Godspeed You! Black Emperor- Lift Yr. Skinny Fists Like Antennas to Heaven! ALBUM REVIEW
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ต.ค. 2024
- Listen: • Sleep: - Godspeed You!...
Reviewing a favorite of mine in celebration of the end of 2011 and the channel hitting 50K! :-)
Buy this album: amzn.to/1HDHVNQ
theneedledrop.com
bit.ly/tndsupport
bit.ly/TNDTwitter
bit.ly/TNDFacebook
bit.ly/TNDPodcast
theneedledrop.c...
GODSPEED YOU! BLACK EMPEROR- LIFT YR. SKINNY FISTS LIKE ANTENNAS TO HEAVEN! / 2000 / CONSTELLATION / POST-ROCK, CHAMBER MUSIC, EXPERIMENTAL ROCK, NOISE ROCK, AMBIENT MUSIC, DRONE
This review is shorter than any of the songs on the album
It's close to the length of the last song, which is 18 minutes long.
Neel 2000 still shorter
White Supremacist Hate Symbol No wonder you have been fighting Dat Boi for your entire life; you just don't let up.
White Supremacist Hate Symbol We will see Nelson Mandatboi come out of jail in a few months, and there will be a triumphant rebel uprising.
SJW's turned Pepe into a hate symbol.
So.. Which are your 4 favourite songs on this album?
Lmfao
Storm, Static, Sleep, Like Antennas to Heaven....
@Firthy boy Actually you don't. R/woooshorwhateverthefuckitisnobodycareshowmanyosthereare
@Firthy boy you thought you had the last laugh, huh?
Firthy boy no much irony
Godspeed You! Black Emperor
GY!BE
GYBE
GBE
GBE = Glory Boyz Entertainment
Godspeed You! Black Emperor is actually Chief Keef, Lil Reese, and Fredo Santana
O.o
This is the best comment I read in awhile haha
Sometimes youtube comments dont kill your brain cells. Once in a while they blow your mind.
why
***** just answering the questions everyone wants to know
Whenever I listen to this album I feel like I have the duty to tell the world about it
I'm late, but I can understand you 100%. I always try to show it to my close friends and family. But it's true that it's not an accessible album and they usually dismiss it as instrumental music for doing homework at best. I don't tell them, but it really makes me sad that they think that
juan carlos pro
I feel you on that man, people just aren't used to listening to music this huge, sophisticated, and emotionally deep, it's as simple as that unfortunately. Can't show my friends either. :(
juan carlos pro exactly. :( I’m in the same position
couldn’t have said it better myself
@@juancarlosprovenciolameira9326 only one of my friends and one of my teachers understand the rest can't grasp the idea of hope in a world of pessimism or pessimism in a world of hope.
A nav feature would made this album a little better
oh my god
lmao
postity rock ock ock. It really pop pop pops
Could have helped to MGK on there as well
throw DJ Khaled in there. why not
12:29 oh so you're into beautiful dark twisted things
severely underrated comment
OMG
lmaoooooooooooo
he and MBDTF is a perfect tsundere couple I ever seen.
Light 6
"If the world were that bad, why make music for it?" - Anthony Fantano.
I never give likes but this quote is pretty nice
That’s a goddamn tasty quote tho. It’s a phenomenal point.
I’m saving this
They called Coney Island the playground of the world
Coney Allan
They don’t sleep anymore on the beach
There was no place like it in the entire world
I live right next to it. it's not. its shit.
@@RP134579 pretty sure that's not the point
Listened to this thing all the way through while walking home from school. Pretty lenghty walk that wasn't 100% safe but MAN no other piece of music could have fit the situation as well as this thing. Easily one of my favorite albums of all time. Such a moving experience with tons of emotion.
Taimir Gore your like the only good commentator in his comment sections
Your school is pretty damn far away from your home
Some of the samples they took of ranting homeless people on tour are really heart rending. That album is a straight up genius level work of art.
