Wow! This is my 1st time listening to CDS Anil, and oh my…he is so smart and knowledgeable! It is good knowing that Modiji has chosen the right person for the job! Our nation’s security is in the right hands! ❤
I took a different view. His responses reflected muddled thoughts and was overall uninspiring. Gen Naravane should have been given the role or maybe someone else. I am worried about Gen Chauhan’s effectiveness in the role
i love how CDS's approach to Ukraine war is based on its process, technique and feedback rather than being driven by any ideological agenda or this vs. that. glad to see highly professional attitude of indian army.
Because 80% of our Indian Military Inventory is of Soviet/Russia Origin. We need Russia for the regular maintenance of the equipment. So he definitely has to be careful just like our Govt's neutral stance
@@mudassaram1410 jab dimag Khali ho to Aisa hi lagta hai tum jaiso ko, aur suna hai pakistan mein is baar military pared nahi ho rha hai bhikh nahi mil rha hai kya🤣🤣
@@mudassaram1410 adani is fraud or not it's a matter of investigation but one thing is clear still he has million times more wealth than puncharputras😝
33:17 that question from Palki was just 🔥👌 brilliant to see. Well done. The American former general felt really awkward there, stood silent for some seconds even.
Why the need to gloat over an imagined put down of American general? The USA is a friend of India. Understand it, and forget about the old history. PM Modi knows this and why India is getting constantly closer to America
@@rickbarrington Repeated foolishness of fools of america shamelessly boasts about Democracy under their Hierocracy.. Fools for the world and supporting fool 💥
@@rickbarrington 'forget about the old history' its like sayings when you do it its everything white and forgivable when others do it, its bad sorry bro India may be friend of US but it definitely not friend of hypocrisy, NATO gen was literally talking about FOE in democracy, not sure why her question offended you or anyone
They left gang will try everything to keep a brahmin away from the power. And they know, Palki is Powerful. She is fierce. They can not frighten her, blackmail her in the name of free speech and liberalism. India had one Ruthless female PM. She was very powerful. Broke pakistan into 2 countries.
@@goldenfiremonkey96 what you said it's true but it's not in the playbooks of so called left-liberal socialist political parties in India . They always cherry pick issues and continue their anti-hindu propaganda...their long term strategy after all ...
33:12 Palki clearly stumped the Former Secretary of Defense with question on allying with China while sermonizing upon Democracy. The arguments of the West are always based on their convenience rather than holding onto ideals. That's exactly the reason why at the end all of the big talk on democracy, it rang hollow with that one question from Palki.
Sometimes people of power can not speak any rubbish like media people, because media is allowed to make mistakes but people in power have to watch, because they are representing a nation.
They were lecturing about democracy and explaining the Russia-Ukrain conflict as per western empire narrative. And of course subtly been playing the narrative " america saved democracy & free world"... blah blah blah... Palki maam just exposed their hypocrisy so beautifully😍😂🤣😂
Imagine if there was congress govt, Barkha would be conducting these interviews you can imagine how she would portray India, we are certainly grateful for good riddance.
Don't go over board by saying that she is so good, She prepared her question and the one's who are answering are spot and they have to be careful before they answer the question, because they are retired and with power they can answer,
All the seals 🦭 clapping in the audience seem to be mostly foreign reporters. It was hilarious 😂 to see these trained pets lap up propaganda of the west.
All these Europeans are coming to the dialogue to score a round of applause from other europeans by speaking against Russia. I'm not making the point that Russia is right but the question is "Are these europeans going to offer tangible and practical solutions to the conflict or will they continue to show the camaraderie towards Ukraine and further arm it?" The USA is fighting a proxy war against Russia at the cost of Ukraine. USA has a long grudge and obsession towards Russia.
You're right, I think we should offer the same solution in Kashmir. As China and Pakistan have more power together than India alone, they have every right to carve up Indian territory amongst themselves. India is not part of any alliance and Russia certainly owes China for their support by withholding military aid to India. Will be interesting to see how such a conflict plays out, doubt it ends well for India though, such a shame.
