Amit Shah-led Parl Panel's Hindi Recommendations ‘Unacceptable, Wrong, Regressive & Retarding’: PTR
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ต.ค. 2022
- Support The Interview with Karan Thapar - fij.mojo.page/support-the-int...
In a 28-minute interview to Karan Thapar for The Wire, the Tamil Nadu Finance Minister said: “We are not going to be accepting of any efforts to suppress our language at the cost of promoting another language”.
Join The Wire's TH-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
I speak Hindi. But I don't want the same to be shoveled down my throat. No thanks...
We need more Politicians like him who don't beat around bush and speak facts. Love and respect from Maharashtra.
Fake news.
@@ahamasmiarinm not as fake as your Bharatiya Jumla Party.
@@vishnukanth8050 Well, let's leave it for the people to decide. I'm no authority to decide for them and I bet neither are you. Right?
In that case tamil nadu should also stop imposing tamil in their schools
@@Salam-qx1qv 😂 stop Hindi imposition in ur shoools pls teach English can't u
I am a Hindi speaker and come from so called Hindi belt, Here parents they dont want their children to study in hindi medium school. People will not accept this even in hindi belt.
Hope you are correct...
th-cam.com/video/r_L1RTzVmOU/w-d-xo.html
Bro they want take you back to many years, simply because , than only you all will not be become intellectual .
..if you become intellectual these people politics come know openly...to hide their mistake they do all these nasty things...
Well, that's because higher education is mostly in English. The day IITs and IIMs start teaching in Hindi, no parents would have any problems in Hindi. The real reason to oppose this recommendation is very very sinister, but this conspiracy too would fail with time.
Its going to kill Hindi language like Hinduism in near or far future
Hindi is the local language of the cow belt only
गाय पट्टा का भासा😁
🙂 LOL ....Good one
I am Marathi. I don't want to "have" to speak in hindi. I can speak, read and write, English, Hindi and Marathi. Each language has a place in my life. My mother can even speak Gujarati. I don't like people telling me which language i should speak.
The most ridiculous part is that because my mother insisted on "English" education, we as a family were able to move out of poverty. It seems to me, they want everyone to become UP.
Yes they want everyone to eat राई का तेल and wear lungi 😁
Nobody has forced anyone to learn any language.
These DMK goons have no job other than crying about language.
Especially this finance minister is a motor mouth 😂😂😂..talks too much.Good English is not good substance.
You are right..
@@kirankoti6316 No one has forced directly but the Parliamentary committee's recommendations are foolish !
Appreciate your satirical comments.
Karnataka will never accept these hindi imposition on us. If kannada speaking people kannadigas are watching, you know what Mr. Palani is speaking about, if not please listen to him. He is speaking for us as well.
Dravidnadu 😁is the solution 😆
Yes rightly said sir
@@Swarajya123 - I COMPLETELY AGREE for Multiple reasons. I truly believe that it is high time, the South Indian States move to create a Separate Nation - It is the ONLY feasible solution in response to such blatant abuse of the Indian Constitution and divisive politics.
@@Swarajya123 its simple another war of independence ....... its time for us to unite and fight for our language .......thank u
@@orphan9334 Try that🤣..Hindus are united never like before..No force can divide them now.
This is not about Tamilnadu only but 60%of India will not accept Hindi at the cost of their mother tongue. Imposition of Hindi is against the unity & diversity of India.
Maybe they don't care about the unity of the country but to feed their ideology easily in future... That's why they want Hindi.
60% of india have lost their ancient native cultures permanently - either they're bimaru states or the northeast whose lingos/cultures are unknown to the rest of us. so the convenient thing for them is to use hindi for jobs but wont give up their native tongues.
@@fkutube1234 fair enuf. - stay in ur bimaru state. stop communicating in english, insist on speaking hindi to ur western employers, etc and see if will have a job.
Agreed this isn't 1960s where only Tamils were proud enough to protest language policy. The recent news has Kannada and Telugu politicians fuming Bengali and Marathi politicians have talked at length at how this won't work in their states and even politicians in Odisha have spoken out. Looks like Punjab might complain as well though we will have to see.
i am from Germany and they are missing the english language... next 50 years... its only english ,,.. dont screw future as kids... they are going to be global citizens and most of cross cultural / cross-geography--- stay and improve in english.
