Psychologist session with Barry/Dennis [Split the movie]
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 เม.ย. 2018
- That implicit laugh at 1:39
Psychologist Dr. Karen Fletcher has a session with Barry about the incident at work in order to bring Dennis' personality forward and talk about Kevin's safety. Dennis claims that Kevin is too weak, and can't realize how powerful they can be.
Dr. Karen doesn't believe that The Beast is his 24th identity and persuades Dennis, that it's just a fantasy.
Clip from the movie Split, starring James McAvoy. His acting is
overwhelming and leaves the audience completely speechless. - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
James McAvoy not receiving at least an Oscar nomination for this role was criminal
Pasajero De La Brújula the oscars is a joke... also glass sucked
darktennisball it was a sequel to Unbreakable more than a continuation of Split, somehow he tried to merge two ends with it and the result was terrible.
@@pasajerodelabrujula8261 lol i thought the ending was great
Yeah 😐
PuRpLePiCkLeS this movie came out a month or so before Get Out did, both films were on the higher end of the spectrum for originality and craftsmanship from screenplay to acting. It’s terrible this one received no major recognition.
James McAvoy nailed this role.
*roles
he nailed everything tbh
It shows how the awards are rigged. This man did phenomenal. He played so many characters so distinctly. Just his body language tells you who it is.
He deserved many awards ❤️❤️🙋🏻♂️
I think roles like this shows the difference between how some people just do movies and make their living. But some of these people really want to ACT and do really good work.
The switch when Dennis stops pretending to be Barry. James is really a brilliant actor.
Also this made me sad. For people who have suffered any kind of trauma and abuse
cant remember the exact quote but I think its "the damaged are the most evolved"
@@dannycool59x49 It is "The broken are the more evolved"
I don't think Dennis was pretending to be Barry. In fact, in the switch from Barry to Dennis, which i also loved because of McAvoy´s acting( perhaps one of my favorite acting in a scene of all time), I'm pretty sure that for that brief moment, Kevin became to light ,just before becoming Dennis. You can realize that because of the sadness of his eyes. It makes sense because Dennis is the most protector of all Kevin´s personalities. He is the one that makes him equanimous, and here he manages to reveal himself in order to keep Kevin safe and not exposed.
@@mariozavalaaldana88 That sadness - just short of tears - was still Dennis. He was overwhelmed by the doctor's show of sympathy. She knew he would be on guard against her calculations and brittle to being disrespected, so she made a detailed show of understanding his higher motives, suggested his courses of action weren't without reason, and pointed out that neither of them wanted to hurt Kevin. Remember, Dennis lost ALL of the other personalities as allies when he chose to follow Patricia, desiring the protection of the Beast to keep Kevin safe. At this point, Patricia and Hedwig are his only allies and he feels isolated, judged and desperate. He went into the doctor's office hoping to keep the heat off for awhile longer, but was unprepared for her to be three steps ahead of him but welcome him with open arms anyway. This scene sets up his heartbreak over later events. I love it for the iron conviction that sets in when Dennis speaks with his own voice. "They keep calling use the Horde..........the others, you know? Miss Patricia and I, we are *ridiculed.* Now we're not perfect, but....we don't deserve to be ridiculed. We're all struggling, they have to *admit* that."
The constant wariness of others' perceptions, of others' mockery. That forceful suggestion of what others *have* to admit. Dennis is terrifying.
This disorder has no evidence that it's real. Most likely he would show signs of borderline personality
the transformation between two personality is awesome.. McAvoy nailed it..
People were saying his performance was "ok" and that "he's just playing five roles in one movie"
But it's harder than that. He has to have each identity completely nailed out with their own tics their own destinnct voice their own moves their own posture their own aura essentially.
It's incredible to watch him switch.
@@jlogan2228 I can't to see More of his Epic Acting in Glass!
J Logan
Yeah it’s incredible watching him shift his posture slightly and... furrow his brow I guess? 🤷🏻♂️
It's actually amazing because he's acting a personality who's pretending to be another personality.
