Most certainly. In a broad sense the focus and investment must be massively in manufacturing or creating hardware on a colossal scale, no doubt about it.
@@anshumanjha3138anufacturing requires anywhere from basic training and education to high level training and education And at the same time manufacturing in sectors that off the bat don't need high skill and education absorbs large numbers of labour easier, like textiles. And India has enough skilled and educated people to atleast start the manufacturing in a few small scale highly technical secotrs ,if that weren't true things like isro wouldn't be true and private space start-ups , at the same time manufacturing in lower skill sectors to absorb labour and have more people with money in hand which in turn helps them to provide more education to future generations to move up the ladder. So I don't get your half assed argument of not having manufacturing? And you claim as if people can't upskill and won't upskill Easier way would have been to bring in more private investments into farming which the farm laws tried but was not welcomed by some , despite more than 80% of farmers welcoming it . That would have immediately brought in more money in the hands of people without having to do anything from scratch.. unlike in manufacturing.. But either way it's important for India to industrialize.😮
No matter what the pundits say India will grow stronger👍. It's MSMEs can propel it with human capital 👍. 🇮🇳 INDIA will become 3rd largest economy in after 10 yrs🇮🇳👍
@@kumararya87agree and disagree its a correct step on the way. India’s size matters like china. Thats what allows china to have gdp per capita far lower than portugal or greece yet be on its way to a superpower.
@@kumararya87 i get this GDP per capita thing and is valid I'm not denying it but I'd also say that the cost of decent living is fairly very low in India if you compare with other Big Economies.
@@kumararya87you're saying heads is one side of the coin and tails is not , Growing GDP and growing per Capita income aren't they two sides of the same coin ? What you mean to say is being overly fixated only on 5trillion dollars GDP is of no use , we have to look to go beyond 10 or 20 But to that I'd say when china reached 5trillion just took them 5 more years to have doubled after reaching the initially 5 trillion mark , and as of now India seems to be poised to do something similar... So 5trillion or 3rd largest is just one trophy out of the many hopefully to come.
The Ivory Tower Indian and Indian American academics and “experts” with deep ideological leanings have not spent even 6 months outside the Indian metros. They see India in spreadsheets and panel discussions and often, they are least qualified to talk about India. This includes The great Amartya, Raghu Ram, Banerjee and the likes of them. Kollengode S Venkataraman
@@adamc2378 it is stupid statement, blacks are in much worse conditions in usa, than lower caste in india. I have lived in usa and seen that. No country has done social justice the way India has done, despite being poor. Our resources go waste bcz of that only.
@@adamc2378 Not only that caste system will never be abolished as long as hinduism will exist but they shamelessly exported castism to USA ,Canada ,UK and Australia...
what India really needs is a very strong and stable govt..Modi govt with a simple majority could not pass one of the most imp agri reforms.. What Arvind and Raghuram Rajan cries about actually defies their own logic when China such an authoritarian non-inclusive govt grew up at more than 10%..democracy has tremendous benefits (and India is diverse, pluralistic, secular, democratic, progressive, liberal to its core; with such low per capita and huge diverse population, India is the only unique example that has always been a democracy when you compare it with countries having similar per capita and socio-economic status), however, when you have such a huge uneducated poor population, democracy becomes the biggest hurdle...
@@guharup - best way is to devolve the authority over agri policy down to the states, and then let each state liberalize as much as it wants. Some states may choose to liberalize aggressively and reap the benefits from that, while other states may choose to lag behind and get the consequences from that. In the long run, competition among states will force them all to progressively liberalize.
As long as we keep the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty family away from the leadership of India, then India and Indians will see enormous growth and development across multiple sectors for the next 50 years And India must not loose its hunger to keep developing ....ever....even in the next 1000 years, India should work hard on development and fuel growth !
All decades were indias decades...but wasted by caste,regionalism,family parties, ruling elites of upper castes,nehrus socialism ....🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️
Too much infighting, not enough unity, ambition and vision amongst Indians. Little countries like Singapore, Malaysia, South Korea, Taiwan all came from behind and trounced India. Shameful!!
