Why Germany Produces The Best Managers | The German Coaching System |
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 มิ.ย. 2021
- Klopp, Nagelsmann, and Tuchel are just the tip of the iceberg, but how does Germany keep producing the best managers?
Mensch: amzn.to/3zaboz2
Support FMS on Patreon: / footballmadesimple
🔔Make sure to enable all push notifications!🔔
Watch the most recent videos:
• What to Watch Next
Follow Football Made Simple:
Twitter: / footballmadesim
Instagram: / footballmadesimple
Watch more Football Made Simple:
In Game Tactics Explained: • In Game Analysis
Detailed focus on Specific topics:
• A Detailed Look - กีฬา
Rank your top 3 German coaches!
*Correction, Hasenhüttl is Austrian of course, not German
Hansi
Thomas
Julian
Flick
Tuchel
Klopp
⚽️⚽️⚽️⚽️
Please make a video on rb leipzeig new coach tactivs.
Also make tactics on marko rose tactics.
Now:
Klopp
Hansi
Tuchell
Hansi, Jurgen,Tuchel
Hansi Flick. "Am I a joke for you?"
Hansi was a well known bayern Munich player and well experienced bro
Manu hör auf überall nach Abos zu geiern. Reicht schon, wenn du das in deinen Videos jedes Mal machst. Ich feier deinen Content, aber dein Betteln nach Abos nervt hart
@@grimaldushelbrecht8811 dont know german bro
@@grimaldushelbrecht8811 Digga. Darf ich keine Kommentare schreiben?
@@rythamdebnath6835 The Manu dude is begging so hard for likes in all of his new videos. So annoying
Hansie Flick deserves a mention.
Hansi has won more than those 3 he mentioned
Hansi has been in the management game since 2006, as an assistant manager for Germany and Bayern. But these 3 started from the bottom.
Agree with you!!
@@rachitdang7453 Wrong, he has been a coach since 1994.
@@taftybufty My bad. But I mentioned about the highest level of football. He has been there since 2006. I was saying in that context.
Beckenbauer, Klopp, Tuchel, Heynckes, joachim low, hansi flick, hitzfeld, lattek....all spectacular coaches
Rehhagel?
Rangnick?
Helmut Schön?
Sepp Herberger?
Ragnick was the worst German coach.
The discipline and the desire to study and to learn is what separates them from others. Majority of the German coaches work their way up. They always start from smaller clubs to implement their ideas, methods. That’s how they build such a strong base. And that’s the way it should be tbh, I really don’t like this new trend wherein former players with a big playing CV but with no coaching experience take on bigger jobs.
That's not a new trend that happens for a long time already. Germanys national team coaches often were just ex players who didn't coach before. Many clubs did that before but mostly it doesn't work but there are cases where it works
Absolutely agree! Even if it is poetic to see Zidane managing Real, Pirlo's Juventus, Solskjaer's United, some teams need real managers. Not motivators, not a captain/teammate, but a man who really understands and knows how to think in the training pitch and with the whiteboard.
@@zirbto5749 I agree it’s been happening for a while now but the step wasn’t so drastic as now mate. In the past, guys like Cruyff directly didn’t jump to a Barca job, he started off at Ajax first. Ancelotti didn’t directly jump to manage AC Milan. Recent examples like Pep started out with the Barca B first. But now? Pirlo gets to manage a club like Juve with no coaching experience, the same with Arteta at Arsenal, Lampard at Chelsea, Ole at Man Utd and the list goes on.
@@miz5138 remember Rijkaard before pep he didn't have any experience. Ole had experience just in Norway his home country. Lampard was as long at derby as pep at barca b. The only examples are pirlo he came probably because nobody wanted the job at that time and arteta who just was an assistant.
@@zirbto5749 Rijkaard had the experience of coaching the Dutch National Team and Sparta Rotterdam. I agree it wasn’t sufficient enough to coach a club like Barca but still he had “some” experience. And you just made my point even more easier to comprehend mate. Do you really think guys like Lampard, Arteta, OGS would’ve got their jobs if it weren’t for their playing careers? Absolutely Not, you need to be a top coach with a commendable CV to coach such teams.
Not just coaching. Germany produces lots of best things silently.
They also create some of the best research scientist I have ever work with.
Like blonde and blue eyed children. :)
@@faramund9865 are you talking about the pure blooded aryan race?
Yeah especially their leaders in the world wars
@@yagesh287 World wars ended 80 years ago. Bad to have an old time machine in your head, huh?
By far the most important coach in German football in last 25 years is professor Rangnick.
In general one of the most important people in German football. A visionary.
@@hhbased "Playstation Football"
Prophetic words...
