@0:36 notice how Monroe starts singing even before she lifts her mic to her mouth? So judge for yourselves, I'm not saying Mariah has passed on the Art of Lip syncing to her daughter but yeah 😌
@@alonzoclarkston1781 Its not funny.....she may or may not get there. She has the same tone a her mother in some aspects and shee can sing but I didn't hear sangin. Anybody can sing. She's not a powerhouse voice like her mother. What is she about as decade years old.....give her time and we'll see what her voice develops into. Just like anybody. Makes perfectly good sense. Ignorant ass, y'all wild
@@Cynthia-ut3sl lol 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂. Why would I hate or be jealous of that innocent precious little baby. All I did was say encouraging words and be honest. She's what a decade, her voice isnt fully developed yet and it's going to develop more so then we will know if she is the next mc until then, right now she is not and that's fine. Don't be dumb and weird
Wow. Usually powerhouse singers don’t have kids that can REALLY sing (some can sing no better than the average person) but Monroe actually is pretty darn good! 👏🏾👏🏾
It's because most don't force their kids into singing or the kids are just not interested. Mariah did say she never forced Monroe. She just allowed it to flow naturally.
@0:36 notice how Monroe starts singing even before she lifts her mic to her mouth? It reminds of when Mariah sung with her mom and her mom almost forgot her que to lip sync lol. So judge for yourselves, I'm not saying Mariah has passed on the Art of Lip syncing to her daughter but yeah 😌 Like mother like daughter like grand daughter, all are lip syncing queens 🤣
@@chadddouglas5453 Exactly and this is despite the fact that she's lip syncing here lol. You can even see the way she pretends to sing that she can't sing at all lol. And these lambs are already simping lol.
I cried so much watching and hearing this omg... this is such a raw sentiment of a mother and a daughter bonding over something so magical and beautiful such as music. This is soulwarming.
@0:36 notice how Monroe starts singing even before she lifts her mic to her mouth? It reminds of when Mariah sung with her mom and her mom almost forgot her que to lip sync lol. So judge for yourselves, I'm not saying Mariah has passed on the Art of Lip syncing to her daughter but yeah 😌 Like mother like daughter like grand daughter, all are lip syncing queens 🤣
Singing is a beautiful gift. I sang a lot for my children. Now we do not even talk, as they were stolen from me. Maybe one day they can see how important singing with each other is, right?
@0:36 notice how Monroe starts singing even before she lifts her mic to her mouth? It reminds of when Mariah sung with her mom and her mom almost forgot her que to lip sync lol. So judge for yourselves, I'm not saying Mariah has passed on the Art of Lip syncing to her daughter but yeah 😌 Like mother like daughter like grand daughter, all are lip syncing queens 🤣
0:35 I know it’s still her voice and she sounds soooo amazing, it’s in her genes!! But you can tell she’s lip syncing, she missed her queue, Mariah had to touch her and the vocals started playing before Monroe put the mic to her mouth. There’s another duet they did in Toronto on December 11 where she’s totally on point. I can’t wait to see this live 12/16/22 this Friday in Madison square garden in NYC!!!!!🐑🦋💖
She does have a nice voice and it clearly runs in the family. However will anybody aknowledge that this is a lyp sinc? The voice has started off a little bit early than her “singing”. No shade as I can barely imagine how scary can be for an eleven yo to debut in a sold out arena…voice is good, she is the cutest, hopefully as she gains more confidence over the years she will feel more compfortable in going fully live! Good job anyway ❤
@@jentyson9538 I think most people notice. It's still her singing but I guess an 11 year old doesn't feel like performing live. Plus mariah is showing her when to jump in
@@alonzoclarkston1781 She surely did when she was younger! I’m a Mariah fan, just don’t need to play make believe with some of the girlies who swear she’s singing live when she’s clearly not 🤷🏻♂️
0:36 Roe misses her cue and Mariah nudges her shoulder to help her come in. For those of you wondering whether or not this is live. No, these are pre-recorded vocals. However, Roe has and Momma MC both have beautiful voices pre-recorded or not.
