Don't compare bhagat Singh with bhindrawale.....both were fighting the tyrannies of their time...stop ur bullshit propaganda of INDIAN mythology.... cope with it, we got gurudwara dedicated to sant ji.....
He is sympathiser of Khalistani he is not condemning bhinderawale bhinderawale is terrorists installed by indra gandhi and sanjay gandhi sikhs are our brothers
@@Cherry-sg4zg Everyone had come to know about Bhindranwale's relation with the Pakistani army. Bhindranwale was waiting for the attack of Pakistani army so that he could attack India from inside and separate Punjab from India. After Bhindranwale's death, most of Bhindranwale's associates fled to Pakistan. Even after that if you support Bhindranwale then clearly you are traitor and salt namakhram of this country. Bhindranwale and the people supporting him were terrorists.
Waheguru ji🙏 Main Himachal se hu or pichle 2 saal se punjab me rh rha hu maine ak baat notice ki hai punjab me Bhindranwale ko lekar adhiktar log ak jaise vichar rakhte hai ki vo sant tha or punjab ki bhalayi chahta tha Is par main apni raye nhi rakhunga Lekin main ak baat khna chahta hu ki yeh khna punjab me caste system nhi hai sab braber hai Sikhism me sab braber jarur hai lekin ground reality kuch or hi hai Jis shop se hum rashan lete hai unhone mere dekhte hi dekhte christianity ko apna liya Ak din unki shop me sada yeshu jag vich aaya hai repeated baj rha tha Maine socha aise tv pr chal rha hoga lekin main bimar tha kuch time ke liye to aunty aaye khte Put tu yeshu de darbar hokar aa menu bhi bda dard siga nale ghar ch bhi kuch thik ni si asi yeshu de darbar ch matha takiya ardas lgayi hun sab thik hai mujhe bahut jayda herani huyi kya bol rhe hai Tab maine ak baba ji se pucha o kehnde athe a sab chal riha bde chira or unhone btaya ki vo sikh jo khud ko dalito ki tarah mante hai christian bn rhe hai Mujhe christian se koi dushmani nhi hai lekin dharmantaran bhi shi nhi manushy ko hamesha khud me sudhar ki jarurat hoti hai darm parivartan ki nhi🙏
Majority of the Sikh comments here are heartwarming!! As a Hindu from Jammu that grew up hearing stories of the Sikh Gurus sacrifice to save humanity and that saw the gurudwara as another legitimate place of worship, these current Khalistani developments are so bewildering. But then comments from some of the Sikh brothers and sisters are so reassuring. Waheguru ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguri ji ki Fateh🙏🏼🙏🏼
No. I’m not a fan of Hindu rashtra. When everything is peaceful, every religion must co-exist. But if Dharma( not religion) is threatened, then one must fight. Not violently, but with every other measure available. And if life is threatened, then violence for self defense is absolutely ok. Don’t you agree?
Thanks for this interview ANI. Despite so much of clarification by Grewal ji, I strongly believe that SGPC need to minimise the gap between Hindus and Sikhs. All Ten Sikh Gurus were Hindu and Sikhs are out of Hindus. We are one and shall remain one. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Probably the most beautiful and valuable comment on this interview.Yet, the no of likes you have got unravels the trench between both the communities which a few of fanatics has successfully managed to peddle.
This is beautiful! And there is comment below that says you are not a real Sikh, I wouldn’t dignify that with a rebuttal. But Sir, it’s elevated thoughts like these that form nations and hold us all together. I hope the Sikhs get justice from the Indian state and we all remain one!! 🙏🏼
When he talked about letting the Sikhs in jail out she didn’t even try to answer that and just skipped over it while telling him to answer everything she asked
The fake hindu account keep barking caste jatt let me tell you khalistan movement founder jagjeet singh chauhan Sikh rajput Babar Khalsa founder talwinder Singh parmar Sikh rajput whole khalistan movement lead by sikh Rajput jatt just fighted for us and we are proud Sikh rajput will face anything to defend sikhi
Why did he didn't explain what was the meaning of staying with bhindrawala when he was fighting with army? Did he explain why he was hiding inside golden temple? Why did sgpc of that time complained to government about his illegal refuge inside the temple?
Bhhindrawala tan terrorist c, bhai jo amritsar ch hindu maare c 1984 de baad ode baare kuj ni boleya, kyon ni beyea, supp sungh geya jinna ne hindu maare,
10th Guru eliminated caste system by giving Singh and Kaur as Surnames but many people still uses caste surnames and still takes pride for there ancestors clans or any other reason also. It is there wish to use anything with common surnames, but Gurus eliminated varna system in Sikhi. And conditions of deprived Sikhs can only be solved through education (both religious and modern) in long run, that government and SGPC should provide. And existence of separate gurudwaras based on caste in villages is very sad thing in Sikhi and that can only be solved through collective effort in Sikh community.
Why is it that the more i hear SIKHS talking the more i am convinced that SIKH Separatism is coming. Even if we for a moment keep aside the KHALASTAN tag, the nature of Separatism is evident in PUNJAB. To ask a few questions 1) Is it true that cast discrimination cases have been on the rise in SIKH punjab, even to the extent that SIKHS are now converting to Christianity. 2) if you say there is no cast discrimination and the reason for establishing SIKHs was to remove cast discrimination, then why are there separate gurudwara for Jaat and not jaat sikh. 3) if you further deny existence of cast in Sikhsim, then what's the basis of having SIKHS and SIKH LIGHT INFANTRY nits in IA. 4) As per you if all the Dharam are same, as you said, then why was KHALSA ever established, afterall we would have been praying to the same god, only the mode of practice and name of the god would have changed and if you say you were a contemporary of all religions, why was there any opposition from Jahagir, after all weren't they could have seen you a SUFI sect let nurture. another observation why are Only SIKHS from PUNJAB AND CHANDIGHAR region seen abusing HINDUS GODS, why was Maa KALI temple attacked in Punjab by NIHANG SIKHS and why do we we not see such acts from SIKHS from UP, BIHAR, MAHRASTRA, MP or any other state for that matter.
@@movieworld7769 argument of convience (jo acha laga woh hum laye the jo bura laga woh Hindus ke wajah se aaya) it's been 500 years still blame the Hindus. As far as respecting all religions are concerned why Raja Ranjith Singh ji had Lord Hanuman and Maa goddess photo on his sword, why did he say he will kill the butchers of cow. Afterall if he did respect all religion there was no need for Sikhism or Khalsa army in the first place. You could have lived in synchronicity by following the religion of the Invader, after all it did deserve your respect, what respectful is also acceptable. isn't it?
@@movieworld7769 why hasn't SJPC done or said anything against cast discrimination in Sikhism? Does SJPC or Khalsa panth actively support and encourage intercast Sikh marriage (seeing as cast was not practiced by Gurus, but was later adopted by the society) are Gurudwara participating in eradicating cast from Sikhism. Punjab is 58 sikh, seeing how you are a majority you should have influenced the Hindus in Punjab, why is it the other way around, is Sikhism soo weak? If castism is Hindu why are more Sikhs converting to Christianity (by mere percentage) in Punjab that in any other state. Clearly there is something wrong in Punjab. As far as your own mindset of Bhagwa is concerned, I Don't give 2 piece about it, it's your filth you deal with it.
Same I’ve also got a question why do did only Hindus in regions like Delhi and northern parts of India demolish gurudwas and kill innocent Sikhs unlike Hindus in mumbai and other places
@@abhaybgh ooo what i will kill some people using your name so is it your fault or my and second part Amritpal singh what crime he conducted what his weapons was licensed by panjab government his AKF what about RSS. Ramdasia loin force bajrangbal. So what crime he conducted if he has some small crime' assume is NSA is the right decision
Sikh gurudwara act 1925 which first time defined Sikh identity and led to creation of SGPC was passed by British and Grewal sahab is suggesting SGPC was created as a resistance to British influence on Gurudwaras. I suggest a counter by Puneet Sahani if ANI and Smita Prakash can invite him for the podcast.
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Puneet Sahani is a complete liar. He knows nothing about Sikhism. Actually he is not a sikh. I say that because Sikhism is not only about wearing turbans
The British had appointed the Mahants after kicking out the Budha dal from the gurduwaras. There was then the Akali movement which sought to take the mahants out of the gurudwaras and establish the SGPC. After many Sikhs died marching against the mahants the British govt finally gave into the Akali movement's demands and established the 1925 act that you are talking about. There is documented proof of this, and many Sikhs even died for this specific movement. You can read up on the Gurdwara Sudhaar movement (Gurdwara reform movement) if you want to. And stop bringing that Puneet mf into the conversation, he is not a Sikh.
This Sardar is speaking like a hypocrite. Saying that Guru Nanak did not wear Janeu whereas the university professors of Panjab University Patiala say in their books that Nanak wore janeu. He is saying that Bhindrawale was not a terrorist, whereas there are proofs on media channels today that he headed a gang of terrorists who shat and raped women inside the holy sanctum sanctorum of Golden Temple. This Sardar is delusional, paid to spread lies.
This Sardar is speaking like a hypocrite. Saying that Guru Nanak did not wear Janeu whereas the university professors of Panjab University Patiala say in their books that Nanak wore janeu. He is saying that Bhindrawale was not a terrorist, whereas there are proofs on media channels today that he headed a gang of terrorists who shat and raped women inside the holy sanctum sanctorum of Golden Temple. This Sardar is delusional, paid to spread lies.
A lot of contradictions and looks like he is also brainwashed, I am sorry people might disgree with me. Hats off to you Smita Ji to keep your calm during the recording.
Amritpal and his followers barged into the Police Station and demanded that one of them, in the police custody be freed. Or else? Is that not going against the State? And he had lately been talking openly about rebellion too.
Smita - What you said in the end... Learning more about sikh faith and SGPC was achieved in the first 10 minutes of the episode... the rest of it was a waste of time. In comparison to your other podcasts ( of which i have heard almost all of them ) this was intellectually shallow and the views expressed here were quite fantastic .... Looks like you made this only to tick a box or meet a deadline to share a podcast....
This Sardar is speaking like a hypocrite. Saying that Guru Nanak did not wear Janeu whereas the university professors of Panjab University Patiala say in their books that Nanak wore janeu. He is saying that Bhindrawale was not a terrorist, whereas there are proofs on media channels today that he headed a gang of terrorists who shat and raped women inside the holy sanctum sanctorum of Golden Temple. This Sardar is delusional, paid to spread lies.
Respected Smita ji, you should have asked him some difficult questions How British convoluted tried to omit the linkage between Hindu ( Santana Dharma) & tried to establish Sikhism as a separate religion altogether Nefarious Designs of Max Arthur Macauliffe works, the British Civil Servant in British imperial rule in punjab after 1857 revolt as a strategy & cultivated many people like assets like Kahn sigh Nabha etc who did selective translations of Sikh literature & traditions following Macauliffe's work, these people of same ideology tried to justify the massacre of Jhalianwala wala Bagh & today work for separatist ideology of Khaalistan Mr. Grewal selectively put all the blame of teaming up with the British to those so called selfish "mahants" British played from both sides as they always did, choosing the characters with weak moral milieu from both sides as their assets to carry on their agenda - Divide & Rule There's a reason why khaalistani operatives given safe heavens in west, it's their project which they use till today as a leverage when dealing with India Pakistan was also British project Britishers loved the likes of MK Gandhi & Nehru while they hated the likes of Netaji Subhash Bose, Savarkar, Sardar Bhagat Singh tried everything to kill them physically & politically. proof is in the pudding
For Hindus also sikh guru also our ,guru like sankarachrya. We are brother by blood. The only thing if anyone think to devide this country then no matter what is the religion of that person muslim,sikh,bodh or even if he is hindu then also he is our enemy.this thing is very clear in our mind.vo hindu ho or khud ka beta ho to dusman hi h.
If you look at Guru Nanaks very early pics he used to wear jenuw and tilak. I want these sikhs stop telling lies and for once tell the truth. They behave they dropped from the sky on some special mission by God. Did sikhs come out of muslims, hindus or from the sky.
That's such a lame argument Hindus have got. They can't just digest the fact that there exists a fraction of people that followed Guru Nanak and his successive descendants which criticize a lot of their practices, and formed their own religion and see themselves as a distinct race. I as a Sikh see nothing in me that is common to a Hindu. Infact, I find Muslims that speak Panjabi more closer to my culture than Hindus of UP or Bihar.
Women seats were reserved even in 1924. GURU NANAK JI MESSAGE was "ਸੋ ਕਿਉ ਮੰਦਾ ਆਖੀਏ ਜਿਸਨੇ ਜੰਮੇ ਰਾਜਾਣ " why women should be considered inferior because they have been given birth to Kings.
This guys says that Punjab feeds the country as if they do it for free.. Punjab k kisan has been the biggest benefactor of the agricultural subsidicies as well as MSP. All the subsidy, tax break, MSP purchases are done by the state / center govt, using the taxpayers money.. So lets not pretend or act like we have been fed for free by punjab..
Panjab's resources have been looted by the Hindi heartland. You take our waters for free without providing us any royalties. India as a country gives 0 fucking rights to its states.
True, let the states decide where they want to procure their grain from for PDS, why should jharkhand buy rice from Punjab when it's readily available from Bihar & west Bengal.
This Sardar is speaking like a hypocrite. Saying that Guru Nanak did not wear Janeu whereas the university professors of Panjab University Patiala say in their books that Nanak wore janeu. He is saying that Bhindrawale was not a terrorist, whereas there are proofs on media channels today that he headed a gang of terrorists who shat and raped women inside the holy sanctum sanctorum of Golden Temple. This Sardar is delusional, paid to spread lies.
A very very patriotic programme i saw today. Both sides made very insightful presentation. Host was very impressive & persistant with equal wittiness show by the other side. Feel proud that i reside in a country, which has the intellect to solve our difference. A super podcast today, full marks Smita Prakash for making today's podcast. This has a far reaching benefit to our country.
Am not convinced with Grewal ji re centre working in tandem with AAP in Punjab. While he continued to point a finger at Modi ji. PM has been most supportive to Sikhs to whom I belong as per my faith. SGPC sending lawyers for every wrong of Sikhs arrested isn't palatable. Why SGPC never fought for the victims of '84 massacre?