Guess who was his main influencer? Arrigo Sacchi.
This is the main reason I want to do my licence in Germany
Could you do it in 2 different countries
@@michaelkiely1961 no
saaaame
@@michaelkiely1961 Yes, Moyes did his badges in both Scotland and England
@@EpicHashTime countries and nations. Pls check the difference.
The secret of all the German manager is ''The Pressing Mechanism''.
That's where they make difference.
Gergendenpressing right?
@@reak.5420 Yeah, one of the best pressing mechanism repopularized by Klopp.
Flick's mechanism was more efficient pressing mechanism like a beast and very compact ✅
@@najmussabir6051 The first one who invented the Gegenpressing was Ralf Rangnick in the 90´s allready.. But yes, Klopp is a big coach!
@@najmussabir6051 Flick's Gegenpressing is very space oriented compared to more of a zonal oriented press by Klopp.
@@GM-kj7sy Also Flick block the passing lane first ✅
The hype by the media in Germany is non existent, that’s what I have observed. Before Julian Nagelsmann broke into the scene with RB Leipzig I didn’t even know him and that’s how it is supposed to be. Don’t unnecessarily hype a coach or player and you will see the magic occur right before your eyes.
He was already considered a very good coach in his time in Hoffenheim though
@neph ilim yes true but maybe I heard more about it because I'm from Germany hard to say how appreciated he was in UK for example
RB Leipzig can go to hell. We don't need cans in europe.
People don't even realise it, but Bundesliga is by far the most tactical league in Europe.
I'd actually love to watch bundesliga but they don't telecast in Bangladesh.
@@ishteerashid5458 star sports does show some Bundesliga games but we don't get to watch all of them because of x, y & z (if you know, you know).
I think La Liga actually takes the top spot. Bundesliga defending is horrible
@bledar zogaj no need to argue 🤟u21 euro is the proof of poor defence lol 🤣
@bledar zogaj what has WC got to do with the leagues?
And while all of this takes place Jogi Low stays as German national team Manager for 15 years.Thats proly the only thing left in Germany to fix lol
He's stepping down after the Euros.
@@sibusisoenockcebekhulu9318 well thats perfection ig
@@GM-kj7sy and Flick is the successor
Stability is better for a team. Long stints for a manager encourages them to look over a decade into the future, which is obviously good. Germans probably understand that these long stints are good for their national team, unlike most other countries who change their managers every few years (usually until they stop getting results. That was one justification for keeping low: usually he produced results. It's changed in the last 3 years though.)
Stability is the key in joachim low germany finished P3 P3 P1 in 3 worldcups except for last worldcup where they went out at group stage but loew is leaving after euros i hope germany wins it and give a loew a good farewell
Because they value strength and attacking football a lot. I guess, there style of play is modern football. Also very flexible in tactics.
And good defense
as 4 consecutive UCL winner in FM21, i can assure you both german clubs and german coaches are hardest to beat.
I live in Germany since January 2019 and I'll admit that they have so much discipline and they care about the smallest of details. They care about work ethic and respect and they're always so serious. German football is just an example.
That's Germany
I agree with you 💯👍🏼
That's right! If you want to adapt to our work ethic, ask yourself: What is the best you can achieve and how do you know it's the best? Two: What is the best way for you to achieve it and why is it the best way? Three: Explain why you stick to your goal when you find out along the way how you can do better and achieve better things?
@@matthiaslangbart9841 But also never forget: Feierabend ist Feierabend!
@@matthiaslangbart9841 and how to progress more ?
Great video. This explains so much. Hansi flick and Thomas Tuchel coming into Bayern and Chelsea respectively and producing immediately was no fluke. They both brought structure and a clear way to play utilizing players they had inherited...Even Klopp in his earlier years at Liverpool. He didn't have the personnel he required but how he wanted Liverpool to play was clear from day one! Fantastic video!
Ask about Klopp didn't had the personnel when he arrived 2008 at Dortmund. Everyone would have laughed at you, when you would have told that BVB would win the league in 2011, win the national double in 2012 and be in CL-Final in 2013. Dortmund was nearly bankrupt in 2005, after the 07/08 Season everyone thought BVB would play against relegation for years, the club had to develop their stars and couldn't afford hiring expensive players. The rise of talented young players like Lewandowski, Hummels, Gündogan or Götze are directly connected to Klopp. Same before at Mainz, the rise to a topflight club ist directly connected to Klopp. Working with limited personnel is what you do for a living in german football, unless your are Bayern Munich (which are also some kind of limited on personnel, when you compare to other european topclubs and when you realise that even the worst PL-Teams get nearly the same money from BPL TV-deals like Bayern gets from german TV-deals as best-earning club).
