Dwarka: Have archaeologists finally found India's sunken kingdom? - BBC REEL
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ธ.ค. 2021
- The city of Dwarka is one of the seven holy pilgrimage centres in India. It is the only place which is contemporary with the events described in the epic Mahabharata, where it is described as the ancient kingdom of Krishna. It is written that upon Krishna's death the city was sunk beneath the Arabian sea.
Today, archaeologists searching for the lost kingdom believe they have found evidence of its existence off the coast of the modern-day Dwarka, and are trying to understand what could have caused it to be lost beneath the sea.
Video by Mithun Pramanik
#bbcreel #bbc #bbcnews
![CAMPปลิ้น | EP.77[2/2] "รับทราบ" แก๊งเพื่อนรัก 10 ปี ที่ไปไหนก็มีตำนาน!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ifc0ofD51B0/mqdefault.jpg)
Minute correction Atantis is a fictional city while Dwarika is a historical city Indian civilization is more than 15- 20 thousand years old.
Story of Atlantis is based on Dwarika......in ancient time....when greek people came to study here in Taxila University....they listen about our..... History....& Make their own version of story....
@Norstark 5361 BC na?
Atlantis might be a myth but dwarka is history which submerged 5000 years back
@Norstark yes you're right
@@sandman4663 to understand that u need to first understand the concept of Avatar. A God taking human form is also bound by the laws and limitations of Nature which includes birth and death.
When invaders invaded India they burnt the books and historic records kept in the universities named nalanda and takshashila which were the worlds first universities. It is also said that the fire went on for about 2 months due to the large quantities of books .
Taxila was burned by the Huns 600 AD and Nalanda by the Khaljis 1196. if not for this India could have more accurate information about its old history
And then they say Hindus don't gave impotance to history. How can they proclaim themselves as historians. Even few lines enough for archeologist and historians to know about past and these early Marxist historians in India always focused on glorifying invaders and white washing their deeds...
Correct
That's really sad 🥺🥺🙁😭
this is so sad
The specialty of India are the enlightened divine personalities who walked on this dusty earth who knew past, present and future. Such great personalities have unearthed all the past history of this planet, shown what people have to do today and what the future will look like. As the saying goes, "When you are ready, you will meet your Guru" ...
Ancient India did not have culture of fiction writings, every place and co-ordinate mentioned in scriptures turns out to be present always..what a beautiful civilization
What do you mean? Person with ten heads, talking monkeys is not fiction?
@@RAIRADIO i would say factual writing of real events and hostory with exaggerated larger than life descriptions
@@RAIRADIOin summary in past aliens from all lower and higher dimension of universe used to stay here in earth as earth is middle plain
@@RAIRADIO That's Vanar = Van + nar that means man from forest could be early man not modern man or homo sapiens .
@@divyac04 homo Neanderthal and other human species died out tens of thousands of years ago
India has many gems hidden in its heart. It's time for the Indian government and people to accelerate and remodel the archeology department with good equipment and funds
The ASI is the main stumbling block
if not for the islamic invasions, much more would have survived. thakshashila would have survived. nalanda would have survived. indraprastha would have survived. thousands of hindu temples of north india would have survived. its really sad what organized religions does to people and civilisations
@Ravishanker R Turkish invasion not Islamic
@@AyushKumar-jj9hk lol Turks were islamic... There was no Islam in India prior to islamic invasion in the 12th century
@@AyushKumar-jj9hk 😂 liberandus like you destroyed India's culture. Mughal empire founder was babur and baburs father was humayu muslim mongal race and babur mother was Turkish race and babur was Muslim and from babur to bahadaur saha zafar all tried to destroy Hinduism, culture,slaughtred Hindus, raped Hindu women and converted Hindus to Islam. I think except Akbar
India's architecture is mesmerizing and ahead of its time.
Look at indus valley civilization
It’s the world’s oldest Civilization
@t s Muthuraman Lol
That's hindu architecture
@t s Muthuraman brain dead, nobody knew who were indus valley people their language has not been deciphered they were not tamil.
Our history has been called mythology ....hope finally these discoveries makes the correction in terminology 🙏.
We know that sea levels have risen 124 metres since the end of the last glacial maxima (12,000 years ago). We know that a lot of coastal cities drowned because the sea level rise. The problem is there are no contemporary records of the city known as Dwarka from where Krishna reigned. Just like there are no contemporary records of the Indus Valley Civilisation. But we do have remains of this civilisation which have been accurately dated and it's not mentioned in any ancient literature from the sub-continent at all. But it does find mention in records 4300 year old records from the Mesopotamian civilisation. They called the nation "Meluhha" by their contemporary Sumerians. Till such remains or references of Krishna's Dwarka are which can be physically dated, it is not considered "historical". The only references we have are from mythology which was transmitted verbally over unknown generations to be documented only around 800 years ago.
@@user-pf4tn2rl9n That's an error margin of 600 years! There is no evidence of the Mahabharat being written anywhere till about 800 years ago. It was passed through the generations orally. It is claimed that it was written between the time period you mention. If you are aware of a document with the epic written on it older than 800 years , I will be grateful if you point me to it.
Dwarka is claimed to be a city of the late Harappan period (that would make it from around 2000 BCE) by some scholars off lately but there is no evidence for it yet. If it was a city from the Harappan period, it would make it the 3rd or 4th oldest continuously inhabitated city of the entire history of our species. The Harappan civilization was in decline around 1900 BCE, completely disappeared by around 1500 BCE, followed by a collapse of most civilisations around 1100 BCE. When civilisation rose again after a few hundred years, what we call classical history started.
mostly quaint myths, just like the Judeo-Christian Bible, with some seed of history at best
@@dopplerduck we need DNA of Krishna to prove that Krishna existed ,is that you mean ?
