- 846
- 1 142 608
Doctrinal Watchdog (Active)
เข้าร่วมเมื่อ 7 พ.ย. 2019
The Doctrinal Watchdog Channel 🌍👎 - ✝️👍The purpose of this channel is to rescue people from false teachers. Not everyone we make a video about however is a false teacher. We also do things (including polls) to generation theological discussion. Please note, as of 2/10/2022 (because we were locked out of our main channel with 17k subs) this is the active Doctrinal Watchdog Channel / was formerly the Doctrinal Watchdog backup channel. This channel is dedicated to discernment and should be balanced with the other spiritual gifts. We hope all of our supporters are part of a local Bible believing church that preaches verse by verse through the Scriptures. Love God. Love others. Warn others. Jesus is Lord. Amen.
Mike Winger Affirms Joel Osteen & Todd White as Brothers - Ruslan Does Conference w/ Osteen
This is for the Mike Winger fans who claimed we were lying! No wonder Ruslan KD was so happy Mike went soft on Osteen, its because Ruslan did a conference with him!! SMH!!! In our recent video we showed Ruslan and Winger talking about how prosperity preacher Joel Osteen is NOT a wolf, because of how gentile Mike is, calling Osteen a brother in Christ, because of that Ruslan called Mike "the gold standard of discernment." That is not true when Mike refuses to call Osteen, Todd White or Bill Johnson a wolf. Will he criticize them? Yes, but only as erring brothers, anyway a few Winger fanboys came on our channel and slandered the Doctrinal Watchdog saying we were lying and that Mike never said that Joel Osteen is a brother. Yes he did and this video is additional proof! We'll take that apology now! smh
Hopefully someone else like @JustinPetersMin or @Protestia will pick up this story to add pressure on Mike Winger to recant. If you didn't see Mike & Ruslan's recent podcast from 11/2024 you must watch it here: th-cam.com/video/S6M6fkYLFmg/w-d-xo.html
Special appearance in this video by Ray Fava @evangelicaldarkweb
Bro, you could do a video on this subject, why Mike won't call Joel a wolf and how Mike still defends Todd White as a brother even after Justin Peters total expose on his fake leg lengthening scam. Thanks for all you do!
Hopefully someone else like @JustinPetersMin or @Protestia will pick up this story to add pressure on Mike Winger to recant. If you didn't see Mike & Ruslan's recent podcast from 11/2024 you must watch it here: th-cam.com/video/S6M6fkYLFmg/w-d-xo.html
Special appearance in this video by Ray Fava @evangelicaldarkweb
Bro, you could do a video on this subject, why Mike won't call Joel a wolf and how Mike still defends Todd White as a brother even after Justin Peters total expose on his fake leg lengthening scam. Thanks for all you do!
มุมมอง: 311
วีดีโอ
Joel Osteen is NOT a Wolf! Mike Winger & Ruslan Double Down in New Podcast - "Osteen is a brother"
มุมมอง 1.2K2 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
A new podcast dropped in November 2024 where Ruslan KD trashes discernment ministries in order to praise Mike Winger as the "gold standard" of discernment. @JustinPetersMin would you be willing to try and talk sense with Mike Winger, he won't listen to us? Also, here is a video of Mike Winger saying real prophecy and real healing are coming out of Bethel Church - th-cam.com/video/X7tZE9ZwZIc/w-...
Professing Christian Rep. Mike Johnson bows to the Trans Agenda
มุมมอง 38312 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
U.S. House of Representatives Mike Johnson claims to be a Southern Baptist. JD Greear would be proud!
Shut down small churches and give the money to people like me! Andy Stanley & Russell Moore
มุมมอง 2.3K21 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
Andy Stanley calls people who attend small churches selfish - th-cam.com/video/ARWmkIR8qlw/w-d-xo.html
Cru puts out statement mourning Harris loss - Trump victory triggers leadership
มุมมอง 347วันที่ผ่านมา
Campus Crusade for Christ has just put out a statement confirming they are actually a left wing progressive organization. How did they do this? By putting out a secret woke statement to their Bi Poc staff. In doing this Cru went full libtard!
