@@buggiemara4902 I figured that some subtle CGI or even some sort of prosthetic eye mask was used during the overdose scene. The dog's eyes are just so drugged out and lifeless! How'd the heck they do that? Hard to believe that it's purely training.
@svoboda8267 not really, there's a lot of rules and guidelines preventing animal abuse in movie media and commercials, and there's always a team who observes this guidelines in every major movie or commerial, a Academy Award racing cound't have the power to change that for any reason, just like unions and secutiry guidelines for actors.
the aspirin scene blew me away i was sitting in the theatre and the only thing on my mind was "how the fuck did they do this? is that dog even real" wow
There are french interviews with the dog's coach on YT, they explain that for this particular scene they trained the dog to play dead first by teaching him how to lay down on the side, then by letting his head feel heavy, then the body. For the eyes it was CGI and the vomit part there was a tube beneath the head of the dog, and someone just had to push a button to make all the nasty stuff come out of the tube. You can find the videos explaining the training labeled as [ "Anatomie d'une chute": on a rencontré le chien Messi qui joue Snoop dans le film ] or [ Les coulisses d'Anatomie d'une chute : Messi, le chien à la Palm Dog ] But there are no English subtitles only French. Hope my answer helped ^^
The OD scene is fucking crazy. The way he pretends to freak out and wake up from the imaginary overdose, sort of stagger to his feet, its truly incredible. Saw somebody mention that this was the best dog acting they had ever seen which prompted me to look him up, and I dont think they are wrong
@@crabstick250 It's not the actress' dog. It's a professional dog who works in movies, with a trainer named Laura. Pure skill. Pure intuition. Pure craft :)
The director said that the vomit was cgi added in post. Which for me doesn't really lessen any of his acting because I assumed it was a tube fed underneath him anyway
@@MrTriplej79 exactly right! Like the reactions don’t seem fake at all or like one of those scene where you can sense the trainer signalling them in the background to do certain actions.
Credit needs to be given to Snoop's handlers and directors themselves. This dog's training and direction is phenomenal. I went to film school and they said to never work with dog's ir children because they cannot provide you with the performances you need, but ckesrly with rhe right handlers you can. But maybe Snoop is just special ❤
they froze his face with CGI the same way they freeze humans when they are trying to play dead but cant hold there breathe long enough or if they are having trouble not blinking
The look, the facial expressions, the attention he pays, the movement of the ears... This is the kind of reaction your dog gives to you, not in a film This dog is phenomenal, congratulations to him and the trainer !
Legit, this was my thought too. I couldn't believe how good the pupper was, the acting in the vomit scene was so good I had to pause and shout at the boy through the screen for doing something so horrible just to prove a point. My dog even reacted at my emotions, so I had to calm him down too! The boy's acting was decent but the dog just blew me away. I genuinely think they should create a new category for Best Performance by an Animal. What a good boy!
I mean realistically he's a child in a absolutely crazy situation trying to figure out the truth behind the death of his own dad, realizing his whole view on his family has been completely wrong. It's not hard to understand where that action came from.
His performance reminds me of Jed, who acted in films like white fang and the Thing but was in tons of movies while he was alive because he was uniquely talented. Most dogs have their tails cgi'd because they can't stop wagging them, but he had a strange stillness about him that made him stand out. This dog has that same thousand yard stare.
i immediately thought of jed when watching this. it's absolutely the expression in the face and the body movement. many dog actors are very well trained but you can tell they are depending heavily on the trainer and due to the precision of commands they tend to look a bit "mechanical" in their movement and faces. most people can't tell and so their acting work is perfectly fine but not exceptional. jed and messi have a way about them that feels like they are interpreting the instructions given by the trainer in their own unique way, the same as a human actor might do with a script.
@@someembarrassingLPs Sorry to reply three weeks behind, but something else Messi here definitely shares with his "phenomenal animal actor" predecessor is his complete lack of looking at the camera. The one time in The Thing where Jed looked directly into the camera, it fit with the story and actually worked to add tension to the scene and make the audience uncomfortable - pushing toward the common compliment Jed was given by his trainers and costars that any move he made, that would be "just something an animal actor will do" to almost every other animal in film, seemed to fit perfectly with the character he was playing. And now, throughout Anatomy of a Fall, Messi's never making eye contact with the camera either. He's fantastic. There are dogs in Horror that can't be focused on directly when playing dead, especially for such long shots, because they can't keep still or make it as believable as Messi managed. Whether that's because he's a Border Collie and Jed was a Wolfdog, or because he and Jed are/were actually aliens disguised as Good Boys, us humans will never know. But they definitely have a special talent for the roles they've been given.