@@dopplerduck in India written practices were started in 2000bc in some area and in some area 1500bc. You do not have any solid proof that Mahabharata was a mythology, and I do not have any solid proof that Mahabharata is a historical fact.
Its not India's Atlanti's, It's dwaraka in Bharat. Way ahead of Atlanti's timeline. One of its own kind and had glorious history.
Atlantis is from the Ice age era of the Ancient Alpine Civilization. Dwaraka is our modern era of only 3500 years back when Lord Krsna walked on this dusty earth. His reign was from Eastern Europe to Japan and from Siberia to South India. He mostly communicated with kings trying to unite with all dharmic /righteous kings.
Kya Tere papa bhi ankh, naak, kaan, muu se Paida hua the bhagwano ki tarah h saale sab Kahania h Hanuman ne Suraj kha Lia aam samajhkar, Karan Suraj se Paida ho gaya or Ganesh Mal se 🤣🤣 ye pakhand failana band karo
@@magd4570 atlantis is fiction.
@@songoku2731 Not that it is very important but Atlantis was real according to reverent Shrii Shrii Anandamurti (PR Sarkar). To know your local spiritual giants is a must and have some regard to what they say and write is better than speak without knowing.
@@magd4570 you can also check other videos where it is written and carbon dating is given also on google
It's Dwarka
Not Atlantis
Why do Europeans have to affiliate everything in a European sense? Like they call Ram Setu as "Adam's Bridge". Why?? Based on what??
It’s missionary tactics.
They always do this nonsense. Try and absorb history and culture of any place into the Christian mythos.
Names have power, why do you think they rename everything to their liking and why libtards in India lose the plot when ancient names resurface
Western people use paper in their toilet, still today. Why?? Based on what?
Based on their global domination
They can't tolerate our rich culture and history
Because Adam who is the first men according to Bible, when fell to earth, he might have fallen in present day Sri Lanka.... And crossed over to India through that bridge.... But they don't have anything to prove... it's Ram Setu
How fascinating. India is a land full of mystery.
Mystery of how cow dung become holy
@@rrsharizam yeah I know why you jealous 🤦 ola uber kid 😂
@@rrsharizam you guys are jealous of cows, cause their clothes don't get ripped off on airports 🤧
@@rrsharizam that's all a small mind like yours can be interested with.
@@rrsharizam How many Sucide Jacket You have .
Very interesting documentary! Fascinating how the so called "stories" are turning out to be histories.
no Western always tried to think our culture as a myth stories. they always started propganda against our culture and belief system. how cheap they were.
@@rrsharizam you cheap. who want to give you. you deserve mid finger salute. you also a dung or bullshit in someone perception as you are when you don't respect others belief system.
@@rrsharizam and you are bacteria of that wrong idelogy who thinks their prophet is messenger and earth is flat.. 😂😂😂
@@rrsharizam yeah cow is holy no doubt, not only cow every creation in this world is worthy to worship who has good qualities and helping us to survive in this world whether there contribution is too little or too much.
cow dung has some medicinal properties that protect from bacterias if we use cow dung to paint house or baramda.
we Believe god is in everything. everything is form of life so called god. where form of life, god exist there. so we worship from heart not by mind not to get something from ALLaha or something , just to spread love and to establish a connection with divine.
if you have good qualities and helping other form of life then you are also holy Spirit to us.
@@rrsharizam I think you're mistaking fuckwits with scholars, you prejudiced fool. What did Indians ever invent or discover... Oh the so called Arabic numerals are indeed Indian. Facts. Religion and science are two different disciplines... There are pl nty of flat earthers in Europe etc. Whatever troll!
Wanna add one fact many believe that Dwarka could actually be the city that inspired the tale of Atlantis. It is belived that Greek travelers took the story with them too and told it in their own way.
It's quite possible...
legit point... it coincides with times when Bharat had cultural, linguistic, knowledge, territorial, literaure, and adhyatmic influence and control over greeks,,, just about few centuries before cult of xtianty took over them.. and like they do even today "cannabalize and appropriate worlds knowledge, and history"
Not possible as Plato wrote about Atlantis one hundred years before Alexander the Great was born to go east.
@@dreddykrugernew That's wrong info actually. Alexander was first Greek Invader not first Greek traveller 👍👍👍
Kya Tere papa bhi ankh, naak, kaan, muu se Paida hua the bhagwano ki tarah h saale sab Kahania h Hanuman ne Suraj kha Lia aam samajhkar, Karan Suraj se Paida ho gaya or Ganesh Mal se 🤣🤣 ye pakhand failana band karo
I love my nation 😍 my hindustan full of mysteries nd reality
Radhe krishna ❣️
Why does your name say you're an atheist?
@@krishcshah it's to troll atheist.
@@redpillmatrix3046 I thought so too, but look at the user's comment history
@@krishcshah nothing wrong in being atheist.
@@krishcshah nothing's wrong with being atheist in sanatana dharma
We don't know any Atlantis, but from ancient times, we know our Dwarka.❣️
Kya Tere papa bhi ankh, naak, kaan, muu se Paida hua the bhagwano ki tarah h saale sab Kahania h Hanuman ne Suraj kha Lia aam samajhkar, Karan Suraj se Paida ho gaya or Ganesh Mal se 🤣🤣 ye pakhand failana band karo
Wtf is dwarka?
@Dr. Gregory House to see wtf is dwarka
@Dr. Gregory House because this video is a dhong like sanatan
no kingdom have been found
@@utkarshswaroop_0306 asli Id se aa
so if dwarika is found then it is easy to date how old is this city and which can be compared with the dates and times mentioned in Mahabharata. this will help us know how old is civilization and will also tell us clues as to what other civilizations used to exist at the same time...
