I’ve noticed that Camille keeps up a fast pace - it means Amber has to make up lies really quickly and inevitably she’s going to trip herself up cos she doesn’t have time to think them through. It puts Camille under pressure too cos she has to be able to deal quickly with Ambers deflections, spot the contradictions and point them out clearly. So in a way it’s a battle of wits - who’s faster to the punch and who’s smarter…
That was Camilles whole strategy. Keep ramping up the speed, keeping her to answering the question then driving on with the next question. Increasing the speed of questions and ramping up the pressure.
This isn't Johnny Depp. You are talking to a scammer! Johnny doesn't have telegram. These guys, scam money from people. Don't give any information@@dixiebuck-bartanen-pw9cz
The smugness on her face when she tries to act intelligent stating "if you remove the metadata". The way she stares and smiles at the jury when she says it makes me cringe. She actually thinks she's smarter than Camille
Love you bro🤣🤣 And when she lie..she though no one finds it out..but its 100% on showing on her face!! The way she move her lips and eyebrows..oh my god.. she never should play werewolf🤣🤣🤣
@@bethanychatman9531 but if you watch her first round with amber she takes a very different approach. There’s also the fact that Camille got amber to basically admit one or two of the requirements of thing Johnny was sueing for. In the rebuttal amber admitted to the article being written by her and it being because of Johnny. After that as long as the jury believed that she was full of it there’s enough evidence to show she had malice(the legal definition of it) and well the rest is history so to speak.
If it was a man, Amber's true colours wouldn't have been shown and it would've played to her comments about men of power. That could've cost Johnny the case
Her whole attitude was great. She adopted this almost-bitchy, accusatory, brilliantly condescending tone. Camille was playing a character a bit (and doing a better job than that heard woman ever has), knowing heard would bitch and snark back because she couldn’t help herself and she’s too vapid and narcissistic to realise she was being skilfully baited. Thus showing who she really is and not the poor ickle victim she had been pretending to be. Once exposed the real heard was laid bare for all to see.
I so agree with that. I said the same to my husband. People are not that stupid, but that still doesn't mean JD wins. However, she does think she is better than everyone else, so I suppose that it goes along with yes, she believes most people are stupid. It is very insulting!!!
@@ethelann I don't think Camille did it for Amber or for the judge. It was definitely a calculated move to emphasize Amber's nonsense claims for the jury to see...
I love that Camille didn't stay on that point, but moved on. It denied Amber the chance to realise she slipped up, so that when she inevitably repeats the lie that the op-ed wasn't about Johnny, she further damages her own credibility.
It was funny. But, I have friends who are attys. They say it happens quite often. Especially when they are really working hard. They get into the narrative and just automatically object. They forget it's their question. lol lol
You’re absolutely right. If Ben Chew was hammering on her like that, she’d have a whole different demeanor and act like a bullied little damsel in distress, and then claim to be badgered by yet another man. We needed Camille to expose her bullshit on this and she did a good job.
If she lied, then it was because she's facing perhaps THE MOST powerful man in showbusiness. He beat her black and blue for five years. And she hid it, like IPV victims so often do, to protect him under the ethos of "until death"-romance. Johnny however, is lying about everything. He isn't after the truth. He wants revenge. Revenge for his son getting confronted with Ambers article, and for his tanked career and for Amber leaving him and telling on him (covert narcissists can't accept being left). But the truth is that HE HIMSELF cause his career to crash with his boozing and drugs. Man up and take responsibility, Johnny!
There were multiple fuckups from Amber during this trial. My top 10 would be: - "Bruise kit" that didn't exist until 2017 - Overdramatic performance on direct exam (my dog stepped on a bee) - Claiming that identical photos with different saturation were taken separately - "I use pledged and donated synonymously" - Referring to Kate Moss rumor - Claiming that she only attacked Johnny in self defense seconds after playing audio with her saying: "I did start a physical fight" - Two black eyes, split lip and a broken nose on Corden show - Claiming she didn't notify TMZ after playing video from 2016 with her saying that "TMZ was alerted" - Admitting that op-ed was about Johnny - "I'm not sitting in this courtroom laughing, smiling, making snide jokes" saying the day after everyone saw her in the courtroom doing exactly that.
Exactly! And if she had just admitted to one thing like the TMZ crap she may have gained some credibility but her narcissistic personality didn’t allow her to own up to a thing!
Bruise kit does exist and its used in filmmaking/theatre to make fake bruises. So what she did is slip up. She pretty much said she used bruise kit. Which is why her bruises look fake. Also the way she described concealing the bruises doesn't add up, first you cover the bruise with the colour opposite of the spectrum (if the bruise is purpe you use green, if it's brownish you use yellow or so, not an expert), then concealer, then foundation and then you continue with your usual makeup. What she testified is that she used foundation, concealer then the bruise kit. Which is how you'd make bruises.
Also I think she's checking the internet for reactions because everyone called her on smirking in the courtroom and she addressed this without even being asked.
@@MyaB1986 i think the bruise kit refers to the amica cream to cover them up, which did not exist at the time and instead she used the flimaking kit to make fake bruises as you mentioned
It’s kinda scary when I hear Camille say “Let’s refresh your recollection”. If I’m ever on the opposite side and she says that I’m confessing to my entire browsing history. She probably already knows it anyways.
@@MasterIceyy actually if you look at their age Camille is 2 years older than Ms. Heard, Camille was born in July 1984 and Ms. Heard in April 1986 so yes Camille is like an elder sister to Ms. Heard
@@treborsirrah7916 i was gonna say, idk anything about it but she's like one of the main lawyers in johnny's team right? ben chew and her 2 are leading attorneys
@@sillybeans929 oh camille is an associate? since she led the cross i thought she was partner im not really versed in this but ive watched Suits like 10 times. so she's like Mike, right. a junior associate? and she needs 5 10 years more experience plus paying the buy in to become a partner?
JD signed the papers where it says noone is making false claims with the intent to get money. JD also wrote those texts. AH is clearly someone who exaggerates and lies a lot but there’s some truth to it. He had much more control than her (he got her the role and wanted her out), but she’s stupid enough to ruin any credibility she has. It’s also the reason mainstream isn’t pro Depp because they know she’s an idiot and full of shit but there’s some truth in there.
"What actual survivor of domestic violence wants that?" A moment of accidental honesty from Amber. She knows she's not an actual victim and that an actual victim would act nothing like her.
@@latebloomer7191 If that were the case, then she wouldn't have used the word "actual." Because no one who is a survivor of domestic violence would refer to themselves as an "actual" survivor.
It's extremely hard not to be a bit in awe of how Camille handled herself throughout this entire trial. She was absolutely prepared well before stepping into the courtroom on day 1, and it was obvious.
I never believed her (plenty of tapes and photos were out even before the trial) but I know one thing: if she were saying the truth and all of those witnesses truly did lie to side with Johnny, she would’ve broke down crying because of the insufferable injustice and despair she'd be feeling (as actual victims do), not getting snarky and argumentative on stand
This right here! When I get mad, I cry lol. Not that I'd do this and that anyone would act like me, blah blah allegedly and my opinion and all that. But I'd be so upset and crying and hysterical if no one believed me when I was telling the truth. Something like that but unrelated happened to me where a doctor wouldn't believe me about something and I cried and cried because I was telling the truth. It was so frustrating!
This lying, aggressive, abusive, sarcastic, and mean temperament on display is the real Amber Heard. Imagine living with this woman even for one day. Depp is a Saint.
Nah. Depp is an asshole who married a spoiled brat for the superficial reason that she is young and beautiful. Depp also has a serious drug and alcohol problem. Why do people have to be on one side or the other? Depp and Heard are disgusting human beings. Depp is a better actor but I couldn’t possibly say if he’s a better person. I suspect not.
Her attorneys didn't call witnesses because there weren't any. Then she admits the reason she wrote the article because she knew people would come out on Johnny's behalf. She "effectively" admitted to doing what she is being sued for, by admitting her reason for writing it. I hope the jury can see through it all.
@@thumpymorrill8001 Thats not true, she had even her own witnesses disagree, if she had all these other witnesses they'd have been allowed like the ones Depp had, if they were relevant and could help the case. Also she apparently had "mountains of evidence" but if she did why didn't her lawyers use it?
when AH said "alot of people come out of the woodwork for the Johnny Depp show" I would have said "when you said Johnny grabbed that womans wrist and threatened to break it...how come she didn't come out of the woodwork to lie for Mr Depp? and don't answer that, cause she doesn't exist."
Starting at 31:17 is Camille’s superb finale. Here we get numerous dramatic moments where Amber’s testimony was impeached. Getting Amber to admit that she wrote the op-ed and that it was indeed about Johnny was a Perry Mason moment. I loved how Camille closed her binder and told the judge she had no further questions while Amber was still sputtering her response to seeing Johnny’s friend, Isaac Baruch, weep in the stand when recalling how destructive her actions were. That is where art meets real life. Bravo, Camille. 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Camille and Ben Chew in closing arguments were fantastic. I wasn't sure if JD will win this, but the story and the trial had such powerful effect I really think JD already won and jury decision doesn't matter.
I was thinking the same thing before, but i think it actually matters a lot to all the men and also women who have been victims of actual abuse. Johnny actually needs this win for him and also to all victims.
35:00 what I think the most brilliant thing though that Camille did here wasn't just to frustrate AH to the point where she admits to writing the Op Ed about JD, it's that she doesn't react to it. The previous times AH was caught in a trap, Camille called the juries attention to it, however if she called attention to this, AH might back out of it and say something like "I meant the type of person he is, the abusers that people like me have to face." By not mentioning it, and trusting that the jury heard and understood what she just said Camille doesn't allow AH the opportunity to back out. One of AHs strongest points was that she didn't mention JD by name in the article. And it got shattered. I believe that it was a key moment in JDs victory.
yup not nailing her there with the classic Dave Chapelle "gotcha bitch" was great strategy as you say and if memory serves they saved Oped "gotcha bitch" nailing for closing.
I don’t believe Amber understood what Camille and Morgan Tremaine the former TMZ guy did by him testifying that the actual person or her representatives notified TMZ it would take less time to publicize -15 minutes. Which was how long it took for TMZ to process the video she sent. By doing this they brilliantly avoided hearsay objections and trouble for Tremaine regarding his liability in disclosing her involvement. AH wasn’t smart enough to realize the damage that did. It proved she has no trouble lying under oath! She didn’t seem to understand but obviously the jury got it. Camille ran circles around Amber Heard.
I just love how Camille ended that "After what you have put him through and so many others with your lies" That was just a beautiful note to end on after dismantling her
Amber’s gaslighting and stalling tactics that try to confuse Camille shows just how manipulative Amber is. This testimony is so telling. Amber looking at the jury the way she does is so manipulative. If i was a juror it would make me uncomfortable.
I agree, the endless hours of that woman's manic, darting eyes! She is performing for them! Look at me! Too bad she couldn't control the audiences in HER (if you please!) epic Aquaman movie from turning their eyes from the screen whenever she "acted" in a scene.
My theory is that her stalling is due to her reading the testimony to get her story straight, that’s why she could come back and say “I don’t know, I need the context.” My other theory was that Camille being a strategic pick bc of her DV history of a female partner. She probably feels comfortable trying to push around another woman. And the strategy was probably to pull that part out of her and expose her true self. I’m not that familiar with law, but this felt impactful in terms of how a juror may view this case.