I was waiting for this video for such a long time i like german coaches a lot these days the way they play ,their philosophy-heavy metal, ruthless, high intensity ,counter pressing football is something that really fascinates me,great work as always mate would you consider making more videos about german football
What I like most about German coaches is that they get the most out of players while implementing their own system.
@@SS-dt1oc yep totally agree with you we can see for example in Liverpool how klopp changed the squad into world class players and he is man motivator as well he scold you and at the same time tells you where you have to improve its like more than manager player relation and that trust brings the best out of the player
It's detroying German football cuz nobody has technique or flair anymore
@@diggermeddler1169 so true. ozil, draxler, reus, gotze, kimmich, hummels, kroos, sane, havertz, all these players are so poor technically 😂
Just look at the atmosphere at German games, these folk love football and are basically footnerds, I wouldn’t be surprised if football coaching becomes a subject in the future in Germany
Football is already a subject in normal school and we really learn about tactics, history of football and also technical abilities. I hated it tho cuz i suck at football but yea most people enjoyed it 😂👌
I would love a series that goes different countries coaching system. An episode on Portugal especially post-Mourinho would be great! A lot of Portuguese coach’s are former players or university graduates. Tactical periodization is really important amongst them.
I'm moving to Germany to get my coaching badges. It's final.
You’re producing soo many great content!
A list of All-Time Great Legendary German Football Managers: (For Reference)
1. Germany National Football Team
(1) Sepp Herberger
(2) Helmut Schon
(3) Franz Beckenbauer
(4) Joachim Low (Before 2017)
2. Club Level
(1) Ottmar Hitzfeld
(2) Udo Lattek
(3) Jupp Heynckes
(4) Otto Rehhagel
(5) Hennes Weisweiler
(6) Jurgen Klopp
(7) Thomas Teuchel
(8) Hans-Dieter Flick
(9) Dettmar Cramer
(10) Felix Magath
(11) Julian Nagelsmann (Has Potential)
3. Innovators
(1) Ralf Rangnick
(2) Christoph Daum
I would place Schon above Herberger simply because his performances in international was better than Herbergers .
@@princesofthepower3690 Fair point. But given what winning the 1954 World Cup as true underdogs meant to the whole West German nation as a miraculous achievement in true dramatic fashion and his influence on so many future generations of German managers, I think Herberger does have a claim to be held in at least the same regard as Schon, who had the most glittering managerial career as the German National Football Team manager while managing the most talented German squad of all time.
So grateful for watching football content of this sort. I'm glad to see this as a follow-up to the last video you posted about how England has improved its talent pool. Kudos to you...
Wow! That was an amazing video! Didn't have any idea of how big was coaching system, never tough that would be SO BIG!
England may have created the sport, but Germany understood it on all levels.
One of a kind content. This one and the England video is very indepth and detailed research. Good video 👍🏼
This channel is criminally under rated! ❤️ Kudos to the team for bringing top quality videos!
Same thing could be said about Spanish or Italian coaches
Very good technical breakdown. Hats off mate!!
Very enlightening and insightful video, good job
Great content. Really learnt something new.
I hope U do one on Italian coaches and why we aren't seeing them grow unlike in the past.
Mancini
Hii ! Excellent video as usual.
Could you please do one on this years Ligue 1 Lille winning squad?
Thanks!
Well German Coaches are rising to the very top :
- Solid in defence , how to defend with and without the ball
- Giving a humble mentality to the players that the team is above all players
- Playing aggressive football and encouraging it
- Every single player of the team participates on pressing , and on defending
- From the starting player to the bench player , all of them have their fair share of contribution to the team
- They have solutions even if their best players get injured, they are constantly proactive on their decisions
- Taking serious every training drill , were they demand the players to give their all for the best outcome
- Having the balls to make call outs when superstar players thought of themselves above the team (Tuchel call out P$G stars , got fired cuz of that , and now look at him , winning the Champions League with Chelsea while P$G bite the dust again and did not even won the Ligue 1 having the highest money LOL)
It's Neymar. He's overrated.
@@engespress He isn't necessarily overrated, more like a great player ruined by his ego. He wouldn't have become such a brat if he had understood that he'll never be the best player in the world because he is well and truly sandwiched between the Messi-Ronaldo era and the Mbappe era.
@@RFC_16 hmm
@@RFC_16 He's overrated. PSG keep not doing well in finals. And they lost the league title too this season.
Great video, really interesting!
