Johnny Depp's attorney torpedoes Amber Heard witness testimony with rapid-fire objections
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.ย. 2024
- Johnny Depp's former attorney Adam Waldman attempted to give a deposition in the actor's defamation trial against his ex-wife Amber Heard. Throughout the testimony, Depp's attorney objected and instructed Waldman not to answer questions because it violated attorney-client privilege. Heard has countersued Depp, claiming that comments made by Waldman, while representing Depp, calling abuse allegations a hoax was defamatory towards her.
Subscribe to LiveNOW from FOX! www.youtube.co...
Where to watch LiveNOW from FOX: www.livenowfox...
Follow us @LiveNOWFOX on Twitter: / livenowfox
Raw and unfiltered. Watch a non-stop stream of breaking news, live events and stories across the nation. Limited commentary. No opinion. Experience LiveNOW from FOX.
I was originally here for JD but his lawyers have made this trial the most interesting trial/show ever. These lawyers are incredible. If JD loses this case, it’s 100% corruption.
Murdochs allegedly involved in UK trail... anything is possible
Money buys you the best there is, AH got here off wish
For sure! You're right. Look, she got away with it in UK. Hopefully, in the US they are smarter and wiser and could see through the Amber LIES.
ITs still possible for JD to lose. ITs really hard to win a defamation case. REALLY HARD.
@@samerbayoumi6378 he may lose the defamation case. which honestly, that's fine. but amber very likely will not win the abuse counter.
Amber didn't even donate her 7 mil dollars at least she should've bought good lawyers from that money instead of getting them from wish
Not Wish 😁
😂😂😂😭😭😭💀💀💀
She is STRUGGLING! I’m sure no one was lining up to represent Amber. Except that I’m sure she’ll blame them for anything and everything like she already has 😂
@@paulhopkins3205
Donate is a verb.
Pledge is a noun.
A pledge is a PROMISE to pay. A donation is the ACTION of paying. She DID NOT PAY the $7 million however you'd like to colour it. Until $7 million is actually donated, she has not fulfilled her obligation. The problem is she was on TV within months of her divorce being settled saying she donated it all ALREADY. In the payment schedule set out on their Separation Agreement, the date she was on TV saying she "donated" it all, it hasn't even been PAID to her in its entirety yet.
She wanted the positive PR and to look good but didn't want to spend money to do it.
LMAO @ Wish
I swear everytime Amber Heards lawyers start questioning anyone I get a headache. They just keep asking the same questions over & over expecting a different answer.
I think we all do .. I’m beginning to not listen to her anymore and just watching johnnys lawyers as she does my head in
^^^^^^^^ THIS
I will say that from what I’ve seen elsewhere asking similar questions (same question worded different) is a valid tactic to get the witness to slip either with a different answer or answering a question they didn’t want to answer. The problem here is twofold, first are the massive amount of lies amber seems to have told her lawyers ahead of time. The second is that they seem to be terrible at getting those lies out though regular questioning. The only thing they can think to do is violate the rules of the court or apparently watching this make others violate the law. (Edited for grammar, I think I got it)
Start questioning... I get one when they even say objection.
You mean adding "what if any" to the start of the question sentence ISN'T a different question??? *surprised Elaine pikachu face*
The fact that a slew of Johnny Depp's former employees (security guard, agent, attorney) are willing to testify for him (not to mention former girlfriends who defended him) speaks to his character.
Hearbie poo poos attorney is pathetic!!!! A waste of time. Same questions different ways!!!! What is wrong with this judge???
Even Amber's ex assistant testified for Johnny. That's very telling. The ex assistant even said he was very kind with her son and gave him a guitar pick. Amber fired her right after she married johnny without giving her notice. She had a kid at the time..like bruh amber is a straight up turd
WHY as an attorney, KNOWING ATTORNEY/CLIENT PRIVILEGE EXISITS, would you CALL AN ATTORNEY as a witness?!?!?!?
To have his back obviously, making it obvious to the world she's asking the wrong questions by having another attorney pointing the obvious to Elaine, attorney-client privilege
And also one that's loyal and sympathetic to Johnny. Strange move indeed.
Because he is a party she has countersued him too because he said her allegations were a hoax and false. She even harassed him on twitter. Where she commented on his short height.
You people act like the law makes sense lol
Cause she’s just grasping for anything she can
Ridiculous line of questioning. She is perfectly aware that he won't answer so why does the judge not call her on this. Wasting the courts time and resources which are paid by the taxpayers
they only get so much witness time so wasting their own time
Actually they’re being paid by their client in civil cases. I’m sure in this case both parties are suing the other for attorney fees. Nevertheless, the attorney is still wasting Amber’s time (which both sides agreed to limit to a certain amount of time) and her money. I mean she asks a question and it’s objected to, in fact she knows the witness can’t answer because she moves on without the judge ruling on the objection. She then proceeds to ask basically the same question but about a different situation and/or circumstances. If I’m Amber, I’m calling a timeout because I want to know why are we asking things we know he can’t answer? Isn’t there something else they can do which is more useful of their time and resources?
I think it’s to get something to the jury without actually saying. The objections are also seen as bad but really it’s to lay out a case for either side if anything goes against their way.
No Chris is right. Who do you think pays the judge, the clerk, the court reporter? The filing fee doesn't cover much lol
The judge is too lenient
Why do they call witnesses that cannot answer questions? The incompetence is unbelievable. But again, she’s getting the representation she deserves.
The representation she pledged for
Boo ya kasha!
how about attorneys who cant ask questions strategically or competently or even correctly elaine needs a nap
But also she don't have no proves of the abuse and they trying to get something from whatever but they ending up looking stupid 🤣
Because, just by asking the question you put that type of thinking in the Jury's head.
This lady is asking so many obvious objectionable questions that even I’m starting to feel like I could be an attorney, calling them out. 😂
Same! HERESAY! SPECULATION!
factssssss
@Hunter Vonnegut do you have any songs recommendations from them ?
Because each of those questions s are a clear topic of communication between johnny depp and his lawyer based on his answer. He's consistently reiterating that he can't answer that specific question because it falls under attorney client communication. That means they talked about it, likely in the respective timeline she's trying to establish. It isn't a game of connect 4 where whoever gets 4 objections in a row wins. It's a bit more nuanced than that. She's building a narrative.
I am so angry lmao!! We Both would have represented Amber Heard with more intellect!! That being said, Amber Heard is a DAMN LIAR!! Mick... we would have made MILLIONS!!!
This guy is very good at accepting instructions.
