Actually there have been rumours that Mary herself fathered up to two illegitimate children of the king that he himself did not recognise. She wasn't sent away but banished from court after her secret marriage to William Stafford, which indeed saved her yet she lived in poverty with no support from family. A price to pay for a long, safe life
I always assumed, especially with Jane Parker's little bit there, that the queen was trying to justify why Mary was there, besides the obvious. She was probably embarrassed that it was obvious she was just there for the King.
Don't like how Catherine is portrayed as an intimidating, almost bullying character who likes to embarrass Mary and and Anne. Nothing could be further from the truth: as queen Catherine was always respectful, dignified and polite, even with her enemies.
@sarailahi7945 someone had a good comment there's a lot going on beneath the surface. She knows she's only here cause the king desires her. After mary sings she applauds her shaky singing as to not embarrasse either one
@@SorcererLordShe is because she is offended by the Boleyn girls thus she does disrespect them but in such a subtle way that no one can really accuse her of mistreating them.
I guess because Catherine just get to meet them, and know them for the first time before in the pass of the time she realizes that they are actually wh*res… lol
The name Mary is so confusing when it comes to the British royal family Anne Boleyn sister is Mary, princess/ Queen Mary is Mary, Mary of the Scott's ( a cousin to henry. In the Victorian era 15% of women were named Mary ( compare that to how 5% of baby girls these days are named Emma).
Well, during Tudor times the noteworthy Marys are *Mary Tudor, Queen of England (daughter of Henry VIII) *Mary Tudor, Queen of France (younger sister of Henry VIII and later wife of Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk) *Mary, Queen of Scots (granddaugther of Margaret Tudor, Queen of Scots, herself the elder sister of Henry VIII) *Mary of Guise, Queen of France (mother of Mary, Queen of Scots and wife of James V of Scotland - the son of Margaret Tudor) *Mary Boleyn (sister to Anne Boleyn, second wife of Henry VIII and his former mistress as well)
@@mr.googoopants3581 Mary of Guise was french, but she wasn't Queen of France, she was the Queen Consort of Scotland and later regent on her daughter's behalf.
I like these historical films despite their inaccuracies.We are not watching documentaries.I consider all this to be in an alternate dimension,like the Southern city of Asgard
Not technically, no. The position was basically a medieval dating service for the 1%. It existed to give the Queen friends, and let her play matchmaker for the daughters of lesser royals and nobility. There was the occasional handmaid-King fling... But because these girls were often the daughters of the King's friends and allies, he would usually cheat with the daughters/bastard daughters of court hangers-on, or upper middle class merchants, to avoid scandal.
No, it means they were servants and companions to the Queen. They did things like dress her and brush her hair and keep her company. However, it wasn't uncommon for kings to have mistresses, especially when their wives were pregnant, and royal mistress was an official position at a royal court. However, Christianity was the dominant religion in Europe at that time and adultery and fornication are both sins in Christianity. So King Henry probably gave Mary to Katherine as a lady in waiting because he knew it would provide Mary with a legitimate and morally acceptable position in his court than just "the royal mistress."
This was an excellent movie but they did mix up & omit certain info. Example; Mary wasn't the innocent virgin Scarlett Johannson is portraying her to be. She was scandalous😜 in her own right
Can someone please tell me where Andrew Garfield is in this film?! He's in the end credits and on Wikipedia it says everywhere that he was in this and I didn't see him feature anywhere?!
He played Francis Weston, best buds with George Boleyn. He would be executed along with George for sleeping with Anne. The scene he appears walking behind Scarlett, when she is wearing the red dress with the flowered petticoat talking with her brother. It may only be in the director's cut, will have to check my copy.
In history that was basically true on Mary Boleyn's part. She was known as the reluctant mistress. Cause this was against her will, but she wasn't exactly as smart as her two siblings are because she was the very person to be a wife and mother like sewing, poems, and singing. Then just like that, the king loses interest in Mary after the birth of her children who later on believed could be the King's or one of them exactly. She was the only surviving Boleyn and they said her father Thomas made amends to Mary and gave her inheritances or whatever houses they had left after the king demoted him and banished him from court. Yet in the end, Mary Boleyn's line became the royalty descended and it was by Elizabeth II who was her descendant.
ahh! The good ol' fake British accent ! Gotta love it! How many of you do that every now and then in front of random people?? I like to talk with a British accent over the phone when getting a cab or ordering food ;)
Linabinaa121 Eddie Redmayne played Mary's husband. He was so dam hot, and sexy in this movie. While i have always found Eddie Redmayne handsome and funny, this is the only movie where i find him sensual .
