วีดีโอ

Would have been nice to have an actual architectural historian write the dialogue; would no doubt have been more coherent and less repetitive.

Thank you being so irritating, just for your lack of knowledge, this is not Ai content, thanks for sharing your deficiencies.

Well it’s no Ai narration. But thank you for sharing that you do not have idea what’s AI contents

@@fzarchitecture ok cool... but you did understand the "THIS IS TERRIBLE" part of my comment. great... i got the point across.

Thank you for your kind words and for watching! 🙏 It’s a shame the Finlandia Hall was under restoration during your visit, but it’s a great reason to plan another trip to Finland. Alvar Aalto’s work is so inspiring, and there’s truly so much to explore beyond the Finlandia Hall. I hope you get the chance to return and experience more of his masterpieces. Thank you for sharing your experience!

Thank you for taking the time to watch! If you have any insights or questions about Aalto's legacy, I'd love to hear them!

That’s a great question! Norman Foster is often regarded as a “genius” because of his pioneering contributions to architecture, particularly in blending cutting-edge technology, sustainability, and timeless design. His works, like the Gherkin in London or the Apple Park in California, redefine the way we experience spaces while addressing modern challenges. Of course, the term “genius” is subjective, but his innovation and global influence are undeniable. What are your thoughts on Foster’s work? I’d love to hear your perspective!

@@fzarchitecture Thank you for the answer: Norman Foster is definitely the right architect for certain tasks; his oeuvre is enormous. His architectural language, however, reads more like the guide to solving a complicated problem than like poetry. On the cutting edge technology note: the Formula 1 industry also claims to have produced a multitude of innovations from which the automotive industry has benefited. Their actual contribution to the solution of the problem of individual transport is minimal. And their main purpose - to continue racing around in circles as quickly as possible - remains doubtful.

Thank you for your honest feedback-I truly appreciate it. Mispronunciations, especially of someone as iconic as Mies van der Rohe, can be frustrating, and I take full responsibility for that oversight. I’ll make sure to improve the narration quality moving forward to ensure it meets the standards this subject deserves. Your input is valuable, and I hope you’ll give future content a chance as I continue to refine and improve. Thank you for watching and sharing your thoughts!

Thank you for your comment! I’m glad you enjoyed the video. The 112 Prairie Houses by Wright are a fascinating part of architectural history, and it’s always a pleasure to share his legacy. Thank you for watching!

Thank you for sharing your personal story-it’s truly inspiring to hear about your journey through art and design education during such a unique time. It’s incredible how opportunities like free tuition and living allowances shaped the careers of talented individuals like yourself, leading to a remarkable fifty-year contribution as an educator, designer, and Dean. It’s wonderful to know that Norman Foster is one of your heroes-his work has undoubtedly left a lasting legacy in the field of design and architecture. Thank you for watching and sharing your experiences!

Thank you so much! I’m thrilled you found the video informative. Herzog & de Meuron’s work is truly fascinating, and it’s a pleasure to share their architectural brilliance. I appreciate your support!

Thank you for such a thoughtful comment! You’ve captured one of Frank Lloyd Wright’s greatest strengths-his ability to create modern designs that harmonize with their natural surroundings. The Goetsch-Winckler House is a perfect example of this, showcasing how innovative architecture can still feel grounded and connected to its environment. Your perspective on modern buildings today is so insightful-Wright’s timeless approach serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of designing with nature in mind. Thank you for sharing!

Thank you for sharing your experience and feedback! Touring Frank Lloyd Wright’s homes in such detail must have been incredible-it’s amazing to discover those hidden gems, like the built-in safe in the Robie House. For videos like this, I aim to provide a comprehensive overview of the house, but I completely understand the desire to see every nook and cranny. Wright’s designs are filled with surprises and intricate details, and I’ll keep your suggestion in mind for future content to ensure a more thorough exploration. Thank you for watching and contributing to the discussion!

Thank you too!

Thank you for your honest feedback-I truly appreciate it. I’m sorry to hear about the issues you encountered with the narration and content accuracy. Mispronunciations and mismatched visuals are certainly frustrating, and I take full responsibility for these oversights. Your suggestion to openly disclose any AI involvement in the content creation is a great point and something I will seriously consider to ensure transparency moving forward. I’ll also make sure to improve editorial oversight to avoid such errors in the future. Thank you for sharing your thoughts-they’re incredibly valuable in helping me create better content!

You are correct, sorry for the thumbnail, but the content for sure is an explanation from his works. Thank you for watching.