In its own way, India has stumbled upon a governance model for 1.50 billion people. This internally generated knowledge and model has got antennas raised in the Western world in particular. They have been left scratching their head on how did this happen. India picked up tools invented in the West and came up with a solution that no one imagined.
...1.5 billion people ,really ?From where did you get another 600 million people to india's population buddy ,or perhaps one of your great talents is to make up or lie without shame...
The governance model is bad to be honest. It needs a lot of improvements. The judiciary right now is a major hurdle for the progress of this country. It’s too slow, too preachy and often time self-contradictory. Also, laws are different for different communities and law enforcement is shit unless you are rich or have connections. India is moving ahead despite the bad governance and judiciary, not because of it.
Realistic parameters of a developed nation/cities/societies can be summed up as follows: 1. Quality of air we breath and the quality of our (daily) transport (roads, traffic and public transport alternatives) 2. Quality of our public healthcare facilities, civic services and accountability from our politicians and the other powers-that-be. 3. Quality & transparency of governance, with freedom of expression, with an unbiased mass-media.
I can make a case for Papua New Guinea scoring very high on your metrics. What is with educated Indians comparing features of post industrial societies as "development"? We don't have state enforcement, industrial capacity and logistics. Each point is a major polluter.
Goldman sachs praised 🇮🇳 in a report in 2023 and said that in order to become the 3rd largest economy India needs to grow at above 5% till 2030s ND around 4-4.5% in 2040s.
It's amazing how pessimistic and biased these experts are. In every way they laud 🇨🇳 (although it is widely perceived that 🇨🇳 fudges its economic data). 🇮🇳 for these people has always bn an economic backwater where nothing works.
These people are *_woolly-headed intellectuals_* touting *_fluffy_* phrases, dreamily building *_castles in the sky_* ("unicorns" -- fluffy way to describe a PRE-PROFITABLE company, and PRE-PROFITABLE is a charitable way of saying UNPROFITABLE. Their market capitalization evaporates very quickly when economic times get tough) Have any of these "eminent intellectuals" actually run a business themselves?
Modi government is the reason India playing boldly, if leftist, chinese agent congress party would be in place of BJP our country still struggling like it did from 2004-2014. Just Google GDP growth of this period, you will be shocked, mind you this is the period where China does it's rapid transformation.
The woman is utterly stupid, water, land and electricity are not at all challenges in India - the challenge is the lithography machines. India must do everything to build its own lithography machines in competition with the Dutch (CIA owned anyway) & it must be multiple companies in India - there should not be a monopoly on Lithography machine making in India. We must also focus on inventing dry fab that requires no water or less water compared to the old wet fab tech that is used currently without any radical change since 50 years.
Your comment utterly ..... Indians suffer from severe water shortage, one light bulb only in some villages and India has the highest population in the world. Indians are migrating Westwards to fill the land mass of other countries. Think before you comment falsehoods
Lithography machine 😂😂😂You seem to have watched too many chinese propaganda channels from where you have borrowed this fixation fr asml . First learn to walk before copying a sprint runner
You are asking for the summit of mountain Everest from a 10year old climber in 2 days. Not going to succeed. If you said Fab facility, at least that's understandable but you are asking to make Lithography machines? Do you know how many hundreds of billions of research in past decade alone went into making them what they are today? Please do tell where does the technology and R&D comes from to make these Chip making machines? Out of thin air?
@@agnescraig2912 one light bulb only 😂😂😂 Rape jihad ki najayaz paidaish ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool hira Mandi me apni begairat behaya ghasti musalmina ammi khala behen ka halala apni 6 saala chudakad Ammi hazrat laudakhor Ayesha Zainab Fatima ki tarah din me 5 Baar doggy style namaz me unka ghazi haji 🍑 uthwakar marwane wale ganduudin dalle paki u again came here to discuss about what happens in 💩 islam smelling islamic Republic of hira Mandi randistan porkistan bhikharistan Pakistan 😂😂😂
I agree that India is still not very business friendly but slowly improving. Foreign investors think that Vietnam, Bangladesh, and Thailand are more business friendly than India.