Skramcave represent
@Gabagool they didn't have ubers in 2015 they either had to ride horses or walk
This man does not age. He looks about a year or two younger here than he does now in 2020.
Probably his vegan diet
or maybe he was old already and now looks younger.
Just listened to it. Holy god.
Jackson Coleman/TG Right?
TheScottish Potato front?
TheScottish Potato Yeah
This is a headphones album, for those of you who haven't tried it yet. In other words, I wouldn't try to get into it on the drive home from work or school. It requires time, a quiet room, and headphones or earbuds. And patience. (No, it doesn't require drugs. I think drugs might make it frightening as hell)
I had never listened to or even heard of the album before today, I thought I would play it in the background as I work but as I listened to the first few minutes I completely spaced out. You are so right. It not only is the kind of album that requires time and complete focus but it also deserves all that, it deserves to be heard that way.
@@arunima8138 did u like it
Areenem I’ll answer for him, yes
@@elfakiscave5669 ok McKnight
Areenem I don’t even like the album that much I just had this pfp for years and don’t want to change it, no need to be mean :(
This album is a religious experience
+Sam Shiiv 100% agree with you. It's what I never got from church. I wouldn't be an atheist if religion made me feel like this album.
+Sam Shiiv 100% agree with you. It's what I never got from church. I wouldn't be an atheist if religion made me feel like this album.
+Sam Shiiv i would call it spiritual not religious
So i know this comment is months old but is the amazing grace cover and the bit with the woman talking about seeing God added to make fun of the religion/ ironically or are these guys Christian?
Just curious
+g m o They are mostly Jewish I believe. I also think it's possible to have a spiritual experience without being religious.
I'm an old person who just discovered this album. I don't know what to say about it other than to use a cliched and worn out word: transcendent.
You should check out swans if you haven't heard them. They really are quite similar.
Sigur ros - agaetis byrjun is another ass fucker of an album.
It blew me away
Thats some louder milk
@MrFartboy79 To be honest, it's probably not going to be a regular thing. Only for this week in celebration of 50K. Maybe we'll do it again if the channel ever hits 100K. I know a lot of y'all are into this idea, but my heart just isn't there, really. I love listening to new music. The only reason I'm able to listen to some of these old albums and review 'em is because they're my favorites, ya know? Regularly reviewing requested "classics" just isn't me. It's not the purpose of TND.
First reply
Sorry Anthony but I just don't see you reaching 100K anytime soon
This didn’t age well
i wonder what kind of life MrFartboy79 is living nowdays
"Maybe we'll do it again if the channel ever hits 100K"
good job bro, you did it, 2 million now
This album is awesome. Heard it for the first time while walking to class and I completely spaced out. I feel like I was going to die, but in a good way
i live on a college campus
***** hahahahha
+ImTooAbstract That's a feeling I sometimes get too :)
Most recently, it was "Death is the Road to Awe" by Clint Mansell from The Fountain OST - feels like the death and rebirth of galaxies...
I felt like I was about to die as well.
+ImTooAbstract i was listening to it on a plane, and i got a picture of the plane exploding in slow motion in my head and just smiled like i never smiled before
Hearing that old man talking about coney island was one the saddest and nostalgic speeches I’ve heard from an old man. Made me feel like world is changing and we can’t do anything to stop that.
Now Anthony, you say that this album isn't accessible but I truly found this album extremely easy to get into.
Ben Lauter yeah this was my first foray into post-rock (if you don’t consider spiderland as post-rock) and i loved from the first listen. the first 10 minutes of storm was enough to get me hooked
exactly, I would never understand why people find it hard to get into, it's just so memorable
Yeah, I was sold on it in about 2 minutes.
Sadly it didn’t hit me until my 3rd or 4th listen but when it did it was incredible.
I think the most inaccessible thing about it to a casual audience would be the length of the songs
"If the world were that bad, why make music for it?"