Andy Stanley attacks Christians who attend small churches - U R Selfish & don't care about your kids
มุมมอง 2.2Kวันที่ผ่านมา
Andy Stanley does not teach the Bible. He teaches his own half baked business strategy as well as his opinion. In this clip his true opinions leak out as he shows his contempt for the average Christian who attends a small church. All the statistics show most Christians attend smaller churches, Andy has some harsh words for you - YOU DON'T CARE ABOUT YOUR KIDS BECAUSE YOU ARE A SELFISH TERRIBLE ...
Billy Graham Granddaughter Jezebel Duford Promotes Kamala Harris as the "Pro Family" Candidate - SMH
มุมมอง 293วันที่ผ่านมา
When you turn on fake news you expect to be lied to, this is just another example of the propaganda fake Christians and fake journalists are spreading as they try and turn the country Communist as they tried to force feed us that Marxist Karmela Harris. They call it Democracy even though Harris didn't win the primary, nor did voters get a say to put her on the Democrat Party ticket.
Homewrecker! Mistress of Steve Lawson EXPOSED!
มุมมอง 7Kวันที่ผ่านมา
Here are some pics of her posted by Grace Community Church & Masters Seminary. Lawson is actually with her in one of the pics! Nobody questioned why this young girl was hanging out with Lawson while his wife wasn't around? Come on guys, you need to do better! Thanks to Ray from Evangelical Dark Web for breaking the story!
The podcast clip that broke the story about Lawson not being pastor / member of Trinity Bible Church
มุมมอง 2.3K14 วันที่ผ่านมา
The "IN ALL WISDOM" Podcast reveals that the man you thought was a top pastor wasn't even a member of a local church! Lawson had time for his mistress but not time to spend with God's people.
God is groaning over Trump victory, we should also - Moore, French & Chang Lamenting Harris loss
มุมมอง 42014 วันที่ผ่านมา
The 3 amigos are lamenting over the Trump victory, according to them God is very sad and therefore all Christians must be sad with God that Karmella Harris loss.
David Platt on LGBT, says straight people are just as bad for watching TV, Romans 1 misunderstood
มุมมอง 1.2K21 วันที่ผ่านมา
We checked out David Platt's TH-cam channel titled "Radical" we found Sam Allberry saying that God is not anti gay along with this nugget from the corrupt pastor of McLean Bible Church shaming straight people, saying Romans 1 isn't really about homosexuality, straight people are just as bad and probably worse, after all you watch sitcoms and commercials with women so that is somehow equal to tw...
Alistair Begg teams up w/ David Platt for woke TGC conference
มุมมอง 2.3K21 วันที่ผ่านมา
The Gospel Coalition was founded by registered Democrat operative Tim Keller - www.thegospelcoalition.org/article/tgc25-conference-announcement/
The "YOU'RE AMAZING GOSPEL" 🤦 Dr. Michael Brown Affirms Arch Heretic Todd White
มุมมอง 45321 วันที่ผ่านมา
Watch as Michael Brown feeds Todd White the answers as he tries to "Brown-Wash" this man's heresy, teaching that the true way to preach "the gospel" is to tell people how amazing they are! Of course Jesus and the apostles preached the opposite.
SBC Megachurch does dance routine with mummies & corpses for worship service
มุมมอง 39521 วันที่ผ่านมา
Church by the Glades is a SBC Megachurch. The SBC is also the organization that helped David Platt take over McClean Bible Church. Platt and his cronies then funneled millions out of the coffers of MBC into the SBC and also another 600k into Platt's own fraud organization "Radical". At this point the corruption of the SBC is worse than the Scribes and Pharisees! Now they have dead people on sta...
David Platt & The D.E.I. Agenda (Diversity Equity and Inclusion)
มุมมอง 2.5K28 วันที่ผ่านมา
David Platt & The D.E.I. Agenda (Diversity Equity and Inclusion)
Dr. James White Exposed as a Failed Watchman on the Wall? Affirms ministry of Dr. Michael Brown
มุมมอง 3.4Kหลายเดือนก่อน
Dr. James White Exposed as a Failed Watchman on the Wall? Affirms ministry of Dr. Michael Brown
Todd White claims he flew at Benny Hinn crusade / Chairs Levitated
มุมมอง 1.7Kหลายเดือนก่อน
Todd White claims he flew at Benny Hinn crusade / Chairs Levitated
Brown affirms White in violation of 2 John 9-11
มุมมอง 1.5Kหลายเดือนก่อน
Brown affirms White in violation of 2 John 9-11
Michael Brown buys into heretic Todd White & his leg lengthening scam
มุมมอง 418หลายเดือนก่อน
Michael Brown buys into heretic Todd White & his leg lengthening scam
Eric Metaxas endorses Drag Queens / Condemns pastors who don't preach what he wants them to preach.
