Please see how he dropped the personality of an accomplished theater actor, and with reverence he is listening as a reader, that's what marks someone who understands art- he understands him as an artist and what he has produced.
মনোরঞ্জন বাবু আপনার সব কটা ইন্টারভিউ আমি দেখেছি । বার বার দেখেছি ।প্রতিবারই অসাধারণ লেগেছে ।আপনার থেকে আরো অনেকে কিছু শোনার ইচ্ছে রইলো ।আপনাকে আমার প্রণাম জানাই ।
কিন্তু মনোরঞ্জন বাবু, এখনকার বাংলা সাহিত্য কলকাতা কেন্দ্রিক, সেই ফুল, লতাপাতায় আটকে আছে, আর সেইসব মানুষরা সেখানকার প্রধান হোতা। আপনাকে অভিনন্দন, আর এ বিষয় নিয়ে আপনি কলম ধরবেন আশা রাখি।
Dear brother naseeruddin shah you cannot imagine what is manoranjan byapari iron Man of India Nelson Mandela of Indian burning person. Manoranjan vyapari is the example of tolerance and soldier of war for food
Some people are troling u manakaka fr yr pronouctio of amanbikata word that does not mean u are a simple fellow. U are a jem of bengali literature and cultute...we salute u. The great mahashetadevi discovered u and given our literature a new dimension those who are trolling nothing but heir of yr undergarments.
Old times ,he is talking about , I think, of 60s. Villages still had few zamindari system back then. Society had changed in urban areas but interior Bengal was still quiet regressive. That is why naxal and communist movements grew in Bengal gradually. Wont deny Casteism has completely been abolished in Bengal, but it is not as extensive as it used to be or adjacent states. Most Bengalies nowadays dont care about Caste much anymore...Not even religion. Some are agnostic, some are atheists and some follow all religions. Caste is irrelevant. That is why you would hardly see caste politics in Bengal nowadays.
Mr.Monoranjon Byapari I do salute you for your inspiration life long war straggle discrimination racism against humanity. I m proud of you. You are Bangladeshi by born if i m not wrong! Oh brother come back your own country, get back your own yeard.You will get full honour respect and human dignity equal rights and opportunity. As a man and humans person no discrimination of schedule caste.Best of all you will be our Bangladeshi Citizen brother. Thank you again we are really proud of you brother.
Sorry unaware of this interview for last 5yrs. 99% of Bengals babu culture is still unaware or fake ignorance of this krantikari as he is primary a dalit and doesn't belong to the elitist community. His one comment haunts me most regarding post-partition refugee crisis - ' Refugees of upper class was rehabilitated under various govt schemes in & around Calcutta,but dalits/lower classes had to settle by their own along sewage canal, by the railway track or was deported to andaman/ chattisgarh refugee camp. Caste system works everywhere, even in crisis also.
I never support him in one thing.... That he talks about his caste.... There is no caste based discrimination in Bengal.... I have never seen such things in Bengal.....
@@biswajitsen5355 Maybe you are elder than me... But i have seen more than you... And know about India morr than you..... I repeat there is no such castebased discrimination in Bengal as compare to other states...
Caste system in Bengal is very much alive in rural parts of Bengal indeed. Discrimination occurs in major cities also in the name of caste e.g. inter-caste marriage. Families in same caste do not give marriage in other subcaste. From this caste system, an entire religious idea called "Matua" has emerged. Please study properly first.
@@susammanbiswas but right now 'matua' is a vote bank and nothing more than that. They fight among themselves only. If you belong to matua community may I ask you a question? Why do you guys select leader from one particular family? All that family want is power. And what about you guy's citizenship? I think you are already a citizen na ?
Wonderful and innocent conversation by two stalwarts.
Good.
Mahashweta Debi would have been so proud today, seeing Monoronjon Byapari touching new dimensions everyday...
Ekdom thik bolechen
Okabke. Chalegaye. Duniachhorke. Par. Manoranjanbabuke. Ma. Bapko. Namaskar. Pranam. Mahaswetadevike
This interview has made me aware of my ignorance. Didn't know about this person till now.
Please see how he dropped the personality of an accomplished theater actor, and with reverence he is listening as a reader, that's what marks someone who understands art- he understands him as an artist and what he has produced.
Most eligible criteria for any brilliant interviewer and Mr. Shah is one of the gem we have.