Sounds more like a question for folk punk.
More like music in general was invented cuz of how bad the world is.
I love when your passion starts to spill out the edges of your cool-nerd demeanour.
I totally agree...the first 6 minutes of 'Storm' is something special...!
It's my favorite part of the album for sure!
I haven’t listened to it yet but I haven’t a sneaking feeling that it’s 6 minutes of nothing
@@xavierd725 well ur no fucking fun lmao
@@xavierd725well…
I've known about Godspeed! for years and years, but never really took an interest, because I was always into metal, hardcore, powerviolence, etc, but after watching Anthony Fantano's videos I had to check them out.....so I literally just sat through this whole thing for the very first time....I'm destroyed.
silenthillvictim Glad you're with us, friend.
silenthillvictim That's the only way I can describe it. It's not just awesome, it's truly an overwhelming album.
"Powerviolence"
+Porco-Dio FIlm what?
+Porco-Dio FIlm what?
Please review F#A#Infinity!
10
bump
🚗🔥
❌💁♂️⚙️
@@joelwilcox5424 I get it, good job
@@joelwilcox5424 good reference
my boyfriend introduced this to me while i drove us and his friend back home from the beach last night and didn’t say anything about it, he just put it on and no one said a word through the entirety of “sleep” and i was blown away, he didn’t even know was to put on after we listened to it. it was absolutely magnificent. he mentioned that he was considering adding it to a collaborative playlist we have (he didn’t for some reason), but i’m actually glad now since i don’t think i would have ever given myself the time to sit and give this album a chance. he put it on at such a perfect time, i don’t know, it was so strangely enchanting and i am so thankful i was introduced to this. as fantastic that it is that this album isn’t incredibly well known considering i believe that adds to the experience of listening to it, i wish it got more attention (or maybe it does an i’m just unaware). but this will definitely go down as one of my favorites of all time
Lucky to have that guy for sure
11:31 "And when you penetrate to the most high god, you will believe you are mad. You will believe you've gone insane.."
I don't consider myself to be a religious person at all but this one line chills me to my bones. it makes me imagine -- what if god actually exists despite having lived entire my life without ever being convinced of it? like i'll be lying on my death bed and when i finally pass on, i'll see the face of god and in that one moment before i die, my entire world just falls apart. the amount of resentment, sorrow and guilt that i would feel when i think about how i spent my whole life being unaware of this massive truth. how would my life have differed if i believed it existed? i mean im only human, how could i have known? i would like to think that if there was a god and it wanted me to believed in it, then it would know what i would need to witness to make me believe. but im at the end of my life and i never got a sign. what does that mean? what does that say about me? like "i dont believe it. this can't be! i won't accept this! i MUST be out of my mind!" and i can distrust what im seeing all i want but none of that would change the fact that i am looking at god with my own eyes..
it reminds me of the death of Anton Lavey. -- /watch?v=5sZcUsrbvfI
this is the kind of stuff that goes through my mind when i listen to this album. I've only been able to listen to it two or three times since i discovered it because the sheer gravity of the thoughts that go through my head and the emotions i feel are truly incapacitating. Lift Your Skinny Fists is one of the greatest, most moving pieces of art that i have ever come across.
J. Michael Alamilla “When someone is searching," said Siddhartha, "then it might easily happen that the only thing his eyes still see is that what he searches for, that he is unable to find anything, to let anything enter his mind, because he always thinks of nothing but the object of his search, because he has a goal, because he is obsessed by the goal. Searching means: having a goal. But finding means: being free, being open, having no goal. You, oh venerable one, are perhaps indeed a searcher, because, striving for your goal, there are many things you don't see, which are directly in front of your eyes.”