Can't. They'd get sued for how they got the dog to behave that way. There's no way that was not drug-enhanced. And you know, of course, that that scene could've been filmed over many days and the key moments edited together. Yeah, the Animal Rights would be all over whatever they were up to. But hey, it's all for Art so they get a pass.
amazing handlers, beautiful performance in this film snoop. the dog & handlers all need an oscar for this because it is truly a work of art. regardless of understanding the language, the acting between the son & especially snoop the dog is phenomenal. breathtaking !!
Guys! I found out today he didn’t win an Oscar but he did win the Palm Dog Award at Cannes 2023 (which has been around since 2001) so fret not he is indeed a internationally acclaimed award winning Good Boy 🏆
Something about Messi at 1:12 is so unnerving. It’s a beautiful shot, but it almost makes it feel like he knows exactly what happened but he can’t say anything because he’s a dog. That look in his eyes says all.
Like can somebody tell me? How the hell he did the choking, eyes , and the tongue… Like did they really poisoned him? HOOOWW HE ACTED BETTER THAN MOST OF THE ACTORS NOW?
He did two months of training for that scene but I'm still flabbergasted at how he was able to do it. What as seriously impressive performance from Messi.
the most impressive, for me, is him hitting all the marks during the long shot. Like stopping, maneuvering relative to the camera, looking at people etc. 1:26 like thats difficult for a person...
Having had a blue merle border collie I can say no dog is as capable of acting, undertaking tasks or understanding instructions as one of them (if food is a reward).
I have never seen a dog so expressive; the overdose scene was masterclass 🐶
really? how was it made?
@@drendelousThey actually trained the dog. Just thinking about the process is insane.
@@buggiemara4902 I figured that some subtle CGI or even some sort of prosthetic eye mask was used during the overdose scene. The dog's eyes are just so drugged out and lifeless! How'd the heck they do that? Hard to believe that it's purely training.
@@gbeneviste They simply overdosed the dog.
@@gbenevisteVI la escena original y quedé sorprendida.
I hope he got a lot of treats after filming
His trainer said she taught Snoop (real name Messi) to act the overdose scene with lots of pets and treats. :)
And hugs and kisses as well
“Never work with children or animals” yeah because they’ll never be as good as snoop
Snoop is the character, the actor's name is Messi
Nah, the true adage goes like this: "never work with children or animals because they will outshine you."
@@carwyn3691 the dog’s real name is Messi, like the footballer? awww 🥹
Snoop double g
The Academy needs a new award for Best Performance by an Animal.
oh yes!
Yeah - they already have one at Cannes.
Messi (the dog) won the Palm dog award at Cannes
Not a good idea. Producers would start racing to get it, leading to a lot of animal abuse.
@svoboda8267 not really, there's a lot of rules and guidelines preventing animal abuse in movie media and commercials, and there's always a team who observes this guidelines in every major movie or commerial, a Academy Award racing cound't have the power to change that for any reason, just like unions and secutiry guidelines for actors.
the aspirin scene blew me away i was sitting in the theatre and the only thing on my mind was "how the fuck did they do this? is that dog even real" wow
SAME, insane! HOW did they do that?
There are french interviews with the dog's coach on YT, they explain that for this particular scene they trained the dog to play dead first by teaching him how to lay down on the side, then by letting his head feel heavy, then the body. For the eyes it was CGI and the vomit part there was a tube beneath the head of the dog, and someone just had to push a button to make all the nasty stuff come out of the tube.
You can find the videos explaining the training labeled as [ "Anatomie d'une chute": on a rencontré le chien Messi qui joue Snoop dans le film ] or [ Les coulisses d'Anatomie d'une chute : Messi, le chien à la Palm Dog ] But there are no English subtitles only French.
