2021 Force Gurkha vs Mahindra Thar - Born tough off-road heroes face off | Comparo | Autocar India
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 มิ.ย. 2024
- The second-gen Mahindra Thar has been a smash hit since launch in 2020. But has it met it's match in the new Force Gurkha? Nikhil Bhatia brings the off-road heroes together to find out. A special thanks to Learn Offroad, Pali for helping us out together this video. Visit www.learnoffroad.com for more.
Camerapersons: Shreyans Chordia, Pradeep Bhondave
Editor: Mohit Sharma
0:00 - Introduction
0:46 - Versions on offer
1:20 - Dimensions and looks
2:52 - Force Gurkha interior
4:23 - Mahindra Thar interior
5:32 - Features
6:11 - Mahindra Thar rear seats
7:03 - Force Gurkha rear seats
8:05 - Luggage space
8:34 - Engines and gearboxes
9:09 - Force Gurkha performance
10:40 - Mahindra Thar performance
12:20 - Thar ride, handling & braking
13:24 - Gurkha ride, handling & braking
14:20 - Safety
14:40 - Off-road specs
16:12 - Mahindra Thar off-road
18:40 - Force Gurkha off-road
21:38 - Prices and verdict
SUBSCRIBE to Autocar India for the hottest automotive news and the most comprehensive reviews ► bit.ly/AutocarInd
Autocar India is your one-stop source for test drive reviews & comparison tests of every new car and motorcycle launched in India. We also offer a great mix of other automotive content, including weekly news, motor show reports, travelogues and other special features.
Website: www.autocarindia.com
Facebook: / autocarindiamag
Instagram: / autocar_india
Twitter: / autocarindiamag
New car reviews ►bit.ly/ACI-NewCarReviews
Comparison tests ►bit.ly/ACI-Comparison
New bike reviews ►bit.ly/ACI-BikeReviews
Features ►bit.ly/ACI-Features - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
Thar has become like royal enfield, earlier both were rare sight now both have become common. Thar has become a lifestyle vehicle...while gurkha is still the pure hardcore offroader.
No, force wants gurkha to be a lifestyle vehicle but they failed doing that. If they really wanted it to be a hard-core offroader and a rural vehicle then they would not have offered double wishbone front suspension.
Yes, mostly due to PUNJABI SONGS.
@@Bhaidostyaar 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Rare???
@@Bhaidostyaar not exactly. Independent suspension is more comfortable & helps in better handling than solid axle which makes gurkha more comfortable for highway cruising. Gurkha Bs6 is much more refined & polished product than earlier. Coming to power, it can easily generate 115ps/350nm, but bs6 will go byee bye!
It's pretty crazy how competent the Gurkha became.
Kudos to Force
I have to say, this video really opened my eyes to the significantly improved comfort levels on the Gurkha. It has more space, and rides more comfortably than the Thar. If only it had the power to match. Am sure there will be aftermarket engine mod jobs for the Gurkha.
Yes but the less power is better for hardcore offroading. And also just a ecu remap can take the power of gurkha to peaks
Thar for city and highway and urban offroad
But gurkha is for village, hilly areas and extreme offroad
Define Urban off-road please. You mean bad roads in Mumbai 😂
@@NarenMariappan 😂
You are right ..Gurkha is for village..where it will be used to transport passenger's..like trax...
No bolero is for Village areas
@@NarenMariappan 🌝
Test drove the Gurkha recently. Felt fine on the open highway. Was comfortably cruising at 90 kmph. When i got into a traffic jam i found it very easy to maneuver through traffic that seemed to just give way to it. While the Gurkha looks great from factory most Thar owners spend a couple of lacs bringing it up to spec. Did you notice how it towered over the Thar and made it look puny in comparasion? A Gurkha with its hardtop and space can easily be the primary and only car for a family of 4 unlike the Thar. Maybe thats why i booked a Green Gurkha right after the test drive.
People customise thar because they want to give it a unique touch and not bcoz it’s a necessity. Even vanilla thar looks really good on road. Except the hard top, thar even in 3 door guise is miles ahead of gurkha.
