Rating AI Generated Magic: The Gathering Cards
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.ย. 2024
- Rating AI Generated Magic: The Gathering Cards
Source: / roborosewaterm
Watch more AI Generated MTG Videos:
You May Put a Permanent Card from Hand Into Play:
19/32: th-cam.com/users/li...
Destroy All Players: th-cam.com/users/li...
Destroy That Permanent: th-cam.com/users/li...
Support the channel through Patreon ► / nikachumtg
Support the channel, become a member! ► / @nikachumtglive
Follow my main channel! ► / nikachumtg
Follow my gameplay channel! ► / @nikachuplaysmtg
Follow my other socials here! ► link.space/@Ni...
Join my Discord here: / discord
Welcome to Coffee and MTG, the morning LIVE STREAM running Mon-Fri 11am-12pm CST.
RENT CARDS WITH MANATRADERS! Use Manatraders coupon code NIKACHU_1JV for 10% off your first 2 months! www.manatrader...
I buy all my cards from FUSION GAMING ONLINE. Use coupon code NIKACHU to save 5% off all your purchases! (Prices are in Canadian $) www.fusiongami...
Send me stuff!
Nikachu
PO Box 34085 Fort Richmond
Winnipeg, MB
R3T5T5, Canada
(Disclaimer: Some Links in this Description are Affiliate Links)
#magicthegathering #nikachu #mtg
"Fun" fact: bones of soldiers killed during the Waterloo battle were supposedly ground into bone meal and used as fertilizer. So "consume corn" seems on flavor.
I'm gonna think about this every time I hear Waterloo now. Thank you.
38:31 Icerator for the Dead would draw yourself to death with Sheoldred, The Apocalypse because every time you drew a card you would gain life and then you would draw cards instead and then gain life and you would create a loop till you were out of cards.
Not even the sheoldred combo would make it broken beyond belief. This would be a staple of all life gain decks, and even if not life gain, it would just be a staple card regardless due to cheating it into play and being able to draw an ungodly amount of cards each turn.
@@thefoxden5753The card basically already exists in Drogskol Reaver.
8:58 then that fights EACH CREATURE on the battlefield (including itself, obviously)
It is so funny that rainbow elemental is still somehow in the color pie because Green gets to destroy fliers and red sometimes gets unconditional non-flier removal.
Googled nutritional benefits of corn and this shows up: It consists primarily of insoluble fiber, which makes it a low-glycemic index food. This means it is a food that is digested slowly and doesn't cause an unhealthy spike in blood sugar. It also contains many B vitamins, as well as essential minerals, including zinc, magnesium, copper, iron and manganese.
The real life Saint Nicholas knocked a guy out at the Nicaean Creed convention. The guy was trying to filibuster, but Santa had an answer to that.
For Goblin Blast, there is plenty of cards which gives you a beneficial effect for targetting them with 0 damage so capping it at 3 might prevent some unwanted interactions. Like using it with a card like Cowardice to target every creature your opponents control and use the actual damage points to damage a commander or send a card to the graveyard you don't want back in their hand.
First third of this video:
(0:04) Ghastly Satchel: Fair, ship. Could get you a bunch of treasures later on when it goes kaput. Hopefully it won't exile an important card from the top of your library.
(0:43) Heh, a Backrooms Swamp.
(0:49) Clash of Brighteers: Underpowered, ship then never play. It's a pretty fun idea to get a bonus for being able to choose a Goat in play, but all you get is one card at best, for five mana. I'd say this should let you draw two cards normally, and give you four cards instead if you're able to choose a Goat.
(2:05) Crossray's Ria: OP, ship then ban. IT DANGER!!! Yeah, let's just plow through the entire library, and then win the game easily with Thassa's Oracle or whatever!
(3:28) Enssour with Artivation: OP, ship then ban. IT ALSO DANGER!!! Though maybe not quite as "danger" as Crossray's Ria, but it's still a lot card draws for just three mana, while also stealing something from the opponent if this reaches chapter 3. Maybe if this saga cost like 6 or 7 mana instead of 3, it would be more fair.
(5:31) Now there's a Backrooms Island.
(5:38) Avatar of Remedy: Fair, ship. That's a rather strange filter land, but it works fine.
(7:42) Restless Portal: Fair, ship. I'd change "those creatures" to "that creature" so that it's more grammatically correct, and also maybe clarify the order in which it fights each creature... unless it's supposed to fight them all simultaneously somehow.
