ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- A girl was completely submerged underwater for 66 minutes. However, she survived. And despite not having a pulse or signs of breathing, her brain remained intact. Was it a miracle or was it science?
Today, we're looking into the cases of 3 people who survived against all odds.
Sources:
[John Smith / Breakthrough]
• Breakthrough Trailer #...
• 'The Impossible': This...
breakthroughmo...
www.usatoday.c...
www.stlmag.com...
www.historyvsho...
• Meet The Mom Whose Son...
• Breakthrough | Nothing...
• The True Story of ‘Bre...
[Michelle Funk]
iaedjournal.or...
www.nytimes.co...
[Justin Smith]
• Meet a Man Who Was Fro...
www.lvhn.org/s...
findadoc.lvh.co...
• Found Frozen: Man Foun...
[Calling Time of]
bit.ly/2Q7HYeT
• Verifying Death - A cl...
• Confirmation of Death ...
[How Does Freezing Effect the Human Body]
www.thescience...
www.ncbi.nlm.n...
www.ncbi.nlm.n...
www.outsideonl...
[Hypothermia Treatment]
www.mayoclinic...
www.tandfonlin...
[How Animals Cope with Freezing]
• Antarctic Toothfish - ...
• Frogsicles: Frozen But...
www.nationalge...
evolution.berk...
www.sciencedir...
• Understanding: Frozen ...
• Water Bears Close Up
• The amazing life of a ...
• Real Video of a Tardig...
• Tardigrades: The Most ...
[Pop Culture]
• Here's Johnny
• Yvon of the Yukon - Ca...
• Captain America The Fi...
• Batman-Mr. Freeze Puns!
• Video
• Lost In The Wilderness...
• Everest (2015) - Left ...
• Video
• Yvon of the Yukon - Ca...
• Lucy Looks into the wa...
• Fox Dives Headfirst In...
• The Orb of Confusion O...
• Thriller - Michael Jac...
• Great Wild North: Bria...
• Birth - Monty Python's...
• Monty Python - "Not De...
• Video
• Arnold from the Magic ...
• Batman and Robin Mr. ...
• Video
• Video
Metric conversions:
*Normal Body Temp* 36.5- 37.5 degrees C
*Hyperthermia* 37.5-38.3 degrees C
*Hypothermia* 35 degrees C
*Michelle Funks Body Heat* 18.9, rose to 25 degrees C
*Antarctic Toothfish* live in -2 degrees C
That was really helpful, thx!
Thanks!
sorry i dont speak tea and crumpets
@@josephedwards9102 u have a British name though
Sorry but I’m not ruining the 69 liked
"You're not dead until you're warm and dead." This is the mantra of medics in Alaska.
as soon as i read this it came up in the video
Anyone else annoyed by how inaccurate the movie was
I always am
religion fueled-things always are
I cringed so hard at the part where the doctors gave and the mother asked God to make her son love and actually working, they took all the efforts made by the doctors away, that kind of stuff annoys me, those people care enough for human life to do some crazy stuff to save it
True
It's insulting to all the doctors and medical professionals and science to make it look like it was because of prayers and religion that saved the guy.
After all those puns we should seriously give him the *cold* shoulder
Danny 😆
nICE pun bro
it is time to stop
Bruh you need to *chill*
Boooooooo
I can imagine John Smith being the default human name
In English speaking countries
@@iDontProgramInCpp
What about in Spanish speaking countries?
@@pugasaurusrex8253 dont think John and Smith are native Spanish names
@@iDontProgramInCpp
I was saying what would be a default Spanish name
@@pugasaurusrex8253 I don't know
I’ve fallen into a swamp in the middle of winter and barely managed to get out because of the heavy clothing I was wearing , that stuff is really scary .
I think your main problem was your boots. For me it's hard to run in boots, and probably even harder to try to rescue yourself
All the doctors: "We tried so hard and he's finally alive!"
Breakthrough: "The doctors were hopeless until a prayer was heard!"
The doctors: "URBVI&UWIYTCNEUIXCBVYWVUJGWJVRY"
Faith should be eradicated. It's what is best for mankind.
@@livedandletdie Faith has it's place.
Sometimes it needs a reminder
Tbf, I don’t really know what happened- but if nothing was working and then one thing just so happened to work- I would say that’s accurate
@@adjmonkey that something was probably the combined effort of 25 people in the room.
@@livedandletdie Faith in terms of religion? Sure. Faith when it comes to trusting and believing in people whom you care about and are close to you? No.