มุมมอง 407หลายเดือนก่อน
Eric Metaxas endorses Drag Queens / Condemns pastors who don't preach what he wants them to preach.
Billy Graham's grandson swears & uses God's name in vain in profanity laced "Sermon"
มุมมอง 2.9Kหลายเดือนก่อน
Billy Graham's grandson swears & uses God's name in vain in profanity laced "Sermon"
Russell Moore’s Pastor, Ray Ortlund, Publicly Endorses Kamala Harris for President
มุมมอง 425หลายเดือนก่อน
Russell Moore’s Pastor, Ray Ortlund, Publicly Endorses Kamala Harris for President
Shocking Details of the Steve Lawson adultery scandal
มุมมอง 9Kหลายเดือนก่อน
Shocking Details of the Steve Lawson adultery scandal
Steve Lawson preaches on Adultery for final sermon - compares himself to John the Baptist?
มุมมอง 5K2 หลายเดือนก่อน
Steve Lawson preaches on Adultery for final sermon - compares himself to John the Baptist?
Biblical & Christlike BIG DIFFERENCE says Andy Stanley
มุมมอง 9142 หลายเดือนก่อน
Biblical & Christlike BIG DIFFERENCE says Andy Stanley
Adultery? Steve Lawson Removed from Pastoral Ministry Due to Inappropriate Relationship w/ Woman
มุมมอง 9K2 หลายเดือนก่อน
Adultery? Steve Lawson Removed from Pastoral Ministry Due to Inappropriate Relationship w/ Woman
Cessationists are the opposite extreme of Paula White?
มุมมอง 4732 หลายเดือนก่อน
Cessationists are the opposite extreme of Paula White?
TGC Board Member says Jesus gave up His rights therefore we should give up 2nd Amendment
มุมมอง 2842 หลายเดือนก่อน
TGC Board Member says Jesus gave up His rights therefore we should give up 2nd Amendment
Alistair Begg Did Not Finish Well / Steps Down as Pastor w/ No Repentance of "Gay Marriage" Advice
มุมมอง 1.1K2 หลายเดือนก่อน
Alistair Begg Did Not Finish Well / Steps Down as Pastor w/ No Repentance of "Gay Marriage" Advice
Pentecostal Steph Curry endorses Kamala mainly so women can abort their babies
มุมมอง 2662 หลายเดือนก่อน
Pentecostal Steph Curry endorses Kamala mainly so women can abort their babies
Watch-doggin for the wrong side man 😅 Mike Winger DID call out Joel Osteen for what disqualifies him from being in leadership - that's the key here!
Mike Winger is worse than Joel Osreen ! Mike Winger & Joel Osteen are brothers in antichrist. They deceive people who do not read , believe , understand , and obey the bible.
🙄 Wow, what a delusional clown!
They are both consistent with Protestantism, (no Catholicism)... Believers in Progressive and Final Justification, what so you expect?
"Im gonna criticize the teachings, but im not gonna call out call him a false brother because of those things. Maybe im wrong, but id rather air on the side of grace when it comes to trying to guess to whether other people are really saved so I treat him like a brother." - Mike Winger I feel like yall are not being generous and are misrepresenting Mike Winger. Not suprised a calvinist would do this though since you dont believe anyone but your own are saved.
False teacher
He gave No scripture to suppor his claim that “the Bible teaches things will get worse and worse” and “to be a post millennialist you have to believe it doesn’t mean what it says”. Zero, nada. I guess he thinks he’s above sola scriptura. Clown makes 400k a year to push Roman Catholic eschatology developed by Jesuits. May Jah judge him speedily.
This is the laziest, most despicable accusation
Although i like watching ruslan, he has always had too little discernment. I hope him and Mike come to realise it
Ruslan is the TMZ of the Christian community and it’s kind of irritating, I don’t know his heart but he doesn’t stand all the time on biblical principles from when I’ve heard him…
I dont see the part where Mike Winger calls him a brother or says he isnt a wolf. I see Ruslan saying things. Ruslan is a closet EO member, hes not the same as Mike Winger.