The problem is that these people consider English as a symbol of colonial past which is entirely incorrect. English is the global medium of communication in all business. We ignore and demean that at our peril.
Additionally, their parent RSS was not in favour of anti British agitation for Independence. Secondly, those who are propagating these wedges have their children educated in English and actively engaged in global stage.
@@Sarthakkumarpal RSS is a paranoia filled org and breeds insecurity everywhere
The irony is they have the history of favoring colonizers and detest Mughals whom were instrumental in moulding Hindi as a language from Persian.
They want us to trade thousands of years of old languages to couple of hundred year old Kindi.
@@sujithkumar2041 well said Sir. Unfortunately there are a huge number of citizens who subscribe to RSS's paranoia and insecurities. It's astounding that nobody questions this orgs power without any accountability as they attempt to control all aspects of Governance and our life.
The first sane comment I've read
It's rare in this world that an elected government is trying to become the ruthless enemy of its people. Shame on Union Government. All Non-Hindi and Hindi speakers must unite to resist this draconian imposition.
An act of aggression towards non Hindi speaking people of India
Haha.....dumb fools still trusting wire. Go and read the actual document. This is no less than fake news.
Then they had soon become Hindi speaking! Speak in Hindi or get out of this Country!
@@evil_pig hypocrisy , tum Khud English main likh rahe ko.
@@penacle7 अरे मैं कम से कम अंग्रेज़ी लिपि में अंग्रेज़ी लिखता हूँ। दोगले तो तुम हो जो हिंदी भी अंग्रेज़ी में लिखता है। और हाँ, तुम्हारा वह बकरी का दूध पीनेवाला बाप तक यह चाहता था के हिंदी भारत की राष्ट्रभाषा बने। पर तुम्हारे ग़यासुद्दीन ग़ाज़ी के वंशज वाले चाचा ने ऐसा होने नहीम दिया। आज विश्वगुरुजी और आज के चाणक्य इस सदियों पहले किये गये पाप का प्रायश्चित कर रहे हैं तो तुम्हारी जल गई?
@@evil_pig तुम निश्चित रूप से अपने मूल्यों को प्रदर्शित कर रहे हो I
TN's FM is a highlight educated man , putting his points strongly in a soft tone.
This kind of PPL should be in the key places in government...
Thanks to The Wire for interviewing Mr. Palanivel Thiagarajan on this circular issue.... 🙏
Brilliant discussion. Mr Thiagarajan is a wonderful smart person, of the caliber to be Prime Minister..Modi has disdain for English as he’s illiterate and feels English as language of the elite. He’s dividing the country along religion, language, and cultural lines.
Absolutely
Agree wholeheartedly!
He has been doing that since the day he entered politics
Can't agree more
Hasso Bhatia has hit the nail. Perfect analysis
I don’t know why Other States like Telangana, Kerala etc are not passing a resolution against such recommendations… Karnataka and Andhra I understand they are wholly dependent on Modiji… thanx for Mr Stalin for standing for language independence
Kerala already sent a strong protest. Wait for next assembly session for further action
@@sujithkumar2041 thanx for the input
Keralites need hindi becoz 70% of people go outside Kerala for the job.. be in the middle east or outside Kerala..
These Tamilans still living in chola hangover..
@@saffronwarrior9920 "Chola hangover" 😁😁. I like that.
@@saffronwarrior9920 more than kerlaites ig northies need tamil,malayalam,kannada etc coz more than 80 percent are here in our states ⚰️
If Hindi is forced then there is no point of all states remaining under single union
Let there be different countries based on language/region
Exactly
Yes
Bcoz your ancestor signed article 351..Nothing is forced
If that's the case were can pappans be stored? In Armenian cold? or can they be dumped back into space where they can speak with gods direct with their godly language named as chancescript
No one is forcing any one . Hindi alternative is only for hindi speaking state. This wire is spreading propaganda and creating divide among hindu
Evil diversion tactics from unemployment,prices jumping and corruption.
Very few sensible people to understand this gimmicks from bjp party unfortunately.
Palanivel Thiagarajan deserves to be unanimously elected as the prime minister of India. He is super educated and knows facts and figures unlike the majority Indians who believed in making a tea seller as a prime minister for the rest of india which is unacceptable to the literate population of this country.
I understand and speak Hindi moderately well. But, if it is shoved down my throat, I will vomit and spit it out.