Little correction here, Brew: Hypo- and Hyperthermia are not when the body's temperature is below or above homeostatic temperatures. The conditions are correctly defined as a core temperature that is either significantly higher, or lower, than the body's Temperature Set Point. A fever is not hyperthermia, since it is the body's set point being moved to a higher temperature in response to stress. The human body's set point can vary safely anywhere between 6 and 10 degrees up or down depending on current conditions set by the hypothalamus, however when the body's temperature changes independantly of the set point, that is where the definitions of Hypothermia or Hyperthermia come into play.
There’s another story of a woman who was completely frozen for hours, found outside in a blizzard. Her story is pretty fascinating too and I don’t think they amputated. There’s also another woman who survived being blasted by a shot gun in her chest, pretty much putting holes all in her lung/s and she walked for miles to a hospital. That’s a badass woman.
She is a badass women
I'm not saying this was the case with John Smith, but it always bothers me when someone is rescued, saved, helped, etc and they thank their god, but not the people who did the work. I'm sure the doctors were thanked profusely in this case, but y'know, how about a little thank you for medical science?
Yes, this makes me very sad. This is one of the reasons I think life might not be not worth living, because people are such idiots more often than not.
Because that takes away from the amount of credit god gets. And thats a big no no when the point of the movie is to make you think god did it all
@hawkturkey you wrote that whole sentence in a way thats extremely wierd and hard to understand. Say it in a straight forward way
@@simonelastname5182 the first 4 lines sound like hes intentionally trying to sound like old English. And what does he mean with all that word fluff?
I aint religious, but if hes thanking all of his saviours then why not let him thank his god
I like the video but please add Celsius
No u
666 like haha
Again, if he doesn't know the Celsius measurement then what? Oh wait, you'd have to do some work like the rest of us who only know Fahrenheit and use a calculator which converts the two. You probably have a cell phone and a laptop right? Use the laptop to watch the videos and the cell phone to use an app to convert the two. Why do you think you don't hear Americans bitching about "can you please include standard or Fahrenheit in your videos? Because we're intelligent enough not to need to be spoon fed and know how to find a calculator and not be lazy about it.
@@toysoldier46552 Kind of missing the point where the cumulative population of all the countries that use the metric system is greater than the population of the countries that use the imperial system. Plus, if it's meant to be an educational video, it would matter quite a lot.
@@cyclonic5206 The point is, he's an American, just like me. We use our standard measurements for our own country which is what you do. Don't expect us to do your conversion work for you, Lord knows I have to do the conversions in my case for UK videos.
This is very interesting and I like it
Thanks for informing people
So much shade thrown at ice coffee drinkers sksk
I gonna break your skskskneecaps
Silence VSCO
VSCO SPOTTED
@@matthewmadayag2426 VSCOs weren't even a thing there?
@@emigoldber woosh
Bruh i was legit drinking ice coffee and you dissed it, good vid tho
I legit just splash out my water I'm drinking when I saw
Michelle 66 minutes 66 ferenhight
That's alot of 6 for a kid
Please at least add a label with the temperature in Celsius. There are fewer countries that use Fahrenheit over Celsius.
At least Kelvin. Everyone use that equally
1 Country which uses Fahrenheit to about 300 others who use Celsius. Only the USA uses Fahrenheit.
But to be fair Celsius is really weird like how 17 degrees Celsius is hot
@@thesonicexplorer75 weird is what you make of it
@@thesonicexplorer75 17°C isn't Hot, 40 is.
Brew: "What do all these people have in common?"
Me: "They are all humans and Americans..."
Brew: "They have all died at least once..."
Me: "... oh you meant not obvious things..."
For the girl I can just imagine her on her fist date with someone and she casually mentions “Guess what? I was dead for 66 minutes with an extreme case of hypothermia back when I was 2.”
The reactions that the hypothetical person she would be out with would be pretty interesting.
this guy about to blow up, 1 million subs before end of the year
Probably not
Ok
200K
December 22 and not even 3k
21
You are right! The movie completely UNDERPLAYS the efforts of the medical team which is unbelievable! its almost an insult
Loved the pun at the end, and I personally think your videos and the topics you pick for them are pretty cool...
Keep up the good work!
*Don't declare me or my son dead ever again.*
Consistent with the quality, very polished uploads. You have a fantastic sense of what a video should and shouldn't be, as well as a good personality. I greatly respect you.
mhm that's cuz the team give this person a script and then the animation team animates it
And nobody even mentioned Anna Bagenholm, the Norwegian skier who fell through an icy lake. Not only was she temporarily dead as well, her body temperature was 56 degrees - the second lowest anybody had ever survived. I usually hear about her a lot - don’t know why she wasn’t mentioned. And that little girl did NOT fall through an icy lake, she went under in a very cold not even frozen creek - she was snagged on a rock in the bottom. But the rest of the story was true - so yeah.