Lol
Yes, like Amber's lawyer keep asking did I read that right, Mr Depp and he said you have been reading them all right...who cares if he got kicked off Twitter, our president Trump was kicked off, and many other conservatives were kicked off. Where I come from, almost a badge of honor to be kicked off. I don't use Twitter, never have and never will. Total insanity, imo
🤣🤣🤣
surely you mean "This guy is very good at not betraying attorney/client confidentiality"? if he had slipped up and broke that A/C privelage, it would have been him potentially getting disbarred, she knew this and thats why she kept asking the same question over and over with different words. she is a snake in the grass and a perfect representation of her client.
Lol
Love how he waits a second before answering to give the lawyer a chance to give instructions or not. Good job
I was thinking the same thing
I think he is well aware when her questions should be objected to.
actually he shouldn't need to wait for instructions. he knows full well he can't break client attorney priveledge and what would do that
because he is a lawyer, Johnny Depp's lawyer nontheless, Amber's team is really running out of people to go to lol You can tell he is much more professional than Bredehoft because when she tries to ask confusing questions that calls for speculation he could call her out on it lol
It's just a tiny delay because he's somewhere else
Dude totally gave up and started saying "same instructions same grounds" after some point 😂
😂😂😂
ahahahahaha!
I can’t!! 😂😂😂
But he should have gone for the longer version.. will have wasted Amber Heard’s attorney’s court time more
Start from @23:25
She thought that because Johnny did drugs and drunk alcohol, everyone would immediately believe her. She couldn't have been more wrong and its too late to back down now.
Drank*
@@Just.D No, I said what I said.
People have believed her lies on two seperate occasions. So God bless Mr. Johnny Depp. I'd pray he comes out of this mess with all dignity, ameen.
Especially when she took drugs and drank almost as much as Johnny did!
She did plenty of drugs and alcohol too! She's just a hypocrite
I don’t understand why they’re questioning this guy, he obviously can’t answer anything, unless Amber’s lawyers are just trying to kill time to get this case over with
And I really dont understand what his Twitter account had to do with anything lol
Don’t get it either…weird
I agree, they should have found another witness if they wanted to win this case. But I guess this could help JD to win🙈
@@nordquist52
Twitter deleted him because he spoke against heard. They did this to a lot of people.
I was getting bored after 10 minutes and just checking the comments to see if I can spare me the rest of this "movie".Thank you - I can now watch something else more interesting...
This is why you always ask for your attorney if you’re being questioned by the police.
Look up Elaine Bredehoft. She has won many awards in the DC area. She's listed as a "Top 10 Super Lawyer" in the DC area. I'm as surprised as you are.
@@kathyp1563 Shocking because she doesn't seem very respectful of the judge or Depp's attorneys, interrupts even after being told her question was overruled and seems off
@@kathyp1563 she seems terrible. I'm watching her fail continuously in real time. Maybe the awards are bogus
@@SpecialJay they just pledged the awards to her
@@kathyp1563 I think it has to do more of WHO she's representing rather than her skill as a lawyer. She only has so much to work with 😆
I feel for Waldman, he seems like a good guy who is being dragged into a situation he doesn't want to be involved in. I appreciate his calmness and his taking the advice of JD's atty. Depp's legal team is so smooth. This is the 1st trial ever that has held my attention.
I don’t think he minds .. if it wasn’t for him we never would have know amber was making false claims.. he for justice for his client
You must not of watched the rittenhouse trial. His lawyers did an amazing job shutting down the prosecution and lying witnesses
He’s the only one I’ve seen to actually wait for an objection before answering
This is the first trial that makes me question why I didn’t go to law school instead of becoming a law enforcement officer. It’s not too late for me though.
@@bee-oz4tp Johnny actually started waiting for “hearsay” when he was on the stand. Lol.
1. Why did the judge even allow this questioning knowing attorney client privilege exists? 2. This lawyer should be disbarred for even trying to bypass attorney client privilege which she knows exists.
IKR it's like banging your head of the wall constantly and expecting it to hurt less.
She allowed it, because she knew it would eat up Amber’s lawyers time.
Did you not hear that he got subpoenaed?
@@TheKadonye yes, but still I do not see why that line of questioning was allowed.
@@JR-Tx I concur
This is outrageous. Solicitor client privilege is sacred. Calling the lawyer of the other party as a witness is inappropriate and amber heard’s lawyer should be sanctioned by the State Bar Association. As a lawyer I’m deeply offended by this.
Thank you so much for saying this. I don't have your education and experience but I felt this was a breach of contract and ethics. I am so disgusted by this circus by Heards attorney's.
Hopefully AH lawyers will never get any worthwhile legal work again!
Why would a judge allow this if so outrageous? Did Depp's attorneys allow this to let Heard's lawyers to anger the jury? I know I would be pissed off at Heard and lawyer for wasying time asking questions they know won't be answered.
I think it's occurring because the guy is not representing Depp at this time.
He's not a solicitor in this case any longer.
Thus is potentially a viable witness.
I heard he was on Amber's side at one point... But obviously he's not stupid and isn't willing to say anything he doesn't want to.
Case is clear etc.
Obviously Amber's lawyers are bad.
@@Quasiguambo he already said he still represents Depp. I just think he can't in court because it's in Virginia.
OMG! Has anyone verified if Amber's attorney is in fact licensed? Is there evidence that she even attended law school? You would think a practicing attorney would fully understand the laws regarding attorney client privilege. Unbelievable. Maybe the forensic psychologist should have evaluated her as well.
😄
hahahaa good one
😆 🤣
i dont know but i have a feeling there will be a new opening at that firm in the very near future :p
They are top tier lawyers .... but it's a lost case. If the teams were vice versa it wouldn't look different ...
Why would these incompetent attorneys subpoena his attorney knowing he cannot break attorney/client privilege????This was a waste of time …
It’s like she keeps saying the exact thing he won’t answer and her questions keep repeating it.
Her lawyers are a bunch of clowns. Perfect for Ms Turd
Because they get to present a timeline of events of their choosing. If you show the lawyer 50 pictures of a dog with a bloody nose. Its objected to for relevance 50 times and sustained. At the end I guarantee you that, even though they were instructed to ignore the pictures and questions, at least one person on the jury is gonna ask how that dog got a bloody nose.
Because some people see refusing to answer as guilt. If they can make the jury wonder what he may have to hide, they've successfully done their job.
He is a witness now, not an attorney now...so clients attorney at the moment is checking on the questions that lady is asking the witness
If this woman knows he cannot answer most of the questions without revealing attorney-client relations, then why does she keep asking them?
She has no choice since Waldman’s statements are precisely the reason for AH’s counterclaim, they have to basically prove that Waldman was instructed by Johnny to say those things about AH on Twitter/press but they literally cannot get even a peep out of him bc of attorney-client privilege. The thing also is Elaine keeps asking the same questions differently which still are objectionable lol basically she sucks. No way AH can win the counter claim, it’s just impossible and laughable.