True, but Mary was pretty out of tune here. Katherine was either lying to be polite or coming from a genuine orientation of charity when she applauded Mary and called her a Nightingale.
THEY BOTH SHOULD JOIN THE CAST OF GAME OF THROWNS AND BRING WAR TO THE IRON THRONE OF STORMHOLD AND THE IRON ISLANDS AND THE CAPITAL OF THE LANNISTERS AND KING'S LANDING!
No one is going to talk about what a bad bitch Catherine was in this scene?! I feel like I should remove my uterus because clearly I've been doing "woman" all wrong for years!
No ,she knew Mary was there because Mary caught the interest of the King,She was looking at a future mistress if she was not one already.She was establishing herself as queen and that Mary was still under her command
Come on, Mary!! Ok, you're shy and all...but you know how to behave! I can't believe she even said "I beg you"! Ughhh I really don't think she was like this in real life...and I also don't think this show is accurate at all!
No wonder the kings didn't live long, they were spreading syphilis all over the damn place. Gave it to their wives who gave it to their children. So on and so forth.....
There were two children she had when she was married and both were rumoured as such yet never recognised but this is heavily disputed as they could have been her husband's as well.. Although she was married in that time she became the king's mistress it is unknown the exact dates of when this started yet it finished when the king wanted her sister. Her daughter Catherine: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catherine_Carey Her son Henry: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_Carey,_1st_Baron_Hunsdon
You should pay attention to the fact that this movie is "based" on true events, however, nobody living today know what happened, in detail. Have you read or studied history or just watched a movie and decided you know enough to hate somebody? Making these comments are very immature unless based on real facts. It is also interesting that you seem hate Anne Boleyn, but how about the man who actually killed her and left Catherine? No comment, I guess? I assume you know this was only the first wife he killed, not the last.
Estrellakatarinathegreatrussian no, Louis 1 is the only true king...you are only king or queen of the people say you are..otherwise, regardless of coronation you are not
Why on Earth they got American actresses to play Mary and Anne I don’t know - the book is fantastic and the film is good but I can’t distract myself from their stilted English accents 😕
The way Catherine of Aragon speaks is so soft... I could hear this woman speak for hours
Valentina Gorini Me too! Her voice is so soothing and pleasant.
Anne sending Mary away from court might have saved her life.
Couldn't agree more.
The mother of his son and the only sane one? Doubt it. If Henry wanted Mary dead, he would have ordered it, regardless of her whereabouts.
Cidi Huia The idea of Mary being the mother of Henry's child is a supposition. The only illegitimate child Henry acknowledged was Henry Fitzroy.
Katheryne Koelker We're talking from an audience's perspective, not from a historical one.
Actually there have been rumours that Mary herself fathered up to two illegitimate children of the king that he himself did not recognise. She wasn't sent away but banished from court after her secret marriage to William Stafford, which indeed saved her yet she lived in poverty with no support from family. A price to pay for a long, safe life
I always assumed, especially with Jane Parker's little bit there, that the queen was trying to justify why Mary was there, besides the obvious. She was probably embarrassed that it was obvious she was just there for the King.
The queen is extremely beautiful. Lovely voice and manner of speaking too. 🌹
Yep that’s why she’s so beloved by people❤ may she rest in peace with God I would love to meet her.
Don't like how Catherine is portrayed as an intimidating, almost bullying character who likes to embarrass Mary and and Anne. Nothing could be further from the truth: as queen Catherine was always respectful, dignified and polite, even with her enemies.
she was very classy and had a lot of dignity.. she's too high to waste her time on bullying.