(9:18) Kionaba: Word salad, shred. Well, wouping the monarch does sound hilarious, but that doesn't exactly work for gameplay. The art is hilariously fitting at least. Maybe to fix this card, I'd word it like this: "Destroy target nonartifact creature. If that creature's controller is the monarch, then creatures you control gain trample until end of turn."
(11:32) There's a Backrooms Plains.
(11:33) Kasima, Satyr Party: I almost want to say "fair, ship", but the +1 ability does not quite make perfect sense. Add the word "If" to the very beginning of that sentence, and this would be perfectly fine, and rather interesting. (Also, if you're having a Satyr Party, you gotta invite Gallia of the Endless Dance. :P)
(14:20) Bog Skix: Underpowered, ship then never play. This only helps your opponent! Why would I ever use this?!
(16:44) Tilant Spirit: Underpowered, ship. A 6/6 flying partner for 5 mana sounds okay, but the ETB ability is harsh, and the LTB ability is even worse! Fitting for a Demon, but for those downsides, I feel like maybe this guy should have even higher stats and/or a lower mana cost. How about an 8/8 flying partner for 4 mana with those downsides? Of course, if you can Donate this to your opponent and then bounce/kill it... Hehehe...
(19:24) Decree of the Drowned: Word Salad, shred. At least it supports the show 24. :P
(21:16) Felidar Triome: Word salad, shred. First of all, this isn't really a triome. Anyway, on a technical level, this is doable, but nothing is done with the mana payment, and while players can certainly play a mountain if it's discarded by Felidar Triome, you never have to pay a mana cost to play a land anyway. And, you're paying WUBRG for this meager effect? Underpowered too. Here's how I'd fix this: Change "if it's a mountain" to "if its mana value is less than or equal to the amount of mana paid". Then it would actually be somewhat interesting.
(24:06) Locus of Rage: Maybe fair, probably can ship. Dragons for everyone, especially when chaos ensues! It Zibers!
(24:32) That is a cool Wastes.
(24:34) Timenan Spirit: Fair, ship. Good if you want to make squids with your red deck.
(26:27) Baad Nix: Super duper OP, ship then ban. IT DANGER!!! Even with no mana cost, requiring you to cheat it into play somehow, this is ridiculous! I bet Robotnik would love Baad Nix to use against Sonic! :P
1:09:35 We've already seen a land that says you win the game unless you pay 1 for each Merfolk you control. That's a 0 mana uncounterable win condition.
Third third of this video:
(1:00:51) Gruul Philospher: Word salad, shred. First of all, it's not red/green, so the Gruul part of the name is wrong. Secondly, the third ability is nonsense. However, the "partner with" ability can technically work on a non-legendary creature, such as with Impetuous Protege and Proud Mentor. We just need a card named "partist of sky, disralters," now.
(1:02:48) Myr Enigmation: OP, ship then ban. Take an extra turn for every creature spell you cast?! IT DANGER!!! I could see this being plausibly reasonable if the mana cost for this artifact were very high, but at just 2 mana, it's definitely way too strong.
(1:04:51) Greatsword Pride: Fair, maybe OP, ship then ban later if needed. Do you like squirrels? If you do, you'll love this possibly underpriced squirrel-maker!
(1:06:38) Shoal Contest: Word salad, shred... unless we can figure out what having king hand means. Also, it's still a land.
(1:08:26) Rainbow Elemental: OP, ship then ban. A 2-mana wrath at instant speed? It DANGER!!! Taste the rainbow... of death!
(1:10:11) Goblin Warchast: Word salad, shred. This guy is facepalming at the nonsense.
(1:11:41) Well Crab: OP, ship then ban. It's basically Ice Storm, but with a cantrip too, which I think makes this a bit too pushed. Now, if the mana cost was like 4 or 5 instead of 3, this probably would've been fair.
(1:12:59) Saffling Burgermaster: OP, ship then ban. It's Ancestral Recall on legs! But, that is a tasty-looking burger at least. Maybe if this required you to sacrifice 3 foods to draw 3 cards, it would be fair.
(1:15:07) Blackblade Mine: OP, word salad, ship then ban. Now we have land destruction on legs at 1 mana, with a bunch of other options thrown in as well, including making someone flip a card. So, we going all Chaos Orb now?
(1:16:00) Oh, right. There are flip cards in the old Kamigawa block, so it could work with those, which is neat. It should still say "Target player" instead of "That player", though.
(1:17:14) Soul Sage: Fair, ship. Ooh, a legendary Time Lord Doctor, so you can pair this with something that has Doctor's Companion. And, everything on this guy works just fine and isn't too OP. Also, it gives red a way to deal with enchantments at a reasonable cost. I like it a lot! It Zibers!