Probably out of desperation, they're aiming to cause suspicion and mistrust with the jury. Since very few facts can be openly stated, they want to only hint at wrongdoings this way.
Because she has *NOTHING* else. She is grasping at straws. Her client is being embarrassed worldwide on a daily basis and she is furiously grabbing for saplings (and failing) as she tumbles down the side of the mountain.
Because she watched mattock growing up and thinks that her questions without answers are winning points.
@@NormaLilia24 Interesting, I didn't think of that. I wonder if she tried to advise Amber not to make this impossible counterclaim but she insisted. Amber's gonna Amber.
This looks to me like Heards team is seriously burning through and/or intentionally wasting their allotted time for questioning during the trial because there's nothing relevant left for them to ask!
Side note, I would not hire Elaine to represent my neighborhood stray.
Exactly times up time for the verdict
I so believe that
This is how her attorneys leave a steamer in *her* bed.
Well, they're getting paid by the hour
The judge is also at fault here. Attorney/Client privilege was a part of almost EVERY question! This was a ridiculous waste of time.
This wasn't in court with the judge It was filmed on Feb 15th, they just played it in court. That's why you hear the guy in the background saying what not to answer
Note that he advises the witness to not answer, he's not objecting the questions. She can ask, and the judge has nothing to do about it.
really the judge in this case is more a referee in the game, there to make sure the players don't get out of hand, at the end of the day it more so digs into the defense's time what they waste with these "witnesses" than it does the Plaintiff's time, so more or less really the defense is shooting themselves in the foot as they waste their own valuable hours (ie why Rottenborn was wanting to rush Plaintiff's witnesses because he was trying to save as much Defense's time as possible whilst not letting the other team score points)
tl:dr;, theyre really screwing themselves over and these ridiculous "witnesses" of theirs and such mostly just possibly annoy the Jury (the actual Scorekeepers of this game) more and more
Exactly!👍🏾🤦🏾♂️🤦🏾♂️🤦🏾♂️
It's a recording of the deposition that was done earlier outside the court. There's no judge nor jury during a deposition.
It’s glorious watching Amber’s lawyer fail over and over.
I know right! I love it!
This is a deliberate fail.Ambers attorney is clearly taking a dive!
Ambers next Op-Ed will be titled “How I Lost In Court Because My Of My Lawyer”
Bargain Basement! 😂😂
Yes
Like..... did her attorneys ACTUALLY think another attorney would answer these questions?!? Like they didn't get similar schooling?!?
Obviously not 🤦♂️ She likely did this for a few reasons, but overall there’s nothing major here and is just space filler.
She knows that lmao that's how most depositions go
Was she trying to make a point to the jury regardless of the answers?
They think in billable hours.
LOL what he wasn't even sure what year he became a lawyer. Isn't that crazy
The only thing this witness proofs is that he accepted the instructions not to answer. lol
Lol
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Well if he had answered most of the questions he would risk getting disbarred, you can't break your attorney client privileges.
LOL
What if any instructions not to answer do you accept?
There is only ONE thing that matters here:
"While plenty has been discussed throughout the trial, the jury’s only job is to answer the following question: Did Amber Heard defame Johnny Depp in her 2018 Washington Post article?"
That's it. This is so sad.
Totally agreed
@@a.ry.a6415 that’s a quote I found online, but I don’t remember which paper said it. It’s true though….and very, very scary. Is she guilty? And the counter suit is just crazy and I PRAY 🙏🏻 they don’t consider it. She’s buried herself so much.
And she continued to defame troughout the all the trial
@Jon Dough
Possibly. If I were a juror, I’d argue that if she committed abuse, even if she suffered abuse, she was a participant rather than a victim. Misrepresenting that fact would, to me, constitute a lie and be grounds for defamation.
The jurors can make that same determination.
but if they can prove that amber abused him and he didnt abuse her then there would be no reason for her to release that oped which means he would've never lost anything, the defamation came the second she said she was a survivor of domestic abuse if they can prove she wasn't the victim then they prove the defamation
I feel that the judge should admonish AH’s attorney for repeatedly asking questions that she should know as a lawyer another lawyer cannot answer.
Literally the definition of insanity lol
I'm surprised she hasn't been threatened with being held in contempt of court for continuing to ASK questions she KNOWS he CANNOT answer.
I know NOTHING about the legal profession/process and I CAN call out every question he isn't allowed to answer based on attorney client privilege. 🤦♀️
She's NOT so stupid that she does NOT know this, Amber's lawyer.
It's redundant and annoying, not to mention a HUGE waste of the court and the judge's time.
This is absolutely NOT helping Amber's case, which is ALREADY on life support.
This case, even if BOTH JD & AH were credible witnesses, will be decided on the quality and expertise of the attorneys who represent them. Not to mention the likeability of or respect for said attorneys. Jeez Louise, this lady is pathetic. I can't even finish this charade..
I thought the same exact thing yesterday while watching the redirect.. How has she not been admonished yet...
FOR REAL!!!
@@metalmamasue3680 judge gives Ms Turds team way too much leeway.
I already love this attorney. He's very precise and wise while answering the permissive questions and he's also good at waiting for "instructions" from Depps team before responding. I loved the numerous " I accept the instructions"😂😂
@Hunter Vonnegut stop. you're weird.
@Hunter Vonnegut I keep seeing this over and over but refuse to
⁹96th and a
LOL! I was saying it too. As soon as I started hearing what he should not answer... It was like I had the same schooling. What a trial.
I was listening to this video and watching of course...then I went to the kitchen without pausing it. When I got back, after rewinding what I missed, I quickly realized that I didn't miss a thing because he was instructed NOT to answer.
Ha!!!
From muffins, to my dog stepped on a bee to instructions to not answer...
This will go down in history.
God bless them all.
I pray that Johnny and Amber can heal and move forward.
Peace, Lynne 🍃💜🍃
Why was this woman allowed to waste the courts time in such a manner? As a lawyer she should have know when drawing up her questions that they couldn't be answered. This make AH's legal team look ridiculous.
It portrays them as desperate and grasping at straws.
They don’t have much to go on.
Amber’s team are running down the clock because they know they don’t have a case. They’ve got about 9-10 hours left if that and even if someone is in the middle of answering one of their questions the judge has made it clear that she will stop them when the time is up. Johnny’s team still has a good few hours left, a lot more then Amber’s because they’ve not wasted any of their allotted time. But same thing applies to them once their time is up regardless if they are in the middle of something the judge is going to stop them when the alarm goes off saying they’ve ran out of time. I don’t think Amber’s team is going to have enough time for closing arguments because they’ve still got a week of questioning and more witnesses including recalling Johnny. Next week is the last week then it’s up to the jury. But going from Amber’s behavior, all the evidence proving she’s a liar along with all her witnesses. Her legal team screwing up multiple times and Johnny’s team absolutely destroying and discrediting every single one of Amber witnesses including Amber and her sister and the fact that she doesn’t have one piece of solid evidence to back up her claims she’s not going to win this. Amber alone has done enough to piss off the jury and on the second day of the trial it didn’t help that her legal team lied to the judge about one of Johnny’s witnesses while having someone with them who was posting live from the courtroom and the judge was livid about them lying to and misleading her. And her finding out what someone with them was doing and had security escort the woman out and not only banned her from the courtroom but the courthouse altogether.
