Catholic vs Orthodox Easter, Which Calendar is CORRECT?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ต.ค. 2024
- In this video, you will learn about why the date of Easter shifts every single year, why Catholics and Orthodox Christians celebrate Easter on different dates and lastly, the differences between the Julian and the Gregorian Calendar.
I hope this video has provided value to you. If so, please like, comment, share and subscribe. Your support will help us reach more people!
Also, follow me on Tik-Tok: @voiceofreason_clips for daily content that you won't find here. If you have any suggestions for video topics you'd like me to cover, please comment them down below.
#catholic #catholicchurch #orthodoxchristian #orthodoxchristianity #orthodox #easter #eastersunday #resurrection #jesus #jesuschrist #christianity
As a Catholic, I love my Eastern brethren. Whether you celebrate on the Gregorian or the Julian date, praise God that Christ is risen 🙏🏻✝️
Very good job. Proud to be a member of Catholic Church 🤍🙏💛
Pr*de is a sin.
@@OrthoKarterThat’s a different kind of pride, but yeah.
This is awesome historical insight. Keep up the great work.
I might need to watch it twice to better understand. Thank you so much for being an Instrument of Christ to create this content.
Sometimes is not only about a week the difference between the two dates but it's actually a whole Month. Take for example the Easter of 2024. The Catholic Easter is on March 31st and the Orthodox Easter is on May 5th. BTW this is a very good video. 👍🏻
This is a great video! I look forward to seeing more content from you - God bless!
Reunite the churches ✝️
This was so well done
I am glad and grateful to be an Orthodox Christian.
I am very much happy to be a Christian and not an orthodox anymore
Good job! I was listening to this whilst playing my old games which helped me listen
Great intro bro! You have a bright future ahead of you Deo Gratias
Fun trivia here, in Armenia Easter is celebrated on the Gregorian calendar date, but Christmas is celebrated on January 6th. In the country of Jordan the opposite is true for all Christian’s in there, where Easter is celebrated on the Julian calendar but Christmas is celebrated on Dec 25th
The Catholic Church is like a singularity in which all else revolves around or becomes apart of. Jesus is at the center of it, all Glory be to God.
Love your stuff man
The filmography is great. The others weren’t bad. But this is an improvement ❤❤❤
I definitely need to watch this video at least twice 😁
As a Catholic, I love all Orthodox traditions and liturgy☦️❤️
Have you looked at the Eastern Catholic rites?
Very good voice of reason you are extremely talented at your job
And i like the intro how long did it take to make?
🥰🥰🥰I did not know that about Easter ❤️ so neat!
Very well said.. Thankyou🙏 amen🙏
EO here: you failed to mention the Catholic Church also switched from the physical full moon to an “ecclesiastical full moon” which is up to 4 days off from the physical moon.
I believe that is the real difference. If you look in the sky - it’s not “after the full moon” when Catholics celebrate Easter but before, but in the Catholic church they use a theoretical “ecclesiastical moon”.
The Orthodox still uses the physical full moon we see in the sky.
Wrong!
So many gems in this video!!
Thank you! ❤️
Thank you. Didn’t Polycarp visit the bishop of Rome over this?
Gospel John 15:1-8
I am the vine, you are the branches
Jesus said to his disciples:
‘I am the true vine,
and my Father is the vinedresser.
Every branch in me that bears no fruit
he cuts away,
and every branch that does bear fruit
he prunes to make it bear even more.
This year Jews will celebrate Pesach on the evening of Monday 22nd of April. Christians who use the Gregorian calendar will celebrate Easter on 31st March. Christians on the Julian calendar will celebrate Easter after Pesach on May 5th.
Amazing video
What you have said is not completely true and accurate, regarding Eastern Orthodox Church. The reason why EO doesn't accept gregorian calendar is because it was in their mind during that time breaking ancient nicean canons to count pascha with solar calendar.
Also another thing that you missed out is that the most correct calendar is not Gregorian calendar but Milankovics calendar, or so called Revised Julian calendar that was introduced in 1920s. In the council that happened during that time EOs have agreed that you can follow this new calendar but that you have to count pascha on solar or julian calendar.
