@@PentePatrolStarWars Thank you for making all of these videos. They are so well done and are delivered with so much care and Passion. Keep up the great work!
Yoda training Anakin would have been a case of the best teacher but not the best father figure. It would have logically made sense, as Anakin is the prophecized Chosen One. But Obi-Wan was one of the most emotional Jedi - far more than he is given credit for - but I think Qui-Gon would have been the ultimate best choice.
@@aaronlopez5163 he would certainly know how anakin was feeling at all times. Hell even not as his master yoda sensed many emotions from anakin through the clone was and prequels.
As his master he's more hands on. Taking him completely out of the consul and academy and training hands on would be a much better teacher and parent figure than Obi-Wan maybe not as good as jin but he doesn't need to be. One of the biggest issues was who anakin looked to as a father figure and trusted with his darkest thoughts. Unfortunately that person was feeding his dark thoughts. Yoda wouldn't feed them instead he would constantly look for the light in every bit of darkness he finds hell he might accidentally make a jedi balanced in both sides of the force if the student is surrounded by that much darkness. He might find there's even a way to keep those who stumble upon the darkside from falling. Under the someone like anakin who lived such a tortuous environment. Watching how they over or pull their darkness towards the light should give him millions of ideas.
This was an outstanding narrative. Given the premise, I could easily see things going this way. Your logic was great here. The choices were unexpected, but not wrong at all. Good one.
@@PentePatrolStarWars So I along with others have been getting notifications of winning g an on going giveaway to contact you on telegram. That isn't you is it?
Yoda is one of the few Jedi who can properly train Anakin and ensure he never turn to the Dark Side including Mace Windu, Jedi Dooku and of course Qui-Gon Jinn. Obi-Wan is great but Anakin felt like he couldn’t go to him about Padme and other stuff that was troubling him. That could be a interesting story, What if Anakin confided with Obi-Wan about his marriage and troubles?
@@ieatpotatosalad535 Anakin would be also stronger than in Canon because Yoda would be able to give Anakin the push needed for him to tap into his full potential
What if Anakin had visions of order 66 instead of padme dying of childbirth? What if Anakin went undercover instead of Obi-Wan? What if tup was taken to the jedi temple instead of getting the atomic brain scan? What if shmi skywalker had a child with Clegg lars?
Your reading and fluency is getting better and better with every video, keep it up man. This was a great story! Hope we can get these animated with enough funding. You deserve the best Master Pente
I've watched quite a few of your "What If" scenarios and I think this one is the best so far. It shows Yoda learning and realizing he must change as well as the Jedi Order itself.
By far my favorite what if so far. When yoda knighted anakin I was welling up. It’s funny that it only has that impact because of how he was treated in canon. Great stuff
I enjoyed this immensely. . Definitely think this is your best video so far. . It ended on a happy note, it ended just as I wish it had, with Anakin staying in the light and fulfilling the prophecy as I think it was meant to be fulfilled. Thank you for making this. I love how you had Yoda learn whilst teaching. The mark of a true teacher in my opinion. Thank you again
My god! That is amazing. In this story, Anakin is truly the Chosen One! He didn't even hesitate that much when he was offered to bring balance to the Force sacrificing himself to Mortis. Yoda's training almost changed his whole personality! It feels like something only Yoda could achieve. Also the voice acting is absolutely great! I enjoyed every single second of this story. Thank you very much for your work! Can't wait to see what would happen if Qui-Gon visited Darth Vader!
While watching your movies, I came up with a few ideas. What if Padme survived but fell into a coma and Vader would find her, but not Luke and Leia? What if Anakin had stayed in the temple as Mace Windu had told him to do? What if the droid army had not been deactivated after Order 66? What if Anakin left the Jedi Order with a group of like-minded knights and Padawans and founded his own Branch of the Order? What if Mace Windu had killed Dooku in Attack of the Clones? What if Palpatine had not been elected Chancellor in The Phantom Menace? What if Palpatin's talks with the Separatists were accidentally intercepted by the Army of the Republic? What if the Republic, apart from producing clones, recruited ordinary citizens?
Not too much. I mean Palpatine has to act like he can’t use it, show no understanding of it, and whether or not he could sense it wouldn’t matter What’re they doing to do? Palpatine can just argue a conspiracy against the Republic if they stalked him
i love the last line change for skywalker! Because I feel if he were to fulfill the chosen one roll as he did the Jedi would have to change! Excellent! Well prepared! Well done! Well illustrated and well voiced! 8.5/10
What if the death star was never built what if anakin was framed for the temple bombing what if palpatine lost the election to bail organa what if general grievous died on the invisible hand What if oppo rancisis trained anakin what if padme didn't trade grievous for anakin
You probably have been suggested this before. Have Anakin be trained by the entire Jedi Council, since he is the chosen one, why would he be trained by only 1?
