DON'T DO E.C. ELIMINATION COMMUNICATION. WHAT I WISH I KNEW BEFORE STARTING E.C. IS IT WORTH IT?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ต.ค. 2023
- I’m here to tell you why you should not do elimination communication. It doesn’t make potty training easier. It doesn’t mean your baby will be potty trained earlier. You change diapers more often because the baby shouldn’t get used the the feeling of sitting in a wet diaper. You can make potty time as part of the disper changing routine.
It’s not potty training it’s communication so you still have to potty train your child.
EC is all about the adult/caregiver recognizing hints of communication the baby is giving that they need to pee/poop.
Though transitioning from communication and potty training is another step but I think the best book to read for that is “Oh Crap Potty Training” which focuses on just that.
You can do EC and potty train earlier or later
You can skip EC but still start potty training early before 2 years.
Just as doing EC does not guarantee early potty training. Not doing EC doesn’t mean you can’t potty train early.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
OTHER VIDEOS
Vlogs • VLOGS
Day in the Life
• Day In The Life
Traveling • Traveling
Let's talk • Let's Talk
My Birth Story • Our Birth Story
Must read parenting books playlist
The Montessori Toddler. • The Montessori Toddler
How to Talk so Little Kids will Listen. • How to Talk so Little ...
The Whole-Brain Child. • Whole-Brain Child
Cribsheet
• Cribsheet
How Eskimos Keep their Babies Warm
• Cribsheet
Elimination Communication. Potty training early.
• Elimination Communication
My Journey with Elimination Communication. • Elimination Communicat...
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
SOCIAL MEDIA
Instagram / kacang_family
EMAIL
kacangfam@gmail.com
Disclosures: The examples and opinions are my own. This video is not sponsored by the books or other channels listed. The links are affiliate links and I may receive a small commission that is no cost to you.
Subscribe Button + Notification Bell (+ Sound FX) 🔔 [Green Screen/Alpha Channel] HD by MrNumber112 • Free Download: Subscri... - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
![[TH] VCT Pacific Stage 2 - Playoffs Day 3 // DRX vs GEN | PRX vs TLN](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CWM1Q-2-o3M/mqdefault.jpg)
![fellow fellow - Proud [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9uZF7BlUQPE/mqdefault.jpg)
We used cloth diapers with wool wicks. We also did Elimination Communication. The simple aspect of giving your infant an opportunity to use the bathroom when they wake up, just like EVERY human does, and also giving them the opportunity around 22 minutes after eating, was VERY effective. My daughter was potty trained before she was 1 years old. She waited to use the bathroom and started giving us sign language cues if we didn't provide the opportunity.
Learning your child and understanding their cicadian rhythm is only a good thing. To say one should not do this or base your anxieties with it as a result of the method is flawed thinking.
Diaper training a mammal to an unatural act causes a harder transition when toilet training later. My daughter ALWAYS associated the bathroom with bowel movements. Instead of teaching her to poop on herself, we taught her to poop in the toilet. How is that a bad thing?
I 100% agree! I could not just let my baby use a diaper when knowing they are peeing or pooping. Even for my husband, we don’t regret doing EC especially when the solid poops start coming or when we travel. I also feel like it’s so respectful to the baby.
Thanks for the video! Just wanted to say that I saw a video of yours from 2 years ago and then this one and your videos have really improved in that time! I'm getting ready to have my first kid in a couple months and found out about EC today and dove into that research rabbit hole which brought me here. I appreciated your perspective.
Thank you 🙏 I was working on this channel for 2 years when I was a SAHM and now I started a new channel and that’s been my focus (along with work and kids). This channel has definitely been more of a learning process and I’m not sure if I will continue to post here 😐
Here is my new channel (totally different niche) youtube.com/@AnnisaChomps?si=kYJzJM67gP6UULXv
Congratulations and have fun with your first baby
Clickbait makes me not respect u at all
So true. But my click through rate is much higher and viewers demand a thumbnail that evokes emotion. There are reasons to do EC and not.
@@KacangFamilyBut your viewers aren’t genuine and won’t come back.
Tha k you for being real about EC!
You’re welcome
I LOVE this kind of no nonsense tips! I tried EC at about 3 or 4 months but what i was doing the way you said but then stopped because i felt like i didnt really understand EC and checking cues all day with another child in diaper and a 4 yo was just too much. I was looking for a video to find more about EC like how to do it practically and found this video. Thats perfect for me. My son is 6 months and i think this is perfect. Ill make a routine.
My older kids are 4 and 2 (3 in 2 weeks). The 2yo still in diaper and i dont want this for the 3rd one. Ill make a routine with the potty and diaper change.
Thank you. I clearly did EC but also see the benefit of not doing EC. Lots of videos make it seem soo easy and just awesome.
When relaxing about looking for cues, I found myself just seeing them at times. It felt less stressful instead of searching for cues. Congratulations on the third baby.