Agreed
I guess they hope for a crucial fault like AH mentioning Kate Moss
I'm glad she did waste her time. Amber's team only had 8 hours left. Johnny's team had 18 hrs left. Let her continue 🤣🤣
she repeatedly asks questions that she knows she shouldn't. She's definitely the worst lawyer there.
She's the judge
@@Mskathleenh4656 No she's not. She's the old lady lawyer.
@@Mskathleenh4656 lol
The worst lawyer EVER in the history of the world.
@@TheVintageBumbleBee AH swindled $7M from JD, but spent $6M on this trash. 😂
This case is not only going to ruin Ambers career but also her lawyers!
lolol so true..probably can only find work as a public defender..dang..
this is actually very true 😂 I forgot about their careers aswell, they going down with the turd
I kinda feel bad for her lawyers, this would be a really shitty case to work on especially when your client is a pathological liar
People who defended this poor looser woman, deserved to be ruined.
Yes!! They’re all toast!
Who in their right mind calls someone’s attorney as a witness EVER. On top of it what kind of Judge allows a personal attorney to be called to the stand. My lord what a joke.
You are right
They just wasted there own time. Such a pointless Endeavour. What are they thinking. Get it together Elaine!
So true man!
Why on earth is Elaine, as an attorney, asking questions that SHE KNOWS he cannot answer? Sad attorney!
This has to be fake. Heard has no case? Her lawyers are trash lol
How ridiculous. Why would you call a lawyer as a witness? Complete incompetence!
Because Amber’s lawyers are incompetent.
Honestly I was originally going with the whole “Oh Amber’s lawyers are pretty good they just got a really bad case”
But nah screw that, I’ve see enough to know that Elaine is incompetent. She’s ridiculous in court and argues with the judge, objects to things that do not fit the criteria, and asks questions that are extremely objectionable.
It happens all the time and lawyers can't even swear themselves in them on their own as Witnesses. I've seen that done
Waste of time on Heard lawyers
there's no case, even attorney should know when he/she break the terms and she constantly asking him questions to do that AH team are desperate
She's probably trying to paint a picture with questions instead of answers.
Why was this lawyer ever called as a witness? Her lawyers are loosing it.
Losing
@@zamfambam Maybe theyre loosing their case into a landfill?
I thought it was redirect
So that we can see his twinkling eyes when he talked about being suspended for life from the Twitter account
To waste time . This case is on a deadline , more time they waste , less time drops lawyers have tk prove wverything
The definition of insanity- doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result. 🤦♀️
💯
Exactly
In this case, it could actually work to try the same thing over and over again. They could slip up and answer a question they shouldn’t. Plus, though inference isn’t allowed (from what I’ve heard), by him not answering certain question, it proves some things. One could understand which things he did or didn’t do based off of the client privilege thing.
According to Einsten, it's the definition of stupidity
Wow great quote
As a lawyer she should know he can’t answer that , it’s giving if her client was getting asked these questions she would let them answer . She can’t even form a question without any objections
Yeah, but it's her job to try to get him to say anything that would incriminate JD, even if that means getting him to slip up on his lawyer/client privilege.
it's a tactic, you hear she is actually expecting this as she just working off a list of questions. A jury can see this as hiding information for the case when a atterney keep refusing to answer (doesnt matter if its allowed or not)
Bladdah, she's doing this on purpose to get this information to the jury. But I don't think anything she said hurt Johnny like she thought it would. Waisted so much time. Grabbing at straws. SOOO silly 😜
Adam waldman is just proving he fights for his clients and believes in justice. All of ambers BS pissed him off
The lawyer on the stand clearly knows what he's doing. Notice how every question he gives is 2-3 seconds before saying anything, to make sure he is not being instructed to not answer.
Yes because he is represented depp
I did. And I too was impressed. Proper.
Yeah the lawyer ON the stands understands the court process. AH's lawyer asking the questions is clueless of court protocol of examination.
Exactly. In all witness prep, the atty tells the client to pause before responding to allow counsel time to object.
I feel like most ppl with half a brain would learn to do that after being interrupted 10 times in a row. We know nothing about that lawyer b/c he barely spoke. I'm sure he's smart, i'm just saying, your comment is kinda dumb, no offense.
Why would you ever call your opposition's attorney? Privilege is IRON tight. What do you think you'll get out of it?
He is part of who she is suing she is suing him for calling her trial and accusations of abuse a hoax, lol
@@kc3654 ah, I get it now. Was wondering why.
Reasonable doubt.
Because his silence and depp's current attorney's objection puts suspicion and wrong expression on jury, like they are hiding something
Prolonging so she can get paid more by the hour
I started saying "I would instruct the witness..." about a third way into this video before she had finished the offending questions. She's a joke. And the witness is so smart to wait a few seconds for the objections. It must be Hella hard to be an attorney as a witness.
its kinda cool to see what an attorney would be like as a witness in a trial. He appears as a model witness. Honorable, truthful, respectful, humble, patient, courteous... If all the witnesses that have appeared throughout this trial could take notes on this guys testimony they just might learn something. I feel like i have. Ambers attorney is fkn ridiculous. SMH. Amber & Johnny should kick her ass.
Why they allow her representation to waste an hour or more of the courts time is unbelievable. He could only answer like 10 out of 1000 questions
They have the right to show their incompetence and provide the free world with entertainment.
There’s a specific amount of hours/time given to each side to ask questions. So, Heard’s side has to spin to their clock down, as they are being paid to do so on behalf of their lunatic. The judge already told them all, to get to it…because the time meter was spinning. Depp’s side had used up a bit more time than the other side when the judge informed them about the time usage numbers. This was just before they went out for ten days, the week before last.
And they're mostly "can you see the screen"
@@EW-uw7dg exactly
Again I advise you not to answer because it discloses communication between lawyer and client
Amber Turds legal team is a shining example of what’s wrong with the law. How are they even practicing?
There are hacks in every profession. Unfortunately in the legal profession there are so many of them that their bad practices have become the norm, and are tolerated and sometimes stood for on the grounds that their bad practices are “technically legal”.