Agree... but I would SHIT it out 🐒🐒🐒
Me too. I already made aware to my kind what Hindi means to him (just another language out of 22 official ones) and try to be NOT any where near to it except what academically needed.
If there was any justice in this world, this man would be running for PM
Majority of parliament voters are from UP
@@yokesh1616 Fake news. The Hindi belt comprises only 40-45% of India's population.
@@RIJU9285 he is making fool out of u all
This will bring down the opportunity of Indian work force across the globe. Jumla committee report should go to trash.
Under Hindutva agenda of one language , one religion and one nation , the Constitution , Parliament etc are treated with disdain ! The consequences for India are ominous !
Yes. A 15 year old girl is defined fit to marry under Islamic by the court in punjab.
Wafq board can grab land and any arbitration is limited to wafq and court and national constitution have no legal claim here.
Yes nupur Sharma is responsible for the turmoil but the peaceful were only exercising their rights by sar tan se juga claim.
The consequences of India are omnious of the Muslims remain to work against national interest puhsing towards khilafat 2.0
Ominous true, but not for IND but anti-Bharat forces, irrespective of their identity. IND haven't actually started yet, it's just building the tools to state it's cause and already people are scared globally.
I don't dwell in past glory but I would say the stature that Bharat had before being enslaved, it was all organic, and when something is organic, it's bound to defeat all odds and shine through. It's not a question of if but when. That's Mother Nature. You wan't to position yourself against Mother Nature, well, good luck!
*Wire has proved to propagate fake news and they even apologize for that*
@@sreyanshuchaterjee3962 Diversion 101. This ramble has nothing to do with this video :).
First of all, Tamil Nadu people will not accept Hindi at any cost. Even if Hindi is imposed on Tamilians at gunpoint, we shall not stop learning English as it is the linguafranga for the Globe
But no one is imposing any language on any one. Hindi alternative is only for hindi speaking state not for tamilnadu or gujrat.
@@animedc69 Why deprive the Hindi belt of English. I live abroad and when I meet people from the Hindi belt they regret not being proficient in English and keep saying that they wished that they were from South India so they could have studied in English. They deserve a choice too.
@@animedc69 it's easy to comment sitting at hindi mainland about non Hindi states position.
Come here and talk, we can't even get basic services in our language from the central government office.
All Central government exams provides Hindi over our language for employment in our state.
Hindi divides more than uniting
I am from Rajasthan and I also do not accept this Recommendation by Central Government. We are living happily in Tamilnadu and we do want to destroy the Peace
I'm also suresh,,Jain❤️
Thank you! ❤️
The BJP clearly does not know the history of the Indian subcontinent. Muhammad Ali Jinnah created Bangladesh in one day, the day he announced that Urdu would be the official language of United Pakistan. They also seem not to know the history of the language riots in Tamil Nadu and the South in 1960 under Jawaharlal Nehru. Pakistan broke to two pieces based on language, we will break into God knows how many!
😂😂It is not the same India.
Anybody trying to divide will be sent straight to Hoors.All they can do is go to courts and cry.Only that is allowed.
And does anyone remember SOWETO riots in the 1970s? The white government tried to disconnect the blacks from the world by switching education from English to Afrikaans. The riots that started then culminated in Nelson Mandela's release 20 years later and black independence. My fellow Indians, do not mess with language. It can only result in the destruction and dismemberment of Mother India!
Indians are the most successful ethnic group in the United States. My American friends ask me how in spite of India being a disaster, every Indian they know is a spectacular success. There are two reasons for this: our remarkable comfort with the English language and the Western culture and our exceptional public education system in India that created institutions like AIIMS and IITs. To put it mildly, we Indians win handily in an even playing field like America as we are 'Nehru ki Aluaad'!
The 'Modi ki Aluaad' bred from the disconnected Hindi world that will follow will resemble Pakistanis more than the present day Indian, mediocre, insecure and agitated!
@@kirankoti6316 It is the same India.. India still fights on basis of caste and religion .. Language is another dividing line and it will get exploited with in minutes..Language was the cause of problems in Sri Lanka and Pakistan ,, It will happen in India too.. Just you thinking it won't doesn't mean it won't..
@@kirankoti6316 You are a joker. The idiots like you thought thirty years before in the iron curtain Russia, Russian would unite all USSR. Disintegration happened.