Veer ji Maharaj Ranjit Singh to baad j kise hukumat ne sikhaan nu naal lai k chlan di jurat kiti hai ta oh Modi sarkaar ne kitti hai ohh bnde de man ch j sikhaan waste nafrat hundi ta oh kde patka bann k guru ghr matha na tekda, par sadde wich kuch lok akal de Anne ho k baithe ne
4:52 ਗੁਰਚਰਨ ਸਿੰਘ ਗਰੇਵਾਲ ਜੀ ਉਹਨਾਂ ਵਿੱਚ ਐਸੇ ਲੋਕ ਤੁਸੀਂ ਵੀ ਸੀ ਤੁਸੀਂ ਵੀ ਸੂਦਰ ਹੋ। ਬਾਕੀ ਤੁਸੀਂ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਦੇ ਮਾਹੋਲ ਦੀ ਗੱਲ ਕਰ ਰਹੇ ਹੋ ਜਿਹਨਾਂ ਦੇ ਘਰ ਉੱਜੜ ਗਏ ਉਹਨਾਂ ਨੂੰ ਪੁੱਛ ਕੇ ਦੇਖੋ ਕ੍ਰਿਪਾ ਕਰਕੇ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਤੇ ਮਿਹਰ ਕਰੋ। GURCHARN SINGH GREWAL YOU ARE SUCH PEOPLE AMONG THEM. YOU ARE ALSO SUDAR. THE REST OF YOU ARE TAKING ABOUT THE ENVIRONMENT OF PUNJAN, ASK THOSE WHOSE HOUSES HAVE BEEN DESTROYED. PLEASE HAVE MERCY ON PUNJAN. SMITA PRAKASH JI YOU ASKED VERY-GOOD QUESTIONS. RAJINDER SINGH AUSTRIA
Also they should open the account of expenditure They should tell govt. Where they are spending money SGPC may have role in bank rolling terrorist through back channels Guru ki golak is occupied by lutera's in sikhi bana
@@ishankalia1219 why...SGPC need to show account to Govt ..It's our religious place what government has to do with this..SGPC should do this and that..u don't know anything and talking rubbish.. But even then just because I feel that there is no need space for bitterness so answer is that SGPC pays to top firms complete audits SGPC finances. Even if your problem isn't solved yet you can go to SGPC office and get a copy from there.. but request humbly.
Seriously man why you need to know what's in the report Akal Takht Sahib appointed the committee to find out about this issue and they had over that report to Jathedar Sahib from Shri Akal Takht Sahib. So the report is already there where it should be why it is became your concern don't you think you are interfering in without any reason ?
Mokaprasti? Then Why did not you also condemm and lebel as T* to Subhash chandra Bose for using shanghai gurdwara as AZAD HIND FOUJ(army) training centre?
@@LovepreetSingh-vx4hi 22,000 as per the estimates of experts on militancy in Punjab. I know you're gonna deny the sufferings of Punjabi Hindus, Jains and Christians. So it's of no use to reply to you. What happened with Sikhs in Delhi and some other parts, was a pogrom by Congress party cadres, goons and anti-social elements. In which around 3-5,000 Sikhs died. This is one of many reasons which turned me against Congress party and Nehru-Gandhi family.
Shri Ram was not political leader .. kings were not politicians.. he cited a very wrong example .. He avoided the Islamic persecution of Sikhs totally .. And as per him “ Bhindranwale was not terrorist .. “ not only he supports Bhrindanwale but he goes on to say that He was at golden Temple fighting Indian Army during op bluestar .. that says it all .. 😊 He forgot Guru Nanak and other gurus were originally Hindus .. Guru Gobind Singh ji was Guru Gobind Rai.. Sikh religion is 99℅ similar to Hinduism.. Panj Pyaare were Hindus from different parts of Bharatvarsh.. 🙂
I haven't come across a brave Sikh who said Khalistan murdabad. They say love Hindus Jai Hind But stay silent on Khalistani Stay silent on Pakistan and Muslims
@@patriot9981 - Stay silent.. 😊 Who are you to advocate Khalistanis and Pakistan? They are both against what I stand for .. Mental blockage is growing day by day with false narratives..
I am a Hindu Punjabi and I have grown up completely surrounded by sikh families, almost all my life. He iss talking a lot of nice sounding words. But the basic message that hes giving is that religion should dominate over politics. That is the basic root cause of all kind of nefarious activities. Country comes first. If he wants religion to take prominence then he should probably move to pakistan. I stopped going to the gurudwara in USA When I saw how proudly the names and photographs of all the terrorists were displayed openly and proudly everywhere. Which is a shame because growing up in India. I do not remember going to a Hindu Temple even 10% of the time we would go to the gurudwara.. My mom would give the food supplies to the gurudwara as part of "shraadh" Activities for my grandparents because she said she is 100%. Sure that the food given there will actually be used to feed all the people Regardless of their cast color or economic status. Something she said she was sure Was not going to happen in a hindu temple. It is sad that such a wonderful religion and a wonderful, lively , brave community of people has been politicized to such an extent.. He is completely wrong. Bhindrawale was a total terrorist And propagated killing just like a terrorist. He is lying out rightly. His so called religious leader gave an interview to the thenn prominent newspaper " navbharat times" Where he clearly demanded a separate state. Worst mistake the congress party made. I hope this guy is being investigated
It’s time u hindu punjabi khatris should know that we know ur reality and backstabbing Sikhs in their cause. Ur a Hindu idol worshipping Hindu which is prohibited in sikhi. About ur mom giving food to a Gurdwara for shraad is for ur own benefit in believing this will reach grandparents. Ur hindu selfishness that is unable to think beyond themselves. It is time more sikhs are now supporting khalistan. We welcome it if it’s given peacefully or otherwise other options are always on the table perhaps it will come after next indo pak and China war.
It would, if you don’t practice what you preach. Using religion to dominate politics is wrong but keeping in mind your faith and taking decisions in any situation is not, unless religion is a facade to coverup for shoddy politics.
Madamji-----Plz RAW agency,,,Int. B and Sanjay Suri,,Anuradha bhargav,,Subramanium Swamy ji ko Sant Bhindrawale ji ke bare me puchiye,,,shyd Sikho par apko vishwas nahi ayega,,,ap har movement ki books paro,,,Anandpur Resolution paro to pta chalega k is resolution ko ignore krke...Sarkar ne,,,intelligence buro ko use krke apni kursi bachane k lye Police cats Sikh veshbusha me Darbar Sahib k ander bhej kr Santji ka vishwas jita or wohi police cats ander weapons leke gye,,,hamare to Darbar Sahib k ander jate purse tak check hote the,,,onhi police cats k thru Weapons ander gye or ek drama operation Bluestar ka rach k congress ne hindu vote hasil ki,,,Sarkar har movement me isi tra krti ha,,social media ek inttli,,buro ka employee, yeh sab kuch bta raha ha wohi jo mene apko bataya,,,Subramonium ji k samne Santji ne 2 hindu girls k ghar father ban kr basaye,,,Kapurthala jail me Shiv mandir banayia,,,1982 me Ramayan ki beadbi hui to wo case larkar doshi ko prison me bheja,,,ese hor kai ex ha,,,,os smey sikho k Guru Granth Sahib ji ki bhi beadbi karwai gyi,,,sikh aurto ko nanga krke ek gaon me parade ki,,,kai sikh youths ko joothe police encountero me mara gya fir bhi Santji ne hinduo ka virodh nahi kya,,,sirf Sarkar se sikho k yeh kamo ko discourage krne ki mang ki...par sarkar ne Anandpur Sahib Resolution ko ignore krke khud ugerwad peda kia or Sikho k khilaf esa jehar ugla k sikho dwara har dharam k logo ki sewa me,carona me ,,apni jaan ki baazi laga dene k baad bhi yeh zehar khatam nahi hua,,,agar nafrat karte rehenge,,to fir sikh yehi kehenge k fir hame alag kr do jese 2 brothers ki lagatar larai k baad batwara hota ha
Religion without Spirituality is like a bottle without perfume. That is what needs to be addressed. Everything will fall in its right place. Today there is no spirituality in religion, only politics and lust for power.
Smita Prakash is not a investigative journalist.. doesn't know how cross question this khalistani on this historical treachery.. she couldn't even handle his cricket BS properly.. 😂
Haha so many investigative journalists tried to throw off Amritpal, none succeeded😂 that either means that the sikh POV is very strong, or that the Hindu POV on Khalistan is untenable
@@manvirsvwhich journalists are you talking about ? khalistani Pov right now is insect for hindus of bharat to actually focus or counter on. We have bigger fish to fry.. enjoy while it lasts.. Ampritpal will take bindiwala route faster than he gets to say"soorma ke kaum.." if you want to save him, you take him away in hiding.. He was a rat on ClubHouse. Semi literate NRI used to show him his place everyday. 😂
She did question and confront Grewal 35th minute onwards. Beyond a point, I think she played safe not to provoke the ones who live on the provocation edge. This quality of aggression made sikhs the top pick even by Brits..so not that I am overall calling this man as aggressive. She takes liberty of cross questioning with liberated minds such as EAM S. Jaishankar, AIM, Sushant Sareen, Tilak Deveshar, each army veteran that came on the show and even Bollywood actors.
The fake hindu account keep barking caste jatt let me tell you khalistan movement founder jagjeet singh chauhan Sikh rajput Babar Khalsa founder talwinder Singh parmar Sikh rajput whole khalistan movement lead by sikh Rajput jatt just fighted for us and we are proud Sikh rajput will face anything to defend sikhi
kuchh gawar logo ko je nahi samj ata . jab koi kisi dharm ko apna leta haye , to us ka purane dharm se koi rishta nahi rah jata . aur dharm insan ki niji marji haye , koi bhagwan ko manta haye ya nahi je har admi ki apni marji haye . insan ko insan samjo je hi sab se acha dharm haye .
Brother, who is akhal takhat jathaydar. He is from sc community. Which is highest temporal seat in Sikhism. In Sikhism no any caste smaller or higher class ..... There are many head priest in gurdwara shaib are from sc, BC community.
So as per your logic last president of India was from SC and present one is from ST so the differences in peoples beliefs in India in these artificial creations have disappeared?
Brothers I just mentioned cast system in Sikh society. But one question 🤔 did JATT Sikh marry their daughters to CHAMAR, no and why people converting to Christianity from Sikh community. Think about it.
@@jalebibai4960 how many western white marrying to black.. how many rich people marry to poor.. how many politicians child marry to middle class... There are so many examples in n Punjab. Few months back Punjabi minister jatt harjot bains tied knot to Hindu girl.. It society issue. still there are many people if their social status is same then people don't hasitate to marriage. For example, my friend who is doctor, he marriage to BC class doctor lady... Captain amrinder Singh nephew married to Hindu family...
SGPC kaha tha when amritpal attacked police station, sgpc did not condemned. SGPC kaha rha jab london high commission mai hamare indian flag ke sath chedkhani ki gayi. SGPC kaha tha jab Indian flag ke sath ladki ko mana kia gaya sabke samne. SGPC kaha rha jab Khalistan ke naare lage Golden Temple me, Talware nikali jaati hai, flags toh allowed nai fir khalistan flags kaise allow kie jaate h. SGPC kaha tha kab bhindrawala weapons jama kar rha tha to fight with center. SGPC wants proof from center and agencies to prove that amritpal is terrorist instead tell amritpal to prove himself as normal citizen. SGPC are supporting everyone who are openly saying "WE ARE NOT INDIANS" in amritpal case. SGPC never ever condemned, when hindu temples got attacked in india or outside india by fake sikhs.
Why indian army attack at golden temple ? If anyone rise aa demand of khalistan every buddy start calling terrorist to him , but why it is not same for hindu raster supports ? Why many people call indian hindustan or it is right or wrong? Most of freedom fighters are from punjab but why this country give more respect or right to punjab ,even though government promised to sikh leader to giver different constitution and rights to punjab , if they drop the plan of there different country , but this country not fulfill his promise so why ?
Hum " HINDU RASHTRA" main sabhi ko apna maante hai chahe wo Sikh ho, Muslim ho ya Esai. Humne kabi bhi Hindu rashtra me baki logo ko alag karne ki baat nai ki. Kabi kisi hindu bhai ne kisi mandir ko kabza karke sarkar se ladai nai ki hame hindu rashtra chaiye. Bhindrawala ne golden temple pe kabza kar lia, Waha usne log jama kie Tactics plan ki, Weapons jama kie. Hate speeches di jisse desh ka mahol kharab ho, kitne saare hindu bhai maare gaye. Center ne galat kia army bej ke we accept or koi rasta nikalna chaiye tha. But uske matlab ye nai jo bhindrawala ne kia wo sahi kia. Bhindrawala ne khud sarkar ko samne se nyota dia aao hamla karo aake. He thought aisa karke usey sympathy milege baki logo ko par wo galat tha. Jaati mai mat batoo, Pahale hum desh wasi hai uske baad hindu muslim ya sikh. Desh hai toh hum h desh nai toh hamari koi pechan nai bahar dusre desh jaate ho to As indian jaate ho not as Hindu, Sikh ya muslim. Dont spread hate or promote anything which breaks unity in our country.
@@dineshgyanani7170Teri yeh baatoh peh koi vishwas nhi karne waala jaisa india hain waise rahega warna jinko jyada chul machi hain hindu rashtra banane ki woh phir reality dekh lenge
@@frequencyatom7052 Sacchai hai, vishwas karo nai farak nai padta. Jaisa chal rha hai ache se chalo kisi ko koi dikkat nai. Baki iss desh me reh ke desh ka namak khaa ke apne baap pakistan ka nara lagyenge khalistan ka nara lagayenge toh koi bhi saccha deshwasi sehen nai karega. !!! Jai Hind 🇮🇳 Jai Shree Ram 🚩
@@dineshgyanani7170 Why you use slogan Jai Shree ram at patriotic debate? Because you want to supress other religion . That's the only motive of hindu rashtra. True Indian is always a Indian. They never support hindu rastra or any other religious country
Is aatnkvadi ko sunne k bad muje lg rha h Khalistan sach me ek serious problem h bharat k liye... Asa q hota h.. sb bharat ko hi dhoka q dete h..😢 Hinduo apne ap ko mjbut bnao Bharatmata ka sath aane vale vkt me sayd sirf hm hinduo ko dena h..😒😒😒
Mr. Grewal is highly redicalized. He sounds more like apolitical leader than a Sikh leader. There are religious differences in India. But Sikhism is not a part of this. They are liked as brothers. They are there in every corner of our country. Except 84 riots there was never any incident against Sikhs.
I don't know what to say. I see there is a resentment in Sikhs but couldn't figure out exactly why? On the other hand I see some statements that are borderline radical. This situation among Sikhs is not as pleasant as I thought it was. But I hope that India remains United. We know Sikhs are righteous and I feel hasty decisions will not be made.