Everypers0n who went to jail for having weed or sex work: am I a joke to you
BCS they know She Will win no matter how bad they are. She knows It too. She Is super protected by metoo an elon
I swear this woman asked the same question in 15 difference ways...wtf man
She is definitely helping the other side to win.
What if any?!...
And still can't frame her question in a way that can be answered not just here but with amber. Elaine really doesn't prepare enough because if you can't answer this one question at all regardless of how it's framed move on and in preparation all her questiona should have been framed in a way that doesn't suck up time.
Fifteen only! Seems like 115 times! 😂😂😂😂
they have nothing
so she has to open a door to anything that may look bad on mr depp
I just feel bad for this witness. Literally just wasting his time, he can barely talk about anything about their interactions. He and JD’s lawyer literally repeating themselves over and over again.
Blame AH's lawyers for repeatedly asking questions they knew would be objected. Just like they have throughout the entire trial.
I’m sure he’s being paid for his time. I feel bad for her attorney who obviously doesn’t understand attorney client privilege and just keeps embarrassing herself.
This witness is smart...he pauses for a while to see if his attorney would object
Well he's a lawyer!
It's obvious that he should wait for his attorney's advice.
As anyone should
"Smart", no. Its common sense
Poor guy. All he had to do was say "I accept the instruction".
Lol 😆
😂😂🤣
Lawyer - Pay my bills Amber?
AH- I pledged yesterday.
Lawyer - I didn't receive it
AH- That's not how you buy house
Lawyer - Did you buy house?
AH - No i live in Johnny's penthouse🙄
😂😂
For an actress, she's not very good with words is she? Pledge and Donate are two completely different words, with separate meanings, she cannot use them in a synonymous way.
He's an attorney. He should have known he wasn't permitted to discuss. He waited patiently for the instruction from Johnny's current attorney. Good for him.
If I was in his shoes and was an attorney, I too still would wait to hear JDs lawyers advice before answering. Out of respect mostly. But they really are brilliant
He’s in an entirely different frame of mind as a witness, than he would be when acting as a lawyer, The lawyer advising him is also paying attention to the question without having to worry about the answers to them so he’s less likely to be caught answering something off the cuff.
Amber’s attorney is asking the same question in 50 different ways and getting the same response 50 different times. This is literally a waste of time, and it doesn’t take a legal expert to see it. Don’t understand why/how the judge let this ridiculous line of questioning to go on as long as it did. It’s like hearing a broken record over and over again.
AH is going to sue her own lawyers when this is over. You heard it here first.
Billable hours
Billable hours
Waiting for a slip up as irritating as she is.
Because each side has a certain amount of time. Do she's wasting their own time, good thing for johnny supporters
A broken nose, also called a nasal fracture, is a break or crack in a bone in your nose - often the bone over the bridge of your nose. Your nose may look crooked, and you may have trouble breathing. Complications or injuries related to a broken nose may include deviated septum, collection of blood, cartilage fracture. It can be a big of a deal. Does Amber Heard have any scar tissues, or any medical records/evidence that can prove she underwent nasal surgeries? I’m asking because most people who experience a nose injury seek emergency medical attention.
she has scar tissue in her nose, atleast according to amber heard herself.. if we should believe that it is highly likely coming from the pledged cocaine use..
no and she states herself she never went to the hospital for pretty much everytime she claimed johnny hit her
Exactly but she always said she didn't see the need and ice fixed her how ridiculous, your will still swell and be irritating sensitive pain . You would want to go to ER. LIKE EVEN A UFC FIGHTER WOULD SEEK MEDICAL ATTENTION AFTER A FIGHT.
She allegedly has scar tissue in her nose however, that can also be a result of insufflating drugs through the nostrils
It's funny there is no evidence of any of the allegations. Why take pics of everything but the abuse the bruises which would solidify your case if you were telling the truth. Cause there were no bruises
This is completely out of line. You never call a lawyer as a witness. Amber heard’s lawyers should be sanctioned for this. This is disgusting. Solicitor client privilege is sacred.
Yeah I’m not understanding why you would ever call on a lawyer
Wow! Lawyer as a witness?! Now I’ve seen it all.
Why does the court allow this much time wasting questioning? This is just ridiculous
I think it's because it's hard to defend Amber, it's just impossible to build a case for her. They simply don't have anything other than these time wasting questions.
Her attorneys just can't ask these popcorn questions.. it has to relate with what the case.
Because Heard has a right to defend herself....... even if it's laughable attempts like this....
It's because they're each on a clock they just wasted an hour. Johnny's team has almost half a day left over Amber's team.
Wow. Elaine is an incredibly brain dead lawyer. Extremely unprofessional, constantly arguing whenever her questions are objected, attempting to change the question but always ends up asking the same question. I have no idea how she obtained her license
She said, "What if any chance I can be a lawyer please?"
I can’t imagine anyone was lining up to represent her. This lawyer had nothing to work with and it shows. I’m exhausted from her voice.
is she even really a lawyer?
What smart lawyer would accept to to take this case !
@@smaebou3799 The money happy ones. They know they get paid even if they loose so they just dont care lol
What on Earth is the defense thinking with this.
Only thing I can think of?
They know fully well they will get shut down asking anything and are hoping this plants a 'He has something to hide' in the jurys heads.
That they are not capable of thinking.
@@svenwagner4717 they would be wrong, any schmuck whose watched a b level ally mcbeal show knows what attorney client privilege.
🤣🤣🤣
Now they only want public openion appearing that jhonny team don't want this lawyer to talk something they are hiding.
Throughout this trial Amber has always sat at the very end of the table, now she's even mirroring where Mr. Depp sits. I mean Dr.Curry's diagnosis of her is spot on!
I loved Dr curry she was a gem 💎
Hes Probably sitting there to stop her launching herself at Elaine after yesterday 😅
@@thegreathoffman16 you may be right.
Its a Turd sandwich.
You know, if there’s ZERO consequences for her actions/lies under oath, I believe this case will set a precedent that says that it’s okay to lie under oath. We are looking at someone who is literally caught red handed not telling the truth, and she has gotten away with it for far too long. Why even have court rules, if they aren’t enforced? Hell, our own Justice System Is enabling her psycho behaviors, by allowing her to get away with doing it!
Badgering the witness, wasting the court's time, asking the same questions over and over again is an embarrasment to our legal system!
It's not badgering lol, nor is it wasting the court's time. This is what trials are really like a lot of the time.
It's part of it... They're trying to ask him the same damn question in every which way possible to catch him slippin... And they're putting the questions out there knowing the witness can't answer but putting seeds in the jurors heads... It's a tactic... Wearing the witness down, but JD lawyers are much much better...