@@harir3628 Most of the companies moving out of China have moved to Vietnam and Mexico. Why not India? Because they think India is still over regulated, beaurocratic and unfriendly to foreign businesses.
Totally agree with Arvind on education. Need an imminent need to scale up education (live a structured career rather than live out of Jugad! ) Especially given that India is now investing heavily on say 900 planes , billions on Drones and local manufacturing of engines. These are good enough incentives for the state governments to improve on education(since education is a state subject). Politically also this will give center a good push back- a win-win.
According to a 2018 economic times report, the amount of black money stashed away abroad by Indians is Rs.300 Lakh Crores or USD 4 Trillion. Can we get it back?
Dr. Subramanian is the only one on the panel who made any sense. The others clearly do not much to say about the central issue of accessibility to quality education.
Jai Hinduja. According to Hisler, IndoIranians are the East German tribes. In fact, German tribes first moved from Asia to Europe. Europe and Germany must recouple with India, the world's largest and fastest growing economy.
Arvind subramanian is another Raghuram Rajan. Only after BJP rule, state were provided tge oppertunity to grow by themselves. They are provided larger fund allocation. None of the state government could be treated at the whims and fancies of Central Govt because it is through revenue sharing formula. The opposition parties are engrassed in such a large corruption, any raids are seen as interference. Still not even one stare govt has been dismissed even though every cheif minister talks such a rubbish language against Modi Arvind is lying
Still there are people with pre concluded notion that we possesed this and that before nation cant become as you wish. When some one shows your fault you ask have you told the fault of US. I have no buisiness to do it. I can only talk about my house. Opp house its their problem.
A loan for 20 years to the private doctors and hospitals to support Ayushman Bharat is too short a period. These are long- time cycle processes and enough time must be given for gestation and the profits to finally flow out of the system. These loans must be given for at least 60-100 years.
For last 30 years, I saw Indian had many many many grand plans but never seemed to get one done right. They are damn good in coming up PPT and present "Grand" plans but always produce miserable results. What's wrong!?
You call CCP 'normal' and peace while the rest of the world is warmongering. Do tell us about the official grand plans you heard from the Indian Governments over the years. We can discuss about how well they fared.
@@jtang63 Stop your gutter oil diet for a week and start reading updated sources. India still has a lot do in healthcare and public infra but spot parroting your CCP propaganda and live in the present. Also, despite the claims by CCP and 50 cent army, apparently there are a lot of Chinese who defec in the open even today even if they have mobile phones and daily wage jobs.
The comment that Indians are coming back to India defies logic. For every one Indian who returns 1000+ Indians leave India. Just check the immigration figures in the West which are not concocted. One Indian origin professor in the U.K. Mentioned a figure of 160,000 student visas alone have been issued besides other visas
Agnes you are not getting the context.The guys coming back are rich Indians. The guys going out are going for education and will come back in the future. Like the Irish Italians French all came to North America.
The Indians who are coming back sees the opportunity in India to be job giver (entrepreneurs) than jobseeker...Job seekers Indians still want to go out in huge numbers. Two of my masters friends from India moved back and in 3 years are making 10 times of what they were making in NYC...
Regarding the health, india is far behind! Science starts at schools and Universities but in India, there isn’t much importance given to scientific curiosity.
Correct the answer is no for this decade… but if everything done correctly in next 2 decades… 3rd could be ours. That’s why study for 25 years guys & than deliver something for the nation for next 30 years.
Strongly disagree with Nivrata Rai’s remark that manufacturing is the key to solving India’s insatiable demand for jobs. If India needs to create jobs quickly, the best way to do that is in services. India can be trusted to not take the necessary measures which will make mass employment profitable; such as by removing wage floors. I am afraid it will be more of the same.
You know what, people like you and their stupid thinking are actually pulling back India from achieving its full potential. Manufacturing is the key. It can provide jobs on a large scale in a short point of time. We need not want to wait 10+2+4 years for the service sector to provide employment. Just vocational and employable upskilling citing 6-month to 1-year courses can contribute positively to job creation. Manufacturing is the future.
