- 52
- 925 620
ExtraCheeseProject
United Kingdom
เข้าร่วมเมื่อ 10 พ.ค. 2020
Entertainment at all costs.
The plan is a new long-form video essay every month and Film Theory short-form videos whenever I have an idea for one. My full meme archive is available via my Reddit account.
Thank you for watching!
The plan is a new long-form video essay every month and Film Theory short-form videos whenever I have an idea for one. My full meme archive is available via my Reddit account.
Thank you for watching!
EVERYBODY missed the point of Gattaca (1997) │ A Video Essay on Doing Wrong for the Right Reasons
At the end of Andrew Niccol’s 1997 science fiction film ‘Gattaca’ a mission to Titan is doomed to fail because the lead astronaut has a heart condition and is already beyond his life expectancy. It’s reasonable to think that this is still a triumphant conclusion, however, the surface level of this film already shows Vincent’s (Ethan Hawke) questionable behaviour, such as assuming Jerome’s (Jude Law) identity, befriending Irene (Uma Thurman) under false pretences, and pummelling a peace officer. Going beyond this, the subtext shows that Director Josef (Gore Vidal) falsely confessed to protect the mission to Titan, which places Vincent firmly as the ‘villain’ of this story.
Props to the audiovisual artist Samuel Francis Johnson for the incredible tracks used as this video's ambient soundtrack: Cosmic Intro Idle long (ID: 118332), Clair De Lune Debussy Dreamy Remix (ID: 8044), and Deep Drone Atmosphere (ID: 11759).
Props also to also to Kevin MacLeod’s track: "Peace of Mind" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Thank you for watching!
Props to the audiovisual artist Samuel Francis Johnson for the incredible tracks used as this video's ambient soundtrack: Cosmic Intro Idle long (ID: 118332), Clair De Lune Debussy Dreamy Remix (ID: 8044), and Deep Drone Atmosphere (ID: 11759).
Props also to also to Kevin MacLeod’s track: "Peace of Mind" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Thank you for watching!
มุมมอง: 17 228
วีดีโอ
Miller vs Winters │ Saving Private Ryan (1998) and Band of Brothers (2001) │ A Leadership Comparison
มุมมอง 4.4K5 หลายเดือนก่อน
The HBO miniseries ‘Band of Brothers’ accurately depicts Major Richard Winters (Damian Lewis) as one of the best military leaders in modern history, whereas this video proves that the fictional Captain John Miller (Tom Hanks) from ‘Saving Private Ryan’ (Steven Spielberg) is actually one of the worst military leaders in film history, who without several lucky breaks would have failed his final m...
Cast Away (2000) Deep Dive │ A Follow-up Video Essay on Betrayal
มุมมอง 19K9 หลายเดือนก่อน
This is a followup to my previous video 'EVERYBODY missed the point of Cast Away (2000)' found here: th-cam.com/video/R_m1mfu3XlY/w-d-xo.html This deep-dive proves beyond doubt that Kelly was a cheating cheater who cheated on Chuck. I’d recommend anyone to watch Cast Away (2000) with this interpretation in mind because it goes from being "a goofy movie about talking to a volleyball" to becoming...
The Sopranos: An Actual Defense of AJ
มุมมอง 926ปีที่แล้ว
I think it's about time somebody stood up for A.J. Soprano: a misunderstood character, maligned by the vast majority of the Sopranos community, but this character study will show that AJ was probably the only good person in the entire series. Chapters: 00:00 - Opening Titles 00:22 - Intro 02:08 - A.J. vs. Tony 05:51 - Bad 06:42 - Bad Adulthood 08:16 - Bad Parents 10:40 - Mafia-shaped Hole 13:15...
Odo Unleashed │ Followup Meme │ #startrek
มุมมอง 1.4Kปีที่แล้ว
A spicy Reddit Star Trek Parody Edit. This video took a bit more effort than usual and I don't usually ask but if you did enjoy please consider liking the video as the support means a lot to me! "Why don't I just get it over with and [bleep] you right now?!" (To clarify for the sensitive, the sound is 'mud squelching' i.e. the creative commons 'mudsquelch' sound effect, that is all.) #memes #me...
Skyler on Trial: A 'Breaking Bad' Character Study
มุมมอง 2.8Kปีที่แล้ว
Skyler was a controlling controller who controlled Walt. Chapters: 00:00 - Opening Titles 00:30 - Introduction 01:23 - Gray Matter to High School 02:30 - Skyler is a Bad Person 07:20 - Manipulation Montage 10:35 - In Defense of Skyler 12:34 - Outro Patreon: www.patreon.com/ExtraCheeseProject Music list (in order of appearance): "Just As Soon" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creat...