"I'm supposed to recognize a picture of some spilled wine on the floor? That's not how that works.." um, excuse me? This is your evidence that you submitted. You considered this so important that you meticulously photographed it at the time and saved it for almost 5 years to be used as evidence in a court trial. You testified to how traumatizing it was to deal the this "drugged up monster" version of your husband that you've accused of r*ping you with a bottle. This is serious shit, you can't claim that this is evidence in your 100 million dollar defamation trial, and completely dismiss the fact that you claimed the same photo is from two different events 6 months apart. It's your responsibility to know exactly what this photo is from, if you can't then don't submit it into evidence. We're supposed to take you seriously when you have a complete disregard for your own enormously contradictory evidence, and WTF WERE HER TEAM OF LAWYERS DOING WHEN THEY SUBMITTED THE SAME PHOTO AS EVIDENCE IN 2 DIFFERENT INCIDENTS?!? Can't stress how pitiful this whole thing is.
and even if she would be telling the truth about the woodwork thing, that also fell as she couldn't know about the TMZ guy, because his testimony was offered provided the judge gave him permission and struck the TMZ motion (so that, not even the judge knew what she was going to do about, cause the motion appeared and didn't exist until the TMZ former journalist was called to testify) Kate Moss couldn't either, as her testimony was approved once AH herself opened that door, so that, BSBSBS...BS BS
"If I were Heard's lawyers, I'd've told her to give short, succinct answers." Yeah. The problem is that she's uncontrollable. She just keeps going, and going, and going. She couldn't care less that she's in a courtroom under oath, or in a penthouse chasing Johnny around, or in Sea-Tac Int'l Airport with Tasya Vanree.
Yeah, she seems like your typical narcissist who thinks she's the smartest person in the room, at all times. So obviously the lawyers should take her lead... 😂😂
If I was her lawyer, I would have put JD in spot for marrying girl of daughter age as object to show off on red carpet. Prove that he ignored her, didn't spend time, no performance in bed so the poop and accuse him of neglecting Amber while she needed treatment and help.
This, she's so narcissistic that she can't let herself admit any amount of fault or mistake about anything ever. Honestly that's what lost her the case.
I think she has too much to lose. If she keeps denying everything there will still be a few people who believe her and support her. Personally, I think there would be people there to support her if she admitted guilt, but I don't think she knows that. This is a very lonely person.
Indeed.. but what's Even More annoying is that her lawyers kept repeating Over & Over how SHE took responsibility for EVERYTHING & how JD didn't take responsibility for ANYTHING... When he damn well did & she damn well did not.
Morgan Tremaine of TMZ was devastating, He said things every person can understand and tied together Amber's character and the accusations against Johnny when he talked of the video sent to the TMZ drop box featuring Johnny. Mr Tremaine said that it was online in 15v minutes and that this would never happen unless a principal provided it. Then Mr Tremaine said TMZ was tipped Amber would be at a courthouse getting a restraining order and a good pic would be found of her face. Then TMZ was tipped Amber would be at a lawyer's office for a deposition. Why would Johnny or his people tip TMZ about restraining order against him? It makes zero sense! It's obvious Johnny was not doing the tipping to TMZ. Morgan Tremaine is that witness that everyone can understand and he really made it clear JD was getting worked over big time.
He also casually murdered both amber and her entire legal team in his testimony (referring to Amber as a B-lister and noting that they must have took the case for clout), never let a Malfoy be a witness for the opposing side. 💀
The way she goes from "I didn't recognise that man", immediately to "How would he know? He wasn't there." says everything that needs to be said about Amber. When one little push doesn't work, she goes for a big one and gets very defensive.
When you see celebrities out (granted AH is no celeb), their faces are down, hair covering faces or faces blocked. In the TMZ video/pics, her hair is tucked behind her ear, face up and she keeps moving her head to the left to expose the right side. She totally set it up. She thinks we are all stupid.
That's an EXCELLENT call out! Most celebrities absolutely keep their head down when they aren't wanting to be seen or photographed! & ESPECIALLY if they are trying to hide a bruise or injury SOMETHING off or not normal on their body.
The most brilliant move Camille made was the pause after Amber admitted that the op-ed was about Johnny. It was the most beautiful moment of cross examination of a sociopath I've ever seen. Pausing, gave the whole world that moment of shock without giving Amber a chance to gaslight everyone about what she just said. And you could hear a pin drop across the world. Justice was coming. Finally. In a world of injustice and lies, truth was exposed. And Amber felt the earth move, but because Camille didn't tell her what she had just done, she went ahead feeling a bit confused, but not knowing what happened. Until it was too late. It sat there too long as truth. Like concrete, it set. And it was over.
I love how Camille points out that Amber and her legal team effectively committed perjury by submitting duplicate photographs for evidence which they testified depicted two separate incidents. Then Amber has the balls to accuse Camille of "hiding the metadata." It's so asinine that the judge literally tells her "That's how it was submitted into evidence." It kind of baffles me how insanely inept Amber and her Lawyers are, if the judge were to hand down summary judgement in favor of Depp at that point I don't think anyone would blame her.
THATS THE FUNNIEST PART. so so so much of the evidence Depp's lawyers used against Heard was "DEFENDENT EXHIBIT" MEANING AMBERS TEAMS. Thats so damn funny that she said about metadata that Camille "covered" but its her own evidence......
Camille did an interview afterwards saying she felt sorry for Elaine at times.. Elaine says “your honor I’m trying” Camille says she looked over and none of the attorneys were doing anything.
“Could we remove the metadata so we could get context?” Says the woman who said only a day prior “I would love to show the jury the picture. That’s not my job.” 😂 Amber Heard, Schmitigation Litigation Attorney of the Year, 2022
I studied criminology in university and would always get bored half to death watching any court proceedings, but watching Johnny’s and Amber’s attorneys somehow made it fun. You can see the clear distinction between minimally meeting expectations and excellence.
19:50 - See the bruise? You're all completely delusional. Can't you see the completely invisible bruise beneath the completely invisible layer of makeup? What's wrong with you people!!
Good point! I think it also shows the difference between a team who really work well together (Jd's) & a team that seem disorganised and scattered. Elaine & Rottenborn don't even gel in their questioning, & Elaine was all over the place (her closing was atrocious).
@@bwenluck9812 I think she wanted to imply that Dr. Curry was bought off. She ended up sounding rediculous. I wonder how the judges see all of this. They should have been in and out in 15min. That makes me worry.
@@nela3986 that and breaching the confidentiality agreement. She was inferring that Dr Curry had told her husband about the case just because he had gotten muffins for their meeting. Just because he got muffins for her meeting doesn't mean anything. So it's utterly ridiculous
Camille was the most aggressive and hard hitting compared to her male counterpart team. She was the gem of Depp’s team. It’s great to watch a well prepared lawyer do her job so well.
Which is intentional. Wayne Dennison, who does the cross for the experts, comes off as jovial, aloof, perhaps even slightly slow. But he absolutely dismantled experts by asking the right questions and staying calm while he provokes them. Camille Vasquez counters Amber. Then Ben Chew brings in the factual evidence and lays the foundation for them both.
Camille Vasquez was best when involved with female witnesses for sure, and that was intended. But Wayne Denison is the guy who tore apart the experts, including people like Dr. Speigel. And Ben Chew was the guy who laid the foundation and narrative with poise, calm, and certainty. That entire firm deserves accolades.
Of course, she has been there with Johnny since the UK trial. She knows everything. She has worked on this trial for years. She knows the evidence that was presented, she knows the evidence that were not presented. She was waiting and waiting for this opportunity. Her years of hard work are now paying off.
It was strategic. The males of the team made sure they appeared agreeable. Camille was used to prod at Amber who would be jealous of another woman being sat beside Johnny and the fact that another beautiful woman is questioning her and calling her a liar. Amber is used to taking this role
Cmon now Amber is a unique victim the kind that beats her abuser and calls them a baby for complaining for it and does the joker laugh while mocking them without any fear of getting the absolute shit beat out of her. A true unicorn
And you wouldn't even been able to leave that easy either! She will destroy your life if you choose to have nothing to do with her as she would take that as a rejection!
I believe JD was going through a mid life crisis . He was captivated by BEAUTY and YOUTH ? There’s a lot said about mature , older , and established women that gives true radiance , and knows what TRUE LOVE is , NOT ALL women or men know what love is . ! True healing comes from God since he created man ! To deny God is to deny existence period ! What is it to gain the world but to loose your soul
Honestly it's probably worse than a nightmare, I would imagine it's something equivalent to hell! I would wish something like her on my worst enemies, but that's because I'm a huge bitch, mega cμn+, and I believe she's a thousand times worse than me!
It really surprises me that she didn’t break down during this. If I had a lawyer hammer into me that way, trying to make me out to be a liar and my story untrue, I would start crying. If any of this was true and people were lying she would have some kind of emotional reaction. Flinching, shaking her head, bowing her head down, tears. She sat the entire time while these people supposedly lied on the stand with no reaction. Just stone faced or a smirk. And all she did this time was argue and get frustrated. Come on, she honestly wants us to believe she is a victim?
Right? She was defensive the whole time. If a lawyer was telling me I lied about my abuse and that I was the abuser, I’d break down at some point, listening to them dismiss my trauma and even turn it on me.
She wouldn't do that cause that would be a sign of weakness in her eyes. Camille became her automatic biggest nemesis in that court room. She was this smart woman spending time with Johnny while he completely ignored her. If it would have been a man questioning her, she would have brought the waterworks. She has traits of narcisism. She wanted to " prove" she was smarter than Camille.
Well i thought amber would break but more like a blow up/ get up and scream at camille after camille pushed her this much. (Im sure she had a burning rage inside tho)
Agree - I've heard cops say that one way they know someone is likely to be guilty is that a person who is falsely accused generally reacts in an angry or outraged manner. They don't just sit and play smart-ass with their accuser like Amber did. So coolness under questioning is a sign of guilt, not innocence. Also like you say, if she was as abused and traumatised (with PTSD, like she said) we would have seen some fear or breakdown in the presence of her alleged abuser (Johnny) and his attack dogs (Vazquez and Chew) but instead, we saw defiance and bare-faced lying as if she were the guilty one and she was showing how smart she was outwitting them. Amber gave herself away with her bad acting and her arrogance that she could fool everyone...
Not being believed, when you're 100% telling the truth is genuinely one of the most frustrating things, any human being can deal with, and can get so many different emotions running all at once, but she has none of that
Retired court transcriber here...having daily transcripts means that there's a team of transcribers working throughout the day and late at night to publish them. The lawyers and their teams would have spent many hours combing through, discussing and organizing the exhibits. Exhausting all around but we can see the results here.
@@sundiverjl I noticed that as well. She truly cannot tolerate anyone receiving any type of accolade for anything any type of attention that’s not directed to amber. This is the fear in feeling in regards to her having a daughter now. You cannot be a decent loving kind mother if your self centered and if your jealous. I’ve read countless comments since this trial started of women and men claiming that their own mothers were so similar to amber and they all say they suffered terribly and it was hard to recover and a lot are still now today in therapy due to their own mothers jealousy and need for attention. I hope I’m flat out wrong about amber or if I’m correct that she just accepts help. All she has to do is ask for help. It’s available.
This was masterful, Camille was pushing AH to get so worked up that she would blurt something out in her anger and she did! She admitted that she could have done a lot more damage by leaking videos but she didn’t, AFTER she claimed that she didn’t know how to leak things. That’s a “gotcha.”
Also, Camille was legitimately pissed off and you could see it. She is so frustrated with the games AH is playing. She was letting her have it. I'm sure it was cathartic.
Thank you for getting that she screwed up and admitted not only that she wrote the op ed, but why she wrote the op ed! None of the other lawyers I watch got the importance of that.