The Clone Wars wouldn’t allow that to happen unless the Jedi didn’t serve in the Grand Army. A decision Chancellor Palpatine wouldn’t allow let them make Dooku would rank up Grievous’s brutality and the Jedi would have to intervene as no one could stop them
Best story.. it makes sense. It is accurate and saddening and very well written. If Yoda were to of trained Anikan this is exactly how it would’ve happened, as sad and minimal action as it is. The Anikan becoming the father makes total sense and I love this
Fantastic story as always my guy. Loved how everything was easy to believe could happen and should have happened if Lucas wasn't so obsessed with limb removal lol
- What If Anakin Was Still Rejected By The Jedi Order Even After "Phantom Menace" - What If Qui Gon Survive And Trained Anakin - What If Dooku Trained Anakin - What If Barriss Offee Framed Anakin Instead Of Ahsoka - What If Anakin Was Trained By Revan's Spirit Or Just A Descendent Of Revan - What If Starkiller Survived "The Force Unleashed 1" - What If Cal Kestis Form "Fallen Order" Was Either Obi Wan Or Anakin's Padawan - What If Yoda Raised Both Luke & Leia - What If Star Wars Legends & The Movies Were Connected "With Some Minor Differences"
What if Maul survived his death in rebels? Just imagine Obi wan's face as he is looking at sliced Maul or What if Obi wan threw sand at vader in New hope?
I never even thought of that but if this single decision had been made, it would've changed everything. I had forgotten that because of Dooku, Yoda had no apprentice, so even according to the code, he really _could_ have taken him on as his apprentice.
this is definately best what if yoda trained anakin i heard, i loved how yoda took anakin away from everyone to train with the force instead of the other jedi younglings, i also loved how qui-gon didn't die meaning clone army was never made, which makes sense, in long run as dooku never left the order
Man I have this permanent feeding tube and terminal disease. So when I'm in pain and overwhelmed, I watch your videos and can distract myself from it for hours. Thaanks for making these.
it would be interesting if you make my what if Revan's force ghost trained Anakin skywalker or What if Revan and Cassus Fett returned during clone wars suggestion,i know it takes a lot of time to write what if's but with your writing and narrating anything would be interesting to watch.Tbh your what if's are better than SW Theory's,im not saying that his are bad but you put a lot of effort and thought into it and thats why i always enjoy your what ifs
Damb brother! I been with you for about 4 months and I’ve never seen a page grow so fast! Well deserved! Your stories are fantastic! Complete! No I’ll finish if you want me too B.S. keep up the great work my friend!
-What if in SWTOR, Ochos of Oblivion didn’t happen and Vitiate/Valkrion return around the movies? -What if Revan escaped the Maelstrom Prison during the Clone Wars? -What if Anakin WAS granted the Rank of Master when appointed to the Jedi Council? -What if Anakin saved Mace Windu and stayed in the light during Order 66? -What if Thrawn was present during the Original Trilogy? -What if Anakin/Vader was a double agent and played the long game like your Rebel Thrawn fic? -What if Maul was found by the Jedi before Sidious? -What if Grevious became Force Sensitive /can us the Force after that blood transfusion from Siyo Dias during his cybernetics reconstruction? -What if Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1? -What if Lord Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 dark side ending and ignoring the dlc? -What if Luke never gave up during the Sequels and gathered/trained more Jedi and prepared? -What if Luke found Rey and ACTUALLY TRAINED her at the Jedi School he founded?
also will anakin still fall in love with padme even if he is trained by toda also make this what if mace windu became grand master and led the entire Jedi order
What if Dooku trained Anakin after Phantom Menace? For this What If, Dooku either a. discovered Anakin on Tatooine before the events of Phantom Menace, or b. stuck around the jedi temple long enough to encounter the chosen one before the death of his former apprentice, Qui-Gon Jinn.
Awesome job. It brand tears to my eyes. Your an amazing story teller. This would be a great animated video. I wish it would happen. Take care my friend. MTFBWY, Always
I’ll just go on record saying that after Qui-hon died this REALLY should have been what happened in canon, if the Jedi had heads on their shoulders instead of trophies and ears/mouths instead of echo chambers.
Hmm well handled and very interesting take on handling things Much Faster... Like this could've been a series of Clone Wars where Yoda is more Active and I wish we Had Hours of this story going into all the detail and ALL the stuff Anakin and Yoda go through and their Reactions to all the Revelations throughout... Cause Mortis I can see being handled SO DIFFERENTLY If Master Yoda had been there... and I DO Love adding in the stuff from Achtoo or however its spelt... I think the Idea of Yoda realising with Anakin that the Order ISNT PERFECT is the Biggest and most Significant change to how the Balancing of the Force Issue is Handled and How Removing him from Coruscant is Also a Complete blending of All these possibilities that only get teased about in Clone Wars etc. I wonder Whether George would've Prefered THIS if He Knew he had ONLY One Movie and He KNEW Ahead of time How 9 movies would go with the Prequel Hate to the Disney Sale to The Sequel Hate... I wonder if He wouldnt Do THIS if He Had ONE Movie or Show to tell the Story... Though I guess it Only Matters with the Context of the Original Canon and so on... Disney fooks a LOT of it up for sure... I wish we had an Anime Made of George's ORIGINAL Plan for the Sequels with him as an Executive Producer that lets Filoni and a few others Just Follow what he had planned... I want The Sequel Trilogy THAT GEORGE WROTE dammit... you know? I mean that's ALL Imagination for now, innit? hehe But Well Done... Love a Lot of the Stories you make even when theyre Simple what if stories that can be told without Hours, its a Better Experience than... well I guess I should Finish watching one or two of the Disney Plus Series I didnt finish... I think it was Just Boba I didnt Watch more than an Episode or two as people continued giving rather Upset Reviews... But I need a Taste of Canon Star Wars from Disney so that I can EVEN MORE FULLY Believe that Only the Fans Can Produce Star Wars Stories that arent Ruined By Corporatism and need for Profit over Sharing Entertaining and Insighful Stories on Consciousness and Possibilities of Universes with Innumerable Lifeforms and Powers that would have high Spiritual Value to anyone in such Universes.... Cheers Pente! Another Well handled one!
you really need a pop filter for the device you used for yoda. i liked the story, and how much it changes the new canon, and still makes so much sense.