They want Hindi Specially in South India, might be Bcoz they failed to put their Ideology so far due to language barrier. 🤪
It looks like the committee which freed 11 Gujrati sanskari rapists & murderers.
both headed by judge, rival, gangster mudering tadipaar
🧐
BJP Rule decides:
What you Eat
What you wear
What you speak
What you Say
What you practice
What you communicate
What you think!
BJP is trying to finish the Democratic nature of India
Perfect and it's precisely doing what is not it's job rather than govern. We have to demand better governance.
@@mittemari Beware of Andhbhakts, they are devoid of rationale n full of balderdash.
@@jhakkuagadhi842 certainly sir Ian aware of them. But rationale and truth always wins
@@mittemari 👍🙏
I am a military brat, because of my fathers profession I had 2 options for school they were either to study in a Kendriya Vidyalaya or to study in a different school and live far away from my father who might visit me once or twice a year, we chose the KVs. Now when you change the medium of instruction to Hindi its like striking out the KVs option for them, parents who want the best for their children would obviously would like their children to study in an English medium school. If Hindi were made the main medium of instruction when I was in school my father would have got us into a English medium school and would have lived separate from family for the entirety of his service so would have so many other service men, it will be like punishing our military personal.
Senseless uneducated criminals in politics want to play vote bank politics everywhere.
Me too, a military brat, who entered what was called Central School, later Kendriya Vidyalaya. Not just the military children but those of the central services such as Railways, Mines, Steel Plants, IAS, IAAS, Forest Service, ICAR etc etc etc.
Every KV alumnus, might just rise up in total opposition as would those of Sainik Schools, IITs, IIMs, AIMS, JIPMER.
I am so miffed with this initiatve.
You are talking in practical sense but the people who are in power have had no proper education and no need to rush for jobs that require English.
There are 112 comments as of now from various states . 95 % of the are against the policy.
What more does the govt wants. This may be the downfall of BJP they are digging their own grave.
This will only cause more xenophobia towards Hindi speakers in non-hindi speaking states. Central govt is dividing India.
Good if they divide who wants to live together fignting instead live alag alag being freind 😁
Hindi speakers should be mature enough to understand their dirty politics
Stop voting for Sanghi in north belt
@@vinaychaudhary8629 i try to tell this to my parents and other relatives but BJP has a very strong grip in my region. Your advice is simple and easy in theory but very hard in practice. Biased media is a big problem.
*Wire has proved to propagate fake news and they even apologize for that*
We are traveling backwards, only now we are connected to the world. We have CEO from India in abroad and foreign companies regularly hiring. In many small nations, they are working hard to learn foreign languages. We want to destroy it all.
Exactly. Ever since the BJP came to power at the centre it has been doing everything that is bound to destroy the very foundation of democracy and secularism in India. Imposing one language in a country where there are umpteen different languages and cultures will result in chaos potentially disintegrating the country. People forget the basic fact that India, as a country, came into being after integrating quite a number of disparate political entities after independence. Any attempt to destroy other languages and cultures will be met with stiff resistance.
@@asathyamurthy2481 dont forget governors in opposition states. RN RAVI TALKING ABOUT ARYAN VS DRAVIDIAN, SANATANA DHARMA, HUMILIATING THIRUKKURAL AND TAMIL LITERATURE, Attacking GU Pope and other english scholars, good english men
Bit still sitting happily in governor pffice and talking about removing colonialism.
Governor is a british era colonial posting
Waste of state funds, peoples tax money.
Its a constituitional post but he using loopholes in constituition and not passing bills approved in state assembly for past 7-8 years in Tamilnadu.
If Modi and RN RAVI hate colonialism, why does union government still appoint governors for each state. No use of a colonial post now when u want colonialism to be removed.
Putting new parliament, replacing navy flag and opening kartavya path will not remove colonialism. Removing fovernor post will. Will RN Ravi reaing, join Bjp rss and then talk about TN.
Will modi dismantle governor post. Does he have the courage 2 do it?
In what way is it for Govenror RN RAVI WHO ALREADY HAD A WORST TRACK RECORD IN NAGALAND, to sit in a constituitional post, take oath and swear by the constituition and talk against State Governments and TN Culture?
dual language policy should be in force all across the nation which is very successful model being practiced in tamil nadu. if we need to participate in global economy, whether you like it or not , english is unavoidable. politicians are using the hindi belt as vote bank. people should think rationally and act accordingly.