Basically it stems from 1947. Sikhs had to decide whether to go with Pakistan or India. Nehru made promises and managed to convince Sikh leadership I.e. SGPC. So, Sikhs left their villages in Pakistan and came to India. Only two states were partitioned; Bengal and Panjab. Bengal had very minimal bloodshed however that was not the case in Panjab. Sikhs lost a lot - read on Rawalpindi massacre in March 1947. Once Sikhs came to india, one of the promises of Nehru was Panjabi state for Sikhs. However the Centre leadership at time was scared of the bloodbath that happened and the fact that Indian army had a lot of Sikhs. So, Government of India did not keep his promises to Sikhs. It’s all part of unfinished partition business. You can also read about Anandpur Sahib resolution that listed Sikh demands. Khalistan is no where to be found.
@@sohis so now u got punjab...all cm were sikhs....most indians think punjabi & sikh are synonyms. U sikhs almost got monopoly over punjab ... Green revolution , milk revolution was started in punjab ( haryana too) by centrsl govt U also got industries like cycle manufacturing, locomotive manufacturing etc. Punjab is one of the highest income states. Your farmers get MSP . Most other state farmers like bihar Jharkhand , bengal , odisha dont get these benifits what more are ur demands?
@@sohis Nope, Not correct 100%. True that Some Sikh leaders wanted a separate state after seeing a strong demand from Muslimbs but that was very late in 1946-47 unlike Muslims who wanted it since 1920s officially but it was not possible, because 1) British only decided to split country in two. Splitting into multiple countries was rejected eariler 2) There were no strong central level Sikh leadres like Jinnah except Tara Singh to push for separate country. Tara Singh even was against Lahore resolution. Sikhs did not have majority in most districts anywhere in West punjab, even in Lahore and most sikhs did not really care up until Feb/March 1947. Even most muslims in Punjab towns/villages did not want/care about separate country. Also Sikhs did not have enough clout with the British. Whoever were friends with British did not push it enough. I dont like Nehru but dont blame Nehru for everything. This was gross failure from sikh leaders. They could not even get Nankana sahib inside indian LOC forget lahore/Gujranawala. Listen to Prof Ishitiaq Ahmed's podcasts. 3) Sikhs never wanted to go to Pakistan. It was very clear in the riots in 1947. Sikhs did not get together with muslims much compared to Hindus where they inter married and visited temples etc.
@@Jahapanah-e-hindustan1. You talk about Green revolution, read the disaster effects of Green revolution that Punjab is still reeling from it today. Declining ground water, growth of commercial farming, introducing plant species not native to the land, declining land size, farmer suicides, climate change, drugs.....you still want more ? 2. You talk of Green Revolution as favour bestowed upon Punjab, it was not. Indian Government specifically chose Punjab because of the good canal network, topography and thus making the investment ripe for itself in Punjab. 3. You talk about Industries, i don't know what world you live in....but post SCL, PUNCOM no major manufacturing initiative has been started in Punjab by the Center Govt for the last 30 years. 4. Punjab being a highly sensitive border state is at risk most times . Major businesses avoid investing as opposed to mainland Indian states. So yes, Punjab needs special treatment. 5. As for justice, just tell me for 3000+ sikhs killed in the anti Sikh riots, how many culprits have been sent to the gallows ? None.......Even convictions that resulted in life sentences happened 25 years later .....so stop bulls*ting about justice.
Yes, he is innocent. What did he do? Did he kill somebody? No. Talking about separatism is not an offence. You are just radicalized by Indian nationalism
Bhindrawale sant ji ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
ANI must get Ramneek SIngh Mann on the podcast to bust what Grewal uttered and claimed in your podcast. Grewal supports Amritpal despite 1. how the rebel showed up in Bharat and within 6 months he grew into an influential mess. Grewal ignores that AP was created - training in Georgia, plastic surgery etc. 2. Drugs, women and weapons ..so much was found but he is not bad 3. Amritpal was on run. If innocent, why did he hide 4. A petty chap causes uprisings, protests and damage to Hindus and hindu properties in Canada, US, UK and AU. Clearlry, indicates anti-Bharat forces are involved in nurturing and supporting criminals like Amritpal. Grewal's conversation reveals the mindset of religious leaders in Punjab.
The fake hindu account keep barking caste jatt let me tell you khalistan movement founder jagjeet singh chauhan Sikh rajput Babar Khalsa founder talwinder Singh parmar Sikh rajput whole khalistan movement lead by sikh Rajput jatt just fighted for us and we are proud Sikh rajput will face anything to defend sikhi
Sikh gurus nay jo kiye wo koi nahi karsaktay.lakin aaj ke is jaisay leader badnam kartay sikhism ko.84 buhat bura hua lekin usse pehlay punjab main hindu maray gay unka kasoorbar jeh kis ko maanta
Very sad to listen to the Sardar Saab . Sikhs are very respected in our country . Some of the arguments put forward by him were not logical . Harbhajan Singh , Yuvraj Singh & Navjot Singh Sidhu are the most admired cricketers in our country . Modi Saab has huge regard and respect for Sikhs . I am a very proud Indian Sikh
Sikhism separated from Hindus way back during guru's time .10th sikh guru gloated about breaking idols in Zafarnama verse 95, had amicable relations with Bahadur Shah, went to Nanded inorder to support Bahadur Shah in battle of succession.Father of 10th sikh guru fought Hindu Ahoms
The fake hindu account keep barking caste jatt let me tell you khalistan movement founder jagjeet singh chauhan Sikh rajput Babar Khalsa founder talwinder Singh parmar Sikh rajput whole khalistan movement lead by sikh Rajput jatt just fighted for us and we are proud Sikh rajput will face anything to defend sikhi
GS Grewal saahab says that central government is against the sikhs. And minorities are being tortured. He also mentions very smartly that if govt. is against them due to their differences with AAP, then they can collude with foreign power to fight central government. 1) Grewal saahab I remember Modiji wearing Punjabi TURBAN at various occasions but in my life never have I ever seen him wearing muslims Cap. 2)Unlike Congress which used Punjabi community in face of Gyani Jail Singh and Several congress thinktanks(self proclaimed ) viz. Sanjay Gandhi, KamalNath etc in the year 1980 - 1984 to create hype of terrorist Bhindrewala and win Punjab and General election in 1985. Modiji and current Central Government would never ever do such things to create the wedge between Hindus and True Sikh community. At several occasions in the video I feel SGPC Grewal saahab is funded by foreign agencies to be the face of Khalistan agitation. And to create instability in Indian mainland. I think he should read book 'Khalistan Conspiracy' by Ex RAW officer. And @ANI and @Smita Ma'am, please ask a direct question to him that Does SGPC or any of it's member wants a separate state for Sikh community. There we will have clear picture of what they think. He also mentioned that Religion and Politics should go hand in hand and political thoughts should be within Religion. My question, Should our country interest be not above all? Be it religion or political parties, Shall we not put Nation above everything?
She is purely ignoring all geniue demands of sikhs , still want him to say that what all points he is asking are wrong . This is sad reality of Indian mindsets . All his points are true and are needed to be answered.
Very probing but respectful 😊questioning by Smitaji. Sardarji presented the history of the Sikh case quite forcefully. As a Non-Resident Punjabi Hindu I feel for my Sikh brethren.🙏🏼
Ok, Guru Nanak Dev ji didn't wear janeu, so many Hindus also didn't wear janeu, just like most of the sikhs wear turban and some don't. It doesn't make any difference what one wears as long as one behaves civilized. Eekonkar was derived from OM, and OM means also that God is one. But there can be many teachers who guide us towards one direction OM or EkOnkar. Just as they say: too many ways lead to Rome, but the Rome is one. If Bhindrawala was so innocent, then why Bhindrawala challenged the Saint of Radha Soami Satsang Beas? He sent 3 insulting letters to the Satguru Charan Singh ji Maharaj by writing Him that: '"Radha Soami Satsang Beas must hand over everything to Bhindreawala, including their disciples to Bhindrawala because he's the only true Saint." How contradictory! Soon after that, in a few days, how Bhindrawala died his own nasty death that too by the army. True saints are never killed by an Army. Such things happen when we trespass the limits. Besides khalistanis are also believe on Bhindrawala who even don't work just eat plundering around especially occupying illegal agricultural land of others and after selling it once even twice to the illegal parties, they run and hide in foreign countries such as Canada etc. This wasn't the teaching of 10 Gurus, was it? I hate Bhindrawala. He misled Sikhs. Punjab belongs to those Hindus, too, who were born before Guru Nanak. Hindus need extra safety and security in Punjab.
This Sardar is speaking like a hypocrite. Saying that Guru Nanak did not wear Janeu whereas the university professors of Panjab University Patiala say in their books that Nanak wore janeu. He is saying that Bhindrawale was not a terrorist, whereas there are proofs on media channels today that he headed a gang of terrorists who shat and raped women inside the holy sanctum sanctorum of Golden Temple. This Sardar is delusional, paid to spread lies.
Jo v ho jaye kuch v glt ho toh pakistan ja sikho ne kiya india sirr pakistan se h mukabla kr skta hai india berujgari se ld raha hai godi midia or modi bhagato ko pakistan ki pdi hai aise vaise
37 min. that's when things start taking a twist. Just a Bhindranwale supporter, I'm sorry. This gentlemen started really well ,after 37 mins it's all downhill. Typical brushing the problems under the carpet approach. Sikkhi is undoubtedly one of the greatest blessings of Hindustan, but he is definitely not the right spokesperson for this beautiful community.
As a Hindu brother of all Sikhs, I've no hesitation in acknowledging Sikhs contribution and patriotism for the country. I'm concerned that a wedge is being created between communities in India from foreign soil. I hope we in India don't fall prey to that. Sikhs are a respected community in India and will remain so.
Chat li sikho ki? Hindus are the only one who keep on licking asses,sikhs get the most benifit on caste system and he denied that sikhs have caste system and insulted hindus,you people are only lickers,amritpal kept on insulting hindus and he supports him,
@@gsjutley no one gives a damn bro,don't count him represtative of Hindus, bhindi bastered threatened to kill all the hindus though he was dreaming,he said a sikh can kill 35hindus,we will kill 5000 hindus in one hour bla bla,Indira just fucked that bastered with his followers, 90percent sikhs count that bastered as a hero,tells the reality,their will always remain a wedge.
@@mindandmettlerss is creating fake Sikhs who are changing Sikh history in books there’s many books.and we are not Hindu that’s rss don’t want to agree and you know now time rss is ruling party.
I seen those video where general Singh Bindra wala abusing other other religions, and ask sikh to kill 4 Hindus... And this video was not tempered.... So what you're saying sir....
There are many statements of Bhindrawale on record, against Hindus. His followers were and are worse than him. Lot of seculars hate modi more than Bhindrawale when modi hasn't even be 1% of Bhindrawale.
Something is wrong ! Either he is not aware of the reality or he has been misinformed/manipulated by someone… It’s also possible that he is truly innocent & speaking from religious angle…
@@harjeetful Yes! Of course Government needs to listen about the problems in Punjab but aggression is not the way…Kind of Drugs flowing, Influence of Pak ISI, Getting driven by & manipulated by external sources, is not the way..!
@@anilyaduvanshia but problem is govt is not listening for last 75 years. When will that time come. In the end people are compelled to take things in their hands
First of all bro you are not from Punjab and you are the misinformed one by believing the fabricated lies of Indian state I'm from Punjab and our elders tell us a very different story of that era in Punjab about what happened to them during that time their real life stories Go to majha region of Punjab and go to villages and listen to stories of victim families with proper evidences During that time more than 100,000 Sikhs were killed in fake encounters and Sikh women got raped in police stations by police search the name of jaswant Singh khalra and learn about his story you will stop calling kps gill a supercop jaswant Singh khalra was a human rights activist he found more than 25000 missing people were killed by Indian govt all of them were Sikhs majority of them were of age between 14-35 they kidnapped young Sikh girls raped them and killed them killed innocent Sikhs who had nothing to do with anything upto this day still people are missing police took them they still haven't been found Try to see things from every perspective you will come closer to the truth
Thank you ANI for bringing the true face of SGPC, Akali Dal forward. He is openly calling Bhindranwale a sant and a martyr. I think there is need for an honest conversation. Even if Bindranwale was a creation of Congress politics. There present generation should be informed. Edit - If the blunder lies with Congress. Then Congress mukt Bharat is the solution. Present day sikhs should not be against India then. Only against congress and gandhi nehru family.
@@Baljeetsingh-mh2dp ha sharafat ka putla tha. Tumhara sabse azeem gurdwara ko jang ka qila bna diya tha. Agar defensive fortification karna tha to kahi aur jaake achi si shelter bna lete. Golden temple ko apna jang ka maidan kyon bnaya?
Deeply disappointed in you Samita ji that you could not pin this bigot down. Bhindrawala called for killings of Hindus from public forum countless times and this bigot claims that Bhindrawala wasn't against any other religion. Could not even get through his drivel.
Several Hindus were taken out of buses in Punjab and shot.hindu target killing happened in punjab.this uncle ji saying there was no terrisiom in punjab .several Hindus families have to migrate to other states . uncle come and talk to me .I can tell each and every killing happened in punjab
This podcast was radically motivated and very disturbing. Person coming on podcast and telling that he supported terrorist Bhindarwalee in 1980s. I was planning my trip to Punjab to visit Golden temple but I am now really scared to go there. If terrorist supporter is serving as a secretary of Golden temple committee, don't know what may happen.
@@harshdeepsingh8211 bhindrawala literally turned harminder sahib into his militia garrison. He used the holy temple for his political & military agendas..sikhs should oppose it.
Sikhism and Snatan Religion has one basis difference. Sikhs believe in one god but in Snatan Religion multiple gods are believed to co exist. We have to be respectful to one another. It doesn't matter if Guru Nanak was born as Hindu or not. Main thing to focus on is his message ੧ਓ God is one
@@direstknight6697 ok but then why do we have separate temples for Brahma ji , Vishnu Ji and Shiv Ji and other gods. Why not just one idol in all. As far as leaf is concerned, Sikhism is the root , rest are leaves
Leaders like this has only one agenda, spread hatred and get political benefits from that. You guys have already ruined Punjab, I don't know what else you want.
Why did Sikhs kill Hindus pulling them from busses.They were innocent citizens Also why did Bhrandewale accurate weapons in Akal Thakt. Two v. Imp. Qs.
Prove that Sikh killed them. You killed your own people to defame Sikhs . Same old technique Hindus are still using same old technique. Example pulwama attack. Killed your soldiers to win elections.
There is nothing wrong in keeping weapons at Akal Takht. You say this because you don't know a damn thing about Sikhi. Even the 6th Sikh Guru kept an Army at Akal Takht. Sikhs don't see weapons the way Hindus do.