This is amazing, Mr. Pente Patrol; I like how you made the story more emotional and gave us something new (besides, someone trained Anakin). You're right about Yoda being a regular person, for he has flaws and needs to see a different point of view as a teacher. Seeing those flaws and understanding there needed some improvement led Yoda to bond well with Anakin and be something like a father figure to him. What's better, Qui-Gon Jinn and Shimi Skywalker are alive because of Yoda's actions. One, Yoda sends more Jedi to assist Qui-Gon. And his padawan, Obi-Wan Kenobi, on Naboo is an intelligent move, for they know if Maul might have acolytes with him, it's a good thing sending more Jedi would prevent Qui-Gon from being killed, which him being alive; would not cause Dooku to leave the order. Two, Yoda freeing Shimi Skywalker is a good thing because Anakin's attachments to his mother and those around him made him unique, and those attachments made him excel and thrive well in his Jedi training. He became a Jedi Knight faster under Yoda's teaching than Obi-Wan's training. Not only freeing Shimi Skywalker is a relief for Anakin, but freeing all the enslaved people in the Outer-Rim is a huge success and made the Jedi peacekeepers of the galaxy and defenders of the people. Because the Jedi Order is now being changed, this Jedi is more open to their emotions and closer to the people they are meant to protect and serve, not the politicians from the Galatic Senate from the Galactic Republic. Imagine if the Jedi could see how flawed their code is, then maybe they wouldn't be facing danger with Anakin turning on the dark side and won't lose any members but help them. I do have some other questions so far related to the video. Have other Jedi such as Quinlan Vos and Assjai Ventress stayed in the Jedi Order or still left? How could the daughter go to Anakin and Yoda if she could not leave Mortis physically? Would Anakin age the same as the father, or he can't? This is an excellent what-if video, Mr. Pente Patrol. This video is an exemplary masterpiece, especially with the voice acting, which made my day even brighter. Also, do you remember those links I showed, for example, on what type of Beskar Armor theme influence would fit best for Anakin? The links are from the comment "What If Plo Koon TRAINED Ahsoka Tano ( Star Wars What Ifs), do you see them on the bottom, and do you like them or dislike them? If you want to hear them out, I have three great what-if ideas for future what-if videos. So, to succeed with the brightest on your hopes and dreams, Mr. Pente Patrol, and May the force be with you!
I believe Windu could of been the perfect master for anakin as they were very a like in their darkside feelings. And i feel like anakin would have tremendous respect for mace as he did not fear the darkside but accepted it and learnt from it.
I've always had a problem with everyone, especially Mace Windu, saying Anakin is to old to be trained. Mace Windu himself, brought a 19 year old Rahm Kota to the Jedi temple to be trained as a jedi. Mace found him as a battle hardened teen that had been a child soldier his whole life up to that point. I just can't understand his disdain for Anakin being trained after that.
Without having listened to this yet, it would honestly make perfect sense for the Grand Master to be the one to train the one believed to be the Chosen One. Far too much would hang in the balance (so to speak) for them to risk someone so powerful to fall to the Dark Side, as of course ended up happening. Starting it now so I can hear your take on how this plays out.... After listening: Damn. It almost feels out of place hearing a Star Wars story with an actual happy, wholesome ending. Like the ending we all wanted Anakin to have and felt he deserved, but he never got.
A couple what if requests What if Luke was raised on alderan and leia was raised on tatooine What if padme didn’t die What if ahsoka joined the rebellion What if general grievous didn’t die What if palpatine found anakin before the jedi
Awesome video! Now I'm wondering what if Yoda turned to the dark side after training Anakin and killed Sidious, taking his place as the new Dark Lord of the Sith?
With the exception of qui gon or plo koon. Yoda is a great choice to teach him he has centuries of experience. What if qui gon survived and becomes the Jedi grand master or master of the order.
You should really consider putting these on Spotify as podcasts, it would help for me tremendously. I Commute a lot and would love to just listen to them while I’m driving
Man, I love the other Star Wars TH-cam channels, and no hate to them at all, but you are the one I’d have to say should actually work for Disney doing a What If series. It’s not only that your stories are great, because there’s a lot of channels who do great stories, but you also make them the perfect length for hour long episodes. Love your videos man
Just one thing I thought about listening to this: would Palpatine still kill Plagueis if he wasn’t able to get to Anakin? And if we assume he still kills Plagueis, would he not find another apprentice?