How can you still believe people would act rationally and accordingly?
Indians by and large are not rational. How do you think BJP is the largest, richest party and could usurp so much power from the other pillars of democracy without people questioning them?
Bjp leaders children studyingin doon school and western universities. But these hindi belt fools dont know that
@@impedimenta934 we can still try. Its a start.
@@impedimenta934 no gst for trying right?
What the cow belt people have been kept ignorant of is that their real mother tongues which is centuries older than hindi like Braj ,awadhi ,bhojpuri maithili , haryanvi etc etc have been abandoned by calling them hindi.
Modern Hindi is 150 yrs old language which was created out of Hindustani language( a hybrid language formed due to the Islamic rule since 12th century) which was spread throughout India by muslims. The british imposed Hindustani for administrative reasons on most of India.
It's ironic that Today the native speakers of awadhi, Braj, haryanvi, maithili, bhojpuri etc are fighting to impose a Mughal/Delhi sultanate camp language Hindi on most of India.
Well said. You have a Good Point
You mean us ????🥺🥺😟😟it is planned by Gujaratis not by us
Sanskrit is not a native indian language
well said
Amithshah can't learn english.. So he don't understand it's important
Absolutely right😲😲
India is divided in South and North since long time ... many of my South Indian friends feel more comfortable abroad than in Northern India ... the North is like a rude, foreign country to them... I would not be surprised if a divide would happen ... in that case, I would settle in the South
Thank God they have not made Gujarati mandatory for entire India.. They have stopped till Hindi at least.. 😀
BJP has already turned Karnataka as UP of South India. Whose turn is Next ??.
We see many people speaking Hindi in Bangalore
Previous ly english and kannada
Where is kannada now?
@@johnjohm2438 yes agree. Kannada, Tamil etc are the original ancient languages of native Indians.
There is danger of losing the Kannada identity if you allow northern culture to influence your tradition. In just 3 generations, the local language could disappear.
Nice interview...Glad that Tamilnadu is acting on behalf of Non Hindi states... Between English has nothing to do with our colonial master...It's a global language... Working in Germany since 20 years...Still exclusively use English in day to day work as our team is sitting in 3 countries/2 continents
Agreed this isn't 1960s where only Tamils were proud enough to protest language policy. The recent news has Kannada and Telugu politicians fuming Bengali and Marathi politicians have talked at length at how this won't work in their states and even politicians in Odisha have spoken out.
bro pls explain in detail about the language policy followed in germany ...... whether english it taught or seen as imposition
Whether we like it or not.. English is a must for all states. Although I like indian languages.. our languages has to improve quite a lot as for as science and technology etc.
Declare English as an Indian language
@@dcmhsotaeh it ALREADY is!
Bad outcome not only in tamilnadu , it will be from Telugu , kannada, Malayalam, Bengali, Punjabi language speaking states also
Hindu Punjabis declared Hindi as their mother tongue during the 1980s - fake Chand
Marathi too.
Agreed this isn't 1960s where only Tamils were proud enough to protest language policy. The recent news has Kannada and Telugu politicians fuming Bengali and Marathi politicians have talked at length at how this won't work in their states and even politicians in Odisha have spoken out.
Add maharashtra as well. Even Gujarat.
Party like DMK and TMC createing a superficial fear of hindi imposition to gain Political mileage, nothing else.
What a terrific take by this gentleman, Mr. Thiagarajan. I can only wish him a life of a thousand years with every year of a thousand days, if not more.
Sardar Patel got 584 Princely States into One India...Now Modi & his Team will ensure Each State Pulls to their own side and ask to be a separate Country..Already Tamil Nadu claims, if its a Separate Country it will be the 18th Networthy Country in the World. I wish India Unity talks about the Unity in Diversity Vs Language/Religion/Caste etc....Easy to go back to Stone Age. Insecurity breeds Regressive behaviour !