I think a lot of the lawyers didn't take it so seriously because they'd already drawn that conclusion themselves. Which is almost worse for AH. Her whole blow up wasn't surprising for anyone.
When she said I think Camille paused and thought if she said you slipped up again Amber would have just spun it around. The jury saw and heard her say it Camille was digging hard into her.
Want to know what she has in common with Johnny Depp? Neither one of them would p!ss on you if you were on fire. Johnny Depp isn’t your brother Johnny and Amber Heard isn’t the bitter ex wife you hate, they’re celebrities who couldn’t care less if you’re alive.
@@hurricaneharvey9053 Actually Johnny is known to be a very kind and charitable person. You are full of crap if you say he isn't. You sound bitter or jealous.
@@hurricaneharvey9053 it seems that you share that trait as well based on your statement here which you may says is not an accurate statement because of my limited knowledge of who you are, that said perhaps you should take some time and think on where that attitude stems from and how to heal. Or maybe you are just a troll either way best wishes and good day.
@@debbielockhart7762 You are right about ONE thing, Johnny Depp is known to be a very nice and kind person on a general basis, charitable as well…but then again most celebrities of that age/stature have learned to be after all those years. This is public information, just like some of his less favorable behavior that people like you chose to ignore. You can re-read my comment if you want the exact words, but what that was clearly intended to mean was that it’s really weird how hundreds if not thousands of you talk about “Johnny this and Amber that” as if they were your in-laws. 100% of us have no idea what actually happened between them yet 90% of people are siding with Johnny Depp because of some misguided sense of loyalty to someone who couldn’t care less if you wake up tomorrow. Was that clear enough?
I think Bruce is right. Amber defeated herself, not only by her lies but also by her snarky answers. I've sat on criminal juries. Amber is simply not a witness that jurors could sympathize with.
Camille outclassed AH to such an extreme, then wiped the floor with her. Everyone from AH on through her entire crew, friends, relatives all the experts, everyone had a definite sleaze factor. JD's team seemed trustworthy and genuine. I am hoping JD wins big and AH goes back to rum guzzling as she reportedly really enjoys..
In my opinion, I do think johnny wins this case. But I don't think he will get any money from this, my guess is the jury will make her pay the full 7 million she pledged on the childrens hospital, not the ACLU for they are as equally guilty in this trial.
Even better question, why would she “cover the bruise” the next day after the entire world seen it? Knowing she’d be photographed.. she had to know people would call her out on it. And I’m no expert in makeup.. but her trying to say she’s wearing makeup in all these photos kills me! I have yet to see one person that does makeup so flawlessly that they look natural!! And the only “natural looks” I have seen WOULD NOT cover a bruise 🙄
@B A That's why she's now known as "the Turd." Quite a feat actually. She's managed to make the word Turd mean something even worse than it already did, she actually managed to defame the name Turd.
AH: oh, the jurors are mostly male, there's a good chance they'll buy anything I say about make up People who use make up: you either look this natural by only wearing BB cream and powder or you maybe cover up a black eye and broken nose but look like a drag queen, babe
Now audio has been released of Amber telling Johnny the reason she started all these absurd lies is that she was afraid she would be evicted from the penthouse.
I think it was strategy that Vasquez was rather aggressiv. They knew AHs reaction. AH switched completely from crying to being aggressive herself. And she showed who she is actually to the jury.
It’s funny how Rottenborn’s closing arguments basically kept calling the jury ignorant by insinuating they wouldn’t be using proper common sense if they didn’t find in favor of Heard. 😂
Probably not the best move. Nothing about a case like this is “common sense”. It comes down to evidence, testimonies, and lack of evidence of alleged claims. Once you have all that information then you can use some what common sense to piece it all together which hopefully the jury has. That remark would be very annoying and disrespectful to those who have enough intelligence to see who’s fabricating the truth here which is clearly Heard. It would be like spitting in the jury’s face at that point
And he literally was saying everything that she was. He took responsibility for everything accept lies and texts that weren't his. She can't concede to anything.
This never gets old. It’s watching the train crash in slow motion. It’s telling that not one person, other than her lying sister, testified on her behalf about anything.
As Camille increases her pace of questioning Amber almost gets whiplash as she turns her head to engage the jury. She also took her right out of her “victim” role into combative and aggressive. All “signs” of PTSD and passivity have vanished.
She could’ve easily lost this trial just by answering every question by looking at the jury. Seriously, she came off so smug and self-assured by doing that. Why didn’t her lawyers tell her how bad that made her look? If I was on that jury I’d be like, stop looking at me already!!!!!
Ambers comment saying “what actual domestic violence survivor does that” sums up everything. It’s because she is not a survivor. She generalized and tried to smoke and mirror her comment.
That was my thought too, she's entirely correct in that no actual survivor or domestic violence would act the way she does, she's just not smart enough to realise that all the evidence thus proves that she's lying.
A good tip I learned during this trial : you can lie and commit perjury and nobody cares about it. When you testify under oath, you can cross your fingers in your pocket and then tell whatever suits you and you won't receive any penalty.
As someone who has had to go through family court with someone *JUST FUCKING LIKE HER*, it's the most satisfying thing to see her get exposed and trapped in her own lies... women like her honestly believe that they are the smartest people in the room, and that she can lie and charm their way out of the box they find themselves in. Always the victim** never the perpetrator, and they typically get away with this kind of shit. She never* thought johnny would take it this far, but again, forethought isn't her strong suit. Depp isn't even interested in the money, he knows he won't ever get it. It's clearing his name and showing that she is absolutely fucking nuts and exposing her for what she is.
My ex is just like her. And he's gotten away with most of what he's done to me and our child because he's an upstanding citizen, has a steady job, goes to church and knows how to charm people. I have social anxiety and only a few close friends. He banks on the fact that he can threaten me with the legal system and I will back down because I don't have the financial or emotional resources to defend myself.
@@zarrahprodan that's WHY your need a GOOD LAWYER. if money is an issue, as it is for all of us, go first to a women's services for any help and possible resources, ask around for lawyers who specialize in your type of case, seek pro bono ( Free ) help, join a support group so you can understand you're not alone let family and friend's know what you are going through, and love your family and child all you can. Also, start mentally preparing YOURSELF for a possible sad and bad outcome because you will need all your strength. Sound's like your ex expects to steamroll all over your, so surprise him by fighting back .. so surprise him ! ! !
💯% & I feel like that took a LOT of guys & bravery & honesty! Bc when you think about ALL the EXTREMELY private things that nobody would ever want splashed quite literally to every person in the 🌎, its mind-boggling! He had to open EVERY closet &show ALL the skeletons & relive some of the most humiliating things to again everybody & have it bed reshared, meme-d & immortalized ♾️! I can't imagine how HARD that would've been!
But from the beginning AH said the op Ed was about him. His lawyers emphasised his name wasn’t mentioned in the op Ed, but I think she was consistently conceding that this article was about JD.
@@karen-xv2wu Not sure now but I think you'll find early on in the case AH vehemently denied it was about JD. Number one, because if it was accepted that the Op-ed had nothing to do with JD, then why is JD in the court room at all. It's a small point anyway, compared with the truckload of BS that AH dumped on the court anyway.
I can't believe she dismissed Kate Moss as being someone "from the 90s" "coming out of the woodwork," as if Kate Moss is some old, washed up nobody. Girl, Kate Moss is only 12 years older than you and had achieved more fame by her teens than you have in your whole 20 year career!
She’s jealous at Kate Moss, Winona Ryder, Vanessa Paradis, her face when Ellen Barkin said she had a sexual relationship with Johnny was priceless. Amber didn’t like to hear that
If someone was trying to show I’m lying in front of the whole world and I was legitimately scared and hurt, even though it’s the lawyers job, and I get that, I would be in tears from fear and frustration. The fact she just argues and argues is not genuine
After a lifetime of watching crime shows and not fully understanding how things work in the courtroom, I really appreciate these analyses. It's so interesting to get insight on the court proceedings and strategies employed by both the plaintiff and the defense as well as the crucial blunders that are made.
I was never a JD die hard fan. I found out he was in one of my favorite movies (Donnie Brasco) after the trial started. But on the first day, I perceived this man to be truthful and sincere. I did not get the same feeling from Amber. I am thankful for the opportunity to watch the entire trial and get to my own conclusions. I support Johnny and see that it was a miracle for him to get out of there alive. That woman not only disrespected her husband and took advantage of his vulnerable moments, she could have killed him after draining everything he worked hard to earn. His work brought people enough positive experiences to give support back and even forgive his demons
Marvelous! Thank you for the adorable analysis. "Kate Moss came out of the woodwork, Miss Heard?" Camille masterfully maneuvered her nemesis onto thin ice with that one parry. Amber knew the sword was poised to make a wound if such insult that would fester. Heard deflected as well as she could. Camille cuts away like a brilliant surgeon. What a team!
Who else feels warm and fuzzy seeing a villain being taken down? I’m curious do you think Amber was honest with her lawyers or do you think she lied to her lawyers about what really happened?
She most likely told them one side and completely ignored anything that made her look bad. Most likely altered the narrative in her favour as per usual. I just find it insane that theres even the slightest chance that Amber might win. Completely mind boggling.
So what happened with the approach is, when Amber said "it doesn't work like that", there was a loud collective gasp in the court room. The jury and the "audience" in the gallery all gasped and if you check the video, even Johnny turned to look at the crowd. Rottenborn asked to approach, to complain to the judge that the gallery is influencing the jury and that she should clear the room. And that's why Judge A issued that warning to the gallery. It didn't really help their case as it made Ambers lawyers look like children throwing tantrums.
12:00 "Absolutely not, what *actual* survivor of domestic violence wants that?" I like how she just implied that she's not an actual survivor of domestic violence.
Bad foundations lead to a unsafe house, having Amber as a client was already a big hurdle for her team, and the fact her testimony just keeps getting more and more outlandish, Rottenborn and Elaine had to object sometimes just to get amber to shut up for a hot second
Not only did her hair distract me, but also the way she answered her questions AT the jury. I’ve been on a jury before, and the plaintiff always spoke to the person asking the questions. It had to be uncomfortable for the jurors since she kept trying to make eye contact with them. Her stalling every time she had to find a page was super obvious. It was really great to see her look right at, and answer Camille (to her face,) once the claws came out. That’s when Amber showed who she really is. And that anger was palpable! Once she got angry, she started to slip up - like admitting TWICE that she wrote the op-ed about Johnny. Camille tripped her and it was fantastic to watch.
This is actually the right thing to do TBH. She's a woman claiming to be abused, and she needs to connect with those jurors to get them on her side. The problem is it failed because she's not a believable, nice, person and instead of acting humble and like an actual victim, she came across as a bully. But it is the right thing to do, especially in a civil trial where the bar for conviction is MUCH LOWER, to try and get the jurors on your side. As Bruce says "That snarkiness is not making her likeable. And your client being liked by the jury is *critical* to your case." I think this was right, but the issue is she's just full of shit and aggressive as a result, so it didn't endear her at all. If she was a real victim and looked those jurors in the face while she went and testified that would resonate STRONGLY and connect with them. Unfortunately though is that it just wasn't true lol.
She says “I don’t know who that man was…” then two minutes later she says “He testified to only a light fixture being broken, just like his security guard sumed up my closet being rearranged…” lady you just said you didn’t know him!!!
I have always liked JD, but I wouldn't say I was a fan. I wouldn't go out of my way to see him in person. I didn't even know who AH was until this case, but I find myself going all in for JD because AH's testimony is so obviously phony!! I don't get why anyone would lie about such things, but she does!!