I completely disagree. Only manufacturing can absorb the vast numbers of illiterate & unskilled Indians through employment that will get them onto the economic ladder, while allowing them to acquire skills on the job. The reality is that the huge number of illiterate & unskilled aren't going to suddenly become software engineers and medical doctors overnight, like Cinderella suddenly transforming from rags to ballgown by a magic wand. No such magic wand exists. Time to face reality and form policies accordingly.
@@harir3628 Who said our external debt is zero? Interest and Principal payments on debt form over a quarter of the union government budget to this day! Allowing for cheaper has two effects: one, it puts a lid on inflation by increasing potential sources of supply; two, Indian manufacturers are kept on their toes and cannot take the consumer for granted. Plus, other countries will be more vested with your interests only if they have something to gain from it. The US wields the influence it does these days thanks in large part to its gratuitous imports from other countries. No one like to piss off their main customer.
Spot-on China grew at 10% for nearly two decades. Whereas considering India's piss poor per capita income of $2500 , a growth of (6.5-7) % is simply too mediocre. China is light years ahead of India. China is a superior Civilisation compared to a mediocre Indian Civilisation. Having said that, Nivruti Rai's analysis is fascinating.
![[JLF 2024] Shashi Tharoor: A Man for All Seasons](/img/n.gif)
R&D and manufacturing are "THE" future for India
Its rubbish in both with people who are very poorly educated and the educated are not good enough to create technology fit for the market.
Most certainly. In a broad sense the focus and investment must be massively in manufacturing or creating hardware on a colossal scale, no doubt about it.
@@anshumanjha3138anufacturing requires anywhere from basic training and education to high level training and education
And at the same time manufacturing in sectors that off the bat don't need high skill and education absorbs large numbers of labour easier, like textiles.
And India has enough skilled and educated people to atleast start the manufacturing in a few small scale highly technical secotrs ,if that weren't true things like isro wouldn't be true and private space start-ups ,
at the same time manufacturing in lower skill sectors to absorb labour and have more people with money in hand which in turn helps them to provide more education to future generations to move up the ladder.
So I don't get your half assed argument of not having manufacturing? And you claim as if people can't upskill and won't upskill
Easier way would have been to bring in more private investments into farming which the farm laws tried but was not welcomed by some , despite more than 80% of farmers welcoming it .
That would have immediately brought in more money in the hands of people without having to do anything from scratch.. unlike in manufacturing..
But either way it's important for India to industrialize.😮
Is it ,but I can find one high tech stuff made in India to buy besides curry powder and basmati rice
No matter what the pundits say India will grow stronger👍. It's MSMEs can propel it with human capital 👍. 🇮🇳 INDIA will become 3rd largest economy in after 10 yrs🇮🇳👍
3rd GDP will mean nothing.. zero.. nada.. if we still remain bottom ranking nation in per capita GDP.
@@kumararya87agree and disagree its a correct step on the way. India’s size matters like china. Thats what allows china to have gdp per capita far lower than portugal or greece yet be on its way to a superpower.
@@kumararya87 i get this GDP per capita thing and is valid I'm not denying it but I'd also say that the cost of decent living is fairly very low in India if you compare with other Big Economies.
@@kumararya87 acha how do u raise percapita income Prabhu without growing gdp
@@kumararya87you're saying heads is one side of the coin and tails is not ,
Growing GDP and growing per Capita income aren't they two sides of the same coin ?
What you mean to say is being overly fixated only on 5trillion dollars GDP is of no use , we have to look to go beyond 10 or 20
But to that I'd say when china reached 5trillion just took them 5 more years to have doubled after reaching the initially 5 trillion mark , and as of now India seems to be poised to do something similar... So 5trillion or 3rd largest is just one trophy out of the many hopefully to come.
The Ivory Tower Indian and Indian American academics and “experts” with deep ideological leanings have not spent even 6 months outside the Indian metros.
They see India in spreadsheets and panel discussions and often, they are least qualified to talk about India. This includes The great Amartya, Raghu Ram, Banerjee and the likes of them.