💙 Annisa
I did part time EC in the way that I put my baby on the potty every time I did a diaper changed. As you mention, I did change her quite often because I didn't want her to get used to feeling wet. In some periods she peed most of the times when I put her on the potty, in other periods she didn't. Fast forward to when she was about... 20 months old, I had an entire week that she was completely potty trained. But then the 'I-am-nearly-two-and-I-say-no-phase' came around and ever since she is sort of fighting when I want to put her on the toilet. Now she is 25 months old and still not out of that phase. I'm patiently waiting till she does. Because I'm convinced that due to E.C. she can deliberately hold her pee if she wants to, she can control her bladder as she likes. And I don't think that that would have been the case without part time E.C. But the biggest advantage of all why I think E.C. is worth it, is because she hasn't pooped in her diaper since she was 4 months old (except for one week when she went through a developing stage). And even though it is my own child, I think that dirty diapers are absolutely disgusting, especially when you do cloth diaper (what we did). So I'd say part time E.C. has been absolutely worth it to me. (I'm from the Netherlands btw ;) )
Hi! Thanks for sharing your experience. Bud bud is 25 months old also and on the no phase. We are also waiting for it to past but he does well out of the house holding it and peeing at offered times or by telling us. At home he tends to pee in his pants and I think it’s because there’s a change of clothes… I’m the same with poop 💩 I want no poopy diapers! 😝 Annisa
Kid#1: EC at 9 months. Last nocturnal accident was at age 14. Used to be every single night until 8, then slowed gradually. Used to pack a change of clothes for school due to almost daily accidents in first year. Has incontinence even now at 15.
Kid#2: EC at 18 months. Last nocturnal accident was at age 10. Still has daytime accidents if tickled for more than 10 seconds (despite enjoying being tickled) at the age of 11.
Kid#3: potty trained at 3. Last nocturnal accident (of less than 10 total) was at age 7. No daytime accidents, even when tickled.
I only bring it up because other moms saw the same pattern with their kids. I suspect that the stress of worrying about wetting themselves creates anxiety which leads to more accidents. 🤷♀️
Oh I haven’t heard of this in the EC community. Mine is now 4.5 and no accidents at night except when sick… but she walks to the toilet on her own. She transitioned herself to it on her own.
Thank you for sharing your experience
My youngest is the only one who will wake up consistently to potty. We had a rule for years that no one would get water for at least an hour before bedtime and there were nights my eldest still had two accidents. She almost never wakes up to go. My middle child also rarely wakes up to go and sometimes dreams that he's on the potty. One time he realized what was happening in his dream and woke himself up to go. @@KacangFamily
Aee you saying 14mo or yrs?
@@sunshineand Years.
Hi there! I enjoyed your video I hope you're well. I'm in northern America, I just started EC yesterday and have caught 3 poops already. I give my almost 7 week old opportunities, after waking, a bit after eating. I like giving her the opportunity to not have to poop in the diaper she's wearing
🙌 I love it. Someone in US ☺️ it’s always scary doing EC in public but then again less poopie diapers is golden. It’s all about the opportunity. I can’t imagine it’s comfortable to sit in your own squishy poop.
Did you end up doing the "Oh Crap" book review? We're doing EC, have been since birth, now 10 months and in Australia.
No I didn’t 😞 I ended up taking a break from posting videos but I’m thinking of starting up again. I like the “Oh Crap” book as a guide. I would do EC until baby is more independent and can walk, pull down pants, and sit independently before attempting potty training. Good job doing EC for 10 months already.
Doctors don’t recommend EC bc the babies tend to hold urine which can result in bladder and kidney infections
Diapers are the biggest waste. So bad for the earth. So I def think cloth is good if you can’t do ec. Also don’t you think they should sit less in their own body waste? That seems better to change more.
Yes! Well we tend to change diaper quite often unless it’s a disposable and we are traveling or it’s night time. But we also do EC while traveling and have also continued using cloth diapers (challenging but doable) with disposables as an emergency.
I did e.c. and my daughter is potty trained at 18 mths besides night time.
I did cloth and she used less diapers. I just did not want her to sit in yuck. I was not stressed I was happy about it.
It is a process.
Not sure why someone would lie about diapers
After doing EC with one baby I just can’t ignore the signs when baby has to pee/poop even if I try. I wasn’t sure my husband would do it with our second but once we catch the poops in the potty it’s addicting.
Definitely not for everyone.
Ec seems like a good balance but you don't have to do just ec
Yes!!! I feel like we are in the middle ground for everything like pureed vs BLW OR cloth diaper vs disposable AND even part time EC. 💙 Annisa
EC is great I couldn't go back to blindly using nappies, theres a great lady from Tamil Nadu on facebook EC group and she said even in traditional EC societies like hers, misses are 100% normal. My first child wasn't EC but still has accidents sometimes. I think the issue is when western perfectionism meets EC it goes wrong for people. I couldn't just sit and watch a baby pooing themselves now it makes me cringe!
Same! I tried to just take a break from EC with my second and it was impossible to just not offer. Especially, when it’s clear or going out my baby didn’t pee in the car seat. 💙 Annisa
@@KacangFamily it’s like you have this new awareness of babies needs! You can’t not offer when you can tell they need to go!!
When I shared this idea with people on FB someone I know said to me "It sounds like the parents are being potty trained". I said you can either use that time to change a dirty diaper or you can bring them to the potty.
Once you know about EC, it would feel neglectful NOT to offer your baby “pottytunities”