I don't know whether entire East would accept this new revised julian calendar or not, but so far there are no major problems.
Can you talk at your next video about filioque and what is your opinion that catholics have the pope that is the highest posision of someone but eastern orthodox have patriarchs that are equal between them
Im proud to be a christian😊
Nice work 👏👏👏👏👏
Catholic and Orthodox united by Christ✝️☦️🕊
Hey I know you said orthodox, catholic, and Assyrian are all viable yet they don’t view each others that way. Can you clarify this a bit in a future video?
The Julian and Gregorian Easter are sometimes on the same day, otherwise there is a week or more difference.
Good video
Quick question. Do Eastern Catholics use the Gregorian or Julian calendar?
They use both. There are two Ukrainian Catholic churches (byzantine rite) near my home. One uses the Gregorian calendar, and the other uses the Julian calendar. Actually, half of the parish left the first church after it adopted the Gregorian calendar and formed the second X number of years ago. I only know this because I plan on visiting one.
@@Saiyan585 Thank you!
I know many easterners claim that it coincides with the miracle of the holy fire. Thoughts on this?
The Miracle of the Holy Fire on Easter & the Miracle of the Light of Mount Tabor on the Transfiguration only ever happen on the Patristic Calendar, never the Gregorian calendar.
I have a question for catholic brothers. Do you believe in the Holy Fire, because it happens at the same time of orthodox easter?
Watch Jimmy Akin he address this
Isn’t Easter always supposed to fall after Passover according to Nicaea?
5:49 “On Adar 11, 5540 Anno Mundi (A.M.) (Wednesday, February 24, 1616 A.D.), the consultants [Catholic Magisterium] unanimously reported the assessment that heliocentrism was philosophically (i.e., scientifically) false and theologically heretical or at least erroneous.
"The following day, the Inquisition, presided by Pope St. Paul V, considered the case. Although it did not endorse the heresy recommendation, it accepted the judgments of scientific falsity and theological error, and decided to prohibit the theory.
"Thus, on Adar 13, 5540 A.M. (Friday, February 26, 1616 A.D.) the Inquisition’s most authoritative cardinal, St. Robert Bellarmine (5467-5546 A.M. / 1542-1621 A.D.), met with Galileo in private and gave him the following warning: the Church was going to declare the idea of the Earth’s motion false and contrary to Scripture, and so this theory could not be held or defended. Galileo agreed to comply." ♥️
Jesus wish for us to unites celebrating Easter , it doesn’t matter for him the date if it’s right or precise but He want us to be united in one , it’s just sad that The Catholic and Protestant already celebrated ate and drank and celebrated around the world without the Eastern Orthodox Church. Pride it’s what separates us Christians Catholic versus Orthodox versus Protestant only Humility can unite us back together and it will be powerful and effective ways to evangelize the whole World 🙏🙏🙏
Opinion for YOUCAT book?
Do you believe in the Holy Fire that is ignited at Jerusalem every year?
Yes! Every time I watch it it gives me chills! 🙏🏽
@@VoiceOfReason_Jimmy Akin address this, it not real
This year 2024 Orthodox Easter is a five week difference, Catholics March, 31 and Orthodox May, 5th.
Orthodox are a hot mess 😢
Having said this. What do you think about the talks between pope Francis and the patriarch of the Greek orthodox church in using the same calendar?
The Feast of the Resurrection must fall after the Jewish celebration of the Passover.
The church have the keys of the kingdom of God on earth, whatever they bind on earth is bind in heaven, you have no say in this matter, protestant are heretic, and the Jewish passover over and done away
Greetings! ... Some would say that neither of them is correct... The "FirstFruits" (Resurrection of Christ) is always upon the 3rd Day of Passover (Pascha) "according to the scriptures."