Sure, it was award winning. Haven't you heard of the Razzie (Golden Raspberry Award) & Golden Tomato (Rotten Tomato Award) for the worst cinematic/acting awards. She definitely would be nominated and take home the award!!
This isn't a criminal trial. Neither Heard nor Depp are accused of a crime. Amber has, however, admitted to several and been shown to have committed others. Depp has largely been exonerated of everything except struggling with substance abuse and being abusive to furniture. If I had to choose between someone who hits their spouse, and someone who hits their kitchen cupboard, I know who I would rather be around.
Its a defamation case. Its either one of them win and go home with the money or both of them loose.. defamation case is hard coz the jury has to come up w/ a decision based on common sense but still abiding legalities/law. And that makes it hard..
I think she did admit in previous trial that she wrote th Op-ed, but it wasnt meant for Johnny. Of course she denied wether she published it and also the title of that article. But this time she spilled the bean, it was about Johnny.
@@MdmChong惊人的 "The OP ed isnt about Johnny the only one who thinks its about him is Johnny" "The OP ed isnt just about Johnny" "He is a powerful man thats why i wrote the OP ed" Its actually funny how she keeps spewing bullshit but it becomes less of a lie gradually but never the actual truth lol im surprised she didnt go with the "I dont remember why i wrote it" or "I didnt know what it meant"
Can’t wait to see her face when she loses. She hasn’t a clue what real victims of domestic abuse endures. I know a survivor and she stills had nitemares and flashbacks. It never goes away even after years and councilling it’s hard to ever forget it. My stomache was sick looking at her faking it. It’s making a mockery of real victims. I believe Johnny. Yes he has his own issues but who hasn’t. Doesn’t make him a bad person or an abuser. I just hope d jury sees her for what she is. They have to !! Bst luck Johnny.
She did tell the truth on the day she described how she used her "bruise kit". She said she used it *over* her normal makeup. However, that is how a bruise is created. To hide a bruise, the "bruise kit" makeup would be used *under* her normal makeup.
When Camille started cross I was quite impressed with the setup she performed to allow the jury to see through the lies and over acting being performed. 🔥
No man could ever do that to a woman bcs she could scream se*ism. A woman’s rage is also very different to a mans. Which makes this whole thing soo satisfying to watch. A real woman destroying a lying woman.
I’ve noticed that Camille keeps up a fast pace - it means Amber has to make up lies really quickly and inevitably she’s going to trip herself up cos she doesn’t have time to think them through. It puts Camille under pressure too cos she has to be able to deal quickly with Ambers deflections, spot the contradictions and point them out clearly. So in a way it’s a battle of wits - who’s faster to the punch and who’s smarter…
That was Camilles whole strategy. Keep ramping up the speed, keeping her to answering the question then driving on with the next question. Increasing the speed of questions and ramping up the pressure.
Spot on. That's why Amber keeps asking to repeat questions, lines, pages etc. The pace is overwhelming her and she knows it.
Easy answer to who is smarter. Camille's left baby toe is smarter.
@@janbo8331 no lol she asks cuz she's thinking of her lie lol
Camille mentally ambushed Amber
I watched the trial at the time. Revisiting it so many months later, it is still a joy to watch Camille work. What a pro!
@johnnydeppofl, and I will continue to support you Johnny. I never believed a word "that woman" said.
@johnnydeppofl , I have been your fan since the Edward Scissor hand movie. You are. Awesome actor! Love you Johnny Depp 💖
@johnnydeppofl , I Will always believe in you and support you Johnny.
This isn't Johnny Depp. You are talking to a scammer! Johnny doesn't have telegram. These guys, scam money from people. Don't give any information@@dixiebuck-bartanen-pw9cz
It’s a wonderful display ain’t it 😂
The smugness on her face when she tries to act intelligent stating "if you remove the metadata". The way she stares and smiles at the jury when she says it makes me cringe. She actually thinks she's smarter than Camille
And the experts who testified you can't really do that.
🤣🤣
Love you bro🤣🤣
And when she lie..she though no one finds it out..but its 100% on showing on her face!! The way she move her lips and eyebrows..oh my god.. she never should play werewolf🤣🤣🤣
This is the most telling moment of the trial. It’s so obvious she’s sunk, and she knows it.
@@wom_Bat I>i
Don't forget that Camille was intentionally being combative to help bring out Heard's real personality. It definitely worked.
She was just doing her job. You can't just not challenge her on her lies and very weak points of her story.
@@bethanychatman9531 but if you watch her first round with amber she takes a very different approach. There’s also the fact that Camille got amber to basically admit one or two of the requirements of thing Johnny was sueing for. In the rebuttal amber admitted to the article being written by her and it being because of Johnny. After that as long as the jury believed that she was full of it there’s enough evidence to show she had malice(the legal definition of it) and well the rest is history so to speak.
She got made partner
If it was a man, Amber's true colours wouldn't have been shown and it would've played to her comments about men of power. That could've cost Johnny the case
Her whole attitude was great. She adopted this almost-bitchy, accusatory, brilliantly condescending tone. Camille was playing a character a bit (and doing a better job than that heard woman ever has), knowing heard would bitch and snark back because she couldn’t help herself and she’s too vapid and narcissistic to realise she was being skilfully baited. Thus showing who she really is and not the poor ickle victim she had been pretending to be. Once exposed the real heard was laid bare for all to see.
Its actually insulting to every person that’s watched this trial,she must think we’re all f-caking stupid,
well its modern day murca she still might win
Some unfortunately are stupid. She comes across as a sociopath.
I so agree with that. I said the same to my husband. People are not that stupid, but that still doesn't mean JD wins. However, she does think she is better than everyone else, so I suppose that it goes along with yes, she believes most people are stupid. It is very insulting!!!
Well kind of stupid to waste your time in watching others lifes
@@sachitagarwal8940 Kind of stupid for you to call others stupid just because they show an interest in this trial. Grow up.
Love the way Camille just walked away at the end. She wasn’t listening to any more of Amber’s self snitching.
I'm pro Johnny but Camille just walking away didn't sit well with me, I found it a bit unprofessional
@@ethelann I don't blame her I don't know she managed to stand there & listen to AH'S lies as long as she did!!!! AH is abnoxious!!!
@@beljw8749 I wasn't blaming her. Its just an observation
@@ethelann I don't think Camille did it for Amber or for the judge. It was definitely a calculated move to emphasize Amber's nonsense claims for the jury to see...
@@jojetparedes4024 Could be, but we'll never know unless Camille says so
“That’s why I wrote the op-Ed.”
I thought she testified that the op-Ed was not written about Johnny Depp and now suddenly it is.
Exactly! I caught that right away, Ms.Turd didn’t even realize what she did
She totally busted
yup. she said “it was never about johnny. johnny made it about johnny.” liaaarrrr
I love that Camille didn't stay on that point, but moved on. It denied Amber the chance to realise she slipped up, so that when she inevitably repeats the lie that the op-ed wasn't about Johnny, she further damages her own credibility.
Yes, she let it slip. Another lie exposed.
Ambers lawyer objecting to his own question was one of the funniest moments I'm justice system history.. 😂
It was funny. But, I have friends who are attys. They say it happens quite often. Especially when they are really working hard. They get into the narrative and just automatically object. They forget it's their question. lol lol
You’re absolutely right. If Ben Chew was hammering on her like that, she’d have a whole different demeanor and act like a bullied little damsel in distress, and then claim to be badgered by yet another man. We needed Camille to expose her bullshit on this and she did a good job.
I would like ben chew hammering on me... XD (sorry lol)
The troll is here again .......
@@jancril7505 😂
@@9teen9t4 w azad aaaaa!aapi are a
@The Amber Heard Playlist!! was it his wit? cause if so her attorney's were assaulted too.
She said “what actual survivor of domestic abuse wants that?” EXACTLY! An ACTUAL survivor wouldn’t. But she’s not an ACTUAL survivor.
She told on herself.
😂 not to mention the fact that she literally tried to be the face of representing DA… she keeps digging her self deeper
Gaslighting
@@lee-nationtv6954 and yet vehemently said she never wanted to be viewed as a victim of anything
If she lied, then it was because she's facing perhaps THE MOST powerful man in showbusiness. He beat her black and blue for five years. And she hid it, like IPV victims so often do, to protect him under the ethos of "until death"-romance. Johnny however, is lying about everything.
He isn't after the truth. He wants revenge. Revenge for his son getting confronted with Ambers article, and for his tanked career and for Amber leaving him and telling on him (covert narcissists can't accept being left). But the truth is that HE HIMSELF cause his career to crash with his boozing and drugs.
Man up and take responsibility, Johnny!
There were multiple fuckups from Amber during this trial. My top 10 would be:
- "Bruise kit" that didn't exist until 2017
- Overdramatic performance on direct exam (my dog stepped on a bee)
- Claiming that identical photos with different saturation were taken separately
- "I use pledged and donated synonymously"
- Referring to Kate Moss rumor
- Claiming that she only attacked Johnny in self defense seconds after playing audio with her saying: "I did start a physical fight"
- Two black eyes, split lip and a broken nose on Corden show
- Claiming she didn't notify TMZ after playing video from 2016 with her saying that "TMZ was alerted"
- Admitting that op-ed was about Johnny
- "I'm not sitting in this courtroom laughing, smiling, making snide jokes" saying the day after everyone saw her in the courtroom doing exactly that.
Exactly! And if she had just admitted to one thing like the TMZ crap she may have gained some credibility but her narcissistic personality didn’t allow her to own up to a thing!
Bruise kit does exist and its used in filmmaking/theatre to make fake bruises. So what she did is slip up. She pretty much said she used bruise kit. Which is why her bruises look fake. Also the way she described concealing the bruises doesn't add up, first you cover the bruise with the colour opposite of the spectrum (if the bruise is purpe you use green, if it's brownish you use yellow or so, not an expert), then concealer, then foundation and then you continue with your usual makeup. What she testified is that she used foundation, concealer then the bruise kit. Which is how you'd make bruises.
Also I think she's checking the internet for reactions because everyone called her on smirking in the courtroom and she addressed this without even being asked.
@@MyaB1986 i think the bruise kit refers to the amica cream to cover them up, which did not exist at the time and instead she used the flimaking kit to make fake bruises as you mentioned
Add "I don't know how to leak it" and "If I wanted to leak it I would've done a better job."
It’s kinda scary when I hear Camille say “Let’s refresh your recollection”. If I’m ever on the opposite side and she says that I’m confessing to my entire browsing history. She probably already knows it anyways.
Lol...alright Camille you got me. I'm guilty, murder this, kidnap that. Now to the important stuff,what day are you free for our dinner? 😆
This comment deserves more likes
@@brazenlilhussy5975 100% see you in 20 years boo.
worthy of a police grilling
@@brazenlilhussy5975 : I imagine Barney Stinson would say something like that if he met Camille. 😂
The social dynamics is that Camille sounds like she's tearing down a mean girl's lies and not letting her make excuses or manipulate others.
True, Camille sounds like the cool older sister, who's come to put the school yard bully back in line
I love it…. Bcus that’s exactly what she did! She confronted the team of the bullies and got schooled
Mollie Labelda~ Camillie slam dunk...
Mean Girl. 100%
@@MasterIceyy actually if you look at their age Camille is 2 years older than Ms. Heard, Camille was born in July 1984 and Ms. Heard in April 1986 so yes Camille is like an elder sister to Ms. Heard
Camille’s career as an attorney is undoubtably going to be SO successful after this trial!
And is obviously well deserved!
