I think there's a misunderstanding of what gluttony means. It's not just something to do with food it's overindulgence so that could mean partying too much just doing too much of everything that makes you happy.
You make a solid point! I was basing the video's idea off of the generic stuff I could find online so that's why it's all food related. Overindulgence changes my thoughts on the theory, now I'm wondering if I could've looked at Squidward (like the whole boredom sequence in Squidville from Season 2). Makes me think a lot more about the theory, thanks for the feedback!
to be fair the 7DS are pretty common character flaws that most characters or people have in one way or another, it's almost like they're not meant to be considered some ultimate evil but instead the 7 fundamental traits that make up all negative behaviours.
@AzureWolf168 I think to some extent the 7DS are necessary, can you have ambition without greed? can you have pride (in the virtuous sense like self esteem) with a little bit of vanity? Can you relax without sloth? maybe gluttony has no redeeming value, and lust is gluttony for sex so maybe those 2 are just no good.
Yup, they're just rough categories that most sinful and negative human behaviors. There's also lesser 7 Virtues that represent their positive opposites.
I see Gary as a tragic character. He has a very deep and intricate mind, but he's in a pets body, meaning he can only have his mind to keep him company, endlessly developing and practicing philosophy without purpose or point. He doesn't have any struggles except for spongebob and anyone who takes care of him, unable to voice his discontent, unable to improve his situation without sheer luck. If spongebob, who is a major authoritive force, but mostly still shows signs of kindness takes care of him, He gets to live a standard pet life, mabye sun tanning on the roof, or reading spongebos books occasionally. If Patrick, who actively terrorizes him, takes care of him, he has to fear for his life. If squidward, who is neglectful takes care of him, he has to find his own way to survive. If Mr. Krabs gets his hands on him, he is reduced to a tool. If plankton gets his hands on him, he loses his identity and comfort, and has to fight to get it back. A carefree, yet tragic life. Hey, at least he can be free in his dreams. (Man, no wonder Gary was angry at spongebob when he invaded his dream...)
I can't see any possibility of Gary being chosen for gluttony other than whoever started the theory got done with a few characters, ran out, and had to give a "sure I guess" to one of them
Thanks! This was my first video so I wanted some chill background footage but couldn't find any good ocean stuff, but then jellyfish just jumped out as an obvious choice to use.
Tbh, Patrick is way more like gluttony than Gary is (since Patrick usually eats a lot of food and in The Patrick Star Show, he literally eaten and killed two innocent people on live television). Also this video made me realize how abusive SpongeBob is to Gary. No wonder why SpongeBob was blaming Gary when he was being eaten alive in A Pal for Gary, it was all leading up to this. Also have you seen what SpongeBob did at the end of the season 5 episode "SpongeBib vs. the Patty Gadget?"
Even if the 7 sins were intended for the series I don't think Gary was apart of them. Sure Gary is a main character in the show but if you look at the original pitch bible for SpongeBob Gary is only mentioned once and not even as a character profile.
really amazing video so far. about 8 minutes in but its worth noting: regular show had a similiar issue with saturation. one episode (forget what it was called but it was about a weight lifting tourtamnet.) had the opposite issue where the colors were SUPER SUPER saturated instead of being slightly more desaturated.
Also I was wondering if Gary is canonically a robot, since in the season 3 episode "The Great Snail Race" we can see him with machine parts inside his shell?
The nuclear mutation theory really isn’t that wrong of a theory. Bikini bottom is based off of bikini atoll, a place where nuclear weapons were tested, and if I remember correctly there was an episode where everyone except Sandy “unmutated” into normal sea life. TL;DR that mutation theory has some solid footing from what I was able to gather
Yes there wasn’t a deleted scene where squidward turned into a snail that was a regular scene intended to be in the episode I remember it when I was 4 years old
The spongebob abuse of gary thing is just one example of how practically everyone one in SpongeBob was kinda a awful person even before the seasonal rot, a little depressing to be honest.
I like to think Lawrence was just doing some Zach Hadel level gaslighting with the other cast members in that clip, and just totally fucking with them.
my interpretation: ms. puff=glutony, she eats apples whole. spongebob=lust, he loves everyone. patrick=sloth, isnt it obvious? plankton=envy, he want the secret formula. mr. krabs=greed, "money, money, money- AAA" squidward=wrath, he is literally wrath. squilliam=pride, he thinks like he is the best. sandy=K A R A T E, come on, they said it!