@Megha Singh great that means verification can all be done and things can be settled regarding when all of these things happened and what other cultures were in existence during that time etc etc
watch for Nilesh Oak 👍
Mahabharat war dating is around 3100 BCE. Multiple sources and evidences point this out. So dwarka should be atleast few hundred years older
@@AST4EVER he's not accurate. Too hyperbolic. Check Manish pandit work.
Look up Raj Vedam on Sangam channel. He has some very good lectures there on these topics with a lot of scientific data.
Krishna was born in 5626 BC. That means well over 7600 yrs ago , Krishna was present on Earth. This statement is based on hundreds of ( geological+ hydrological+ Astronomical )evidences researched by Nilesh Oak and his team. That means the present Archeological society of India has to dig the areas which were unsubmerged in and around 7000 yrs ago, which is farther away in sea from the present coastline . I am confident we will find the real remains of original Dwaraka sometime in future , that will be the greatest find in our Indian history. The Real Hindus know that their Itihasas ( Ramayana and Mahabharata) are real histories. We dont have to prove to the rest of the world anything , but our Govts have to invest more money and resources to find our historical proofs for our love and devotion to our lord.
😂
🤣🤣🤣
So in mahabharat children are born form sun, fire lol
So he was born and died but is still God ?
@prajnana liberals ki jal rahi hai 😂😂
@@ralphrau Jesus didn't die?
How ancient history become mythology...Simple because history books where destoyed...But how long science can be suppressed, And it's amazing to see even after so much bashing and looting earth's first Civilization is still alive and thriving which is also known as India...
Yes
This was awesome! Especially about the information about the fluctuating sea level over the past 15000 years. It makes sense how cities and civilizations could rise and fall with such significant changes in sea level!
Atlantis a fable？a sunk city is caused by sudden geological disaster which won’t live with gradual sea level change。
Shiva met the Sanskrit top Dogs they sayd are you Shiva ?
Shiva Sayd who are you guys ?
They sayd we are a Plot.
Shiva Plotted along.
They walked Shiva walked.
They sayd friendly you walking along with smiles.
Shiva sayd smiling yes.
@@wonderwang1585 Atlantis was a fiction created by one man to explain political ideas. Duh.
@@honeysucklecat Atlantis is not disappeared still intact.
Its in Italy.
@@honeysucklecat I read Plato's Atlantis, it does not read as an allegory. It sounds like a scrap of history preserved for thousands of years in oral tradition.
Read it and see if you agree.
Hinduismus is not myth,it’s real and everything documented in our Dharmik books
Hinduism is mixture of mythology , history and philosophy
Myths like stories on Shiva were created for describing things much easily
@@Noone-gz8li You just can't claim that, Who knows that Shiva stories might also be our history.
@@vineethv1629 Shiva don't have any roop or structure
So how come stories are real ?
@@Noone-gz8li How do you know that Shiva has no roop or structure?
@@vineethv1629 so if Shiva have structure
How come Shiva is every where ?
Do u even even know that Shiva is omnipresent ?
What are u ? A Hindu ?
Don't Call It Indian's Atlantic !!
It's Precious Then Atlantic For Us
It Is Shri Dwarika Ji
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
Why are you calling yourself kaafir
@@wolfiesingh7093 because we are proud kaafir
I visited Dwarka few years back.......what a feeling it was felt like I reached back to Mahabharat period....Whole town is filled with Joy of spirituality.........Waking up early taking dip in Maa Gomti river along with blessings of Dwarkadish and watching Sunrise 🌅 on ghat can't share that feeling...... Request everyone to visit once in lifetime ✨
Is the river clean ??
@@Aman-wt9iv yup....people also feed fish with ata ball after dip.........
Wow. Great brother
Thousands of year passed and people still celebrate Birthday of Krishna, so how much we believe in him.
Can you imagine to know the REAL history of Lord Shiva 7000 years ago, who was the same as Lord Krsna (3500 years ago) in a different era? Divine manifestation - sadguru teaching Yoga/Dharma/Medicine/Music/Dance/Devotion.
@@magd4570 Bhagwan Shiva never stepped foot on Mrityuloka, but his Rudra Avatar Hanuman did
@@rrt_xoxo5632 After you look into the volumes by Shrii Shrii Anandamurti on Shiva you may find a missing link
@@magd4570 🙏
@@magd4570 Lord shiva lived like human on Earth somewhere around 60000 year's Varanasi is older than legend we can't even imagine our history.
When you talk about India , Hinduism it's all ways go back thousands of years
True. This new findings prove so called mythology of Hindus is Actual History of India. city found in Gulf of Khambhat is 32000 years old which sank nearly about 9000 years back. at the time when there were no cities in world. & still so called scholars of India calls Mahabharata still a Mythology. Unfortunately They don't want to accept scientific side of Hinduism.
And they say Mahabharata and Ramayana are myths not history 😐😐
@t s Muthuraman truth is not to be proven
Fact remains as it is !
@t s Muthuraman ok🙏🏻
@t s Muthuraman no doubt
That tamils are losing thier true history
Because of crossbreeds like u
I guess you say tamils conquering Indonesia is also not true??
So proud to see Indians going to back their glorious heritage instead of aping the West
DWARKA is one of the 4 Most holy sites for hindus. The 4 sites combined are known as 'Char-dham'
The other 3 being Jagannath Puri in the east, Rameshawaram in the south and Badrinath in the North.
Apart from these the 51 Shakti peeths scattered all over the Indian subcontinent are also of great significance.
.
Do read about the Shakti-peeths of India, it's fascinating how goddess Sati's body was cut into 51 pieces by Vishnu and the places where those different body parts fell, they became shakti peeths.