Are you an owl? │ Heat (1995) Parody Edit │ #memes
มุมมอง 615ปีที่แล้ว
"All I want, is her husband and his whole crew. (Who?) Who? Who?! What are you, an owl?" Props for the tense background creative commons music: Music from @Argsound Background Music Name of track: "Shadow" Link: th-cam.com/video/k-DJUohjcKo/w-d-xo.html #parody #spoof #extracheeseproject #meme
Bob Odenkirk: Action Hero? │ Nobody (2021) │ A Video Essay on Insecurity
มุมมอง 3.7Kปีที่แล้ว
Bob Odenkirk may not be a typical 'action' hero, but he is an 'actual' hero in real life, which is far more important than 'acting' the hero in a move. Our Patreon: www.patreon.com/ExtraCheeseProject Chapters: 00:00 - Intro 01:32 - Part 1: Violence is not the Answer. 02:37 - Part 2: Reality Undermining Fantasy 04:30 - Part 3: Acting is not Heroic 10:17 - Outro Music (in order of appearance): yo...
Floor it, Johnny! │ Ford v Ferrari (Le Mans '66) │ Parody Edit #memes
มุมมอง 618ปีที่แล้ว
Props to Dan & Tom's Whiteboard for drawing such a funny Johnny Bravo! Go Dan and Tom! #parody #spoof #extracheeseproject #meme
Nerys Unleashed │ Legendary Reddit Meme │ #startrek
มุมมอง 3.1Kปีที่แล้ว
A spicy Reddit Star Trek Parody Edit. This video took a bit more effort than usual and I don't usually ask but if you did enjoy please consider liking the video as the support means a lot to me! "You are a sadist Miles Edward O'Brien... a little harder please." (To clarify for the sensitive, the sound is 'mud squelching' i.e. the creative commons 'mudsquelch' sound effect, that is all.) #memes ...
The "Strong Silent" Type │ Yellowstone │ Parody Edit #memes
มุมมอง 1.4Kปีที่แล้ว
"What was he doing here?" Who knows. #parody #spoof #extracheeseproject #meme
"It's not very big! Half the size of Quark's!" [DS9 and Voyager Funny Scenes] #memes
มุมมอง 5Kปีที่แล้ว
"It's not very big! Half the size of Quark's!" [DS9 and Voyager Funny Scenes] #memes
Data's Speech Processor Malfunction │ TNG │ Parody Edit #memes
มุมมอง 13Kปีที่แล้ว
Data's Speech Processor Malfunction │ TNG │ Parody Edit #memes
Geordi is a Sucker │ TNG │ Parody Edit #memes
มุมมอง 1.4Kปีที่แล้ว
Geordi is a Sucker │ TNG │ Parody Edit #memes
EVERYBODY missed the point of Cast Away (2000) │ A Video Essay on Betrayal
มุมมอง 821K2 ปีที่แล้ว
EVERYBODY missed the point of Cast Away (2000) │ A Video Essay on Betrayal
Sandy Unleashed her Inner Ruth Langmore │ SpongeBob vs Ozark │ Mashup Meme #memes
มุมมอง 4102 ปีที่แล้ว
Sandy Unleashed her Inner Ruth Langmore │ SpongeBob vs Ozark │ Mashup Meme #memes
Really u gave it all another meaning and the right one...😊
Thank you so much! 😄
Chuck fell asleep on the sofa so Kelly decided to slip away (this divorced woman needed some tending to). Then he fell asleep on the raft and Wilson decided to float away. Falling asleep at pivotal moments is just how Chuck rolls. Wake up man!
You're right, Chuck needs to drink more coffee, he even fell asleep on the island after removing his tooth and lost a whole 4 years 😴☕😅
If she was cheater, why run to him and say he was the love of her life?
Because we're imperfect people. She cheated because of her faults and because he was always away. He was deeply hurt, but didn't blame her, because he was always away and not with her when he should have been. What a great movie. Thanks for explaining this whole infidelity angle in detail Irish guy. It was so perfectly subtle, that it slipped many of us lesser movie buffs.
Take it from someone who has been cheated on, words from these type of women mean NOTHING.