@@sudarshaniyer2747 except india has got nukes, anything they'd try, they'd get it back just as good!! As the saying goes better to die than to live as a slave !
can’t tell if y’all are all bots or just brainwashed don’t cry for the help of the west when China bum fucks you and daddy Russia don’t do shit to help you yall dirty cunts
Some comments gloat over Palki’s imagined put down of the American general. Why? The USA is a friend of India. Understand it, and forget about the old history. PM Modi knows this and why India is getting constantly closer to America
Thanks a lot ,Pallavi. You have shown them the mirror! !! No politian of any stature could have spoken the way you framed the Last question .None of these crooks will henceforth be able to face you in an interview session. Journalist of the 21 st century you are & so is your last question !!@
1. Do not tell us that NATO is run from cafeterias of NATO offices. NATO used to allow deliberations with representatives of Russian state there because it is confident of its secure military grade internal tactical and strategic communications structure remaining impregnable to such token gestures of access by those russian respresentatives. 2. With assistance through military aid to Ukraine in this war, the NATO has made its intentions clear that at this juncture (given the numerical nuclear and nonnuclear tactical and strategic wherewithal Russia is still in possession of) NATO has no intentions of invading Russia directly and officially with troops of its member countries as it will blunt the curated narrative propagated by NATO member states of NATO not being an aggressor and as it will open floodgates for Russia to target expensive dual use (military and civilian) infrastructures leading deterioration of law and order and oberall stability of socioeconomically advanced western member states that have tremendous role in fuelling economic growth that funds military might that in return helps to maintain edge in long term hegemonic strategic posture of the western allies. For NATO, directly invading Russia right now makes no sense as militarily weakening Russia through conflict with non-NATO countries by provoking Russia firing off their shoulders is part of their agenda- so this theatrics like "they have taken troops from along borders with NATO member states as they know NATO is not a threat to them" is a drivel that cuts no ice with neutral military watchers. Russia is no saint either. But that does not provide any moral high ground and bully pulpit of ethics and morality to NATO member states and western allies given their past and recent misdemanors. There is no denying that Nato's pre war and (pre crimea conflict as well) push for eastward expansion through 1997 expansion, 2004 and 2007 statements opening doors for eastern non-NATO countries and regime changes through colored revolutions provoked Russia further deteriorating prospects of global peace and stability as Russia is well within sane rationale to construe that its positive signalling through dismantling of the warsaw pact (a nasty alliance in itself just like the NATO) was taken for a ride as its weakness to build upon and mount pressure on Russia by expansion of NATO with possibility of sorrounding Russia further along its border with nuclear stockpile that would diminish Russia's capability as a continental neighbor of neutralising nuclear tipped missiles fired at its territory with significantly reduced reaction time while the US as a transcontinental player as well as an offshore balancer would remain safer at a far longer dustance from Russian nuclear tipped missiles fired from Russian territory providing the US significantly more reaction time, thus tipping the balance of power between the US and Russia by tilting the doctrine of Mutually assured destruction, especially with deployment of ballistic missile defense in europe, in favor of the US by means of weaning Russia's strategic deterrence away. Political oneupmanship by means of loudmouthing threat of nuclear retaliation is still nicer than actual use of nuclear weapons as the US did in Japan. If anything, this threat deters NATO from miliarily invading russia that NATO tonguetwists as its deliberate choice of not posing any threat to russia. There is no point exaggerating the nuclear deterrent posed by russia as the US coordinating with Russia for safe landing of Biden in Kyiv only goes to prove that backchannel diplomatic communications between Russia and NATi are intact even in this chaos for thwarting a nuclear escalation in the eventuality of one. 3. When it comes to shared democratic values, the west has supported military dictatorships of Pakistan with funds and military weapons in their past wars against democratic India. Also the west using its militico-politico-financial clout in the UN, have formulated a resolution in favor of Pakistan wherein the west in the garb of neutrality have secured Pakistan's de facto control of parts of Kashmir illegally occupied by Pakistan by means of force despite the fact that Kashmir legally acceded into India through instrument of accession (as part of india independence act mutually agreed to between the british indian colonial regime, Indian nationalists and pro-Pak faction of undivided India) and the west keep preaching india on arriving at a solution based on the biased resolution through a referendum. If the west wants to condone the illegality of Pakistani occupation of Indian territories and seeks a referendum on the basis of religion (India being hindu majority secular country while the Indian state of Kashmir is Muslim majority), India will ofcourse draw a equivalence on the double standards at play here by the west as the west promptly calls out Russian occupation of eastern ukrainian states as "invasion by Russia" (but does not call out Pakistan's invasion of Kashmir in similar tone) and does not call for a referendum to be held on the basis of lignuistics to see as to which country between Russia and Ukraine, Russian speaking population of eastern Ukraine side with (very different from western stance of a referendum being held in Kashmir). Democratic values and rules of order go both ways, they are not set in motion for being observed by developing countries like india at the cost of their core interests, that of their territorial integrity while being whimsically tweaked and twisted to suit to the farfetched strategic interests of rich western countries in faraway continents where they often fund and support authoritarian, undemocratic, military dicatorships relgious theicracies, zealots, despots from time to time so long as they cater to their strategic interests only to have them bumped off in the name of cause of humanitarian intervention and spread of democratic values when they are of no use or alogn against the strategic interests of the west. 4. The western countries are well within their sovereign rights to insulate their population from what they consider as cyber disinformation by the Russian state and parenthesising Russian digital media under it, citing security threat but the west should not then complain by playing the broken record of democratic values being undermined when China does the very same with western media citing security threat and attempts of cyber disinformation by western media as the west behaves like a nanny by deciding for its population by not allowing them democratic right of expression and freedom to determine on their own as to whether news reports, analyses, editorials and opeds by Russian media outlets wholly or partially constitute disinformation campaign. Do the western socalled democracies have no trust and faith reposed on judgment of their educated people? The western countries, the collective west so to speak of, absolutely can not decide for population of sovereign countries in rest of the world on what constitites as disinformation, by weaponsing its militico-financial and technological clout like banning russian media on global platforms like TH-cam.