@@colin-campbell It's not just that, not even close. It's his breathing pattern, his eye movement, and overall a radical behavioral transition when he sends nonverbal responses to the things she says. He goes from being choked up to an ultimate sense of composure almost instantaneously, which as anybody knows it's very difficult to conceal sadness evoked through tears. The camera doesn't cut away, which was a very nice touch.
While we can't credit McAvoy for the change in the characters' dialogue, we can for the change in his dialect (and outside of the accent he has a completely altered his tone and flow of speech). He does it in a slightly exaggerated caricature sort of way as to differentiate the identities and provide a sort of cinematic presence (if you will), but they are all believable people. It's easy to imitate Trump or something, but it's a completely different task to take on Paul Smethers from Altoona, Iowa.
It's the nuances that makes every character stick. I'm seeing the exact same white-skinned, head-buzzed male doing these things, but for some reason when first watching this I never said: "That's somebody doing an impression." Instead, I'm saying: "That's Dennis. ... That's Barry." Things like that. Him being a woman or a child is significantly more noticeable, but this scene would have been demoed for Oscar contention easily.
And sure, he does shift his posture and furrow his brow. More than I can do, anyway. I'll take that, on top of the twenty other people he portrayed going into Glass.
What I really love is that Dennis' portrayal of Barry is slightly over the top compared to when we actually see Barry towards the end. It's his impression & interpretation of Barry's behavior.
Barry was in the beginning also who went to meet with Dr. First
@@2KILLAVILLE that was Dennis pretending. The doctor quite literally mentioned his "previous visits where you pretended to be Barry". This comment included that first visit. ... unless I'm mistaken. I believe the only times we actually see Barry are at the very end and also and the recorded videos on the computer.
@@gatewayrealtor664 could be true...cause I Remember her now saying something bout Barry being protective of his pics or drawings..but she was calling him Barry during the 1st visit tho cause the other 2 visits after she knew he was Dennis pretending to be Barry..I'm not sure but you could be right
2KILLAVILLE it’s always Dennis. The first visit he makes mistakes like forgetting his sketch pad etc. he also denies the email. We never see Barry until the video.
@@TheSuperNats idk..could be true but I believe Dr. Fletcher would've called Dennis out tho like during the other visits if it was Dennis pretending to be Barry during the first visit
Damn that transition from berry straight to dennis at 3:47 is brilliant. McAvoy is criminally underrated.
He's not really underrated after his X-Men bid
McAvoy Tight!! Cant wait to see more of his Epic Acting in Glass!!
He was Dennis the whole time acting like Barry
@@sticktalk7830 I know. I mean the way he just dropped the facade was epic.
Oh wow he sits back and furrows his brow - so incredible(!)
No one is commenting about this but what amazing therapy that woman gave him. She constantly pounded on the door to be let in, to have Dennis admit that he was in charge. While continuously backing it up with the theme that “we’re all here to protect Kevin”. It was a master class in helpful manipulation. She just didn’t realize how bad it actually was...
Well to be fair to her there's 23 indentities to keep track of and find out about and she clearly has intimate knowledge of their personalities she knew it was Dennis because she noticed his OCD and she clearly knows Barry very well to easily spot it wasn't him. Also we have fore knowledge of what the Dennis and Patricia have done the doctor doesn't she knows the other identities are under stress and she's trying to find out. I think eventually one of them would have told her thats why Dennis went to the appointment as Barry.
All that prying actually spelled her doom. Some peoples minds are best left alone
That was her doing her job, very well I might add.
Yeah, that's not good therapy
@@brooklynkeith2877 you know he was killing girls right? He needed a mental hospital, not to be left alone
The physical change you can see in his face when he finally succumb to admitting he is Dennis! Body language, tone of voice, posture, look in his eyes, his face even changed to look more strong and stern.. everything!! 🖤🖤 Soooo sexy!! Talented and was brilliant! James McAvoy should've won a damn oscar for this role!!
Rebekah Jackson Yaaaaas! I felt the SAME exact way! It was the subtle nuances in the change/transition that was really impressive to me. From his body language, to his voice, to even his facial expressions on his face.... I was impressed! You're right... It was sooo sexy!! lol... James McAvoy is a GREAT actor. Very underrated imo. :) And you're right, he really should have (at the VERY least) been nominated for an Oscar for this role. But I don't even think the film got recognized by the Academy that year at all. :-/
@@DestinyC1020 I totally agree with this comment to the fullest!!!!! 💯💯
He's short as hell
@@kalypsothefreak9717 um ok. Lls
Calm yourself
"I know you're someone who cares for Kevin. You're not evil to me... You were necessary".