( 1 Corinthians 15 : 1 - 4 & Leviticus 23 : 4 - 14 .. 1 Cor. 5 : 7 -8 ... 1 Cor. 15 : 20 - 23 )
Easter/Eostre is a pagan fertility sun-goddess celebrated around the time of the Spring equinox... and has nothing to do with the gospel of Jesus Christ. : (
Easter is only called Easter in Germanic languages because the feast of Pascha happened to coincide with the secular Anglo-Saxon feast of Eostre which also began roughly around springtime. Eostre was named after an ancient Anglo-Saxon feast day for what St. Bede thought might have been a god, but he is the only source for this and it's possible Eostre was just an Anglo-Saxon word for rising or new life. Either way, this is no different than using the names "March" or "June" for the months in our calendars since clearly we are not celebrating pagan deities by simply using their names and they are just convenient distinctions in time we can use to calculate dates of events.
Prior to Saint Gregory the Great's evangelization of the Anglo-Saxon people in the 6th century, Easter (Pascha or a variation of Pascha in Latin, Greek, and Aramaic; the languages of the early Church) was celebrated on the same day and was not even named after a secular celebration since they just used their word for "passover" in their respective languages. If we are going to quibble about the use of pagan names in Christian life, we should all really only use Hebrew names, since all translations of original Biblical names have some degree of paganization in order to make the sounds pronounceable to foreign tongues. Even so, "Moses" was an Egyptian pagan name and "Christ" (which is where your name comes from) was a Greek pagan title meaning "anointed one" before the word Messiah (meaning the same thing) was translated from Hebrew into Greek as Christ. Even the word "passover" is an invention by Protestant William Tyndale as the Hebrews used the same word "Pascha" which is similar but etymologically very different.
Even if our calculations for the date of Easter (pascha) were pagan, the Holy Spirit continues to guide the Church (the new Israel and the new temple) through the successors of the Apostles. Surely whether we're celebrating the risen Christ today, tomorrow, or yesterday, we are still loving Christ as best we can. Holy scripture doesn't even tell us to celebrate Easter (pascha) on a specific day, just that we ought to celebrate the risen Christ. Thus, the Church, following the custom of the earliest Christians, was free to choose one day to celebrate. This is now binding on Christian because our authorities, using their powers to bind and loose (Matthew 16) have told us as Christians that it is spiritually adventagious for all of us to gather on the same day to worship, which is not unreasonable.
If you have a problem with the Church making her own feast days, you are not trusting the protection of the Holy Spirit given to the Bishops, Priests, and Deacons of Jesus Christ to bind and loose, especially given to Saint Peter and his successors
@@catholicchad2254 ... Hello again,, and thank you for your thoughtful reply... Your video came across my recommended front page... so i also thoughtfully replied to the question in your video-title ... and will now again...
In regards to binding and loosing:... The Church can only go so far in that authority... just in the same way that the elders of ancient Israel, Judah, & Levites were given authority...And when they had begun to go beyond what was written in the scriptures as commanded... even into lawless territory... their authority still got trumped by what the scriptures say... even as an example for us, that still applies today.
2 Timothy 3 : 16 - 17:
16 )"All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is Profitable For Doctrine, For Reproof, For Correction, For Instruction in righteousness:"
17) "That the man of God may be Perfect, throughly furnished unto all good works."
( See also: Matt 15.. Mark 7 ... Matt 23 )
Also in regards to binding and loosing... To put it in context... after His statement in Matt 18 : 18 ...
"Verily I say unto you, Whatsoever ye shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven: and whatsoever ye shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven."
He goes on to give "The Parable Of The Wicked Servant", who kept his servant "bound" and unforgiven in his small debt, after he, himself had been "loosed" and forgiven by the King from his large debt.
The same lesson for The Church:
Matt 6 : 14 "For if ye forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you:" ( Loosed in heaven )
Matt 6:15 "But if ye forgive not men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses." ( Bound in heaven )
As for Easter... The Church has inherited many lies... in which, the changing of the time of Passover, away from the scriptures, is one of them...
( Not even Polycarp would keep Easter Sunday, because it was never given to him to keep personally by the Apostle John... And if the Bishop of Rome was truly the successor of Peter, and John knew that... then why didn't he likewise convey the knowledge of that supposed authority to Polycarp, when the Roman Bishop Anicetus was trying to coerce him into observing a different time for the Pascha Of Christ?...