Why did Indian army kill a million Hindus in the golden temple. And why was their genocide of 2 million Hindus in India after Indra ghandi was killed. What about Hindu Brahmins in Kashmir
Wow, the way he twist words and present. No doubts that a special quality and no wonder why the Sikhs the frontline of India (in every aspect) is being degrading (in sense of not liking their country anymore) 😔😭
How do you feel when Rabid Hindus call for Sikh genocide and a repeat of 1984 every other day. Just imagine, 6 month old Sikh babies burnt alive by coward Hindu mobs in their Rabid hatred for Sikhs in 84.Mass rapes, extrajudicial killings, burning alive in the streets of Delhi, Kanpur, Indore, Jamshedpur, Bhopal. The list goes on. Just go to the widow colonies in Delhi and tell them how proud you are. Just tell the mothers of Punjab who are still waiting for their sons to return one day, that you are proud of treating Sikhs as the Children of a lesser God. The worst is that Hindus are proud of these atrocities they have committed on Sikhs, just a minuscule minority.
Guru Nanak ne to us daur mai hi Freedom Of Religion ki baat krdi thi jab angrezo ne is theory k bre mai socha b nh hga......Aur Baba Guru Nanak ji to highly Intellectual bhi the 28 languages aati thi unko
I'm Sikh but I don't agree with him he's pro akali dal and pro amritpal that's why people get confuse to know that what's really going on ?? They play with the people,s emotions with name of sgpc and religion!!
Its seems like he is also supporting khalistani elements...i think centeral agencies have to take strict action against these kind of elements who have soft corners towards khalistan agenda including this guy also who is sitting in Amritsar gurdwara on the name security provider and so called SGPC
As regards 1984, SGPC Head must clearly answer how, from where, and for what purpose were so many weapons collected inside the Golden temple. In my view, bringing arms inside the temple amounts to its desecration. As regads SGPC, it is a "Prabandhak Committee" for Gurudwaras (Managing Committee) for Gurudwaras and that is the role. They very name says so. It does not have the mandate of representing the Sikh Community as a whole for which elections take place.
ਅਸ ਕ੍ਰਿਪਾਨ ਖੰਡੋ ਖੜਗ ਤੁਪਕ ਤਬਰ ਅਰੁ ਤੀਰ ॥ ਸੈਫ ਸਰੋਹੀ ਸੈਹਥੀ ਯਹੈ ਹਮਾਰੈ ਪੀਰ ॥੩॥ "As kirpan khando kharag tupak tabar aru tir Saif sarohi saihthi, yahai hamarai pir" गुरु साहब ने शस्त्रों को गुरु के सम्मान स्थान दिया गया है sikhism में ! तख़्त श्री हज़ूर साहब जा के देखो सबसे ऊपर शस्त्र सुशोभित हैं गुरुद्वारा साहब में ! सभी तख़्तों पे शस्त्रों को विशेष सम्मान दिया गया है ! गुरु साहब ने यहाँ तक कहा है के शस्त्रों के बिना सिख एक भेड़ सम्मान है, जिसे कान से पकड़कर कोई भी कहीं भी ले जा सकता है और ऐसे सिख को कभी दर्शन नहीं देंगे “ ਬਿਨਾ ਸਸਤ੍ਰ ਕੇਸੰ ਨਰੰ ਭੇਡ ਜਾਨੋ | ਗਹੇ ਕਾਨ ਤਾਕੋ ਕਿਤੈ ਲੈ ਸਿਧਾਨੋ | “ “Bina Shashtar Keshang Nar Bhed Jano, Geh Kaan Tako Kite Lai Sidhano “
He did not understand Ashardeep issue even after explaining. When someone want to play victim, that person will find a way. If not Ashdeep then Bilkis Bano
Sikhi zindabad 😎🚩🙏🏼 salute to 1984 sikh dharmi warriors and martyrs who fought against the invading napak indian terrorist colonialist army 🙏🏼 project sikh south asia zindabad 🚩
Abdul fasaad original name se comment kr.. Tuje pta bi he 1984 me indian army ke majority of Top army generals operation blue Star ke khilaaf the aur aaj bi usey galat maante he bas fark itna he ki indian democracy me civilians supremacy ke chlte indian army ko indian Government ke orders ko hr haal me follow karna hi hota he ye koi pakistan army nhi jo civilian Govt ko bi overrule & overpower krde.. 1984 operation blue Star and anti sikh riots indira Gandhi & congress party ki creation thi apne political intrest ko pursue krne ke liye Aur jisme bhindrewala ko khadda bi indira gandhi Aur congress party ne kia tha Aur khatam bi usi ne kia Aur indira gandhi ne uski kimat bi chukaai pr afsoos ki sikho ne congress party ko vo punishment nhi di jo vo deserve krti he
He is not the right representative of SGPC, He is not able to put his point of view. SGPC must sent qualified and good orator on such important platforms. These are the the important platforms to endorse your points otherwise useless to speek on social media .
He said absolutely right Whenever sikhs come front to talk about their contribution towards the country or talk about genocide faced in 1980s some label us Khalistani
Yup thats absolutely right. Khalistan demanders are khalistanis and not real sikhs. And because of these khalistanis, all other sikhs face these ongoing BS. Very good that bhindi waala terrorist was killed. Image of sikhs and their history will be wiped out if this khalistan shit continues.
Sir aape bhut galat khe rhe hai.Sir hum nhi mante Shaheed, please Don't compare Bhagat singh with So called aapke shaheed bindrawala.
❤❤❤❤❤ very true didi
That's your ideology as an Indian. Sikhs consider him shaheed and he was biggest martyar of 20 century for Sikhs.
He is from SGPC... So he has to talk like that
Don't compare bhagat Singh with bhindrawale.....both were fighting the tyrannies of their time...stop ur bullshit propaganda of INDIAN mythology.... cope with it, we got gurudwara dedicated to sant ji.....
What do u know of being shaheed?
He is sympathiser of Khalistani he is not condemning bhinderawale bhinderawale is terrorists installed by indra gandhi and sanjay gandhi sikhs are our brothers
Did Indira Gandhi installed bhinderawale knowing that we would ultimately act like that ?you can't blame Indira Gandhi for what bhindrawale became
@@Cherry-sg4zgwas her creation
@@Cherry-sg4zg Everyone had come to know about Bhindranwale's relation with the Pakistani army. Bhindranwale was waiting for the attack of Pakistani army so that he could attack India from inside and separate Punjab from India. After Bhindranwale's death, most of Bhindranwale's associates fled to Pakistan. Even after that if you support Bhindranwale then clearly you are traitor and salt namakhram of this country. Bhindranwale and the people supporting him were terrorists.
@@bimladhar6575 so did she purposely did that all. It wasn't her fault that he turned like that .
@@Cherry-sg4zg Indira Gandhi ordered open fire on hindu saints killing 300 of them
Waheguru ji🙏
Main Himachal se hu or pichle 2 saal se punjab me rh rha hu maine ak baat notice ki hai punjab me Bhindranwale ko lekar adhiktar log ak jaise vichar rakhte hai ki vo sant tha or punjab ki bhalayi chahta tha
Is par main apni raye nhi rakhunga
Lekin main ak baat khna chahta hu ki yeh khna punjab me caste system nhi hai sab braber hai Sikhism me sab braber jarur hai lekin ground reality kuch or hi hai
Jis shop se hum rashan lete hai unhone mere dekhte hi dekhte christianity ko apna liya
Ak din unki shop me sada yeshu jag vich aaya hai repeated baj rha tha
Maine socha aise tv pr chal rha hoga lekin main bimar tha kuch time ke liye to aunty aaye khte
Put tu yeshu de darbar hokar aa menu bhi bda dard siga nale ghar ch bhi kuch thik ni si asi yeshu de darbar ch matha takiya ardas lgayi hun sab thik hai mujhe bahut jayda herani huyi kya bol rhe hai
Tab maine ak baba ji se pucha o kehnde athe a sab chal riha bde chira or unhone btaya ki vo sikh jo khud ko dalito ki tarah mante hai christian bn rhe hai
Mujhe christian se koi dushmani nhi hai lekin dharmantaran bhi shi nhi manushy ko hamesha khud me sudhar ki jarurat hoti hai darm parivartan ki nhi🙏
mai punjab Hoshiarpur se hun.bhai boht bura haal hai punjab ka. sabhi Christianity me convert ho rhe hai😢
Majority of the Sikh comments here are heartwarming!! As a Hindu from Jammu that grew up hearing stories of the Sikh Gurus sacrifice to save humanity and that saw the gurudwara as another legitimate place of worship, these current Khalistani developments are so bewildering. But then comments from some of the Sikh brothers and sisters are so
reassuring. Waheguru ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguri ji ki Fateh🙏🏼🙏🏼
Hindutava Hindu rashtra is ok, bhaiya?
No. I’m not a fan of Hindu rashtra. When everything is peaceful, every religion must co-exist. But if Dharma( not religion) is threatened, then one must fight. Not violently, but with every other measure available. And if life is threatened, then violence for self defense is absolutely ok. Don’t you agree?
@@ASingh1699k is hindu rashtra theory breaking country ?
@@ASingh1699k before sanatan dharm had different branches it was 100% hindu country....u need more understanding of hindu rashtra....
@li0noid.108 Sikhs and panhab were never hindu country respect that if you want me to respect hindu. Respect is a two-way thing .
Thanks for this interview ANI. Despite so much of clarification by Grewal ji, I strongly believe that SGPC need to minimise the gap between Hindus and Sikhs. All Ten Sikh Gurus were Hindu and Sikhs are out of Hindus. We are one and shall remain one. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Probably the most beautiful and valuable comment on this interview.Yet, the no of likes you have got unravels the trench between both the communities which a few of fanatics has successfully managed to peddle.
And yes, it's miserable that SGPC has done nothing in recent past to bridge the gap, moreover they continue to pedlle hatred and animosity.
"Na hum Hindu Na hum musalman" If you can't acknowledge the words of Guru himself then you aren't a Sikh
This is beautiful! And there is comment below that says you are not a real Sikh, I wouldn’t dignify that with a rebuttal. But Sir, it’s elevated thoughts like these that form nations and hold us all together. I hope the Sikhs get justice from the Indian state and we all remain one!! 🙏🏼
@@tapsimavinkeredayanand8454 brother a religion is about LISTENING to its teachings and not rebelling just for someone elses approval
Your mindset is so wrong.Sir aapne Education Ki baat Ki, multinational companies Ki baat Ki Punjab mein, aap bhi blame game khel rhe hai.
Very well said , i want to have a conversation with u ? How can I contact u?
When he talked about letting the Sikhs in jail out she didn’t even try to answer that and just skipped over it while telling him to answer everything she asked
Coz she is RSS di kutti😁
The fake hindu account keep barking caste jatt let me tell you khalistan movement founder jagjeet singh chauhan Sikh rajput Babar Khalsa founder talwinder Singh parmar Sikh rajput whole khalistan movement lead by sikh Rajput jatt just fighted for us and we are proud Sikh rajput will face anything to defend sikhi
You are totally right she should've answer that ... That was the real truth that's whyy she couldn't resist it 🙂🙌🏻
Exactly
Why did he didn't explain what was the meaning of staying with bhindrawala when he was fighting with army? Did he explain why he was hiding inside golden temple? Why did sgpc of that time complained to government about his illegal refuge inside the temple?
Bhhindrawala tan terrorist c, bhai jo amritsar ch hindu maare c 1984 de baad ode baare kuj ni boleya, kyon ni beyea, supp sungh geya jinna ne hindu maare,
ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ 🌹🙏❤️.
12:23
He is misleading everyone. If there is no caste system in Sikhi then who are the Majhabi sikhs? Why r there seperate gurudwaras for them????
not according to gurbani but yes there were historical reasons because of which caste came but guru sahib eleminted caste
proof
10th Guru eliminated caste system by giving Singh and Kaur as Surnames but many people still uses caste surnames and still takes pride for there ancestors clans or any other reason also. It is there wish to use anything with common surnames, but Gurus eliminated varna system in Sikhi. And conditions of deprived Sikhs can only be solved through education (both religious and modern) in long run, that government and SGPC should provide. And existence of separate gurudwaras based on caste in villages is very sad thing in Sikhi and that can only be solved through collective effort in Sikh community.
Very good interview and throws light on Sikh perspective on various issues of Punjab.
Hopefully smita do a podcast with nirmala sitharaman as well. Let's hear what's her take on current economic situation
ਸੰਤ ਜਰਨੈਲ ਸਿੰਘ ਜੀ ਖਾਲਸਾ❤❤❤❤
Why is it that the more i hear SIKHS talking the more i am convinced that SIKH Separatism is coming. Even if we for a moment keep aside the KHALASTAN tag, the nature of Separatism is evident in PUNJAB.
To ask a few questions
1) Is it true that cast discrimination cases have been on the rise in SIKH punjab, even to the extent that SIKHS are now converting to Christianity.
2) if you say there is no cast discrimination and the reason for establishing SIKHs was to remove cast discrimination, then why are there separate gurudwara for Jaat and not jaat sikh.
3) if you further deny existence of cast in Sikhsim, then what's the basis of having SIKHS and SIKH LIGHT INFANTRY nits in IA.
4) As per you if all the Dharam are same, as you said, then why was KHALSA ever established, afterall we would have been praying to the same god, only the mode of practice and name of the god would have changed and if you say you were a contemporary of all religions, why was there any opposition from Jahagir, after all weren't they could have seen you a SUFI sect let nurture.
another observation why are Only SIKHS from PUNJAB AND CHANDIGHAR region seen abusing HINDUS GODS, why was Maa KALI temple attacked in Punjab by NIHANG SIKHS and why do we we not see such acts from SIKHS from UP, BIHAR, MAHRASTRA, MP or any other state for that matter.
Nice try to divide and insult them. Idiotic
@@movieworld7769 argument of convience (jo acha laga woh hum laye the jo bura laga woh Hindus ke wajah se aaya) it's been 500 years still blame the Hindus.
As far as respecting all religions are concerned why Raja Ranjith Singh ji had Lord Hanuman and Maa goddess photo on his sword, why did he say he will kill the butchers of cow. Afterall if he did respect all religion there was no need for Sikhism or Khalsa army in the first place. You could have lived in synchronicity by following the religion of the Invader, after all it did deserve your respect, what respectful is also acceptable. isn't it?
@@movieworld7769 why hasn't SJPC done or said anything against cast discrimination in Sikhism?
Does SJPC or Khalsa panth actively support and encourage intercast Sikh marriage (seeing as cast was not practiced by Gurus, but was later adopted by the society) are Gurudwara participating in eradicating cast from Sikhism.
Punjab is 58 sikh, seeing how you are a majority you should have influenced the Hindus in Punjab, why is it the other way around, is Sikhism soo weak?
If castism is Hindu why are more Sikhs converting to Christianity (by mere percentage) in Punjab that in any other state. Clearly there is something wrong in Punjab.
As far as your own mindset of Bhagwa is concerned, I Don't give 2 piece about it, it's your filth you deal with it.