I feel like this line describes Dennis perfectly. Keep in mind that Dennis was the first alter that had surfaced in Kevin's head. He had been with him the longest and understood his purpose was to act as Guardian. His OCD was a method to protect Kevin from further abuse by his mother. Dennis cares so much about keeping him safe that he became the second most dangerous alter, behind the beast.
It is also Dennis who transform into the beast
Sephelutis Lucifus not true...The Beast is an independent alter, in Glass he transforms from Hedwig.
Dennis is very dangerous, but I think Patricia shouldn't be underestimated. She isn't physically strong, but she is cunning, and a perfectionist. I'd say she's "the brain" behind Dennis's actions, at least those that have something to do with the Beast.
@@thecannonfodder1144 Dennis reconsidered his actions at the end of Glass
Ah OCD?!? LMFAO
No DID. Christ 🙄🤣
One thing I appreciate about the character of Dr. Flechter is how she treats them (the personalities) with some kind of respect. She knows that Kevin is a patient but she doesn’t see him as ‘crazy’...others in her profession would have suggested he be taken to an asylum, given pills etc, but her compassion (shown with her wiping her tears) enables her to understand him and offer some kind of advice.
Empathy gets them to talk. I suppose her goal would be to try to heal and empower Kevin so he no longer needs the others.
are you kidding!? Kevin hadn't been in the light for years. All she gave a fuck about was having some medical marvel to get fundings and write books about. People with his condition under proper therapeutic settings recover in around 6 to 7 years. This bitch abused a young man and that is why she was killed by such a loving 'hug' by The Beast. He was the protective father figure who killed the terrible mom. I have HAD a therapist exactly like Fletcher to the point I thought it was her when I first time saw her in the movie and BELIEVE YOU ME! they are the worst! I got worse under her 'motherly' care and it got me nothing
Devyani Account she tried her best to understand him and helped him what is wrong with you. When she saw the kidnapped girl, she tried to advice him he’s wrong. She let the others get the chance to express themselves
And then she died
Exactly why he trusted her and showed empathy in return. Until she did too much 😂😩
That internal struggle of Dennis trying to pose as barry and the frustration and torture he feels when she gets closer to the truth, and the transition between the two. Fk , the oscars man. This man is pure gold
Ikr
So let me get this straight James is playing a character “Kevin” while playing another character “Dennis” Who is impersonating another character “Barry” now that is freaking talent! 🙌🏻
He’s a dude, playin’ a dude, disguised as another dude!
Reminds me of Tatiana Maslany in Orphan Black! She played Sarah who was in disguise as Cosima
@@TheAnders369 Tropic Thunder in a nutshell xD
he isn't playing Kevin in this scene. he's playing Dennis who is impersonating Barry. that's all.
You kind of made it sound more complicated than it is 😆He had to play Dennis undercover as Barry and crcks gradually into revealing he's really Dennis
How does he make himself look visibly larger than Barry? He’s just amazing.
When you straighten your back you have a broader and more stable posture, and Dennis is so particular with how he acts, talks, and dresses that he subconsciously stands taller and bigger, cuz he's the most mature of the 23
How Dennis tries to impersonate Barry, the moment he realises how Dr.Fletcher concluded that she's not talking to Barry and that shift from Barry to Dennis....In words of Anya Taylor Joy, watching him act is like watching an acting masterclass.And kudos to shyamalan for this shot.He kept the camera in closeup to capture his every move.
That actress playing the therapist is awesome honestly, I love this scene
"You are not evil to me, you were necessary"
That little laugh at 0:19
Dennis played Barry so good
...so well* , sorry the Dennis in me couldn't surpass that 🤓
But I agree brilliant impression of subtleties or over the top exaggerations of what Barry really is like
People with D.I.D. can impersonate other alters with ease
@@HWest-lh7kf it just goes to show the level of trust and intimate knowledge Dr Fletcher has of their identities and their personalities that she saw straight through Dennis pretending to be Barry. She had never met Dennis before because he wasn't allowed to be in control but she knew him when she saw him and didn't ridicule or mock Dennis like he says the other indentities do she empathises with him then valids him as a person which is how she gained his trust I wish there were more scenes with her
James played Dennis played Barry so good 😊.