Mysore was the richest kingdom It was equal to European countries in its emdevelopment Wodeyars were called ideal kings by British Kannada was the state language of Karnataka from 599 AD right from Kadamba dynasty to wideyar dynasty Karnataja was never under Muslim rule British rule Portuguese rule
Karnatak voluntarily joined Indian union in 1947
We will fight Hindi at all costs
What a Politician.. TAMILNADU you are LUCKY
We have different languages in our country 😎... There must not be any partiality 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Karan, a great interview with a no nonsense minister. The ruling dispensation and their ideologues have realised that Hindu Muslim agenda is losing its traction with the people. So something else is needed to divert the attention from the burning problems like hunger, inflation, unemployment, downward spiralling economy and rupee. And imposition of hindi, medical education in Hindi, Ganesh ji and Laxmi ji on currency are the opium debates that are the need of the hour.
Bro you are from West Bengal...my brother's and sister's over there... when ever we Tamil Nadu people raises voice we always get first support from my beloved states WB... thank you bro and sisters
@@bossbaskaran1944 thanks a lot friend, it's really nice to know that you and family feel this way. In fact this is how it should be in every part of the country. WB or some other states should not be the exception, but the rule.
Yes it is a statement of aggression against non-Hindi states. An uneducated decision that lacks wisdom..
The Hindi politicians aren't going to rest till India breaks away into smaller nations as in 19th century. For their political survival they indulge in divisive ideas and actions.
What's the benfit of this to hindi politicians?
@@Swarajya123 Why should a politician other than from Hindi heartland impose Hindi?
@@kumardhanapal4229 no i m asking what's the benfit of broken india to Hindi Politicians ??, as u wrote in ur first comment.
@@Swarajya123 United India is a thousand years dream. It should be protected
@@kumardhanapal4229 i thing no need to protect we should get divide then we can protect our language and culture also...and freedom from north Indians 😄
Dr. PTR is absolutely right 👍🏼. Whether we like it or not, we are now on the track of the global economy, eliminating English or pushing Hindi will not only disadvantage the non-Hindi speaking Indians but also the Hindi speaking Indians. We will be losing our global significance. There is no rationality behind the Union Government's regressive and aggressive recommendations to mandate Hindi. It doesn't matter whether it is only in the Central Universities and Institutions in the Hindi speaking States or the others.
When EVM , EC are in RSS office, it gives illiterate gang exemplary guts to recommend Hindi as a replacement for English!!😮
Do they even have basic textbooks in different disciplines in Hindi? Hindi medium in higher education is the surest way to take the country fast in the reverse direction. What else can be expected from a govt that has made trampling on the constitution a pastime?
Well said PTR sir! Greatly interviewed Karan!
Dravidian tamil politicians saved india, today's success in IT services job is purely down to indias English continuity simply pushed and institutionalised by great language war on making english an official language.. today's Indias service export is down to them. I thank them from North india
Tamil or Tamilnadu politics. not dravidian.
@@gpremkumar8275 Whats is Tamil then, its senior language o the dravidian family. All praises to Tamilians for upholding and saving rights of evey language in India.
@@siddhartha5186 Tamil is father of Indian languages and Civilization ( Sanskrit, Telugu, Tulu, Malayalam and Kannada) and many foreign languages.
Not senior junior language.
@@gpremkumar8275 this is a lazy bias of looking at the Great Tamil...by simply calling it a languages related to Indo Aryan Sanskrit
@@siddhartha5186 don't relate 50000 years old Tamil language and civilization with 2000 years old Arya/sanskrit and 100 years old dravidam DRAMA groups.
Being a tamizhan if union govt forcely impose Hindi in place of English we will take demand in our hands to dis unite TN from India as language is our identity .
This one step, will break India - sure
Good 😁
Hats off to Mr.Thiagarajan for his wonderful talk. When the country is facing so many problems and issues, why is it that these illiterate and Semi illiterate ignorant Leaders at the helm go all out distracting the people on these topics of language and religion etc at a time like this ?
Finance minister of Tamilnadu Mr. Thyagrajan openly clearly give the veiw about language policy & importance of English. Thanx Sirji for this interview. 💐🇮🇳
Hindi chauvinism at its worst. The so called Hindi belt is not a monolithic entity. Maithili language spoken in large part of Bihar is much older than Hindi. It had its own script and has great works of Vidyapati to
its credit.
Such linguistic fanaticism will cause great deal of upheaval.
I may add Magdhi is my mother tongue spoken in Gaya, Patna, Hazharibag etc.
🌞 Sun may raise in west...but we Tamilians never ever accept Hindi by force....Tamil is classical language....Tamil is more than our Life....