But AHs lawyer was always reminding everyone to respect court's time. Projecting so much while wasting everyone's time
@@android12921 that is why they say it
Great witness for Depp. Only thing that was voiced is the fact that 9 people testified to not seeing any injuries on Amber 😳
Why would they call him as a witness. This is embarrassing 😳
So weird
To try to show there’s something fishy? No idea really would like to know
i’m so confused. can someone please explain this comment to me 😭
@@zashiworld the witness was Johnny Depp's attorney and any questions asked involving Johnny if answered would violate attorney/client confidentiality.
I think team Turd has no more witness so just trying to use up all their allocated time. These last few days they’ve called really odd witnesses.
Truly impressed that he kept a straight face during this nonsense.
Intentionally wasting time with no foundation for questioning. Should be held in contempt by the judge.
they are wasting their own defense time. the more time they waste putting things like this in court, the better!
Lazy preparation. Elaine isn't up against lawyers from sesame street Johnny can afford good lawyers and those lawyers can afford good lawyers. You'd think the trial of her career that the entire world would see would be better prepared
JD's lawyers are worth every penny.
All she managed to do was bring to the Jury’s attention that Johnny’s counsel believed Amber was setting Johnny up. That’s what I would take from this if I was on the Jury.
Exactly! Just like the social media expert just revealed that the whole world believes Depp over Heard, lol.
She also shown that the reply "my layers decided to do that" from Amber it's a lie, since they only give advice, and Amber had to decide if follow those advises.
Layers?
@@cappsginny699 sorry, lawyers
@@cappsginny699 dude, you knew what they meant. Layers is an easy word for autocorrect to misconstrue. There are layers to this case, though, you're right on about that!👍😃
I'm sure this poor guy has to deal with morons all the time, but I can feel the amount of patience he has dealing with this mess. She literally got nothing out of this
I bet she is REGRETTING the day she started these outrageous LIES, because she has definitely destroyed & damaged reputation, creditability & her future!
Perhaps if Elon Musk has her back, she will be set for LIFE, because if he does not BOW to her demands, one can be assured, that she will try to do to Musk, what she has done to Johnny!
If I am "sensing" my vibes correctly, regarding Amber, she would be awesome in the S&M Profession! This creature is a perverted freak!
I'm no where near a lawyer but I began to object like I was an expert attorney! I just knew what questions would be objected. Same intruction, Same basis 😩🤦🏾♀️
Me too!!!😂😂😂😂
😭😭😭😭😭on point!!!!! Me 2! 🤦🏻♀️
Jajaja omg ME too
You're a qualified paralegal now 😀
Same 🤣🤣
Amber's lawyer keeps asking illegal questions. She's obviously just padding her bill because she's paid by the hour. Why does the judge allow these questions?
Maybe because the jury still hears the questions. Plus this all seems like a circus show.
@@laurel1865 I've been saying this since the get go, it's all a very entertaining circus show, but justice for Johnny cause this is some BS
As a lawyer you'd think you'd know what u can and cannot ask anothwr lawyer about
lawyers are hourly?
I believe we are seeing a video of a deposition. I don’t know all the details, but typically a judge is not present and the lawyers are basically the mediators.
Watching Johnny Depp, you'll understand that - He's a very intelligent man - He's Hollywood celebrity and he understands how the game works - His calm, poise and ability to draw people to him is a Masterclass in how to behave in a court room - He's a simple man and his kids are goddamned lucky to have a father like him
id be pissed if i learned my dad sat in a nightclub and didnt call an ambulance while river pheonix OD'd outside
@@rocktheboat56 ???? Bhows he supposed 2 know WTH? Is going on outside ?
Agree with everything you said
@@jaimegrayson6739 because he had him escorted out minutes before
@@rocktheboat56 lol. Kids don’t hold their parents to mistakes they may or may not have done BEFORE they were born!!
You know nothing of being a good daughter/son.
Jesus Christ she keeps asking the same question but slightly tweaked. No way in hell does she not know that it's going to get shot down, but she keeps asking anyway. Is this woman even competent enough to be a lawyer? At what point does it constitute malicious intent as she is trying to goat him into breaking the law by disclosing confidential information?
"What if any".... I hate these words now
She did this all throughout the trial same questions,when Camille objected- already answered the judge let her get away with it
What I don't understand Mr Waldman stated Amber Herd faked sexual violence against Mr Depp and that is exactly what the Jury found so why should Amber get 2 million dollars I guess they thought she should get something even though they found she was lying.
Skip to 44:40
JD lawyer: “I instruct the witness to not answer Base on attorney/client relations
Witness: “I accept the instructions”
That’s all that happen lol
I wish I saw this comment before I listened to all of that nonsense. LOL 😆🙄
I wished this comment was pinned 🥴
Yo I busted out laughing once I clicked this and that time stamp was the end of the vid 🤣😂🤣😂thanks!!!!
Why would they bring such a person who cannot answer anything? This is just a waste of time for either side.
Even the witness looks bored.
Because they can and they can ' go fish' ;)
I think to break the memory of the jury
@@Zach-Fetters Good point, confuse the jury
It's Amber's lawyers and her own fault.
I love the part when she said “2005, 2010, 2015” and he said “do you want me to speculate ?” 🤣
This guy continuously having to say, “I instruct you not to answer due to attorney client privilege….” was getting tired of repeating, but remained professional, I, on the other hand was wishing she could hear me saying, ENOUGH IS ENOUGH, YOUR GOING NO WHERE W/THIS, NOW TAKE A SEAT!!! 🙄🙄🙄🙄 😂
This is soooo funny! "Attorney" questioning an Attorney who has an Attorney. You can't make this stuff up!
Attorneys "R" Us. 😆 🤣
Lol attorney inception
Ahahahahaha! LMFAO!!!!
JD’s attorney’s attorney probably has his own attorney standing next to him instructing him on how to instruct the attorneys attorney.
She doesn’t realize that using, “behalf” is a clear indicator of the exchange of communications between attorney and client🙄
She say johnny deep😂
That and she always starts her sentences with "what ifs".... Which automatically lead for hearsay objection... It's like she is actually not a real attorney... It's unbelievable...
I would pay good money to sit in on one of the after meetings with Ms. Heard and her attorneys after court. I just see her screaming in peoples faces, flipping tables over and telling everyone how stupid and incompetent they are. Kind of like Veruca Salt in Willy Wonka...haha
OMG yes!
She'd make a lot of money.
She is so delusional she probably thinks they’re doing great
I wouldn't be surprised if she sues them if she loses. She'll claim she lost because of incompetent council. She's already thrown them under the bus
Personally, I don't think anyone will be flipping any tables...
.. I would assume that those tables lawyers sit at would be bloody heavy.
Imagine having lawyers for your lawyers who have their own lawyers.
This woman is actually talking to herself at this point like there’s no response in return holy damn.
Exactly. Amber could have found a better lawyer in a trash can 😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂right!!!!!