- Herman Hesse- Siddartha
I can't listen to this album without crying but I still listen to it all the time because I like to cry I find it freeing
I try to think on how to convince you that YES!!! HE IS!.... and he wants that relationship with you. I know that simple statement will make people bash on me for days and write two pages comments explaining me how I'm wrong (or two words, calling me stupid). I'm a fan of Radiohead, Godpeed, Talk Talk and Sigur Rós, and seeing so many people saying that their favorite music is their religion... while, in truth, there is a melody that never fades, that you can only find in silence. Sometimes I tell friends about that... and it happens sometimes that one comes back to me after a few months and tell me : "I never tought that this would happen... but you were right, I found God!" I think... in a way, you gotta be ready to loose everyting to receive everything! God doesn't take anything away, but he gives everything, everything, everything.
How wild, 5 years later and I thought about the exact same things as you did when I heard that part. It's really alternate, is the best word I can think of.
Seriously considering getting the “it is all a dream, a dream in death” tattooed on me
@royercrafter and you are an awesome person who deserves love and happiness. i wish you well, sir. :-)
Ok.
Ok.
Royercrafter was found dead by coronavirus
Ok
Ok.
They don't seep anymore on the beach...
+Jimmy Russels Don't make me cry.
+Killa Luigi They don't sleep anymore, on, on Cony Island
I feel real baaaaad.
"Coney Awland, they called Coney Awland the playground of the world!"
They don't seep indeed. lol
The thing to know about Godspeed is that they go beyond just being a band and feel more like a movement. Seeing them live and meeting the band shows you they have a social desire to awaken people. The last time i saw them was in Seattle 2 years ago and yes they did have a merch table, the bigger thing happening was an anarchist book section. If you love this band, you're probably gravitating towards more than just their music which is amazing in its own right but subconsciously you're embracing your inner disgust with the state and also love of the natural world that's being destroyed whole sale for shiny things.
Wait they're anarchists?? Like I love them because of their music but their political beliefs are also similar to mine?!
@@malcolm_mal2055 Little known fact, GY!BE actually stands for Goldman Yes! Bookchin Excellent
@@joelwilcox5424 oh shit GY!BE WAS CAPITALISM ALL ALONG
@dead dog molester Maybe you just feel threatened by people who are more intellectually and politically astute? Maybe there will be a Red State You Fascist Emperor you can align yourself with when the US goes full on theocracy in 2024! Good thing you were not alive in the 60's when music moved people to protest Vietnam ! So thanks for you comment Julia Child Molester!
@found sounds this. People label godspeed as pretentious and even though i love them i cant disagree based on how obnoxious their fans are.
I cant even express how much i love godspeed. Every time I listen a song from them i still get choked up
there is just no other like Godspeed. they're just...the best. make me cry all the time
They're the only band that consistently gives me the strongest reactions
The "Broken Windows" part of Sleep gets me every time. It's like walking into a creepy ghost town as, one by one, people start to step out from the shadows. Their faces look dirty and joyless, but they still have a small glimmer of hope in their sunken eyes.
The music slowly goes from foreboding to forlorn, and it's one of the most moving moments in music to me.
Could you share the timestamp please
@@barathivaasan5876 the last 10 minutes of it
Cinematic is the best word for this album
The part in "antennas to heaven", which starts around minute 10:10 might have the most beautiful and touching drums i've ever heard. always have to close my eyes at this time of the song...
great review btw
+SuperKingGoofy Same thing at the end of "sleep" of course. they're nearly the same
+SuperKingGoofy Hnng. The end of Sleep gets me every god damned time.
5:30 in the same track also hits different
Listening to this album makes real life feel like walking through a documentary to me.
talussAthner Despite this album being lyrically deficient, I feel like I could write a book explaining what this album might be explaining philosophy, socially, politically, and religiously. If only the mainstream could recognize that too.
you should do it! I would buy like 10 copies. Aphex Twin rules btw
@@Neel-ff4mn They have this way of telling a story through musical noise. Sure albums do that but they take it too the 100% and it's just beautiful
One of the best experiences I've ever seen in music
Seen ??
@@shawnmalone837 He was talking about how sexy Fantano is in the video.