@@movieworld7769 patli gali pakad ke nikal 😏, sorry tu toh already dum daba kar bhaga hai. Bhagoda
Same I’ve also got a question why do did only Hindus in regions like Delhi and northern parts of India demolish gurudwas and kill innocent Sikhs unlike Hindus in mumbai and other places
Khalisan jindabad Never forget 1955 Never forget 1984 Never forget delhi sikh genoside never forget what india done with panjab
We never forget what khalistani did with India
Bindrawala gone , amritpal gone, next your supporters no will come
@@abhaybgh ooo what i will kill some people using your name so is it your fault or my and second part Amritpal singh what crime he conducted what his weapons was licensed by panjab government his AKF what about RSS. Ramdasia loin force bajrangbal. So what crime he conducted if he has some small crime' assume is NSA is the right decision
@@abhaybghIndira Gandhi say hi from narak 💀
Second Partition of India 2047
Mother India is a myth
Also never forget who kill ranjeet sing 😂😂
Sikh gurudwara act 1925 which first time defined Sikh identity and led to creation of SGPC was passed by British and Grewal sahab is suggesting SGPC was created as a resistance to British influence on Gurudwaras. I suggest a counter by Puneet Sahani if ANI and Smita Prakash can invite him for the podcast.
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh
Puneet Sahani is a complete liar. He knows nothing about Sikhism. Actually he is not a sikh. I say that because Sikhism is not only about wearing turbans
The British had appointed the Mahants after kicking out the Budha dal from the gurduwaras. There was then the Akali movement which sought to take the mahants out of the gurudwaras and establish the SGPC. After many Sikhs died marching against the mahants the British govt finally gave into the Akali movement's demands and established the 1925 act that you are talking about. There is documented proof of this, and many Sikhs even died for this specific movement. You can read up on the Gurdwara Sudhaar movement (Gurdwara reform movement) if you want to. And stop bringing that Puneet mf into the conversation, he is not a Sikh.
@@jairajbirsingh7948exactly
@@beyondnetero5080truly said
This Sardar is speaking like a hypocrite. Saying that Guru Nanak did not wear Janeu whereas the university professors of Panjab University Patiala say in their books that Nanak wore janeu. He is saying that Bhindrawale was not a terrorist, whereas there are proofs on media channels today that he headed a gang of terrorists who shat and raped women inside the holy sanctum sanctorum of Golden Temple. This Sardar is delusional, paid to spread lies.
Isne Quran nahi padha, Islam ke baare mein kuch nahi janta...generic baatein bol rha hai
This Sardar is speaking like a hypocrite. Saying that Guru Nanak did not wear Janeu whereas the university professors of Panjab University Patiala say in their books that Nanak wore janeu. He is saying that Bhindrawale was not a terrorist, whereas there are proofs on media channels today that he headed a gang of terrorists who shat and raped women inside the holy sanctum sanctorum of Golden Temple. This Sardar is delusional, paid to spread lies.
A lot of contradictions and looks like he is also brainwashed, I am sorry people might disgree with me. Hats off to you Smita Ji to keep your calm during the recording.
He didn't fit your narrative. What you wanted Smita to do, abuse him, he was willing to talk to her, hats off to him.
true , he is looking like Brainwashed
Amritpal and his followers barged into the Police Station and demanded that one of them, in the police custody be freed. Or else? Is that not going against the State? And he had lately been talking openly about rebellion too.
Fake fire what about that ?
Smita - What you said in the end... Learning more about sikh faith and SGPC was achieved in the first 10 minutes of the episode... the rest of it was a waste of time. In comparison to your other podcasts ( of which i have heard almost all of them ) this was intellectually shallow and the views expressed here were quite fantastic .... Looks like you made this only to tick a box or meet a deadline to share a podcast....
This Sardar is speaking like a hypocrite. Saying that Guru Nanak did not wear Janeu whereas the university professors of Panjab University Patiala say in their books that Nanak wore janeu. He is saying that Bhindrawale was not a terrorist, whereas there are proofs on media channels today that he headed a gang of terrorists who shat and raped women inside the holy sanctum sanctorum of Golden Temple. This Sardar is delusional, paid to spread lies.
Respected Smita ji, you should have asked him some difficult questions
How British convoluted tried to omit the linkage between Hindu ( Santana Dharma) & tried to establish Sikhism as a separate religion altogether
Nefarious Designs of Max Arthur Macauliffe works, the British Civil Servant in British imperial rule in punjab after 1857 revolt as a strategy & cultivated many people like assets like Kahn sigh Nabha etc who did selective translations of Sikh literature & traditions following Macauliffe's work, these people of same ideology tried to justify the massacre of Jhalianwala wala Bagh & today work for separatist ideology of Khaalistan
Mr. Grewal selectively put all the blame of teaming up with the British to those so called selfish "mahants"
British played from both sides as they always did, choosing the characters with weak moral milieu from both sides as their assets to carry on their agenda
- Divide & Rule
There's a reason why khaalistani operatives given safe heavens in west, it's their project which they use till today as a leverage when dealing with India
Pakistan was also British project
Britishers loved the likes of MK Gandhi & Nehru while they hated the likes of Netaji Subhash Bose, Savarkar, Sardar Bhagat Singh tried everything to kill them physically & politically.
proof is in the pudding
Sikhs are not hindu or Muslim. Why right of Sikhs Khalistan is not ok, but hindutava rashtra is ok?
KHALISTAN ZINDABAAD ❤❤
Khalistan meri lunn te guru granth mere lunn te
As a sikh from punjab all i want to say is Jai Hind🇮🇳🇮🇳.
Love for Hindus🕉️
Jai Shree Ram🕉️🕉️🚩🚩
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh🚩🚩
For Hindus also sikh guru also our ,guru like sankarachrya. We are brother by blood. The only thing if anyone think to devide this country then no matter what is the religion of that person muslim,sikh,bodh or even if he is hindu then also he is our enemy.this thing is very clear in our mind.vo hindu ho or khud ka beta ho to dusman hi h.
Smita Prakash has not discussed The Brij Bhushan case?
Bhai 🫂🫂
Love for all if ur a true Indian
And we say waheguru ji ka Khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
If you look at Guru Nanaks very early pics he used to wear jenuw and tilak. I want these sikhs stop telling lies and for once tell the truth. They behave they dropped from the sky on some special mission by God. Did sikhs come out of muslims, hindus or from the sky.
Was camera invented in that time?
@@Babumoshai.. Khalistan sympathiser.
Didn't you evolved from a Bandar? So Should I still address you as one?
That's such a lame argument Hindus have got. They can't just digest the fact that there exists a fraction of people that followed Guru Nanak and his successive descendants which criticize a lot of their practices, and formed their own religion and see themselves as a distinct race.
I as a Sikh see nothing in me that is common to a Hindu. Infact, I find Muslims that speak Panjabi more closer to my culture than Hindus of UP or Bihar.
@@satwinderbarath5783 dude wtf ?? It's just a simple question how does that makes me khalistani sympathizer?
Grewal जी मैडम को बताओ के संत जरनैल सिंह जी खालसा bhindrawala जी को सिखों के मनो से कोई भी नहीं निकाल सकते।
Tyaar rho fer 72 hooran kol jaan nu 🤣
Women seats were reserved even in 1924. GURU NANAK JI MESSAGE was "ਸੋ ਕਿਉ ਮੰਦਾ ਆਖੀਏ ਜਿਸਨੇ ਜੰਮੇ ਰਾਜਾਣ " why women should be considered inferior because they have been given birth to Kings.
He said sikhism doesn't have caste then how 51% of sikhs are taking reservation of sc/st and obc.
Dalit Sikhs continues convert in Christianity
Not to mention, most of these khalistani Sikhs come from upper Jatt caste, they control everything.
He himself has grewal surname so he is lying when he says there is no caste in Sikhism
1. Wrong number.
2. Due to political system of India.
Brahminwaadi virus
This guys says that Punjab feeds the country as if they do it for free.. Punjab k kisan has been the biggest benefactor of the agricultural subsidicies as well as MSP. All the subsidy, tax break, MSP purchases are done by the state / center govt, using the taxpayers money.. So lets not pretend or act like we have been fed for free by punjab..
Panjab's resources have been looted by the Hindi heartland.
You take our waters for free without providing us any royalties.
India as a country gives 0 fucking rights to its states.
True, let the states decide where they want to procure their grain from for PDS, why should jharkhand buy rice from Punjab when it's readily available from Bihar & west Bengal.
This Sardar is speaking like a hypocrite. Saying that Guru Nanak did not wear Janeu whereas the university professors of Panjab University Patiala say in their books that Nanak wore janeu. He is saying that Bhindrawale was not a terrorist, whereas there are proofs on media channels today that he headed a gang of terrorists who shat and raped women inside the holy sanctum sanctorum of Golden Temple. This Sardar is delusional, paid to spread lies.
A very very patriotic programme i saw today. Both sides made very insightful presentation. Host was very impressive & persistant with equal wittiness show by the other side. Feel proud that i reside in a country, which has the intellect to solve our difference. A super podcast today, full marks Smita Prakash for making today's podcast. This has a far reaching benefit to our country.
Grewal saab ਖੁੱਲ k ਬੋਲੋ ਕਿਸੇ ਇਕ ਧਰਮ ਨੂੰ ਖੁਸ਼ ਕਰਨ ਵਿਚ ਜ਼ੋਰ ਲੱਗ ਰਿਹਾ aa tuhada. Gurbani ਤਾਂ katash ਕਰਦੀ aa ਸਭ karm kaad ਤੇ
Am not convinced with Grewal ji re centre working in tandem with AAP in Punjab. While he continued to point a finger at Modi ji. PM has been most supportive to Sikhs to whom I belong as per my faith. SGPC sending lawyers for every wrong of Sikhs arrested isn't palatable. Why SGPC never fought for the victims of '84 massacre?
They've fought for the victims of 1984 and are still providing them legal aid.
Veer ji Maharaj Ranjit Singh to baad j kise hukumat ne sikhaan nu naal lai k chlan di jurat kiti hai ta oh Modi sarkaar ne kitti hai ohh bnde de man ch j sikhaan waste nafrat hundi ta oh kde patka bann k guru ghr matha na tekda, par sadde wich kuch lok akal de Anne ho k baithe ne
@@ishankalia1219 why they hate modi and hindu?
@@Ghytvhu if they start thinking logically instead of emotionally they will stop hating narinder modi
@@ishankalia1219 emotionally bi modi me inka kya bigada ha? Modi to inhe khush karne ma lga rehta ha
ਆ ਬੀਬੀ ਸਰਕਾਰ ਦੀ ਕੌਲੀ ਚਟ ਹੈ ਆ ਸਿੰਘ ਜੀ ਤੋਂ ਸਾਰੇ ਭੇਦ ਲੈਣਾ ਚਾਹੁੰਦੀ ਹੈ ਕੀ ਸਾਡੀ ਕੌਮ ਦੀ ਸਿਰਮੌਰ ਸੰਸਥਾ ਕਿਦਾ ਕਾਰਜ ਕਰਦੀ ਹੈ ਤੇ ਓਦਾਂ ਤਰੀਕਾ ਕਿਦਾ ਦਾ ਹੈ
ਆ ਸਬ ਮੀਡੀਆ ਵਾਲੇ rss ਕੇ ਦੇ ਚਮਚੇ ਨੇ
ਆ ਸਾਡੀ ਹੋਂਦ ਨੂੰ ਹਿਲਾਣਾ ਤੇ ਮਿਟਾਣਾ ਚਉਂਦੇ ਨੇ ਤੇ ਆ ਸਾਡੇ ਸੰਤ ਤੇ ਸਿਪਾਹੀ ਸ਼ਹੀਦ ਸੰਤ ਜਰਨੈਲ ਸਿੰਘ ਜੀ ਦੇ ਬਾਰੇ ਸਿੱਧਾ ਕੈ ਰਹੀ ਹੈ ਕੀ ਓਨਾ ਹਥਿਆਰ ਤੇ ਬੰਦੇ ਲੈ ਕੇ ਗੁਰੂਵਾਰੇ ਸਾਹਿਬ ਚ ਕਿਦਾ ਬੈ ਗਏ ਸਾਡੇ ਸਿਰਮੌਰ ਸੰਸਥਾਵਾਂ ਨੂੰ ਏਨਾ ਦੋਗਲਿਆਂ ਨੂੰ ਇੰਟਰਵਿਊ ਨਹੀਂ ਦੇਣਾ ਚਾਹੀਦਾ ਆ ਸਾਡੇ ਧਰਮ ਚ ਦੂਜੀ ਪਾਰਟੀਆਂ ਨੂੰ ਵੀ ਸ਼ਾਮਿਲ ਕਾਰਨਾ ਤੇ ਸਾਡੇ ਗੁਰੂ ਘਰਾਂ ਚ ਮਸੰਦਾ ਨੂੰ ਭੇਜਣਾ ਚਉਂਦੀ ਹੈ ਏਦੀ ਗੱਲ ਸਾਫ ਹੈ
ਤੇ ਬੀਬੀ ਤੁਸੀਂ ਬੋਲਿਆ ਅਪਣੇ ਹਿੰਦੂ ਸੈਂਕਰਾਚਾਰੀਯਾ ਨੂੰ ਵੀ ਕੈ ਜ਼ੋ ਅਜ ਧਰਮ ਦਾ ਚੋਲਾ ਪਾਕੇ ਰਾਜਨੀਤੀ ਕਰਦੇ ਫਿਰਦੇ ਆ ਥੋਨੂੰ ਅਪਣਾ ਕਾਰਜ ਨਹੀਂ ਦਿਸਦਾ ਸਿਰਫ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਤੇ ਸਿੱਖਾਂ ਦੀ ਹੋਂਦ ਥੋਡੇ ਨਜਰਾਂ ਚ ਰੜਕਦੀ ਹੈ ਆ ਗੱਲ ਅੱਜ ਤੋਂ ਨਹੀਂ ਵੰਡ ਤੋਂ ਪੈਲੇ ਤੋਂ ਚੱਲੀ ਆ ਰਹੀ ਹੈ, ਤੁਸੀਂ ਹਿੰਦੂ ਲੂਣ ਹਰਾਮ ਤੇ ਦੋਗਲੇ ਹੋ ਏਦੇ ਚ ਕੋਈ ਸ਼ੱਕ ਨਹੀਂ
इसके अंदर पूरा जहर भरा हुआ है, साला बूढ़ा अगर इतना ही सिख की फिक्र है तो पंजाब में इतने क्रिश्चियन कैसे हो गए। 😂
Jase Kerala mai hua hai lol 😂 Hindhu Radhtra lol 😂
Jesy india ma love jihad kerala story ma hindu fasty haa rhy hai lindu 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Hum kisi ko pakad kar nhi rakhte koi jata hai to jaye hum quality mai vishwash rakhte hai quatity mai nhi
@@deepabutter6223 Quality my foot. Quantity quality ki vote se le leta hai.