This proves you don’t need to go to Harvard Law to be a great lawyer- Go South West Law
I think she was already recognized as one of the most successful lawyers in the state
@@treborsirrah7916 i was gonna say, idk anything about it but she's like one of the main lawyers in johnny's team right? ben chew and her 2 are leading attorneys
She’s amazing!
@@sillybeans929 oh camille is an associate? since she led the cross i thought she was partner
im not really versed in this but ive watched Suits like 10 times. so she's like Mike, right. a junior associate? and she needs 5 10 years more experience plus paying the buy in to become a partner?
the overwhelming evidence against her and there's still ppl on HER side blows my mind
JD signed the papers where it says noone is making false claims with the intent to get money. JD also wrote those texts. AH is clearly someone who exaggerates and lies a lot but there’s some truth to it. He had much more control than her (he got her the role and wanted her out), but she’s stupid enough to ruin any credibility she has. It’s also the reason mainstream isn’t pro Depp because they know she’s an idiot and full of shit but there’s some truth in there.
It blows my mind that the jury didn’t come back with an answer already . That is worrisome to me
@@kadeelacayo4806 they start deliberation tmm
Exactly
There's people backing her?
"What actual survivor of domestic violence wants that?"
A moment of accidental honesty from Amber. She knows she's not an actual victim and that an actual victim would act nothing like her.
Nice catch 👌
That's totally reading into her response. She was actually claiming it as a label for herself.
@@latebloomer7191 If that were the case, then she wouldn't have used the word "actual." Because no one who is a survivor of domestic violence would refer to themselves as an "actual" survivor.
Right!? An “actual” survivor doesn’t. A woman with a huge payday looming and a publicist in tow, does! 😂
@@SentFromMyiPwn haha You got that right. Scamber is at it again.🤥🫣
Did she just manipulatively claim she cried on the stand? She didn't shed a single tear. The gaslighting is immense.
Another of her countless lies.😂
Judge Penny
‘Alright… crie..eh..redirect’
😂😂
She ain’t fooling no one
Eddie well said! She's awful, and soo obvious
Fake cries,like she knows her acting roles...🤔🧐
Not a SINGLE tear is right!
It's extremely hard not to be a bit in awe of how Camille handled herself throughout this entire trial. She was absolutely prepared well before stepping into the courtroom on day 1, and it was obvious.
The whole team was amazing. I remember a guy on the team also making a few brilliant plays.
I'm in awe as I gaze among them tots ladled up under all that
@@_Twink Yeah, the whole team did a great job, but Camille and Ben Chew were outstanding.
That’s why she made partner!! Total pro
She was amazing.
I never believed her (plenty of tapes and photos were out even before the trial) but I know one thing: if she were saying the truth and all of those witnesses truly did lie to side with Johnny, she would’ve broke down crying because of the insufferable injustice and despair she'd be feeling (as actual victims do), not getting snarky and argumentative on stand
You'd certainly think so.
Fair scenario, however she was caught lying so often, it's more likely she was lying 🤥
This right here! When I get mad, I cry lol. Not that I'd do this and that anyone would act like me, blah blah allegedly and my opinion and all that. But I'd be so upset and crying and hysterical if no one believed me when I was telling the truth. Something like that but unrelated happened to me where a doctor wouldn't believe me about something and I cried and cried because I was telling the truth. It was so frustrating!
@@TaurusWitch29I want to cry when I get mad too. 😂
Exactly!...
This lying, aggressive, abusive, sarcastic, and mean temperament on display is the real Amber Heard. Imagine living with this woman even for one day. Depp is a Saint.
I would be in jail
Nah. Depp is an asshole who married a spoiled brat for the superficial reason that she is young and beautiful. Depp also has a serious drug and alcohol problem.
Why do people have to be on one side or the other? Depp and Heard are disgusting human beings. Depp is a better actor but I couldn’t possibly say if he’s a better person. I suspect not.
That cooch must be divine if depp stayed with her for that long
Ehhh saint is quite a stretch. He’s definitely not.
@@SuperDan1006
I agree. Depp is an old druggie. But he’s a MUCH better actor than Heard.
Her attorneys didn't call witnesses because there weren't any. Then she admits the reason she wrote the article because she knew people would come out on Johnny's behalf. She "effectively" admitted to doing what she is being sued for, by admitting her reason for writing it. I hope the jury can see through it all.
They did interview "alot" of people 😕. But couldn't put them on the witness stand.
@@thumpymorrill8001 Thats not true, she had even her own witnesses disagree, if she had all these other witnesses they'd have been allowed like the ones Depp had, if they were relevant and could help the case. Also she apparently had "mountains of evidence" but if she did why didn't her lawyers use it?
Oh I think the jury do see this if most of the world sees it.
I’m sure they are very smart people that can see threw her crap.
when AH said "alot of people come out of the woodwork for the Johnny Depp show" I would have said "when you said Johnny grabbed that womans wrist and threatened to break it...how come she didn't come out of the woodwork to lie for Mr Depp? and don't answer that, cause she doesn't exist."
@@dawnwalker4574 but don't forget there are people who are unable to think outside their political beliefs and fully believe anything a woman says.
Starting at 31:17 is Camille’s superb finale. Here we get numerous dramatic moments where Amber’s testimony was impeached. Getting Amber to admit that she wrote the op-ed and that it was indeed about Johnny was a Perry Mason moment. I loved how Camille closed her binder and told the judge she had no further questions while Amber was still sputtering her response to seeing Johnny’s friend, Isaac Baruch, weep in the stand when recalling how destructive her actions were. That is where art meets real life. Bravo, Camille. 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Camille and Ben Chew in closing arguments were fantastic. I wasn't sure if JD will win this, but the story and the trial had such powerful effect I really think JD already won and jury decision doesn't matter.
Yup. Whether he wins the suit or not, the court of public opinion has largely spoken in his favor.
I was thinking the same thing before, but i think it actually matters a lot to all the men and also women who have been victims of actual abuse. Johnny actually needs this win for him and also to all victims.
If Depp doesn't win this it will be an overt obscenity.
Well that is 100 million .. that matters to JD and it would trigger more drinking and drugs that will kill him damaging his liver
@@helenike132 even if he loses or she wins, it's still in his favor, many who supports JD will EXPLODE because of injustice and unfairness
35:00 what I think the most brilliant thing though that Camille did here wasn't just to frustrate AH to the point where she admits to writing the Op Ed about JD, it's that she doesn't react to it. The previous times AH was caught in a trap, Camille called the juries attention to it, however if she called attention to this, AH might back out of it and say something like "I meant the type of person he is, the abusers that people like me have to face." By not mentioning it, and trusting that the jury heard and understood what she just said Camille doesn't allow AH the opportunity to back out. One of AHs strongest points was that she didn't mention JD by name in the article. And it got shattered. I believe that it was a key moment in JDs victory.
yup not nailing her there with the classic Dave Chapelle "gotcha bitch" was great strategy as you say and if memory serves they saved Oped "gotcha bitch" nailing for closing.
I don’t believe Amber understood what Camille and Morgan Tremaine the former TMZ guy did by him testifying that the actual person or her representatives notified TMZ it would take less time to publicize -15 minutes. Which was how long it took for TMZ to process the video she sent. By doing this they brilliantly avoided hearsay objections and trouble for Tremaine regarding his liability in disclosing her involvement. AH wasn’t smart enough to realize the damage that did. It proved she has no trouble lying under oath! She didn’t seem to understand but obviously the jury got it. Camille ran circles around Amber Heard.
I just love how Camille ended that "After what you have put him through and so many others with your lies"
That was just a beautiful note to end on after dismantling her
❤❤❤🥰. Cant stop watching it. So masterful done!
I think I have watched it more than 10 times,sooo beautiful
Amber’s gaslighting and stalling tactics that try to confuse Camille shows just how manipulative Amber is. This testimony is so telling. Amber looking at the jury the way she does is so manipulative. If i was a juror it would make me uncomfortable.
I know Amber was always gaslighting poor Johnny Depp!!
I agree, the endless hours of that woman's manic, darting eyes! She is performing for them! Look at me! Too bad she couldn't control the audiences in HER (if you please!) epic Aquaman movie from turning their eyes from the screen whenever she "acted" in a scene.
Those people have done the same... theres millions of similar fraudulant cases, many women done that, so they are protecting this shit bag
My theory is that her stalling is due to her reading the testimony to get her story straight, that’s why she could come back and say “I don’t know, I need the context.”
My other theory was that Camille being a strategic pick bc of her DV history of a female partner. She probably feels comfortable trying to push around another woman. And the strategy was probably to pull that part out of her and expose her true self.
I’m not that familiar with law, but this felt impactful in terms of how a juror may view this case.
If I were sitting in that jury box, I’d be afraid her glance would turn me to stone.
"I'm supposed to recognize a picture of some spilled wine on the floor? That's not how that works.." um, excuse me? This is your evidence that you submitted. You considered this so important that you meticulously photographed it at the time and saved it for almost 5 years to be used as evidence in a court trial. You testified to how traumatizing it was to deal the this "drugged up monster" version of your husband that you've accused of r*ping you with a bottle. This is serious shit, you can't claim that this is evidence in your 100 million dollar defamation trial, and completely dismiss the fact that you claimed the same photo is from two different events 6 months apart. It's your responsibility to know exactly what this photo is from, if you can't then don't submit it into evidence. We're supposed to take you seriously when you have a complete disregard for your own enormously contradictory evidence, and WTF WERE HER TEAM OF LAWYERS DOING WHEN THEY SUBMITTED THE SAME PHOTO AS EVIDENCE IN 2 DIFFERENT INCIDENTS?!? Can't stress how pitiful this whole thing is.
and how she's goes on about the " meta data" ( the word and term she learned the day before )
@@myshellee or how she tries to explain meta dat TO the jury bwahahaha She's a joke
@@_HimToo I know right! Lol
and even if she would be telling the truth about the woodwork thing, that also fell as she couldn't know about the TMZ guy, because his testimony was offered provided the judge gave him permission and struck the TMZ motion (so that, not even the judge knew what she was going to do about, cause the motion appeared and didn't exist until the TMZ former journalist was called to testify)
Kate Moss couldn't either, as her testimony was approved once AH herself opened that door, so that, BSBSBS...BS BS
@@myshellee She turns to the members of the jury: "You see, metadata is what allows..."
Camille: "Miss heard, stop mansplaining to the jury"
“Miss Heard, There’s no question pending”
~Miss Vasquez
"If I were Heard's lawyers, I'd've told her to give short, succinct answers."
Yeah. The problem is that she's uncontrollable. She just keeps going, and going, and going. She couldn't care less that she's in a courtroom under oath, or in a penthouse chasing Johnny around, or in Sea-Tac Int'l Airport with Tasya Vanree.
Yeah, she seems like your typical narcissist who thinks she's the smartest person in the room, at all times. So obviously the lawyers should take her lead... 😂😂
This is her last performance. She paid >6m for this moment. Let her lie.
😂😂 oh this cracked me up 😆
If she listens .. Remember she needed help and treatment from psychiatry
If I was her lawyer, I would have put JD in spot for marrying girl of daughter age as object to show off on red carpet. Prove that he ignored her, didn't spend time, no performance in bed so the poop and accuse him of neglecting Amber while she needed treatment and help.
The fact that she literally can’t concede to anything even when the truth is obvious is super annoying.
This, she's so narcissistic that she can't let herself admit any amount of fault or mistake about anything ever. Honestly that's what lost her the case.
I think she has too much to lose. If she keeps denying everything there will still be a few people who believe her and support her. Personally, I think there would be people there to support her if she admitted guilt, but I don't think she knows that. This is a very lonely person.