It's so dumb because each sin really just a simple character flaw (being a lazy doofus, being a grump, being a little too lovey-dovey?) and not some nefarious symbolism
now that you have proven that gary is not gluttony you now must make a video for each of the cast and a final one putting the correcrt characters into the 7 deadly sins
I may be able to, but I barely managed to squeeze enough content out of Gary for this video lol, but I'll keep it in the video ideas inventory for a potential future upload, thanks!
i liked this video for the most part. i think using more clips than screenshots would make it better though. i really like your humor and you make some great jokes in this. visually there isn't a whole lot going on in the video so the part where you put the stats on screen of how often gary is seen with food was good! but also bad because you don't say it out loud. remember that if your video isn't engaging enough for people to watch and they just listen, they'll miss out on important details like those stats. just some helpful tips and thanks for the video!
True for all that! This was my first video so it was just dipping my toes into this to try it out, so the quality kinda sucks at some points. I honestly didn't think the video would do so well, but of course it _had_ to be the video with a ton of rookie mistakes lol. Still, thanks for the feedback!
The Squidward turns into a snail scene does exist, but idk if it was just part of the DVD I watched the episode on, I no longer have the disc but I remember it was something like a Halloween special, it included 3 episodes one was when squidward forgets about Gary, another was the Halloween episode where spongebob shaves himself to be a ghost, and the last one…. I can’t remember off the top of my head
that 7 deadly sins shit is... whatever. But like, Patrick is sloth? Gary is gluttony? Reverse that shit. Patrick showed gluttonous behaviour more times than gary IN THIS VIDEO ABOUT GARY BEING A GLUTTON. Gary is a snail! Snails are SLOW, one might even say SLOTHFUL.
I loved the video man. You got a like and subscriber outta me, but one friendly piece of constructive criticism.: The speaker blowing yelling thing for the sake of a punchline is genuinely funny and you do it well, but I think it should be a little more reserved. Like 2 times in a video might be a cap for a lot of people, but hey, that could just be me.
I completely agree, and the speaker cap is mainly unintentional. This was my first vid so I had no idea how to even get a semi-decent mic recording. It gets better with each new video on the channel I promise lol
There's quite a few theories I believe(Many because they are funny.) but the main theory I believe is the nuclear one. Mainly because it's not a theory it's been confirmed that it's based on Bikini Atoll a nuclear test site.
The 'turn into a snail' thing refers to the urban legend of an extended scene of squidward undergoing a graphic transformation that was censored. while the episode does end with squidward as a snail we do not directly see him trnsform for more info th-cam.com/video/vw7YXhVe_lg/w-d-xo.html
This video should have been named something along the lines of “Every SpongeBob & Gary moment”. Because that’s what it felt like watching this drag on longer then it needed just for a small debunking on one detail of an absurd theory. But nice Video anyway, I’m not gonna hate!
Maybe someone said this already but Procrastination got censored a little after the first airing. The part where Sponge imagines his friends outside having fun got cut cause Patrick is rubbing sunscreen on Sandy's shoulders. I think some people though he was rubbing her boobs or something? I forget official line but in re-airings, that scene was removed. I think they fucked up the color when Nick had it edited. That's always been my theory anyway
OMG OMG OMG! I have seen this and watch this video on TH-cam and it was awesome! I love SpongeBob SquarePants because it's the best show ever! I think Gary is Gluttony since he loves to eat food. I can also relate to him since I eat certain food (usually McDonald's) too! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I feel like the roles are all wrong which is why Gary gets such an unfitting role. Patrick is an easy Gluttony. Squidward is easily Pride. SpongeBob is Wrath (this video damn near proves it). Plankton Envy. Krabs Greed. Sandy Lust (the biggest stretch, but her thrist for knowledge and bikini figure could do enough). And lastly, Gary is Sloth.
The thing is, I feel you could pose the same theory to any screwball comedy with an eclectic cast. The goal is to give each character some unique flaw, which due to its intrinsic ties to studied human behavior leads to each of them often vaguely resembling one of the seven sins. It's yet another case of people trying to find a "deeper meaning" in something when the answer is so much simpler if you just have a basic understanding of what characters, themes, and narratives make for compelling entertainment. It just ain't that deep bro.
I think there's a misunderstanding of what gluttony means. It's not just something to do with food it's overindulgence so that could mean partying too much just doing too much of everything that makes you happy.
You make a solid point! I was basing the video's idea off of the generic stuff I could find online so that's why it's all food related. Overindulgence changes my thoughts on the theory, now I'm wondering if I could've looked at Squidward (like the whole boredom sequence in Squidville from Season 2). Makes me think a lot more about the theory, thanks for the feedback!