@@Faltu-z3e tumari kya quality ha yeh batao moot peena aur gober khana
4:52 ਗੁਰਚਰਨ ਸਿੰਘ ਗਰੇਵਾਲ ਜੀ ਉਹਨਾਂ ਵਿੱਚ ਐਸੇ ਲੋਕ ਤੁਸੀਂ ਵੀ ਸੀ ਤੁਸੀਂ ਵੀ ਸੂਦਰ ਹੋ। ਬਾਕੀ ਤੁਸੀਂ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਦੇ ਮਾਹੋਲ ਦੀ ਗੱਲ ਕਰ ਰਹੇ ਹੋ ਜਿਹਨਾਂ ਦੇ ਘਰ ਉੱਜੜ ਗਏ ਉਹਨਾਂ ਨੂੰ ਪੁੱਛ ਕੇ ਦੇਖੋ ਕ੍ਰਿਪਾ ਕਰਕੇ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਤੇ ਮਿਹਰ ਕਰੋ।
GURCHARN SINGH GREWAL YOU ARE SUCH PEOPLE AMONG THEM. YOU ARE ALSO SUDAR. THE REST OF YOU ARE TAKING ABOUT THE ENVIRONMENT OF PUNJAN, ASK THOSE WHOSE HOUSES HAVE BEEN DESTROYED. PLEASE HAVE MERCY ON PUNJAN.
SMITA PRAKASH JI YOU ASKED VERY-GOOD QUESTIONS.
RAJINDER SINGH AUSTRIA
Why SGPC did not unveil the report perpared by the committee headed by karnail singh peer mohammad on AJNALA incident for taking GGS ?
Also they should open the account of expenditure
They should tell govt. Where they are spending money
SGPC may have role in bank rolling terrorist through back channels
Guru ki golak is occupied by lutera's in sikhi bana
@@ishankalia1219 why...SGPC need to show account to Govt ..It's our religious place what government has to do with this..SGPC should do this and that..u don't know anything and talking rubbish.. But even then just because I feel that there is no need space for bitterness so answer is that SGPC pays to top firms complete audits SGPC finances. Even if your problem isn't solved yet you can go to SGPC office and get a copy from there.. but request humbly.
Seriously man why you need to know what's in the report Akal Takht Sahib appointed the committee to find out about this issue and they had over that report to Jathedar Sahib from Shri Akal Takht Sahib. So the report is already there where it should be why it is became your concern don't you think you are interfering in without any reason ?
@@ishankalia1219 why not you should first get authority over temples which are under control of govt.
U didn't ask these two qs.
Killing innocent Hindus n weapons in Golfden temple if Bhrindwale wasn't a Atantanki.
Your Hindu ideology is atantanki
Mokaprasti? Then Why did not you also condemm and lebel as T* to Subhash chandra Bose for using shanghai gurdwara as AZAD HIND FOUJ(army) training centre?
How many hindus were killed that time i know kise ko marna koi solution nhi h but can you explain genocide of sikhs were right ?
@@LovepreetSingh-vx4hi 22,000 as per the estimates of experts on militancy in Punjab. I know you're gonna deny the sufferings of Punjabi Hindus, Jains and Christians. So it's of no use to reply to you.
What happened with Sikhs in Delhi and some other parts, was a pogrom by Congress party cadres, goons and anti-social elements. In which around 3-5,000 Sikhs died. This is one of many reasons which turned me against Congress party and Nehru-Gandhi family.
Shri Ram was not political leader ..
kings were not politicians.. he cited a very wrong example ..
He avoided the Islamic persecution of Sikhs totally ..
And as per him “ Bhindranwale was not terrorist .. “
not only he supports Bhrindanwale but he goes on to say that He was at golden Temple fighting Indian Army during op bluestar ..
that says it all .. 😊
He forgot Guru Nanak and other gurus were originally Hindus .. Guru Gobind Singh ji was Guru Gobind Rai.. Sikh religion is 99℅ similar to Hinduism.. Panj Pyaare were Hindus from different parts of Bharatvarsh.. 🙂
I haven't come across a brave Sikh who said Khalistan murdabad.
They say love Hindus
Jai Hind
But stay silent on Khalistani
Stay silent on Pakistan and Muslims
@@patriot9981 - Stay silent.. 😊
Who are you to advocate Khalistanis and Pakistan?
They are both against what I stand for ..
Mental blockage is growing day by day with false narratives..
In sgpc walo k lie bhagat singh antakwadi tha prakash singh badal k interview dekhlo
@@stalwart_dhanan Abe bevakuf vo simranjeet singh maan hai prakash singh badal ni
Fact test is must
I am a Hindu Punjabi and I have grown up completely surrounded by sikh families, almost all my life. He iss talking a lot of nice sounding words. But the basic message that hes giving is that religion should dominate over politics. That is the basic root cause of all kind of nefarious activities. Country comes first. If he wants religion to take prominence then he should probably move to pakistan.
I stopped going to the gurudwara in USA When I saw how proudly the names and photographs of all the terrorists were displayed openly and proudly everywhere. Which is a shame because growing up in India. I do not remember going to a Hindu Temple even 10% of the time we would go to the gurudwara.. My mom would give the food supplies to the gurudwara as part of "shraadh" Activities for my grandparents because she said she is 100%. Sure that the food given there will actually be used to feed all the people Regardless of their cast color or economic status. Something she said she was sure Was not going to happen in a hindu temple.
It is sad that such a wonderful religion and a wonderful, lively , brave community of people has been politicized to such an extent.. He is completely wrong. Bhindrawale was a total terrorist And propagated killing just like a terrorist. He is lying out rightly. His so called religious leader gave an interview to the thenn prominent newspaper " navbharat times" Where he clearly demanded a separate state. Worst mistake the congress party made. I hope this guy is being investigated
It’s time u hindu punjabi khatris should know that we know ur reality and backstabbing Sikhs in their cause. Ur a Hindu idol worshipping Hindu which is prohibited in sikhi. About ur mom giving food to a Gurdwara for shraad is for ur own benefit in believing this will reach grandparents. Ur hindu selfishness that is unable to think beyond themselves. It is time more sikhs are now supporting khalistan. We welcome it if it’s given peacefully or otherwise other options are always on the table perhaps it will come after next indo pak and China war.
It would, if you don’t practice what you preach. Using religion to dominate politics is wrong but keeping in mind your faith and taking decisions in any situation is not, unless religion is a facade to coverup for shoddy politics.
Real terrorists are those who deliberately suppress others, especially minorities and their issues.
@@endeavour1349 When religious bodies are involved in politics And are political policy decision makers then it is always a cover for shoddy politics
You gave very good msg every one should read ur msg
Madamji-----Plz RAW agency,,,Int. B and Sanjay Suri,,Anuradha bhargav,,Subramanium Swamy ji ko Sant Bhindrawale ji ke bare me puchiye,,,shyd Sikho par apko vishwas nahi ayega,,,ap har movement ki books paro,,,Anandpur Resolution paro to pta chalega k is resolution ko ignore krke...Sarkar ne,,,intelligence buro ko use krke apni kursi bachane k lye Police cats Sikh veshbusha me Darbar Sahib k ander bhej kr Santji ka vishwas jita or wohi police cats ander weapons leke gye,,,hamare to Darbar Sahib k ander jate purse tak check hote the,,,onhi police cats k thru Weapons ander gye or ek drama operation Bluestar ka rach k congress ne hindu vote hasil ki,,,Sarkar har movement me isi tra krti ha,,social media ek inttli,,buro ka employee, yeh sab kuch bta raha ha wohi jo mene apko bataya,,,Subramonium ji k samne Santji ne 2 hindu girls k ghar father ban kr basaye,,,Kapurthala jail me Shiv mandir banayia,,,1982 me Ramayan ki beadbi hui to wo case larkar doshi ko prison me bheja,,,ese hor kai ex ha,,,,os smey sikho k Guru Granth Sahib ji ki bhi beadbi karwai gyi,,,sikh aurto ko nanga krke ek gaon me parade ki,,,kai sikh youths ko joothe police encountero me mara gya fir bhi Santji ne hinduo ka virodh nahi kya,,,sirf Sarkar se sikho k yeh kamo ko discourage krne ki mang ki...par sarkar ne Anandpur Sahib Resolution ko ignore krke khud ugerwad peda kia or Sikho k khilaf esa jehar ugla k sikho dwara har dharam k logo ki sewa me,carona me ,,apni jaan ki baazi laga dene k baad bhi yeh zehar khatam nahi hua,,,agar nafrat karte rehenge,,to fir sikh yehi kehenge k fir hame alag kr do jese 2 brothers ki lagatar larai k baad batwara hota ha
Religion without Spirituality is like a bottle without perfume. That is what needs to be addressed. Everything will fall in its right place. Today there is no spirituality in religion, only politics and lust for power.
Absolutely right
@Gurmohan Singh Very well said! 🙏
Religion is an abrahamic concept and abrahamic cults like Christianity, Islam are full fledged political imperialist militant ideologies
there is no spirituality in organized religion
well said
ये पूरी तरह साइलेंटली भिंडरे वाला का समर्थक है और अभी अमृतपाल के पीछे खड़ा है।
Good
Smita Prakash is not a investigative journalist.. doesn't know how cross question this khalistani on this historical treachery.. she couldn't even handle his cricket BS properly.. 😂
Haha so many investigative journalists tried to throw off Amritpal, none succeeded😂 that either means that the sikh POV is very strong, or that the Hindu POV on Khalistan is untenable
@@manvirsvwhich journalists are you talking about ? khalistani Pov right now is insect for hindus of bharat to actually focus or counter on. We have bigger fish to fry.. enjoy while it lasts.. Ampritpal will take bindiwala route faster than he gets to say"soorma ke kaum.." if you want to save him, you take him away in hiding.. He was a rat on ClubHouse. Semi literate NRI used to show him his place everyday. 😂
She did question and confront Grewal 35th minute onwards. Beyond a point, I think she played safe not to provoke the ones who live on the provocation edge. This quality of aggression made sikhs the top pick even by Brits..so not that I am overall calling this man as aggressive. She takes liberty of cross questioning with liberated minds such as EAM S. Jaishankar, AIM, Sushant Sareen, Tilak Deveshar, each army veteran that came on the show and even Bollywood actors.
@@durgh_reloadeddurgh_reload5751 there is another route called Indra Gandhi route general vadya and so many more 🤣🤣
@@singh1117 please try.. I have this free "dhakka max pro" lying around for a long time.. lage hath pakistan ke dharti bhi cheer deege..😂
संत जरनैल सिंह जी ने कहा था कि जब भारती फौज हरमंदर साहिब प्र अटैक करेगी तब खालिस्तान की नीव रखी जायेगी
Khalistan meri lunn te guru granth mere lunn te
The fake hindu account keep barking caste jatt let me tell you khalistan movement founder jagjeet singh chauhan Sikh rajput Babar Khalsa founder talwinder Singh parmar Sikh rajput whole khalistan movement lead by sikh Rajput jatt just fighted for us and we are proud Sikh rajput will face anything to defend sikhi
Fer rakhi to gyi hai bhai jang Jari hai..........
kuchh gawar logo ko je nahi samj ata . jab koi kisi dharm ko apna leta haye , to us ka purane dharm se koi rishta nahi rah jata . aur dharm insan ki niji marji haye , koi bhagwan ko manta haye ya nahi je har admi ki apni marji haye . insan ko insan samjo je hi sab se acha dharm haye .
JATT upper cast
SAINI middle cast
RAMGARIA middle lower cast
CHAMAR lower cast. He is roughly describing cast system.
Brother, who is akhal takhat jathaydar. He is from sc community. Which is highest temporal seat in Sikhism.
In Sikhism no any caste smaller or higher class .....
There are many head priest in gurdwara shaib are from sc, BC community.
So as per your logic last president of India was from SC and present one is from ST so the differences in peoples beliefs in India in these artificial creations have disappeared?
Brothers I just mentioned cast system in Sikh society. But one question 🤔 did JATT Sikh marry their daughters to CHAMAR, no and why people converting to Christianity from Sikh community. Think about it.
@@jalebibai4960 how many western white marrying to black.. how many rich people marry to poor.. how many politicians child marry to middle class... There are so many examples in n Punjab. Few months back Punjabi minister jatt harjot bains tied knot to Hindu girl..
It society issue. still there are many people if their social status is same then people don't hasitate to marriage.
For example, my friend who is doctor, he marriage to BC class doctor lady... Captain amrinder Singh nephew married to Hindu family...
@@TheKhalsa008 bus kr jatta tu bahla ee changa banda lagda aa, ....changa Rabb rakha
SGPC kaha tha when amritpal attacked police station, sgpc did not condemned.
SGPC kaha rha jab london high commission mai hamare indian flag ke sath chedkhani ki gayi.
SGPC kaha tha jab Indian flag ke sath ladki ko mana kia gaya sabke samne.
SGPC kaha rha jab Khalistan ke naare lage Golden Temple me, Talware nikali jaati hai, flags toh allowed nai fir khalistan flags kaise allow kie jaate h.
SGPC kaha tha kab bhindrawala weapons jama kar rha tha to fight with center.
SGPC wants proof from center and agencies to prove that amritpal is terrorist instead tell amritpal to prove himself as normal citizen.
SGPC are supporting everyone who are openly saying "WE ARE NOT INDIANS" in amritpal case.
SGPC never ever condemned, when hindu temples got attacked in india or outside india by fake sikhs.
Why indian army attack at golden temple ?
If anyone rise aa demand of khalistan every buddy start calling terrorist to him , but why it is not same for hindu raster supports ?
Why many people call indian hindustan or it is right or wrong?
Most of freedom fighters are from punjab but why this country give more respect or right to punjab ,even though government promised to sikh leader to giver different constitution and rights to punjab , if they drop the plan of there different country , but this country not fulfill his promise so why ?
Hum " HINDU RASHTRA" main sabhi ko apna maante hai chahe wo Sikh ho, Muslim ho ya Esai. Humne kabi bhi Hindu rashtra me baki logo ko alag karne ki baat nai ki.
Kabi kisi hindu bhai ne kisi mandir ko kabza karke sarkar se ladai nai ki hame hindu rashtra chaiye.
Bhindrawala ne golden temple pe kabza kar lia, Waha usne log jama kie Tactics plan ki, Weapons jama kie. Hate speeches di jisse desh ka mahol kharab ho, kitne saare hindu bhai maare gaye.