Thank fucking you for introducing me to Swans, I'm gonna have one hell of a fucking adventure going through all of their albums and songs. It's been 2 years since I've gone on a spree like this post-discovery of GYBE. I've been searching for a band just like GYBE for those 2 years.
I've gotten so into Swans since I bought To Be Kind. I consider them to be almost at Beatles level at this point.
Swans are my favourite band ever
Same
I discovered swans through some Napalm death members
And oh boy i love swans so much
Too bad about all the “miscommunication” M. Gira likes to talk about when it comes to his conduct in the studio with certain collaborators.
damn, you hit 50k almost five years ago and now you're chasing 1,000,000
i remember just starting to watch your channel around that time of the year
time flies
this album still gets airplay on my speakers to this day
keep on doing it you're doing it
Anyone else get gitty when they read or hear the words "Lift Yr. Skinny Fists Like Antennas To Heaven!" jeez Godspeed is Top Tier with their Names.
Murdoc Niccals hi murcock
Murdoc Niccals release your album already you muppet
honestly, by the end of the album i wanted to stand on top of a hill with my fists high in the air screaming incoherently
I sort of liked F#A#infinity more but the intro of Storm is brilliant
Signor Pomodoro I agree.
I remember me and a bunch of mates sat around in a living room. We had this album on CD and a decent sound system. We also had candles, a smoke machine and a tonne of ketamine. We turned out the lights. Sat back. The Smoke machine was on full power and it the smoke created an awesome kind of canvas for the ketamine trip to be projected onto. The music provided a fantastic roller coaster of texture and emotion. No one said a word for an hour or so. It was one of the best evenings of my life. I've never quite been able to recapture the meditative intensity of it. It was almost religious. This will always be one of my favourite albums, and GYBE will always be one of my favourite bands.
This sounds amazing
Bro don't fuck with that shit
That album on dxm sounds amazing
Perfect album. I remember seeing them live about 10 years ago. When the spoken word part from "Static" started playing, the crowd went apeshit.
The preacher?
this album is an absolute masterpiece
still loyal to it i see
@@idecanymoretbhfr 😭
7 years later and it's still your pfp. Appreciate the commitment
The ambient part that comes in at 15 minutes in Antennas to heaven is so stunningly beautiful that it cures me every time. This is the best album of all time in my eyes because of the emotions. It's just crushingly sad.
Anthony said he never gives a 10. This wasan unspoken 10.
He's given 3 10's...
what??? when??? which ones???
Death Grips The Money Store, Swans To Be Kind and Kendrick Lamar TPAB
if you go on his rym he has plenty of 5 star albums
WHAT? HE HAS A RYM?? LINK, PLEASE!
I often tend to listen to new albums - especially blind buys - while laying in bed at night. Usually, I fall asleep after like half of it and I get a feeling for it after 2-3 days. Not with this one, though. I did not even dare to fade into sleep. When the first snippet came out of nowhere, I almost shitted my pants. It caught me completely off-guard and from there on, the intensity of the record quite literally made me sweat. It is, indeed, a movie-like album and astonishingly beautiful (in it's own way).
Thanks for the review (or rather some other video, in which you mentioned it, for I am just now, after the mentioned night, watching your review), otherwise I probably would have never experienced this unique stroke of genius.
This is the first time I ever cried to an instrumental. Its just so powerful.
i dont necessarily think of these as apocalyptic albums, but just more like post war, recovery albums. some moments i like to think they are even during the war, or right beside it at least.
Been a fan of this album since I was 19/20. I'm 34 as of yesterday. I love this review and feel it is spot on. I remember being a young kid and my job took me to rural florida. I listened to the second half of "skinny fists" as I drove around and it changed my life. Many of GYBE's songs have had that impact at some time or another. Yet this was especially beautiful to me. I'm a very mood music oriented person. Driving through a foreign territory as a young impressionable person with this heart achingly beautiful album playing will always be a favorite memory of mine.
how did u find it back then? you had it on an ipod? or bought a cd?