Yep, it's called gas-lighting.
@@thatsalt1560 well, that, and also perjury lol
Indeed.. but what's Even More annoying is that her lawyers kept repeating Over & Over how SHE took responsibility for EVERYTHING & how JD didn't take responsibility for ANYTHING... When he damn well did & she damn well did not.
Morgan Tremaine of TMZ was devastating, He said things every person can understand and tied together Amber's character and the accusations against Johnny when he talked of the video sent to the TMZ drop box featuring Johnny. Mr Tremaine said that it was online in 15v minutes and that this would never happen unless a principal provided it. Then Mr Tremaine said TMZ was tipped Amber would be at a courthouse getting a restraining order and a good pic would be found of her face. Then TMZ was tipped Amber would be at a lawyer's office for a deposition. Why would Johnny or his people tip TMZ about restraining order against him? It makes zero sense! It's obvious Johnny was not doing the tipping to TMZ. Morgan Tremaine is that witness that everyone can understand and he really made it clear JD was getting worked over big time.
Mhm, I was shocked they tried to imply Depp sent the paparazzi to the TRO and divorce filing. That makes absolutely no sense.
He also casually murdered both amber and her entire legal team in his testimony (referring to Amber as a B-lister and noting that they must have took the case for clout), never let a Malfoy be a witness for the opposing side. 💀
@@Blue.. 'never let a Malfoy be a witness for the opposing side.' lmaoo
when he said the video had to come from a news source his eyes were fixed on Amber :D
They why he just murder Elaine with his comeback was one of the best moments of the trial
The term pathological liar is thrown out a lot, but she truly is the definition and living embodiment of that condition.
The way she goes from "I didn't recognise that man", immediately to "How would he know? He wasn't there." says everything that needs to be said about Amber. When one little push doesn't work, she goes for a big one and gets very defensive.
Worse "So you're accusing him of perjury?" "How would he know he wasn't there"
I would have leaked much better than that , but I don't know how to leak...
She knew him down to his shirt it was black w holes she states it! Yet when he comes on the stand how would he know? I’ve never seen that man
She's so dismissive of people she views as beneath her. Johnny is no Saint, but she's extremely unlikable and unbelievable.
That “man” that she claims wasn’t there is the freaking owner of the motor homes in Hicksville. The blatant lies 🫣she’s so not credible.
When you see celebrities out (granted AH is no celeb), their faces are down, hair covering faces or faces blocked. In the TMZ video/pics, her hair is tucked behind her ear, face up and she keeps moving her head to the left to expose the right side. She totally set it up. She thinks we are all stupid.
That's an EXCELLENT call out! Most celebrities absolutely keep their head down when they aren't wanting to be seen or photographed! & ESPECIALLY if they are trying to hide a bruise or injury SOMETHING off or not normal on their body.
Johnny's right handed. Her bruise should be on her left side of her face
It was SOOOO obvious, even awkward the way she was moving her head as if she were saying “look here” 😂😂😂😂
Its so funny that she says everyone's lying when these people have absolutely nothing to gain but jail time for lying😂
Exactly tho💀
The most brilliant move Camille made was the pause after Amber admitted that the op-ed was about Johnny.
It was the most beautiful moment of cross examination of a sociopath I've ever seen.
Pausing, gave the whole world that moment of shock without giving Amber a chance to gaslight everyone about what she just said.
And you could hear a pin drop across the world.
Justice was coming.
Finally.
In a world of injustice and lies, truth was exposed.
And Amber felt the earth move, but because Camille didn't tell her what she had just done, she went ahead feeling a bit confused, but not knowing what happened. Until it was too late. It sat there too long as truth. Like concrete, it set.
And it was over.
this comment is beautifully written wow.
God damn dude that shit was as beautifully written as watching that exact moment your talking about
I came to say this comment was beautiful, I am apparently late to the party 😂
Are you an author? Because jeez that was so well done.
Beautifully written!!!!
I love how Camille points out that Amber and her legal team effectively committed perjury by submitting duplicate photographs for evidence which they testified depicted two separate incidents. Then Amber has the balls to accuse Camille of "hiding the metadata." It's so asinine that the judge literally tells her "That's how it was submitted into evidence." It kind of baffles me how insanely inept Amber and her Lawyers are, if the judge were to hand down summary judgement in favor of Depp at that point I don't think anyone would blame her.
THATS THE FUNNIEST PART. so so so much of the evidence Depp's lawyers used against Heard was "DEFENDENT EXHIBIT" MEANING AMBERS TEAMS. Thats so damn funny that she said about metadata that Camille "covered" but its her own evidence......
"miss Heard you might THINK you are an expert in everything but you are not on the stand as an expert metadata witness"
Camille did an interview afterwards saying she felt sorry for Elaine at times.. Elaine says “your honor I’m trying” Camille says she looked over and none of the attorneys were doing anything.
The photos were from her own side so if the metadata was redacted it was redacted by her and her team.
“Could we remove the metadata so we could get context?”
Says the woman who said only a day prior “I would love to show the jury the picture. That’s not my job.”
😂 Amber Heard, Schmitigation Litigation Attorney of the Year, 2022
I studied criminology in university and would always get bored half to death watching any court proceedings, but watching Johnny’s and Amber’s attorneys somehow made it fun. You can see the clear distinction between minimally meeting expectations and excellence.
19:50 - See the bruise? You're all completely delusional. Can't you see the completely invisible bruise beneath the completely invisible layer of makeup? What's wrong with you people!!
Good point! I think it also shows the difference between a team who really work well together (Jd's) & a team that seem disorganised and scattered. Elaine & Rottenborn don't even gel in their questioning, & Elaine was all over the place (her closing was atrocious).
Does anyone know where Elaine was going with her "muffin" line of questioning? And her questioning of "dinner and drinks"????
@@bwenluck9812 I think she wanted to imply that Dr. Curry was bought off. She ended up sounding rediculous.
I wonder how the judges see all of this. They should have been in and out in 15min. That makes me worry.
@@nela3986 that and breaching the confidentiality agreement. She was inferring that Dr Curry had told her husband about the case just because he had gotten muffins for their meeting. Just because he got muffins for her meeting doesn't mean anything. So it's utterly ridiculous
Camille was the most aggressive and hard hitting compared to her male counterpart team. She was the gem of Depp’s team. It’s great to watch a well prepared lawyer do her job so well.
But I think it would be unwise for the legal team to have the same type if lawyer representing Johnny
Which is intentional. Wayne Dennison, who does the cross for the experts, comes off as jovial, aloof, perhaps even slightly slow. But he absolutely dismantled experts by asking the right questions and staying calm while he provokes them. Camille Vasquez counters Amber. Then Ben Chew brings in the factual evidence and lays the foundation for them both.
Camille Vasquez was best when involved with female witnesses for sure, and that was intended.
But Wayne Denison is the guy who tore apart the experts, including people like Dr. Speigel.
And Ben Chew was the guy who laid the foundation and narrative with poise, calm, and certainty.
That entire firm deserves accolades.
Of course, she has been there with Johnny since the UK trial. She knows everything.
She has worked on this trial for years.
She knows the evidence that was presented, she knows the evidence that were not presented.
She was waiting and waiting for this opportunity.
Her years of hard work are now paying off.
It was strategic. The males of the team made sure they appeared agreeable. Camille was used to prod at Amber who would be jealous of another woman being sat beside Johnny and the fact that another beautiful woman is questioning her and calling her a liar. Amber is used to taking this role
Camille went SO HARD in this cross. It was like watching Picasso paint.
"What actual survivor of domestic abuse wants that?"
Exactly, Amber.
When I was watching this I was also like "yeah, good question Amber. That's what we're asking ourselves as well." That last day was such a self-own.
When she said that, i said to myself, exactly. You're not an actual victim of DV
Cmon now Amber is a unique victim the kind that beats her abuser and calls them a baby for complaining for it and does the joker laugh while mocking them without any fear of getting the absolute shit beat out of her. A true unicorn
@@deathitself6985 Don't forget gifting him a giant knife that literally read "hasta la muerte", "until death".
@@deathitself6985 Exactly, I guess another word for abuser is "imperfect victim" nowadays. At least according to news articles.
Amber is full of aggression and arrogance and is never in the wrong! I'd imagine being married to someone like this is a complete nightmare!
And you wouldn't even been able to leave that easy either! She will destroy your life if you choose to have nothing to do with her as she would take that as a rejection!
I was married to somebody this arrogant, maybe not so aggressive, but this is totally the same attitude. This reminds me of her so much
Exactly!
I believe JD was going through a mid life crisis . He was captivated by BEAUTY and YOUTH ? There’s a lot said about mature , older , and established women that gives true radiance , and knows what TRUE LOVE is , NOT ALL women or men know what love is . !
True healing comes from God since he created man ! To deny God is to deny existence period !
What is it to gain the world but to loose your soul
Honestly it's probably worse than a nightmare, I would imagine it's something equivalent to hell! I would wish something like her on my worst enemies, but that's because I'm a huge bitch, mega cμn+, and I believe she's a thousand times worse than me!
It really surprises me that she didn’t break down during this. If I had a lawyer hammer into me that way, trying to make me out to be a liar and my story untrue, I would start crying. If any of this was true and people were lying she would have some kind of emotional reaction. Flinching, shaking her head, bowing her head down, tears. She sat the entire time while these people supposedly lied on the stand with no reaction. Just stone faced or a smirk. And all she did this time was argue and get frustrated. Come on, she honestly wants us to believe she is a victim?
Right? She was defensive the whole time. If a lawyer was telling me I lied about my abuse and that I was the abuser, I’d break down at some point, listening to them dismiss my trauma and even turn it on me.
She wouldn't do that cause that would be a sign of weakness in her eyes. Camille became her automatic biggest nemesis in that court room. She was this smart woman spending time with Johnny while he completely ignored her. If it would have been a man questioning her, she would have brought the waterworks. She has traits of narcisism. She wanted to " prove" she was smarter than Camille.
Well i thought amber would break but more like a blow up/ get up and scream at camille after camille pushed her this much. (Im sure she had a burning rage inside tho)
Agree - I've heard cops say that one way they know someone is likely to be guilty is that a person who is falsely accused generally reacts in an angry or outraged manner. They don't just sit and play smart-ass with their accuser like Amber did. So coolness under questioning is a sign of guilt, not innocence. Also like you say, if she was as abused and traumatised (with PTSD, like she said) we would have seen some fear or breakdown in the presence of her alleged abuser (Johnny) and his attack dogs (Vazquez and Chew) but instead, we saw defiance and bare-faced lying as if she were the guilty one and she was showing how smart she was outwitting them. Amber gave herself away with her bad acting and her arrogance that she could fool everyone...
Not being believed, when you're 100% telling the truth is genuinely one of the most frustrating things, any human being can deal with, and can get so many different emotions running all at once, but she has none of that
26:22 "No, I didn't ask you about anything."
Pure gold reply.
Why on earth would amber and her lawyers think using the same pictures for different supposed incidences would not get noticed by anyone? Wtf
Retired court transcriber here...having daily transcripts means that there's a team of transcribers working throughout the day and late at night to publish them. The lawyers and their teams would have spent many hours combing through, discussing and organizing the exhibits. Exhausting all around but we can see the results here.