Hope my answer helped ^^
@paperman712 thank you so much for this comment!!😭 wow amazing
@@paperman712wait what.. i strongly beleive we need an award for the trainers and the animals then
LMAO CG EYES genius@@paperman712
The OD scene is fucking crazy. The way he pretends to freak out and wake up from the imaginary overdose, sort of stagger to his feet, its truly incredible. Saw somebody mention that this was the best dog acting they had ever seen which prompted me to look him up, and I dont think they are wrong
Legitimately an oscar worthy performance
Showing more acting talent in a few minutes than the entire cast of Riverdale during it's 25 year run
Hey, Riverdale includes Charles Melton, and that guy gave one of the best performances of 2023 :D @@minuishaq631
@@minuishaq631i mean duh, almost everything is better than riverdale
I was genuinely shocked at how good this dog is at acting?
I am in complete shock, the scene when he looks at the picture....like, how???????????
Why didn't he win any awards?!
@@Raheel_Ishaq He won the Palm dog award at Cannes
That unblinking unmoving thousand-mile stare in Snoop's eyes during the OD scene was so haunting.
the last scene apparently was not scripted for snoop to sleep by her side and they kept it
So the dog can act AND improvise??? DEFINITELY DESERVES A LOT OF TREATS AND AN OSCAR 🏆
Because it's actually her dogl!
@@crabstick250 It's not the actress' dog. It's a professional dog who works in movies, with a trainer named Laura. Pure skill. Pure intuition. Pure craft :)
@crabstick250 the one where the actress owns the dog is the lady from The zone of interest, thats why he followed her everywhere
That last scene and the part where snoop just comforts her it actually broke meeeee
forced to be a dog born to be an award winning actor
For me more than the playing dead, it’s the vomiting and instantly sprinting backwards out of fear and confusion. HOW TF DID HE DO IT SO WELL!!!!
I agree. He was so good in that scene. Wow!
The director said that the vomit was cgi added in post. Which for me doesn't really lessen any of his acting because I assumed it was a tube fed underneath him anyway
@@MrTriplej79 exactly right! Like the reactions don’t seem fake at all or like one of those scene where you can sense the trainer signalling them in the background to do certain actions.
Snoop and Milo Machado Graner acting are the best proof Justine Triet is the director of the year.
Messi. His real name
Everyone's talking about the Margot Robbie snub, but what I want to complain about is the Messi snub for Best Supporting Actor!
He deserved a whole new category just for him, the most Epic perfomance! 😅
Ronaldo better
Messi has the most human looking eyes I’ve ever seen on a dog. They’re absolutely beautiful and he really nails that 1000 yard stare
Credit needs to be given to Snoop's handlers and directors themselves. This dog's training and direction is phenomenal. I went to film school and they said to never work with dog's ir children because they cannot provide you with the performances you need, but ckesrly with rhe right handlers you can. But maybe Snoop is just special ❤
This takes “playing dead” to a whole new level. Greatest animal performance of all time 🙌🏼
they froze his face with CGI the same way they freeze humans when they are trying to play dead but cant hold there breathe long enough or if they are having trouble not blinking
@@breakbad9753I heard it was just the eyes 👀
The look, the facial expressions, the attention he pays, the movement of the ears... This is the kind of reaction your dog gives to you, not in a film
This dog is phenomenal, congratulations to him and the trainer !
Messi needs an honorary oscar for this and I’m not even joking. Seriously the best animal performance I’ve ever seen.
Ryan Gosling got nominated over him? Wtf
Legit, this was my thought too. I couldn't believe how good the pupper was, the acting in the vomit scene was so good I had to pause and shout at the boy through the screen for doing something so horrible just to prove a point. My dog even reacted at my emotions, so I had to calm him down too! The boy's acting was decent but the dog just blew me away. I genuinely think they should create a new category for Best Performance by an Animal. What a good boy!
I mean realistically he's a child in a absolutely crazy situation trying to figure out the truth behind the death of his own dad, realizing his whole view on his family has been completely wrong. It's not hard to understand where that action came from.
Robert Dog Nero
Daniel Dog Lewis
@@keimat4470 Donald Woofterland
Leonardog Decaprio
Robert RedSetterford
I’ve never been so relieved to see a dog vomit in my entire life.