Expedition unknown dwarka in hindi
th-cam.com/video/XI9ebS3mN4I/w-d-xo.html
No, only 12
So India is Gods own country. Not just Kerala ? And because God was born and resides in India, the rest of the world is not as blessed as India....
@@ralphrau What hell you're talking.
I am an Indian, and I know India is God's own country. I can't speak of other countries. May be they are all converted countries.
@@ralphrau whole world is the part of Hinduism and Bharat varsha crackheqd
There's no such thing as "India's Atlantis". What is is "Western Dwarka".
Euro centrism at its finest
@@bhaveshtochabbra6853 after that they will white wash ancient people of dawrka also. And call ancient dwarka people who built this city as white Europeans or Aryan the Sanskrit word for their agenda that's how their propaganda works.
INDIA AND ITS PAST ARE AMAZING !!! BLESSINGS SENT !!!!!
This new findings prove so called mythology of Hindus is Actual History of India. city found in Gulf of Khambhat is 32000 years old which sank nearly about 9000 years back. at the time when there were no cities in world. & still so called scholars of India calls Mahabharata still a Mythology. Unfortunately They don't want to accept scientific side of Hinduism.
🙏🙏🙏🙏
Atlantis might be a myth but dwarka is history which submerged 5165 years back
Yeah sure fascist
@@agrajyadav2951 sure librandu
@@agrajyadav2951 chutiya when you fail logic you call someone fascist. You're not anti bjp you're anti Indian culture
.most probably a convert
🤡@@agrajyadav2951
Their Mystery is our History 🇮🇳🙏
❤️❤️👌🏼👌🏼
Ancient India was not Atlantis, but definitely was neighbors worthy of trade, love and respect. Something people from our generation couldn't even grasp mentally.
True. This new findings prove so called mythology of Hindus is Actual History of India. city found in Gulf of Khambhat is 32000 years old which sank nearly about 9000 years back. at the time when there were no cities in world. & still so called scholars of India calls Mahabharata still a Mythology. Unfortunately They don't want to accept scientific side of Hinduism.
When Megasthenes visited India, he mentioned in his book that he saw a lineage of kings that spanned 6042 Years imagine that knowledge.
The Rig veda was created in the stone age nobody knows the exact time.
Also, why the bullock cart parts are named exactly the same in all Indo European languages...means those tribes were living at the same place when bullock cart was invented!
What the names of bullock cart parts? What you say has piqued my interest. Please share...you have something here that others should pay attention to.
@United Provinces of Planet Earth I don't understand...why the rant?
@United Provinces of Planet Earth you are typical low IQ troll,live in your own cuckoo land
@United Provinces of Planet Earth do you even read what you post?
@United Provinces of Planet Earth You clearly don't. I am asking an explanation from YOU!
Anyone here after watching karthikeya 2 movie 😊 & interested to know more about Indian culture ?
When sea levels rose, many “Atlantises” were submerged. In the last 20,000 years, the oceans have risen 400 feet, most of that in the first 13,000 years of that period.
Well, they've risen and fallen and risen. It's more complicated than that. Also, cities are only about 12,000 years old.
@@gyozakeynsianism no, actually they are not. The remains of the earliest city known are 200,000 years old, and they're in Southern Africa. Gotta update your history.
@@omggiiirl2077 what is the name of that city? Because as far as i know gobeckli tepe was said to be the oldest found, at least 10000 years old.
@@omggiiirl2077 You're making things up. Humans weren't even in their modern form 200,000 years ago. Read scientists, not rumors on the internet.
@@nuthai4951 it's Mozambique's Maputo ruins.
Ohoo BBC showing Hinduism in Good light 😂
Paise ke liye koi kuch bhi karega
Some people termed our History as Mythology but Truth can never be hidden for long. 🙏
Exactly
Its termed Mythology since its never been proven yet. even this video doesnt fully show the connevtion with Krishna and Dhwarka
@@dagadag5599why r u so dumb
When the sawmi said Dwapar Yuga, the translation of it was "3000 years ago" nice one BBC
They’re simply talking about a lost, advanced, ancient civilization.
It's the port city of Krishna, one of the monumental historical character from the hindu epic mahabharata. This is ancient Indian history and not a separate civilization.
True. This new findings prove so called mythology of Hindus is Actual History of India. city found in Gulf of Khambhat is 32000 years old which sank nearly about 9000 years back. at the time when there were no cities in world. & still so called scholars of India calls Mahabharata still a Mythology. Unfortunately They don't want to accept scientific side of Hinduism.
If you took all the mythologies of the west and middle East together , even then it wouldn't compare to the grandeur of this city as is described in the scriptures.
There's a reason why Hindus so fiercely stock to their scriptures.
All of the legends of the rest of the world put together - even then they wouldn't compare to Mahabharata alone - there's dazzling grandness in every aspect of it.
Besides our living spiritual traditions make us believe in them.
the Hindu civilization.
Yes your white forefathers were also responsible.
After two thousand years, archeologists will dive into western India to rediscover the mythical city of Mumbai. Climate change is real whether you believe it or not.
Hahah nice
climate change is happening since the Earth formed. Human driven climate change is absurd!
Isn't it already mythical? Mythically world class, apparently.
😄 except it won't be mythical. We have more permanent methods of passing information from one generation to another
@@gazpachopolice7211 this is exactly what ancient Indians assumed when they built Taxila and Nalanda. Nothing is permanent.
Who are here after watching karthikeya 2 ??🙂
India is the one of the greatest , oldest and longest living civilisation in history
@Juniper tamil is India
India is the land of nice people I like their traditions, culture and food, above all the ancient cities are incredible
You are foreign born Indian right?