It was so petty that A.H. refused to clap even everyone else was clapping to thank the court workers
@@sundiverjl I noticed that as well. She truly cannot tolerate anyone receiving any type of accolade for anything any type of attention that’s not directed to amber. This is the fear in feeling in regards to her having a daughter now. You cannot be a decent loving kind mother if your self centered and if your jealous. I’ve read countless comments since this trial started of women and men claiming that their own mothers were so similar to amber and they all say they suffered terribly and it was hard to recover and a lot are still now today in therapy due to their own mothers jealousy and need for attention. I hope I’m flat out wrong about amber or if I’m correct that she just accepts help. All she has to do is ask for help. It’s available.
@@sundiverjl Yes! Probably never occurred to her. They're the invisible backbone of the whole process and I'm sure it felt great to be recognized.
I wondered about that! Those transcripts are huge.
I wouldn’t clap if those transcript is against me, call me selfish #amberturd, #nevermyfault.
This was masterful, Camille was pushing AH to get so worked up that she would blurt something out in her anger and she did! She admitted that she could have done a lot more damage by leaking videos but she didn’t, AFTER she claimed that she didn’t know how to leak things. That’s a “gotcha.”
Along with getting her to admit writing the op-ed & why she wrote it!!!!
Also, Camille was legitimately pissed off and you could see it. She is so frustrated with the games AH is playing. She was letting her have it. I'm sure it was cathartic.
@@Rae777 I mean she was obviously lying and contradicting herself
Exactly!That was a genius strategy of Camille and works specially well with aggressive arrogant people full of them selves like AH!
And she admitted that the op-ed was about him.
“Everyone is full of shit except for me, can’t you see that?” 😂💀
" I'm a public figure" Yeah, Ok, no one even knew who you were before this trial.
EXACTLY 💯
Thank you for getting that she screwed up and admitted not only that she wrote the op ed, but why she wrote the op ed! None of the other lawyers I watch got the importance of that.
I think a lot of the lawyers didn't take it so seriously because they'd already drawn that conclusion themselves. Which is almost worse for AH. Her whole blow up wasn't surprising for anyone.
What other lawyers do you watch
Ben Chew ended up mentioning it in the closing!
When she said I think Camille paused and thought if she said you slipped up again Amber would have just spun it around. The jury saw and heard her say it Camille was digging hard into her.
@@TimeToGoo Rekieta Law, Emily Baker, Good Lawgic
I would have felt so uncomfortable as a juror with her constantly looking at me as she answers questions
The way Heard acts, even when she´s caught in a lie, is so typical for a person with borderline and/or narsacistic disorder!
Want to know what she has in common with Johnny Depp? Neither one of them would p!ss on you if you were on fire. Johnny Depp isn’t your brother Johnny and Amber Heard isn’t the bitter ex wife you hate, they’re celebrities who couldn’t care less if you’re alive.
@@hurricaneharvey9053 Cool it with the pessimistic remarks, it's just an assessment....
@@hurricaneharvey9053 Actually Johnny is known to be a very kind and charitable person. You are full of crap if you say he isn't. You sound bitter or jealous.
@@hurricaneharvey9053 it seems that you share that trait as well based on your statement here which you may says is not an accurate statement because of my limited knowledge of who you are, that said perhaps you should take some time and think on where that attitude stems from and how to heal. Or maybe you are just a troll either way best wishes and good day.
@@debbielockhart7762 You are right about ONE thing, Johnny Depp is known to be a very nice and kind person on a general basis, charitable as well…but then again most celebrities of that age/stature have learned to be after all those years. This is public information, just like some of his less favorable behavior that people like you chose to ignore. You can re-read my comment if you want the exact words, but what that was clearly intended to mean was that it’s really weird how hundreds if not thousands of you talk about “Johnny this and Amber that” as if they were your in-laws. 100% of us have no idea what actually happened between them yet 90% of people are siding with Johnny Depp because of some misguided sense of loyalty to someone who couldn’t care less if you wake up tomorrow. Was that clear enough?
She’s convinced herself that she’s correct on everything.
Ha Ha Ha that's a good one
Pathological liar who is absolutely DELUSIONAL
She lives in a different reality.
That’s what COMPULSIVE LIARS do.
Nah, she's too scared to be proven wrong after she opened that can of mega-worms.
Crazy how she went from emotional when her team was asking questions to argumentative when Depps team started.
and vice versa
Perfect memory at times for her team spotty memory for JDs team
I think Bruce is right. Amber defeated herself, not only by her lies but also by her snarky answers. I've sat on criminal juries. Amber is simply not a witness that jurors could sympathize with.
Camille outclassed AH to such an extreme, then wiped the floor with her. Everyone from AH on through her entire crew, friends, relatives all the experts, everyone had a definite sleaze factor. JD's team seemed trustworthy and genuine. I am hoping JD wins big and AH goes back to rum guzzling as she reportedly really enjoys..
In my opinion, I do think johnny wins this case. But I don't think he will get any money from this, my guess is the jury will make her pay the full 7 million she pledged on the childrens hospital, not the ACLU for they are as equally guilty in this trial.
no, she'll use her baby who's probably Elon's kid from the embryo they fought about and ask for more money that she will pledge to be a child support
@@justaverage7610 I think that donation money is still her money so it doesn't seem fair to give such an order even if she pledged or whatever
@@nayannbg6314 is it her money though? Or is it Johnny's 🤔
It made me laugh on the closing when they stop trying to convince she didn't wrote it about JD but brought up the freedom of speech
"let's see if we can refresh your recollection" 😂 I love Camille. She's a beast!
Even better question, why would she “cover the bruise” the next day after the entire world seen it? Knowing she’d be photographed.. she had to know people would call her out on it. And I’m no expert in makeup.. but her trying to say she’s wearing makeup in all these photos kills me! I have yet to see one person that does makeup so flawlessly that they look natural!! And the only “natural looks” I have seen WOULD NOT cover a bruise 🙄
Bingo
exactlyyyy
@B A That's why she's now known as "the Turd."
Quite a feat actually.
She's managed to make the word Turd mean something even worse than it already did, she actually managed to defame the name Turd.
Natural makeup!! Heavy foundation on a woman you will know this chick barely smeared anything on her 20’s like ok 🤺
AH: oh, the jurors are mostly male, there's a good chance they'll buy anything I say about make up
People who use make up: you either look this natural by only wearing BB cream and powder or you maybe cover up a black eye and broken nose but look like a drag queen, babe
Now audio has been released of Amber telling Johnny the reason she started all these absurd lies is that she was afraid she would be evicted from the penthouse.
I like the way Camille's questions end with "Didn't you?" "Weren't you?" "Isn't that correct?" 😂
That's how cross-examination works. You leave as little room as possible for the witness to editorialize.
"Right?" 🤣😅😂
I think it was strategy that Vasquez was rather aggressiv. They knew AHs reaction. AH switched completely from crying to being aggressive herself. And she showed who she is actually to the jury.
It’s funny how Rottenborn’s closing arguments basically kept calling the jury ignorant by insinuating they wouldn’t be using proper common sense if they didn’t find in favor of Heard. 😂
To be fair though, he was attempting to make pottery out of dog crap :)
Probably not the best move. Nothing about a case like this is “common sense”. It comes down to evidence, testimonies, and lack of evidence of alleged claims. Once you have all that information then you can use some what common sense to piece it all together which hopefully the jury has. That remark would be very annoying and disrespectful to those who have enough intelligence to see who’s fabricating the truth here which is clearly Heard. It would be like spitting in the jury’s face at that point
He was born rotten what else can you expect ?
@@st6086 Haha you mean 'Amber crap' literally!
And he literally was saying everything that she was. He took responsibility for everything accept lies and texts that weren't his. She can't concede to anything.
This never gets old.
It’s watching the train crash in slow motion. It’s telling that not one person, other than her lying sister, testified on her behalf about anything.
@Johnnydepp26 you’re welcome, spammer
I watch this over and over and over. It never gets old
Having Camille Vasquez cross examine Amber Heard is like watching _"The Revenge of the Smart Girls Against the Mean Girls."_
The best virally 😂😂always my favourite parts of the trial
Camille was setting her up for the closing.
and the process is a masterpiece
As Camille increases her pace of questioning Amber almost gets whiplash as she turns her head to engage the jury.
She also took her right out of her “victim” role into combative and aggressive. All “signs” of PTSD and passivity have vanished.
She could’ve easily lost this trial just by answering every question by looking at the jury. Seriously, she came off so smug and self-assured by doing that. Why didn’t her lawyers tell her how bad that made her look? If I was on that jury I’d be like, stop looking at me already!!!!!
Her lawyers were probably scared shitless of her 😂
Yeah if I were on that jury constantly being looked at like that would make me uncomfortable to say the least, it was manipulative and intimidating.
She listens to no one as the Monstrous Narc she is
@@bakedogg98one of the jurors spoke out about that very thing . He said they were so annoyed by her doing that they stopped looking at her .
Ambers comment saying “what actual domestic violence survivor does that” sums up everything. It’s because she is not a survivor. She generalized and tried to smoke and mirror her comment.
Exactly!!!
That was my thought too, she's entirely correct in that no actual survivor or domestic violence would act the way she does, she's just not smart enough to realise that all the evidence thus proves that she's lying.
It's also weird wording for a survivor to use. She distances her self from the identity of a survivor by saying "actual survivor" like she isn't one.
@@amberhanlon8973 Indeed. Its a very damning statement
From her survivor research but no personal experience
That little snarl when she talks about bringing her publicist with her ' in case ' was a real flash of 2016 Amber deposition.
As if she was actually a public figure lmfao. She needs to get over herself
@@Grant849 I've never heard of amber before now
@@Grant849 uhp
She showed her nasty side
It's amazing how AH is so aggressive and confrontational not just to Camille but also the jury.
A good tip I learned during this trial : you can lie and commit perjury and nobody cares about it. When you testify under oath, you can cross your fingers in your pocket and then tell whatever suits you and you won't receive any penalty.
Only if you’re rich and famous though! Not for us peasants…
As someone who has had to go through family court with someone *JUST FUCKING LIKE HER*, it's the most satisfying thing to see her get exposed and trapped in her own lies... women like her honestly believe that they are the smartest people in the room, and that she can lie and charm their way out of the box they find themselves in. Always the victim** never the perpetrator, and they typically get away with this kind of shit.
She never* thought johnny would take it this far, but again, forethought isn't her strong suit. Depp isn't even interested in the money, he knows he won't ever get it. It's clearing his name and showing that she is absolutely fucking nuts and exposing her for what she is.
Sorry you had to experience a person like that. I can't imagine. Glad they got exposed.
My ex is just like her. And he's gotten away with most of what he's done to me and our child because he's an upstanding citizen, has a steady job, goes to church and knows how to charm people. I have social anxiety and only a few close friends. He banks on the fact that he can threaten me with the legal system and I will back down because I don't have the financial or emotional resources to defend myself.
@@zarrahprodan that's WHY your need a GOOD LAWYER. if money is an issue, as it is for all of us, go first to a women's services for any help and possible resources, ask around for lawyers who specialize in your type of case, seek pro bono ( Free ) help, join a support group so you can understand you're not alone let family and friend's know what you are going through, and love your family and child all you can. Also, start mentally preparing YOURSELF for a possible sad and bad outcome because you will need all your strength. Sound's like your ex expects to steamroll all over your, so surprise him by fighting back .. so surprise him ! ! !
@@servraghgiorsal7382 I've done all of what you've suggested.
💯% & I feel like that took a LOT of guys & bravery & honesty! Bc when you think about ALL the EXTREMELY private things that nobody would ever want splashed quite literally to every person in the 🌎, its mind-boggling! He had to open EVERY closet &show ALL the skeletons & relive some of the most humiliating things to again everybody & have it bed reshared, meme-d & immortalized ♾️! I can't imagine how HARD that would've been!