Any imposition will have strong opposition. Many of Indians got jobs in IT industry for not only their technical knowledge, for communicating in English.
Not only the South India, as we usually refer to the region, the so-called eastern India also will have the same line of thinking regarding this subject
South supports you, too, bro... 🙂
Nice interview.
All the points which are discussed in the debate should considered by the committee formed by the govt. Language is the ciritical matter in India and it required proper investigation before implement.
This issue will divide India.non hindi belt will be deprived of government jobs since competitive exams will be conducted in hindi.it is unfortunate that central leaders behave like despots and not as servants of this country.
Diverting minds of citizens from real issues, with these kinds of issues.
Nailed the backdoor trojan 👀
Are we heading to create a new country, Tamil Nadu, if imposition continues by Home Minister?
The absurdity and unconstitutionality of the report are well exposed. Very eloquently articulated by PTR. It must be made clear to Mr. Shah and the committee that 'Hindi' is not mother tongue in most of the states in India. Please refer to Dr. G.N.Devy's report.
This is why this idea of hindi imposition is dead on arrival. Of course, they can start it in some universities in Bimaru states, but then there will be students who flock to private universities/colleges where medium is English. I actually think this is a grand plan to wipe out Govt universities to benefit (more benefit) private univs.
thats a new angle. it may actually be like you said this govs line of thinking is as such.
Aurangzeb wanted one country Hindustan, one language Hindustani,. one religion Islam. The present regime is promoting the same policy with one alteration.
Central Government is trying to make Hindi an official language of UN.
Tamil Nadu Government should write to UN and make it known to the authority there that there are many Indian languages and according to constitution of India no single language has more priority than the other.
In order to promote multiligualism UN added Hindu , Urdu , Bangla and some other language . And Hindi is world's 3rd most spoken language on the planet therefore it's added since lesser spoken languages like Russian and Arabic are also there.
Yeah UN will listen to Tamil Nadu government ignoring the central governmemt .What kind of powder do people smoke here 😂😂
@@kirankoti6316 UN will have to forward the petition by TN government to the central government and the later will have to provide an explanation to the UN.
@@BiswarupRay Oo where u read this ?
@@divyanshsingh9138 its Mandarin chinese , russian ,german ,spanish and many other language that stand in the queue BRO NOT HINDI .......educate yourself
This rule if implemented is going to backfire like demonetisation.
Shah does not know ABCD. This is the whole problem
All Hindi speaking states should mandatorily learn tamil. Would that be fair?
Yes as millions are coming to work in our T N..
Tamils also have strong regional feelings.
Ethnocentrism isn’t necessarily a deterrent to progress
@@RIJU9285 Then there is no difference between them and BJP......
@@HeartistMurali It is a language that is centuries old. Why shouldn't one be proud of one's own culture? The real question is does your culture include accepting others or does it demonize others in order to assert itself. The north has been doing that (the latter) to the south since the Ramayanas.
@@RIJU9285 If I am a Bhakt why would I criticize BJP?? ... You are talking of demonization of other languages. Remember, Karunanidhi vowed never to use Sanskrit. Both BJP and Tamils are obsessed with Hindi culture and Tamil culture respectively. Both claim that they are the ones who truly own India.
@@HeartistMurali I stand corrected sir. However, it can hardly be argued which language has been imposed upon the majority of the Indian people in spite of English being the lingua franca.
All the kingdoms ( rajyas ) will seek freedom to live their own lives if this goes on.
It should happen asap 😁
No rajya (Kingdom )language can be the official language of India.
All languages are Rani’s No language can be maharani
Why other states like west Bengal, Punjab, Kashmir, odisa not voicing out against Hindi compulsory,,,pls be national interest
Proud to be a Tamil. PTR is one among the very few or single minded Erudite persons who is surfaceing the states rights referencing the Constitution to voice Verciforiously against the messed up BJP's ideology which is curbing the rights of the citizen of India. Mr Modi feels he has got the licence to do what he is doing. He should go for a crash course on the Constitution. Mr Modi has got more burning issues such as Unemployment & Economic Growth & the Weakening of the INR. Is the Indian PM not Questionable in the Parliament.Has he become the PM to divide India. He is a petty minded man. He is very much one of the most disoriented Indian PM of all time. Amit Shah should learn to read and write English. Am of the opinion he is jealous because he doesn't know English a bit therefore throwing his weight around. India is at the Threshold of Dooms days under the duo.