We never report something that isn't true, if you need to hear Mike say the specific words himself watch our most recent upload - th-cam.com/video/-76kRykXgZo/w-d-xo.html
Yeah Todd White is sincerely a heretic and a fake healer and a false prophet, and good grief for Mike Winger to even consider saying that about Todd White and Joel Osteen is unbelievable!
Mike Winger is great.....Man drama is very feminine
Good video
But the irony is that as a Calvinist you believe that God ordained for Joel Osteen to be a wolf and that He wanted Mike Winger and Ruslan to support him 🤷♂️
That is a great point.
God always gets the glory, as a glory cultist myself you sir are not of this cult
Makes more sense that this channel and the people on it are calvinists. The hypocrisy makes sense now.
OkieAllDay, what you are saying is false. We do not believe that at all.
@@doctrinalwatchdogactive6454 So you disagree that God ordains all things in the world?
Winger is a pseudo-intellectual FALSE convert - and I believe he is purposely trying to deceive people because he is a leftist who hates Christ
Unsubbed from mike. This is ridiculous
Have you even watched Wingers original video?
Galatians 1:6-9 -I am astonished that you are turning away so quickly from the one who called you by the grace of Christ to a different gospel, 7 not that there is a different gospel, except there are some who are disturbing you and wanting to distort the gospel of Christ. 8 But even if we or an angel from heaven should proclaim a gospel to you contrary to what we proclaimed to you, let him be accursed! 9 As we said before, and now I say again, if anyone is proclaiming a gospel to you contrary to what you have received, let him be accursed!
I have a genuine question and would appreciate some insight. Can someone truly believe in God and that Jesus Christ died for our sins while engaging in deceitful behaviors or being a false preacher who is obviously doing things for money? This isn’t a loaded question-I’m not here to argue or defend anyone. I’m simply trying to understand. I’ve always believed that eternal salvation means you can’t lose it, no matter what you do, even if you become a deceiver. For example, if Todd White and Joel Osteen genuinely believe in God and in Jesus’ sacrifice for our sins, wouldn’t that still make them Christians? Could they simply be poor examples of what a Christian should be? Perhaps there’s no heavenly reward for such behavior, but would they still be saved? I might have this all wrong, but I’d love some help in understanding this better.
A Christian can be in error but if they (especially a pastor) if they are involved in ongoing sin, teaching a false gospel, ignoring correction, they are to be admonished twice and then excommunicated / marked and avoided Titus 3:10, Romans 16:17-18. Jesus says we are to regard such a person as a wolf, or at least a heathen or a tax collector so that means you don't go around telling everyone they are a brother in Christ. Winger is way out of line on this one but he is a charismatic and it's understood among charismatics that you go light on each other.
@@doctrinalwatchdogactive6454 The fact you think Mike Winger is a charismatic shows that you have never actually watched him. Not suprised by a calvinist though. Modern day pharisees.
@@doctrinalwatchdogactive6454 This seems like a fair answer based on scripture. Is it fair to say then that they these guys (Osteen & White) might be Christians, but only God knows if they really are in their heart? And at the very least, we as Christians should stay very far away from these guys and certainly not affirm them. Is that a fair way to assess that in your eyes?
Mike and his ministry have more fruit, more good fruit, than this channel and its approach to doctrinal correction. People have come out of the extremes of Bethel, out of mormonism, out of catholic error, because of Mike sharing sound doctrine. The bitter obessiveness that is infused into every post is so hilariously ironic, as it will drive anyone away who otherwise could have been saved. You are not motivated by Gods love, and you become like a sounding gong and clanging cymbal.
Jemeyezedten3930 you say we are not motivated by love. Okay, and you know this how? Is MIke motivated by love when he does expose videos? Is Winger the olny guy who is allowed to do this, are you biased because you like and agree with his charismatic theology and you don't like our conservative Calvinistic theology? Why do you make false accusations against us? We have literally thousands of videos uploaded and what percentage of those videos are about Mike Winger? Its less than %0.01 so hardly obsessive and certainly not bitter but we find it interesting that you think you can judge our motives and read our mind. Besides Winger critiques people every time the camera is on, but when we critique him you flip out and judge us, so why can Mike do it but we cant? Mike is clearly wrong about this, Osteen, Todd White and Kris Vollotton are not brothers, Volotton is literally a false prophet who claimed direct revelation from God and even admits his prophecy was false. Mike said real prophecy and real healing were coming out of Bethel despite their hereys and prosperity teachings, do you agree with Mike Winger about that? Yes or no?
