time to Count the Times Heard's tale has been contradicted so much as to count as a big fat lie? This is one for sure!
@@w.t.1338 Absolutely Shows how Elaine has a "good" reputation; she's earned it with these Experts & more in her pocket. I bet future Attorneys up against her from now on come down hard on her "Experts". Because it seems they are paid to write Exactly the BS Elaine needs, factual or not backed up with facts (Speigel), to write reports that say what she wants/needs. Her Experts never expected to be cross examined. They never expected to be Questioned about their reports/findings. Lord it's so obvious They Never Expected to Face Depp's Attorneys In Court. probably told it would settle or be dropped.
I always find it so strange how these lawyers have no idea what Twitter is or how a tweet works. She was acting like Tweeting a reply at someone is like meeting them for a coffee and then having a discussion then becoming lifelong friends.
I have a medically fragile child, and diagnosed PTSD. When I heard this man speaking about people like me, I choked up mostly because I felt heard, seen, understood but also because our trauma was brought up in the "typical world" and not just in the special needs community. Thank you so much sir for all you do for families like mine.
Same. I remember when I was listening to Mayim Bialik's podcast about the difference between trauma and PTSD, and I was like, "holy crap, I have PTSD. I need to talk to someone about this." I had absolutely no idea whatsoever. And when someone, a real person in my regular life, inadvertently revealed to me that I had PTSD, it shattered me. I was so grateful that there was an ANSWER. And ever since then, when people talk about it I get choked up because it makes me feel like a real person, that someone understands and recognizes.
I am so glad that this trial brought something positive to people dealing with PTSD, as I imagine a lot of people going through struggles feel very triggered by some things coming up so it was nice to see something be a positive rather than a negative. Reading comments like this is also making me think I should ask my mother more often how she is doing and if she needs to talk about things.
I don't know if this will make sense. But, his voice was like listening to a gentle spring rain. I just wanted to curl up and take a nap lol. But he was also so pleasant and professional I felt like I needed to listen to everything he was saying
Dr. Speigel Was The Dr. Elaine Had Lined Up To Examine Depp IF She Had Won The Motion to have Depp Undergo the Psych Exam Amber Was Demanding!! OMG I bet Speigel has Given Elaine Everything She Wanted prior in other cases for depositions; she usually gets to Settlement in her cases could this be a contributing factor? If I had a client who was forced to undergo an exam by him in one of those cases I would be filing paperwork immediately. This is why hiring the same expert works over & over. He got into so much horse shit about Depp that had zero substance ie...street drugs, vomit vs ice cream, fed lines vs music in an earpiece. There was so much more he gave Elaine it's pitiful if he did this to others.
Your utter humanness and realness is so deeply appreciated. You power through Law Nerd info with such intelligent commentary and dedication. It is seen and heard. Thank you for all you do. Just as a side note: an ABC channel had 16k watching watching the Depp Heard trial live, at the exact moment that you had 173k watching. Kudos to you!!
Elaine - "motion to strike"--right after Hicksville guy states that Amber's behavior triggered him, based on his own personal experience in an emotionally abusive relationship! 🤯🤯🤯
But it’s funny that when Josh Drake’s deposition was shown he testified that he was a victim of domestic violence. Elaine wants to have her cake and eat it too! If it’s her witness it’s fine.
@@princessadora uh. Why do you remember this non event from 6 years ago? Witnesses are allowed to say WHY they'd remember a random Tuesday afternoon. Because its weird otherwise.
Witnessing these objections in *real time* with Mr. Knight realllly make you read like just *HOW* much information is withheld from us & the jury during a trial…
@@lypscratch he is high as a kite on his own fumes. read the few bits of published research to his name, it's all about testing drugs on old people in ways that also seem dubiously ethical
The thing that TMZ have tried to stop the Wittness from testifying really just compounds the belief we all have that Amber herself was the one who sold the video
Is it only implied that the photos received by TMZ came from Amber so that the journalist only technically reveals his sources? Or is there some hearsay rule or something that keeps somebody to come straight out to accuse her? I missed a bit of the trial.
Not really. They would've done so regardless who were on the trial. Their reputation would be tarnished if they aren't trying their best to protect their sources who wishes to be anonymous. Who would leak or provide a media outlet of information if there's a risk that that said media outlet has a reputation of revealing their sources?
I only subscribed recently due to your coverage of this trial, but the moment near the end where you got choked up from that super chat had me tearing up! I guess I hadn't realized how much of a distraction I needed from other world events until that chatter pointed it out, and like them I want to thank you for what you do and for creating a community full of law nerds who can have respectful discussions and kindly explain things to a lay person like myself. It's a rare thing to find on the internet. Your coverage of this case and your explanations have allowed me to understand the more objective, legal side where my initial thoughts were rooted in emotions. It's a breath of fresh air to find someone who is reasonable and logical, while still maintaining empathy and kindness with humor thrown in. You've been a great role model in the short time I've watched your content. 500k subs (and counting) are much deserved. Congratulations! Enjoy your night. 💜
Q: Are you a Depp fan?..A:...NO!...😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🇦🇺...Here in Australia we'd call him...Ridgy Didge!...or...True Blue!...or we'd say...He's a Real One!...He gained MANY fans today!..God Bless his cotton socks!...👍🇦🇺👍🇦🇺👍
I mean, I have been fortunate not to have experienced abuse in my life, but I find during some parts of this trial, I find myself being extremely angry and near shouting at the screen. I also feel so very sorry for this man and the way he was treated. They were both toxic for its other but the only person I have found to be abusive is Amber Heard. We have started watching the Pirates movies with our kids for Johnny.
1:32:05 - My favorite line of the day: *"ELAINE, THE JURY LIKES THIS WITNESS. DON'T WRECK YOURSELF!!"* Somehow the way you said it just sat so well with me.
Dr Richard Shaw’s opinion was spot on. This man provided a thorough explanation of what can be said and how without actually meeting with the person you are providing an opinion on. I have done about a thousand clinical psychological assessments and what he has said in his testimony is how I was trained. I did some neuropsychological assessments as an intern and know you can conclude nothing from a mini mental status exam without further assessment. Any screener like that can at best raise red flags to guide further assessment. Dr Spiegel’s careless answers are very professionally concerning.
Same here! The previous psychiatrist threw ethics, standard practices and professional guidelines out of the window with a fury! TRUE expert witness!🤷. I wouldn't trust Dr. Spiegel to diagnose a chicken as poultry! 👨⚕️vs.🤡
Yes, the man who unprofessionally almost diagnosed Johhny without even meeting him made me see red. That man deserves in my opinion to even loose his job, bc if that's how he acts in public court, I fear what he is doing with clients behind closed doors. I agree with Emily that you shouldn't go give him online reviews without being actually his client but I hope he gets some investigation bc of this. He seems dangerous
I was screaming when he said that JD has slow processing speed. “He can’t make that conclusion based on him talking in a deposition!!” Then when he went so far beyond what you can actually conclude from an MMSE, I was cussing him out!
Luckily they’ll have all of it to review and look back on in the transcript. But yes, it is…SO much. I wonder if they’re starting to experience empathy fatigue.
Years ago I came across an essay in a magazine that was so good and well written I tore it out. It was by Johnny Depp. I had no idea who he was at the time, and I have lost the clipping, but remember the experience and the genius writing.
@@chrish2277 I, too thought of the audio where a belligerent AH's is taunting JD about selling his journals. Only bc I'd definitely buy a copy of JD's innermost thoughts. A little less than 20 years ago I bought a book which was simply the journal of Kurt Cobain. The cover art was an exact recreation of his journal covers (doodles, coffee rings, & all) and the pages inside were incredible, a mix of lyrics, philosophy, poetry, artwork, etc
This trial shows me lawyers can make the trial informative or boring due to the way they question. Boring might even be desirable depending on their client. I have learned a lot .