Shes trying to collect her hourly wage yall. Who knows when she'll be hired as an attorney again?
@@melkal7818 Her lawyers at this time likely know that they will lose and are just trying to collect a check. Before this case, they had a good reputation and likely initially thought this was an easy case but AH lied to them as well. Those lawyers could have found a better client in a trash can.
😭😭😭😭💯💀 I can't with her at this point🤣😭😂😂🤦🏽♀️
Elaine should leave the profession. The attorney- client communication privilege is the basic principle in law 😁... Elaine surprise everyday with some stupid acts
She has to try and bend the rules in order to win the case for Amber because Amber is 100% guilty. It’s hard to win a case with so little to work with while also facing insane amounts of evidence against her case.
@@demoneyin9390 not much of bending. She should be well aware he cannot answer attorney-client communication. Yet several of her questions are directly asking about communications i.e. "Did you ask Mr. Depp...". It seems it may be some defense strategy to make the jury think he won't answer any questions
Shes like a dumber version of nancy pelosi even their voices match.
Not only is it hard bc she’s guilty, it’s hard bc Amber goes off script with her over the top acting, not only that but she answers questions and then looks immediately at the jurors
Well said 🙌🏾 she is really a muppet 🤦🏾♂️
I am now starting to believe that Elaine is doing everything she can for Amber to lose. 😈
😂😂
Honestly I almost feel bad for the team. Well not so much Elaine, she’s about as unprofessional as it gets. My Lord. But aside from that, they really have not much to work with. Plus a freakin nightmare of a client.
😂
And she's doing an excellent job . .
I think is bc AH lawyers can not help a client that has no prove or good witnesses. There’s only so much AH lawyers can do for her
Jesus Christ, 44 minutes and the only thing that was determined is that he was Johnny Depp's attorney. How many times can you say "I would instruct the witness not to answer" before just losing your sh*t? Good on him for keeping his cool, because that was just ridiculous
As a victim of an abusive relationship, I'm ashamed to admit that I once believed Amber Heard. Not simply because she was a woman, but because seeing tabloid photos of his condition several times and prior experience with such made it seem all too likely.
I know it doesn't ALWAYS lead to abuse and violence, and I should have remembered that. Never again will I assume something based on tabloid photos and simply someone's word on a matter.
I too ,initially believed her because after my own experience I could not imagine anyone could be so vindictive as to make up such horrible lies in such a public manner… but I realized very quickly she is the typical narcissistic abusive psychopath and this was her final devastation to Johnnys life🤔I also think Johnny has issues with substance abuse because of abuse from his mom, all the negative things that come along with fame and just generally lots of emotional damage , which is how a lot of us cope! It makes me angry that she taunts him and belittles him about his substance use when she too is not above taking mdma, coke, drinking till she’s sick and smoking weed🤔🤔🤔
@@melissajohnson3308 I think she's going to find that this case may have absolutely torpedoed her own career. I wonder if she will think it was worth it? There's a possibility that some of JD's friends might give him a chance to reestablish himself, if he wins-- but not many people are going to be willing to give another chance to a woman who has proven that she's willing to lie about someone regardless of consequences in order to try to achieve her own twisted aims.
I wouldn't allow her to step foot inside of my house, because she's the kind of person who might create an incident on your property in order to be able to sue.
@@thesussexbunion I’m sorry that you had to go through that.
@@thesussexbunion Yea, I think any Hollywood execs are going to steer clear of her,never mind the backlash anyone who gives her a role will receive now! She’s done to herself exactly what she was trying to do to Johnny… she’s successfully labeled herself an abuser!
@@tamaracarey5803 🤗
Thanks, Tamara. I made it through it, when sadly many others of us haven't. 😪
This is hilarious. Was she thinking Depp had some other kind of relationship with this guy other than the guy being his attorney. And that it was an at will arrangement. Wtf. What was she hoping to get from this ?
She was actually trying to test the witness's patience...sometimes they get irritated and slip up...this guy was extremely professional and calm...
Any lawyer wud do this tbh...they will grab at any spot tht u slip up...
@@adityaagarwal2341 not any lawyer, I get it though that what you write is a crowd pleasing statement and gets the likes. She however is more likely trying to establish in the jury’s minds that Depp’s legal team is hiding something, which doesn’t necessarily require his former attorney to slip up or even say anything.
Lawyer: you can't ask any questions that disclose attorney / client relations
Elaine: ima bout to ask 60 questions about attorney / client relations
😂😂
🤣🤣🤣
For real
How dare Amber Heard make a mockery of women's real pain. I was in an abusive relationship and I take offense to her horrible acting. She is the type of woman that makes the me-too movement a joke she is the reason why a lot of women that are abused are not believed. She should be charged with something
You are a joke😂
This is laughable. What kind of lawyers are these on AHs side? They keep asking questions he can’t answer.
@@RopeDrink Shouldn't the judge have intervened at some point
Boy , this attorney is definitely trying trickery. She knows the law and ignores it just trying to get him to slip up.
He is not stupid Amber 😂😂
Trickery i dnt think so its incompetance this whole line of questioning is completely pointless cos he cannot answer yet she keeps asking
You think Elaine is a trickster. She's not a working brain cell in her head. She's directing a lawyer who has another BETTER lawyer and she gets nothing. Zero. The big 0. And she wasting all the courts time and if I were Amber id p*nch her while she's giving them out!!!
But Elaine, couldn't break thru this wall with this gentleman on her azz!.. Good job!!
What an absolutely infuriating woman this lawyer is. Wtf is she doing ? She keeps asking the same questions in a different way over and over. She's playing games. She knows very well he can't answer. She needs disbarring. My head is gonna explode. Surely she is damaging her own reputation as a lawyer....if she ever had one !
She is like every social service worker in the UK. The only difference is that the social workers are supposed to represent the man and the woman. I imagine having this woman is a social worker. Where she draws the man accuses the man writes down false testimony about the man. And will not say anything bad about the woman as if she is the woman's solicitor or attorney this is the UK social service and family Court system.
This is why they had to make everything private, to do the evil deeds In darkness.
Now imagine if you give an answer that they don't like they just write down the the answer that they wanted you to say. They blatantly and straightforward lie they go to court and commit perjury because they cannot be held accountable. This is the legal system in the UK. With anything to do with men woman family Court children etc.
No I'm not lying to you about this I'm telling you the 100% truth.
This goes for the police, social services, cafcass, and woman at the cohesion of these government departments
Agree!!
What a stubborn lady
I felt the same way watching this. She's infuriating.
I'll save you some time, literally nothing is learned, ambers lawyer rephrases a question a hundred times and the remaining questions really serve no purpose and he is usually advised to not answer them, what a disgrace to their law firm.