Winger is an apex narcissist who knows only one thing. He is right about everything. He is an unbeliever like Osteen. WingNut is known by the company he keeps. Galatians 4:16 Ephesians 5:11
You are a pharisee
We know this isn't exactly new info for most of our followers but a some Winger fans recently said we were lying in the last upload and that Mike does not call Osteen a brother in Christ. We had to upload proof to defend our reputation. If we get something wrong we admit it and we pull the video down, Winger instead doubles down and calls people who disagree with him liars, his video about us and BTWN is still up even though we proved with video evidence everything we said was true - th-cam.com/video/cS0QOr_nwL4/w-d-xo.html
Man you are so manipulative, your entire channel is made to misquote and get clout from it, absolutely missed when he said he was quoting a comment but nah. I am so happy there is a block feature in youtube. You know what you are doing because no one does anything like this out of ignorance, I hope I never find your channel again and I am praying for you hope you repent soon.
So Ruslan wasn't happy Mike went soft on Joel? Mike has called Joel a wolf? No, our information is totally accurate but it does make Mike Winger look bad so therefore Winger fans twist things to try and make ol DW look like a liar. You guys are the ones in the wrong, and Winger looks bad because of what WINGER said and because of who he fellowships with, don't complain about the guy pointing it out why don't you complain to the guy actually defending Osteen as a brother. In reality Osteen should have been under discipline and him and his wife excommunicated for heresy a long time ago, if we lived in more sane times Osteen would not have a platform at all. smh
Winger is bought and paid for. Righteous anger isn't a wrong thing against these fools.
When will get to understand that when you know them by their fruits that its about more about their ability to be kind and forthright. Olsteen absolutely has very poor theology and sounds like more like a motivational speaker. He was never trained well and the people in his church thought automatically he should take over his dad's church. A lot of the problems at Olsteen's church is a systemic problem not an Olsteen problem.
It's nepotism, Osteen made his wife and children "pastors"! It's all a money making scam, they are clearly false shepherds but Mike Winger refuses to admit the obvious because he preaches the gospel of niceness.
@@doctrinalwatchdogactive6454because not everyone uses the slash and burn technique. If are not that guy?, you are not that guy. However Mike uses good sound research and issues public apologies when he’s in error. Not everyone is going to overturn the tables and use a lash to get rid of the money changers from the temple.
So wait, the videos of Mike Winger showing that Joel Osteen is not to be trusted somehow means that Mike Winger approves of him? You are just making a mountain out of a molehill. I can't speak in defense of Ruslan, but all I've seen from Mike Winger is a man who truly dives into the Bible to understand it, and if ever finds a place where he is wrong he quickly admits it. I'm not here to condemn you, but I would watch how you slander others within the Kingdom of God. It just brings more division than unity
You are the one slandering pal. In order for something to be slander it must be false. We said Mike and Ruslan say Osteen is a brother and not a wolf, that is true as the video demonstrates. Stop twisting what we said, the video title doesn't say "Mike Winger approves of Joel Osteen" - maybe go and get your glasses then apologize for slandering. You lied, not us.
@@doctrinalwatchdogactive6454 For someone to think of another as a brother, they would have to approve of what they do. Because Mike clearly condemns the teachings and ways of Joel Osteen, how can he also think that he is a brother? Your logic makes zero sense. In addition, I made no lie. I've watch this video multiple times to try to see where Mike Winger calls Osteen a brother, but no such claim was made. I don't mean to come off as bashing, but this video seems to be just clickbait and a way for others who don't watch the video to make a claim that the clip doesn't even support. Furthermore, your response indicates some sort of malice. I am not angry in any sense, and I don't know why you would be either, but there is no reason to be angry. I'm just hear to try to understand why you are here trying to cause division in the Kingdom of God, especially in a place where nothing was done. You are just trying to trash others' names without evidence, and its really sad to see. If I somehow still missed where Mike Winger expresses that Joel is a brother, give me a timestamp and a quote where he clearly says it. All I see in the video is Mike telling how his video critiquing Joel Osteen was taken down and how he handled it in a godly manner. All-in-all, I'm here to have a civil discussion and expect that you are here to do the same, and would appreciate if you would engage without being so defensive and bashful in your responses.