How is she disrespectful here... I thought she was highly dignified
@sarailahi7945 someone had a good comment there's a lot going on beneath the surface. She knows she's only here cause the king desires her. After mary sings she applauds her shaky singing as to not embarrasse either one
@@sarailahi7945 She is clearly being disrespectful to her, how can’t you see that..?
@@SorcererLordShe is because she is offended by the Boleyn girls thus she does disrespect them but in such a subtle way that no one can really accuse her of mistreating them.
Catherine is so graceful
😍
Katherine of Aragon was a beautiful redhead. For real.
Eddie Redmayne and Benedict Cumberbatch in the same movie. oh my
Natalie Portman and Scarlett Johansson in the same movie. oh my
Oh my
ArtplusChocolateMilk ᴀɴᴅ ᴀɴᴅʀᴇᴡ ɢᴀʀғɪᴇʟᴅ ɪғ ɪ ᴄᴀɴ ғɪɴᴅ ʜɪᴍ
Samara Dantas ɪ ʜᴀᴠᴇ ᴛᴏ ᴡᴀɪᴛ ᴜɴᴛɪʟ ɪ ɢᴇᴛ ᴏɴᴇ ᴏғ ᴛʜᴏsᴇ ʜᴜɢᴇ ᴛʜᴇᴀᴛᴇʀ sᴍᴀʀᴛ ᴛᴠ's
They look so much alike
The way Anne is portrayed in this pisses me off. She wasn't like this.
How was she like?
Agreed. I think Natalie Dormer played her wonderfully and was more true to Anne Boleyn.
Umm...I think she was.
Menelik Charles no she wasn’t. She wasn’t perfect but she wasn’t depraved.
Faith Summers who knows
Why people in the comments are acting like they were besties of these people
lol so true
Hahahaha best comment ever 🤣
I guess because Catherine just get to meet them, and know them for the first time before in the pass of the time she realizes that they are actually wh*res… lol
Everyone's a historical expert on the internet, it's hilarious.
The name Mary is so confusing when it comes to the British royal family Anne Boleyn sister is Mary, princess/ Queen Mary is Mary, Mary of the Scott's ( a cousin to henry. In the Victorian era 15% of women were named Mary ( compare that to how 5% of baby girls these days are named Emma).
It's because at that point in history England was Catholic.
Every Catholic girl has Mary as her name, in some form. Mary, Maria, Mariana .....
Mary Tudor, Mary Boleyn, Mary Queen of Scots.. not that hard
Not at all, Super.Chuck.
Well, during Tudor times the noteworthy Marys are
*Mary Tudor, Queen of England (daughter of Henry VIII)
*Mary Tudor, Queen of France (younger sister of Henry VIII and later wife of Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk)
*Mary, Queen of Scots (granddaugther of Margaret Tudor, Queen of Scots, herself the elder sister of Henry VIII)
*Mary of Guise, Queen of France (mother of Mary, Queen of Scots and wife of James V of Scotland - the son of Margaret Tudor)
*Mary Boleyn (sister to Anne Boleyn, second wife of Henry VIII and his former mistress as well)
@@mr.googoopants3581 Mary of Guise was french, but she wasn't Queen of France, she was the Queen Consort of Scotland and later regent on her daughter's behalf.
Scarlett Johansson sings beautifully normally I can't imagine how hard it was to make her sound this way.
She sings better than me
Did anybody else throw their device across the room in frustration at the historical inaccuracy of this film?
I like these historical films despite their inaccuracies.We are not watching documentaries.I consider all this to be in an alternate dimension,like the Southern city of Asgard
That's because this movie was based off of a novel. Not exact historical truths.
The book this was based off of was so much worse. Soooo much worse.
They are based on fictional historical inaccurate books
Did ladies in waiting, mean they were waiting to get screwed by the King?
Not technically, no. The position was basically a medieval dating service for the 1%. It existed to give the Queen friends, and let her play matchmaker for the daughters of lesser royals and nobility. There was the occasional handmaid-King fling... But because these girls were often the daughters of the King's friends and allies, he would usually cheat with the daughters/bastard daughters of court hangers-on, or upper middle class merchants, to avoid scandal.
I agree with your statement. However, that was not how King Henry played it!
Basically yes!😄
But then they end up with a baby and are really screwed.