I would say yes, the whole reason he killed Plagueis was because he had his apprentice and he just won the seat of Chancellor. He killed Plagueis before Maul lost on Naboo
This was absolutely amazing! The narrative, the writing, the ending it was all so superbly done! Outstanding job and keep up the great work! I just found your channel through this video however, I do believe I will be subscribing for more exemplary content like this! I'm also very happy about two things in the story line which I will try to explain without spoiling it for others. The first one is Mortis I always wished they did more with that story arc and I've always wondered "what if?" (haha pun intended). The second thing is Yoda learning from Anakin and the way you used what he learned to shape things going forward in the galaxy as a whole! Once again amazing job and may the Force be with you Always!
Great video as always dude. I love and respect how much time effort and thought you always put into all these 'what-if' scenario videos. And I personally think that it's a 4-way tie between Master Yoda, Master Windu, Master Shak-Ti, and Master Plo Koon for second place as far as which Master on the High Council would have been best choice to train Anakin, with Master Yaddle being the BEST possible choice (in my personal opinion your 'what-if' video featuring Master Yaddle as Anakin's Master showed she would have been the BEST possible teacher for Anakin, but that's just my opinion). I'd love to see a 'what-if' scenario video if the Jedi Council member with the snake-like lower body (I HONESTLY don't remember his name) had trained Anakin. But even if that particular 'what-if' scenario never happens, again GREAT video dude.
Pente I'm willing to bet this will be ur best what if ever man, hopes it's a good one
Tbh it's my personal favorite right now XD y'all are not ready!
@@PentePatrolStarWars ok now I. want to time travel and watch this
@@PentePatrolStarWars Thank you for making all of these videos. They are so well done and are delivered with so much care and Passion. Keep up the great work!
@@clickfire8687 Thank you so much! It's all for you guys
@@PentePatrolStarWars 👋
What If the Republic and Jedi took Kalee’s side in the Huk War, leading to Grievous becoming a Republic General?
Gas idea
Hey yoo
Yea!
Hell yh love that
We need this
26:35 I never thought I would ever say this but Yoda needs to get himself a pop filter.
This was truly a beautiful story. So full of emotion and positive changes.
Thank you so much!
Yoda training Anakin would have been a case of the best teacher but not the best father figure. It would have logically made sense, as Anakin is the prophecized Chosen One. But Obi-Wan was one of the most emotional Jedi - far more than he is given credit for - but I think Qui-Gon would have been the ultimate best choice.
Right you are
Wise and perceptive. At least yoda is a certified therapist so it wouldn’t get too too bad so quickly
@@aaronlopez5163 he would certainly know how anakin was feeling at all times. Hell even not as his master yoda sensed many emotions from anakin through the clone was and prequels.
As his master he's more hands on. Taking him completely out of the consul and academy and training hands on would be a much better teacher and parent figure than Obi-Wan maybe not as good as jin but he doesn't need to be. One of the biggest issues was who anakin looked to as a father figure and trusted with his darkest thoughts. Unfortunately that person was feeding his dark thoughts. Yoda wouldn't feed them instead he would constantly look for the light in every bit of darkness he finds hell he might accidentally make a jedi balanced in both sides of the force if the student is surrounded by that much darkness. He might find there's even a way to keep those who stumble upon the darkside from falling. Under the someone like anakin who lived such a tortuous environment. Watching how they over or pull their darkness towards the light should give him millions of ideas.
Nah hear me out qui gon would be the /mf best teacher while yoda is the third but the best one to teach anakin would be vos
This was an outstanding narrative. Given the premise, I could easily see things going this way. Your logic was great here. The choices were unexpected, but not wrong at all. Good one.
Thank you so much!
@@PentePatrolStarWars So I along with others have been getting notifications of winning g an on going giveaway to contact you on telegram. That isn't you is it?
Yoda is one of the few Jedi who can properly train Anakin and ensure he never turn to the Dark Side including Mace Windu, Jedi Dooku and of course Qui-Gon Jinn. Obi-Wan is great but Anakin felt like he couldn’t go to him about Padme and other stuff that was troubling him.
That could be a interesting story, What if Anakin confided with Obi-Wan about his marriage and troubles?
Master Plo and Shak Ti could properly train Anikin also.
What about Fisto?
@@cassie7328 Anakin would have the power of That Smile
Mace was too much of an asshole to train him properly. As for Yoda, he trained Dooku and that didn't stop him from falling.
Yaddle would have been a good master for him as well.
Man I love someone who doesn’t do multiple part theory’s
what if Revan's force ghost trained Anakin Skywalker
This is YES.
Yes
Then we get a video where the word balance is thrown around enough times to make a drinking game out of it.
@@Elyseon take a shot every time you hear balance
I see nothing wrong with Yoda training Anakin.
yep for a time Yoda was Anakin's therapist
I think obiwans lack of experience was a reason for anakin being lost in a way
A therapist can be a mentor too if they lived for a millenia so i Don’t see anything wrong with this it actually feels right for a change
Yep, Gungans are dead, so that's good
@@ieatpotatosalad535 Anakin would be also stronger than in Canon because Yoda would be able to give Anakin the push needed for him to tap into his full potential
I have an idea that I’ve been thinking about for a few days…
What if Yoda was the Chosen one? How would that change the Galaxy 800 years early?
