วีดีโอ

love the analysis btw keep going i love this content

characters that have almost nothing to do with one another like renji and nnoitora are written to have almost the same arc over and over. constantly trying to obtain the moon only to be powerless. its insane writing

Yuji during the series becomes more competent and less foolish

ive learned to respect this side of the argument, i just hard disagree because theres no reasonable person that would actively acknowledge a killer is in the house but still unlock the doors like what yuji did. thanks for the comment, i agree with your other takes abt world building and his development

Also, I dont really blame your behavior that much, i did see your back and forth with some of the comments below. Yeah, they're annoying to argue with. And I'm saying this as someone who has been arguing with these people for a very long time. To the point, you just dont feel like arguing with them, and just thinking that they're mindless sheep. Cause they act all the same. Tho, I dont really want to side with AoT haters, even though I do understand them, some of the points they make, just make them seem no better than the defenders. Its a whole ah war going on lmao. It is rather ironic though, that I want to move on from Attack on Titan, but no matter how much videos of other things i try to watch, do other activities, etc. I just keep have something that brings me back, to AoT, and having myself argue with Ending Defenders.

the point is that its very convenient that Falco just gets a flying-type of titan. And is able to use his titan transformation for a rather long time. And on that very same topic, how other characters have an infinite about of stamina and blades.

Annie said herself that on Marley they made many experiments giving her to drink many different things to give her new abilities (such as the hardening and the ability to call pure titans), we even saw eren obtains his hardening skill by drinking some liquid kept by the reiss family. So what's so strange that falco gets some beastly ability by drinking Zeke's spinal fluid? Moreover it's shown that the beast titan gets his shape by some animal that has some meaning to them, Zeke has a monkey toy, Xavier's son had a goat toy. We see in the first scene where falco is introduced looking at a bird wishing he could fly away from the war. So it makes completely sense

no. in chapter 93 the military commanders of marley all agree that they dont have any titans with wings. in the video, i ask why does marley not know that there WAS a titan with wings. this is straight up impossible. to think that the eldian empire who largely fought marely had a titan with wings and that marley let this information be lost to time is BEYOND a stretch of the imagination. nobody besides falco has been able to see deep far memories about past titans as well. making it even more of a contrived point. if falco was always intended to be a bird titan. isayama shouldve integrated it a lot more naturally without causing world building issues

eren in his own head and secret conversations said he waa going to 100% rumble. he also wanted to protect the island. how are these consistent if he didnt do that

@@dekuopioids The 100% declaration could've been a small mistake, but he def did protect the island. That was the purpose of the rumbling in it of itself

@ he didn’t save eldia and he didn’t end the cycle of hatred (things intimately linked). these are also the things he says out loud and in his head as what he wants to do

@Abraham-yf2sd And he keeps them safe by... leaving them to their own hands after killing 80% of the population, where the remaining survivors could have very well just ignored Armin's speech (again, Armin's speech never worked, that im aware of) and killed them all. Him going all out, would have guaranteed their safety. He does not act like himself. And i just dont understand how people can look at Eren and say "Yeah thats him alright." And yeah, but he also didn't say that Eren said that he wanted to destroy the cycle of hatred. He stated that Eren didn't save Eldia. And he didnt end the cycle of hatred. He is talking about his actions, not about what he said. And he was referring about him saving the island / his friends. The cycle of hatred is tied in on this (i assume), because him leaving anyone alive, will bring the cycle of hatred, in which, his friends would not be safe. His original plan was to do a full scale rumbling, and then acts like 80% was his plan all along, which doesnt even really make sense (referring about the latter not the former).

@Abraham-yf2sd this is why i cant take anything half of u guys say seriously. "eren never said he wanted to destroy the cycle of hatred". eren explicitly stated this in chapter 130, proving you once again to be categorically, objectively, and scientifically wrong. please stop commenting especially this fucking nonsense

i do not. some of my favorite stories have undeniable holes but with aot (a plot driven series), having plot holes so deeply woven into the core concepts of the series, kills it. its like if roger was never the one to find the one piece or something

I didnt misunderstand anything in this video. If you have a different “interpretation” that is not me misunderstanding. Having a plot driven series end with loose mechanics and things not being fully explained is textbook bad writing so thanks for conceding that. Every single plot hole i mention, i point out verifiable contradictions and or logical discrepancies. Nice try tho! Ik people with cat pfps usually dont have an iq above 40 so thank your neurodivergence for allowing you to get this far

