Catherine the Great - Lies - Extra History
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ส.ค. 2024
- Catherine the Great ruled for many years - too many for a six-episode show to cover completely. James talks about the mistakes we made and the stories we left out!
* Watch Extra History ad-free & get 1-week early access on NEBULA go.nebula.tv/e...
* Suggest & Vote on our next episodes, get exclusive content & 24-hour early access on PATREON bit.ly/EHPatreon
* Show off your fandom with MERCH from our store! extracredits.st...
Interested in sponsoring an episode? Email us: extracredits@standard.tv
TWITTER: bit.ly/ECTweet I FACEBOOK: bit.ly/ECFBPage
INSTAGRAM: bit.ly/ECisonIn... I TIKTOK: bit.ly/ECtiktokz
BLUESKY: bit.ly/ECBlueSky I TWITCH: bit.ly/ECtwitch
GAMING: / @extracredits
Miss an episode in our Catherine the Great Series?
Part 1 - • Catherine the Great - ...
Part 2 - • Catherine the Great - ...
Part 3 - • Catherine the Great - ...
Part 4 - • Catherine the Great - ...
Part 5 - • Catherine the Great - ...
Part 6 - • Catherine the Great - ...
Series Wrap-up & Lies Episode - • Catherine the Great - ...
♪ "Ascension in C" by Sean and Dean Kiner - • ♫ "Ascension in C" - S... - Available on Patreon!
Thanks for the high-quality conversations & for following our community guidelines here: bit.ly/ECFansR...
Host/Extra History Writer: James Portnow
#ExtraHistory #CatherinetheGreat #History
James talks about the mistakes we made and the stories we left out in the tale of Catherine the Great!
Support us on Patreon: www.patreon.com/ExtraCredits/
S. I. V. Yes I want to know
James, your pronunciation of Moscow bothers me. You pronounce it like it is a cow made of moss. The best English pronunciation ends in a long 'O' sound silent 'W'. :)
Oh, I'm going to be at the Hermitage Museum in May! I didn't realize art formally owned by Robert Walpole is housed there! :D
Well, I always had a thing for art. ;)
Aww still no frederick the great or bismarck? (although i would personally prefer frederick)
"And we basically get to apologize for having flags in the show." - Savage. :D
S. I. V. First few sentences
It's not like they were using the Tricolor or something. for pre-Revolutionary France. A lot of people tend to thing the Russian Empire flag always had the yellow canton with the double eagle in the top left, but that was only used in the last few years of the empire.
Being paranoid is pretty normal for any autocratic ruler who gains power via coup. We tend to romanticize the business of monarchy these days, but actually it's always pretty murderous.
Who does that?
Otherwise I agree. Many monarchs died a fast death/young death.
I've actually been seeing a rise of romanticizing monarchs, mostly be people who feel that the 'ordained by (the roman catholic) god' gives them special 'will do what is best for people because they are different' powers.
Wait what? Thats new to me. Such medival believes shouldnt be around in modern Europe.
You can thank Disney for that romanticism.
what?? weve always talked shit about those
1:21 ''She isn't seen as quite as favorably in Poland and Lithuania'' Gee I wonder why ?
Mikhail Bychkov im lithuanian
and i'm Russian, nice to meet you! Now... give us your means of productions comrade
Mikhail Bychkov I think I need to show you commies a big bullet of FREEDOM *bald eagle caw*
lol, they have none.
awww... But they do have land, yes ?
Catherine's forced resettlement of jews to isolated catons (the "Pale of Settlement") is particularly interesting to me because I have spent quite a long time reading Robert Massie's generally excellent biography of her and it does not mention this at all.
It is an object lesson in the need for multiple sources- and in the danger of becoming too fond of your subject matter. It also puts me in mind of another biography I read, of Marie Antoinette, by Antonia Fraser, which utterly failed to include any serious discussion of the attempts Antoinette made to restore her husband's rule in the days of her and her husband's captivity - including letters in which she bluntly attempted to procure military aid to overthrow the Revolution which might have at least partially justified her execution on grounds that it would have been suicidally dangerous for the Revolution to keep her and her husband alive. (though I concede the matter is debatable).
It is also a reminder that although we may take many admirable things from the leaders of the past, we should never seek to blindly emulate them.
Well said.
Agreed.