A couple of days ago, Law & Lumber was on a video with The Behavioral Arts, and he mentioned that clients generally gravitate towards attorneys that match their personalities. That seems to extend to attorneys picking expert witnesses as well, and I only just realized how much witnesses reflect on the people they're "for." I paused the video to write this, and so far all I've seen Dr. Shaw do is give his CV, but already he's reflecting SO well on JD to me.
Yep, cluster b people tend to like other cluster b people or conmen, they all kind of buy each other’s bullshit, - grandiose statements, belief they are the best at their work or in the field etc. But they don’t check well enough for if it can be backed up with facts or logic. You can see that in the Dr Death series too. Politicians have this issue in spades as well.
Just wanted to clarify my original point. I don't know JD, of course, and TBF, I always have to remember that JD and AH are both actors (JD arguably being a much, much better actor), so I can't say for certain that I know his true personality even after seeing his testimony. So when I say that Shaw reflects well on him, I don't mean that I know they match personalities, exactly. What I mean is, well... I'm having a hard time putting this into words (I should be asleep right now), but what I mean is that I never realized just how much a witness can make the person they're testifying "for" look good just by association. Like, even though Shaw and JD probably only know each other through JD's lawyers, just the fact that JD picked his lawyers and his lawyers picked Shaw made JD look good, just because Shaw came across as so quiet and unassuming.
I loved hearing Dr. Shaw talk about PTSD in parents of NICU babies. My middle daughter was in the NICU for 3 months and I know the trauma firsthand. People do not understand it at all.
#3 was born at 27 weeks. I got medivaced to a city five hours away n had her alone and man.....the fear and trauma of the whole thing and after being told she probs wouldn't make it. Still gets me and she's almost 16 now.
I'm sure JD loved spending time with all Amber's friends to celebrate his bday...not! I bet she never asked JD what his wishes were. I'm glad he's away from her and her entourage.
Solid gold Hicksville owner testimony ! Poor Elaine and Amber can’t believe someone who recognizes intoxication, abuse, intimidation and demeanor changes witnessed amber yelling and acting upset that she wasn’t being payed enough attention to by Depp and that mr Depp appeared to be fearful and cowering at the verbal attack and jealous interrogation of yelling by amber and his demeanor changed from extrovert to introvert and quiet after this. Glad he spoke up with the truth and the details of nothing alarming in damage just a $62 light fixture had broken. Quite a different story from what Amber & Co said and put out to the media.
@@littlebird5207 only a single light fixture broke and he found a replacement for the pair, so they'd match, for $62. It took a couple of weeks because they are vintage but they said it is a common event and they tend to replace a light fixture or two every couple of weeks. These were of more note because it was in the trailer that was filled with the most vintage and authentic replicas. (I believe I've restated that portion of testimony fairly accurately.)
Emily, you really held it together after hearing about the shooting. I could visibly/audibly see you change after that news. You are a true professional and an even greater human being.
Emily, I started with you love this morning, but kept falling behind for a number of reasons. I’m so sorry you got blind sided, but for what it’s worth, being with you and your coverage has really helped me level and ground myself after so, so, so many triggers. I don’t know if you’ll ever see this, but I had to thank you. You and your channel have become a safe space in a world of mess. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
It is so nice to see how supportive JD team is to each other. After the physiatrist testimony (2:50:52) when the young lawyer is sitting down, they all (including Johnny) congratulate her. Very sweet moment.
Don't forget she's not relaxed, she's aware of needing to control her face/reactions at all times. The Behavior Panel experts said they thought she had done homework in studying facial "tells" (she's had lots of time to watch their and other body language experts' commentary on her deposition and other videos), but even so they were still able to determine her deception
Yeah the guy was calling her friends hipsters so she was definitely not amused and it sounded like there was a reaction from everyone in the room. Whats funny is that the whole idea of trailer park realness as a theme for a getaway is very hipster in itself lol. I think she has been very annoyed from the beginning of rebuttals because it is the most her character and popularity has been attacked this whole time. Up until now its been about the DV allegations in which she feels completely validated and she expectes kickback from JDs team on that and was prepared to react stoically wherein she feels this is all very unfair and it is harder for her to keep her emotions in check about it. It is clear that as soon as rebuttal happened she startes being more animated, writing feverishly and passing notes to the lawyers doing cross ex to ensure they made the points she wanted. Wherein JD has trusted his lawyers implicitly and only on one occasion passed a note to chew who them passed a note back because something was said that JD realised was not accurate. She on the otherhand seems to not trust her team 100% and it shows with the demeanor at her table imho.
This whole thing has been more interesting to me than ANY movie I've ever watched, and part of that is because of you and your commentary and explanations. Love it!
I believe the fight won't be over. If Depp will win you can only image what heards pr team will be writing about all injustice. If heard wind I believe Depp fans will keep pushing to make him accepted in movies. Heh I really hope will really see what a snake heard is :/
I just love your explanation of things. Helps us non lawyers understand what may or may not be happening. Very educational and you have 100% on point hair makeup and I'm a huge fan of the cursey words.
We love you, Emily! We know you're human and also navigating these heavy world events while working hard to provide us commentary on this trial. Please take care of yourself. If you need a break of any kind we will understand.
Thank you so much for creating this space to watch and learn together. I so appreciate your approach and style and perspective... and especially your empathy and heart. Phew, so very touched by you at the close. Thank you for being so authentic. Enjoy your special family moments tonight. Congrats on 500k! 💗 💜💜💜🙏🏻🌌
Very interesting listening to Dr. Shaw speak as I am a parent who suffers from PTSD due to DV, and being the parent to a medically fragile child. I'm also a recovering addict (go figure), and this case is really hitting home for me!
A lot of the morning testimony goes to Amber's sense of grandiose. She really thinks she’s worth a lot more. Goes towards her being narcissistic. And to everything being said about her.
I lololooooove this man. He’s so sweet adorable and precious and it’s huge of him to stand up for truth and go out of his way like this! I hope all of us can answer the call when we face times life this.
I love how he stopped and apologized whenever their was an objection - so refreshing - and the fact that he said he was horrible with names to Camille and then corrected Elaine for saying people’s names wrong twice during cross. If he’s bad with names, Elaine is worse.
Talking about seeing celebrities, one of the nuns at my high school said she was once on a silent retreat and while she was on a walk she saw a man and a woman came out of the woods on horseback. She didn't know who the woman was but the man was Christopher Reeve and he was on a white horse. She told us "I broke my silence to give them directions because they were very lost, and I'll never forget that." It was DECADES since the encounter and you could tell she remembered it clear as day.
I love motions like this. "Our former employee can't testify because it would disclose our confidential source. Also they don't know the source and would be purely speculative."
I’m glad you took a moment to allow yourself to feel for those children and for the domestic victims who need you to be their safe space. Thank you for not shying away from your feelings and your hurt. I’m sure that was hard to learn in front of thousands of people but I feel you handled it appropriately and I appreciate you trying to stay on topic while not hiding your emotions. You’re so elegant and graceful and definitely someone to be admired. Thank you for doing what you do and remaining human through out. You’re definitely an excellent role model. We have so much to learn from you.
Her smiling while the Hicksville guy was explaining the lack of damage says a lot. If what she says happend actually had happend, watching him say what he did would actually upset her. But she's laughing and smiling
It seemed that started when Elaine accidentally called Johnny "Mr. Heard" and she totally lost control of her face. She smiled like 3 times in 10 seconds.
Now this is a highly qualified, compassionate Professional that I would trust. Having had my own issues with Depression illnesses I cannot emphasise enough how stigmatised I have felt by certain Dr[s( I have 3 degrees and am a retired S/W and Nurse-so I think I AM not to " NUTS" !