Slasher did a pretty unique thing with this concept
to be fair the 7DS are pretty common character flaws that most characters or people have in one way or another, it's almost like they're not meant to be considered some ultimate evil but instead the 7 fundamental traits that make up all negative behaviours.
@AzureWolf168 I think to some extent the 7DS are necessary, can you have ambition without greed? can you have pride (in the virtuous sense like self esteem) with a little bit of vanity? Can you relax without sloth? maybe gluttony has no redeeming value, and lust is gluttony for sex so maybe those 2 are just no good.
didnt the spongebob crew confirmed that the 7DS were a very rough layout of their characters personality flaws?
was waiting for the 4DS, they made the 7DS?????
Yup, they're just rough categories that most sinful and negative human behaviors. There's also lesser 7 Virtues that represent their positive opposites.
i prefer the 3ds tbh
I see Gary as a tragic character. He has a very deep and intricate mind, but he's in a pets body, meaning he can only have his mind to keep him company, endlessly developing and practicing philosophy without purpose or point. He doesn't have any struggles except for spongebob and anyone who takes care of him, unable to voice his discontent, unable to improve his situation without sheer luck.
If spongebob, who is a major authoritive force, but mostly still shows signs of kindness takes care of him, He gets to live a standard pet life, mabye sun tanning on the roof, or reading spongebos books occasionally. If Patrick, who actively terrorizes him, takes care of him, he has to fear for his life. If squidward, who is neglectful takes care of him, he has to find his own way to survive. If Mr. Krabs gets his hands on him, he is reduced to a tool. If plankton gets his hands on him, he loses his identity and comfort, and has to fight to get it back.
A carefree, yet tragic life. Hey, at least he can be free in his dreams. (Man, no wonder Gary was angry at spongebob when he invaded his dream...)
He'd make a good agent at OWCA
I like when he says meow
You know it's going to get wild when "minor spoilers for Evangelion" is in the first frame of a Spongebob video.
I can't see any possibility of Gary being chosen for gluttony other than whoever started the theory got done with a few characters, ran out, and had to give a "sure I guess" to one of them
i actually have memories of the desaturated look of procrastination. guess the aussie nick did'nt catch on as fast as the US version
this jumped in popularity WHY DO YOU GUYS LIKE THIS VIDEO SO MUCH
Came for the sin of Gary stayed for the sin of the of SpongeBob. We need retribution for Gary. #freegary
The way you incorporated the music into the video, along with the jellyfish visuals made it very soothing and has a nice vibe to it
Thanks! This was my first video so I wanted some chill background footage but couldn't find any good ocean stuff, but then jellyfish just jumped out as an obvious choice to use.
@@btanmanYOUR FIRST VIDEO?! i honestly thought you were a well established experienced youtuber based on the quality of the vid
Tbh, Patrick is way more like gluttony than Gary is (since Patrick usually eats a lot of food and in The Patrick Star Show, he literally eaten and killed two innocent people on live television).
Also this video made me realize how abusive SpongeBob is to Gary. No wonder why SpongeBob was blaming Gary when he was being eaten alive in A Pal for Gary, it was all leading up to this. Also have you seen what SpongeBob did at the end of the season 5 episode "SpongeBib vs. the Patty Gadget?"
Gluttony Greed and Sloth are siamese triplets
Source?
Also Gary is a murderer. He deserves eternal abuse.
@@bungiecrimes7247 Source for what?
@@bungiecrimes7247Yeah he did canonically kill people.
The mutation theory was kinda confirmed a bit considering that Bikini Bottom is supposed to be where Bikini Atoll is irl
Schizopost video listing every instance of gary eating in all of spongebob, with good humor? Liked.
3:02 “Thankfully, just abused” got me cackling, this video was amazingly entertaining 👍 keep it up bro!
The only spongebob theory that I believe is the nuclear bomb one
The nuclear bomb is where the Bikini in Bikini atoll came from. It was hotter than a woman in a Bikini. And SpongeBob is in Bikini Bottom. Hmmm
Even if the 7 sins were intended for the series I don't think Gary was apart of them. Sure Gary is a main character in the show but if you look at the original pitch bible for SpongeBob Gary is only mentioned once and not even as a character profile.
He was meant to be like Shelly yea
really amazing video so far. about 8 minutes in but its worth noting:
regular show had a similiar issue with saturation. one episode (forget what it was called but it was about a weight lifting tourtamnet.) had the opposite issue where the colors were SUPER SUPER saturated instead of being slightly more desaturated.
Also I was wondering if Gary is canonically a robot, since in the season 3 episode "The Great Snail Race" we can see him with machine parts inside his shell?