@@dekuopioids "Has a ton of plotholes" "Is terribly written" Like I get it man, it is good idea to get viewers with a lousy ragebait but come on. If you watch the series or read the manga objectively, this cannot be a real conclusion. "I didnt misunderstand anything in this video" Bro, how bout be responsible of your points and ask what u misunderstood?? For example, Zeke didn't start the rumbling, Eren did. Zeke was required for Eren to use the founder, since he needed to touch royal blood, which Zeke had through Dina. That's pretty simple and well displayed through the show. U could argue that what happened to Zeke after that was a bit weird with the rules of the universe but u clearly misunderstood so please... Or for example in the first one, how do we know that Armin is familiar how the time is passing in the paths? I think Ymir captured him there just keep him from blowing up Eren, so I think time passed normally then. Like the writing can be viewed with critical pov and I do not think the writing is 100% perfect but why should it be? Is there any other piece of fiction that is 100% perfectly written with 0 plot holes? And would it be better if the series gave u 100% of the answers all the time and nothing to work for yourself? Like I appreciate different opinions and not just jumping on a glazetrain but attacking ur viewer and insulting them doesn't make u look very good :D

After reading a few of the other comments, where you boast that ur commenters "could never win a debate", more insults and glazing people who agree with you... Like my man. Hating on people with differing opinions and arguing/"debating" like a 10 year old just shoutting "headcanon" and shit u know that is the very definition of poor argumentation. And do you always take everything that one character in a big series say as 100% the truth? Like I get that Kenny is saying in S3 that powers of the titans do not work on Ackers and that but does he know everything and does that inevitable mean that Mikasa would not hear Eren in the paths? May not be the most solid point but I just wanted to loosen this way of thinking a bit, like this story is pretty complex and not every character saying something means its 100% true?? And before you say that is lazy writing or something, that is a great way of making a story more deep and interesting, used in many great and valued pieces, Fire and Blood by Martin etc. So yeah if Connie in S2 thinks Reiner is a good guy that necessarily does not mean he is.

@@dekuopioids this is why neither you or your channel will ever amount to anything great. Not with that childish attitude at least, even less with your ridiculous opinions. I suggest you try and become a more respectable figure, rather than someone who will be mocked for their lunacy.

@@dekuopioids never gonna amount to anything great with that attitude.

like what. i misunderstand the fact that paths was retconned? i misunderstand the fact grisiha had zero reason to give the founder to eren? i misunderstand the fact that historia's baby had no plot relevance?

if you genuinely think historia's baby was a red herring so people could not guess the ending of the series, genuinely never ever ever ever ever ever ever talk about attack on titan or any other manga

@@dekuopioidsi actually understand the writing unlike you lmao, im saying thats WHY he wrote it like that. Not the sole purpose of Historia’s baby being written. It serves as a new beginning for Historia

“I understand the writing unlike you” “Historia’s baby was a red herring so people wouldnt guess the ending” you dont know what youre talking about, you dont understand basic storytelling, and you could NEVER beat anyone in a debate

"well knit story" tell me why grishia gave eren the founder

@dekuopioids first of all thnx for asking, this allowing for a conversation to start. And to answer you, in short grisha's 13 year term is almost over and he doesn't have the drive or means to use it as shown in previous scene. And in long form, He's kinda done with everything by that point. As in making peace with his past hence why he aborts his mission earlier. But then eren slowly keeps showing him glimpses of future (cause zeke took him into paths) then at Chapel he literally re ignited grisha's trauma that he buried. And by showing him only glimpses about his wife Carla eren had leverage over his dad. Basically eren almost blackmailed/ manipulated grisha into doing it.

alright. thanks for headcanoning a bunch of stuff. chapter 131 page 39 zeke explicitly states and rationalizes that eren showed grishia something that would persuade him into giving eren the founder. eren confirms this by saying he was delighted in the sight he saw FROM grishia's memory which is the reason why grishia fed himself to eren. not to be rude but stop ignoring the story to bridge gaps inside of it. ts is an oxymoron

@@dekuopioids are you saying eren was delighted or was it grisha. Because no one there is feeling delighted. Grisha is clinging on to the hope of safety, that eren provided through showing him glimpses of future or rather past (cause the ep1 wall breach already happened by that point ), and did as he was asked to (taking founder and ending the royals). He doubts it after coming out of the chapel and sees zeke while warning him and saying sorry. Later we can see in ep 2/3 of anime that grisha is riding a horse cart(?) back while wondering if carla and eren are safe.