Hunter Vonnegut you are annoying. Stop it
Her lawyer is ridiculous. She is supremely incompetent. I'm not a lawyer and can tell when a question is going to get an objection. If she was going against less competent lawyers her angle might work and get a slip up. This lawyer is too sharp for this approach that she refuses to abandon. It's borderline exhausting and annoying listening to her.
She calls herself a lawyer 🤨. She’s a terrible one. She should know that EVERYTHING she asked would be considered attorney client knowledge and can not be released without the clients permission. What a waste of time. This went no where.
Was looking for this comment, was curious if I was the only one thinking this, a bit insane imo how she's even a lawyer. 👏
@@RopeDrink telling the jury how much of moron she is...
it shows adam is a fraud actually
Not completely. Asking "would you do...if", is not "did you..because".
Leading and telling a story to get the jury to think her questioned situation was real
If was on the jury I would be pissed at the defense wasting my time. How the judge allowed this is questionable.
How is it questionable
Probably it's for world to see how ridiculous the questions were.
Esp for only $10 a day
I think the judge does not stop here bc, she has repeatedly said y'all only have so much time...so if her lawyers want to waste their time, the judge thinks so be it...maybe exhausted from this circus. Imo
Idk man.. I’ve watched most of this trial, and have to say, this judge seems to be doing pretty well and if anything, you can kinda tell she smells AHs bs
Did I just listen to 45 minutes of someone being told they can't answer?
Yes I did.
Did I spend 90% face palming, yes.
Do I care? Strangely, no.
I feel like Amber’s lawyer has trouble understanding the difference between witnessing and hearsay; I’m really surprised that she passed the bar.
The only bar she knows is the liquor bar hahahahaha
Wow, my ears are ringing! (POOPY GIRL/AH, dem lawyers REGRET they took the case. Tell Elaine to sit down😭 😁
Best joke coment everrrrr! She literally acts like a abusive messy alcoholic teacher, Al she does is harras ppl and push boundaries,
I agree that based on counsel's dubious understanding of hearsay vs. Witness testimony that her entrance to the bar is rationally suspect.
You all ignore elaine is supposedly part of virginia's top 10 laywers😂😂😂😂 a fact i wonder how?
You cannot lead, nor hearsay, nor accept any answer without foundation.
Her attorneys are pathetic.
And Camille is AWESOME.
She'll be the next Johnny Cochrane
JD's lawyer ANNIHILATED Amber's lawyer with a very simple comment: "I instruct the witness not to disclose this due to attorney-client privilege!" Watching this is better than any HBO show! Love it.
Exactly hehehehhe
Not really, she wasn't expecting an answer, she was just talking to the jury. Not that it'll work, that counter suit makes no sense, but she had to do her job so she did. If anobody did great during that testimony, it's the witness. JD's lawyer didn't annihilate anything here, he was more likely bored out of his mind.
@@GuillaumeG-oz3hz Absolutely NOT. Lawyers always ask questions they want the answers to - that was the whole point of this interaction. But JD's lawyer was on to it, just like Camille was the other day with "objection, your Honour"! So, no, you're wrong.
@@Ada_Isabella I'm not sure why i answer... Do you even watch the trial ? Haven't you noticed all those occasions where the lawyers ask super long questions and only want a "yes" or "correct" in return ?
That's because they want to control the discussion, tell the story, and the witness to shut up while they run the show. Questions matter, sometimes a lot more than the answer.
For the countersuit, she has to prove that what this guy said were Johnny's words. Which is impossible since he's privileged and won't answer anything. Her only way to do that is to make the jury accept the fact that yes, he probably said what his client told him to say. That's it.
Note that i am not having an argument with you. Just sharing facts in case this trial brings you to be interested by how those things works.
@@GuillaumeG-oz3hz I am not arguing with you either, I am simply disagreeing on this particular point. That’s all.
It annoys the crap out of me, how Amber answers a question and constantly looks at the jury
The only thing I got out of this was, “I accept the instruction.” by the witness (attorney). Complete waste of time no matter what they think the questions will do for the jury. Can’t think on much without the answers. Heard’s lawyers are incompetent, point blank period.
Great answer if the rest of us ever go to court
I’m a recent law graduate and am very befuddled by the point of having him as a witness. Not only would, almost, all his conversation and actions on behalf of Depp be privileged, but more than half these questions are hearsay. The only reason I can fathom for this wast of time is so that Heard’s lawyers could try to put in the minds of the jury that Depp instructed the witness to act on his behalf to, I don’t know, sue people related to this incident and make negative comments in the media. Honestly, I can’t quit grasp what Heard’s attorney must have stipulated as cause to subpoena one of Depp’s attorneys here. They gained no useful information and looked incompetent. But honestly I’m more frustrated that the judge allowed this.
I doubt you follow this case seriously, if you're a law graduate, or you'll understand everything at play here. She has a countersuit against Depp for things that this lawyer said when he was representating Depp. So they had to bring him in, even though he can't answer. Just enough to put things in the mind of the jury like you said.
I find that kind of tactic shady, but that's all they can do. How do you prove that it was Depp's words coming out of his lawyer's mouth, if he can't answer question ? Well you can't... So you try to manipulate the jury. The real mistake was the suit, knowing you have to go through a privileged witness to prove anything.
Well by the date on the screen I would assume it's a previously recorded interview. And I would say yes, it's building a narrative. They know they can't answer the question but by power of suggestion in the questions they are implying that Depp instructed the lawyer to send out this info by Twitter, therefore defaming Heard. Trying to prove her claim of defamation.
Do you think it is just so the jury can hear her questions and then make assumptions? Not a lawyer, here, and I can't think of any other reason..
This entire thing is a mess. The divorce moving into this defamation trial. Honestly, I'm lost when this seems an ongoing divorce trial, rape trial, perjury trial, defamation etc... Amber Heard lying and lying some more really blew this past ridiculous.. 😒
AmberTurd is def my fave hashtag, it's so descriptive and accurate. Given the turd's central part in these proceedings, I think her pursuing this counter suit is going to end in such a huge case of Streisand-Effect that it will forever after be known as Streisand-Turd-Effect and quite possibly result in another defamation action against Heard by Streisand as a result of Streisand's name being forevermore associated with a turd which she herself never in fact pinched out. It's a fascinating legal dilemma which may yet set some significant precedents in the complex highly specialised field of turd law. I'm indeed myself observing with a tightly clenched ring here.
Entire video in a line, “I instruct you to not answer that question based on attorney and client privilege, I agree to accept the instruction 😂😂😂”
After 26 minutes of questioning and we have firmly established that the witness had Twitter account & now no longer has a Twitter account. 😂
Best comment in this. That's the only information I learnt through this 26 mins of my life. Additionally that he is banned for life. 🤣😂
😂