Dennis is my favorite alter. Patricia is great too but Dennis you can tell is the one trying to keep it all together
Dennis is broken and the Beast was a purpose. Once he doubted the beast, he could see the broken person he had become.
brandon brooker I don’t think it was that he doubted the beast he believed what he could do, he saw it first hand multiple times not to mention he was the one who greeted the beast at the train station. . I think he just wanted nothing to do with it anymore towards the end of glass, in a way it seems he realized what the horde was doing was wrong.
@@johnnybravo8129 i meant doubted what he stood for, not his abilities
brandon brooker ah I got you, just a simple misunderstanding on my part. one can see how that could be taken both ways ya know what I mean
When the realperson came thru it was so sad I’m talking about Wendell
when you don't need a squad, because you are the squad ;D
Nice. Glorifying such an ilness for a little fun. Very mature.
@@jlsg87 I don’t understand how that’s such a bad thing. It’s complementing
@@jlsg87 easy there snowflake
The look in his eyes when Dr Fletcher says he’s not evil broke my heart. He looks like he finally found someone who understands him.💔
Dr Fletcher didn't ridicule or mock him like he says the other identities do. She spoke to him like an equal, empathised with him, showed she knew a lot about him without judging him and finally she validated Dennis as a person not some crazy figment of Kevin's imagination. Thats why Dennis dropped his facade
@@wickedwitchoftheeast88 Poor Kevin, at least he knew he others cared for him like Dr.Fletcher and Casey 🥺🥺♥️♥️
@@tayladunn7490 I agree Kevin was never given love, empathy or understanding only Casey and Dr Fletcher gave him that. I love this film and wish James had won an Oscar for it but I do understand why his portrayal of DID caused controversy because not all individuals with DID are violent and dangerous they create these identities because the majority with it have been horrifically abused just like Kevin and the identities each serve a purpose.
the change in his face @ 3:47 is amazing. I really enjoy James in this role.
I think Dennis and Magneto would get along.
Dennis would remind Magneto of Kevin Bacon; it would end with a coin through the head
He really should have been nominated for an Oscar for this role...
“You were necessary” words I’ll never hear someone tell me.
You ARE necessary
Nick Avila thank you!
You dont NEED others to compilment you. You are, what you believe you are!
@Roy G Biv i agree
@Roy G Biv i got out by swimming btw
I will never shut up about how James got snubbed for an Oscar. But then again I feel like the feedback he’s gotten from fans is more valuable to him than an award. This is one of my favorite scenes in any movie ever.
“You are not evil to me. You were necessary.”
He wants to cry in rejoice when hearing those final words!!
I often think that every child no matter how damaged they were or are needed to hear these lines once in their life!! So powerful. So raw. So real. Always gives me chills. You were necessary!!! So many feel the opposite and to hear this
WOW
I love how James mcavoy played Dennis he scared the hell out of me when he spoke
The way the therapist made him feel comfortable to come out was stand out how they do it
Wow. The transition was amazing. The way he straighten his back, the way his soft features transformed into an intimidating frown, the way his baby blue eyes turn into a steely stormy blue. Acting at its finest! James is an amazing actor.
The scene where he turns into the beast his eyes turn completley black like.hes blacking out having a psychotic episode...... my eyes change colors too when I get angry from blue to green
4:13 that speech gives me...wow
James is phenomenal. His transition from Barry to Dennis is just… incredible. I don’t think anyone else could nail this role.
This actor should be paid x24 what is supposed to be paid. He just acted as 24 different characters
He acted 7.
@@Slechy_Lesh you beat me to it.
it should be added though that in the sequel he played almost all 24 alters.
Edit: he played 20.
@@Liravin Wow I gotta see that
1:50 that voice just took my breathe.