Kollengode S Venkataraman
Speaking of ivory towers, India as a society must abolish the caste system if it wants to truly harness its potential and rise economically.
@@adamc2378 caste is redundant now, OK bot
@@adamc2378 it is stupid statement, blacks are in much worse conditions in usa, than lower caste in india. I have lived in usa and seen that. No country has done social justice the way India has done, despite being poor. Our resources go waste bcz of that only.
@@adamc2378 Not only that caste system will never be abolished as long as hinduism will exist but they shamelessly exported castism to USA ,Canada ,UK and Australia...
@@adamc2378West Should decrease black killing
what India really needs is a very strong and stable govt..Modi govt with a simple majority could not pass one of the most imp agri reforms.. What Arvind and Raghuram Rajan cries about actually defies their own logic when China such an authoritarian non-inclusive govt grew up at more than 10%..democracy has tremendous benefits (and India is diverse, pluralistic, secular, democratic, progressive, liberal to its core; with such low per capita and huge diverse population, India is the only unique example that has always been a democracy when you compare it with countries having similar per capita and socio-economic status), however, when you have such a huge uneducated poor population, democracy becomes the biggest hurdle...
the agri reform was passed alright, it could not be implemented due to street protests by punjabi and harayana large farmers
@@guharup - best way is to devolve the authority over agri policy down to the states, and then let each state liberalize as much as it wants. Some states may choose to liberalize aggressively and reap the benefits from that, while other states may choose to lag behind and get the consequences from that. In the long run, competition among states will force them all to progressively liberalize.
@@manofsan agreed. Until then, periodic appearance of vegetable inflation
As long as we keep the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty family away from the leadership of India, then India and Indians will see enormous growth and development across multiple sectors for the next 50 years
And India must not loose its hunger to keep developing ....ever....even in the next 1000 years, India should work hard on development and fuel growth !
All decades were indias decades...but wasted by caste,regionalism,family parties, ruling elites of upper castes,nehrus socialism
....🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️🧜🏻♂️
Too much infighting, not enough unity, ambition and vision amongst Indians. Little countries like Singapore, Malaysia, South Korea, Taiwan all came from behind and trounced India. Shameful!!
Manufacturing definitely needs to be boosted in India and services should be further encouraged both in and by private and and Government
For that India needs educated and skills labour force which sadly India doesn't produce in mass scale.
Look forward to more of such panel discussions
.....me too so I can laugh my a$$ out...
In its own way, India has stumbled upon a governance model for 1.50 billion people. This internally generated knowledge and model has got antennas raised in the Western world in particular. They have been left scratching their head on how did this happen. India picked up tools invented in the West and came up with a solution that no one imagined.
Thought the ‘tools’ of democracy had their roots in Bharat ?
@@ranenbhattacharyya136 By tools I had in mind technology; both software and hardware.
...1.5 billion people ,really ?From where did you get another 600 million people to india's population buddy ,or perhaps one of your great talents is to make up or lie without shame...
@rakadus extremely well articulated.......but I still feel we have a long way to go.
The governance model is bad to be honest. It needs a lot of improvements. The judiciary right now is a major hurdle for the progress of this country. It’s too slow, too preachy and often time self-contradictory. Also, laws are different for different communities and law enforcement is shit unless you are rich or have connections. India is moving ahead despite the bad governance and judiciary, not because of it.
Hindus mind is hungry for knowledge . His mind and soul is so pure he has no problem using knowledge .
Hindu mind is hungry for constant praise and self aggrandism . It is full of egotism .
@@cb9461😂😂😂
@@cb9461thank god we don't have muslim party congress anymore
Arvind economics is same as of Raghuram, seen his so called research paper debunked at so many level.
God saved us by having these two out of the system.
They will always be critical. If they are so smart why are they not super rich?
India needs to create 8 million jobs every year & not 8 million jobs over the next decade.