(1:18:32) Battle of the Glens: Fair, ship. This card is practically a real Magic card already. There exists Arachnoid Adaptation, which does the same thing for a single green mana, but it also gives the creature reach too. So, I could see this exact card existing in white.
(1:20:28) Cabaretti, Voice of Kiss: Fair, ship. I love how it benefits from equipment, and the graveyard hate is just gravy. It Zibers!
(1:21:49) Goblin Blast: Fair, ship. Arc Lightning just got power-crept, yo. I still think it's not way too OP, though. Also, the art is really good. It Zibers!
1:20 Finally, some Monty Hall synergy.
Love how the snowball joke on spur tacker just compleetly goes over his head😂
Kisama becomes a lot less threatening when you realize it’s only spirit or plainswalkers Nikachu
"Well Crab" is great, just turn that last letter 180 degrees.
So, "Well Craq"?
@@SomeGuy712xnot in the plane of the text, rotate it towards you.
Festive Hope is a cool card. It makes me question my assumptions about what entering tapped actually means
25:36 Nikachu, people were trying to tell you that the artist was called Edward Munch, and there you are going, "munch? It doesn't say munch on the card!" You are so cute!
interesting thing with "Goblin Blast" you can target 3 things but do 3 to target A and 0 to target B and C, but still have 3 targets.
Santa's cross between a mitre and a military uniform makes him look like a 40k commander and I need a real card with that artwork.
Kasima is somewhat balanced that it can only target spirit or planeswalkers--which in current standard has few targets--so it's a bit niche in some formats
For Bog Skix, since until end of turn is part of the quotes, I'd say just the tap ability is until end of turn, and the +1/+1 is permanent
Displayer of Lurch--God of Avacyn: reading the card explains the card
17:46 You could donate this and then bounce it back to your hand to make that player loose the game?
8:50 Restless portal gives a creature +4/+0 then that creature fights all creatures on the battlefield including itself. That is how it reads it looks like
THANK YOU. I thought I was losing my mind, he kept reaffirming that it only fought itself and I kept getting more confused.
I feel like Myr Enigmation is printable. Pretty balanced with the modern design philosophy
8:29 idea to fix this: Target creature gains +4/+0 until end of turn. It must attack thist turn if able. (possibly replace attack this turn with must attack whenever able aka forever or until it leaves the battlefield)
it says "fights EACH creature" meaning it would fight every creature so it doesnt really need fixing aside from maybe a slight change in wording.
@@kingzut That's why it's a suggested fix, not an explanation of what's already there.
@@leurunner4764 its not really a "fix" then since it already works it just changing the card, but i get what you are saying.
I feel like buff the power, creature deals damage to itself equal to its power is interesting
@@bestaround3323 thats not what it does tho. its a buff then it deals damage to all creatures and they deal damage to it. tho im not sure if the damage will happen at every time or all at once. so it may or may not live to deal damage to everything.
22:40 the image is depicting the AI’s struggles to learn game rules
If you kill the monarch with damage in multi player format, that player is set to zero health. They do not lose the game until state based effects are checked. This occurs any time a player would gain priority, so the trigger always goes on the stack to change the monarch to you.
This is however not the end of the story - we need to then figure out who owns the trigger itself. All triggers are owned by the card causing the trigger, and in the very odd case of the monarch (which is a status, not a token counter or card) the trigger is connected to the attacking creature.
The end result is you become the monarch - unless all the creatures that dealt damage are owned by the deleted player. In these cases (*) there is now no monarch.
(*) there used to be dragons here - as it used to be that "there is a monarch" and "x is the monarch" were tracked separately, and some - but not all - ways to become the monarch would fizzle if there "was a monarch" but no player was in fact the monarch. This has been "fixed" but there are now sone very very complex situations where multiple people are becoming the monarch at once.
Titan spirit makes so much sense. It's an axorius demon with the most masochistic text box. Just pain upon needless pain
Love that card, I mean it's quirky, the drawback is you have to use a partner commander but it gives you 2 more colors which is fine utility and it's got that insane effect, he'll never be played but when he is it's fun. Print it
Nika, as a former goalie, pulling the goalie is an advantage! You get an extra attacker!!!
Yeah I think he knows that. He was talking about make a final push towards victory, so you pull the goalie out to achieve victory.
26:28
I've been waiting forever for the Ski-Free Secret Lair.