মনোরঞ্জন বাবু আপনার সব কটা ইন্টারভিউ আমি দেখেছি । বার বার দেখেছি ।প্রতিবারই অসাধারণ লেগেছে ।আপনার থেকে আরো অনেকে কিছু শোনার ইচ্ছে রইলো ।আপনাকে আমার প্রণাম জানাই ।
Such a beautiful conversation, so honest, so innocent!
Thanks Vaish for wording my feelings.
A great inspiration for the strugglers like me ! Salute to Manoranjan Babu !
Most inspiring story
" police ne jab pakda , tab puja path to Nahi kiya". Too good ...
কিন্তু মনোরঞ্জন বাবু, এখনকার বাংলা সাহিত্য কলকাতা কেন্দ্রিক, সেই ফুল, লতাপাতায় আটকে আছে, আর সেইসব মানুষরা সেখানকার প্রধান হোতা। আপনাকে অভিনন্দন, আর এ বিষয় নিয়ে আপনি কলম ধরবেন আশা রাখি।
Byapari ji is a little star struck - so cute! Naseer was the best interviewer I have seen of Byapari ji.
respect for both of you sir
Thanks for asking very sensible questions.
আপনার জিবনি সংগ্ৰাম অনেক কিছু শিখিয়ে দেয়।ধন্যবাদ আপনাকে।ভালো থাকুন আরো নতুন নতুন চমকপ্রদ ব,ই লিখুন।।
आदरणीय व्यापारी और शाह सर, इस इंटर्व्यू के लिए धन्यवाद।
Last signature episode is so touching, which does that both of you are the grounded and genius.
fascinating personality. cant wait to read this book particularly, along with Milk Teeth.
We are proud of both the two personalities like Jnab Nasiruddin & Manoranjan Saheb.
Amazing.. Love to watch two nice persons talking.. ❤
Such an inspiration!❤️
What a wonderful interview
Too good conversations.
Incredible, my deepest respect for you Sir
It's been five years since this interview and I look at it today, I don't remember what I did in these 5 years.
He is a very honest and innocent writer ❤❤❤
Great job comrade 👏🏾👏🏾
A wonderful interview 🙏🏾🙏🏾
Only one think is there that is .।।।।।।।। Nasir sir I really like u
Dear brother naseeruddin shah you cannot imagine what is manoranjan byapari iron Man of India Nelson Mandela of Indian burning person. Manoranjan vyapari is the example of tolerance and soldier of war for food
Loved the conversation. Two gods Talking with each other. 💙
A biopic about this writer would be phenomenal? 🤪
Contesting in Bengal elections this time hope you can bring the change you spoke of !
He is greatest!! 🖤🖤🖤
Inspirational person 👍
Nasiruddin sir s Voice ❤
Some people are troling u manakaka fr yr pronouctio of amanbikata word that does not mean u are a simple fellow. U are a jem of bengali literature and cultute...we salute u. The great mahashetadevi discovered u and given our literature a new dimension those who are trolling nothing but heir of yr undergarments.
What a beautiful person
সাবাশ, অসাধারণ কথোপকথন।
Such a good interview
Sir thank you. আপনাকে অনেক অনেক ধন্যবাদ। আপনাকে দেখে নতুন করে বাচার ইচ্ছা জাগে মনে। ধন্যবাদ sir
Salute to ur innocence
আমার সশ্রদ্ধ প্রণাম আপনাকে।🙏🙏🙏
Wish it win this year's prize.
I like when companies spend their marketing budgets right 👏🏼👏🏼
Byapari sahab is a great person.
Love u Manoranjan baperi sir
And respect
The time of shadow soumitra chatterjee,s cenema like a major anjan byapari life
हज़ारो सलाम आपको👍
Subhan Allah mashah Allah zindegi kitni kathin hoti he
Good interview, lal salaam....
I love you monoranjan sir ❤
Joy Horichand thakur Joy Guruchand thakur ❤❤
Sukrya ji
Great work
Just love it...
You are the best sir really appreciate you
Where do you live in kolkata sir I wanna meet you please reply ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Book name?
He is so innocent. Hallmark of an artist.
Where is this happening in West Bengal? Where still caste system is practiced? Extremely curious to know.
Old times ,he is talking about , I think, of 60s. Villages still had few zamindari system back then. Society had changed in urban areas but interior Bengal was still quiet regressive. That is why naxal and communist movements grew in Bengal gradually.
Wont deny Casteism has completely been abolished in Bengal, but it is not as extensive as it used to be or adjacent states. Most Bengalies nowadays dont care about Caste much anymore...Not even religion. Some are agnostic, some are atheists and some follow all religions. Caste is irrelevant. That is why you would hardly see caste politics in Bengal nowadays.