Center ne galat kia army bej ke we accept or koi rasta nikalna chaiye tha. But uske matlab ye nai jo bhindrawala ne kia wo sahi kia.
Bhindrawala ne khud sarkar ko samne se nyota dia aao hamla karo aake. He thought aisa karke usey sympathy milege baki logo ko par wo galat tha.
Jaati mai mat batoo, Pahale hum desh wasi hai uske baad hindu muslim ya sikh. Desh hai toh hum h desh nai toh hamari koi pechan nai bahar dusre desh jaate ho to As indian jaate ho not as Hindu, Sikh ya muslim.
Dont spread hate or promote anything which breaks unity in our country.
@@dineshgyanani7170Teri yeh baatoh peh koi vishwas nhi karne waala jaisa india hain waise rahega warna jinko jyada chul machi hain hindu rashtra banane ki woh phir reality dekh lenge
@@frequencyatom7052 Sacchai hai, vishwas karo nai farak nai padta. Jaisa chal rha hai ache se chalo kisi ko koi dikkat nai.
Baki iss desh me reh ke desh ka namak khaa ke apne baap pakistan ka nara lagyenge khalistan ka nara lagayenge toh koi bhi saccha deshwasi sehen nai karega. !!! Jai Hind 🇮🇳 Jai Shree Ram 🚩
@@dineshgyanani7170 Why you use slogan Jai Shree ram at patriotic debate? Because you want to supress other religion . That's the only motive of hindu rashtra. True Indian is always a Indian. They never support hindu rastra or any other religious country
Is aatnkvadi ko sunne k bad muje lg rha h
Khalistan sach me ek serious problem h bharat k liye...
Asa q hota h.. sb bharat ko hi dhoka q dete h..😢
Hinduo apne ap ko mjbut bnao
Bharatmata ka sath aane vale vkt me sayd sirf hm hinduo ko dena h..😒😒😒
ਤੁਸ ਵੀ ਬੀਬੀ ਓਹੀ ਕਰ ਰਹੀ ਹੈ ਜ਼ੋ ਤੇਰੇ ਹਿੰਦੂ ਬਾਪਾ ਨੇ ਕੀਤਾ ਤੁਸੀਂ ਜਬਰਦਸਤੀ ਕੇਂਦੇ ਹੋ ਸਾਡੇ ਸੰਤ ਨੂੰ ਅੱਤਵਾਦੀ ਤੇ ਵੱਖਵਾਦੀ
Mr. Grewal is highly redicalized. He sounds more like apolitical leader than a Sikh leader. There are religious differences in India. But Sikhism is not a part of this. They are liked as brothers. They are there in every corner of our country. Except 84 riots there was never any incident against Sikhs.
1984 is a genocide not a riot Mr.
@@anmolsinghkhanuja24 yeah bro it it was geonicide.. like kashmiri hindus geonicide, direct action day, malabar geonicide..
He is a danger to the Nation
@@brokenjaz any non Hindu who talks about his right is nowadays danger to the nation.
@@anmolsinghkhanuja24 but never ever hindus demanded different states like muslim ( pakistan)and somewhat ( only minority) you demaned khalistan..
I don't know what to say. I see there is a resentment in Sikhs but couldn't figure out exactly why? On the other hand I see some statements that are borderline radical. This situation among Sikhs is not as pleasant as I thought it was. But I hope that India remains United. We know Sikhs are righteous and I feel hasty decisions will not be made.
Basically it stems from 1947. Sikhs had to decide whether to go with Pakistan or India. Nehru made promises and managed to convince Sikh leadership I.e. SGPC. So, Sikhs left their villages in Pakistan and came to India. Only two states were partitioned; Bengal and Panjab. Bengal had very minimal bloodshed however that was not the case in Panjab. Sikhs lost a lot - read on Rawalpindi massacre in March 1947. Once Sikhs came to india, one of the promises of Nehru was Panjabi state for Sikhs. However the Centre leadership at time was scared of the bloodbath that happened and the fact that Indian army had a lot of Sikhs. So, Government of India did not keep his promises to Sikhs. It’s all part of unfinished partition business. You can also read about Anandpur Sahib resolution that listed Sikh demands. Khalistan is no where to be found.
@@sohis so now u got punjab...all cm were sikhs....most indians think punjabi & sikh are synonyms.
U sikhs almost got monopoly over punjab ...
Green revolution , milk revolution was started in punjab ( haryana too) by centrsl govt
U also got industries like cycle manufacturing, locomotive manufacturing etc.
Punjab is one of the highest income states.
Your farmers get MSP . Most other state farmers like bihar Jharkhand , bengal , odisha dont get these benifits
what more are ur demands?
@@sohis Nope, Not correct 100%. True that Some Sikh leaders wanted a separate state after seeing a strong demand from Muslimbs but that was very late in 1946-47 unlike Muslims who wanted it since 1920s officially but it was not possible, because 1) British only decided to split country in two. Splitting into multiple countries was rejected eariler 2) There were no strong central level Sikh leadres like Jinnah except Tara Singh to push for separate country. Tara Singh even was against Lahore resolution. Sikhs did not have majority in most districts anywhere in West punjab, even in Lahore and most sikhs did not really care up until Feb/March 1947. Even most muslims in Punjab towns/villages did not want/care about separate country. Also Sikhs did not have enough clout with the British. Whoever were friends with British did not push it enough. I dont like Nehru but dont blame Nehru for everything. This was gross failure from sikh leaders. They could not even get Nankana sahib inside indian LOC forget lahore/Gujranawala. Listen to Prof Ishitiaq Ahmed's podcasts. 3) Sikhs never wanted to go to Pakistan. It was very clear in the riots in 1947. Sikhs did not get together with muslims much compared to Hindus where they inter married and visited temples etc.
@@Jahapanah-e-hindustan1. You talk about Green revolution, read the disaster effects of Green revolution that Punjab is still reeling from it today. Declining ground water, growth of commercial farming, introducing plant species not native to the land, declining land size, farmer suicides, climate change, drugs.....you still want more ?
2. You talk of Green Revolution as favour bestowed upon Punjab, it was not. Indian Government specifically chose Punjab because of the good canal network, topography and thus making the investment ripe for itself in Punjab.
3. You talk about Industries, i don't know what world you live in....but post SCL, PUNCOM no major manufacturing initiative has been started in Punjab by the Center Govt for the last 30 years.
4. Punjab being a highly sensitive border state is at risk most times . Major businesses avoid investing as opposed to mainland Indian states. So yes, Punjab needs special treatment.
5. As for justice, just tell me for 3000+ sikhs killed in the anti Sikh riots, how many culprits have been sent to the gallows ? None.......Even convictions that resulted in life sentences happened 25 years later .....so stop bulls*ting about justice.
In his views amritpal is innocent 😅😅😅😅
And Supremacist Bra-man parasites are terrorists
@@RL-zd2cf than what ?
Khalistani apne bap Pakistan se le lo jmin , indian ho India ko love kro
They will support anyone with turban bro. Right or wrong comes later.
Yes, he is innocent. What did he do? Did he kill somebody? No. Talking about separatism is not an offence. You are just radicalized by Indian nationalism
Such a biased journalist can be expected from godi media!
Try as hard u can to suppress us nd we will stand again!
Raj Karega Khalsa!
Bhindrawale sant ji ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
ANI must get Ramneek SIngh Mann on the podcast to bust what Grewal uttered and claimed in your podcast.
Grewal supports Amritpal despite
1. how the rebel showed up in Bharat and within 6 months he grew into an influential mess. Grewal ignores that AP was created - training in Georgia, plastic surgery etc.
2. Drugs, women and weapons ..so much was found but he is not bad
3. Amritpal was on run. If innocent, why did he hide
4. A petty chap causes uprisings, protests and damage to Hindus and hindu properties in Canada, US, UK and AU. Clearlry, indicates anti-Bharat forces are involved in nurturing and supporting criminals like Amritpal.
Grewal's conversation reveals the mindset of religious leaders in Punjab.
Mann does not speak for Sikhs. While SGPC, an elected body, does. Grewal is representing Sikhs via SGPC. Mann is a political worker.
Showed up in Bharat ? Or India ?
The fake hindu account keep barking caste jatt let me tell you khalistan movement founder jagjeet singh chauhan Sikh rajput Babar Khalsa founder talwinder Singh parmar Sikh rajput whole khalistan movement lead by sikh Rajput jatt just fighted for us and we are proud Sikh rajput will face anything to defend sikhi
Sikh gurus nay jo kiye wo koi nahi karsaktay.lakin aaj ke is jaisay leader badnam kartay sikhism ko.84 buhat bura hua lekin usse pehlay punjab main hindu maray gay unka kasoorbar jeh kis ko maanta
Very sad to listen to the Sardar Saab . Sikhs are very respected in our country . Some of the arguments put forward by him were not logical . Harbhajan Singh , Yuvraj Singh & Navjot Singh Sidhu are the most admired cricketers in our country . Modi Saab has huge regard and respect for Sikhs . I am a very proud Indian Sikh
You are real Shishya of gurus. We love Shikhis more than anyone in India. Vo pahele se hi desh ke pyare he. 🙏
Every day beat Sikh in every state open your eyes
They want to make our beautiful Sikhi like radical Islam. Hope sanity prevails are our Sikh brothers see through the radical thoughts of SGPC
Sikhism separated from Hindus way back during guru's time .10th sikh guru gloated about breaking idols in Zafarnama verse 95, had amicable relations with Bahadur Shah, went to Nanded inorder to support Bahadur Shah in battle of succession.Father of 10th sikh guru fought Hindu Ahoms
Democratic election is the main core problem of the Gurdwara internal issues and corruptions.
I m Punjabi Hindu and proud be Punjabi
The fake hindu account keep barking caste jatt let me tell you khalistan movement founder jagjeet singh chauhan Sikh rajput Babar Khalsa founder talwinder Singh parmar Sikh rajput whole khalistan movement lead by sikh Rajput jatt just fighted for us and we are proud Sikh rajput will face anything to defend sikhi
@@sacred6235 how did you conclude it's a fake id?
@@sacred6235sacred singh asli name di id 😂😂card
GS Grewal saahab says that central government is against the sikhs. And minorities are being tortured. He also mentions very smartly that if govt. is against them due to their differences with AAP, then they can collude with foreign power to fight central government.
1)
Grewal saahab I remember Modiji wearing Punjabi TURBAN at various occasions but in my life never have I ever seen him wearing muslims Cap.
2)Unlike Congress which used Punjabi community in face of Gyani Jail Singh and Several congress thinktanks(self proclaimed ) viz. Sanjay Gandhi, KamalNath etc in the year 1980 - 1984 to create hype of terrorist Bhindrewala and win Punjab and General election in 1985. Modiji and current Central Government would never ever do such things to create the wedge between Hindus and True Sikh community.
At several occasions in the video I feel SGPC Grewal saahab is funded by foreign agencies to be the face of Khalistan agitation. And to create instability in Indian mainland. I think he should read book 'Khalistan Conspiracy' by Ex RAW officer.
And @ANI and @Smita Ma'am, please ask a direct question to him that Does SGPC or any of it's member wants a separate state for Sikh community.
There we will have clear picture of what they think.
He also mentioned that Religion and Politics should go hand in hand and political thoughts should be within Religion.
My question, Should our country interest be not above all? Be it religion or political parties, Shall we not put Nation above everything?
ਪਤਰਕਾਰ ਚ ਦੋਗਲਾ ਪਨ ਆ
She is purely ignoring all geniue demands of sikhs , still want him to say that what all points he is asking are wrong . This is sad reality of Indian mindsets .
All his points are true and are needed to be answered.
Very probing but respectful 😊questioning by Smitaji. Sardarji presented the history of the Sikh case quite forcefully. As a Non-Resident Punjabi Hindu I feel for my Sikh brethren.🙏🏼
Ok, Guru Nanak Dev ji didn't wear janeu, so many Hindus also didn't wear janeu, just like most of the sikhs wear turban and some don't.
It doesn't make any difference what one wears as long as one behaves civilized.
Eekonkar was derived from OM, and OM means also that God is one. But there can be many teachers who guide us towards one direction OM or EkOnkar. Just as they say: too many ways lead to Rome, but the Rome is one.
If Bhindrawala was so innocent, then why Bhindrawala challenged the Saint of
Radha Soami Satsang Beas? He sent 3 insulting letters to the Satguru Charan Singh ji Maharaj by writing Him that:
'"Radha Soami Satsang Beas must hand over everything to Bhindreawala, including their disciples to Bhindrawala because he's the only true Saint."
How contradictory!
Soon after that, in a few days, how Bhindrawala died his own nasty death that too by the army.
True saints are never killed by an Army.
Such things happen when we trespass the limits.
Besides khalistanis are also believe on Bhindrawala who even don't work just eat plundering around especially occupying illegal agricultural land of others and after selling it once even twice to the illegal parties, they run and hide in foreign countries such as Canada etc. This wasn't the teaching of 10 Gurus, was it?
I hate Bhindrawala. He misled Sikhs.
Punjab belongs to those Hindus, too, who were born before Guru Nanak.
Hindus need extra safety and security in Punjab.
Bolea c khalistan bre bhindrwale ji ne ona ne keha c ki jdn drbar sahib te hmla hoya ta dunia te misal banugi ki khalistan banea aa 💯✍️✍️
Twisted a lot of historical facts... no wonder the direction they are taking now
konse facts?
One ex militant group explained how isi helped bhinderwala to procure weapon and all support he is lying like laywer
Shame on ANI, Didn't find any other person for podcast on punjab?
This Sardar is speaking like a hypocrite. Saying that Guru Nanak did not wear Janeu whereas the university professors of Panjab University Patiala say in their books that Nanak wore janeu. He is saying that Bhindrawale was not a terrorist, whereas there are proofs on media channels today that he headed a gang of terrorists who shat and raped women inside the holy sanctum sanctorum of Golden Temple. This Sardar is delusional, paid to spread lies.
Are is bevkuf aadmi k hisab se fr to kashmir k aatnkvadi shi hh ...vo b yhi bolte h hmne to mjburi me bnduk uthayi h
Jo v ho jaye kuch v glt ho toh pakistan ja sikho ne kiya india sirr pakistan se h mukabla kr skta hai india berujgari se ld raha hai godi midia or modi bhagato ko pakistan ki pdi hai aise vaise
37 min. that's when things start taking a twist. Just a Bhindranwale supporter, I'm sorry. This gentlemen started really well ,after 37 mins it's all downhill. Typical brushing the problems under the carpet approach. Sikkhi is undoubtedly one of the greatest blessings of Hindustan, but he is definitely not the right spokesperson for this beautiful community.