Realistic parameters of a developed nation/cities/societies can be summed up as follows:
1. Quality of air we breath and the quality of our (daily) transport (roads, traffic and public transport alternatives)
2. Quality of our public healthcare facilities, civic services and accountability from our politicians and the other powers-that-be.
3. Quality & transparency of governance, with freedom of expression, with an unbiased mass-media.
I can make a case for Papua New Guinea scoring very high on your metrics.
What is with educated Indians comparing features of post industrial societies as "development"? We don't have state enforcement, industrial capacity and logistics. Each point is a major polluter.
You expressed it well, sir.
@@rutvikrs Educated Indians living in the US*
@@arunsar7893 Bhai I see you everywhere. We getting same recommendations lol
@@SunilKumar-nf7ft :-)
Goldman sachs praised 🇮🇳 in a report in 2023 and said that in order to become the 3rd largest economy India needs to grow at above 5% till 2030s ND around 4-4.5% in 2040s.
Yes.
Enough of self complementing....keep head down and work
Why does all discussions make it about India vs the world? It is imperative that India grows for it’s own sake, to provide for 1.4b people.
It's amazing how pessimistic and biased these experts are. In every way they laud 🇨🇳 (although it is widely perceived that 🇨🇳 fudges its economic data). 🇮🇳 for these people has always bn an economic backwater where nothing works.
These people are *_woolly-headed intellectuals_* touting *_fluffy_* phrases, dreamily building *_castles in the sky_*
("unicorns" -- fluffy way to describe a PRE-PROFITABLE company, and PRE-PROFITABLE is a charitable way of saying UNPROFITABLE. Their market capitalization evaporates very quickly when economic times get tough)
Have any of these "eminent intellectuals" actually run a business themselves?
How can India be an economic super power when they can not even provide clean water, hygiene and bath rooms for it's own people?
Just 1 week after the upload this lady was fired and thanked for her services
SAB SE AAGEY HONGE HINDUSTANI YEH BAAT HAI SAB NE MAANI
build restroom first
@@tarantinofan8947Nope Toilet 😅 GDP per capita more or less same as kangladesh
@@Sp67860 are you Pakistani
@@tarantinofan8947 I am Indian
@@tarantinofan8947 porkistan GDP per capita is 1000
Modi government is the reason India playing boldly, if leftist, chinese agent congress party would be in place of BJP our country still struggling like it did from 2004-2014. Just Google GDP growth of this period, you will be shocked, mind you this is the period where China does it's rapid transformation.
The woman is utterly stupid, water, land and electricity are not at all challenges in India - the challenge is the lithography machines. India must do everything to build its own lithography machines in competition with the Dutch (CIA owned anyway) & it must be multiple companies in India - there should not be a monopoly on Lithography machine making in India.
We must also focus on inventing dry fab that requires no water or less water compared to the old wet fab tech that is used currently without any radical change since 50 years.
Your comment utterly ..... Indians suffer from severe water shortage, one light bulb only in some villages and India has the highest population in the world. Indians are migrating Westwards to fill the land mass of other countries. Think before you comment falsehoods
@@agnescraig2912 Blah blah blah.....if you care so much, give up your country to India & live on mars.
Lithography machine 😂😂😂You seem to have watched too many chinese propaganda channels from where you have borrowed this fixation fr asml . First learn to walk before copying a sprint runner
You are asking for the summit of mountain Everest from a 10year old climber in 2 days. Not going to succeed.
If you said Fab facility, at least that's understandable but you are asking to make Lithography machines? Do you know how many hundreds of billions of research in past decade alone went into making them what they are today? Please do tell where does the technology and R&D comes from to make these Chip making machines? Out of thin air?
@@agnescraig2912 one light bulb only 😂😂😂
Rape jihad ki najayaz paidaish ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool hira Mandi me apni begairat behaya ghasti musalmina ammi khala behen ka halala apni 6 saala chudakad Ammi hazrat laudakhor Ayesha Zainab Fatima ki tarah din me 5 Baar doggy style namaz me unka ghazi haji 🍑 uthwakar marwane wale ganduudin dalle paki u again came here to discuss about what happens in 💩 islam smelling islamic Republic of hira Mandi randistan porkistan bhikharistan Pakistan 😂😂😂
I agree that India is still not very business friendly but slowly improving. Foreign investors think that Vietnam, Bangladesh, and Thailand are more business friendly than India.