Another great thought. I hope the author of this story sees this and makes another video based on this. Great thought
This will most likely be your best what if I hope it lives up to the expectations
I believe it will ;)
@@PentePatrolStarWars Pente where would anakin scale in power next to other with and Jedi
@@PentePatrolStarWars like is he maul level?
What if Anakin had visions of order 66 instead of padme dying of childbirth?
What if Anakin went undercover instead of Obi-Wan?
What if tup was taken to the jedi temple instead of getting the atomic brain scan?
What if shmi skywalker had a child with Clegg lars?
love the first idea
What if kit fisto stayed at the Jedi temple with anikan while windu went to arrest the chancellor
I love these Star Wars what ifs and yoda training Anakin. The ultimate sacrifice to the force to maintain balance.
Thank you so much!
That intro before the story was just… insane. I thought I was listening to an auction
Best story you’ve ever done, in my opinion. This made me feel something positive about Star Wars for the first time in a long time… Thank you
Thank you so much!
Your reading and fluency is getting better and better with every video, keep it up man. This was a great story! Hope we can get these animated with enough funding. You deserve the best Master Pente
Thank you so much!
I've watched quite a few of your "What If" scenarios and I think this one is the best so far. It shows Yoda learning and realizing he must change as well as the Jedi Order itself.
By far my favorite what if so far. When yoda knighted anakin I was welling up. It’s funny that it only has that impact because of how he was treated in canon. Great stuff
I enjoyed this immensely. . Definitely think this is your best video so far. . It ended on a happy note, it ended just as I wish it had, with Anakin staying in the light and fulfilling the prophecy as I think it was meant to be fulfilled. Thank you for making this. I love how you had Yoda learn whilst teaching. The mark of a true teacher in my opinion. Thank you again
Thank you so much!
This could very well be my favorite "What if" that I've experienced! Thank you for your time on this!
I love it so much when your videos have this much logic and it always makes me think this is the way things should have been
Thank you so much!
My god! That is amazing. In this story, Anakin is truly the Chosen One! He didn't even hesitate that much when he was offered to bring balance to the Force sacrificing himself to Mortis. Yoda's training almost changed his whole personality! It feels like something only Yoda could achieve. Also the voice acting is absolutely great! I enjoyed every single second of this story. Thank you very much for your work! Can't wait to see what would happen if Qui-Gon visited Darth Vader!
Thank you so much!
While watching your movies, I came up with a few ideas.
What if Padme survived but fell into a coma and Vader would find her, but not Luke and Leia?
What if Anakin had stayed in the temple as Mace Windu had told him to do?
What if the droid army had not been deactivated after Order 66?
What if Anakin left the Jedi Order with a group of like-minded knights and Padawans and founded his own Branch of the Order?
What if Mace Windu had killed Dooku in Attack of the Clones?
What if Palpatine had not been elected Chancellor in The Phantom Menace?
What if Palpatin's talks with the Separatists were accidentally intercepted by the Army of the Republic?
What if the Republic, apart from producing clones, recruited ordinary citizens?
What if Palpatine got recognised as a force sensitive by the Jedi
Not too much. I mean Palpatine has to act like he can’t use it, show no understanding of it, and whether or not he could sense it wouldn’t matter
What’re they doing to do? Palpatine can just argue a conspiracy against the Republic if they stalked him
@@TheUncivilizedNation i think he meant, as a very young child.
@@TheUncivilizedNation if they knew he was force sensitive they would watch him like a hawk
i love the last line change for skywalker! Because I feel if he were to fulfill the chosen one roll as he did the Jedi would have to change! Excellent! Well prepared! Well done! Well illustrated and well voiced! 8.5/10
7th attempt to what if Anakin Skywalker and Galen Marek were rivals, Excellent what if per usual!
What if the death star was never built
what if anakin was framed for the temple bombing
what if palpatine lost the election to bail organa
what if general grievous died on the invisible hand
What if oppo rancisis trained anakin
what if padme didn't trade grievous for anakin
You probably have been suggested this before.
Have Anakin be trained by the entire Jedi Council, since he is the chosen one, why would he be trained by only 1?
The Clone Wars wouldn’t allow that to happen unless the Jedi didn’t serve in the Grand Army. A decision Chancellor Palpatine wouldn’t allow let them make
Dooku would rank up Grievous’s brutality and the Jedi would have to intervene as no one could stop them
@@TheUncivilizedNationbetween episodes 1 and 2
Probably the best one yet and the voice actors were great.
Can you do a What if The Jedi Council collectively trained Anakin?
Take care and Peace ✌🏻
Best story.. it makes sense. It is accurate and saddening and very well written. If Yoda were to of trained Anikan this is exactly how it would’ve happened, as sad and minimal action as it is. The Anikan becoming the father makes total sense and I love this
Thank you so much!
Ehh not so much for me I'd rather he become a master then become the father
Thank you!!! THANK YOU!!! I LOVE Revan!!! The Revan storyline in SW:TOR is one of my favorite quests.
I am loving Yoda training Anakin. Loved the end where Anakin stayed on Mortis and Yoda defeating Sidious. Best is getting the order to grow
Thank you so much!