We don't support this war but still we also don't accept the statement that Russia was not provoked 🙄. Nato also to be blamed. But still this has to stop
Last question destroyed all earlier biased answers. Kudos to Palki. I wish lavrov also interviewed by Palki not by that stupid who doesn't have basic courtesy of not interrupting while other one is answering.
History shows that Kiev, has been involved in both the World Wars & in the present Kyiv with it's changed etymology of two central alphabets 'ie' changed into 'yi' does not deny it's participation in the classification hinted as the Third World War. The World under the Threat of Climate Change Consequences in the Future should definitely work towards a " War Free World " . The Nations of the World are so inter dependent, hence " War Free World " is the Necessity, rather than a Choice.
Gen.Campbel & Gen. Mattis spoke more like politicians then Generals. NATO is the biggest meschief monger in the whole issue. The west unfortunately comprises of the worst war mongerers we have seen that in the Middle East in the near past. The Russia- Ukrain war can only stop if the west is kicked out of the scene, earlier Ukraine understands this so much better for them.
The last question was a killer !!! Palki should have mentioned Pakistan instead of just China.....cat got his tongue...Catty question from Palki !!...Gotta love Indian woman !!
While the US & Europe will always blame Russia for this war, they quietly refuse to look at the promises made by them to Russia after the disintegration of the USSR in 1991 or around, and NATO's subsequent actions....
Gen Mattis asked why India chose to be a democratic nation when it gained independence. This isn't a pressing question for Indians. The question should be, why has Pakistan gone down the road that it has since its independence? Why did Germany establish the Third Reich? It seems that they don't trust the world that they live in, and then they communicate this distrust to others. How can this change? Pakistan expects India to take advantage of it being disadvantaged, and it wants to be in India's shoes instead. India is not taking advantage of Pakistan's current predicament, perhaps Pakistan will acknowledge that when the time comes.
FANTASTIC question By Palki Sharma, a WARNE quality ripper of a last ball, after a brilliant set up!!! Well done Palki. Enjoyed it. STUMPED has now got a MEME.
@@SodiumSyndicate that was the point, he was conceding that the US has contradicted itself plenty of times in the past, which is why he commended the question
@@SodiumSyndicate no it doesn't, if anything it makes him more credible, Putin could easily choose to stop attacking today and even has taken troops away from NATO borders to throw into Ukraine, no one forced Putin to do anything
@@sudarshaniyer2747 Why should Putin stop? - he ought to wipe off Ukraine or take over fully. Expanding NATO onto Russian borders was a no no & Russia has been warning against it since 1990s. This is like the 1962 Cuban Missile Crisis where USA threatened to nuke Cuba for housing Soviet nukes on its soil right in USA's backyard. Now it is the other way around. Putin has the moral right to decimate Ukraine but he has been immensely merciful last year - not so much this year & thus Russia is going to win, Ukraine stands decimated already.
Those capping for Ukraine, we in India don't care about your politics. We have our partnership with Russia and Ukraine isn't that valuable for us to break it. Keep yourself entertained.
Keep your emotions aside and be logical at first. India has a extreme trade deficit with Russia and China. When it comes to trade with US, Australia and EU , India contributed exponentially to its GDP (employment,FDI ,Export and Import etc). Country does not run by emotions, it runs by money (economy) in this modern world.
Why no one is reacting like Russian minister, in past America did to many times like Russia at present but the matter of fact is due to West bullshits and America too nobody is criticising them yet whole world is suffering and being rich in current scenario they are not.