Osteen is not our brother.
That’s not what I see happening in this clip. I see Mike Winger stating that his critique video of Osteen was removed after Osteen was made aware of it, which is further proof that Osteen is a wolf. Read between the lines, people, not the headlines….
Exactly. Im a subscriber but this video is stupid. I don’t even like Mike winger but that doesn’t give us the right to straight up make a false headline
@@roberttrevino62800 you guys are unreal. They are talking about how Winger treats Osteen as a brother and NOT a wolf, its literally stated outright and then you deny it and claim they said something they never said. Besides we have other videos confirming many times Winger has called Osteen a brother, anyone who follows him knows that is his position. Now does Winger criticize Osteen, yes. We never said otherwise, but you need to pay attention, you can criticize someone as an erring brother or you can criticize someone as a wolf. Go back and watch and then apologize for lying about us.
@doctrinalwatchdogactive6454 being wrong does not a wolf make. You're engaging in mind reading, assuming Osteens expressed goal is to lead people to another gospel. The prosperity gospel still points to Christ, but gives the wrong motivation. The woman at the well wanted the living water to never have to draw water again, but ultimately received something much more powerful. Osteen, undoubtedly, has created more true believers than you and those who act like you. If we are to judge by fruit, and using your standard, then you are the wolf.
@@doctrinalwatchdogactive6454 nah you’re off on this one. Mike winger is literally saying in this video how osteen blocked his video and they both laugh because it proves how scared and cowardice osteen is. Ruslan (who I also don’t like) literally says “you didn’t even call him a wolf”, which means that Osteen is even more of a coward for striking a softball video
@@roberttrevino62800 not talking about Osteen being a coward, the point is Winger calls him a brother, do you deny that? Watch our recent upload, Winger on multiple occasions has said Osteen, Todd White, Bethel, they are brothers in Christ and they are not wolves. We have documented evidence and we are presenting this recent podcast showing this is still where Mike and Ruslan stand, and yet you deny this how?
If Osteen isn't a false teacher the word has no meaning. He's the biggest most obvious false teacher. Anyone that defends him should question their salvation.
Mercy...🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
Well, two weak Christians talking about Osteen, an enemy of the Lord.
All are false heretical preachers
And all Catholics are saved..
Joel Osteen is a wolf.
How much more evidence does anyone need? Deception is widespread in the so called church. Thank you for continuing to expose this.
If MW is the gold standard, we are in alot of trouble.
If Christ and Scripture are the gold standard, we are in good hands.. Good thing those are what Mike Winger used to prove that Joel Osteen is acting in ways that disqualify him from being in leadership!!!
Thank you for your ministry
Group both of them with Dr. Michael Brown. They are the real wolves in sheeps clothing. Joel Osteen, K. Copeland, J. Duplantis, T. White….Those guys are wolves in wolves clothing. Ruslan and Mikw Winger are wolves in sheeps clothing as we sit today in 2024. As time goes on the disguise will get even harder to recognize.
Interesting point. Clearly anyone with half a brain and the Holy Spirit can recognize White & Copeland are wolves. If Ruslan walked into a church 70 years ago would any true church accept him as a member? Doubtful.
This is who Winger fellowships with, the "Christian Rapper" who trashes John MacArthur & visits pot dispensaries. Nice discernment there Mikey!
So MacArthur is beyond reproach?
MacArthur is a bigger false teacher than any of these people.
Where has he trashed them?
0:49 Ruslan is basically saying all discernment channels slander Osteen by calling him a wolf and a charlatan. Osteen is most certainly a bad guy because he is making millions deceiving people knowingly ignoring parts of the Bible, blending Christianity with new age to produce a hybrid form of motivational speaking with a twist of spirituality / law of attraction and getting rich off it as he leads millions of people away from the true gospel and the true Christ who preached against sin, and taught self denial etc.
If you can't properly discern whether Osteen is or is not a Christian and you hang out with Ruslan as if he is a Christian and you think Bethel is a God fearing congregation of Christians, then I have to assume Winger is not a Christian. Seems plain as day to me.