I was today years old when I realized that the actress who played Dr Flechter is the gym teacher from Carrie (1976)
and the actor who plays Kevin is literally Mr Tumnus from Narnia!! like WHAT
3:39-3:49 that’s the moment of the transformation. I keep going back to those seconds, he is brilliant
The actress playing the psychologist is just brilliant.
I literally WATCHED a person change from one to another
That. Takes. SKILL!!!!
Sweet Lord. This is some of the BEST acting I've EVER seen in my life.
No one can EVER change my mind.
James McAvoy is fantastic.
1:30 why does his face always get me at this scene 😂🤣😂🤣
this guy is so talent when changing to different personalities, its so smooth, its amazing, this man deserves an oscar!
Because it is real ....
@@chazzlucas6395 D.I.D is real yes and I have it but he doesn't have it
Every character is so well defined, so well and subtly acted. So glad I'm not the only one who thinks he deserves an oscar for this! Brilliant acting, just brilliant!
He switches with his face. Fucking brilliant. His expression and everything changes and its immediately evident hes a different personality. James McAvoy is so god damn talented
They keep calling us the hoard ... flawless acting 👏🏻🤩
2:31 the subtle switch.
I get goosebumps everytime
That switch from McAvoy where he went from 'fake Barry' to Dennis was amazing
i was literally about to comment the same thing as below ...he was absolutely robbed....one of the best acting performances ive ever seen
I could just watch an entire movie with an extended therapy session with just these two
McAvoy should've received 9 different oscar nominations for 9 different roles
His acting is superb......so believable. he should have gotten an award
Not acting : (
Rarely does a movie, pictures on a screen, give you literal chills.
This reminded me of the extraordinary film Sybil with the iconic Sally Field. Well done James McAvoy. Well done:)
I remember watching that movie in school
Man... what a scene. I was so into it. No music for most of it, no jump scares. Just great dialogue
Both actors are doing a fantastic job, she almost persuaded me that the beast does not exist.
James not receiving all awards for this performance is a crime!!!!!! this is a masterpiece,..
that transition dude >
Dennis is my favorite
McAvoy did a beautiful job of this scene, he even portrayed (even if unintentionally) the mild dissociation that can sometimes occur in moments of emotional confusion, it seemed a very visible and gradual switch from Barry to Dennis, and even if it was dennis the whole time, that's even more impressive, a character acting out a different character
Something you can catch on rewatch - when you see the "real" Barry later on, in the video on Kevin's computer, he's much more subdued than Dennis's impersonation of him. Dr. Fletcher knows the "real" Barry well enough to know that something's wrong, and she knows enough about the other alters to guess what's happened.
James McAvoy is fucking phenomenal, dude
James McAvoy will always be one of my favourite actors, from childhoods Mr. Tumnus to this movie reintroducing me to him I’ve been hooked on his performance, motivation, and stellar work in any roll he’s given
Well, this scene made me like Dennis....all he wanted was protect Kevin.....
James McAvoy nailed this scene!
His acting is amazing.
This role must of been a dream for an actor.
He should’ve won an Oscar for each of the parts he plays.
James McAvoy was gorgeous in this movie - his acting, his look, everything
James McAvoy is a incredible actor
I just hope everyone takes a second to appreciate how this was a dude playing a dude disguised as another dude...
The fact that James McAvoy didn't get an Oscar is just criminally heartbreaking because that facial change from Barry to Dennis is just fucking amazing!!!
After learning about DID and then coming back to this movie is mind blowing. After understanding you see this movie completely different
The Academy didn’t know who to give the Award to… him or the Others 🤷♂️
James deserved an Oscar he was phenomenal!! DID is a fascinating topic, they done an a couple of episodes covering it in Criminal Minds and it wasn't as good as James McAvoy but it was a brilliant performance. James Van Der Beek played the UnSub with DID and he was pretty accurate too
The transition is top notch
Both of these actors should have gotten Oscar nods.
He deserves Oscar
He's awesome I mean look at him so talented and magnificent..!!
I can't find words to describe how Wonderful he is ❤️❤️❤️❤️😘
An Oscar worthy actor. 💯
I feel like M night's movies have this serene feel to them, I can't quite place it but I sure do love it
James was so sexy in this movie, esp as Dennis it's not even funny
#facts
Omg I'm not the only one that thinks this 😂💕
Yes i agree.