Dr. Shaw has such a soothing voice. So calm and kind ❤️❤️❤️ I would love to have him on my mental health team. The other one made me immediately think "I would NEVER want that asshole as my psychiatrist!" Soooooooo different
Okay, watched more of the video now… firstly, I fcking loved Mr Nights testimony. He was hilarious without trying to be, and that’s the best kind of funny. Secondly, I also have adhd, and can get distracted by, and ruminate on things that are triggering, and I’m amazed at how well you were able to take a moment and pull yourself together after hearing the horrific news that came out of Texas. You took a moment, pulled yourself together, and focused back on task…I don’t know that many of us could have, even those who are neurotypical surely would have had difficulty with that. Your empathy is what makes your channel so good to watch; your empathy is a strength. x
Thanks for showing your humanity and vulnerability. I have had struggles with severe PTSD myself (and winning the battle these days!!!💪💪) and seeing someone else deal with triggers makes me feel so seen. Thank you, thank you, thank you.
I know y’all didn’t share why but I’m glad I’m not the only one. Just want to let y’all know you guys are not alone and we’ve build a wonderful and safe community here. ❤️ bless all of you!
I worked at the Met Gala in 2000, an unforgettable “night at the museum.” I worked in museum education during the day & events at night. Saw every celebrity imaginable in one place! I remember it moment by moment.
Emily I saw you go off camera, and I think I heard you crying (sorry if I'm assuming). I saw the news too in the middle of a meeting and it hit me really, really hard. I hope you know that for me as a viewer you NEVER have to apologize for your emotions, experience, trauma and empathy. We're here WITH you and because of YOU.
I hope that the highlighting of the "goldwater rule" will encourage people to stop making armchair diagnoses of all involved in this case, including amber heard. There could be a number of things going on for either parties here. (Not a fan of amber just saying we shouldn't all claim to be clinical psychologists)
No we all don’t but when you grew up with a diagnosed narcissist with diagnosed bpd and you now have diagnosed ptsd and bpd you can sit there and say yep that’s exactly what she looks like she has. Cos a lot of us have lived and are living it.
Yes exactly, especially because it does not present the same in each person. Two people could have BPD and have completely different symptoms / behaviours etc.. so no one can ever truly know even if they themselves have BPD or have family members with BPD (or other diagnosis)
@@andreacollins3204 100% living with someone with mental illness and personality disorders 24 hours a day for years on end makes me an expert. Not being able to talk about that is hard after being told so often that there is nothing wrong with the narcissist . BUT if I was testifying as a licensed psychiatrist my ethical responsibility is to the health and wellness of the subject. Dr Curry did that by speaking about Amber as a human who has shown these traits. Like if Amber went to her for treatment, I feel like Dr Curry would treat her with dignity and respect and try to help her
I also mentioned the Goldwater Rule. I do believe it's as important as a civil rights law.Armchair psychiatrists thrown out diagnoses along with Baker Acting and 5150 holds = human trafficking.
I forgot how epic rebuttal was! Lmfaooooo!!!!! Morgan knight is hilarious!! How did I forget about the schizophrenia comment! Holy shit! I love him all over again!
Watching on replay : I was looking through my dad's year book and I saw Tina Fey( he was a grade above her). I asked him why he never told me he went to school with her and he had no idea she was famous now. I showed him the picture and he commented "yeah, she was weird."
Yes it does shows that he is liked and can hold longtime friendships also ambers friends not being friends anymore and not wanting to show up in court shows alot about her video depos and they all looked agitated af.
@@thevosburglife6006 I disagree. Changes in friendships happen frequently for varying reasons. Your comment implies Amber's friends decision to not testify on her behalf is driven by an alignment to Johnny's position and there is no evidence of that. Additionally, both parties have had friends who have indicated a once deep friendship that no longer continues. I'm not sure I'd characterise "Hicksville guy" as a longterm friendship either. They met twice in 40 years.
"honestly sounds like schizophrenia" The most I've actually physically laughed out loud in goodness know how long 🤣thst was absolutely brilliant, Emily your laugh gives me life 🤣😂
There were several witnesses/days I missed originally because of work etc, so I've slowly been rewatching the trial as background noise to see the whole picture. Originally when I saw the Morgans' testimonies, I was so peeved with Elaine for accusing them of seeking their 15 minutes. Watching that testimony now, with the context of AH's friend depo's, the doctors, damage experts etc, it makes me laugh, but also LIVID. Over the course of a few days Elaine watched a dozen holes get poked in their sides story (Bania obliterating the damage expert and hashtags, the dr's rebutting AH's side, the holes poked in Rocky/Josh/IOs annoyingly similar stories), and started attacking peoples' character because she had nothing left to go on. She sat through the Rebuttal Battle of the experts and knew they were fucked, so decided to play even slimier and dirtier than she had already. Absolutely gross behavior.
I can’t believe how many new law nerds we have!! At this rate, we’re gonna hit a mill soon!! I feel so proud to be an original law nerd! Out of all the TH-cams this channel has been the funnest safest space in all the land! Emily, you should be so proud of the space you’ve created for so many people!! We love you& can’t wait to see where we can take this fantabulous channel!!! 🌈🔥❤️✨💙❤️💜⚡️‼️we yeet all the Fuckery!!!
Hey Em, I have a friend that survived parkland and I respect and understand you taking a moment, I did as well and I want you to know that not everyone is over the terrible horrors perpetrated by lone persons against a mass of good people. Love and and would love to talk to you further if you’d like, you are a very good person and I admire the stoicism you demonstrated during the ama and can honestly say I couldn’t have done the same
So happy I've found you, Emily. Can only watch during breaks during my 10+ hour work day,then catch up at night. Just wanted to thank you for your dedication and great humor. I much appreciate you 🤗
Same! Having her videos with time stamps have been a lifesaver while catching up with this trial at the end of my day. I listen to it while I walk my dog at night and can only catch up on so much. Having her videos and the recaps have been the only way I’ve been able to stay up to date.
morgan (hicksville) night done stole my heart! Elaine being all arsey and hes still being respectful and nice !! what a guy infact all of todays witnesses are so nice richard shaw thankyou for all the work you do !! wait all of Depp's witnesses to this day have been lovely respectful people where as Ambers have not surley that says a hella lot!!!!! ALSO SIDE NOTE EMILY BEEN WATCHING FOR OVER A YEAR SO PROUD WE DUCKING LOVE YOU 🦆
I forgot to mention that big am watching the trial again from start to finish.. and today my dear you really choked me up. After watching this day 21.. I went and hugged my 2 beautiful sons 10 and 16 years old. My youngest 1p year old has ADHD and I am so proud of him and know he will do great things!
I wish that after Elaine objected even just once, Camille simply said what if anything and repeated the same question verbatim, maybe then Elaine could work out why it’s not a fix all
Pros of being behind: endless trial content and no cliff hanger Cons: I have no idea what’s going on in the present and sometimes tweets spoil it 🤣 Love your channel!!! I’ve been out of work due to injury and watching this trial with you has been my saving grace from pure boredom!
Lol me rn. I started on the trial a week late because I didn't realize it had started until my boyfriend started sending me memes of Johnny Depps testimony. I'm here now, and at work today had someone tell me the verdict. I still want to finish watching the trial though because it's fascinating, but the end has already been spoiled 😂
The Judge is soooo patient and professional and respectful! Really a pleasure to listen to her every words! And Ms. Vasquez is equally so amazing! It makes me so happy to think of all the new vocations this trial is going to bring to the world.
Watched this on replay, you are totally awesome! I am a sympathetic crier, when you cry I cry. I've also been going through some hard stuff and this is a great distraction and totally interesting!! I also love reacting with you because I don't know what's shocking so that's been very fun! Thank you!
Just catching up on yesterday's testimony! HOLY CRAP! This is fantastic! I have never be so entertained. Thanks Emily for your commentary. I really enjoy it!