Response to Comment #1: Thank you for sharing such a thoughtful critique. You raise some excellent points about the Walker Art Center addition and Herzog & de Meuron’s design philosophy. The contrast between the Barnes-designed galleries and the addition does indeed spark debate-while some find the “wrinkled skin” captivating, others, like yourself, view it as lacking the rigor and logic of the original structure. The concept of “architectural eroticism” can certainly be subjective, and I appreciate you bringing a nuanced perspective to the discussion. It’s always enriching to hear how architecture resonates differently with individuals-thank you for your detailed analysis! Response to Comment #2: Thank you for the clarification! You’re absolutely right-Minneapolis is far from isolated, with its significant international business presence and robust corporate connections. I appreciate you pointing this out, as it adds important context to the discussion. It’s great to see viewers engage with the details-thank you for sharing your insight!

@@fzarchitectureThanks for your response! I just want to clarify that I really do appreciate your video. It is thoughtful, interesting and very nicely done. My comment is restricted to my own experience with the Walker Art Center and Herzog & de Meuron’s design. And I might be a little harsh. :) But it's only because the Walker has had a rather stellar reputation as a modern art museum, and I'm just not sure the Herzog & de Meuron addition lives up to that. But hey, it's only my opinion. I like some aspects of the addition. But in the end, it's kind of an "OK" with me. Not great, not bad, but it could have been so much more. And that's merely where my mild disappointment sits. I have to contrast the Walker addition with the brilliant Jean Nouvel design for the Tyrone Guthrie Theater in the same city. Nouvel grabbed the historic industrial aesthetic of the Minneapolis riverfront and ran with an entirely new interpretation that culminates with a structural tour de force in the 54-meter long, 2-story cantilever. The Walker needed the same bold treatment.

Thank you so much for your kind words! It’s wonderful to hear that you’ve studied Mies and even visited the Barcelona Pavilion-it’s such an iconic work. I’m thrilled that the video could provide new insights and add to your knowledge. Best of luck with your ongoing architectural journey, and thank you for watching and sharing your experience!

Thank you for catching that! You’re absolutely right-the Qatar National Library (QNL) is indeed one of Rem Koolhaas’s remarkable designs. It’s a stunning project that showcases his innovative approach to blending functionality and bold architectural concepts. I appreciate you pointing this out and adding to the discussion-thank you!

Thank you so much! I’m thrilled you enjoyed the video. Herzog & de Meuron’s work is truly fascinating, and it’s a pleasure to share their architectural brilliance. Your support means a lot!

Thank you for pointing that out! You’re absolutely correct-the museum is located in Watermill on Long Island, not upstate New York. I really appreciate the clarification, and I couldn’t agree more-it’s an amazing building! Thanks for watching and contributing to the discussion.

Thank you for sharing! It’s wonderful to hear how much you valued visiting Dana Thompson Lawrence during your travels. Retirement opens up new ways to enjoy these incredible places, and I’m glad videos can help you revisit and experience them again. Wishing you many inspiring virtual journeys!

Who needs a front door anyway? Just think of it as an open invitation for all the fresh air and unexpected visitors!

Wright's houses never present a banal, predictable, obvious formal front entrance door as most mundane suburban houses do. Instead, Wright presents a sequence of turns, exterior sheltered spaces, and a slow revelation of the interior spaces leading to the final surprise. Wright teases one with glimpses of each upcoming space as a theatrical entry experience. After approaching the prominent, deeply sheltered cantilevered carport at the Goetsch-Winkler Residence, one continues walking the length of a broad cantilevered , sheltering eave, teased by glimpses over the brick wall through low clerestory workspace-kitchen windows into the studio beyond. Once one walks beyond the low brick kitchen wall, one sees more of the studio and interior space through the taller glass doors. However, the stunning fireplace, which is the finale, is not revealed until one is deep within the house and looking back towards the entry. Wright's signature designs always enter through a deeply sheltered and compressed space which later opens up to reveal the taller, more voluminous space by stark contrast, as a surprise. Through compression and release, a slightly taller ceiling height feels grand, while actually maintaining a relatively low and intimate human scale throughout: This is the magic of Wright's spaces ~ the human scale and intimacy is unfamiliar to us. The Goetsch-Winckler Residence slowly reveals its spatial layers, even when walking around inside. All of the roofs are floating planes hovering over thin horizontal clerestory windows. One can never instantaneously grasp the entirety of Wright's spaces, even once inside. The workspace-kitchen cannot be seen from the very intimate inglenook living room seating alcove, and vice versa. This exemplifies Wright's mastery of space. I will grant you that in the case of the Goetsch-Winckler house, looking at the floor plan, the design may leave one confused as to which of the multiple glass doors do you choose to enter the house? I believe the answer is the last glass door at the perpendicular brick wall. That brick wall terminates the eave-sheltered entrance walk and turns one into the house. I believe if you visited the house and experienced the space, that projecting perpendicular brick wall would usher you to enter the house exactly where Wright desired.