India has the cheapest manufacturing base and digital credit system which none of these have
And please check the EOB rankings… India is best amongst the mentioned ones here…
Indian market is big and sophisticated
Vietnam or Thailand don’t have robust administrations. Their economies are very flimsy
@@harir3628 Most of the companies moving out of China have moved to Vietnam and Mexico. Why not India? Because they think India is still over regulated, beaurocratic and unfriendly to foreign businesses.
Totally agree with Arvind on education. Need an imminent need to scale up education (live a structured career rather than live out of Jugad! ) Especially given that India is now investing heavily on say 900 planes , billions on Drones and local manufacturing of engines. These are good enough incentives for the state governments to improve on education(since education is a state subject). Politically also this will give center a good push back- a win-win.
The only thing india gets to do is assembly of products created by the brains of other people Western brain and indian labour ...that about right...
According to a 2018 economic times report, the amount of black money stashed away abroad by Indians is Rs.300 Lakh Crores or USD 4 Trillion. Can we get it back?
unshakel bureaucratic controls instead promote rule base regulation for promotion
Aravind Subramanyam is very pessimistic on India.
Half the video was Pratham Pratham Pratham Pratham Pratham Pratham Pratham
Dude, chill
China says we are a developing country and we need to work hard.India says we are a developed super power and it's our decade😂
53:00
India needs to focus on STEM education like crazy… ignore social sciences for a decade or two
Dr. Subramanian is the only one on the panel who made any sense. The others clearly do not much to say about the central issue of accessibility to quality education.
Jai Hinduja. According to Hisler, IndoIranians are the East German tribes. In fact, German tribes first moved from Asia to Europe. Europe and Germany must recouple with India, the world's largest and fastest growing economy.
Arvind subramanian is another Raghuram Rajan. Only after BJP rule, state were provided tge oppertunity to grow by themselves. They are provided larger fund allocation.
None of the state government could be treated at the whims and fancies of Central Govt because it is through revenue sharing formula.
The opposition parties are engrassed in such a large corruption, any raids are seen as interference. Still not even one stare govt has been dismissed even though every cheif minister talks such a rubbish language against Modi
Arvind is lying
Still there are people with pre concluded notion that we possesed this and that before nation cant become as you wish. When some one shows your fault you ask have you told the fault of US. I have no buisiness to do it. I can only talk about my house. Opp house its their problem.
A loan for 20 years to the private doctors and hospitals to support Ayushman Bharat is too short a period. These are long- time cycle processes and enough time must be given for gestation and the profits to finally flow out of the system. These loans must be given for at least 60-100 years.
For last 30 years, I saw Indian had many many many grand plans but never seemed to get one done right. They are damn good in coming up PPT and present "Grand" plans but always produce miserable results. What's wrong!?
You call CCP 'normal' and peace while the rest of the world is warmongering.
Do tell us about the official grand plans you heard from the Indian Governments over the years. We can discuss about how well they fared.
@@varun2250 Such as public restroom construction.
@@jtang63 Stop your gutter oil diet for a week and start reading updated sources. India still has a lot do in healthcare and public infra but spot parroting your CCP propaganda and live in the present.
Also, despite the claims by CCP and 50 cent army, apparently there are a lot of Chinese who defec in the open even today even if they have mobile phones and daily wage jobs.
@@jtang63 chinki ccp
@@jtang63 Over a 100 million toilets have been built since 2014 and more than 95% of the rural population have access to them. Not a good example.
what's the answer? don't know? just say so.
Insecure intellectuals.
There are only 100,000 different proteins.
India does R and D, not science.
当我听到印度专家说印度汽车自动化制造水平比中国高时，我就放心了，印度还是那个印度，只会吹牛。
The comment that Indians are coming back to India defies logic. For every one Indian who returns 1000+ Indians leave India. Just check the immigration figures in the West which are not concocted. One Indian origin professor in the U.K. Mentioned a figure of 160,000 student visas alone have been issued besides other visas
Agnes you are not getting the context.The guys coming back are rich Indians. The guys going out are going for education and will come back in the future. Like the Irish Italians French all came to North America.