I do not know why we in india do not focus on how a person and weapons looks. See these 2officer's uniforms. which looks more comfortable and good looking??? Plz focus on everything. leave "chalta hai" attitude. Same with Equipment people say in war how weapon look doesn't matter true but then why western weapons looks cool in battle yet effective???? This is how they market effective and good looking. We do not see that in India. Be it PM on some inauguration or he is on some event displaying new technologies those presentation are always poor. See when our Defence minister Rajnath Singh hands over indigenously developed equipment and systems to our army see that solider the way he talked and they way that equipment was sitting on him, and that wire coming out does that looked war ready no??? So people should pay attention to presentations and equipment. When our companies are making equipment if they make something good looking and still effective what is the harm??? Also some things need to changed in indian military. See that way we like US President's Beast and United States Secret Service see how they operate. I would like TATA or Mahindra giving our PM and President something similar to Beast. West even IRAN who is sanctioned put so much effort on how they products looks so they look cool to show on the other hand we completely ignore that. If you think this doesn't matter check Strat News Global Nitin Gokhale said that our soldiers on China border were happy when they received TATA's Safari Storm he said some soldiers mentioned to him how They always see Chinese soldiers come in good looking, comfortable cars and We (indian soldiers) were using gypsy. They are also human they have also emotions if we can give them comfortable and cool looking yet effective equipment it boosts their moral. Just see videos of our soldiers vs any other ours look like they are not going to gym and do not have equipment for war and do not have proper equipment someone's helmet is covering eyes, someone is wearing patka, someone have jacket others don't. They are protecting us it is our job to give them proper equipment. FOr that have to change "chalta hai" mindset See US new Abraham-X tank how futuristic it look and that doesn't mean its not effective. They focused on its looks unlike us
I don’t think this war is just. However, I don’t think the West and its allies can ever talk about just invasions or wars when they have done the same!!
Indian General disclosed the substantial & concrete points which they learnt..... But rest of both didn't reveal any substance......only Prescribed lines they propagated.... When would Indian Generals start 2 learn 2 deal with these backstabbers......
That's why we love Palki. She simply nailed it in the end.
Yes...she asked a hard question...was really hard😂😂
Out of syllabus
Send the time stamp
@@karandoshi8828 last 4-5 minutes
@@karandoshi8828 Watch last 2-3 minutes.
All generals but Palki ambushed all of them. Brilliant
Wow! This is my 1st time listening to CDS Anil, and oh my…he is so smart and knowledgeable! It is good knowing that Modiji has chosen the right person for the job! Our nation’s security is in the right hands! ❤
I took a different view. His responses reflected muddled thoughts and was overall uninspiring. Gen Naravane should have been given the role or maybe someone else. I am worried about Gen Chauhan’s effectiveness in the role
@@rickbarrington who are you westerners
i love how CDS's approach to Ukraine war is based on its process, technique and feedback rather than being driven by any ideological agenda or this vs. that.
glad to see highly professional attitude of indian army.
Because 80% of our Indian Military Inventory is of Soviet/Russia Origin. We need Russia for the regular maintenance of the equipment. So he definitely has to be careful just like our Govt's neutral stance
😜😜😜 meanwhile, I was seeing a confused CDS.😜😜
@@mudassaram1410 jab dimag Khali ho to Aisa hi lagta hai tum jaiso ko, aur suna hai pakistan mein is baar military pared nahi ho rha hai bhikh nahi mil rha hai kya🤣🤣
@@kundansah6701 suna Hai Adani fraud is exposing badly... foreign sajish😂😂😂
@@mudassaram1410 adani is fraud or not it's a matter of investigation but one thing is clear still he has million times more wealth than puncharputras😝
33:33 Palki mam question was out of syllabus for US general.
Even the CDS Anil Chauhan couldn't hold his laughter for the last question 🤣
33:17 that question from Palki was just 🔥👌 brilliant to see. Well done. The American former general felt really awkward there, stood silent for some seconds even.
lapet diya Palkiji ne
American Defence -- Pissed out.. No answer idiots.
Why the need to gloat over an imagined put down of American general? The USA is a friend of India. Understand it, and forget about the old history. PM Modi knows this and why India is getting constantly closer to America
@@rickbarrington Repeated foolishness of fools of america shamelessly boasts about Democracy under their Hierocracy.. Fools for the world and supporting fool 💥
@@rickbarrington 'forget about the old history' its like sayings when you do it its everything white and forgivable when others do it, its bad sorry bro India may be friend of US but it definitely not friend of hypocrisy, NATO gen was literally talking about FOE in democracy, not sure why her question offended you or anyone
She's great at how she handle this great men in their field..hats off to you Palki
How confidently journalism is done if you're right proved by Mam.
Palki madam is next level... Her journalism is top notch 👍
This woman in future is going to be India' 1st journalist to become President!
No chance, they'll come with exsuse to say she comes high caste and reject her those grounds.
@@kaushikthaker9666 Your caste does not determine your role but your abilities do.