@@mrvehi Thank you for the awesome answer and feedback! 😃
Reading the comments here, it seems to me that many of you forget the woman he meets up with at the crossroads, near the end of the movie. th-cam.com/video/4aM1DjtaeF8/w-d-xo.html She's pretty and vivacious and apparently independent; a now he's become lean, tanned, and physically and mentally stronger. And so much wiser and more appreciative of life. It's, IMHO, a _great_ ending!
Absolutely! Bettina and Chuck experiencing similar betrayals in parallel, Chuck on an island in the middle of nowhere and Bettina in an island of loneliness in sparsely-populated west Texas, it's beautiful ❤️🩹
Wow! Something new and insightful on the Internet - amazing! NEVER thought of the issues of the movie in this way.
Thank you so much! 😄
This is gold.
Thank you! 😃
Girl would never recommend a dentist she was having an affair with.
Guy's literally 'Mr. Big' though 😬
@@ExtraCheeseProject Ah but what better way to camouflage her affair than to send Chuck to the dentist she recommends? How would Chuck ever suspect something so seemingly innocuous? If this is so, it adds a deeper and more devious and calculating aspect to Kelly's deception, which paints her in an even darker light. Remember also the comment by the female pilot: "A woman's gotta do what a woman's gotta do", thereby giving voice to what I am now certain was Kelly's own false justification to herself.
@@williamjpellas0314 Agreed, well said! 👏
Disagree with the actual thesis, but admit you make a very respectable case. Just as importantly, looks like you had a ton of fun doing it… Good on ya!
Thank you for the great feedback! 😃 'Respectable' is the height of my ambitions so this is a definite win! 😅
I agree with this theory, why would they make such a big deal of him having tooth ache, Dr Spalding, and then she's married to a dentist who knew Dr Spalding.
Chuck was betrayed by Kelly, Dr Spalding, and even his own teeth 😭
Brother my dad just put this on tv and we both lost our minds laughing lmfao You rock
That's awesome! Thank you for the great feedback it made my day! 😃
@@ExtraCheeseProject 😎❤️👍🇦🇺
this is brilliant
Thank you! 😃
There was no point...watching the film. Nobody cared.
STFU. Making up stuff with no proof
Gattaca is about human struggle but in particularly about the struggles of disabled people in a world where only perfection is acceptable. Being disabled myself I have had to work so much harder than others to get much less. I loved the swim scene too because it’s how it feels to use every last ounce of yourself to keep going but even then he still saves his abled body brother and himself because bodies have limits but love does not. This was after a lifetime of his brother berating and abusing him for being disabled. He still rose above, carried the privilege sought across the water on his back. Great scene!
Thoreau.
Well, this just ruined my day 😭🤝☕
Run Forrest, run!
I want to see a Kelly vs. Jenny Whorey death match!!
Zemeckis made an entertaining film up until the moment Chuck is rescued. But everything that follows is cringeworthy. Poorly written? Poorly acted? After watching this I am half convinced that it was all done with deep meaning. Or is the presenter reading too much into it? That said, when I saw it in the theater, I was largely gripped by the story. Every time I’ve watched it since, it has looked sillier and sillier. Perhaps I need to see it again.
It sounds like you're on the fence still so yes I'd recommend watching it again 👏
Nope, Helen Hunt isn’t a great actor. She isn’t nearly as overrated as Diane Keaton, but still. Hunt plays a fairly unlikable character. Was she playing unlikable or is she just unlikable? She’s as nitwitted as she was in Twister.
Why do you hate women, though?
@@RideAcrossTheRiver Ah, now we have a member of the unreasoned woke mob chime in who thinks that criticism of one or several women is equivalent to criticizing all women. Your comment is offensive, insulting, and totally unfounded.
monogamy is too cruel a thing... 😭
Not bad for a civilian.
Croims
Dude, thanks for breaking this movie down. I’ve seen it about 10 times but I never thought about it like this..👏👏👏
Crazy lol
bad take being honest, he overcame all the problems, so im sure he going to make it via space. also for me it was to provide that being perfect is more then genetics, its wiliness
Dude, The "random sound" was Tom Hanks laughing.😂😂😂 Haven't you seen his movies? He sometimes does a weezy laugh as he exhales (best way I can explain it).
We are never getting out of this planet... Maybe highly genetically modified versions of us will... Or just even easier, send humanoids...
Excellent video and discussion... Unfortunately in the end we all die, the earth will die, universe will die, everything is useless in the end...