@@projecttruth3610 you have your views and i have mine. Looks are very subjective anyway. If you like the Thar then that is your choice and deserves respect. 👍
@@IndianOverlander Congrats man 💐 Im a student and if I had that much money then definitely I would have gone for the Gurkha I'm a type of guy who don't buy things coz of the quirky features,stacked spec sheet and all the bells n whistles (Thar lovers don't get offended I love the new thar too but Gurkha is more of my type)
Ur money is gone ; damn slow in highways… and very heavy for offroad… but looks is awesome…… same like tank
With due respect welcome to the 8 Mighty North eastern states of India, you will taste real off roading, mud , slush, black ice, sand , rocks ..I guarantee you will enjoy, when you see deep gorges as you drive with 4 wd in low ratio, Love from Mizoram 👍👌..
Which one do u prefer out of the two..? Thar or gurkha or the mighty Gypsy
Next summer bro
Indian G-Wagon vs Indian Wrangler.
Road performance doesn't matters much in an off-road vehicle. But practically like more space and comfortable ingress will help. Will choose Gurkha over thar 👍
The 140bhp Gurkha was a beast. Force disappoints again.
An engine remap can get the job done
Thar is certainly a superior car but Gorkha runs it surprisingly close. In fact it looks tougher, more imposing and is more spacious. It's a more practical family car. For a typical customer of this class of cars who want only one car in the family these are the virtues that appeal to him more. Well done Force Motors!
The attention to detail in various comparison aspects of both the cars in the review is done to perfection ! Great job !
Manuuj Kathuria • 0 seconds ago
Lets talk about practicality for a moment: The Gurkha has way more space for luggage, more head room, leg room and shoulder room for passengers. Its metal hardtop ensures one can have a factory fitted luggage carrier, besides being much safer too.
Most highways I've driven on have a speed limit of 90 kmph. One can cruise all day at 2000 rpm at 90 kmph in a Gurkha. Why would i need to drive at 120 and pick a 2000 challan every speed camera i cross?
The Gurkha is better offroad, practical since its more spacious, safer with its metal top, quieter at high speeds, better ride quality, and looks far better in stock form than the Thar. Looks ofcourse are subjective.
@ManuujKathuria Also we can’t drive any BS6 vehicle beyond 120 kmph with that annoying speed warning chime
Yes Gurkha lools more practical than Thar...if want feature rich go for XUV 700 all wheel drive
The problem is safe overtaking on a single lane highway. With a 0-100 time of almost half a minute(terribly slow for a vehicle in this day and age) the gurkha will struggle to even pass busses and trucks safely. You will have to plan for overtakes which in turn tires the driver out on longer journeys. Meanwhile the thar will be much safer for the same. So the gurkha makes sense only if the use case is offroad most of the time
@@himanshu0784 dude mahindra has just said all wheel drive i am damn sure xuv 700 will not be able to do any off roading
A manual locking differential definitely gives you an advantage in tricky situations. Mahindra must consider it atleast as an optional package. Off roading enthusiasts surely wouldn't mind the extra premium for the same.
Thar gets mld bro
You 89n
Exactly yatesh !
If you are an actual enthusiast then you wont even consider buying the current gen thar.
The most awaited comparo, so delighted and thankful to you team autocar. You always bring smile, in mornings, precisely!!
Well Said........Most Awaited Tpoic
I will go for Gurkha without any second thoughts!
Well then give it a logical third thought
Then go
@@salesalpha3832 ....I dont think he needs to ....Reviews have made things clear ...Gurkha for the Win
Gurkha may be less in numbers, but it has got more personality than thar.
Absolutely, also gurkha has both front and rear differential. It's the more underrated car than thar.
Exactly Gurkha is maybe not the most stacked car in terms of numbers but it has lots of character in it
Great review; a very touchy and sensitive topic handled with elan and all fairness...