We also see him with a butt😹😹
It's called a gag lol
The nuclear mutation theory really isn’t that wrong of a theory.
Bikini bottom is based off of bikini atoll, a place where nuclear weapons were tested, and if I remember correctly there was an episode where everyone except Sandy “unmutated” into normal sea life.
TL;DR that mutation theory has some solid footing from what I was able to gather
Yes there wasn’t a deleted scene where squidward turned into a snail that was a regular scene intended to be in the episode I remember it when I was 4 years old
It was him and SpongeBob and Garry all snails on a wall
@@KingsNJenssonsthat’s real. What isn’t real is people say there’s a scene where you can see squid transform like a werewolf kinda
@@KingsNJenssonsI have it on dvd :D
The spongebob abuse of gary thing is just one example of how practically everyone one in SpongeBob was kinda a awful person even before the seasonal rot, a little depressing to be honest.
I like to think Lawrence was just doing some Zach Hadel level gaslighting with the other cast members in that clip, and just totally fucking with them.
7:59 it looks like a creepypasta tbh
my interpretation:
ms. puff=glutony, she eats apples whole.
spongebob=lust, he loves everyone.
patrick=sloth, isnt it obvious?
plankton=envy, he want the secret formula.
mr. krabs=greed, "money, money, money- AAA"
squidward=wrath, he is literally wrath.
squilliam=pride, he thinks like he is the best.
sandy=K A R A T E, come on, they said it!
dude i thought i was alone in my hatred for this theory!! LOL
It's so dumb because each sin really just a simple character flaw (being a lazy doofus, being a grump, being a little too lovey-dovey?) and not some nefarious symbolism
I think we need an investigation on Spongebob...The race episode was the nail in the coffin for me when I was younger
Idea: make bubble bas gluttony
Reason: his order at the krusty krab
now that you have proven that gary is not gluttony you now must make a video for each of the cast and a final one putting the correcrt characters into the 7 deadly sins
I may be able to, but I barely managed to squeeze enough content out of Gary for this video lol, but I'll keep it in the video ideas inventory for a potential future upload, thanks!
squid so turned into a snail because patrick threw a rock or something at him for meowing
i liked this video for the most part. i think using more clips than screenshots would make it better though. i really like your humor and you make some great jokes in this. visually there isn't a whole lot going on in the video so the part where you put the stats on screen of how often gary is seen with food was good! but also bad because you don't say it out loud. remember that if your video isn't engaging enough for people to watch and they just listen, they'll miss out on important details like those stats. just some helpful tips and thanks for the video!
True for all that! This was my first video so it was just dipping my toes into this to try it out, so the quality kinda sucks at some points. I honestly didn't think the video would do so well, but of course it _had_ to be the video with a ton of rookie mistakes lol. Still, thanks for the feedback!
So karate is the 8th deadly sin is canon now
Patrick is more gluteus the sloths Gary in a snail
Patrick is gluttony. SpongeBob is pride
Pat is more gluttonous since we’ve seen him eating way more than Gary bear
Nuclear bomb is configmed in the pilot book thingy show bible or whatever it's called
@AzureWolf168 bikini atol was bombed💀
The Squidward turns into a snail scene does exist, but idk if it was just part of the DVD I watched the episode on, I no longer have the disc but I remember it was something like a Halloween special, it included 3 episodes one was when squidward forgets about Gary, another was the Halloween episode where spongebob shaves himself to be a ghost, and the last one…. I can’t remember off the top of my head
that 7 deadly sins shit is... whatever. But like, Patrick is sloth? Gary is gluttony? Reverse that shit. Patrick showed gluttonous behaviour more times than gary IN THIS VIDEO ABOUT GARY BEING A GLUTTON. Gary is a snail! Snails are SLOW, one might even say SLOTHFUL.
Plus Gary's favorite pastime is watching TV.
Personally, I still think Gary being voiced by Keith David that one time is a Coraline reference given he voiced the cat in that movie
Squid did turn into a snail .. in that episode when they were on the gate
Pet sitter pat is an underrated episode its funny
Spongebob is "rigging mob votes" is one heck of a quote
14:36 as a chicago resident i can confirm that this has happened
I'm so sorry for you :(
Haha
@@btanmanplease reply to me, I help unpopular channels get popular 😊
Gary as sloth just does not add up for me. I'd rearrange how a couple of them are listed at least. Solid video, thank you for some entertaining stuff!
I loved the video man. You got a like and subscriber outta me, but one friendly piece of constructive criticism.:
The speaker blowing yelling thing for the sake of a punchline is genuinely funny and you do it well, but I think it should be a little more reserved. Like 2 times in a video might be a cap for a lot of people, but hey, that could just be me.