It's the same sin that 'The House of Israel' fell into, when Jeroboam of The Northern Kingdom issued a "counterfeit" Feast time, in the place of the Feast Of Tabernacles, upon the 8th month, instead of in the 7th, in which God had commanded.
( 1 Kings 12 : 25 - 33 & Leviticus 23 : 33 - 44 )
The Prophet Daniel also foresaw a 4th "Beast" ( Kingdom ) rise up, and out of it a "man", speaking great words against The Most High, persecuting the saints, and thinking to "change" the appointed "times" and "Law".
And even Paul warned that the apostasy within the Church, would start to begin, even in his day...
Acts 20 : 28 - 31
28 ) "Take Heed therefore unto yourselves, and to all the flock, over the which the Holy Ghost hath made you overseers, to feed the Church Of God, which he hath purchased with his own blood."
29 ) "For I know this, that after my departing shall grievous wolves enter in among you, not sparing the flock."
30 ) "Also of your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away disciples after them."
31 ) "Therefore watch, and remember, that by the space of three years I ceased not to warn every one night and day with tears."
I've never heard that the name "Moses" was a pagan Egyptian-god... That's interesting.. Will have to look into that... I always thought the name meant: "to draw out of water", or something like that?...
But the Greek word for "anointed" is just a verb in the description of what something; being a person, place, or thing, is.
And yes, The honor of pagan gods upon a so-called "Christian" calendar, shouldn't even be a "situation" we have to deal with either... Especially when it was in "Pope Gregory's" Power to finally get the names of those "false gods" off and out of there .. ( in which, was also part of the downfall of ancient Israel, as just another example! )
Exodus 23 : 13
"And in all things that I have said unto you BEWARE: and Make No Mention Of The Name Of Other Gods, Neither Let It Be Heard OUT OF THY MOUTH."
Deut 12 : 3
"And ye shall overthrow their altars, and break their pillars, and burn their groves with fire; and ye shall hew down the graven images of their gods, And Destroy THE NAMES Of Them OUT OF THAT PLACE."
It's just a shame that mankind keeps repeating the same mistakes against our Creator... even within the numerous examples of cause and effect, given to us Through His Word, and in hindsight. : (
Still Orthodox ❤
Left Orthodox
@@bbakleh L to u
Nobody care
🤯🫢 a lot of valuable information here, and new shirt idea… “use a calendar? Thank a Pope” 🤭 11:03
But why orthodox Christians are celebrating christmas around 2 weeks later?
Because they don’t follow the Gregorian calendar they follow the other one :)))
Orthodox is Catholic
No it's not.
@@BillySap12 hahaha bro I’m not even gonna argue it’s just basic knowledge
@@Thesonsofman ... They are two separate churches.
@@BillySap12 there is a difference between Roman Catholic, and Catholic
@@Thesonsofman but you said that orthodoxy is catholicism 💀
Neither, Passover was kept by followers of The Way on the 14th of Avib-Nissan like St Polycarp Bishop of Symerna and the Quartodecimans. Only the Messianic Kehilah Ekklessia keep the 14th of Avib-Nissan and The Church and Orthodox need to both yield to Scripture and both admit they are both wrong.
The church have the keys of the kingdom on earth, whatever they bind on earth is bind in heaven, protestant and jew are heretic sets
Why do you celebrate Yule?
Why do you celebrate Yule? 0:27
Christmas isn’t yule
Christmas isn’t Yule
@@CatholicMaan it’s saturnalia
@@WideSpreadHello nope! Scholars disagree
@@CatholicMaan what do they say about the Hellenization
This isnehy Christianity makes no scene
📆 Both [Julian & Gregorian] are pagan calendars. New Easter [Pasover] doesn't exist in scripture and that is heretic, so the truth is on 14 Nisan/Abib. Sorry for you all, in the judgment day we will have many surprises.. 😑
Why do you celebrate Yule?
I don’t, and neither do any Christians 😉 Easter/Passover is the celebration of the Resurrection of Jesus Christ. 🙏🏽