Just to add to your comparison/conclusion, Mahindra's wide distribution of service centers will always keep it way ahead of Force. Frankly, I haven't seen a Force Motor service center yet, in my 17 yrs of driving experience!
I've seen one outside the Force Motors factory
I would choose Gurkha for sure because of lots of space, comfier ride,boot space, better off-roader, even though engine is sluggish.
Unlike other car companies Force deliver cars from the plant to the dealership by appointing a driver to drive .
Yeah... Tell the entire facts.. they do a service before handing over... Complete change of all fluids and pre delivery check
Isn't it impractical and expensive?
@@abhijiths7637 But that translates into better customer satisfaction.
Do they do it for Trax series vehicles? Or only for traveller?
@@arunjoshy7893 They do it for all vehicles. They are having a seperate agency for delivering the vehicle to the showroom. All force vehicle is driven from factory to showroom.
Showroom executives will check for any damages during the transit and then issue a clearance certificate to the agency. And they will do a complete service check up prior to delivery.
Gurkha has got more character and ruggedness. A hardcore drivers delight.
Most Verrrry Waited 😎👍😁
Great video! It’s nice to see the offroad vehicles available around the world. Very cool 🤙🏾
Not gonna go into the off-road bits but man that Gurkha is stunning 🤩
I saw the complete video with my morning tea and boy oo boy ur guys dedication and commitment for us is commendable
Thar is smart ❤️
But gurkha is raw off-roader 👍
Most awaited
Great comparison. Amazing video guys.
Perfect comparo ❤️🔥🔥
Great video @nikhil. Loved the narration and shots.
Thank you!
Gurkha looks huge beside thar 🙌🏼
Most awaited.......
Great review n superb hardwork done 👌👍
You done toughest review without any negative just killed it man
Force should immediately reconsider the Mercedes sourced OM 611 engine of the earlier Gurkha to stay in the game. Rather than selling the obsolete rotten TD 2650 engine of yesterdecade.
Yes, it needs power. 90 bhp is not working for the mammoth.
Stunned to see the zoomed out view of both cars realising thar is very small compared
With proper locking differentials, Gurkha is the way to go for off roaders.
I just love the gurkha. This will be the most reliable offroader India.
Not at all.Force motors have terrible service network and parts availability.After sales experience is not good
Force motors are producing the best low maintenance work horses
Looking both of these beasts together is immensely intimidating!! 🔥😎
most awaited .... video
A matured man Gurkha and dudy boy Thar
Truth 👍
Good to see Nikhil back!
Nicely put!
Special mention to the camera man for some amazing footage throughout the video!
Hiiii Autocar India.... Appreciate your efforts!!!!!
Mahindra Thar- A monster which can never be tamed!
It has been tamed
Autocar has been my preferred choice for any car news since 22 years. Im 31. As always their content is the best. Here practicality will dictate, people will purchase the Thar over Gurkha anyway. Irrespective of what the comments say. Also surprisingly I haven’t seen a single Gurkha on road or rather off it too. Simply like how the comments gush over Altroz but you see more Balenos on the road. Comments seem very hypocritical.
If you do off roading 24x7 the Gurkha is the winner but if you need something which is at home in the city , highways and has decent off road capabilities for the weekends the thar wins. Thar is just an easier car to live with.
Thar has nice road presence 🥵🔥
1 view and 22 likes now that's autocar India
I love both. Both are above level.
So will anyone suggest which is better for Mild off roading and regarding modifications also
Thank you!
I will prefer gurkha as it's more practical & has a unique road presence 😍
Mahindra THAR🔥🔥
KEEP IT UP FOR THE SAKE OF HUMANITY LOVE KINDNESS
My compliments to the narrator. He covers all aspects of the vehicles and mercifully,does not break into that monstrous English-Hindi mix.
Thar for sure 🤞
Very honest review. I like it
WERE YOU DEVELOPING THESE WHILE WE WERE PLAYING LOCKDOWN GAMES? FREAKING AWESOME
Tbh on offroad Gurkha feels more smooth xD
Just noticed, Thar HT doesn't come with roof liner or is it optional?