@@solartea_ I had a friend introduce me to the band Sigur Ros and fell totally in love. While researching similar bands online, I heard GYBE mentioned several times. Then I saw the movie 28 days later, heard East Hastings and immediately bought the album, then subsequent albums. Wish I could go back and relive the music with virgin ears all over again 😁
This must've been such a chore to mix and master with how long and diverse this record is
one of my fav videos on YT. you feel the fandom in his voice and body language for this music, and I kinda miss this era of theneedledrop. It was so nice discovering someone who took the time to praise this album the way he did. It's one of my favorite records too. I don't think enough good things can be said of it.
I specifically and instantly became a GY!BE fan at the beginning of watching 28 Days Later. That initial crescendo coupled with the pan out of the city was mind blowing. I turned to my roommate in the theater, and he was like, "why are you crying man?" I said "Who the fuck was that band that just played that track?"
As mentioned in this review: soundtrack to an apocalypse...
man, i really need to check out gy!be if they can move someone to tears just like that
Dan Terlizzi Seriously do that, and start with this album. The part in the review he talked about the woman talking about god moved me to tears the first time I heard it, and will forever haunt me every time I listen to it again.
Super late I know but I just wanted to say that’s a fucking awesome way to discover the band
i'm jealous of this album. i wont ever be able to make something like this and it PISSES ME OFF
did u do it yet?
LOL, this video was made at 50k subs.
Today, there are 2.72 MILLION.
Congrats, Anthony. Been with you the whole way, and am happy you're still around.
Awww, needledrop is in love.
I first listened to Storm in an instrumental music playlist I had found on Spotify, and it remained in my daily playlist for years, surviving all the cleanings and times I removed songs from my playlist. It wasn't until two years later that I decided to listen to the whole album, and then the whole band and now it's my favorite band of all time
Absolutely love this record! If it weren't for this video, I probably wouldn't have heard of this album, or I would've heard it way way later at the least. This is a great review for one of my favorite albums in the post-rock genre. Everybody should absolutely check the record out!
GYBE has been my favorite band since 1999. I saw them live in 2003 and it was the greatest concert I've ever seen. Until I watched your review of this album I never heard the second movement of the first song as a version of "Amazing Grace." The fact that 14 years later I can still find new things about GYBE's music is a testament to their artistry. Wow.
No other album can make me feel motivated, anxious, calm, and depressed such as this one.
Seriously, this album makes me feel every emotion ever
Thank you for introducing me to this. Skinny Fists has become my favorite album ever. No matter how often I listen to it, it never ceases to amaze me. Sleep is absolute musical perfection in my eyes.
I like F#A# infinity CD version more.
+BenjamminClark Better than the LP version or better than LYSF?
+chris ford Both imo
Killmetbh What are the differences between the vinyl and CD versions of F#A#?
***** Providence
what the fuck
hearing "when 2012 starts" in 2023 feels unreal
It's now 2024. 😢
LET'S ARGUE: Album Covers with hands on it are always good.
The Big Day has entered the chat
@@vladimirvich468 "Hands" not a Hand.
Any other exemples? I can only think of Master Of Puppets
@@kioro4221 RTJ
St. Anger?
You are a brilliant reviewer man ! That's difficult to do...
This is certainly among my favourite records of its kind. At it's best I think it ranks among perhaps one of my favourite albums in popular music. The ending of Antennas to Heaven is as perfect as it gets.
i played this album when i was playing Minecraft , on god, one of the best experiences in my life u guys should try!
I play this song while playin farming sim 19
Bro I did the same with Allelujah! Don't Bend Ascend
Fighting creepers and skeletons with mladic in the background is so epic
imo the best album of all time.
Same.