I don't think so
@@rrsharizam I saw your comments which is negative against Indians( you are a Muslim,so I assume you hate our Hindu religion)
Come on bro your name "Ashish Chaudhary" why use their culture.
Don't do that. If people gonna love india their are gonna do this on their
own not some random indian pretending to be foreigner loving india. Why use these shameful methods???
@@TGill22 and you're an Indian with appropriately named "T Gill" 🤣
2:32
Just Imagine Krishna might have touched one of these 4-5 thousand years ago😮😮
My thought exactly
No, cuz he didn't exist. And that's such a lame thing to think.
@@agrajyadav2951 there was only one king of Dwarka lol Sri Krsna
@@agrajyadav2951 abdul come by your real full name
@@agrajyadav2951 He existed ask your mom.
Dwarka is Dwarka we don't want to compare it with "Atlantis". Maybe you can call Atlantis as the Dwarka of West because Dwarka is much older than Atlantis
So how is it older than atlantis
Who is here after kartikeya 2 ?
Iam 😁
There are also old maps from the 1500 that were made from older maps where it shows dwarka above water. And there is a giant road on those maps that can be seen underwater... CRAZY!!!
Can u give reference ?
Dwarka submerged 3000BCE WHICH MEAN 5000 YEARS BEFORE
@@dalitnahipehlehinduhu6569 where!? Any evidence!? We still finding millions of year old fossils but here
Yeah sure dude lmao
True. This new findings prove so called mythology of Hindus is Actual History of India. city found in Gulf of Khambhat is 32000 years old which sank nearly about 9000 years back. at the time when there were no cities in world. & still so called scholars of India calls Mahabharata still a Mythology. Unfortunately They don't want to accept scientific side of Hinduism.
See I know Ramayana and Mahabharata really happened. You can't just create such epics from nowhere. I read Mahabharata happened around 3100 BC. So it's not a coincidence that Dwarka dates back to that period. I know it's hard to digest it for liberandus and western media, but you can't hide the truth forever 😂😂.
Itihas means Historical
That is a bad argument irrespective of whether the events happened or not
@@VSM101 bruv why you so dumb?
India is so rich in culture. Such a pity they are speaking more and more English instead of their own languages
@t s Muthuraman no
I went to Dwarka last year as a trip with my friends before everyone went to their own colleges. It was wonderful ~ We lived in sea-facing tents, swam in the sea, played volleyball-kho kho etc on the beach, went scuba diving, visited the Dwarkadhish Mandir, went to see dolphins deep in the sea, explored the city. It was the definitely the best trip I've ever been in & going with friends only made the experience richer.
Dwarka indeed is a lovely place and I will wholeheartedly recommend everyone to visit it once before you die.
Jai Shree Krishna
BBC Showing positive side of India really shocked 😲
@Norstark right
Wait for it, they will put a spin on it.
Never let the white man define our history and culture for us.
A lesson that Indian “intellectuals” fail to learn
So interesting how myth and history interact. Just like how 19th century Western archaeologists were motivated by proving the Bible, we can use mythology as historical text (with plenty of caution!) in other areas of the world. This also tells us something about the importance of the sea for civilizations, and how changes in sea levels can be catastrophic. Unfortunately, that may well be a future many of today's cities are facing.
The Iliad to find Troias (Troy)
@@christopherellis2663 But we have to be careful. The Trojan War may not have happened, like Noah's Ark.
@Jiang Dashan Oh no! Conspiracy! Get a grip.
@@rrsharizam Unlike the older Rigveda (is that what you are referring to?), the Mahabharata appears to be indigenous to South Asia and India specifically. It specifically makes reference to Dwarka and other Indian geography. I think it's fair to call this an Indian story.
Also, those oldest bits of the Rigveda from the Middle East predate even Zoroastrianism. They're truly ancient. Whether anyone has any business calling those elements "Hinduism" is another story however!
@@rrsharizam Malaysians are people fit to be ruled because they don't have a culture of their own and are living under an Arabic culture.
All our ancestors were too genius in mathematics, Astronomy and many things. Proud to be an Indian💗
🤯 BBC covering positive news about Indians and Hinduism 😱
Somnath temple distroy 17 times by mohammad ghori.
But the temple is still there, standing with honor and faith.
Proud to be hindu. 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
And people from somnath are still there in South India. Sourashtrians. I am one of them
Interesting! Somnath Temple was reconstructed every year so Ghori can destroy in again and again!!!
@@ronhak3736
In 1026, during the reign of Bhima I, the Turkic Muslim ruler Mahmud of Ghazni raided and plundered the Somnath temple, broke its jyotirlinga. He took away a booty of 20 million dinars.
Somnath was destroyed when Delhi Sultanate occupied Gujarat in 1299. In 1394 it was destroyed again. In 1706, Mughal ruler Aurangzeb again demolished the temple.
Story of Atlantis is based on Dwarika......in ancient time....when greek people came to study here in Taxila University....they listen about our..... History....& Make their own version of story....
Yeah and u do have a reference for that, right?
@@agrajyadav2951 Tere paas proof hai kya ki Dwarka aur Atlantis alag hai Gawar ki jhaant
@@agrajyadav2951 tun rehne de tere sar pe Hanuman ka asli gada bhi padega tab bhi saboot mangega
Greek mythology is copied from Hinduism
@@agrajyadav2951 Yes, details from Harivamsa are identical to Plato's edition, including the exact same ratio of the 3 concentric moats. Plato made some changes in his dialogue 'TIMAEUS' to teach morals to his fellow Hellenes. @Akhand Bharat
Daughter of S.R.Rao, a historian, in USA once gave details of findings of her father about Dwaraka . It is said that sea level rose 100 feet about 12000 years back and again 40 feet about 5000 Years back if I can remember.