She in articles online I have found she sucame some with the russian antisemitic mentality. I read that mentality was not present where she grew up and also if you dig hard enough she pardoned some Jewish people from living there and supposedly a Jewish man saved her in her youth.
I still genuinely think of her as a good ruler. It's hard to find a ruler that I admire.
I can't stand Peter the great. His son alexi makes me sad.
I've been looking into Europe and antisemitism and until England had a ruler that was holding the throne that looked the other way to Jewish people living there, antisemitism had been widespread.
Generally ireland has had good relationships with its Jewish population.
It's sad there's currently places in the world that don't think the holocaust was as bad as people say.
James, you don't have to keep it short due to us thinking we don't care about a longer part. I think most people actually want it longer!,
Dear God, Ivan VI's story is utterly heartbreaking. Somebody spends his whole life in prison for no crime of his own (not even the pretense of a crime, just for existing), he only knows a handful of people, and he is murdered in cold blood. It reminds me of the Kafes in the Ottoman Empire, where the Sultan would keep his second and third sons in prison and strangle them to death the moment his first son had children (even if the second and third sons were infants).
If I was one of the guards I too would have tried to help crown Ivan, just because of how much I feel sorry for him. It's too bad the guards didn't succeed; somebody who spent his whole life in prison might be more sympathetic to the plight of the serfs.
Seriously WTF was THAT?! Here's me sort of listening calmly, when all of a sudden this gets dropped. Good lord. Russia....
It's almost like... The Russian version of The Man in the Iron Mask: Royalty Edition
17:00 nice of her to think of the doctor's life. I would think all monarchs would be so thoughtfull
Wait, did Ivan VI even know who HE was?
An Elder Scrolls main character.
Veniczar B. Pavel You have no idea how much I want that to be the set up of an Elder Scrolls game now.
He actually did seem to know, since he referred to himself as the Gosudar(sovereign). However, he was otherwise uneducated and thus, as mentioned never really attempted to lead a rebellion himself(also a bit difficult from jail).
I kinda wonder who told him he was the secret emperor when he hadn't seen his parents since he was two. Someone who felt sorry for him?
In Poland we call Catherine Katarzyna Wielka so Catherine the Great is used also in Poland when talking about her.
You know, I keep thinking that today is the day that Walpole won't be tied back into it... and the day Walpole can't be related to an Extra History episode, I don't know if I'll be relieved or devastated...
When is it never not me?
It's our god walpole
WAAAAALPOOOOOLE!
When it was the Mongols... but that was the exception... and another channel.
Alex Pope it's always Walpole's fault, and the Mongols are always the exception.
will there ever be an episode about Alexander the Great
bump
become a patreon and vote for it.
risker34 I have no money. I am poor
Beggars can't be choosers.
I would go for one about Ashoka first, since he's less well known and also did something more than just conquer.
Thank you for mentioning the Pale of Settlement
what part of history HASN'T Robert Walpole and his family had any involvments in? seriously, next thing you know they tie this family back to the Roman soldier who speared Jesus when he was crucified.
That was their ancestor.
You guys have run into a lot of sad chapters of Jewish history; do you guys think you'll ever have the chance to do one of the brighter chapters of Jewish history? The Hasmonean dynasty, the politics around the discovery of Deuteronomy or some other episode where Jews had some agency? It just would be a nice change of pace
They did do that episode about the Jewish Vizier in Granada, "Prince of all the Jews" I think
Well they did that one episode of that jewish prince in Anatolia. But yeah variety is always nice.
*Andalusia
I was thinking of a time period when the community as a whole had more weight. I remember HaNagid episode, although if they only got around to more profiles I would be down with a Dona Garcia or a Mendelssohn episode (I'm not a Patreon donor though :/ )
Perhaps they could explore theology a little. Jewish/Christian creation story and myths.
Yes! Edward "Ned" Kelly is next! :D
Sure, most Aussies grew up hearing his story (and the theories about one of his brothers surviving the final shootout), but it'll be nice to get a bit of our lore spread around the world!
Great, someone I do not know yet.
Aussie here.
Ned Kelly sucks.
Aussie here. Ned Kelly was a hero and you are certainly living up to your name duck
The one item of Australian history anyone outside Australia has heard of.
AgentTasmania I would argue that the Great Emu War has spread pretty far across the world.
Another great episode of Lies, Walpole, and Walpole's Lies.
Well, it's not a Lies episode without me. ;)
Dammit walpole just how many historical events have you got yourself into.