Emily! I have been with you since before 50K!!!!! I was so revved up today!!!! I didn't want court to start back up before the official count! And then when it hit 500K I screamed out loud by myself and threw my arms in the air!! You are so lovely and I am so happy for you! I watched your amazing TED talk last night. You deserve all the good Karma coming your way. I love this community. Let's Rock.
Why did Elaine act So Shocked that Hicksville Owner said Johnny Drove There? The Scottish Security Guard Testified Johnny Drove His Antique Car There. I thought he said it was a 50s something Plymouth?
It is haughty indifference to purposely misprounced a human's name. You are taking them they are 'less than' and you don't have to make an effort to properly say their name. In actuality, it makes the person look stupid - they can't learn and say the right name.
Rewatching this and when Morgan Night is testifying AH is hot pissed. She didn't think anyone would show up to refute her story of that night and she is big mad that he is there.
I absolutely *lost it* when Mr. Knight said "that sounds like schizophrenia". Duuuude this trial is bonkers
🤣🤣🤣🤣 I loved that guy!
Same
I've replayed that more times than I can count, and still funny
I was cackling 💀
just catching up and I'm howling 😂
Emily, I just won my jury trial with a very difficult client!!! To be honest, I learned a lot from just watching this trial and your comments. My objections during the trial were on point! Thanks to AH attnys what-not-to-do performance!
Congratulations 😀
Congrats!
Amazing! Congrats!
Congrats!!
Congrats!!!!!!! We’re all so proud of u!!!!
This guy from Hicksville seems so down to earth and honest.
🤢🤮
1,043,075 views. There’s a reason why we’re all listening on Emily’s channel. It’s nice to have an attorney that talks to us laymen in terms that we can understand and comprehend. Thank you Emily. 🙏🏻🥰❤
I wouldn’t be surprised if Hicksville’s already booked til 2030.
Ikr?? I wanna go!
Time to get a cuddle puddle going 🤭
Literally my husband and I strongly considered going there for our next vacay hah
not booked, I checked, but the prices are super high.
I hope so!! I would absolutely love to cuddle puddle there lol. Bud & Breakfast 💯
Thank you Elaine for reminding us she pledged 3.5 million. The problem is she lied IN PUBLIC saying she paid already in interview to dutch TV and to the U.K. court as well. I sent a check to the Children's Hospital in Johnny Depp's name.
oh great idea
She lied under oath as well
@@veronicam6641 p
@@thatsclassicher1149 plus that heavily influenced the judgement in her favor during the UK trial. The judge ignored all of Johnnys evidence and even stated his decision was based on that “donating 7 million dollars, is not the actions of a gold digger”. He basically made up his mind from her lies about her donating her entire divorce settlement! I wish Johnny could go back and appeal that judgement even further because it was won based on lies and bias.
JD paid $100K to each to the ACLU and LA Children Hospital. The just over $1million paid to the ACLU in AH's name was 100% paid by ELON. AH has not given ANY money to the charities.
Elainnnnnnnne’s treatment of the Hicksville man was awful 😒-I hope the jury sees how horrific she comes across!
I’m sure it will, since we all saw it (before our eyes).
She was so disrespectful!
Yeah she was really mean and it didn’t seem needed. He is just a normal guy. I get she needs to do her job but she doesn’t have to be rude. Also, I bet the jury liked him so being rude wouldn’t look good.
Elaine did Amber NO FAVORS by her behavior toward Mr. Knight. However, we see this again, and again, from Amber's side. Amber AND her attorneys are extremely demeaning & rude. It's a bad look and it WILL hurt them with the jury, no doubt.
Elaine is fighting for her life
Dr. Shaw is really pleasant to listen to and a breath of fresh air in this trial. His demeanor is respectful, responsible and direct. No stupid flippant exclamation, no digs at anyone, just candid and insightful. He really engaged me and I learned a few new things too. Fabulous witness. 😊👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Coherent and concise is what Depp's team have brought forward with their witnesses. Convoluted , contradicted AND confrontational is all I've taken from Heards team.
This is also what I have observed. It is striking to me how arrogant Heard’s psy eval witnesses had been. Polar opposite of team Depp’s who are calm and collected with affable demeanor-and clearly knows their stuff.
Exactly & these Experts have bulldozed thru for Elaine's wins prior, probably pre-trial settlements! Has anyone Ever Taken Time to Count the Times Heard's tale has been contradicted so much as to count as a big fat lie? This is one for sure!
@@w.t.1338 Absolutely Shows how Elaine has a "good" reputation; she's earned it with these Experts & more in her pocket. I bet future Attorneys up against her from now on come down hard on her "Experts". Because it seems they are paid to write Exactly the BS Elaine needs, factual or not backed up with facts (Speigel), to write reports that say what she wants/needs. Her Experts never expected to be cross examined. They never expected to be Questioned about their reports/findings. Lord it's so obvious They Never Expected to Face Depp's Attorneys In Court. probably told it would settle or be dropped.
Perfect observation
Just like the client herself!
I always find it so strange how these lawyers have no idea what Twitter is or how a tweet works. She was acting like Tweeting a reply at someone is like meeting them for a coffee and then having a discussion then becoming lifelong friends.
I love this comment lol you are so right.
That's Elaine for ya
In fairness, I’m 33 and have no idea how Twitter works. I can code in R and Python, but Twitter scares me.
I object to TMZ calling itself a news organization.
Sustained
“I think it’s pronounced Geralyn ” and Emily’s laugh is life!
yes, the laugh gave me life!
That was so funny. Other funny part was the “Amber isn’t Jason Momoa”
Would someone be able to add a time stamp for this part please. I cannot find it.
@@141986rosa it’s in earlier in the day. Sorry with the testimony of the lawyer who does the contracts with celebrities
@@141986rosa 51:38
I have a medically fragile child, and diagnosed PTSD. When I heard this man speaking about people like me, I choked up mostly because I felt heard, seen, understood but also because our trauma was brought up in the "typical world" and not just in the special needs community. Thank you so much sir for all you do for families like mine.
Same. I remember when I was listening to Mayim Bialik's podcast about the difference between trauma and PTSD, and I was like, "holy crap, I have PTSD. I need to talk to someone about this." I had absolutely no idea whatsoever. And when someone, a real person in my regular life, inadvertently revealed to me that I had PTSD, it shattered me. I was so grateful that there was an ANSWER. And ever since then, when people talk about it I get choked up because it makes me feel like a real person, that someone understands and recognizes.
@@PromisedJubilee I relate to this deeply 🥺💙
I am so glad that this trial brought something positive to people dealing with PTSD, as I imagine a lot of people going through struggles feel very triggered by some things coming up so it was nice to see something be a positive rather than a negative. Reading comments like this is also making me think I should ask my mother more often how she is doing and if she needs to talk about things.
@@PromisedJubileeevdnedvnEpDveevdedede fedv pkekevdkdkekeked e
The British psychiatrist has a nice way of explaining things to you in a simple way, but not making you feel stupid or demeaned as he does it
I don't know if this will make sense. But, his voice was like listening to a gentle spring rain. I just wanted to curl up and take a nap lol.
But he was also so pleasant and professional I felt like I needed to listen to everything he was saying
Dr. Speigel Was The Dr. Elaine Had Lined Up To Examine Depp IF She Had Won The Motion to have Depp Undergo the Psych Exam Amber Was Demanding!! OMG
I bet Speigel has Given Elaine Everything She Wanted prior in other cases for depositions; she usually gets to Settlement in her cases could this be a contributing factor? If I had a client who was forced to undergo an exam by him in one of those cases I would be filing paperwork immediately. This is why hiring the same expert works over & over. He got into so much horse shit about Depp that had zero substance ie...street drugs, vomit vs ice cream, fed lines vs music in an earpiece. There was so much more he gave Elaine it's pitiful if he did this to others.