It's refreshing to see some unique quality content on TH-cam. Subbed
I was diagnosed clinically dead twice once for 3 hours and the second time for 50 minutes. The ambulance staff confirmed each time that I was dead (no heartbeat, stopped breathing) by the time they got there. I don't really remember the first time, I just remember vivid out of person experience as I saw myself collapse like a stiff board when I looked behind me. I sat next to my body in the ambulance and heard and saw everything but from an outer perspective until they got me into the ICU and suddenly I felt like something yanked my legs hard and fast and the next thing I remember is waking up in my own body in the next room after the brave surgeons finished. Turned out I had a perforated appendix in the late critical stage and they got me in narrowly in the last hour possible.
The second time the same happened but I could feel it beforehand but still fell as a bag of potatoes. I didn't experience outer body experience but my consciousness was thrown into another misty, muddy world and as decades passed in there I found a way to come back and when I stepped in a door in a specific hotel I was just 50 minutes from where the second whole thing started, I was in my body but I couldn't move, my skin was the whitest white I ever saw and it was cold, I stayed there like this for about 5 minutes and then the ambulance staff came (they couldn't get there sooner because they got delayed), they said they still want to check on me if I'm saveable even though it was well over the 4 minute threshold for emergencies. One of the staff came over to me to check my pulse, breathing and pupils to confirm the date of death and while he's doing it he's talking about it to his colleagues and that's when I was finally able to slowly roll over, get on my knees, stand up and wobble towards the bottle of water on a nearby desk to everyone's surprise in the room. They offered to still bring me to the hospital for a checkup just in case but this time they didn't find anything what caused it and what changed that I woke up on my own after 50 minutes of no heartbeat and no breathing (first checked by the school nurse and then the PE teacher, then the ambulance medic).
I just simply cannot believe that you have such low sub and viewer numbers... Your content is absolutely top notch. Im actually getting emotional about how much you deserve more spotlight
I just found you, and I like this.
(I should be studying)
great video on this very informative also question Brew what kind of coffee you drink I drink hazelnut very great coffee ☕
woahh I watched spill and now there's a brew? What next lol...
I watched brew first
grill.
Brew -> spill -> clean :3
Brew then Grill and then Spill
ur back!!!!😆🖤
My only critique is not including Celsius. I kept having to pause the video to convert them 😅 aside from that the format is very polished. Fix that and I don't think you'll have future complaints from the rest of the world lol
Moral of the story: if your brain is intact, you can survive
Love your channel, stay awesome!
Fahrenheit to Celsius is roughly minus 32 divided by 2
Eg: 66 - 32 =34
34/2 =17 Celsius
Nice tip. Since it's actually divided by 1.8, just remember the actual numbet would be higher than the numbers calculated that way.
@@nanwijanarko1969 cheers yeah i just checked its 9/5 yep 1.8 awesome !
Looks like Smith's are good at bring frozen and coming back to life....
OHH!! So THAT'S why I like the cold....
Thank you for explaining hypothermia, although I have absolutely no idea what degreed you used. It's still easy to understand what it is at least
Farenheit
Only a few vids and theres a lot of quality in these vids, dang its a good start
The pulse thing is pretty innacurate because sometimes the pulse can be so low it seems like they’re dead but they’re alive. And some ppl r buried alive like this. But some people’s heart also stops beating...that doesn’t mean ur dead yet- not every BODY follows the same- one minute no pulse and your dead rule. There have been several exceptions to this. I hope docters evolve their knowledge too!
I never heard about the 66 minute one, That crazy stuff. Love the video and the research that goes behind it. Also love the puns, they are very nice :D
I love the steaming coffee next to picture of cold conditions
they couldnt wait 3 more minutes?
Glad you are back.
For all those people asking for Celsius, the formula for Fahrenheit to Celsius is
(F-32)/9*5=C
"Kind of hungry for blood" sounds like a vampire shitpost
I love your videos so, so much! Keep doing what your doing!
Another great video. Thanks Brew!
Coffee doesn't need to be hot. It can be as cold as you like.
Such a fascination video! Can’t wait to hear and see more of your content! Thank you to @spill for this recommendation!
What about the woman who collapsed head first into snow overnight and lost part of her face but was clinically dead until they revived her through thawing?
8:03 passive *REWARMING*
Global rewarming (2020 edition)
I like that you take your time to rechserch stuff thank you for taking your time to look stuff up
Finding a tight enclosed space is less likely confusion, and more likely the instinct to find a place where the igloo effect can help prevent further body heat loss.
It's amazing what the human body does to itself when in extreme situations in order to enter into a state of self-preservation.