The Raging Storm all of them. Absolutely all of them.
4 1/2 minutes in, "let's get started." i love extra history
did Catherine just Walpole a Walpole?
Mateo Gg Or did Walpole just Walpole Walpole?
IT WAS WALPOLE!
Or was it ALL just Walpole?
Catherine Was Walpole all allong.
Please do the series about Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth. It's great material to explain and talk about. I would be so happy :3.
"Catherine was an autocrat at heart..."
Aren't we all? I mean, all of us with a reasonable chance of making it into a position of power.
Well, you know what they say about power and corruption.
Timothy McLean A pinch of elitism, an ounce of power corruption, and for flavor some well-intentioned extremism
"Nature has left this tincture in the blood, That all men would be tyrants if they could."
- Daniel Defoe
Timothy McLean I don't think so. It is possible for people in positions of power to just not want complete control- George Washington is a great example, as his officers wanted to overthrow congress and institute a dictatorship after congress failed to pay them. Washington was horrified by the thought, and shot it down without a second thought. This was much like his inspiration, Cincinnatus, once made dictator of the Roman Republic, but upon dealing with a war that threatened Rome, he relinquished all his power and returned to his farm.
Timothy, I think Alexander II of Russia and Pedro II of Brazil would like to speak with you. These are two Emperors that were consistently checking and limiting their own power (Pedro didn't even really want to rule, from my understanding)
I absolutely and genuinely love the way you talk about history. Your passion and enthuisiasm is really infectious.
I was hoping for a mention of Catherine's patronage of Francisco De Miranda. A good tie-in to the Bolivar story, and yet another part of nis amazing life.
No don't keep is shorter! I could watch this everyday. James is a great speaker.
Extra History is definitely my favourite series. I came for the video games and stayed for the history lessons.
this channel is awesome because unlike literally everyone they admit their mistakes
Love this part of the show! Only downside is I wish it was longer and more in depth like at the beginning.
I still don't get why people keep emphasizing the difference between Czar and Emperor (or "Imperator"). They're basically synonymous! Like earl and count and graf. A whole bunch of European aristocratic titles were ill-defined or overlapping through multiple languages. It's not like there was ever a central regulatory body for various monarchs/despots/sovereigns/etc. to refer to when their titles needed sorting.
OMG! I can't believe I just gave in and started watching this series and you're about to cover Ned Kelly! Such an icons for us Aussies (ofc he is a crim but we aren't as inherently dark on that down here, haha). In our schools he's covered as quite a hero to be honest. By the way, I absolutely loved this history on Catherine the Great, whom I think must have been quite the bad arse despite her flaws. Keep it up guys!
It's good to see Max Landis branching out and telling stories about history.
Interesting to note is that Peter III is often portrayed differently in sources that weren't tainted Catherine's influence. Palmer describes him as progressive:
-He abolished the secret police.
-He made education mandatory for the nobility.
-He promoted mercantilism (which removed some power from the nobility, see there was a reason they all liked Catherine so much).
-He gave serfs protections from their masters and gave certain ones more rights and freedoms.
-He started reforming the Russian military along Prussian lines.
-He enacted religious freedom.
-He wished to secularize many Church institutions.
Yes, he had many faults, he was not the brilliant intellectual that Catherine was, he was vehemently German, and his actions in the 7 years war can be seen as either stupid or naive and idealistic. But it's a but unfair to say he was all bad.
Killing Ivan was a mercy, living a life in isolation like that is unbelievable cruel
A mercy would be releasing Ivan. One gets no points for mercy if a more merciful action is within one's power to do.
Great and informative series but people seem forget that Chaterine was a brutal dictator (as rulers were in that time) whom in her later years gave up on the enlightment almost completly to focus on maintaining her own powerbase.
The history of the Pale of Settlement is worth a few episodes itself. Especially the sad ending of it.
She is called the great not only in Russia but also in Germany and other countries
Alright, time for the annual summoning: Walpole...Walpole...Walpole!
*Falls from the sky*
You rang?
Robert Walpole Great seeing you again, old friend. How goes joyriding on the rug of space and time? Also, as is the theme of these summonings, have you ever been traveling around during the 7 year war? And if so, what were the likes of Voltaire, Frederick and Catherine the Great *really* like?
You gotta do Frederick the Great soon as well!
Der Alte Frtiz was an interesting guy!
Jeez this story about Ivan VI is one of the saddest stories I've ever heard...