This was insightful. Thank you
Thanks FMS , i am opened to depth understanding of football because of your well explained videos, i would like to know if there are football coaching courses i can do with your agency.
please do a video on the french coaching course just like this one,and nice video btw
Thank you I really learnt a lot from this video.
Additional props for the Mensch book by Jonathan Harding mentioned @0:49. Incredible read for anyone interested in coaching.
Amazing video ! also DFB deserves a lot of respect for doing this !
Very interesting video and great pronunciation!
Beautifully explained FMS !
Great video.👌🏾👌🏾
very good read from Harding. definitely worth checking out 👌🏽
These videos always have strong content, although I wish the graphics had less spelling errors, to be honest. Last video "quarter finals" without the "r" twice, here, diligently with mixed up letters and "lisense" a couple of times, although it is either "license" or "licence", depending where you're from.
I hope this aspect of the presentation can get better, because the content is of high quality.
Simple and very good explanation
Thanks, this video though me that I need to learn German coz I soo wanna study in Germany 🤩
Lets see if Low can do something with Germany after that horrendous World Cup 2018 showing
What a great informative video.
Mentality is the key. Grew up in a German family....played for German coaches.
One thing is expected earn everything.
Start from the bottom work your way through the ranks.
Seems to translate to football.
No mention of Hansi Flick?
I would love to live in Germany. It seems like a great country. I would just have to learn the language. I've always admired German Coaches. Jurgen Klopp being one of the top ones for me. Julian Nagelsmann of course.
Same
One of the main reasons Brazilian Football is in decline is not only by loosing it's talent so young but having terrible managers.
The only Brazilian manager that is almost in European Club level is Tite, the national team coach. Muricy Ramalho was the last great manager of Brazilian football, sadly he's retired now
The rest of them are below avarage to say the least. There are teams that are painful to watch
In Germany the best Coaches actually get the top-tier spots
Not Just former players
it's as simple as this, every one in the cycle feels the responsibility and wants the best for all. from dicision makers (Qualified/Competent not endorsed by a Ghost) to the juniors (from the Common not a Pre-selected/Pre-endorsed Ones), no time to blame just learn the lesson and keep proceeding. Thanks for the example Germany, and Thanks Football Made Simple for the efforts.
BTW Science always works...
You forgot the best coach Hans Deiter Flick
The German way might not be perfect but they're always leading the way . Very informative this video .
Good analysis, but you missed Hansi Flick, who won the CL in 19/20 ;-).
Actually, while Klopp is the most recognised in England, but actually, it was Christian Streich, Folker Finke, Christoph Daum, Ralph Rangnick that modernised the game..
Underrated content 🙌😭😭
Not shocking..Germany massive contribution and investments into football management, administration etc etc in all sectors of the sport is no secret worldwide. No wonder some folks use the phrase "Football made in Germany"
Fun fact:
The last three ucl winners were also German coaches.
Hasenhüttl who is not even German but no Flick who has won the UCL?
Nice video! very informative.
Why no mention of Flick and Terzic? Surely they deserve a mention here?
Hasenhuettl is Austrian and Tedesco is originally from Italy, I think.
Tedesco was born in Italy but raised in Germany. And both Hasenhüttl and Tedesco did their coaching degree in Cologne, Germany.
Tedesco means german in italian so he probaly is german if you go far enough
This was an amazing video
Hansi Flick was so missing from this video...
That Wormuth quote is so good.
It's not only coaching Germans are good at everything look how the tackled covid-19 while it was ravaging neighbouring countries
They are quality people
The famous coaching school of Koln!!
Small mistake: the 3.Liga isn’t a Bundesliga anymore, it’s just the 3.Liga. But great video!
U forgot flick
Man, what a superb analysis. I would also suggest that the underlying organisational culture of Germany is just more rational and middle class than that of the UK, not just in football but in everything else too. The way the UK jumps favours big names over expertise and knowledge, is a good example. Predictably, a superior society will also produce superior football coaches.
Thats super cool to learn
That compulsory academies investment is a damn good rule. I wish my country have the balls to do that.
Loved this presentation. Love to see more of these types of segments. Fantastic!
mantab, sekarang pelatih yang sering menjuarai CL berasal dari Jerman
Please make a video on the red bull system of coaches and players development
Really good it was on my mind. last 3 champion League’s were won by german coaches. I guess this just proves if you give people equal chances it really does move those people forward.
Im a german watcher and i love it
Hansi Flick: 6 trophies in one and a half year at Bayern including the Champions League and in 2014 the World Cup
You mentioned David Wagner but not Flick🤦♂️
Your spot on why German coaches are the best managers in the world.