I'm getting smarter here than I am probably getting today at school
Wow Brew, those ice puns sure are *slick*
Wim Hof: first time?
You missed an important point. In a lot of early thaw attempts that looked promising, the person suddenly the dies. What was eventually discovered is that the low metabolism during the "frozen" stage results in a peripheral acidosis, that once circulation is re-established can overload the body and stop the heart due to the pH imbalance. So another standard component of re-warming systems is intravenous buffer administration.
Doctor: well I don’t know if he’s dead yet. Let’s dethaw him and see what happens.
I was warm and dead. No pulse, no breathing. For around 10+ minutes. When emts finally arrived they brought me back with CPR.
If she's heated for long enough she'd be perfectly medium rare
R/CursedComments
Please keep up the great videos!
i love you so much you’re an icon. i love the blend of science and humor, please keep these amazing videos up💜✨
Something I heard a lot from park rangers when I did some hiking across the US was "you're not dead until you're warm and dead."
They’ve only died once each? My grandma died twice in one week... and is currently living with my cousin
She had 2 heart attacks and was revived twice
You should make a video purely dedicated to puns XD
Lmao...I loved every single pun 🤣😭
That's a good bit of injustice the movie did to portray the actual events.
Can I just say how ironic it is that our body feels COLD and at a dangerous level at NINETY-FIVE DEGREES. I just can’t get over how funny that is since if it was 95 degrees outside that would be seen as hot.😅
i think your humor is quite COOL
"You're not dead until you're warm and dead"-Jack is still alive.
8:02 love the sudden change in voice
I wonder if that means we could find a dead person on say mount everest ... and resurrct them.
Love his videos
For some reason every time I see your animated character i think of Grian. Idk why
No views, seven likes😐
No human has ever been frozen and resuscitated . Chilled yes , not frozen .
"If that makes you feel uneasy, thunk of reheating coffee in the microwave"
That made me even more uneasy...
That film totally downplayed the efforts of the medical professionals
Ice cold coffee
The reason why you simply can’t freeze yourself to be preserved for the future is because when water freezes it turns to crystals. You can imagine how having 60% of your body’s makeup turning into sharp little crystals isn’t good for your health.
The difference from newer videos, audio and animation
Great. Giving god credit that scientists and medical professionals deserve. Thanks religion.
most of the time, the true people who have been record-holding in something amazing, usually aren't the ones we know, there are people out there who have most likely been dead frozen for much much longer than released to the public, also the true strongest, smartest, fastest, etc. people in the world are usually the ones that the public doesn't know about, my cousin knows a guy who was dead for an entire night frozen, and somehow doctors were able to bring them back and they almost didn't lose any limbs, maybe just a finger or two, idk how true that is, but if it is true then I wonder what OTHER things people have survived
I think it's scary that I'm constantly between normothermia and hypothermia
Doctors: revives him after many hours of stressfull cpr and medical attention
Her: Thank you god for saving my son
Doctors: 👁👄👁
I can't really see the case of Michelle funk😭💝
extracorporeal is basically reverse liquid cooling a pc
He lost his pinkies and all of his toes? That is like, not so bad at all. His facial features are fine (you can easily lose your nose) and the most important fingers are still there! All things considered, this dude is very lucky!
I've died once, but I was in the hospital so I was only dead for 2 minutes, then I was in acoma for almost 2 weeks.
12:07 If prayer was so good, why do we still have hospitals ?
There are people who are able to spend a short amount of time (15 minutes) going swimming in frozen lakes by cutting out the ice. But for 66 minutes that is very long time in the cold water.
Rule of thumb in my ems classes. If they were frozen or hypothermia they have to be warm and dead
Can u use better and more scientific temperature units or also known as Celsius. At least in brackets
Please use Celsius.
In some cases, when regural passive warming isn't enought butbairway rewarming isn't needed, alcohol is used. Yes it is mostly myth that alcohol KEEPS you warm but it will speed up warming you as it changes the way your blood flows, thus not only making you feel warm, but actually helping to warm some of your organs.
You ain't dead until you're warm and dead.
Dude justin is cracked at surviving my guy.
OMG more use of ECMO!! yay! (It can also be used to prevent overheating from fevercaused by serious infections / sepsis!)
I know if you unfreeze someone frozen for a long period of time he is dead, most probably their blood veins will explode. If the heart stops it can't be revived specially if it was frozen. And the brain and many other things can't be revived. And about the blood veins blust, it is because blood isn't like water, it can't go back to liquid, it will freeze and burst. That is what I heard. But theoretically we don't know. But I know that's why we can't freeze people to preserve them for the future.
I ain't dead til I'm dust and even then you ain't breathing easy.