And here is the genius writing of Isayama. First time watchers know carla is dead and listening to grisha words where he wonders his wife and son are safe, they assume "poor soul he doesn't know his wife's dead yet". But upon seeing this episode you find eren (fake) promises grisha safety of his family if he does the deed of ending the royals but still can't trust eren, hence why he wonders that question. See, here we can see even after making a full circle trip through the show, girsha ends up with same feelings but in a different context.

idk big dawg, if i say, they literally came back but armins explosion killed them whats ur response? left vague and nonsensical u can basically say whatever you want

@ idk man I'm not thinking too deep about it, it's entertainment - maybe you have a point, and I'm sure you do, but I'm not gonna ruin my experience watching it tho bc I still thoroughly enjoyed it, despite the average ending.

eren stated thr founders power allows him to see the future AND the founder has all the abilities of all titans

@@dekuopioids no he didnt. you are wrong on this lol

​@@dekuopioidsactivating the founder made all titan memories accessible to him all at once. Since Eren held both the Attack Titan AND Founder he got flooded with future memories too. As far as we know, the only other person to hold both Founder and Attack is Ymir

​​@@dekuopioids stupid ahh. All your points say "I can't make any critical thinking without the story outright confirming it and explaining it like im 5 years old, also, if I don't agree with it I'll ignore it and act like it makes no sense.

chapter 139 lmao. did u not read the story?

Righttt

also a few more for #4 it is stated that you can create anything in paths that could also include humans, #8 Berthold controlled his titan on the first try it is stated by Reiner, #12 the founding titan is not 4D Ymir specifically is and since Ymir was "freed" by Eren he became 4d that's how i think about it, #13 not a plot hole tbh 😭

a good portions of these are interpretations or headcanons to substantiate ur claim that they arent all plot holes. which is cool ig, but still indicative of lazy writing -even if ackermans are connected to paths (cant prove it), mikasa should not have the power of the titans work on her. -this a headcanon, u cant prove this as well cant prove that zeke dying WOULDNT stop the rumbling if ymir and eren didnt orchestrate it that way -historia’s pregnancy is a dropped plot thread that leaves holes in the story with multiple characters inclusions. -headcanon as well. i specifically showed a panel of eren and armins colossal looking the exact same while presenting a through line of sizes to make the argument. frankly put, what u said makes no sense.

creating humans in paths. u want me to believe armin, zeke, and ymir were somehow sculpting grisha’s cock in order to stop the rumbling. makes sense. i could just not remember that, if that bertolt statement is true however bertolt is extraordinarily competent and we cant use an exception to justify others breaking the rule. 13 is frankly just me talking abt all the nonsense concerning others seeing dead people. to actually explain, marco is a pivotal point for jeans character and denying that assertion to fuel cheap emotion bait with sasha is a gap for jeans overall character. the same way historia’s baby not being plot relevant is also a plot hole

@@dekuopioids Ackermans are genetically modified eldians to guard the king this proves that they are connected to paths, the only thing that doesnt affect them is the memory wipe/ modification. 2. Bringing back humans in the paths is really not far fetched since its a space that transcends time and space. 3. well falco could also be an exception its more plot conveniency than a plot hole because it isnt the first time someone masters it 1st try (Reiner stated this after ymir ate marcel to annie. cant remember the specific chapter)

i try to limit the negativity. like 2 videos before one covering bad writing

@@dekuopioids I understand

nice sarcasm

@shrihanyt what sarcasm? I'm dead serious

@ I recommend visiting a mental hospital

@@Lord_Vanns yea the mental hospital is needed

@@Awesomedog1021 For what exactly? You guys just don't value your time and it shows. Have you ever thought about how long you watched and read a series for and what else you could've been doing with that time? Of course, I won't deny I chose to watch the series. However, what's the point if by the end you feel like you wasted that time? That's my problem with AOT. Similar to a relationship, you spend years with someone and then they leave you for someone else. You're gonna feel like you wasted your time and that's the issue.

i will one day (definitely not)

pretty colors, flowery words, and characters laughing and smiling