The only character we know is telling the truth in the whole movie and he can't even speak English, let alone French or German.
That last scene killed me. Whether it was or wasn’t scripted, it was a magical scene all the same.
The last is actually his trainer telling him to jump up on the bed and lay down
From what ive heard that was just improvised. The dog just did that
@@cheycheyfriend247 no i saw his trainer and she said she commanded to do it
His performance reminds me of Jed, who acted in films like white fang and the Thing but was in tons of movies while he was alive because he was uniquely talented. Most dogs have their tails cgi'd because they can't stop wagging them, but he had a strange stillness about him that made him stand out. This dog has that same thousand yard stare.
i immediately thought of jed when watching this. it's absolutely the expression in the face and the body movement. many dog actors are very well trained but you can tell they are depending heavily on the trainer and due to the precision of commands they tend to look a bit "mechanical" in their movement and faces. most people can't tell and so their acting work is perfectly fine but not exceptional. jed and messi have a way about them that feels like they are interpreting the instructions given by the trainer in their own unique way, the same as a human actor might do with a script.
@@someembarrassingLPs
Sorry to reply three weeks behind, but something else Messi here definitely shares with his "phenomenal animal actor" predecessor is his complete lack of looking at the camera. The one time in The Thing where Jed looked directly into the camera, it fit with the story and actually worked to add tension to the scene and make the audience uncomfortable - pushing toward the common compliment Jed was given by his trainers and costars that any move he made, that would be "just something an animal actor will do" to almost every other animal in film, seemed to fit perfectly with the character he was playing.
And now, throughout Anatomy of a Fall, Messi's never making eye contact with the camera either. He's fantastic. There are dogs in Horror that can't be focused on directly when playing dead, especially for such long shots, because they can't keep still or make it as believable as Messi managed. Whether that's because he's a Border Collie and Jed was a Wolfdog, or because he and Jed are/were actually aliens disguised as Good Boys, us humans will never know. But they definitely have a special talent for the roles they've been given.
im pretty sure jed was half wolf which is why he didnt wag his tail
I haven't seen the movie but almost started crying when I thought he was dead. Now that's is some effective acting!!
This dog definitely needs an Academy Award, by far the best performance I have ever seen
The best dog acting I've seen since The Thing (1982). It's almost scary how good Messi's acting is.
best animal actor...the aspirin scene! behind the scene please!
Can't. They'd get sued for how they got the dog to behave that way. There's no way that was not drug-enhanced. And you know, of course, that that scene could've been filmed over many days and the key moments edited together. Yeah, the Animal Rights would be all over whatever they were up to. But hey, it's all for Art so they get a pass.
He played dead so well that I cried!
It's amazing how expressive this dog was!
Sandra Huller: I'm the standout of Anatomy of a Fall
Snoop: Hold my bark
It's like he took Dog Acting classes at Juillbark School
this dog actually came to my work once but i didnt get to see him. i was so star struck when i saw his paw prints outside.
Probably the best acting from a dog since The Thing remake.
I’m so happy I am not the only one that was amazed 😅
Thank you for uploading this!! WE LOVE SNOOP 🧡
I don't think it's even far to assume this dog was an aspiring actor in it's past life
So happy he/she got the recognition they deserve in this life!
A masterclass in canine performance right here.
Snoop did it. Deserves best actor.
They need to have a Biggest Bag of Treats Award for phenomenal dogs like this! This dog should win one!
Lassie don't have nothing on Messi. Kudos to the actor and his trainer.
The overdose scene was a real dog?! What the fuck
Yep he was trained to act sick. The vomit was added in with CGI but everything else was just good training
This has got to be one of the most talented dogs I've ever seen.
amazing handlers, beautiful performance in this film snoop. the dog & handlers all need an oscar for this because it is truly a work of art. regardless of understanding the language, the acting between the son & especially snoop the dog is phenomenal. breathtaking !!
Amazing acting of a dog and this is how a star is born y'all
snoop ate this up omg
Good job, Messi and his trainer!! ❤
He is he greatest animal actor in a long long time. King.
right up there with Jed's performance in The Thing
I searched for this video after hearing Kimmel mention his performance on the Oscars.