Bog Skix would be good when using Goad. You give all the creatures haste, and they either swing with all of them, or swing a super buff guy at an enemy
Kionaba would be cool if it said "destroy target creature. If that creature was an artifact, you become the monarch."
Restless Portal can be used to target a creature you control with deathtouch (power of targeted creature isn't super important cuz of +4 power) and then you just assign that deathtouch creatures damage to all of your opponents stuff instead of yours. One-sided destroy all creatures for 4 and a deathtouch creature is busted. Be careful of first/double strike tho. It also doesn't really have to fight itself since you can just assign the damage it deals to something else.
Bog Skix begs for Phyrexian Oblitterator.
for clarification bog skix's buffs don't go away after the end of turn, those creatures just get +1/+1 forever and gain that ability for the rest of the game, the tap ability is until end of turn, but the rest is permeant, look up the ruling on "riding the dilu horse" for how this card reads lol.
Its ability doesn't say "until end of turn" for giving the ability and the buff, the tap ability is the one with the timing restriction.
riding the dilu horse reads as such: Target creature gets +2/+2 and gains horsemanship. (It can't be blocked except by creatures with horsemanship. This effect lasts indefinitely.)
Snow Assassin is actually broken. Nobody is gonna wanna donate land since its a may ability, so essentially its a "3 mana, draw three cards" spell
3 mana for net 2 cards is fine.
27:35
He's just putting a card down... *menacingly*
Icerator + Sheoldred instantly decks you. You gain life with Sheoldred and Icerator replaces it with card draw. And then Sheoldred triggers again due to card draw and you would gain life which is replaced with card draw, which triggers Sheoldred again…
1:22:05 - That… was the Snow/Colorless card I think. Piercing Icicle Barrage, I think. That was me. Worded differently.
Bog skix. My opponent attacks someone. I can buff either the attacker or blocker and/or give them haste
After seeing this kasima i cant wait for AI card with effect "target player dies"
17:13 Gift it to your opponent in a zedruu deck
39:58 Spitballing - what if it said “If you would gain life, draw that many cards *and lose that much life* instead”? More risk/reward to impose a cost?
Are there red arbor dryads but that costs mana?
fight each creature. Holy Grail
I’d like to see you play some vintage merfolk on MTGO.
Do you see that as doable?
I played a little bit of that last year! But I'm a bit too motivated to play Modern right now.
with crossray you can use biomancers familer and animate artifact to create infinite mana
The create a 24 card is actually useful: you play a card that asks you to roll a die, like deck of many things, and then instead of rolling you create a 24.
Restless portaling someone's Phyrexian Obliterator would be funny.
Restless Portal is OP. I’m baffled you and your chat didn’t read that it fights EACH creature in play.
Second third of this video:
(31:21) Consume Corn: Fair, ship. CORN!!!
(33:54) That's a neat Forest planet.
(33:57) Painted Bond: OP, ship then ban. Holy Yawgmoth's Bargain on legs, Batman!
(36:11) Festive Hope: Underpowered, ship. You have to work to make this meaningful.
(37:42) Icerator for the Dead: Likely OP, ship then ban later if needed. Wow, now Healing Salve becomes Ancestral Recall! But, 6 mana to cast and only 2 toughness, and it does not have any kind of built-in protection. This might actually be fair.
(40:19) Cool Mountain planet.
(40:21) Snow Assassin: Word salad? Fair, maybe OP, ship. Not sure how you play a land on an opponent, but otherwise, drawing 3 cards for 3 mana is perhaps okay. It's a little bit pushed, but not quite at Ancestral Recall's power level. If it means that players can play a land under the control of an opponent, then this could be great as a "group hug" type of card in Commander.
(42:27) Spur Tacker: Fair, ship. Very simple, totally doable, and on theme. It Zibers!
(44:18) Christmasters of Tarant: OP, ship then ban. That seems like an easy alternate win condition to fulfill, especially if you can proliferate, and while you're working on that, your opponents' attacks can allow you to get rid of artifacts and/or enchantments that are bothering you.
(47:10) Icky Swamp planet.
(47:15) Christmas Dreadnaught: Fair, ship. Not sure why you'd want to Ninjutsu this, as it's just a 1/1, and you can't use Kicker with Ninjutsu. So, the main reason to play this guy is to kick it for the 9 damage to a creature, which for 5 total mana, is probably fair. (Shivan Meteor deals 13 damage to a creature for 5 mana, as a comparison.)