@@goldenfiremonkey96 let me tell you if you are a brahmin then it's a disadvantage, because I'm one and I know
They left gang will try everything to keep a brahmin away from the power.
And they know, Palki is Powerful. She is fierce. They can not frighten her, blackmail her in the name of free speech and liberalism.
India had one Ruthless female PM. She was very powerful. Broke pakistan into 2 countries.
@@goldenfiremonkey96 what you said it's true but it's not in the playbooks of so called left-liberal socialist political parties in India .
They always cherry pick issues and continue their anti-hindu propaganda...their long term strategy after all ...
Palki mam ..is just awesome.. inspiration to many..
28:09 I don't sympathize with Russia but damn that was ruthless by Palki.
Palki mam was savage at the end 😂😂
What a smart reply by the CDS at 34:17
33:12 Palki clearly stumped the Former Secretary of Defense with question on allying with China while sermonizing upon Democracy. The arguments of the West are always based on their convenience rather than holding onto ideals. That's exactly the reason why at the end all of the big talk on democracy, it rang hollow with that one question from Palki.
Lmao, palki mam killed it at the last🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
27:52 Palki maam you've just nailed it maam..kudos..asking that question straight to the face..wow..👏👏👏👏👍👍👌👍👌👍
Great respect to General Matis. From India.
Sometimes people of power can not speak any rubbish like media people, because media is allowed to make mistakes but people in power have to watch, because they are representing a nation.
Good ending 😂
The propaganda that both the 'Goras' were vomiting was giving me a headache
They were lecturing about democracy and explaining the Russia-Ukrain conflict as per western empire narrative.
And of course subtly been playing the narrative " america saved democracy & free world"... blah blah blah...
Palki maam just exposed their hypocrisy so beautifully😍😂🤣😂
Imagine if there was congress govt, Barkha would be conducting these interviews you can imagine how she would portray India, we are certainly grateful for good riddance.
We all know who's the best achor in the world: None other than Palki Sharma Upadhyay 👍🙏🙏
I don't any comparison to her 👍🙏She's incredible 👍🙏
Gen. Chauhan : Is a soldier and talks from perspective of a soldier
Gen. Campbell and Gen. Mattis : Talk as Politicians , Putin bad Ukraine Good! lol
जनरल चौहान एक सुलझे हुये व्यक्ति है ।
उन्हें CDS बनाना एक अच्छा निर्णय है ।।।👍👍👍
Palki Ma'am is always a pleasure to watch
Don't go over board by saying that she is so good,
She prepared her question and the one's who are answering are spot and they have to be careful before they answer the question, because they are retired and with power they can answer,
Palki...you demolished him😂👍👏
That last question is enough for all the earlier bull we listened😂
The last question, and that was straight out of the park!! :D
Palkiji you are the best and the daring! I always admired you!
The smile on the CDS's face: 34:05
Its good to see Gen. Mattis, a good friend of India in Washington when he was in office. Welcome back to India, General!
Fuck dude that last question!! I literally laughed out a lot!!!!!!😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Great conversation .
Three very distinguished speaker , all very professional . I like general Mattis comments.
Palki pulled out a Big Mirror 🪞 and showed it to the American guy with her last question, poor man stood shocked for some seconds 😂😂😂
Palki mam 💥💥😍😍
All the seals 🦭 clapping in the audience seem to be mostly foreign reporters. It was hilarious 😂 to see these trained pets lap up propaganda of the west.
Actually I also noticed that
सही कहा ।।।
Omg please so true they were so annoying, no mannerisms at all . Rightly said seals clapping after every single line of propaganda 😅😂
The silence at 33:42 is too loud.
World class journalist!
I gotta say she did good...
All these Europeans are coming to the dialogue to score a round of applause from other europeans by speaking against Russia.
I'm not making the point that Russia is right but the question is "Are these europeans going to offer tangible and practical solutions to the conflict or will they continue to show the camaraderie towards Ukraine and further arm it?"
The USA is fighting a proxy war against Russia at the cost of Ukraine. USA has a long grudge and obsession towards Russia.
You're right, I think we should offer the same solution in Kashmir. As China and Pakistan have more power together than India alone, they have every right to carve up Indian territory amongst themselves. India is not part of any alliance and Russia certainly owes China for their support by withholding military aid to India. Will be interesting to see how such a conflict plays out, doubt it ends well for India though, such a shame.
Don’t cry to The Europeans if Pakistan starts to bomb the Indians.
@@sudarshaniyer2747 except india has got nukes, anything they'd try, they'd get it back just as good!! As the saying goes better to die than to live as a slave !
33:20 that was brutal😂
palki doing good and she is the correct choice
That is an epic final question.