A cast so good even the dog killed it 👌
This dog took play dead to the next level
I loved "Snoop" AKA Messi. 💘💖💕 I was scared for him when he had OD'ed. I was glad when he was OK. 🐶❤
One of the all-time great canine performances in cinema history (up there with the alien dog from "The Thing")
Sandra Hüller's canine co-stars in "Anatomy of a Fall" and "The Zone of Interest" were both awesome.
milo best actor messi best suppoerting actor... i said what i said
I return to this video regularly to remember what truly good acting is.
nah that bith is way too smart to pretend to be dead like that, thats a well trained animal like damn,
I must watch this for Messi
It's a great one, very thought-provoking
He was a good boy, and he did a good job!
I’m not ashamed to admit I watched this movie just for the dog alone.
The aspirin scene and the ending got me crying so hard i feel asleep after.... All because his acting shook me
And he got uninvited from the Oscar’s literally how dare they
he was invited again by POPULAR DEMAND
So Messi is going to win the Oscar for best actor? The meme would come true 😂
That tracking shot from the dogs perspective is beautiful. To me it suggests the dog is the heart and truth of the movie
Guys! I found out today he didn’t win an Oscar but he did win the Palm Dog Award at Cannes 2023 (which has been around since 2001) so fret not he is indeed a internationally acclaimed award winning Good Boy 🏆
Apparently the last scene was Messi's owm acting. Truly an acting phenomenon.
And yet he was snubbed by the academy.
I had a border collie, great dog.. highly intelligent and easily trained. Wasn't an actor, though he did a little improv.
this dog made me so happy while watching the movie
I have never seen this movie but I already know this is the most talented dog in cinema
Something about Messi at 1:12 is so unnerving. It’s a beautiful shot, but it almost makes it feel like he knows exactly what happened but he can’t say anything because he’s a dog. That look in his eyes says all.
bradley cooper could never
Like can somebody tell me? How the hell he did the choking, eyes , and the tongue… Like did they really poisoned him? HOOOWW HE ACTED BETTER THAN MOST OF THE ACTORS NOW?
He did two months of training for that scene but I'm still flabbergasted at how he was able to do it. What as seriously impressive performance from Messi.
border collies are super smart and clearly the owner of Messi trains him incredibly well
I think they used some VFX for the eyes as well
Jfc no, they didn't really POISON the dog. The playing dead is superb, but the eyes are CGI, the vomit is from a hidden tube.
What a good boy.
the most impressive, for me, is him hitting all the marks during the long shot. Like stopping, maneuvering relative to the camera, looking at people etc. 1:26 like thats difficult for a person...
He was SNUBBED for best actor!
Snoop is a Border Collie , ofcourse is a smart trooper ❤
Having had a blue merle border collie I can say no dog is as capable of acting, undertaking tasks or understanding instructions as one of them (if food is a reward).
this dog be a better actor than some humans oml
Before this, the best dog acting for me was in the Thing, when he’s the monster in disguise and is stalking the halls.
I haven't seen a dog this good at his job since Jed from John Carpenter's The Thing.
Border collies are so brilliant ❤❤❤
I JUST WATCHED THIS FILM. His acting is soo good 😅😅
the aspirin scene, man i still don't know how they filmed it
Please give Sandra Hüller her well deserved academy, anyway ❤
The last thing i expected to heard in this movie is 50 Cents's PIMP and i loved it.
That last scene... "I know you did it, but I still love you."
Messi should have won Best Supporting Actor! idgaf about Oppenheimer and RDJ
every single actor in this movie was amazing even the fcking dog
Je crois que je vais revisionner le film avec plus d'attention à l'incroyable performance de Snoop ( Messi) . wow.. I love that dog.
pretty sure this dog is smarter than 60% of americans. and i'm american so i'm allowed to say it.
And where is his OSCAR? You telling me RDJ won but messi got snubbed ? Something so sinister about this……
Messi's acting was so good that at a point I suspecting him of being the murderer
That dog should jave been nominated over Gosling, Ruffalo or RDJ
When I saw this screened at NlY Film Festival, the director and Sandra were there. This little cute doggo is actually Sandra's dog!!!
This fella clearly took inspiration by the one from the thing 😂
so he walked around, and then layed down... wow powerful lol
Now THAT is a good boy