At some point. Italian coaches were doing better than others.
yeah
Yeah, just same way we enjoyed the tiki taka football from Spain few years ago. Tactical approach to football is really evolving very fast, and I love it.
The German managers are different in that some weren't pro players
sure, but that was before tiki taka. u need 2 have a good understandment of real strategies for teams like barcelona bayern psg n co they hard 2 outplay n only being physical isnt that good of a tactic
@@jonklaudverdammt229 It’s turn by turn. For England to start producing so many world class coaches then the English F.A have to reduce the amount of money to be paid to become a coach. It’s too expensive in England.
Very interesting and well explained. However you need to look a little further when talking about the starting point. Actually, it was not Jurgen Klopp to start it but rather Ralf Rangnick. He strated as a coach with SSV Ulm. If you check for the roots of all these young promising and successful German coaches, they all root back to Ralf Rangnick somehow. So, he is the one starting it all.
Nevertheless, the general principle is well explained and to the point. Well done.
I guess Elite Youth Level license is a forever long term initiative to produce and give more chances to youth players. This was mentioned in the previous FMS video which shows How DFB are concentrating on the youth
A crime that you left out the only German coach to have won the Sextuple.
Subtitles would make your Videos perfect!
Flick
Nagelsmann
Klopp
the disrespect to hansi flick
Mmm.....I don't know. One spectacular season under unforeseen and tragic circumstances. The next season BM "only" won the Bundesliga.
I think that he'd need more successful seasons in a 'normal' environment to be up there.
Thomas Tuchel must be Ranked first,he came to Chelsea and dominated most games,won Uefa, Super cup,club world cup
Make a video on why Spanish coaches are also good. Ans a book reference on Spain coaches too if there is one
There are only two spanish coaches who are good outside of spain. Guardiola and Benitez and even in spain the 3 biggest clubs don't have spanish coaches.
@@fleetenkieker3445 How about Arteta, Enrique and Martinez? Are they not counted as good?
@@xvolnutt8654 Arteta is not really good. I didn' count national trainers in, because they don't have to compete on a weekly basis, but Martinez has achieved nothing so far. Enrique otherwise is quite good.
@@fleetenkieker3445 Ok fair enough
Only true football fans have figured football out. It is all about support and providing resources to the players, coaching and support staff, it is not all that complicated.
Innovation leads to Evolution and the theories of evolution from catenaccio to total football to German innovation have been as a result of the bottom line which is a very well funded and functional culture based on nationalist ideals. Pragmatists and individual talents have always been outliers as with the case in France, they take African players, re-educate them and give them a platform to compete in which in itself is still very nationalist and that is their key to success
Klinsmann,Berti vogts and especially Otto rehagel
Now I know why Germany is a consistent high level achiever. You guys just do a lot of research to get ahead in everything including sports! I wish my country Nigeria would borrow a leaf from you. In my country, mismanagement and maladministration is the order of the day. Then, when the tournament starts, they go to church to seek "annointing" to win matches. I know some "hyper-religious" Nigerians will respond to this to troll me for not "respecting" God or not being "born again enough" with what I have written but I don't care. I subscribe to Germany's approach than the Nigerian approach. Germany has far more achievements to show for their approach. 4 World Cups out of 8 World Cup finals from 16 World Cup semi finals! That is not luck. These Germans are just good in whatever they do. Period. Enough religious nonsense in Nigeria. Let's start using our brains. We will get more result that way.
Nigra
Lampard's defense suffered and it took him more than 2 years to get his defense right which was still imperfect.
Whereas for Wolves game Tuchel solved it within 3-4 hours that he had.
Tuchel is so better tactically it's not even close
Good Video, but what about the constant blips and plops in the voice over?
This is amazing
Short answer, cause they study tactics in Italy. For example Klopp many times f.a.p.p.e.d. himself talking about the way to play of Sarri.
Also you have seen what Euro did Hungary? They have an Italian coach, that countered masterfully the French,Portuguese and German tactics.
And it's useless to say how Italy is playing wonderfully, all know that.
Don’t forgett Mainz 05. Wagner, Klopp and Tuchel, all of them are ex Mainz. 😁
No for real Klopp went from Player to Manager in a Day. He and some of the Managers like Schwarz, Krammny, Rose and even Tuchel were influenced by a guy named Wolfgang Frank.
Mainz may be a smal club, but smal clubs with an open mind like that contibutute greatly to the sucsess of german managers.
Given that these coaches get so much coaching to work well with players, it’s just a myth that players at PSG were the reason Tuchel left PSG
He fell out with the board if I’m not wrong. He demanded reinforcements after the CL Final loss but didn’t get them
I thought it was german style football is the currently in trend just like spanish style in the early 2010s