Self Reliance, 20:45 - We just taken some Baby Steps
This General, from Australia is a liar. Australian soldiers a complain alot, the ones in Ukraine.
can’t tell if y’all are all bots or just brainwashed don’t cry for the help of the west when China bum fucks you and daddy Russia don’t do shit to help you yall dirty cunts
that last question wow
She is just too good.
Some comments gloat over Palki’s imagined put down of the American general. Why? The USA is a friend of India. Understand it, and forget about the old history. PM Modi knows this and why India is getting constantly closer to America
Palki is lady Chanakya. She got the better of US CDS. Bravo.
In the end it was lit
Thanks a lot ,Pallavi. You have shown them the mirror! !! No politian of any stature could have spoken the way you framed the Last question .None of these crooks will henceforth be able to face you in an interview session. Journalist of the 21 st century you are & so is your last question !!@
Who’s Pallavi? Lol
What a beauty , Palki Sharma 👌☺️
Wow !! Palki is an awesome moderator.
Loved the trap she did at the last part. What a presence of mind. Cool !!!🙏🙏
1. Do not tell us that NATO is run from cafeterias of NATO offices. NATO used to allow deliberations with representatives of Russian state there because it is confident of its secure military grade internal tactical and strategic communications structure remaining impregnable to such token gestures of access by those russian respresentatives.
2. With assistance through military aid to Ukraine in this war, the NATO has made its intentions clear that at this juncture (given the numerical nuclear and nonnuclear tactical and strategic wherewithal Russia is still in possession of) NATO has no intentions of invading Russia directly and officially with troops of its member countries as it will blunt the curated narrative propagated by NATO member states of NATO not being an aggressor and as it will open floodgates for Russia to target expensive dual use (military and civilian) infrastructures leading deterioration of law and order and oberall stability of socioeconomically advanced western member states that have tremendous role in fuelling economic growth that funds military might that in return helps to maintain edge in long term hegemonic strategic posture of the western allies. For NATO, directly invading Russia right now makes no sense as militarily weakening Russia through conflict with non-NATO countries by provoking Russia firing off their shoulders is part of their agenda- so this theatrics like "they have taken troops from along borders with NATO member states as they know NATO is not a threat to them" is a drivel that cuts no ice with neutral military watchers. Russia is no saint either. But that does not provide any moral high ground and bully pulpit of ethics and morality to NATO member states and western allies given their past and recent misdemanors. There is no denying that Nato's pre war and (pre crimea conflict as well) push for eastward expansion through 1997 expansion, 2004 and 2007 statements opening doors for eastern non-NATO countries and regime changes through colored revolutions provoked Russia further deteriorating prospects of global peace and stability as Russia is well within sane rationale to construe that its positive signalling through dismantling of the warsaw pact (a nasty alliance in itself just like the NATO) was taken for a ride as its weakness to build upon and mount pressure on Russia by expansion of NATO with possibility of sorrounding Russia further along its border with nuclear stockpile that would diminish Russia's capability as a continental neighbor of neutralising nuclear tipped missiles fired at its territory with significantly reduced reaction time while the US as a transcontinental player as well as an offshore balancer would remain safer at a far longer dustance from Russian nuclear tipped missiles fired from Russian territory providing the US significantly more reaction time, thus tipping the balance of power between the US and Russia by tilting the doctrine of Mutually assured destruction, especially with deployment of ballistic missile defense in europe, in favor of the US by means of weaning Russia's strategic deterrence away. Political oneupmanship by means of loudmouthing threat of nuclear retaliation is still nicer than actual use of nuclear weapons as the US did in Japan. If anything, this threat deters NATO from miliarily invading russia that NATO tonguetwists as its deliberate choice of not posing any threat to russia. There is no point exaggerating the nuclear deterrent posed by russia as the US coordinating with Russia for safe landing of Biden in Kyiv only goes to prove that backchannel diplomatic communications between Russia and NATi are intact even in this chaos for thwarting a nuclear escalation in the eventuality of one.