Who is here after kartikeya 2? 🙂

ENGLISH
Dwarka
The ancient Indian city of Dwarka is known in Hindu culture to have been the great and beautiful city of Krishna. The Hindu writings say that when Krishna left the Earth to join the spiritual world, the age of Kali began and Dwarka and its inhabitants were submerged by the sea. The tales of the submersion can also evoke a tsunami like the one that struck India in 2004.
The modern Dwarka is today one of the seven sacred towns of Hinduism, visited each year by pilgrims worshiping Krishna. The search for its submerged part began in the 1930s, and the first archaeological excavation took place in 1963. Numerous ancient artefacts were found, as well as the submerged remains of the ancient Dwarka during the next excavation led by an underwater archaeologist.
Between 1983 and 1990 the archaeologists discovered a fortified foundation on which the ancient city walls must have been built along the river banks. Stone blocks used for the construction, pillars and irrigation systems were found but a debate is still ongoing regarding the dating of the vestiges, either from 3 000 to 1 500 years BC or from the Middle Ages.
Numerous stone anchors have also been recovered on the site at the same depth, which suggests, along with the size of the submerged part of the ancient city, that Dwarka must have had a place in the trading relations between Indian and Arabic areas during the 15th to 18th centuries and must have been an important trade port in the past. The world ‘dwarka’ means ‘door’ or ‘gate’ in Sanskrit, so this ancient port city could have been a gate for foreign sailors who arrived in India.
Dwarka is indias dwarka, not Atlantis. You shouldnt compare the historical beauty dwarka with any place
Cute nose 😊
Fascinating! If only we had a way to know the secrets of the past!
Unfortunately, indian archaeology agency haven't don't this yet just becoz they are hinduphobic. Also, it will reveal many truth about india's ancient glories.
Ramayan & Mahabharata..
Actually India had a lot of books about the ancient India in the Nalanda University and the Takshashila University but all of them were destroyed by the muslim invaders. It is said that the there were so many books at the Nalanda University that when the invader burnt then it burnt continuously for 6 months.
You can get a real glimpse into the past through the work of Shrii Shrii Anandamurti. You will be surprised, not only in term of actual timeline but also in many other ways. Look for his books
Who is here after Karthikeya 2 like and comment
Me
Who is here after watching Karthikeya 2?
ME
Hindu-Americans Rank Top in Education and Income. Hindu-Americans have the highest socioeconomic levels among all religions.
American is not a religon.
@@bhaveshtochabbra6853 big brain. 'Hindu Americans have the highest socioeconomic level among all the other religious communities in America.' That's what he means.
Who came here after karthikeya 2 💫
Hare Krishna ❤
I strongly feel this is a Indus-Saraswati civilization city . Remember the phase in Mahabharata when Krishna went from Mathura to Dwarka using Saraswati. The Saraswati delta is the Runn of kuchh in Gujarat. And this is the dwarka. It all ads up. The 5000 year sea rise co-incides with the 3000 BC date of the mahabharata. it makes the Indus valley cities around the same date as the Mahabharata. Also the finding of Rakkhigarhi near present day Kurukshetra and that too being an Indus Valley city. This is very exciting.
Mythologies are related.
Vedas share identical similarities with Zoroastrianism, from the storyline to even the language and grammar used. Zoroastrianism is pivotal to Semitic faiths like Judaism and later, Christianity.
It's very easy to get lost in the aesthetics and ethnic disambiguations of faith but as long as you trace each's origins and history, you start seeing striking similarities.
Essentially, all stories are one, every faith's events are retelling of the same global events. You can piece chronologies by using the periods in which every book of every faith was written/compiled.
Vedas doesn't have stories bro
@@mahendradhanushreddy2620 are you getting confused between the Vedas and the rest? (manusmriti, Upanishads, puranas). Wouldn't blams you if so, that's the whole idea lol.
@@paulie4450 The worst thing is you never read those scriptures
@@mahendradhanushreddy2620 have you read every single one of them? I will be reading RigVeda in the most proper translation soon, have been reading commentary and discussions of the gathas, and even without translation Sanskrit is quite easy to understand since Im familiar with most of the words. I like the RgVeda stories a lot.
@@paulie4450 Frist you read man I'm reading Agama shathras now
I guess it's a small step forward towards acknowledging truth by BBC even if they can't help but call it Atlantis.
A part was covered in the series *Expedition Unknown* by archaeologist Joshua 'Josh' Gates. They found some incredible samples to carbon date. Dwaraka is part and parcel of Bharat's ancient civilization and culture that has spanned eons 🙏
@t s Muthuraman the same connection which your parents has with missionary 🤣
Expedition unknown dwarka in hindi
th-cam.com/video/XI9ebS3mN4I/w-d-xo.html
@t s Muthuraman Lord Krishna is a character within the Mahabharta, and 'his city' was Dwarka...Their is your connection🙃
What a history of Hindus and Bharat ❤❤
Feel proud of our thousands of year of past but also at the same time feel sad after seeing partioned India where our culture has lost
I know how you feel I also used to feel like that when I was kid, but as I started learning history I got know that many civilization and nations where built,divided and eventually collapsed. so only thing we can do is to accept it and preserve it's remains. while taking inspiration from them to make our current civilization and nation more prosperous and grand than it used to be.
Thanks BBC
Beautiful documentary, I feel blessed just by watching this Krishna's city.
Indian Archaeology proves that Mahabharata and Ramayana are not Mythology it's a History ♥️
@t s Muthuraman i guess you are talking about yourself
@t s Muthuraman some things are to be understood and researched not explained. People who consider everything a joke including themselves don't deserve any explanation
Does that matter you ?
Yes , then GET LOST !
No, then GET LOST!