Subramanim swamy is also bhindrawale supporter
This is what sikh believe you should know true face of sikhs
As a Hindu brother of all Sikhs, I've no hesitation in acknowledging Sikhs contribution and patriotism for the country. I'm concerned that a wedge is being created between communities in India from foreign soil. I hope we in India don't fall prey to that. Sikhs are a respected community in India and will remain so.
Chat li sikho ki? Hindus are the only one who keep on licking asses,sikhs get the most benifit on caste system and he denied that sikhs have caste system and insulted hindus,you people are only lickers,amritpal kept on insulting hindus and he supports him,
This wedge was created by Indira Gandhi, Congress and also by RSS...
@@gsjutley no one gives a damn bro,don't count him represtative of Hindus, bhindi bastered threatened to kill all the hindus though he was dreaming,he said a sikh can kill 35hindus,we will kill 5000 hindus in one hour bla bla,Indira just fucked that bastered with his followers, 90percent sikhs count that bastered as a hero,tells the reality,their will always remain a wedge.
First of all there is no wedge created between Sikhs and Hindus. And how does RSS comes into the picture? @@gsjutley
@@mindandmettlerss is creating fake Sikhs who are changing Sikh history in books there’s many books.and we are not Hindu that’s rss don’t want to agree and you know now time rss is ruling party.
I seen those video where general Singh Bindra wala abusing other other religions, and ask sikh to kill 4 Hindus... And this video was not tempered.... So what you're saying sir....
There are many statements of Bhindrawale on record, against Hindus. His followers were and are worse than him.
Lot of seculars hate modi more than Bhindrawale when modi hasn't even be 1% of Bhindrawale.
I don't have much knowledge on Punjab. But I felt SGPC is more of a political body than religious body.
Something is wrong !
Either he is not aware of the reality or he has been misinformed/manipulated by someone…
It’s also possible that he is truly innocent & speaking from religious angle…
Bro reality is you are misinformed about Punjab. Govt need to take steps to listen legitimate demand of punjab
@@harjeetful Yes! Of course Government needs to listen about the problems in Punjab but aggression is not the way…Kind of Drugs flowing, Influence of Pak ISI, Getting driven by & manipulated by external sources, is not the way..!
@@anilyaduvanshia but problem is govt is not listening for last 75 years. When will that time come. In the end people are compelled to take things in their hands
First of all bro you are not from Punjab and you are the misinformed one by believing the fabricated lies of Indian state I'm from Punjab and our elders tell us a very different story of that era in Punjab about what happened to them during that time their real life stories
Go to majha region of Punjab and go to villages and listen to stories of victim families with proper evidences
During that time more than 100,000 Sikhs were killed in fake encounters and Sikh women got raped in police stations by police search the name of jaswant Singh khalra and learn about his story you will stop calling kps gill a supercop jaswant Singh khalra was a human rights activist he found more than 25000 missing people were killed by Indian govt all of them were Sikhs majority of them were of age between 14-35 they kidnapped young Sikh girls raped them and killed them killed innocent Sikhs who had nothing to do with anything upto this day still people are missing police took them they still haven't been found
Try to see things from every perspective you will come closer to the truth
Thank you ANI for bringing the true face of SGPC, Akali Dal forward. He is openly calling Bhindranwale a sant and a martyr. I think there is need for an honest conversation. Even if Bindranwale was a creation of Congress politics. There present generation should be informed.
Edit - If the blunder lies with Congress. Then Congress mukt Bharat is the solution. Present day sikhs should not be against India then. Only against congress and gandhi nehru family.
Tum nai samjhoge bhai...wo terrorist b nai tha
Bro stay out of Punjab politics! Your not helping
@@Baljeetsingh-mh2dp ha sharafat ka putla tha.
Tumhara sabse azeem gurdwara ko jang ka qila bna diya tha.
Agar defensive fortification karna tha to kahi aur jaake achi si shelter bna lete.
Golden temple ko apna jang ka maidan kyon bnaya?
Even Swami subramaniam calls sant bhindranwale as SANT ?? So talk to swami subramanium
He is a saint not a coward like Brar and thakrey
Host don't have knowledge about punjab history.
Chairman should give interview to shekhar Gupta instead of fake journalist.
Amritpal ke sath podcast krte fr pta chlta ki kon sahi hai kon glt jhoothe ko dlil nahi ati fr ach ke samne jhooth jiyadatr n chlta
Inka kahana hai Congress hatao,BJP hatao , aam Aadmi party hatao, sirf hamen Satta de do..... Bus dadaji Khul ke bol nahi pa rahe😅
Sabka apna haq hai wo qanooni mang sakte hai
@@muhdarif4321 tumare purane comments dakh sakte ha, Abdul tume pata ha na, India se ho ya Pakistan se..😅
Binderwala demanded Sikh land I was wondering how he. Lying he killed somany people from police civilian .
Even many leaders
Deeply disappointed in you Samita ji that you could not pin this bigot down. Bhindrawala called for killings of Hindus from public forum countless times and this bigot claims that Bhindrawala wasn't against any other religion. Could not even get through his drivel.
Several Hindus were taken out of buses in Punjab and shot.hindu target killing happened in punjab.this uncle ji saying there was no terrisiom in punjab .several Hindus families have to migrate to other states . uncle come and talk to me .I can tell each and every killing happened in punjab
This podcast was radically motivated and very disturbing. Person coming on podcast and telling that he supported terrorist Bhindarwalee in 1980s.
I was planning my trip to Punjab to visit Golden temple but I am now really scared to go there.
If terrorist supporter is serving as a secretary of Golden temple committee, don't know what may happen.
Yes. Stay away please. Thank you.
Sant bhindrawale was never a terrorist
@@harshdeepsingh8211 SANT? the guy who desecrate the GOLDERN TEMPLE , get real , don't insult our Sikhs brothers.
@@roshnivaldar2746 lol, the indian army and indira gandhi insulted sachkhnad shri harimandir sahib
@@harshdeepsingh8211 bhindrawala literally turned harminder sahib into his militia garrison.
He used the holy temple for his political & military agendas..sikhs should oppose it.
Sikhism and Snatan Religion has one basis difference. Sikhs believe in one god but in Snatan Religion multiple gods are believed to co exist.
We have to be respectful to one another. It doesn't matter if Guru Nanak was born as Hindu or not. Main thing to focus on is his message
੧ਓ
God is one
Sanatan talks about pramatma as well, it's the ignorance of the people that they doesn't know it.
Sikhi is a leaf on the tree of Sanatana
@@direstknight6697 ok but then why do we have separate temples for Brahma ji , Vishnu Ji and Shiv Ji and other gods. Why not just one idol in all.
As far as leaf is concerned, Sikhism is the root , rest are leaves
@@BalwinderSinghDeolyou are a living example of how empty vessels make lot of noise.
One god different names - Period
@@You-ov3yb if you can't answer my question then stop making noise here. It makes you sound like a empty vessel.
"Ekam Sat Vipra bahuta bhavanti" - one truth, the knowledge ones express him in various forms. That's Hinduism my friend
Bhindrawale ji de naam se itna drte kyu ho aap log🤔🤔🤔😂😂😂
Leaders like this has only one agenda, spread hatred and get political benefits from that. You guys have already ruined Punjab, I don't know what else you want.
Waheguru ji da khalsa Waheguru ji di fateh 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🕊🕊🌍🌍🌍🌍
Why did Sikhs kill Hindus pulling them from busses.They were innocent citizens
Also why did Bhrandewale accurate weapons in Akal Thakt. Two v. Imp. Qs.
Prove that Sikh killed them. You killed your own people to defame Sikhs . Same old technique
Hindus are still using same old technique. Example pulwama attack. Killed your soldiers to win elections.
There is nothing wrong in keeping weapons at Akal Takht. You say this because you don't know a damn thing about Sikhi.
Even the 6th Sikh Guru kept an Army at Akal Takht.
Sikhs don't see weapons the way Hindus do.
Why did Indian army kill a million Hindus in the golden temple. And why was their genocide of 2 million Hindus in India after Indra ghandi was killed. What about Hindu Brahmins in Kashmir
Wow, the way he twist words and present. No doubts that a special quality and no wonder why the Sikhs the frontline of India (in every aspect) is being degrading (in sense of not liking their country anymore) 😔😭
😂😂😂😂
How do you feel when Rabid Hindus call for Sikh genocide and a repeat of 1984 every other day. Just imagine, 6 month old Sikh babies burnt alive by coward Hindu mobs in their Rabid hatred for Sikhs in 84.Mass rapes, extrajudicial killings, burning alive in the streets of Delhi, Kanpur, Indore, Jamshedpur, Bhopal. The list goes on. Just go to the widow colonies in Delhi and tell them how proud you are. Just tell the mothers of Punjab who are still waiting for their sons to return one day, that you are proud of treating Sikhs as the Children of a lesser God.
The worst is that Hindus are proud of these atrocities they have committed on Sikhs, just a minuscule minority.
Just like tu twist jatiwad and verna system
Twisting ? Try and understand the reasons for what is happening. Aankhen kholo bhai. Andhbhakti ne pehle hi desh ka satyanaas kiya hua hai.
@@bikramsingh7768 He is right though. Padha kar thoda... Clearly you haven't read Qur'an
Guru Nanak ne to us daur mai hi Freedom Of Religion ki baat krdi thi jab angrezo ne is theory k bre mai socha b nh hga......Aur Baba Guru Nanak ji to highly Intellectual bhi the 28 languages aati thi unko
I'm Sikh but I don't agree with him he's pro akali dal and pro amritpal that's why people get confuse to know that what's really going on ?? They play with the people,s emotions with name of sgpc and religion!!
Its seems like he is also supporting khalistani elements...i think centeral agencies have to take strict action against these kind of elements who have soft corners towards khalistan agenda including this guy also who is sitting in Amritsar gurdwara on the name security provider and so called SGPC
Bhut desh bakti h army ne jao yaha gyan mat do tum sahi bki galat h✌️
@@LovepreetSingh-vx4hi chtye English samjh ATI ha tujhe...pehle English samjh le unpad ki kya likha ha mene . Awien chusne agya mera😜
As regards 1984, SGPC Head must clearly answer how, from where, and for what purpose were so many weapons collected inside the Golden temple. In my view, bringing arms inside the temple amounts to its desecration. As regads SGPC, it is a "Prabandhak Committee" for Gurudwaras (Managing Committee) for Gurudwaras and that is the role. They very name says so. It does not have the mandate of representing the Sikh Community as a whole for which elections take place.
ਅਸ ਕ੍ਰਿਪਾਨ ਖੰਡੋ ਖੜਗ ਤੁਪਕ ਤਬਰ ਅਰੁ ਤੀਰ ॥ ਸੈਫ ਸਰੋਹੀ ਸੈਹਥੀ ਯਹੈ ਹਮਾਰੈ ਪੀਰ ॥੩॥
"As kirpan khando kharag tupak tabar aru tir Saif sarohi saihthi, yahai hamarai pir"
गुरु साहब ने शस्त्रों को गुरु के सम्मान स्थान दिया गया है sikhism में !
तख़्त श्री हज़ूर साहब जा के देखो सबसे ऊपर शस्त्र सुशोभित हैं गुरुद्वारा साहब में ! सभी तख़्तों पे शस्त्रों को विशेष सम्मान दिया गया है !
गुरु साहब ने यहाँ तक कहा है के शस्त्रों के बिना सिख एक भेड़ सम्मान है, जिसे कान से पकड़कर कोई भी कहीं भी ले जा सकता है और ऐसे सिख को कभी दर्शन नहीं देंगे
“ ਬਿਨਾ ਸਸਤ੍ਰ ਕੇਸੰ ਨਰੰ ਭੇਡ ਜਾਨੋ | ਗਹੇ ਕਾਨ ਤਾਕੋ ਕਿਤੈ ਲੈ ਸਿਧਾਨੋ | “
“Bina Shashtar Keshang Nar Bhed Jano, Geh Kaan Tako Kite Lai Sidhano “
Chaman tere ko ye nhi pta shastar rakhna sikh rehat maryada me h
@@Mani5451M❤de toh automatic rifle aur machine gun rakhenge chaman
@@sahilthakur7336 shastra shastra hi hota h chahe kirpan ho ya rifle ya gun or teri kyu gand fat rahi h 😂
@@Mani5451M lekin gurudwara ko military garrison me tabdeel kar dena bhi kya reyat maryada me shamil hai?
He did not understand Ashardeep issue even after explaining. When someone want to play victim, that person will find a way. If not Ashdeep then Bilkis Bano
He is delusional like Joe Biden😂😂
Sikhi zindabad 😎🚩🙏🏼 salute to 1984 sikh dharmi warriors and martyrs who fought against the invading napak indian terrorist colonialist army 🙏🏼 project sikh south asia zindabad 🚩
Abdul fasaad original name se comment kr.. Tuje pta bi he 1984 me indian army ke majority of Top army generals operation blue Star ke khilaaf the aur aaj bi usey galat maante he bas fark itna he ki indian democracy me civilians supremacy ke chlte indian army ko indian Government ke orders ko hr haal me follow karna hi hota he ye koi pakistan army nhi jo civilian Govt ko bi overrule & overpower krde.. 1984 operation blue Star and anti sikh riots indira Gandhi & congress party ki creation thi apne political intrest ko pursue krne ke liye Aur jisme bhindrewala ko khadda bi indira gandhi Aur congress party ne kia tha Aur khatam bi usi ne kia Aur indira gandhi ne uski kimat bi chukaai pr afsoos ki sikho ne congress party ko vo punishment nhi di jo vo deserve krti he
@@vinodkaka5225 chup salay aurangzeb ke gandhi nassal napak alluad
He is not the right representative of SGPC, He is not able to put his point of view. SGPC must sent qualified and good orator on such important platforms. These are the the important platforms to endorse your points otherwise useless to speek on social media
.
Waheguruji🙏🏻
JaiShriRam🚩
Sant je jendabad
He said absolutely right
Whenever sikhs come front to talk about their contribution towards the country or talk about genocide faced in 1980s some label us Khalistani
Yup thats absolutely right. Khalistan demanders are khalistanis and not real sikhs. And because of these khalistanis, all other sikhs face these ongoing BS. Very good that bhindi waala terrorist was killed. Image of sikhs and their history will be wiped out if this khalistan shit continues.
No one called HS Phoolka Khalistani the problem is that you are not ready to accept Bhindrawala as terrorist.
@@udta_terr I don’t even care about bhindravale or khalistan
But that’s the reality “some” label us that when we talk about our things
@@japneetsingh9145 I have never seen one just casually calling someone Khalistani.
@@udta_terr check out the comment secrion, I am not saying everybody does that but their are some elements in every group
Arshdip par ye Buddha abhi hinduo ko hi jimmedar manta he ise abhi pata bhi nahi ki so sab pkisthan se opret ho raha tha.