3. When it comes to shared democratic values, the west has supported military dictatorships of Pakistan with funds and military weapons in their past wars against democratic India. Also the west using its militico-politico-financial clout in the UN, have formulated a resolution in favor of Pakistan wherein the west in the garb of neutrality have secured Pakistan's de facto control of parts of Kashmir illegally occupied by Pakistan by means of force despite the fact that Kashmir legally acceded into India through instrument of accession (as part of india independence act mutually agreed to between the british indian colonial regime, Indian nationalists and pro-Pak faction of undivided India) and the west keep preaching india on arriving at a solution based on the biased resolution through a referendum. If the west wants to condone the illegality of Pakistani occupation of Indian territories and seeks a referendum on the basis of religion (India being hindu majority secular country while the Indian state of Kashmir is Muslim majority), India will ofcourse draw a equivalence on the double standards at play here by the west as the west promptly calls out Russian occupation of eastern ukrainian states as "invasion by Russia" (but does not call out Pakistan's invasion of Kashmir in similar tone) and does not call for a referendum to be held on the basis of lignuistics to see as to which country between Russia and Ukraine, Russian speaking population of eastern Ukraine side with (very different from western stance of a referendum being held in Kashmir). Democratic values and rules of order go both ways, they are not set in motion for being observed by developing countries like india at the cost of their core interests, that of their territorial integrity while being whimsically tweaked and twisted to suit to the farfetched strategic interests of rich western countries in faraway continents where they often fund and support authoritarian, undemocratic, military dicatorships relgious theicracies, zealots, despots from time to time so long as they cater to their strategic interests only to have them bumped off in the name of cause of humanitarian intervention and spread of democratic values when they are of no use or alogn against the strategic interests of the west.
4. The western countries are well within their sovereign rights to insulate their population from what they consider as cyber disinformation by the Russian state and parenthesising Russian digital media under it, citing security threat but the west should not then complain by playing the broken record of democratic values being undermined when China does the very same with western media citing security threat and attempts of cyber disinformation by western media as the west behaves like a nanny by deciding for its population by not allowing them democratic right of expression and freedom to determine on their own as to whether news reports, analyses, editorials and opeds by Russian media outlets wholly or partially constitute disinformation campaign. Do the western socalled democracies have no trust and faith reposed on judgment of their educated people? The western countries, the collective west so to speak of, absolutely can not decide for population of sovereign countries in rest of the world on what constitites as disinformation, by weaponsing its militico-financial and technological clout like banning russian media on global platforms like TH-cam.
In the last of discussion US representative was speechless......
Palki Mam is tremendous.
Love to see Palki
We don't support this war but still we also don't accept the statement that Russia was not provoked 🙄. Nato also to be blamed. But still this has to stop
Last question destroyed all earlier biased answers. Kudos to Palki. I wish lavrov also interviewed by Palki not by that stupid who doesn't have basic courtesy of not interrupting while other one is answering.
History shows that Kiev, has been involved in both the World Wars & in the present Kyiv with it's changed etymology of two central alphabets 'ie' changed into 'yi' does not deny it's participation in the classification
hinted as the Third World War.
The World under the Threat of Climate Change Consequences in the Future should definitely work towards a " War Free World " .
The Nations of the World are so inter dependent, hence " War Free World " is the Necessity, rather than a Choice.
This war is between timid NATO hiding behind Ukranian and the bold Russia. The Braves will take the trophy 🏆
This particular x 10
The world people like to listen the topic of War 🤗
Palkhi = goddess. brilliant
The best question is the last one
Indian man had to answer for american
The American grandpa literally begged the Indian uncle to answer it for him.
Gen.Campbel & Gen. Mattis spoke more like politicians then Generals. NATO is the biggest meschief monger in the whole issue. The west unfortunately comprises of the worst war mongerers we have seen that in the Middle East in the near past. The Russia- Ukrain war can only stop if the west is kicked out of the scene, earlier Ukraine understands this so much better for them.
The last question was a killer !!! Palki should have mentioned Pakistan instead of just China.....cat got his tongue...Catty question from Palki !!...Gotta love Indian woman !!
Palki Sharma is a Legend 💯🔥
While the US & Europe will always blame Russia for this war, they quietly refuse to look at the promises made by them to Russia after the disintegration of the USSR in 1991 or around, and NATO's subsequent actions....
Yes
Gen Mattis asked why India chose to be a democratic nation when it gained independence. This isn't a pressing question for Indians. The question should be, why has Pakistan gone down the road that it has since its independence? Why did Germany establish the Third Reich? It seems that they don't trust the world that they live in, and then they communicate this distrust to others. How can this change? Pakistan expects India to take advantage of it being disadvantaged, and it wants to be in India's shoes instead. India is not taking advantage of Pakistan's current predicament, perhaps Pakistan will acknowledge that when the time comes.
Love palki ma'am 🤩
FANTASTIC question By Palki Sharma, a WARNE quality ripper of a last ball, after a brilliant set up!!! Well done Palki. Enjoyed it. STUMPED has now got a MEME.
JIM MATTIS SIR ...GIVING VERY CLEAR REPLY.
What clear reply, he got stunned in the end.
@@SodiumSyndicate that was the point, he was conceding that the US has contradicted itself plenty of times in the past, which is why he commended the question
@@sudarshaniyer2747 Which makes his entire half an hour diatribe against Russia & authoritarianism utterly useless.