Harappan Civilization :
There are so many Harappan sites in Gujarat that it is likely that Dwaraka or Bet Dwaraka existed as part of that civilization.
Coming to Indian tradition, Mahabharata says that Dwaraka was submerged in the sea. In the Mausala Parva of the Mahabaratha, Arjuna witnesses the submergence of Dvaraka and describes it as follows:
" The sea, which had been beating against the shores, suddenly broke the boundary that was imposed on it by nature. The sea rushed into the city. It coursed through the streets of the beautiful city. The sea covered up everything in the city. I saw the beautiful buildings becoming submerged one by one. In a matter of a few moments it was all over. The sea had now become as placid as a lake. There was no trace of the city. Dvaraka was just a name; just a memory."
One must be careful combining history, archeology and mythology. Today many exaggerations and claims are made by some people, which make it difficult to separate fact from the fiction.
Graham Hancock told us about this nearly 20years ago.... Glad they excavating.... 👍
Hare krishna🌸💙
"More than 90% of India’s heritage lies buried and space archaeology can help unearth it … using satellites as a tool"
~ Sarah Parcak, Prof @ Univ. Of Alabama.
You can Imagine what lies under us.
Dwarka, Harappa, Mohenjodaro, Dhaulaveera and all, Only constitute less than 10% of India's heritage.
It's sad in previous 70 years nothing much has been done.
Finally they have brought out the truth about Sinauli, a good start.
Excellent work by our Geologists. Not only Archeological, but from religious poin of view, the study is relevant. It also strengthen believes in Sanatan.
You can't hide the truth.. Dwarka will gain its glory it deserves
Our History 🚩🙏🏾
Looks like TH-cam is recommending this after Karthikeya 2 😊
Whatever West thinks as myth and mystery, actually it is our civilizational history 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳✊✊✊✊✊✊✊🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I’m a history teacher in the United States. This is fascinating!!
جئی شری کرشنہ
Much of the last world Kingdom is lost below the sea.
This new findings prove so called mythology of Hindus is Actual History of India. city found in Gulf of Khambhat is 32000 years old which sank nearly about 9000 years back. at the time when there were no cities in world. & still so called scholars of India calls Mahabharata still a Mythology. Unfortunately They don't want to accept scientific side of Hinduism.
Yes it was lord Krishna city it's clearly mentioned in hindusium about it
We should thank bbc for showing this in a positive outlook mixed with religious beliefs and history.
Wait! propaganda is on the way. This is grass which butchers feed to goat before butchering them...
This is brilliant. More studies should be conducted here. ❤🇮🇳🚩
This is very misleading. Dwarka was never a missing or lost city. It was always known, because its an active city and was never abandoned. The fact that the Mahabharat mentions of its sinking proves that it was written many centuries after the temple etc submerged in water. The temple or structures were always clearly visible to the natives on the shores, so its sinking was never a mystery. Just like the Ram Setu is a protruding mountain ledge forming a bridge to Sri Lanka. It was obviously used to be above water, many centuries ago. The people formed mythologies upon these cities and rulers thousands of years after those ancient civilizations.
Yes like a Jesus. Jesus not a God child. He never do miracle but all act was coincidence..
Yes just like the myth of how marry gave birth to Jesus and still remained virgin
@@omkarnarkar8814 also when she gave birth three mysterious men appeared bearing gifts. I guess they didn't even know who the father was poor cuckold Joseph
Butthurt westerners
Nope, The original Metropolis of Dwarka built by LORD SHRI KRISHNA 🙏🏻 was submerged into Sea just in a few years after the GREAT WAR OF MAHABHARATA...THE CITY YOU OBSERVE NOW HAD BEEN RECONSTRUCTED....
Proud of you Vinod Sir 👏
Who is here after Kartikeya 2
That's all we could work on Dwarka? There is so much potential to explore and find out. I feel sad we haven't done our best to explore our history.
wow this is so fascinating. behind every myth lies a truth
Our History is marketed is myth by colonial powers and then colonised govts.
Because they are not myths, forcefully labelled myth by so called popular missionary rats
@@sayanchakraborty1252 they are??? nobody's willing to deny it if you've got reliable evidence. the version of religion we hear today is probably nothing more than a exaggerated version of something once real
UNFORTUNATELY, Government of India doesn't not support or give funds to ASI to carryout excavation of this site which is under sea....
The Man who had excavated three decades ago and discovered this site did this with his funds...
ASI does 10% good and 90% bad to the sites they are managing. Don’t believe me, visit any of the places managed by them . For example Visit Konark and experience how bad they are dealing with that beautiful gem
@@prabodh11 yes,governement employees become careless once they get their jobs...they will protect their house with all their might and main but when it comes about preserving somerhing which is connected to society they act very careless....
ASI wasn't adequately funded before 2014 when Modiji's government came to power. Congress misused and exploited ASI for achieving their goals in secularism and minority appeasement politics and blatantly distorted our history. In the last 8 years, we have seen some changes.
@@MrAgolikeri still ASI is not funded well..the tax we pay to the government is used on IT cells and Election promotion of BJp...
@@zaktanazaki8785 true and sadly every political party in India has done that . And that's what hurts our country. Our country has remained backward even 75 years after independence because of its politicians.
But yes, BJP is at least doing something positive, even if insignificant or little.
Dwarka is our kingdom . The kingdom of holy Gods , our Hindustan , our BHARAT , Our India . Sabse sresth Bharat 😭😭😔🕉️🚩🇮🇳🇮🇳
Most ancient and most advanced civilization!
@t s Muthuraman get lost paid bot! In ancient times all cultures respected each others that's why we share same history and country is United! Unlike Abrahamic rats! Who are still fighting! Missionaries are teaching you how to divide the country may be....but they do not know the core strength, so people like you will always fail and Missionaries in India will always fail!