No, it means they were servants and companions to the Queen. They did things like dress her and brush her hair and keep her company.
However, it wasn't uncommon for kings to have mistresses, especially when their wives were pregnant, and royal mistress was an official position at a royal court. However, Christianity was the dominant religion in Europe at that time and adultery and fornication are both sins in Christianity.
So King Henry probably gave Mary to Katherine as a lady in waiting because he knew it would provide Mary with a legitimate and morally acceptable position in his court than just "the royal mistress."
Natalie Portman brilliant actress
0:55 pmg, stephen hawkings and his geniusness to go back in time
The queen’s accent triggered my asmr a little bit.
Ironic they are both tied to marvel
Jane Foster and The Black Widow
This was an excellent movie but they did mix up & omit certain info. Example; Mary wasn't the innocent virgin Scarlett Johannson is portraying her to be. She was scandalous😜 in her own right
Una mujer muy ambiciosa Ana Bolena.
Can someone please tell me where Andrew Garfield is in this film?! He's in the end credits and on Wikipedia it says everywhere that he was in this and I didn't see him feature anywhere?!
Lucy Munden saaaaame!
Eddie redmayne is in this movie but I don’t remember Andrew Garfield being in it
He played Francis Weston, best buds with George Boleyn. He would be executed along with George for sleeping with Anne. The scene he appears walking behind Scarlett, when she is wearing the red dress with the flowered petticoat talking with her brother. It may only be in the director's cut, will have to check my copy.
@@PrincessofErised In which scene ??
I heard his character was cut from the movie
In history that was basically true on Mary Boleyn's part. She was known as the reluctant mistress. Cause this was against her will, but she wasn't exactly as smart as her two siblings are because she was the very person to be a wife and mother like sewing, poems, and singing.
Then just like that, the king loses interest in Mary after the birth of her children who later on believed could be the King's or one of them exactly.
She was the only surviving Boleyn and they said her father Thomas made amends to Mary and gave her inheritances or whatever houses they had left after the king demoted him and banished him from court.
Yet in the end, Mary Boleyn's line became the royalty descended and it was by Elizabeth II who was her descendant.
A *NIGHTENGALE* she did not need to add salt to the wound 😂😂😭😭
One of my favorite scenes in the movie along with "the Boleyn whores"
ahh! The good ol' fake British accent ! Gotta love it! How many of you do that every now and then in front of random people?? I like to talk with a British accent over the phone when getting a cab or ordering food ;)
THE ACCENTS IM CRYINGSGGEGDGDG IMAGINE A BRIT WATCHING THIS UNFOLD-
And.........???
Andre Suston what purpose did ur reply serve i-
@@izzy965 I'm sorry, I wasn't aware that I needed your validation to make a comment. ✌️
Andre Suston bruh......you twelve or summ..?
@@izzy965 Please hush. That's ALL you gotta do.
where are the dragons?
Catharine: *trys hard not to laugh at her song* 😶.....
0:55 - Eddie Redmayne?? lol
yup!
Linabinaa121 also Benedict Cumberbatch
Linabinaa121 Eddie Redmayne played Mary's husband. He was so dam hot, and sexy in this movie. While i have always found Eddie Redmayne handsome and funny, this is the only movie where i find him sensual .
luvprue1 Eddie played her second husband, while Benedict played her first
luvprue1 Thank you for letting us know that..
Are there no dwarfs or Elves in this version of Aragon ?
lmfao
Where can I watch this???
you can either rent it or watch it online
0:56 BENEDICT!!!!!!!!!
Hey! That necklace Natalie has on at 0:21 was used in The Tudors too--I know because I own a replica!
😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
I just come here to hear Natalie and Scarlett's accents
Do you know the name of the nightingale?
Scarlette Johanson is her real name.
To be fair, a young singer would be nervous performing in font of the Queen and her ladies for the first time
True, but Mary was pretty out of tune here. Katherine was either lying to be polite or coming from a genuine orientation of charity when she applauded Mary and called her a Nightingale.
THEY BOTH SHOULD JOIN THE CAST OF GAME OF THROWNS AND BRING WAR TO THE IRON THRONE OF STORMHOLD AND THE IRON ISLANDS AND THE CAPITAL OF THE LANNISTERS AND KING'S LANDING!