"Embrace the pathos" ☕ Thank you for the awesome feedback! 😃
Your’re amazing. Great mind, wonderful analyses. I came across your channel via the Cast Away and Gattaca videos. Terrific ideas in those! The amount views you have on your vids are criminal, you should be in the top tier. Keep going man, I will watch every last one of thesis videos from here on out.
Thank you so much! This feedback is so encouraging that it's made my year! 😭🥲🙏
@@ExtraCheeseProject meant every word buddy! Keep grinding 💪
Meg Ryan never would have given up on him, though, now that I think about it, she also was known to betray her significant other. Still, their love was magic.
I’m pretty sure this take is accurate.
I do believe this video makes sense, and it probably was cut out of the movie as too depressing. They already had a great movie with him being marooned on an island and her cheating on him could be seen as "too much". The clues are there, but it was intentional they did not explicitly put this into the plot.
I agree completely 👏
I have NEVER noticed that Dean Norris was in Gattaca. Insane
So ironically Dean Norris was the _sussy baka_ 😅
Must have been after his holodeck shenanigans
They definitely dragged her being scared of Walt way too long, it was the most annoying part of the show
I agree. They should have done the _Skyler's scared of Walt_ stuff much sooner in the show, probably Season 2, because the _"I am the danger"_ moment happens about forty episodes in and that was much too late to take her _fear_ seriously 😬
you have some sound reasoning in many cases but when you hyperfocus on rules you lose sight of the plot. and im not talking about the movies.
I don't understand.
@@ExtraCheeseProject humanity is currently in the process of quantifying ourselves as a species for the purposes of exploitation and profit and we will only lose more and more control over our lives and environments as time goes on according to what are increasingly distant politicians, bureaucrats, corporations and algorithm and whatever they deem we are worth. life is not always binary. its fluid and i dont like being a number.
@@ExtraCheeseProject and beyond this...do you think such a heavy handed practice would be immune to bias forever? edit: and oh wow, youtube decided to shadow ban this comment. what a great demonstration of techno dystopia eh?
Your analysis is helpful and made the movie better. Still don’t understand why Jerome left fluids and killed himself knowing Vincent probably wouldn’t have made it back.
Jerome didn't know that Vincent was exhibiting symptoms of a heart problem so he was probably just trying to give him the best chance possible; this fits his character because he was consistently _optimistic_ about Vincent's chances since he saw Vincent have that leg-extension surgery 😬 Thank you for the awesome feedback! 😃
I had always assumed he was the killer because no motive was ever presented for anyone else.
Why should he kill the man? If it wasn't the Titan-mission he would have flown another one. 10 rockets a day and you think it was all for the Titan project? They had imho several parallel missions ...
@@yesyesyesyes1600 I think there are a lot of hints that Vincent is not emotionally stable
I was a Fedex pilot for 26 years. At 5:30 when Tom Hanks is looking out the window at her and husband, that building and parking lot do not exist, they're on what we call the Germantown Ramp at the Memphis Fedex hub.
I think the moral of this story is that genetics only takes you so far. In the end it’s hard work and determination that allows you to succeed. In now way is it certain that he will die, or the mission is doomed to fail
How do you explain the incident on the treadmill then? Also, Vincent tells Irene that _"I don't have twenty or thirty years left in (my heart); mine is already 10,000 beats overdue"_ and in his final monologue he says _"They say that every atom in our body was once part of a star, maybe I'm not leaving (Earth), maybe I'm going home"_ i.e. his body is returning to space. Also, Vincent _"not saving anything for the trip back"_ during the swimming contest is a parallel to him going to space because he knows that is also a one way trip.
I disagree with your take. The whole point of the movie was that society doesn’t define the person, the individual defines themselves. Vincent potential heart problem, is just that potential, there is a chance it might never happen. Vincent is also a genius, his borrowed ladder got him in the door, but his mind is what got him to be lead navigator. After the movie, I prefer to think his abilities are what saves the mission. But there is one dark point you failed to mention, if Vincent completes the mission, Jerome’s blood and other samples would all be from a 30 year old and damaged by cryo storage, he would be found out eventually and most likely charged with Jerome’s murder
The treadmill incident confirmed the prognosis of a heart defect and Vincent's predicted life expectancy of 30 years. Maybe under normal conditions he could live for another decade, but being without gravity causes the heart to change shape (become 10% more spherical) and this would be catastrophic for a heart defect, not to mention the harmful effects of 'cardiac atrophy, endothelial dysfunction, and oxidative stress' (Baran et al. 2021; The Cardiovascular System in Space: Focus on In Vivo and In Vitro Studies). Also, the concept of Vincent _"not saving anything for the trip back"_ during the swimming contest is a parallel with him going to space because he knows that's a one way trip; to conclude his final monologue he says _"They say that every atom in our body was once part of a star, maybe I'm not leaving (Earth), maybe I'm going home"_ i.e. his atoms are returning to space. So, I believe that Vincent's mission to Titan being a one way trip is the correct interpretation of the _subtext_ and that any analysis which concludes otherwise is not being accurate to the film.