The Indians who are coming back sees the opportunity in India to be job giver (entrepreneurs) than jobseeker...Job seekers Indians still want to go out in huge numbers. Two of my masters friends from India moved back and in 3 years are making 10 times of what they were making in NYC...
do you have any idea about the population of india? 160k is like not even a drop
Regarding the health, india is far behind! Science starts at schools and Universities but in India, there isn’t much importance given to scientific curiosity.
Yeapp, But India holds lot of records in lot of Science and Technology Sector, Example, India's Space Program.
I think you doesn't know India well.
He is overseas india I guess so who settled in america enjoying thier facilities....
It is catching up. What matters is the trajectory. The rest of the world is slipping.
The answer is no
As a CCP homeboi, you are entitled to say that.
@@varun2250 As someone from a country called shithole by west, you are expected to say sth meaningless.
Correct the answer is no for this decade… but if everything done correctly in next 2 decades… 3rd could be ours. That’s why study for 25 years guys & than deliver something for the nation for next 30 years.
Leftist idiology prevail in this whole discussion 😂😂😂
... "Is This India’s Decade?"... it is NOT!...
Yes, man, you are right! It’s not Indias decade, but it is Indias century!
Just curious why do you think so
...is IS!... seems just caps and exclamation mark suffices for logic here
Strongly disagree with Nivrata Rai’s remark that manufacturing is the key to solving India’s insatiable demand for jobs. If India needs to create jobs quickly, the best way to do that is in services.
India can be trusted to not take the necessary measures which will make mass employment profitable; such as by removing wage floors.
I am afraid it will be more of the same.
Services will be taken over by AI. Manufacturing is the only way for uneducated people to be trained quickly & employed gainfully.
Hh
You know what, people like you and their stupid thinking are actually pulling back India from achieving its full potential. Manufacturing is the key. It can provide jobs on a large scale in a short point of time. We need not want to wait 10+2+4 years for the service sector to provide employment. Just vocational and employable upskilling citing 6-month to 1-year courses can contribute positively to job creation. Manufacturing is the future.
I completely disagree. Only manufacturing can absorb the vast numbers of illiterate & unskilled Indians through employment that will get them onto the economic ladder, while allowing them to acquire skills on the job. The reality is that the huge number of illiterate & unskilled aren't going to suddenly become software engineers and medical doctors overnight, like Cinderella suddenly transforming from rags to ballgown by a magic wand. No such magic wand exists. Time to face reality and form policies accordingly.
Indias beauty is a hindu followers vedic knowledge human beings who have freedom to think move talk and do things .
22:00 Arvind Subramanian has a good point about keeping the Indian economy open. Cannot conquer the world if your keep navel-gazing.
China did not do that. You need to protect your economy. We only need high level technology imports. That is why our net external debt is zero.
@@harir3628 Who said our external debt is zero? Interest and Principal payments on debt form over a quarter of the union government budget to this day!
Allowing for cheaper has two effects: one, it puts a lid on inflation by increasing potential sources of supply; two, Indian manufacturers are kept on their toes and cannot take the consumer for granted.
Plus, other countries will be more vested with your interests only if they have something to gain from it. The US wields the influence it does these days thanks in large part to its gratuitous imports from other countries. No one like to piss off their main customer.
No.
Spot-on China grew at 10% for nearly two decades.
Whereas considering India's piss poor per capita income of $2500 , a growth of (6.5-7) % is simply too mediocre.
China is light years ahead of India.
China is a superior Civilisation compared to a mediocre Indian Civilisation.
Having said that, Nivruti Rai's analysis is fascinating.
How can you compare civilization? Do you even know what's that word mean? I highly doubt that
Feku will go and growth will come
G-had-i spoted.
Your dream to defeat bjp will never come true. Bjp again coming back in 2024.
Gasbags