Your utter humanness and realness is so deeply appreciated. You power through Law Nerd info with such intelligent commentary and dedication. It is seen and heard. Thank you for all you do.
Just as a side note: an ABC channel had 16k watching watching the Depp Heard trial live, at the exact moment that you had 173k watching. Kudos to you!!
Mioi
Elaine - "motion to strike"--right after Hicksville guy states that Amber's behavior triggered him, based on his own personal experience in an emotionally abusive relationship! 🤯🤯🤯
Admit your client is an emotional abuser without admitting they're an emotional abuser.
he's not allowed. he's supposed to just answer the question not interject his own personal experiences.
I feel like he needed to say that.. For his own healing. And that kinda moved me.
But it’s funny that when Josh Drake’s deposition was shown he testified that he was a victim of domestic violence. Elaine wants to have her cake and eat it too! If it’s her witness it’s fine.
@@princessadora uh. Why do you remember this non event from 6 years ago?
Witnesses are allowed to say WHY they'd remember a random Tuesday afternoon.
Because its weird otherwise.
‘The Hicksville Hero’.
A life story of an honestly nice man.
Starring: Johnny Depp.
Coming to a Movie Theatre near you.👍🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼😁
Elaine even plugged his book! 😂 and his bud and breakfast! And the Twitter statements! Geeze
Witnessing these objections in *real time* with Mr. Knight realllly make you read like just *HOW* much information is withheld from us & the jury during a trial…
The amount of times they mention TUG like he is some kind of criminal mastermind. It makes me giggle every time.
It shows Amber's immaturity
Love it! In a way he is a bit of a mastermind he put so many things together he could have ran the whole case.
I love this surprise guy! He's so straightforward and obviously honest
@@snooopydooo I'm watching Dr Spiegel right now. Yikes!
@@lypscratch he is high as a kite on his own fumes. read the few bits of published research to his name, it's all about testing drugs on old people in ways that also seem dubiously ethical
@@tugger So odd! What a fascinating vocation!
Loved the Hicksville guy. More than meets the eye
Yes, I'd love to know his backstory and his dv story if he is up to sharing it.
The thing that TMZ have tried to stop the Wittness from testifying really just compounds the belief we all have that Amber herself was the one who sold the video
Agree! & I'm way behind on my watching but I hope JDs team really brings that to the forefront of all the jury & the 🌎's mind!
It shouldn't. They'd file that argument for basically any court proceeding where an employee might be asked to reveal a source.
Is it only implied that the photos received by TMZ came from Amber so that the journalist only technically reveals his sources? Or is there some hearsay rule or something that keeps somebody to come straight out to accuse her? I missed a bit of the trial.
TMZ claiming to be journalists was the most ridiculous part of this for me...
Not really. They would've done so regardless who were on the trial. Their reputation would be tarnished if they aren't trying their best to protect their sources who wishes to be anonymous. Who would leak or provide a media outlet of information if there's a risk that that said media outlet has a reputation of revealing their sources?
Watching this again a year later and this has me in stitches! Ducking funny! “He talks to the umbrella guy? That sounds like schizophrenia!” 🤣
The Hicksville thing was so interesting 🧐 I couldn’t believe the bill 💵 was under $100. Just wild
Yeah I was under the impression floors and walls would have to be fixed
I only subscribed recently due to your coverage of this trial, but the moment near the end where you got choked up from that super chat had me tearing up! I guess I hadn't realized how much of a distraction I needed from other world events until that chatter pointed it out, and like them I want to thank you for what you do and for creating a community full of law nerds who can have respectful discussions and kindly explain things to a lay person like myself. It's a rare thing to find on the internet.
Your coverage of this case and your explanations have allowed me to understand the more objective, legal side where my initial thoughts were rooted in emotions. It's a breath of fresh air to find someone who is reasonable and logical, while still maintaining empathy and kindness with humor thrown in. You've been a great role model in the short time I've watched your content. 500k subs (and counting) are much deserved. Congratulations! Enjoy your night. 💜
I concur! Wholeheartedly
Emily rocks
I laughed so hard after he said “honestly, this sounds like schizophrenia” 🤣🤣🤣
He had a lot of great one liners
I would've had to leave the court room
That was such a great response, funny as hell! Loved this guy, great to hear from a down to earth genuine witness
Timestamp please?
Q: Are you a Depp fan?..A:...NO!...😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🇦🇺...Here in Australia we'd call him...Ridgy Didge!...or...True Blue!...or we'd say...He's a Real One!...He gained MANY fans today!..God Bless his cotton socks!...👍🇦🇺👍🇦🇺👍
We all have our triggers. Especially during this trial. It’s touched all of us in some way. We love you, Emily!
It’s so triggering. Emily makes it bearable. Still triggering
So true
I mean, I have been fortunate not to have experienced abuse in my life, but I find during some parts of this trial, I find myself being extremely angry and near shouting at the screen. I also feel so very sorry for this man and the way he was treated. They were both toxic for its other but the only person I have found to be abusive is Amber Heard. We have started watching the Pirates movies with our kids for Johnny.
When she cried, I burst into tears. Much love to David I hope he is okay.💙
Watching this back AGAIN. I’d forgotten how good Dr Shaw is
1:32:05 - My favorite line of the day:
*"ELAINE, THE JURY LIKES THIS WITNESS. DON'T WRECK YOURSELF!!"*
Somehow the way you said it just sat so well with me.
ME TOO! I say it to myself regularly now
Dr Richard Shaw’s opinion was spot on. This man provided a thorough explanation of what can be said and how without actually meeting with the person you are providing an opinion on. I have done about a thousand clinical psychological assessments and what he has said in his testimony is how I was trained. I did some neuropsychological assessments as an intern and know you can conclude nothing from a mini mental status exam without further assessment. Any screener like that can at best raise red flags to guide further assessment.
Dr Spiegel’s careless answers are very professionally concerning.
Same here! The previous psychiatrist threw ethics, standard practices and professional guidelines out of the window with a fury! TRUE expert witness!🤷. I wouldn't trust Dr. Spiegel to diagnose a chicken as poultry! 👨⚕️vs.🤡
Exactly!!
Yes, the man who unprofessionally almost diagnosed Johhny without even meeting him made me see red. That man deserves in my opinion to even loose his job, bc if that's how he acts in public court, I fear what he is doing with clients behind closed doors. I agree with Emily that you shouldn't go give him online reviews without being actually his client but I hope he gets some investigation bc of this. He seems dangerous
This!
I was screaming when he said that JD has slow processing speed. “He can’t make that conclusion based on him talking in a deposition!!” Then when he went so far beyond what you can actually conclude from an MMSE, I was cussing him out!
The jury has to be so damn tired. No brain can retain all of this information
Right!!! Feel for them
Luckily they’ll have all of it to review and look back on in the transcript. But yes, it is…SO much. I wonder if they’re starting to experience empathy fatigue.
I hope their notes are good 😪
JD should write a book; His memoirs. I'd love to read a book about his life experiences.
I'm sure he plans to when he's older. With Amber taunting him about all his 'journals'.
Years ago I came across an essay in a magazine that was so good and well written I tore it out. It was by Johnny Depp. I had no idea who he was at the time, and I have lost the clipping, but remember the experience and the genius writing.
@@constancewalsh3646 you could likely track it down if you knew the name of the magazine
@@tugger if it's the same article I remember it was in spin magazine.
@@chrish2277 I, too thought of the audio where a belligerent AH's is taunting JD about selling his journals. Only bc I'd definitely buy a copy of JD's innermost thoughts. A little less than 20 years ago I bought a book which was simply the journal of Kurt Cobain. The cover art was an exact recreation of his journal covers (doodles, coffee rings, & all) and the pages inside were incredible, a mix of lyrics, philosophy, poetry, artwork, etc
Oh my gosh, when Elaine accidentally called Johnny "Mr. Heard" WATCH AMBER. She freaking LOVED it. The woman can't control her face to save her life.