F# is just as good if not better imo
@@Userrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr.r And Slow Riot for New Zero Kanada is EVEN better! Imho obviously ;)
Nice job hitting 50k Anthony! Keep up the good work.
Whenever someone older than 35 years calls these kind of albums boring or "not real music" I assume their favorite band is Led Zeppelin or Queen, and most of the time I end up guessing right.
Uh huh. I'm not saying queen are bad but they are the most entry level rock band of all time
@@reganpetty8803 same with led zeppelin
@@davidw9736 not really
@@haywoodjblome4768 yes really.
@@polkanietzsche5016 Queen are entry level because of their music and popularity. Led zeppelin are only entry level because of their popularity. They're less accessible than 95% of bands with the similar popularity
Is this a 10/10. I think this is a 10/10
@@cbrad_edits what's that album?
It is
8 years later and this man has not changed one bit
Hey Anthony, can you please review F#A# infinity by Godspeed You! Black Emperor (CD Version with East Hastings) , Soundtracks for the blind by Swans, The earth is not a cold dead place by Explosions in the sky anddddd, Spiderland by Slint? I'd be very interested as to hear your opinion on these albums. And did you review Mogwai young team? if not I would like tp hear your opinion on that one too. Thanks.
Listened to this album on a road trip to my college for the 1st time. One of the greatest experiences of my life.
@brazilianEYEreportU i don't feel like it--especially since you had some mean words to say there. :-P i hope you have a nice day, man. i love you. stay nice, awesome, friendly. *hugs hugs hugs*
*hugs hugs hugs*
The end of sleep is the most beautiful thing I’ve ever heard
good job on mentioning the part in static with the whole slowed down voice. that part always hits me so hard when i listen to it.
"To be Kind - Swans" is like a more pop-esc nu-metal-esc version of this album.
SuperDuck lol'd
U wot m8
You can't really draw comparisons between those two albums, since they are different in so many ways, maybe some older swans stuff..
nice meme
+SuperDuck esque u melon
Finland. It's summer. I'm commuting to work at 4 a.m and the sun is rising. It's a cool 12 degrees celcius and "Yr Skinny Fists" is playing from beginning to end.
That feeling is how I'd review the album.
It's a decade on and this still sounds like the perfect setting to listen to this album.
The funny thing is that at the time of this review, LYSFLATH was about as old as MBDTF is now
that’s so weird to think about
So I gotta admit: this album hooked me. On paper, it's not my cup of tea: 4 tracks, over 20 minutes each, mostly instrumental, pretty esoteric, and a slow, slow burn.
But once it hit... man. It got me.
Absolutely wonderful review for this amazing album... Subscribed!
Shu Mai!
Yeah okay buddy
I'm glad you decided to review your favorites.
As I'm one of I'm sure hundreds of people who said you should somewhere down the line of your videos.
theneedledrop-Forever
this review finally made me subscribe to you. we are kindred spirits after all
On static, the crescendo about halfway where those violins and screeching guitars is fucking insane. The transition from that crescendo led in by a snare drum that brings the menacing violin melody to the front may be the most eerie/badass pieces of music created.
More of an F#A#Infinity guy myself...and mostly because of Dead Flag Blues
But this was my GY!BE introduction.
KenzieM Same. That album is overwhelming even though I love this album so much I own it on vinyl.
This review does the album so much justice, thank you Fantano!
I don't listen to this album that much, like once a year or so, but every time I listen to it, it's a different experience, it just keep getting better and better. It's a masterpiece.
Saw your other video about top depressing albums or something like that, so I thought why not, and I saw you talking about this album so I decided to listen to a bit of it, and as I got through the first half of the album I thought this is AWESOME, being a fan of bands like Pink Floyd and Joy Division I really enjoyed it now I have it on vinyl along with another one of their albums, so just want to say cheers for introducing this to me.
Their older stuff (this album and previous ones) had better use of samples and were darker. Their new music is good but not as great as this one, but it's nice they're still making music.