Fantastic story as always my guy. Loved how everything was easy to believe could happen and should have happened if Lucas wasn't so obsessed with limb removal lol
Thank you so much!
What if Anakin joined the CIS on Genesis and helped Dooku overthrow Palpatine
And great job with the videos I hope you get close to a mil subs
- What If Anakin Was Still Rejected By The Jedi Order Even After "Phantom Menace"
- What If Qui Gon Survive And Trained Anakin
- What If Dooku Trained Anakin
- What If Barriss Offee Framed Anakin Instead Of Ahsoka
- What If Anakin Was Trained By Revan's Spirit Or Just A Descendent Of Revan
- What If Starkiller Survived "The Force Unleashed 1"
- What If Cal Kestis Form "Fallen Order" Was Either Obi Wan Or Anakin's Padawan
- What If Yoda Raised Both Luke & Leia
- What If Star Wars Legends & The Movies Were Connected "With Some Minor Differences"
Very good ideas! 👍
You can find the What if Qui Gon trained Anakin video on Star wars theory's channel
@@nezarecdiscipleofthewitnes3823he ememt in the ppsw style
What if Maul survived his death in rebels? Just imagine Obi wan's face as he is looking at sliced Maul
or
What if Obi wan threw sand at vader in New hope?
I think Vader would have blew up tatooine in rage
Vader would start killing everyone… like he tends to do in the Comics
I never even thought of that but if this single decision had been made, it would've changed everything. I had forgotten that because of Dooku, Yoda had no apprentice, so even according to the code, he really _could_ have taken him on as his apprentice.
They taught each other what it means to be a Jedi and how to help the galaxy
Sheesh make another one of these this was just amazing
Thank you so much!
@@PentePatrolStarWars no problem keep doing what you do you’ve helped me through so many bored nights you truly help people
This was a great video
What if an ancient Jedi master traveled through time and ended up in the clone wars times
He really should have trained Anakin, with Qui-Gons death he's the only one left that could have really given him a good chance
Really good one. Top 5 of my favorite Star Wars what ifs.
Thank you so much!
as an avid listener of starwars fan stories on youtube this is by far the best one i heard anywhere on youtube
Could you do maybe a what if obi wan never snuck on padme’s ship to mustafar i think that would be very interesting
What if Anakin and Grand Admiral Trawn were best friends and what if Anakin fell in love with Dutchess Satine
this is definately best what if yoda trained anakin i heard, i loved how yoda took anakin away from everyone to train with the force instead of the other jedi younglings, i also loved how qui-gon didn't die meaning clone army was never made, which makes sense, in long run as dooku never left the order
That was amazing story, your best work yet!
Thank you so much!
Man I have this permanent feeding tube and terminal disease. So when I'm in pain and overwhelmed, I watch your videos and can distract myself from it for hours. Thaanks for making these.
i bet that this video will go viral
👀👀
3 days 32k it will be
it would be interesting if you make my what if Revan's force ghost trained Anakin skywalker or What if Revan and Cassus Fett returned during clone wars suggestion,i know it takes a lot of time to write what if's but with your writing and narrating anything would be interesting to watch.Tbh your what if's are better than SW Theory's,im not saying that his are bad but you put a lot of effort and thought into it and thats why i always enjoy your what ifs
YES this is the VID I WAS WAITING FOR
Damb brother! I been with you for about 4 months and I’ve never seen a page grow so fast! Well deserved! Your stories are fantastic! Complete! No I’ll finish if you want me too B.S. keep up the great work my friend!
Thank you so much!
@@PentePatrolStarWars 100% deserved !
Dude this was beautiful man 100/10 and just saw your lasted one it is really good man
Thank you so much!
This was beautiful. Thank you for the stories.
-What if in SWTOR, Ochos of Oblivion didn’t happen and Vitiate/Valkrion return around the movies?
-What if Revan escaped the Maelstrom Prison during the Clone Wars?
-What if Anakin WAS granted the Rank of Master when appointed to the Jedi Council?
-What if Anakin saved Mace Windu and stayed in the light during Order 66?
-What if Thrawn was present during the Original Trilogy?
-What if Anakin/Vader was a double agent and played the long game like your Rebel Thrawn fic?
-What if Maul was found by the Jedi before Sidious?
-What if Grevious became Force Sensitive /can us the Force after that blood transfusion from Siyo Dias during his cybernetics reconstruction?
-What if Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1?
-What if Lord Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 dark side ending and ignoring the dlc?
-What if Luke never gave up during the Sequels and gathered/trained more Jedi and prepared?
-What if Luke found Rey and ACTUALLY TRAINED her at the Jedi School he founded?
What if Obi-Wan Kenobi found a way to stay young during his exile on Tatooine through the force?
also will anakin still fall in love with padme even if he is trained by toda also make this what if mace windu became grand master and led the entire Jedi order
I honestly can’t wait to see this outcome.
This story needs a part 2
This was beautiful. Good work:)
This was beautiful - again! Although Im struggling to cope with Anakin getting over Padme, but ill be fine. i think. :D
Awesome story! Thank you for everything! You have renewed my heart for star wars.
Thank you so much!