वेद जी की बंगाल चुनाव वीडियो के बाद कौन कौन ये वीडियो देख रहा है ll
Brilliant!!
Just salute to you 🖖
Ek rickshawala ko writer bana diya ek soch ne... Wo soch jo kahta har insaan same hai...
बहुत सुंदर बात चित है , आप कि सारे किताब के बारे जनना चाहता हु , मगर कैसे ?
Naseeruddin Sahase request hay ki Monoranjan babu k liye kuch kare.
Bahut aachchha interview.
Jai Bhim
খুব ভাল।
Great, he belongs to the party of JCB or tajmul hossein
Chandal growth like a krishna
Great writer
My favorite people. But Manoranjan babu, I think upstaged Naseeruddin sir in charisma.
Terrific
A Good Heart person with a Pkmkb person
Shandaar
Mr.Monoranjon Byapari I do salute you for your inspiration life long war straggle discrimination racism against humanity. I m proud of you. You are Bangladeshi by born if i m not wrong! Oh brother come back your own country, get back your own yeard.You will get full honour respect and human dignity equal rights and opportunity. As a man and humans person no discrimination of schedule caste.Best of all you will be our Bangladeshi Citizen brother. Thank you again we are really proud of you brother.
He was born in the outskirts of Calcutta in the slums to very poor parents.
Jay bhim manoranjan da aap ko mere pure pariwaar ki aur se salam
👍
♥️♥️
Gem !
রতনে রতন চেনে আর........চেনে কচু।।। কিছু না, এমনি মনে পড়ে গেল আর কি 🥳😀😆😝😛
nice!
After looking the activist.
What is the name of the book?
There's gunpowder in the air
After bioshala
☹️😥😭😭
মনোরঞ্জন বাবু আপনার লেখা বই যদি bollywood তে film বানানো যায় ,তাহলে নতুন record করবে , আর আমরা ওই আশাতে থাকলাম।
Is it from "JCB"? Indeed??
11:14
He is a tmc candidate,of vidhansabha election 2021 in West Bengal.
Yes
Salam monoranjan babu
আপনার সাথে দেখা কোরতে চাই
Unbelievable
Monoranjan dada jindabad
Kitab ka naam toh bata dete 🤦🏿♂️
There's Gunpowder in the Air.
@@bm0204thank you ... maine baad me pata kar li ...lekin in logo ko batana chahiye tha interview me ...
@@v.a.2796 you know his name? google it. You will find all of his books and awards he received. Thanks
So less views. Disappointed 😕
Sorry unaware of this interview for last 5yrs. 99% of Bengals babu culture is still unaware or fake ignorance of this krantikari as he is primary a dalit and doesn't belong to the elitist community.
His one comment haunts me most regarding post-partition refugee crisis - ' Refugees of upper class was rehabilitated under various govt schemes in & around Calcutta,but dalits/lower classes had to settle by their own along sewage canal, by the railway track or was deported to andaman/ chattisgarh refugee camp.
Caste system works everywhere, even in crisis also.
True actors....no stupidity no dikhawaaaa
Entertainer businessman. Reading the novel soon.
I never support him in one thing.... That he talks about his caste.... There is no caste based discrimination in Bengal.... I have never seen such things in Bengal.....
Then you know nothing about the caste system not only in Bengal, but all over India.
@@BestQuotesVault It doesn't mean it will be considered on the basis of anyone's caste...
@@biswajitsen5355 Maybe you are elder than me... But i have seen more than you... And know about India morr than you..... I repeat there is no such castebased discrimination in Bengal as compare to other states...
Caste system in Bengal is very much alive in rural parts of Bengal indeed. Discrimination occurs in major cities also in the name of caste e.g. inter-caste marriage. Families in same caste do not give marriage in other subcaste. From this caste system, an entire religious idea called "Matua" has emerged. Please study properly first.
@@susammanbiswas but right now 'matua' is a vote bank and nothing more than that. They fight among themselves only. If you belong to matua community may I ask you a question? Why do you guys select leader from one particular family? All that family want is power. And what about you guy's citizenship? I think you are already a citizen na ?
কাগজ দেখাবো না.......
তা বলছিলাম..বাংলাদেশ থেকে আসার কি দরকার ছিল?
তোরই বা জন্মানোর কি দরকার ছিল?
Bangladesh theke esechilo to 71 e ekhun tara citizen hoyei gechhe.
JCB ki padhai
akcortin2 i see what you did there