Well summed up Nikhil!👍
Was hunting for highway performance of new Gurkha. Notification came as a surprise. Felt like someone offering Briyani, while I was still looking for at least a cup of tea. This is real quick. Thanks for sharing.
I still can't understand why did force cancelled the 140hp engine that Gurkha once provided..it should have killed the thar once in for all..btw when it comes to superior offroading..its always the Gurkha..but the price is not justified!
What? Didn't you hear him saying that he was not confident on the side incline in the Gurkha? So 🤔
Too low volume
@@salesalpha3832 Because he was driving Gurkha first time off road once you own car you will adjust
Absolutely, they have marked up the price, only thing the Gurkha needs is a better engine to leave no stones unturned
Gurkha is struggling in sales compared to the Thar.
Awesome & Thanks :)
The Force sounds good, a proper rugged
Old school pure off road rough and tough with comfort (mercedes engine) + milage
It's force
Looks and tec it's thar
Thank you. Well made video covering the features and capabilities well.
I was a Thar fan, but Gurkha really stole my heart.
Thar for everyone. Gurkha for heavy drivers
Finally!!! Was waiting for this. I love the gurkha btw
Gurkha is the legendary car & black colour looks beast 🔥🔥🔥
When can we see safari vs xuv 700 video?? Please share that at the earliest.🙏🙏
Although i like the Gurkha better, unfortunately if these two would ever be sold in my country, i will probably choose Thar regardless of its disadvantages. All cars with engine larger than 2.5 litres are considered luxurious vehicles, and thus are charged with higher tax 😶😶😶😶
I will fell proud to tell about Gurkha.....with its safety and spacious Features, the riding comfort, more over all. Did u check the clutch and breaks are more user friendly in Gurkha.....
The most awaited comparison ♥️
Force Gurkha 🔥
It astounds me to read that the Force 13 seater Trax Toofan 4x4 has the same 90 bhp engine as the far lighter Gurkha where it already struggles ...
The Force Ghurka Extreme FM 2.2 CR was better spec’d as far as performance was concerned , the interiors .. well that’s another story ! Would love to see a comparison though !!
Gurkha, cos soon thar will become too common to be exclusive...other positives of gurkha is easily maintainable & economic commercial engine and better road comfort.
Any recommendations to learn off-road driving? I genuinely want the Gurkha...one day hopefully...😅😅😅
Great review
Hello from the US. Cool to see these 2 vehicles not available here. Do you think the snorkel exhaust on the Force is part of the reason it is so down on power? Perhaps some sort of cutout for use in dry conditions would help.
I doubt it, how can a exhaust make a difference of 20-30 HP even if it has got more displacement
Please explain about analog 4x4 and regular 4x4
Gurkha is perfect for hard-core off roaders.
Thar is for those who need to balance city and offroad.
I think most of these buyers don't live in a jungle....do 80% usage would be on a Tarmac. So which do you choose.
Love from Nagaland
🔥🔥
THANKYOU.
Definitely Gurka which is always ahead during off-road
Gurkha should improve cabin quality nd also tune their engine with more Bhp
Gurkha looks amazing and really tough off roader
Are these 2 models planned for sales in Europe?
Gurkha ❤️❤️my favourite 🔥🔥
I like that colour 👌😍
The Gorkha is for Men, the Thar is for boys. The Gorkha has much more character and ruggedness. And it demands smart off road driving skills. This makes driving a Gorkha a challenging but rewarding experience. Force Gorkha for the win!!
Gurkha a better vehicle. Better 4wd than Thar, more reliable and rugged.
My fvrt Gurkha exterior 🔥
Gurkha is more practical here better seat layout more luggage space Hardcore off road capabilities, Thar is more aspirational here. Yes it has definitely more power and better interior that's about it. Want to travel long/ or do bit off road with family take Gurkha. Thar ok it will be good for weekend end trip nearby for couples. Seriously!
To be honest both are adult tuskers 💛
Definitely My dream Mahindra Thar... ❤😘