You know nothing Jon snow
Actually Alfie Allen is in it too
"why hasn't it hit her? He doesn't want to bang you, somebody hang you!"
SOMEONE PLEASE TELL ME WHAT SING THIS IS!!!!!!!
Me too!
I had to do a double take when I realized it was Eddie Redmayne at 0:54
What song is Scarlett singing
Westron Wynde.
@@Silver_Owlthank you!
Wow....did the writers get this wrong!!!!! This IS NOTHING MORE THAN HOLLYWOOD LIES!
this movie was based on a historical FICTION book. This movie isnt claiming to be a documentary or recreation.
what are you talking about, Henry 8th slept with MAry Boleyn, anne, and their cousin, his fifth wife
The book ain't accurate
Starr: You want accuracy, go back in time.
Scarlett Johansson can’t play meek and feminine to save her life lol
And??? Thats alright
pan pixie NOT IF UR BUSINESS IS THAT
What is the song that Mary tries to sing?
Elber Ríos western wind
Jasmine Badon by who?
A nightingale called western wind.... At beginning it was only with sounds, the first version with words appeared in 1530 😊
Queen AMADALA was tricked by that bitch when she had that Rough Night!
She should’ve sang Bad Romance
Hello Hogwarts lol
No one is going to talk about what a bad bitch Catherine was in this scene?! I feel like I should remove my uterus because clearly I've been doing "woman" all wrong for years!
No ,she knew Mary was there because Mary caught the interest of the King,She was looking at a future mistress if she was not one already.She was establishing herself as queen and that Mary was still under her command
Catherine of Aragon is a badass.
Come on, Mary!! Ok, you're shy and all...but you know how to behave!
I can't believe she even said "I beg you"! Ughhh I really don't think she was like this in real life...and I also don't think this show is accurate at all!
why are you even on this video clip then?
AND ARAGORN WILL CONTINUE TO FIGHT FOR LIV TYLER'S HAND IN MARRIAGE!
No wonder the kings didn't live long, they were spreading syphilis all over the damn place. Gave it to their wives who gave it to their children. So on and so forth.....
Its possible Mary's son was by Henry VIII.
Nop, was William Carey's son
Garrett Óg but Mary did have a daughter from Henry I think Catherine Carey but got Williams last name
There were two children she had when she was married and both were rumoured as such yet never recognised but this is heavily disputed as they could have been her husband's as well.. Although she was married in that time she became the king's mistress it is unknown the exact dates of when this started yet it finished when the king wanted her sister.
Her daughter Catherine: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catherine_Carey
Her son Henry: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_Carey,_1st_Baron_Hunsdon
Side note but they look absolutely nothing alike
Scarlett Johanessen cannot hold a candle to Natalie Portmans beauty.
It's Time for Scarlet Johansson's Character to Involve Herself into the Game OF THRONES! played by Natalie Portman...
Horrible movie. Loved the book though.
Why does the actress playing Queen Katherine not have that thing removed from her lip? It's so gross
her eyes are so beautiful, but we keep focus on that thing like you said
I hate Anne Boleyn. Catherine the real Queen,no other than her.
You should pay attention to the fact that this movie is "based" on true events, however, nobody living today know what happened, in detail. Have you read or studied history or just watched a movie and decided you know enough to hate somebody? Making these comments are very immature unless based on real facts. It is also interesting that you seem hate Anne Boleyn, but how about the man who actually killed her and left Catherine? No comment, I guess? I assume you know this was only the first wife he killed, not the last.
Estrellakatarinathegreatrussian no, Louis 1 is the only true king...you are only king or queen of the people say you are..otherwise, regardless of coronation you are not
"Woman were treated so unfairly." Then bam "she's a whore." Yeah. She honestly had much choice in the matter when it came to her life.
She sings horrible lol ...... In my opinion
That's the whole idea.
That's the whole point mary couldn't sing. Catherine put her on the spot
Why on Earth they got American actresses to play Mary and Anne I don’t know - the book is fantastic and the film is good but I can’t distract myself from their stilted English accents 😕
How many British actors play Americans