I agree with every point mentioned by PTR..we need to compete with other countries in global tech evolution..if we enforce language in reputed institutes then it will damage more than giving any benefits.
Amazing interview. Found it very intellectual and learned so much more on how to carefully word your responses.
Both are educated and intellectual not like samosa selling wala hope you understand and uneducated are ruling our country therefore the problem.....?????
@@bossbaskaran1944 they are just making fool out of u and creating imaginary fear in your mind. In a democracy like Indian no language can be impose on anyone not even English. What government was they created alternative for hindi speaking state . Not in gujrat or Tamilnadu. Wire is spreading false propaganda
I welcome the committees recommendation. The cow belt deserves to be in the Hindi cesspool. Imagine all non Hindi belt where the higher education in mostly in English will be far more educated and in a far better position to further their careers than their cow belt brethren. Just see the difference in eloquence between FM Jai Shankar and the defense minister in a press conference in the USA. The reason English proficiency. The cow belt deserves Hindi.
Excellent interview 👏
Thank you for for your program Mr. Thapar I am enjoying your programs.
PTR Thiagarajan is a class of his own ... he is putting forth his views bery clearly..
Mr PTRP Thiagarajan hails from a dravidian cultured family. We the people of Tamilnadu fully endorse our T.N. Finance Minister Hon. PTRP Thiagarajan's view which bewildered the Union Govt. Nothing wrong in democracy, if his advise is well taken by the Union Govt, whose comments are in the interest of the nation and self respect for the Indians who are mesmerized in the name of Hindu religion /sectarian or communalism.
Wish PTR becomes India's finance minister
If Hindi will be medium of instruction of in institutes of higher education in Hindi belt, then may be RoI should prohibit students from Hindi belt at their institutes of higher education, wonder how that will sound ?
Wonder why TMC is siltent on this ? Has Bengal lost its spine during the partition ?
Why is it always southern states who rise up when it comes to assault on mother tongue ?
Sorry to say this, but it looks like if it was up to 'West Bengalis' - there might not be a Bangaladesh, we would have happily accepted Urdu and ditched Bengali - because one of our 'leaders' was dreaming of becoming PM...
They have no Idea of what country is going through now. So to divert the attentions of the people, all sorts of gimmicks will bring in.This is a Democratic Nation.Nothing could be force on the citizens.
Hindi VS non hindi ..... take on karan boldly VS run away with a glass of water ... proud to be a tamil and united to be an Indian
Regional political parties are real backbone of India. India should go as European Union for prosperity
Bjp is going down as jhagra party.
Were there no members from non hindi speaking states in the parliamentary committee?
The two person who are responsible for creating this parliamentary committee they both are Gujarati speaker.
@@shaktisinh_charan leave them inko lagtaa hai ki sab hum hindi bolne waale hi kar rhe hain wo bhi isliye kyonki humne bjp ko vote diyaa
❤Respect mother, mother tongue, mother land, mother country. Without mother nothing will move in the world. With the step mother no kids will grow healthy 🇮🇳
If Amitshah does not have the capability to learn English, it does not mean that every other citizen has to learn Hindi so that they can communicate with everyone. As a union minister let him figure out to do some useful work to this nation.
Listen to him! every word he utters in response has clear meaning! Why Indian people elect very foolish people to govern them? Elect people like him! I not only recommend him to be a union Finance minister but also to be the PM of democratic India.
Mr. Karan we want more such interviews with TN fm who is very clear in thoughts and expression.
The dimwit of the party that is at the centre is smoking the best maal that lands on mundra port...
Well put! 😂😂
Please don't divide this country in the name of religion and language, let us all respect every religion and every language and every human being and respect humanity. God bless and save this country.
This man is a Genius...
Such a bad move now will ignite regional feeling and can lead to achieve real federalism like US where each state is free to implement laws they feel good for them.
This is only because two mad people in centre and I'll literate and mentally effected can only
It's quite clear that this is a desperate measure directed to promoting majoritarian solidarity
Duel language policy is
Successful one across
Country & that policy being
In thamilnadu , kerala
South getting good education forward & developing globle economy.
Sir
Palanivel l have whole heartedly support you & your views. What they are going to do is 'Hindi Chauvinism'which ultimately will hurt the Country.