(49:56) Winter Gargoyle: OP, don't even ship it! A free 6/6 + 1/1 + make your opponent discard two cards?! IT DANGER!!! Change the mana cost from 0 to at least 6 or 7 to make it reasonably fair.
(50:30) Is this a rerun? I'll check real quick... And, yep! It was the very first card shown in the previous AI stream! Welp.
(50:35) Christmas Blood Power is also a rerun. It was the second card shown last time.
(50:50) I remember that really nice Island planet too.
(51:18) Sdelloons Pumpered: Word salad, underpowered, shred. 0/0 that dies instantly, the Bestow doesn't do anything useful, and the reminder text for Bestow is stamped. I don't think the zpowe would really consider this successful.
(53:07) Boneshaker Breaker: Maybe OP, ship then ban later if needed. Well, it definitely wants to be the goodest mechanical boy, and fetch cards for you. It's totally doable, but maybe it's a wee bit too goodest. I would say it Zibers, though.
(54:06) Displayer of Lurch: Fair, maybe underpowered, ship. It works, and even uses kicker correctly, but seems lackluster for the mana costs. Maybe if this thing actually had flying, and if the kicker cost was reduced from 4 to 1, then it would be better.
(55:12) It's at the very bottom of the flavor text, dood.
(55:52) Radiant's Eye: OP, ship then ban. It stares into your soul, and draws you way too many cards for the cheap cost. It this trying to be the new Contract from Below?
(56:36) Yes there is-- Contract from Below, an ante card, which draws you 7 new cards for just 1 black mana. The caveat is that you have to discard your current hand, and ante one additional card. Contract from Below is incredibly good in the old Shandalar computer game, since the story does play with ante rules.
(58:30) Riveteers' Route: Word salad, shred. Well, a 2/3 for 2 mana is okay, but then the rules text got sicks the game.
(58:57) 7 is indeed lucky. A week ago, I won 8 Dominaria Remastered packs in a draft (and during that draft, I had pulled a foil retro Force of Will, which was just insane luck already), and the 7th booster pack in that pile contained a Vampiric Tutor!
Restless portal works with black cards that prevent damage to themselves to destroy permanents
7:55 you read Restless Portal wrong! It says those creatures fight "each creature on the battlefield"! So you buff your guy and your guy fights everyone!
1:02:04 Gruul Philosopher might be what blue needs against Crashing Footfalls. Doesn't kill the 4/4 tokens but makes them manageable and you have to pay 1 at upkeep so it's fair. Too bad it's mostly nonsense
Hell yeah! Gimme my 2 white mana draw 7 and my 2 mana artifact with infinate turns! The power 9 ain't got shit on the AI!
*insterts picture of Monarch from Venture Bros
You are thinking of spring jack pasture
No comment on the fact that the cat card has it as the lead singer of KISS? You don’t normally get real people on magic cards do you?
Crossray's Ria goes infinite with power artifact, or training grounds with KARN.
You woup the monarch by giving them 3 or more poison counters. Simbolizing poisoning a king to steal his throne
39:12 Sheoldred would go infinite! Get you your Thassa’s oracle ready! Also, draw equals life gain, life gain equals draw.. that’s the infinite
Burgermaster looks like a US civil war picture.
opponent: I play tialand spirit!
me:...well I guess I doom blade it...I guess I win huh?
2:43 if it is 5 mana is still broken banned in all formats. even if it is one mana of each color, you will probable made the deck to use this card.
Bog Skix would be a decent aura curse if it were written a little better.
Training Grounds and this for infinite mana too 2:47
There's far worse danger to play against over Painted Bond..
Politics baby! 40:48
Hurry up, Pauper has a new best card! 35:23
isnt stamp an unset mechanic
How about a show where we rate the cards that are word soup as you would call them
Why can't I draw three cards for one plains manna I thought this was AMERICA?! I'm trying to manifest my destiny over here.
Plainspower
Icerator of the Dead aint that bad. since while its out you cant heal. and unless you have certain cards out you start discarding after getting i think 8 cards? so you will quite quickly just drain yourself of hp. and any smart player would never kill it because while you drawing a lot can be dangerous you also have 0 ways of getting life back while its out on the field.
bless Jess Marchand
Meh, not enough white card draw here.
Radiant eye needs a buff
Artivation 😂
Ghastly Satchel was your mom’s nickname
Sssnake nurssssse isss cute.
Foxes are feline not canine
Volpine
@@bestaround3323and that's a subset of -canines- felines, derp
40:25 is a political card. Get opponents to give you a land by promising you will give them the draw 3.