What if Dooku trained Anakin after Phantom Menace? For this What If, Dooku either a. discovered Anakin on Tatooine before the events of Phantom Menace, or b. stuck around the jedi temple long enough to encounter the chosen one before the death of his former apprentice, Qui-Gon Jinn.
This is absolutely amazing. I love this!
Thank you so much!
@@PentePatrolStarWars following!
Awesome job. It brand tears to my eyes. Your an amazing story teller. This would be a great animated video. I wish it would happen. Take care my friend. MTFBWY, Always
Got a cool request, "What if the Galactic Empire found a Star Forge?"
I’ll just go on record saying that after Qui-hon died this REALLY should have been what happened in canon, if the Jedi had heads on their shoulders instead of trophies and ears/mouths instead of echo chambers.
Oh no
First oho wan now qui hon
What’s next, Anakin Skyhonker?
Hmm well handled and very interesting take on handling things Much Faster... Like this could've been a series of Clone Wars where Yoda is more Active and I wish we Had Hours of this story going into all the detail and ALL the stuff Anakin and Yoda go through and their Reactions to all the Revelations throughout... Cause Mortis I can see being handled SO DIFFERENTLY If Master Yoda had been there... and I DO Love adding in the stuff from Achtoo or however its spelt...
I think the Idea of Yoda realising with Anakin that the Order ISNT PERFECT is the Biggest and most Significant change to how the Balancing of the Force Issue is Handled and How Removing him from Coruscant is Also a Complete blending of All these possibilities that only get teased about in Clone Wars etc. I wonder Whether George would've Prefered THIS if He Knew he had ONLY One Movie and He KNEW Ahead of time How 9 movies would go with the Prequel Hate to the Disney Sale to The Sequel Hate... I wonder if He wouldnt Do THIS if He Had ONE Movie or Show to tell the Story... Though I guess it Only Matters with the Context of the Original Canon and so on...
Disney fooks a LOT of it up for sure...
I wish we had an Anime Made of George's ORIGINAL Plan for the Sequels with him as an Executive Producer that lets Filoni and a few others Just Follow what he had planned...
I want The Sequel Trilogy THAT GEORGE WROTE dammit... you know?
I mean that's ALL Imagination for now, innit? hehe
But Well Done... Love a Lot of the Stories you make even when theyre Simple what if stories that can be told without Hours, its a Better Experience than... well I guess I should Finish watching one or two of the Disney Plus Series I didnt finish... I think it was Just Boba I didnt Watch more than an Episode or two as people continued giving rather Upset Reviews... But I need a Taste of Canon Star Wars from Disney so that I can EVEN MORE FULLY Believe that Only the Fans Can Produce Star Wars Stories that arent Ruined By Corporatism and need for Profit over Sharing Entertaining and Insighful Stories on Consciousness and Possibilities of Universes with Innumerable Lifeforms and Powers that would have high Spiritual Value to anyone in such Universes....
Cheers Pente! Another Well handled one!
you really need a pop filter for the device you used for yoda. i liked the story, and how much it changes the new canon, and still makes so much sense.
I’m gonna have the VA work on that, and thank you so much!
This is amazing, Mr. Pente Patrol; I like how you made the story more emotional and gave us something new (besides, someone trained Anakin). You're right about Yoda being a regular person, for he has flaws and needs to see a different point of view as a teacher. Seeing those flaws and understanding there needed some improvement led Yoda to bond well with Anakin and be something like a father figure to him. What's better, Qui-Gon Jinn and Shimi Skywalker are alive because of Yoda's actions. One, Yoda sends more Jedi to assist Qui-Gon. And his padawan, Obi-Wan Kenobi, on Naboo is an intelligent move, for they know if Maul might have acolytes with him, it's a good thing sending more Jedi would prevent Qui-Gon from being killed, which him being alive; would not cause Dooku to leave the order.
Two, Yoda freeing Shimi Skywalker is a good thing because Anakin's attachments to his mother and those around him made him unique, and those attachments made him excel and thrive well in his Jedi training. He became a Jedi Knight faster under Yoda's teaching than Obi-Wan's training. Not only freeing Shimi Skywalker is a relief for Anakin, but freeing all the enslaved people in the Outer-Rim is a huge success and made the Jedi peacekeepers of the galaxy and defenders of the people. Because the Jedi Order is now being changed, this Jedi is more open to their emotions and closer to the people they are meant to protect and serve, not the politicians from the Galatic Senate from the Galactic Republic. Imagine if the Jedi could see how flawed their code is, then maybe they wouldn't be facing danger with Anakin turning on the dark side and won't lose any members but help them.
I do have some other questions so far related to the video. Have other Jedi such as Quinlan Vos and Assjai Ventress stayed in the Jedi Order or still left? How could the daughter go to Anakin and Yoda if she could not leave Mortis physically?
Would Anakin age the same as the father, or he can't?
This is an excellent what-if video, Mr. Pente Patrol. This video is an exemplary masterpiece, especially with the voice acting, which made my day even brighter. Also, do you remember those links I showed, for example, on what type of Beskar Armor theme influence would fit best for Anakin? The links are from the comment "What If Plo Koon TRAINED Ahsoka Tano ( Star Wars What Ifs), do you see them on the bottom, and do you like them or dislike them?