SPOILER ALERT
"Because Kevin's dad left on a train" CHILLS and tears...
That train became the origin for 2 of the most powerful heroes.
I had no idea she was the gym teacher in Carrie
I haven't seen the movie but I think I will tonight. It looks amazing! James is a fantastic actor.
did you like it?
Omg James McAvoy is amazing
Im a James fan after this scene. It was just.. Wow
He is a phenomenal actor one of my most favorite movies loved him ever since wanted and the way he transforms perfect👏👏❤
This is one of my if most favorite scenes in this movie. I also realized here how much danger Dr Fletcher was in
James McAvoy deserves the Oscar
That switch from Barry to Dennis was insane.
I would LOVE to see a movie showing how Dennis and the others came into existence
Probably from watching TV, neighbors, people he saw as a boy.
It would just be a feature length retelling of the abuse referenced in flashbacks and dialogue. You ever heard of the book “a child called it”? It would just be 2.5 hours of shit like that
@@Mikey-jv5fv I was hoping maybe more like Crazy Jane and the underground. Or a mix of his life and the other alters popping up
I'd rather not this movie already does a terrible job at portraying the mental illness.
@@sibs544 films arent made to portray mental illnesses but to entertain. They are fiction not a documentary. I know there are films made to educate people but it wasnt told it was the case of this film. It is just fiction for entertaining porpuses. Nobody should take a film as a guiance in real life
I absolutely love Kevin and the other personalities. Dennis mostly lol 😍😍😍😍😍
James McAvoy Deserves a Oscar for this role he is one of my Favorite actors I love that movie Split
I dont care what anybody says here. Dennis is HOT
Man, i've always thought that the actress, not the doctor, teared because of McAvoy DOING THAT. It's simply amazing, OMG
So freakin good. Taking notes
Love this scene..excellent transition
When dr. Fletcher said "You where necessary!" I bust out crying cause that makes me feel good about my Dennis I carry around to survive. My Dennis is also strong and disciplined. But original me is weak.
GOD BLESS YOU. FIND ME ON FACEBOOK AND MESSAGE ME. IF NOT, PRAY TO GOD FOR STRENGTH!
@@tomhibbert1210 Fuck GOD...if God existed you wouldn't have such shit existing in the first place and don't give me the bullshit that we are sinned or the devil or whatever fking excuse.
If GOD is the almighty and everyone and thing is below his rules. Then he can jollywell make the fking rules to tell the devil or sinners or whatever the fk rationality you have to justify abuse and the results of it. Instead of bullshitting that suffering is not his fault or at least that's what the idiots that try to preach about him tell.
@@kaister901 you speak in such anger, why? what pain in your heart would fuel such a violent reaction
@@waross8214 Nah I just hate dumb people that's all. If you need an imaginary friend as a coping mechanism, just admit that. Instead of giving bullshit advice to people that need actual help. Sitting in a room and singing kumbaya isn't gonna do shit and anyone that says it did..probably are ignoring other factors that did do the job.
@@kaister901 see I hear what you're saying but the fact that your speaking with such ill contempt makes me feel like there's something deeper going on
Still amazed till this day about McAvoy’s acting in this film, the therapist also did pretty well
Such an amazing actor it’s unreal
I so love this scene with a passion because it slows down the narrative for us to get the background and a psychological/psychiatric understanding behind "split." The idea of all the personalities being in one room sitting on chairs waiting for their opportunity to have the light is beyond interesting. It explains a lot of what is going on today.
God he is such a great actor. He was fantastic in this movie.
I swear I didn’t hit dislike, it was Patricia!!
The fact when we first saw Barry, it was really not James playing Barry, but James playing Dennis playing Barry.
The best part from this scene is without a doubt when Dennis drops the act. His facial features seem to change completely in a matter of seconds, brilliant acting
Those two teenage girls having a lark unwittingly _unleashed the Horde._
That may be the reason the Beast is obsessed with targeting teenage girls, the Horde chooses those that resemble the popular girls who pulled that prank.
M night should do a whole franchise with split/ glass The Beast,Hedwig and all 23 characters is So ICONIC 💯💪🏽
#Philly