Well, she is a well nourished male. Little things, but that's something to be proud of.
I apologize for this but Elaine is embarrassing.
When was it? I think i missed it
Funnily that could play into the “need for control” part of the alleged personality disorder.
@@x-Beatrix-12 I don't have a time stamp, sorry, I'm tech illiterate so I don't know how to... But it was during the camp manager's questioning.
This trial shows me lawyers can make the trial informative or boring due to the way they question. Boring might even be desirable depending on their client. I have learned a lot .
Morgan Night is such a pleasant surprise.
A couple of days ago, Law & Lumber was on a video with The Behavioral Arts, and he mentioned that clients generally gravitate towards attorneys that match their personalities. That seems to extend to attorneys picking expert witnesses as well, and I only just realized how much witnesses reflect on the people they're "for." I paused the video to write this, and so far all I've seen Dr. Shaw do is give his CV, but already he's reflecting SO well on JD to me.
Wow this makes so much sense.
Yep, cluster b people tend to like other cluster b people or conmen, they all kind of buy each other’s bullshit,
- grandiose statements, belief they are the best at their work or in the field etc. But they don’t check well enough for if it can be backed up with facts or logic. You can see that in the Dr Death series too. Politicians have this issue in spades as well.
Just wanted to clarify my original point. I don't know JD, of course, and TBF, I always have to remember that JD and AH are both actors (JD arguably being a much, much better actor), so I can't say for certain that I know his true personality even after seeing his testimony. So when I say that Shaw reflects well on him, I don't mean that I know they match personalities, exactly. What I mean is, well...
I'm having a hard time putting this into words (I should be asleep right now), but what I mean is that I never realized just how much a witness can make the person they're testifying "for" look good just by association. Like, even though Shaw and JD probably only know each other through JD's lawyers, just the fact that JD picked his lawyers and his lawyers picked Shaw made JD look good, just because Shaw came across as so quiet and unassuming.
I loved hearing Dr. Shaw talk about PTSD in parents of NICU babies. My middle daughter was in the NICU for 3 months and I know the trauma firsthand. People do not understand it at all.
#3 was born at 27 weeks. I got medivaced to a city five hours away n had her alone and man.....the fear and trauma of the whole thing and after being told she probs wouldn't make it. Still gets me and she's almost 16 now.
The most important thing about Hicksville to remember is that it was for Johnny's bday, but it was Amber and *her* friends there to celebrate.
I'm sure JD loved spending time with all Amber's friends to celebrate his bday...not! I bet she never asked JD what his wishes were. I'm glad he's away from her and her entourage.
I’m rewatching this & I thought the same thing
Wow that’s such an important point!
@@patricianunez5423she hated his friends and called them boring old farts or something.
@@LLGC510 I'm currently rewatching and honestly totally forgot that the Hicksville party was for his birthday! How depressing.
SUCH a good day for Depp in court. One of my favorite group of experts, evidence and testimony!!
OMG Elaine was totally shook up with this surprise rebuttle witness.
Yeah actually heard genuine emotion in her voice, it was fear but it was genuine!
Wait, when did that happen?
Solid gold Hicksville owner testimony ! Poor Elaine and Amber can’t believe someone who recognizes intoxication, abuse, intimidation and demeanor changes witnessed amber yelling and acting upset that she wasn’t being payed enough attention to by Depp and that mr Depp appeared to be fearful and cowering at the verbal attack and jealous interrogation of yelling by amber and his demeanor changed from extrovert to introvert and quiet after this. Glad he spoke up with the truth and the details of nothing alarming in damage just a $62 light fixture had broken. Quite a different story from what Amber & Co said and put out to the media.
Wait how much did they claim the damages were? Sorry I'm trying to play catch up.
@@littlebird5207 only a single light fixture broke and he found a replacement for the pair, so they'd match, for $62. It took a couple of weeks because they are vintage but they said it is a common event and they tend to replace a light fixture or two every couple of weeks. These were of more note because it was in the trailer that was filled with the most vintage and authentic replicas. (I believe I've restated that portion of testimony fairly accurately.)
Amber looks like she's thinking Damn or oh shit. Never thought I Would Ever See This Guy Again! He wasn't on their Witnesses List! WTH
Emily, you really held it together after hearing about the shooting. I could visibly/audibly see you change after that news. You are a true professional and an even greater human being.
💟 thank You Emily for being the shiny, sparkly Badass we all need in our lives 👸
Emily, I started with you love this morning, but kept falling behind for a number of reasons. I’m so sorry you got blind sided, but for what it’s worth, being with you and your coverage has really helped me level and ground myself after so, so, so many triggers. I don’t know if you’ll ever see this, but I had to thank you. You and your channel have become a safe space in a world of mess. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
❤️🩹❤️🩹❤️🩹❤️🩹 right
This 🙌🏻🙌🏻. I felt the exact same way. Thank you for sharing… ❤️🩹❤️🩹
It boils my blood every time that Elaine says “Vaz-coo-ez”… for weeks! It’s so unprofessional how little she tries to correct herself.
It's either ignorant or deliberately rude. Neither is good.
I’ve heard her pronounce it the correct way-one time. I think she’s a petty witch.
She learned to press the button for the mic eventually….
She does come off as very high faluting. It's an intimidation trick she learned off of "Suits".
She says a bunch of people's names wrong, to be fair.
It is so nice to see how supportive JD team is to each other. After the physiatrist testimony (2:50:52) when the young lawyer is sitting down, they all (including Johnny) congratulate her. Very sweet moment.
Rottenborn finds the expression “young hipsters” funny , turns to Heard to share a laugh. She doesn’t notice at all and continues to look annoyed! 😂
Don't forget she's not relaxed, she's aware of needing to control her face/reactions at all times. The Behavior Panel experts said they thought she had done homework in studying facial "tells" (she's had lots of time to watch their and other body language experts' commentary on her deposition and other videos), but even so they were still able to determine her deception
Yeah the guy was calling her friends hipsters so she was definitely not amused and it sounded like there was a reaction from everyone in the room. Whats funny is that the whole idea of trailer park realness as a theme for a getaway is very hipster in itself lol.
I think she has been very annoyed from the beginning of rebuttals because it is the most her character and popularity has been attacked this whole time. Up until now its been about the DV allegations in which she feels completely validated and she expectes kickback from JDs team on that and was prepared to react stoically wherein she feels this is all very unfair and it is harder for her to keep her emotions in check about it. It is clear that as soon as rebuttal happened she startes being more animated, writing feverishly and passing notes to the lawyers doing cross ex to ensure they made the points she wanted. Wherein JD has trusted his lawyers implicitly and only on one occasion passed a note to chew who them passed a note back because something was said that JD realised was not accurate. She on the otherhand seems to not trust her team 100% and it shows with the demeanor at her table imho.
Timestamp: 1:40:18
This whole thing has been more interesting to me than ANY movie I've ever watched, and part of that is because of you and your commentary and explanations. Love it!
I feel the exact same way. I don't know what we're all gonna do once trial is over lol
Agreed! I ask everyone how they are keeping up with the trial and if they dont say Emily D Baker, I set them straight and they thank me everyday :)
I believe the fight won't be over. If Depp will win you can only image what heards pr team will be writing about all injustice.
If heard wind I believe Depp fans will keep pushing to make him accepted in movies.
Heh I really hope will really see what a snake heard is :/
I LOVE JD, always have, but it's the walkthrough and attitude for me. Emily reminds me of my sister.
I just love your explanation of things. Helps us non lawyers understand what may or may not be happening. Very educational and you have 100% on point hair makeup and I'm a huge fan of the cursey words.
We love you, Emily! We know you're human and also navigating these heavy world events while working hard to provide us commentary on this trial. Please take care of yourself. If you need a break of any kind we will understand.