If you want to hear them out, I have three great what-if ideas for future what-if videos. So, to succeed with the brightest on your hopes and dreams, Mr. Pente Patrol, and May the force be with you!
I believe Windu could of been the perfect master for anakin as they were very a like in their darkside feelings. And i feel like anakin would have tremendous respect for mace as he did not fear the darkside but accepted it and learnt from it.
I've always had a problem with everyone, especially Mace Windu, saying Anakin is to old to be trained. Mace Windu himself, brought a 19 year old Rahm Kota to the Jedi temple to be trained as a jedi. Mace found him as a battle hardened teen that had been a child soldier his whole life up to that point. I just can't understand his disdain for Anakin being trained after that.
I loved this version of the Star Wars story. I saw it all well in my mind how it played out. A great retelling of an already great story.
I love your "What if" videos the most out of all the other youtubers. I like the long videos and I find them very interesting and exciting to watch.
Thank you so much!
3:52 “No Master Mundi, my thoughts dwell on YOUR mother.”
Dang i missed this and the gui gon one. Your killing it man!! Cant wait to listen while at work. 😁👍
Without having listened to this yet, it would honestly make perfect sense for the Grand Master to be the one to train the one believed to be the Chosen One. Far too much would hang in the balance (so to speak) for them to risk someone so powerful to fall to the Dark Side, as of course ended up happening.
Starting it now so I can hear your take on how this plays out....
After listening: Damn. It almost feels out of place hearing a Star Wars story with an actual happy, wholesome ending. Like the ending we all wanted Anakin to have and felt he deserved, but he never got.
willing to bet this will be ur best what if ever man, hopes it's a good one
Thank you so much!
What If, Anakin Skywalker was slightly more emotionally mature
A couple what if requests
What if Luke was raised on alderan and leia was raised on tatooine
What if padme didn’t die
What if ahsoka joined the rebellion
What if general grievous didn’t die
What if palpatine found anakin before the jedi
Awesome video! Now I'm wondering what if Yoda turned to the dark side after training Anakin and killed Sidious, taking his place as the new Dark Lord of the Sith?
Your story fits so right it was just what anikin needed to go to the light this should be made into a movie
Started binge watching these and was wondering: What if Quilan Vos discovered Anakin and then trained him
I never understood the age requirement that the order was so mad about, cus the grandmaster himself wasn’t a Jedi till he was like 100-150 years old
This is my favorite what if. I'm watching this for a second time
Thank you so much!
What if Anakin Skywalker left the Jedi Order as soon as he was denied the rank of Master?
With the exception of qui gon or plo koon. Yoda is a great choice to teach him he has centuries of experience.
What if qui gon survived and becomes the Jedi grand master or master of the order.
Anakin will have the "Higher" Ground.
ah yes the higher ground
You should really consider putting these on Spotify as podcasts, it would help for me tremendously. I Commute a lot and would love to just listen to them while I’m driving
Man, I love the other Star Wars TH-cam channels, and no hate to them at all, but you are the one I’d have to say should actually work for Disney doing a What If series. It’s not only that your stories are great, because there’s a lot of channels who do great stories, but you also make them the perfect length for hour long episodes. Love your videos man
Thank you so much!
Well done, man. This is one of your best.
Just one thing I thought about listening to this: would Palpatine still kill Plagueis if he wasn’t able to get to Anakin? And if we assume he still kills Plagueis, would he not find another apprentice?
I would say yes, the whole reason he killed Plagueis was because he had his apprentice and he just won the seat of Chancellor. He killed Plagueis before Maul lost on Naboo
Disney should have and a small group of content creators, write all they're shows from now on.
You have such amazing ideas and how you write!
Thank you so much!
This was absolutely amazing! The narrative, the writing, the ending it was all so superbly done! Outstanding job and keep up the great work! I just found your channel through this video however, I do believe I will be subscribing for more exemplary content like this! I'm also very happy about two things in the story line which I will try to explain without spoiling it for others. The first one is Mortis I always wished they did more with that story arc and I've always wondered "what if?" (haha pun intended). The second thing is Yoda learning from Anakin and the way you used what he learned to shape things going forward in the galaxy as a whole! Once again amazing job and may the Force be with you Always!
What if Denal survived to become an ARC Trooper
Algorithmorg comment, brain is melting, but it’ll be good to wake up to this being premiered
Great video as always dude. I love and respect how much time effort and thought you always put into all these 'what-if' scenario videos.
And I personally think that it's a 4-way tie between Master Yoda, Master Windu, Master Shak-Ti, and Master Plo Koon for second place as far as which Master on the High Council would have been best choice to train Anakin, with Master Yaddle being the BEST possible choice (in my personal opinion your 'what-if' video featuring Master Yaddle as Anakin's Master showed she would have been the BEST possible teacher for Anakin, but that's just my opinion).
I'd love to see a 'what-if' scenario video if the Jedi Council member with the snake-like lower body (I HONESTLY don't remember his name) had trained Anakin.
But even if that particular 'what-if' scenario never happens, again GREAT video dude.
Your one hell of a story teller bro. Keep up the great work. Your doing a awesome.
Thank you so much!