Thank you for sharing your opinion. It’s interesting how architecture can spark such passionate debates. Norman Foster, like other great architects, has left a distinct mark on contemporary design, although I understand that not everyone connects with his style or vision. The beauty of architecture lies in its diversity, allowing both classicism and modern trends to coexist and enrich our built environment. Thank you for joining the conversation!

@fzarchitecture 🙏👍

Thank you for sharing such a profound observation. It’s a poignant reminder of the impact our built environment has on nature. As architects, it’s crucial to reflect on these truths and seek ways to design responsibly-using sustainable materials, incorporating green spaces, and prioritizing coexistence with the natural world. Your comment highlights the delicate balance between human needs and environmental preservation, and it’s a perspective that continues to inspire thoughtful, conscious architecture. Thank you for this powerful reflection.

Thank you for sharing such a thoughtful perspective. It’s true that architecture inevitably interacts with nature, often at its expense. This reflection reminds us of the importance of designing with sustainability and harmony in mind, finding ways to integrate buildings into their natural surroundings rather than displacing them. As architects, we have the responsibility to rethink materials, prioritize green spaces, and consider the broader ecological impact of our creations. Your comment is a powerful reminder of the balance we must strive for-thank you for inspiring this reflection.

Well it is a short from the main video. Thank you for sharing!

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. Architecture, like all forms of art and design, is open to interpretation and personal preference. While many admire Norman Foster for his innovations and his influence on modern architecture, it’s valid that not everyone resonates with his approach. Such differing opinions are what make architectural discourse rich and engaging. It’s always interesting to explore how architects shape the built environment, for better or worse, in the eyes of the beholder.

@@fzarchitecturewonderful reply ❤

Absolutely! Wright’s Usonian designs are a perfect blend of beauty, practicality, and ingenuity. His open floor plans and the subtle ‘hiding’ of functional spaces like the kitchen demonstrate his remarkable ability to harmonize aesthetics and functionality. Thank you for highlighting this brilliant aspect of his work-it’s one of the reasons his designs continue to inspire us all!

Thank you so much! 😊😊❤ Usonian homes are truly fascinating, and I’m thrilled to hear this one is among your favorites. Your support means a lot-stay tuned for more architectural gems! 🌟

Check on the description that someone owns and it is on airbnb to visit and stay there. It is an opportunity!

Thank you for your honest feedback! I’m sorry to hear that the motion and voice didn’t meet your expectations. Your suggestions are invaluable, and I’ll explore ways to refine the visuals and narration style for upcoming videos. I appreciate you sharing your perspective, as it helps me grow and enhance the content for my audience. Thanks for watching and contributing to the conversation!

Thank you for your feedback! I truly appreciate you taking the time to share your thoughts. I understand that the motion in the video might not be to everyone’s taste, and I’ll take this into consideration for future content. My goal is to improve and provide a better experience for all viewers. Thanks again for your input!

Agree and to much textual repetition in the narration. I do appreciate the subject matter.

Thank you for you recommendation!

Please show the thumbnail plan with the red location dot briefly and then take it away. Permanently shielding your view of a portion of the image is extremely irritating.

Thank you so much for your kind words! I’m really glad you enjoyed the video and appreciated the details-it means a lot to me! 😊 Yes, I do know about the movie “How Much Does Your Building Weigh, Mr. Foster?” It’s an incredible documentary that beautifully captures Norman Foster’s vision and philosophy. Have you seen it yet? Let me know your thoughts on it if you have! 👏🎥

@@fzarchitecture i saw a movie in a cinema in Milan many years a go with another architect friend of mine. The cinema was located in Piazza Liberty, exactely where Foster designed few years later the beautiiful Apple Store and in the same time he redesigned the entire Piazza, like he did in Nimes. It' s a masterpiece. Have a look.

Thank you so much for watching and for your kind words! I’m thrilled you enjoyed the video. Your support means a lot! 😊🙌

Thank you so much for your feedback! I really appreciate you taking the time to share your thoughts. I’ll definitely work on tightening up the narrative and avoiding repetitive information to make the videos more concise and engaging. The idea of incorporating the Ken Burns effect is a fantastic suggestion-I’ll explore that to bring more life to the visuals. Your input is invaluable for helping me improve, so thanks again for watching and for your constructive advice! 😊

@@fzarchitecture I'm happy you actually take constructive criticism! I like your channel and topics, and I do want to see you succeed.

Thank you so much for your kind words and for watching the video! I’m thrilled you enjoyed it. The Museum der Kulturen in Basel is a fantastic suggestion-it’s such an inspiring project and would be a great topic to explore in a future video. Stay tuned, and thank you again for your support and thoughtful suggestion! 😊

Thank you for sharing that perspective! FLW's genius really does stand the test of time, doesn't it?