I think I can shorten this review to just 10 of Fantano's favourite words, all of which he uses religiously on every single GYBE and Swans album review
Instrumentation
Segway
Interlude
Unsettling
Dropped
Soundscape
Ambient
Transition
Cinematic
Uplifting
If anyone's aware of an LP by one of these bands where he hasn't used at least seven of these words I'll die of shock
Does anyone see "Storm" as the soundtrack to the Big Bang and the subsequent formation of the current state of the Earth? Like right when Gathering Storm starts, we just see a silhouette of the Earth against the sun. Not a lush green earth but a molten one. As the song progresses we see the past 4.6 billion years on fast forward, oceans forming, mountains surging, rains beckoning. Let me know what you feeling. love u
caseystu123 Feeling exactly the same way, a lot of people tend to refere to that part as of the birth of a person/childhood but I feel more like antony as it being more wide of a concept with the begin and the ending of the world. Especially with storm I can't help but think of the birth of life and nature on the planet rather than something on a small scale
caseystu123 eh. Personally, albums like laughing stock or f#a# are more aesthetically straight forward and my mind builds intense imagery because of it. Lift your skinny fists is not that uplifting and not that dark, and while the samples and random effects and changes(especially on the last song) are interesting in themselves, the whole point of the album(the epic, BIG feeling) is awkward due to the non effect and sample covered parts being pretty too plain. I'm always confused what too feel about this album as a whole. When I heard this album at the beginning of my music journey it was everything. But 2000 albums later(Thank you RYM) it's mildly unique at best.
One of the greatest reviews i've ever heard from one of my all-time favorite albums. Thank you
Holy fucking shit. This is an album that’s been on my list of listens and I’ve been putting it off to keep up with new music and, I’m not familiar with a lot of Post Rock stuff.
This is one of the most intensely emotional listening experiences I’ve ever had. I’ve just sat staring at my floor on the dark and I know this seems corny but, I felt like I couldn’t even blink. This is most definitely deserving of a stamp of approval and then some.
Came up on my feed and reminded me how good this album is, recently got a record player and building up my collection, this will be next on the list
Same! Just ordered a copy
Trout Mask Replica is indulgent? The only indulgence is that Captain Beefheart indulged the world to share his amazing music and visual art with the world for 30+ years.
He also physically and mentally abused his band while holding them hostage
Greg Lytle t. Scaruffi
Greg Lytle the good captain was insane. I love and adore his work and counterparts but he was certifiable.
What's wrong with indulgent?
Bittergrapefruit But everyone still cares about them...and he died they are all still living. So who is really the winner lol
I need this entire discography to become more popular. Godspeed You! Black Emperor is not impossible but definitely a difficult listen, but it is so rewarding, I almost hate spoiling it for people. Sleep's finale is the single most emotionally moving musical piece I've ever heard in my life, at least from Rock/symphonic, however you'd classify this. I hope Fantano also reviews Yanqui UXO one day. I miss his classic reviews for this.
hi, 2022 here. This is a 10 y’all
Thank you for this. This album and band has been very important to me in my past and I feel like I've disconnected from listening to music like this. And i've gotten better headphones since then...
I remember when this came out and being really happy that the /mu/tant shitposting review guy's channel was blowing up. Figured you would peak around 100k and eventually get burned out and stop posting reviews. Glad I was wrong.
Hey man, thank you for sparking my interest in this band with thos Review, i've had some great moments with them since :)
Now storm is one of my all time favorite peaces of music :)
Anybody else who feels like "The Sound" from Swans Soundtracks for the Blind is like a precurser to Storm?
Fuck this album; this changed my whole perception of 'good music'. For the good or the worse - mostly good.
Great review. Appreciated the bit regarding accessibility (most other reviews make it sound like you can just pick it up and insta-like it). I had to revisit this album several times over the course of years before I really loved it, but it's worth that effort. I do wish you'd said a little about the very last few minutes of the album -- so sublime.