I hate to be "that guy", but it's GATTACA in all caps. If you look at any of the promotional materials, movie posters, etc. it's always written as GATTACA. This comes from the way we write the nucleotides of DNA.
You're right, but every publication - IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Screen Rant, Metacritic, Amazon, etc. - uses 'Gattaca' so at a certain point it's just about metadata 😬
I always said AGATTHA for the name of the movie, never noticed it was something else
Very interesting and I thought it was a FedEx commercial sponsored by Wilson
To me the message of the movie was that the main character learned how to live a life without expectations, without having to be in a hurry, without holding onto other people, and that he can do anything by himself the way he wants to. Just breathe and see where the wind takes you.
06:13 *LOL* that got me good haha
Upstart hypocrite, then antihero
The people who don’t see cast away as a story about a “lost” love have never been in a relationship that went sour. Even when I was 12 when I first saw this movie I thought Hellen hunt was kind of a beotch with something weird going on. When I got older and rewatched the movie I was like, yep, Hellen hunt definitely did something funky. The scene where the husband turns her around at the airport is exactly how a lot of relationships are that were spawned of adultery, usually one has total control over the other and it’s probably because the relationship was not truly organic to begin with. The adulterous relationship is based on a sort of lie, hiding, guilt etc (basically a lot of emotions and ideas that aren’t exactly healthy. I never understood why people cheat outside of financial stability for the one party. It’s not like they want their cake and eat it too because the cheating party has plans on leaving but they don’t have the balls or ovaries to be honest in the first place and they be a relationship before starting a new one.
Well said! 👏 _"The adulterous relationship is based on a sort of lie, hiding, guilt etc."_ Exactly! It's like the parable of a house built on sand falling to the wind, i.e. Chuck's rescue was the wind and it effectively ended Kelly and Lovett's relationship because it was built on sand. Ironically, when I googled 'building a house on sand' the first result was an article on 'how to build a house on sand' e.g. _"... it's now possible to build stable structures on sand with the proper technology etc."_ 😅
@@ExtraCheeseProject I just happened to see a reference to relationships and built on sand reference earlier today.. Funny
@@dizzle6709 😆 Maybe we're finally running out of metaphors 😬
Gerome is no more a hero than what his brother Anton is. Where one had the physical attributes of perfection, the other had something beyond perfection within the imperfect. As Anton is genetically flawless, it would also stand to reason that his cognitive ability and mental state would be perfectly functioning. Psychologically, he would be very rational - weighing up the risk to reward factor to ensure the greatest chance of success and survival - perfect for a policeman. Vincent, on the other hand has been proven to be somewhat unstable, and willing to commit major fraud of identity and physical ability. He's also displayed aggressive and unreasonable behaviour - causing serious physical injury to others in order to protect his lie. There is a psychotic drive that propels Vincent into doing the irrational to ensure the greatest chance of success and survival. With all that said, the reason Vincent beat his brother twice in the swim races had little to do with physical ability, and more so with the irrationality of throwing all of your chips on the table and be at the mercy of the roll of the dice. It's all or nothing. In for a penny, in for a pound. There has to be a small degree of "psycho" for Vincent to "save nothing for the swim back." Anton's body didn't shut down on him during that swim. His mind did. For the second time, Anton couldn't comprehend how crazy Vincent truly was - panic set in and control was lost, where he then began to slip under the water. For the second time, Vincent's craziness outweighed the perfect man's perfect mental fortitude. Every achievement of greatness and to be awarded the highest of distinction, breakthroughs, pushing through unchartered frontiers into the unknown has always had some kind of madness behind it - a madness Anton or any "perfect human" would never possess. As I had mentioned earlier..."something beyond perfection within the imperfect."
This is great analysis 👏
The point of Gattaca is that Pretty people in Pretty suits go to Space. Average looking people do not.
😭 This has _"He's out of line, but he's right"_ energy 😅
Man, I think you're right. 🤯