She’ll definitely have a break in a few days and when the trial ends for the day
Its pronounced "Gerrihlyn" so smooth and calm. Great Moment
Elayne was so desperate to get revenge on Camille that she ended up looking petty, and pathetic with her constant objections in redirect.
Right? Pretty entertaining watching Elaine jump out of her chair every time she’d object.
Thank you so much for creating this space to watch and learn together. I so appreciate your approach and style and perspective... and especially your empathy and heart. Phew, so very touched by you at the close. Thank you for being so authentic. Enjoy your special family moments tonight. Congrats on 500k! 💗 💜💜💜🙏🏻🌌
Very interesting listening to Dr. Shaw speak as I am a parent who suffers from PTSD due to DV, and being the parent to a medically fragile child. I'm also a recovering addict (go figure), and this case is really hitting home for me!
A lot of the morning testimony goes to Amber's sense of grandiose. She really thinks she’s worth a lot more. Goes towards her being narcissistic. And to everything being said about her.
I was cracking up at the comparisons 😆 🤣 and 50 mil future lol
Good point!
It must be killing her to hear it all
yessss
She was married to a guy for 15 mos. She walked away with $7 million and more. Does she leave him alone, no. Amber loves the attention.
I lololooooove this man. He’s so sweet adorable and precious and it’s huge of him to stand up for truth and go out of his way like this! I hope all of us can answer the call when we face times life this.
I love how he stopped and apologized whenever their was an objection - so refreshing - and the fact that he said he was horrible with names to Camille and then corrected Elaine for saying people’s names wrong twice during cross. If he’s bad with names, Elaine is worse.
1:32:49 When Elaine said "twitters", you can see Doug actually chuckle. Even Amber was laughing . 🤣🤣🤣
Ben Chew was clearly buying “facts not fuckery” merch from the lawnerds shop. 😆 Congrats on 500K subs! 💜💜💜
I was just about to comment this! 😂
Someone should really send some of this merch to all Johnny's lawyers. They so should rock it.
Did I just notice Ben Chew also wear rings
Talking about seeing celebrities, one of the nuns at my high school said she was once on a silent retreat and while she was on a walk she saw a man and a woman came out of the woods on horseback. She didn't know who the woman was but the man was Christopher Reeve and he was on a white horse. She told us "I broke my silence to give them directions because they were very lost, and I'll never forget that." It was DECADES since the encounter and you could tell she remembered it clear as day.
That's so funny! Reminds me of the man in life of Brian!
I love motions like this. "Our former employee can't testify because it would disclose our confidential source. Also they don't know the source and would be purely speculative."
I got a cramp with how hard I laughed at Camille's "what if anything" question after Elaine's two objections. It was perfectly timed. 1:27:03
I’m glad you took a moment to allow yourself to feel for those children and for the domestic victims who need you to be their safe space. Thank you for not shying away from your feelings and your hurt. I’m sure that was hard to learn in front of thousands of people but I feel you handled it appropriately and I appreciate you trying to stay on topic while not hiding your emotions. You’re so elegant and graceful and definitely someone to be admired. Thank you for doing what you do and remaining human through out. You’re definitely an excellent role model. We have so much to learn from you.
Her smiling while the Hicksville guy was explaining the lack of damage says a lot. If what she says happend actually had happend, watching him say what he did would actually upset her. But she's laughing and smiling
Yeah, if only she could act..
Her whole face during that testimony - especially when he said Johnny was cowering spoke volumes
Physically sickening. I want to do like Johnny and never look at her again.
It seemed that started when Elaine accidentally called Johnny "Mr. Heard" and she totally lost control of her face. She smiled like 3 times in 10 seconds.
If I’m not wrong she was smirking at the testimony about her yelling and him being triggered
i appreciate this expert doug coming in and defending Zendaya's honor, someone needed to
🤣🤣🤣
Zendaya goes by one name 😂
Look at Elaine up thinking she's this great Lawyer,hands f la y ing she's the worst of the worst
Now this is a highly qualified, compassionate Professional that I would trust. Having had my own issues with Depression illnesses I cannot emphasise enough how stigmatised I have felt by certain Dr[s( I have 3 degrees and am a retired S/W and Nurse-so I think I AM not to " NUTS" !
Dr. Shaw has such a soothing voice. So calm and kind ❤️❤️❤️ I would love to have him on my mental health team. The other one made me immediately think "I would NEVER want that asshole as my psychiatrist!" Soooooooo different
Okay, watched more of the video now… firstly, I fcking loved Mr Nights testimony. He was hilarious without trying to be, and that’s the best kind of funny.
Secondly, I also have adhd, and can get distracted by, and ruminate on things that are triggering, and I’m amazed at how well you were able to take a moment and pull yourself together after hearing the horrific news that came out of Texas. You took a moment, pulled yourself together, and focused back on task…I don’t know that many of us could have, even those who are neurotypical surely would have had difficulty with that. Your empathy is what makes your channel so good to watch; your empathy is a strength. x
Thanks for showing your humanity and vulnerability. I have had struggles with severe PTSD myself (and winning the battle these days!!!💪💪) and seeing someone else deal with triggers makes me feel so seen. Thank you, thank you, thank you.
Thank you so much for all of this coverage! I’m going through hard times and this has been my only escape and I love it!
Right there with you! I keep reminding myself though nothing is permanent- including the bad things.
I’m with both of you! It’s not permanent tho
I know y’all didn’t share why but I’m glad I’m not the only one. Just want to let y’all know you guys are not alone and we’ve build a wonderful and safe community here. ❤️ bless all of you!
❤️
I worked at the Met Gala in 2000, an unforgettable “night at the museum.” I worked in museum education during the day & events at night. Saw every celebrity imaginable in one place! I remember it moment by moment.
Sometimes I watch TV shows I've watched repeatedly to fall asleep. But I'm bored of rewatches. So I'll rewatch trial with Emily instead. 💜💜
@morepeaspls me, too! My family makes fun of me, but I have specific days of the trial I put on to drift off. EDB is awesome!
Emily I saw you go off camera, and I think I heard you crying (sorry if I'm assuming). I saw the news too in the middle of a meeting and it hit me really, really hard. I hope you know that for me as a viewer you NEVER have to apologize for your emotions, experience, trauma and empathy. We're here WITH you and because of YOU.
Elaine, you play stupid games you win stupid prizes!
I love your genuine heart. And you are a kick ass court commentator ❤️❤️❤️
I hope that the highlighting of the "goldwater rule" will encourage people to stop making armchair diagnoses of all involved in this case, including amber heard. There could be a number of things going on for either parties here. (Not a fan of amber just saying we shouldn't all claim to be clinical psychologists)
No we all don’t but when you grew up with a diagnosed narcissist with diagnosed bpd and you now have diagnosed ptsd and bpd you can sit there and say yep that’s exactly what she looks like she has. Cos a lot of us have lived and are living it.
Yes exactly, especially because it does not present the same in each person. Two people could have BPD and have completely different symptoms / behaviours etc.. so no one can ever truly know even if they themselves have BPD or have family members with BPD (or other diagnosis)
@@andreacollins3204 100% living with someone with mental illness and personality disorders 24 hours a day for years on end makes me an expert. Not being able to talk about that is hard after being told so often that there is nothing wrong with the narcissist . BUT if I was testifying as a licensed psychiatrist my ethical responsibility is to the health and wellness of the subject. Dr Curry did that by speaking about Amber as a human who has shown these traits. Like if Amber went to her for treatment, I feel like Dr Curry would treat her with dignity and respect and try to help her
I also mentioned the Goldwater Rule. I do believe it's as important as a civil rights law.Armchair psychiatrists thrown out diagnoses along with Baker Acting and 5150 holds = human trafficking.