Ooh if you're doing an Australian, I'll nominate Sir John A Macdonald - the alcoholic who founded Canada - for the next series.
Are they going to do an Australian? I'd be up for hearing about Sir John A though!
Ned Kelly
Agilemind isn't John a Mcdonald Scottish or irish?
He was also Canada's first Prime Minister, and a drunk.... I wouldn't say he *founded* Canada, though.
He was born in Scotland but lived in Canada from a very young age.
Somewhat of a worry: the story flow from episode to episode of a part of the series has gotten a bit choppy. Like, a story got dropped off without getting resolved. Other than that the show is great. Keep up the good work!
It was Walpole
-'s art collection...
I would love a series about Frederick the Great.
i like theway theese videos have gone from 2 minutes to 22
Would love if there was a series about Portugal in the near future
I would love a series on the war of the roses
Excellent series. I forgot how interesting some of these Extra History videos can be.
You really should call these episodes "xxx - Oh, and... - Extra History"
I love the longer tangents you go on
The FFXI music gives me crazy nostalgia. I want to decorate my Mog House again!
When I hear Australia, I remember one thing.
Never forget the Great Emu War.
BTW for those that haven't notice this girls are pretty much their adult height at 14 assuming good nutrition. (Boys are pretty much adult height at 16.) She was going to have good nutrition so by the time we're talking about she was either at or almost at her adult height.
God dammed, you guys are by far my favorite TH-cam-Channel.
After your finished with Ned Kelly, can you guys PLEASE do an Extra History on Frederick the Great? He has to be my favorite person/character from this time period.
Oh jeeze, if you could show Minnesota some love and do a Paul Bunyan one. That’s would forsure be shown in my and most history classes! Love the shorts, quick and factual.
Lithuania getting some love!!!!
The other thing that was not covered sufficiently well in the first episode was the fact that Catherine’s father was the co-ruler of the Principality of Anhalt-Zerbst, ruling alongside Catherine’s uncle, Johann Ludwig II. It’s kind of mentioned but they don’t explain it well.
The other thing not mentioned is that Catherine actually outlived that younger brother of hers, Frederick Augustus, and although the Anhalt lands of the family went to other branches, Catherine did inherit the Lordship of Jever from her brother (located on the North Sea coast, eventually formed the most northwestern portion of the state Oldenburg) as it had been acquired by Catherine’s family when her great-great-great grandmother, Magdalene of Oldenburg, married into the Anhalt-Zerbst branch of the House of Ascania. Catherine became the Lady of Jever and the territory was governed by her sister-in-law, the Dowager Princess of Anhalt-Zerbst Friederike Auguste Sophie until the end of the state at Napoleon’s hands in 1806. The Lordship would be turned over to the Grand Duchy of Oldenburg by Tsar Alexander I following the end of the Napoleonic Wars, as it was ruled over by his paternal second cousin, twice removed
If you guys at Extra Credits are reading this, could a series on Timur be put on your Patreon page as a possible series? He was the last great Mongol conqueror and his descendants would eventually create the Mughal Empire.
All this Final Fantasy 11 music. So great to hear while learning history.
You guys should do a series on the Treaty of Waitangi. It's the only instance where the British crown has ever tried to settle peacefully in a country and there's a ton of interesting little stories around it.
Catherine the Great on the serfs: Trickle Down Freedom.
12:52
Its almost like a War of the Roses situation, only with the Lancastrians keeping the Mortimers locked away and certainly not allowing them to marry back into a leading noble family (who also happens to be a junior branch themselves) and thus producing a child who is an awesome military leader, and also has an awesome sauce bloodline that is kind of superior to the King's own claim of descent from Edward III. Oops!
I just wanted to say that I am super excited about you doing Ned Kelly. He is quite a hotly debated person here in Australia, particularly in Victoria, whether he was a hero or a villian!
Remember that Fredrick is the guy that made an essay trying to debunk Machiavelli
I like how a bunch of the lies are "you guys thought we were wrong but we weren't for once ha!" XD
I've waited all week for this!
18:45 James says Kazakhs, but the image says Cossacks, which is it? Those aren't the same people (though interestingly, their names are etymologically related).
icedragon769 I think he said Cossacks, he just said it in a way that sounded like Kazakhs.
Precisely. And, yeah, it would be interesting to see episode or two about cossacks.