Absolutely! She claimed the op-ed was never about JD and convicts herself by admitting it was.
But from the beginning AH said the op Ed was about him. His lawyers emphasised his name wasn’t mentioned in the op Ed, but I think she was consistently conceding that this article was about JD.
@@karen-xv2wu Not sure now but I think you'll find early on in the case AH vehemently denied it was about JD.
Number one, because if it was accepted that the Op-ed had nothing to do with JD, then why is JD in the court room at all. It's a small point anyway, compared with the truckload of BS that AH dumped on the court anyway.
I know . It echoes in my head. She tossed the rope around her neck. Car-Ma baby..
She called him conceited or vain for thinking it was about him
Amber has proven Depp's case for him !
I can't believe she dismissed Kate Moss as being someone "from the 90s" "coming out of the woodwork," as if Kate Moss is some old, washed up nobody.
Girl, Kate Moss is only 12 years older than you and had achieved more fame by her teens than you have in your whole 20 year career!
Her disrespect is very telling
I picked up on that too! So snarky and disrespectful towards Kate Moss.. “ from the 90’s” girl PLEASE! Ambers jealousy is so obvious
She’s jealous at Kate Moss, Winona Ryder, Vanessa Paradis, her face when Ellen Barkin said she had a sexual relationship with Johnny was priceless. Amber didn’t like to hear that
If someone was trying to show I’m lying in front of the whole world and I was legitimately scared and hurt, even though it’s the lawyers job, and I get that, I would be in tears from fear and frustration. The fact she just argues and argues is not genuine
After a lifetime of watching crime shows and not fully understanding how things work in the courtroom, I really appreciate these analyses. It's so interesting to get insight on the court proceedings and strategies employed by both the plaintiff and the defense as well as the crucial blunders that are made.
I was never a JD die hard fan. I found out he was in one of my favorite movies (Donnie Brasco) after the trial started. But on the first day, I perceived this man to be truthful and sincere. I did not get the same feeling from Amber. I am thankful for the opportunity to watch the entire trial and get to my own conclusions. I support Johnny and see that it was a miracle for him to get out of there alive. That woman not only disrespected her husband and took advantage of his vulnerable moments, she could have killed him after draining everything he worked hard to earn.
His work brought people enough positive experiences to give support back and even forgive his demons
Donnie Brasco such a great movie
In it! He was the lead actor (with Al Pacino).
You didn’t realize that Johnny Depp had the lead role in one of your favorite movies??? 🤔🤷🏽♀️
@@TheBerkeleyBeauty I didn't either. Just found out just now. Who did he play?
@@mikejunker1163 JD was Donnie Brasco. Lead role⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Marvelous! Thank you for the adorable analysis. "Kate Moss came out of the woodwork, Miss Heard?" Camille masterfully maneuvered her nemesis onto thin ice with that one parry. Amber knew the sword was poised to make a wound if such insult that would fester. Heard deflected as well as she could. Camille cuts away like a brilliant surgeon. What a team!
Talk about coming out of the woodwork …. Ellen Barkin for the defense!
We need more lawyers like Camille.
She can destroy an abusive woman like no man could.
A woman destroying another woman like that… hypnotizing.
Who else feels warm and fuzzy seeing a villain being taken down? I’m curious do you think Amber was honest with her lawyers or do you think she lied to her lawyers about what really happened?
No, why would I feel warm and fuzzy about all this pain? I don't think she was honest with her lawyers. I don't think she is able to be honest.
She most likely told them one side and completely ignored anything that made her look bad. Most likely altered the narrative in her favour as per usual. I just find it insane that theres even the slightest chance that Amber might win. Completely mind boggling.
everything she does is for show. smirking, crying, writing post-it notes. all fake. she is sick in the head.
Lied!!! Lied!!! Lied!!! Lied!!! LIED!!!
I'm thinking turds lawyers are wishing their office had been closed the day they got the phone call
"Everyone But Me is a Liar: The Amber Heard Guide to Legal Defense"
Lol
I needed a laugh, this is hilarious!
The quick way to lose a trial
So what happened with the approach is, when Amber said "it doesn't work like that", there was a loud collective gasp in the court room. The jury and the "audience" in the gallery all gasped and if you check the video, even Johnny turned to look at the crowd. Rottenborn asked to approach, to complain to the judge that the gallery is influencing the jury and that she should clear the room. And that's why Judge A issued that warning to the gallery. It didn't really help their case as it made Ambers lawyers look like children throwing tantrums.
They all deserve each other.... spoilt brats
Thank you. I have always wondered what that was about. I thought Rottenborn was making something up to give Amber time to collect herself.
Why didn't she throw out the guy who coughed throughout the trial spreading germs probably a lawyer and Elaines Michael was off all the time
That page flip she does to end the cross examination was awesome 😂
12:00 "Absolutely not, what *actual* survivor of domestic violence wants that?"
I like how she just implied that she's not an actual survivor of domestic violence.
Amber had a tendency to say the quiet part out loud. Absolute clown ass abuser
Based on what we know about Amber, my guess is that her lawyers had very little control over what was happening in that courtroom.
Bad foundations lead to a unsafe house, having Amber as a client was already a big hurdle for her team, and the fact her testimony just keeps getting more and more outlandish, Rottenborn and Elaine had to object sometimes just to get amber to shut up for a hot second
I wonder if her lawyers believed Amber was truly a victim of DV or If they knew it was all a lie.
Not only did her hair distract me, but also the way she answered her questions AT the jury. I’ve been on a jury before, and the plaintiff always spoke to the person asking the questions. It had to be uncomfortable for the jurors since she kept trying to make eye contact with them. Her stalling every time she had to find a page was super obvious. It was really great to see her look right at, and answer Camille (to her face,) once the claws came out. That’s when Amber showed who she really is. And that anger was palpable! Once she got angry, she started to slip up - like admitting TWICE that she wrote the op-ed about Johnny. Camille tripped her and it was fantastic to watch.
I kept thinking her hair reminded me of chicken noodle soup, the color and texture.
@@terriedupuy1625 Ramen noodles! 🤣🤣🤣
This is actually the right thing to do TBH. She's a woman claiming to be abused, and she needs to connect with those jurors to get them on her side.
The problem is it failed because she's not a believable, nice, person and instead of acting humble and like an actual victim, she came across as a bully.
But it is the right thing to do, especially in a civil trial where the bar for conviction is MUCH LOWER, to try and get the jurors on your side.
As Bruce says "That snarkiness is not making her likeable. And your client being liked by the jury is *critical* to your case."
I think this was right, but the issue is she's just full of shit and aggressive as a result, so it didn't endear her at all.
If she was a real victim and looked those jurors in the face while she went and testified that would resonate STRONGLY and connect with them. Unfortunately though is that it just wasn't true lol.
@@terriedupuy1625😂😂😂
@@tiffanyanthony😂😂😂
She says “I don’t know who that man was…” then two minutes later she says “He testified to only a light fixture being broken, just like his security guard sumed up my closet being rearranged…” lady you just said you didn’t know him!!!
I did not catch that before. I thought she was just saying "that man that i have never met is sitting there on the stand saying these things"
I have always liked JD, but I wouldn't say I was a fan. I wouldn't go out of my way to see him in person. I didn't even know who AH was until this case, but I find myself going all in for JD because AH's testimony is so obviously phony!! I don't get why anyone would lie about such things, but she does!!
To advance her career is why. She's evil.
Same here
I'm just hoping the jurors are as smart as most of us. What an act, definitely not award winning.
I hope so!
Sure, it was award winning. Haven't you heard of the Razzie (Golden Raspberry Award) & Golden Tomato (Rotten Tomato Award) for the worst cinematic/acting awards. She definitely would be nominated and take home the award!!
I wish they come watch this youtube channel lol.
I really hope Johnny will be cleared of this crime that I believe he is innocent.
This isn't a criminal trial. Neither Heard nor Depp are accused of a crime.
Amber has, however, admitted to several and been shown to have committed others.
Depp has largely been exonerated of everything except struggling with substance abuse and being abusive to furniture.
If I had to choose between someone who hits their spouse, and someone who hits their kitchen cupboard, I know who I would rather be around.
@@BaalsMistress Addendum: Abusive to furniture when drunk, high, and emotionally distraught from bad news.
Its a defamation case. Its either one of them win and go home with the money or both of them loose.. defamation case is hard coz the jury has to come up w/ a decision based on common sense but still abiding legalities/law. And that makes it hard..
I appreciate the time you took to explain the narratives for the people who are unable to fully comprehend the judicial meanings and process.
The moment when she said "That's why I wrote the Op-ed" was f'ing priceless!!! Then she said it not once, but twice!! 🤦♀️🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I think she did admit in previous trial that she wrote th Op-ed, but it wasnt meant for Johnny. Of course she denied wether she published it and also the title of that article. But this time she spilled the bean, it was about Johnny.
I screamed like a teenage girl!🤣
@@MdmChong惊人的 "The OP ed isnt about Johnny the only one who thinks its about him is Johnny" "The OP ed isnt just about Johnny" "He is a powerful man thats why i wrote the OP ed" Its actually funny how she keeps spewing bullshit but it becomes less of a lie gradually but never the actual truth lol im surprised she didnt go with the "I dont remember why i wrote it" or "I didnt know what it meant"
@@MdmChong惊人的 exactly! She had been denying that it was about Johnny...then she got so flustered with Camille that she just spit it out. 🤣🤣🤣
You are a great reference to come to for proper professionalism and court breakdowns. Thank you for your much appreciated work.
How did her attorneys not see that they had 2 pics that were clearly from the same event but were testified as two different occasions.
Her attorney even asked their witnesses to lie...
I’ve watched this a few times and Camille exposes her lies, duplicity and cruel narcissist intent!
Vile woman!
Can’t wait to see her face when she loses. She hasn’t a clue what real victims of domestic abuse endures. I know a survivor and she stills had nitemares and flashbacks. It never goes away even after years and councilling it’s hard to ever forget it. My stomache was sick looking at her faking it. It’s making a mockery of real victims. I believe Johnny. Yes he has his own issues but who hasn’t. Doesn’t make him a bad person or an abuser. I just hope d jury sees her for what she is. They have to !! Bst luck Johnny.
I believe Johnny too, but I’m real nervous he isn’t going to prevail. Remember, OJ was found not guilt too
Johnny win!
@@TheMillieSmalls well in the criminal trial. He was found guilty or responsible in the civil trial.
@@Mrtfarrugia
neither one was a criminal trial....
Sorry - my bet is that you won’t see her face. She’ll be out of that courtroom like a scalded cat.
She did tell the truth on the day she described how she used her "bruise kit". She said she used it *over* her normal makeup.
However, that is how a bruise is created. To hide a bruise, the "bruise kit" makeup would be used *under* her normal makeup.
And the makeup to cover the bruises would be called a color corrector or color wheel. The bruise kit is for creating bruises.
And it wouldn't be bruise kit makeup.
and she even caught a snap of it in the ice cream sleeping pic...😆
I’ve seen Camille’s rebuttal like 15 times. It was so epic!!
I love her!!
It’s like watching Iron Mike Tyson’s best Knock Outs! I’ve watched it countless times myself.
When Camille started cross I was quite impressed with the setup she performed to allow the jury to see through the lies and over acting being performed. 🔥
Camille Vasquez is amazing at dismantling and eviscerating Amber's clearly false testimony
No man could ever do that to a woman bcs she could scream se*ism.
A woman’s rage is also very different to a mans. Which makes this whole thing soo satisfying to watch.
A real woman destroying a lying woman.