@@SodiumSyndicate no it doesn't, if anything it makes him more credible, Putin could easily choose to stop attacking today and even has taken troops away from NATO borders to throw into Ukraine, no one forced Putin to do anything
@@sudarshaniyer2747 Why should Putin stop? - he ought to wipe off Ukraine or take over fully.
Expanding NATO onto Russian borders was a no no & Russia has been warning against it since 1990s.
This is like the 1962 Cuban Missile Crisis where USA threatened to nuke Cuba for housing Soviet nukes on its soil right in USA's backyard.
Now it is the other way around. Putin has the moral right to decimate Ukraine but he has been immensely merciful last year - not so much this year & thus Russia is going to win, Ukraine stands decimated already.
Gen mattis got whiplash from that one 33:16
Looks like, either the occasion or ORF has cramped the Palki style...
Good.
Russia , asked if it could join nato as well , but unless it's American side kik , usa don't allow such joinings
We need peace between Ukraine and Russia.
WE SUPPORT RUSSIA AND OPPOSE WESTERN BULLYING!
As a Australian l do not stand behind all the comments made
You stand behind your European masters 🤣🤣🤣
Can you elaborate on that please John Molnar
Those capping for Ukraine, we in India don't care about your politics. We have our partnership with Russia and Ukraine isn't that valuable for us to break it. Keep yourself entertained.
Keep your emotions aside and be logical at first.
India has a extreme trade deficit with Russia and China.
When it comes to trade with US, Australia and EU , India contributed exponentially to its GDP (employment,FDI ,Export and Import etc).
Country does not run by emotions, it runs by money (economy) in this modern world.
General Saab aap toh serious hi ho gaye, class thodi chal rahi hai ..power projection chal rahi hai.
Uncle sam preaching peace
5.00. UN charter?😂 the US has over 250 military interefrences into sovereign states, many of them illegal, since the end of the Soviet Union.
General Jim Mattis seems knowledgeable.
Mattis was ambushed at last.
You can't poke the Bear for 30 years, and when it attacks, say it was unprovoked.
33:14 😂
Why no one is reacting like Russian minister, in past America did to many times like Russia at present but the matter of fact is due to West bullshits and America too nobody is criticising them yet whole world is suffering and being rich in current scenario they are not.
I do not know why we in india do not focus on how a person and weapons looks. See these 2officer's uniforms. which looks more comfortable and good looking???
Plz focus on everything. leave "chalta hai" attitude. Same with Equipment people say in war how weapon look doesn't matter true but then why western weapons
looks cool in battle yet effective???? This is how they market effective and good looking. We do not see that in India. Be it PM on some inauguration or he is on some event
displaying new technologies those presentation are always poor. See when our Defence minister Rajnath Singh hands over indigenously developed equipment and systems to our army
see that solider the way he talked and they way that equipment was sitting on him, and that wire coming out does that looked war ready no??? So people should
pay attention to presentations and equipment. When our companies are making equipment if they make something good looking and still effective what is the harm???
Also some things need to changed in indian military.
See that way we like US President's Beast and United States Secret Service see how they operate. I would like TATA or Mahindra giving our PM and President something similar
to Beast. West even IRAN who is sanctioned put so much effort on how they products looks so they look cool to show on the other hand we completely ignore that.
If you think this doesn't matter check Strat News Global Nitin Gokhale said that our soldiers on China border were happy when they received TATA's Safari Storm he said some
soldiers mentioned to him how They always see Chinese soldiers come in good looking, comfortable cars and We (indian soldiers) were using gypsy. They are also human they have
also emotions if we can give them comfortable and cool looking yet effective equipment it boosts their moral. Just see videos of our soldiers vs any other ours look like they are not
going to gym and do not have equipment for war and do not have proper equipment someone's helmet is covering eyes, someone is wearing patka, someone have jacket others don't.
They are protecting us it is our job to give them proper equipment. FOr that have to change "chalta hai" mindset
See US new Abraham-X tank how futuristic it look and that doesn't mean its not effective. They focused on its looks unlike us
I don’t think this war is just. However, I don’t think the West and its allies can ever talk about just invasions or wars when they have done the same!!
The Finest Blend of Premium Cope
Good morning Anna akk14.2024.
50 countries versus 1 nation.
Indian General disclosed the substantial & concrete points which they learnt.....
But rest of both didn't reveal any substance......only Prescribed lines they propagated....
When would Indian Generals start 2 learn 2 deal with these backstabbers......
50 countries versus 1 nation.😂😂😂😂
Video quality could have been better
How unimpressive were these guys? Imagine if you are a soldier under these guys and they decide the strategy. Damn