He speaks about cossacks[kaz-ak]. But yeah, pronouncation is really similar to kazakhs[kuh-zakh]. To make it even more weird, Russian pronunciation of kazakh butchers it a bit - [ka-zah]
Haha, that's actually funny, becouse there are sound and spell even more simular in russian. This even more confusing, becouse kazakhs were part of Russian Empire too at the time. I made this mistakes few times when I read history books and I am a kazakh)
I think Kazakh and Cossack both mean 'free man'.
Great video. Also, had to take a happy double-take when I heard the Vana'diel music in the bg.
Man, you know you're a Car Talk fan when you hear "this is the part of Extra History where I get to confess our mistakes, talk about our errors, and" and think "share the solution to last week's Puzzler!"
Now I just want to know more about Frederick the Great.
Thanks for always making followups
great intro there james lol
i miss our book club and seeing you apartment lol
Some of these weird political twisty twists make for great inspiration. Gonna take note of some of the stuff from that whole Ivan thing. It sounds like material I could use in one of my games, they often involve nasty backstabby political shenanigans.
And what's this? The next series is about an australian outlaw? Oooh, sounds fun. XD
Ivan VI's life sounds like something from 'Game of Thrones' or an Alexandre Dumas novel!
i'm actually really excited for Ned Kelly! As an Australian, I know of him and how he was an outlaw and what he wore, but beyond that, all I know is he's seen as our 'Robin Hood', so to speak. The episodes can't come soon enough :)
correcting mistakes made makes extra credits better.
...I'm sorry I got really distracted. I was super excited to hear the FFXI music ...lol...
The story of an outlaw on Extra History... I am now interested
It's okay to say that a historical figure has a dark side. Please don't apologize over it and call it a character flaw.
I'm looking forward to the next series. I don't know much about Australian history, so I hope to learn alot.
Frederick the Great next.
Thank you
Lithuanian here. Really sad that Lithuania a part of the Commonwealth wasnt mentioned once in the series :(
Your Channel is AWESOME!!!
Im sorry im not good writing in english, i would love to explain properly how happy i am to see this videos of you.
Greetings from Peru :D
This music was excellent. I think I will download it.
you certainly don't seem to be minding the busy schedule James.
It was cool to hear the story about Ivan VI. I doubt even he knew who he was nor why he was a prisoner.
Seeing as it's Canada's 150th anniversary, would you kindly consider doing Sir John A. MacDonald and the Confederation of Canada (which was begun in Charlottetown, PEI)? Thank you.
Still sad that Alexander Suvorov wasn't even mentioned.
But perhaps Extra History will get around to the French Revolutionary Wars and we'll see him then.
It would be a disgrace to just forget about this guy.
I'd never, ever, heard about catherine's sexual escapes until this series.
Catherine has been sneeringly talked about in sexual terms ever since she was alive, and especially after her death, when someone right after her death started spreading the rumor that she was fucked to death by a horse.
Dean Cutler i was actualy suprised they didn't talk about it earlier.
It was in the big bang theory. Terrible show...but millions of people watch it.
It was a polish propaganda. They were a bit upset at that time. Not that anyone cared, though.
VonKrauzer yea but it would be such a perfect ending.
It's not right to call Potemkin Villages entirely fictitious since the term has since been used for entirely real deceptions and to call them entirely fictitious implies that those are also fictitious.
It is more correct to say that the association with Potemkin is fictitious or slanderous.
I first heard about Catherine the Great from ERB.
Best part of "Lies" is the FFXI music imo
could you guys just do an entire series or one off about Walpole?
THANK YOU! THANK YOU FOR MENTIONING LITHUANIA!!
3:52 they had foresight for what was to come
One flaw: Katherine became quite fat in her later years. But her appearance here at Extra Credits keeps its slim figure.
Who was really the father of Catherine's so- It was Walpole.
So the murder of Peter III was basically "someone rid me of my turbulent husband?"
Some personal criticism, I suggest that this series are made slightly longer and more in depth, as it's getting to the point where the lies episode is way more interesting than any other episode in the series, when in fact it should be a place to correct and fit in little stuff that HAD to be cut out, not mayor events like the whole Ivan ordeal. Keep up the great work.
Didn't you already mention you guys calling Russian monarchs "Czar" in the WW1 videos with Nicky?
I have NEVER in my life heard of this horse thing before! XD could that possibly be a thing more popular in the English-speaking realm?