@t s Muthuraman In a major finding that could impact the understanding of Indian ancestry, the DNA study of a 4500-year-old skeleton found in Rakhigarhi, in Haryana, suggests that modern people in India are likely to have descended from the same population.
These path-breaking insights came to light after scientists were able to sequence genome from the skeleton of a woman and study the archaeological evidence found in Rakhigarhi, a village located some 150 kilometers from Delhi. Rakhigarhi is the largest Harappan site in India.
“The ancient-DNA results completely reject the theory of steppe pastoral or ancient Iranian farmers as source of ancestry to the Harappan population. This research also demolishes the hypothesis about mass human migration during the Harappan time from outside South Asia,” Prof Vasant Shinde, director of the Rakhigarhi project, said.
Shinde said the new breakthrough completely sets aside the Aryan migration or invasion theory. “The skeletal remains found in the upper part of the citadel area of Mohenjodaro belonged to those who died due to floods and not (of those) massacred by the Aryans as hypothesised by Sir Mortimer Wheeler. The Aryan invasion theory is based on very flimsy ground,” Shinde said, adding that the history being taught to us in text books should now be changed.
The DNA revealed that there was no migration or inclusion of any Iran or Central Asian gene into Harappan people. "There is a continuity till the modern times. We are descendants of the Harappans. Even the Vedic culture and (that of) Harappans are same,” Shinde said.
“This research, for the first time, has established the fact that people of Harappan civilisation are the ancestors of most population of South Asia. For the first time, the research indicates movement of people from east to west. The Harappan people's presence is evident at sites like Gonur in Turkmenistan and Shahr-i-Sokhta in Iran. As the Harappans traded with Mesopotamia, Egypt, Persian Gulf and all over South Asia, there are bound to be movements of people resulting into mixed genetic history,” he added.
These revelations assume political significance as there have been demands to rewrite the history books to say that Vedic people were the original inhabitants of the country and they did not come from Central Asia. “Our premise that the Harappans were Vedic people thus received strong corroborative scientific evidence based on ancient DNA studies,” he added.
Another significant claim in the study published in the scientific journal Cell, titled "An Ancient Harappan Genome Lacks Ancestry from Steppe Pastoralists or Iranian Farmers”, is that farming was not brought to South Asia by large-scale movement of people from the Fertile Crescent where farming first arose. Instead, farming started in South Asia by local hunter-gatherers.
As the study results were published, separate statements were issued by Harvard Medical School which had collaborated in the study.
"Even though there has been success with studies of ancient-DNA from many other places, the difficult preservation conditions mean that studies in South Asia have been a challenge," says senior author David Reich, a geneticist at Harvard Medical School, the Broad Institute, and the Howard Hughes Medical Institute.
In this study, Reich, along with post-doctoral scientist Vagheesh Narasimhan and Niraj Rai, who established a new ancient-DNA laboratory at the Birbal Sahni Institute of Palaeosciences in Lucknow, led the preparation of the samples. They screened 61 skeletal samples from a site in Rakhigarhi, the largest city of the Indus valley Civilisation. A single sample showed promise: it contained a very small amount of authentic ancient DNA. The team made over 100 attempts to sequence the sample. Reich says: "While each of the individual data sets did not produce enough DNA, pooling them resulted in sufficient genetic data to learn about population history."
"Ancestry like that in the Indus Valley Civilisation individuals is the primary ancestry source in South Asia today," says Reich. "This finding ties people in South Asia today directly to the Indus Valley Civilisation."
The authors of the study, however, have a word of caution. “Analyzing the genome of only one individual limits the conclusions that can be drawn about the entire population of the Indus Valley Civilization.”
@t s Muthuraman That is just your assumption. Any evidence to back your claim. Also tell me your address people like you deserve to be debated with face to face.
@t s Muthuraman Ignorant people like you don't understand that we Indians are ONE Race. The imperialists and the invaders divided us Indians by creating this Aryan-Dravida divide. Same thing they did in countries like Nigeria and Rwanda.
@t s Muthuraman 🤣🤣nice joke
Thanks BBC..such a beautiful documentary..🙂👍👍
Very very fascinating. I really wish to visit Dwaraka one day.
The rise of sea level through dating data is strong evidence and the antiques truly unlocks the past. Great to know many hidden mysteries of our ancient era ☺️
Proud of my hindu culture we were ahead of time.... it was written in book 3000 year back 🇮🇳incredible
@Hari Krishnan plz don't say sorry to an arrogant person 🥺 you are right why Tamils always comment that all thing belongs to them ?? Why so much hate on Sanskrit and still having name in Sanskrit they're hypocrite
@Hari Krishnan bro out of 100 % 60 % tamzhans are head full of sh$$its ... they don't know who they are and what they are ... the british successfully manipulated there sh$$it head
Who is hear after watching Karthikeya 2 movie👍
Krishna was just too great an architect, weather expert, kinetic energy specialist or the greatest physicist, warrior, statesman you name it... He was it all! 🙏💫🙏
Sarcasm 😮
@@jayanthlaxman9188no sarcasm this is the believe among vaishnavistes. So yea they are true in a sense
You don't need to search as Dwarka is residing in our hearts ❤️
Hey everyone! In Himachal pardesh there is a town by the name Bilaspur. If you search its history and stuff, its really amazing. If you see the Satluj river there, you can spot Temple tops coming out of the water…on 6-8 spots…in a large sq…i think in 800sq metres of area…and if you talk to people there…everyone knows there’s a hugee hidden temple beneath the river and river surface…and it’s really over the world to just watch the site with your eyes…knowing that there is something big under it…and it’s not a guess…you can clearly spot that there is big hidden temple under the mother earth..
Contact praveen mohan