I completely agree, and the speaker cap is mainly unintentional. This was my first vid so I had no idea how to even get a semi-decent mic recording. It gets better with each new video on the channel I promise lol
Underrated content
Thanks for the message, it means a lot!
There's quite a few theories I believe(Many because they are funny.) but the main theory I believe is the nuclear one. Mainly because it's not a theory it's been confirmed that it's based on Bikini Atoll a nuclear test site.
cool video and all, but you have achieved peak comedy with that thumbnail.
Did no one else notice when he called rock bottom, Detroit. 😂
If you're gonna includr gary biting squidward in little Yellow book the you gotta include once bitten
THE SCENE WITH SQUIDWARD IS REAL, WE JUST JUMPED TO A LAMER UNIVERSE. I KNOW I SAW THE DAMN SCENE
the theory is literally confirmd by the creators, also squidward did turn into a snail it was not cut to
The 'turn into a snail' thing refers to the urban legend of an extended scene of squidward undergoing a graphic transformation that was censored. while the episode does end with squidward as a snail we do not directly see him trnsform
for more info
th-cam.com/video/vw7YXhVe_lg/w-d-xo.html
just because is was the intention of the wirters doesn't make it true. some sins fit multiple characters, others fit none like lust.
@@SpykeTheSU ohhhhhh ok didn't understood cause we do see him as a snail
@@waddafugg3072 the theory is true I didn't say gary was 100% glutonny but still it was confirmed
...how is... spongebob lust....?
This video should have been named something along the lines of “Every SpongeBob & Gary moment”. Because that’s what it felt like watching this drag on longer then it needed just for a small debunking on one detail of an absurd theory. But nice Video anyway, I’m not gonna hate!
fair point, this was my first vid so I didn't have a great grasp of a good video concept lol
I understand@@btanman thank you.
Maybe someone said this already but Procrastination got censored a little after the first airing. The part where Sponge imagines his friends outside having fun got cut cause Patrick is rubbing sunscreen on Sandy's shoulders. I think some people though he was rubbing her boobs or something? I forget official line but in re-airings, that scene was removed. I think they fucked up the color when Nick had it edited. That's always been my theory anyway
OMG OMG OMG! I have seen this and watch this video on TH-cam and it was awesome! I love SpongeBob SquarePants because it's the best show ever! I think Gary is Gluttony since he loves to eat food. I can also relate to him since I eat certain food (usually McDonald's) too! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
15:00 I LOVE THIS EPISODE
Pets/ Dogs and Cats don't know the next time there going to eat so they eat how much is in there thing
What do you mean squid turning into a snail was not real? I vividly remember that being a Thing?;
most definitely
Are you just traumatized by squidward turning into a snail or have you just never seen it cause it does exist
I feel like the roles are all wrong which is why Gary gets such an unfitting role. Patrick is an easy Gluttony. Squidward is easily Pride. SpongeBob is Wrath (this video damn near proves it). Plankton Envy. Krabs Greed. Sandy Lust (the biggest stretch, but her thrist for knowledge and bikini figure could do enough). And lastly, Gary is Sloth.
I mean Mr. Lawrence could be wrong? Hopefully?
I am high and I only realized you were being sarcastic this video at the 9:40 mark 😂
Btan, im pretty sure "there will be grease" is from season 13
Dis good vid
#freegarry
OH MY GOD GARY WTF 😂 14:51
I actually really like the theorizer’s SpongeBob theorys, but Alex Bale made the best😅
How tf does one tie in evangelion to spongebob
#Garryisoverparty
Yummy
🐌💩
Yeah, I’ve heard of that dumb theory, it’s the most annoying one, probably
so far almost every episode with gary has him interacting with food. I still think this theory is stupid though
what so no skin theory
The thing is, I feel you could pose the same theory to any screwball comedy with an eclectic cast. The goal is to give each character some unique flaw, which due to its intrinsic ties to studied human behavior leads to each of them often vaguely resembling one of the seven sins. It's yet another case of people trying to find a "deeper meaning" in something when the answer is so much simpler if you just have a basic understanding of what characters, themes, and narratives make for compelling entertainment. It just ain't that deep bro.
That was my thought when going into the theory, I got tired of hearing it everywhere lol.
not a theory. was confirmed in an interview years ago.
No.
But really do the ww2 one
Great vid but not my favorite thumbnail :/ it looks gross
#spongebobisoverparty
UUh the theory is that Gary’s sloth well cuss du Patrick’s gluttony
The one hundredth comment