Amber Heard is more clear cut than trump. We're not giving testimony
I forgot how epic rebuttal was! Lmfaooooo!!!!! Morgan knight is hilarious!! How did I forget about the schizophrenia comment! Holy shit! I love him all over again!
Watching on replay : I was looking through my dad's year book and I saw Tina Fey( he was a grade above her). I asked him why he never told me he went to school with her and he had no idea she was famous now. I showed him the picture and he commented "yeah, she was weird."
Oh, so she hasn't changed since then? 😂😂
I am a fan of hers, so I mean she's weird in the best way 😆
The fact that people who met him briefly 40 yrs ago or so, are here for him, just tells you a lottt.
Does it? Really????
Yes it does shows that he is liked and can hold longtime friendships also ambers friends not being friends anymore and not wanting to show up in court shows alot about her video depos and they all looked agitated af.
@@kirstynunn6201 yes it really does!
@@thevosburglife6006 I disagree. Changes in friendships happen frequently for varying reasons. Your comment implies Amber's friends decision to not testify on her behalf is driven by an alignment to Johnny's position and there is no evidence of that. Additionally, both parties have had friends who have indicated a once deep friendship that no longer continues. I'm not sure I'd characterise "Hicksville guy" as a longterm friendship either. They met twice in 40 years.
@@whatn7667 please explain how. I just don't see it.
The exchange between Elaine and the Hicksville dude basically became a Monty Python skit. You can't make this stuff up.
"honestly sounds like schizophrenia" The most I've actually physically laughed out loud in goodness know how long 🤣thst was absolutely brilliant, Emily your laugh gives me life 🤣😂
I bet the jury wanted to laugh too!
Agreed! I laughed out loud, by myself, in my car. "talks to the umbrella guy".
He was so dry when he said it too, like it wasn’t a joke.. which makes it even more hilarious
Timestamp? 😄
@@dortheamaria 1:38:00
There were several witnesses/days I missed originally because of work etc, so I've slowly been rewatching the trial as background noise to see the whole picture. Originally when I saw the Morgans' testimonies, I was so peeved with Elaine for accusing them of seeking their 15 minutes.
Watching that testimony now, with the context of AH's friend depo's, the doctors, damage experts etc, it makes me laugh, but also LIVID. Over the course of a few days Elaine watched a dozen holes get poked in their sides story (Bania obliterating the damage expert and hashtags, the dr's rebutting AH's side, the holes poked in Rocky/Josh/IOs annoyingly similar stories), and started attacking peoples' character because she had nothing left to go on. She sat through the Rebuttal Battle of the experts and knew they were fucked, so decided to play even slimier and dirtier than she had already. Absolutely gross behavior.
I can’t believe how many new law nerds we have!! At this rate, we’re gonna hit a mill soon!! I feel so proud to be an original law nerd! Out of all the TH-cams this channel has been the funnest safest space in all the land! Emily, you should be so proud of the space you’ve created for so many people!! We love you& can’t wait to see where we can take this fantabulous channel!!! 🌈🔥❤️✨💙❤️💜⚡️‼️we yeet all the Fuckery!!!
Hey Em, I have a friend that survived parkland and I respect and understand you taking a moment, I did as well and I want you to know that not everyone is over the terrible horrors perpetrated by lone persons against a mass of good people. Love and and would love to talk to you further if you’d like, you are a very good person and I admire the stoicism you demonstrated during the ama and can honestly say I couldn’t have done the same
So happy I've found you, Emily. Can only watch during breaks during my 10+ hour work day,then catch up at night. Just wanted to thank you for your dedication and great humor. I much appreciate you 🤗
Same! Having her videos with time stamps have been a lifesaver while catching up with this trial at the end of my day. I listen to it while I walk my dog at night and can only catch up on so much. Having her videos and the recaps have been the only way I’ve been able to stay up to date.
morgan (hicksville) night done stole my heart! Elaine being all arsey and hes still being respectful and nice !! what a guy
infact all of todays witnesses are so nice
richard shaw thankyou for all the work you do !!
wait all of Depp's witnesses to this day have been lovely respectful people where as Ambers have not surley that says a hella lot!!!!!
ALSO SIDE NOTE EMILY BEEN WATCHING FOR OVER A YEAR SO PROUD WE DUCKING LOVE YOU
🦆
"it feels like schizophrenia to me" is my fav quote from that guy.
Me too! He is great! 😂
Literally screaming 😂
Sorry to be THAT annoying person but can someone send me the timestamp? Thanks in advance! 😊
That was so funny. I totally agree it sounds insane.
@@cre448 About 1:38:00 so you can also get the context.
I forgot to mention that big am watching the trial again from start to finish.. and today my dear you really choked me up. After watching this day 21.. I went and hugged my 2 beautiful sons 10 and 16 years old. My youngest 1p year old has ADHD and I am so proud of him and know he will do great things!
Sending you and all the parents out there so much love and prayer and good vibes and trying to keep myself open to it.
Much love from TX
I wish that after Elaine objected even just once, Camille simply said what if anything and repeated the same question verbatim, maybe then Elaine could work out why it’s not a fix all
😆
You deserve all the good things coming your way. Hope your channel continues to grow
Pros of being behind: endless trial content and no cliff hanger
Cons: I have no idea what’s going on in the present and sometimes tweets spoil it 🤣
Love your channel!!! I’ve been out of work due to injury and watching this trial with you has been my saving grace from pure boredom!
holla back, replay crew! we still ride, just at different times 🤣 🐎
I'm currently trying to rush through the remaining videos before the verdict because I don't want it spoiled!
My thoughts exactly!! I'm like 4 days behind 🤣 Another pro is being able to watch streams in 1.5 speed ahah I'll be caught up in no time!
Lol me rn. I started on the trial a week late because I didn't realize it had started until my boyfriend started sending me memes of Johnny Depps testimony. I'm here now, and at work today had someone tell me the verdict. I still want to finish watching the trial though because it's fascinating, but the end has already been spoiled 😂
I'm glad I'm not the only one behind 😂 Emily has been saving me from work boredom. I actually feel more productive at times.
The Judge is soooo patient and professional and respectful! Really a pleasure to listen to her every words! And Ms. Vasquez is equally so amazing! It makes me so happy to think of all the new vocations this trial is going to bring to the world.
Watched this on replay, you are totally awesome! I am a sympathetic crier, when you cry I cry. I've also been going through some hard stuff and this is a great distraction and totally interesting!! I also love reacting with you because I don't know what's shocking so that's been very fun! Thank you!
Just catching up on yesterday's testimony! HOLY CRAP! This is fantastic! I have never be so entertained. Thanks Emily for your commentary. I really enjoy it!
Emily! I have been with you since before 50K!!!!! I was so revved up today!!!! I didn't want court to start back up before the official count! And then when it hit 500K I screamed out loud by myself and threw my arms in the air!! You are so lovely and I am so happy for you! I watched your amazing TED talk last night. You deserve all the good Karma coming your way. I love this community. Let's Rock.
When this is all over we need a compilation of Emily’s reactions to all the fuckery in this trial.
Why did Elaine act So Shocked that Hicksville Owner said Johnny Drove There? The Scottish Security Guard Testified Johnny Drove His Antique Car There. I thought he said it was a 50s something Plymouth?
I love how in the two seconds we get of Elaine questioning Jennifer Howell, she stills manages to throw in a Vasquez mispronunciation
I know right! I'm an aussie...miles from Spain or Mexico yet I know to pronounce Camille's surname as "Vaskez" phonetically
I think she's doing it on purpose.
It is haughty indifference to purposely misprounced a human's name. You are taking them they are 'less than' and you don't have to make an effort to properly say their name. In actuality, it makes the person look stupid - they can't learn and say the right name.
at first I thought it was just her being ignorant, but after a while it starts to feel more like haughty old white lady stuff.
It drives me INSANE!