@@codywalsh2075 if you’re recording it for others to see and hear don’t scream over Mariah. she already has a soft singing voice let’s not overpower her so her fans that couldn’t go will be able to hear her. Thank you.
Wowwwwwwwww this young lady has beautiful talent, following in her mother's footsteps💝her Mom's soooooo proud of her, love that🌹 #MotherAndDaughter #AmazingTalent
I'm sure it was nice. But it was hard to hear over those people talking over their singing. I wish I could see a professional's clean and clear version of their performance.
To everyone debating whether this was lipped or not, yes it was lipped *but that is not the point!* The point is *that's monroe's voice, and its beautiful!* She is 11, and her mother is a powerhouse vocalist, the pressure is immense. Do not do to Monroe what everyone did to Whitney's daughter, let the girl find her feet. We do not want to make her have stage fright, Mariah had bad stage fright in the beginning of her career and she was a grown woman with a strong voice. For children of talented musicians it's much harder if they try to enter the same space their parents dominate, there are high expectations and haters before the kids even open their mouths. But at least we know *she can sing!*
@@JTScott1988 honey, yes it was. Mariah's first whistles were live, but everything after that was lipped. Roe Roe missed her cue to put the mic to her mouth, and then when they whistled together Mariah grabbed her shoulder for dear life so she didn't miss her cue. There's nothing wrong with admitting an 11 year old is lip syncing. It's her first time ever being on stage with her mother doing a duet, she's clearly nervous.
In other news, we may be getting a new Christmas album with this song on it somewhere. I'm sure Mimi has been recording new tracks, this was deffo made in the studio so she better release it!
This was a 😇BEAUTIFUL performance & maybe Monroe's part was lip synced but I think that's just bc of nerves & not wanting to mess up in front of thousands of people😳 (well millions if you count the live broadcast on CBS!) I don't understand why so many people are 🗣️complaining about it in the comments on other videos I've watched, I don't hold it against either one of them..she's clearly very gifted just like her mother👩👧 At the end of the day I know I still enjoyed the performance & I'm sure others did too which is really all that matters!🐑🎄♥️
I think Jesus is smiling down with this one God bless Mariah and her family and her being able to see God bless Nick Cannon and his family much love love to see this beautiful
Imagine having Mariah Carey as your vocal coach.
That was absolutely beautiful 🤍
@0:36 notice how Monroe starts singing even before she lifts her mic to her mouth? So judge for yourselves, I'm not saying Mariah has passed on the Art of Lip syncing to her daughter but yeah 😌
Right!👏👏
Oh my GOOOOOOD. I can sleep in peace. The succession of Mariah's voice is assured. MISS MONROEEEEEE
Not really. Time will tell but we will see. Not looking that way though
@@scorpiocara6798 lmao sthu😂
@@alonzoclarkston1781 Its not funny.....she may or may not get there. She has the same tone a her mother in some aspects and shee can sing but I didn't hear sangin. Anybody can sing. She's not a powerhouse voice like her mother.
What is she about as decade years old.....give her time and we'll see what her voice develops into. Just like anybody.
Makes perfectly good sense.
Ignorant ass, y'all wild
@@scorpiocara6798 your jealousy and hatred towards a child is all. I wish you with time to shine to be less hateful
@@Cynthia-ut3sl lol 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂.
Why would I hate or be jealous of that innocent precious little baby.
All I did was say encouraging words and be honest. She's what a decade, her voice isnt fully developed yet and it's going to develop more so then we will know if she is the next mc until then, right now she is not and that's fine.
Don't be dumb and weird
Omg Monroe’s tone! Got it from her momma
omg amazing! I knew Monroe had the "voice" because she has a raspy speaking voice just like Mariah ❤️
Mariahs tone is GORGEOUS now im truly truly shocked
Wow. Usually powerhouse singers don’t have kids that can REALLY sing (some can sing no better than the average person) but Monroe actually is pretty darn good! 👏🏾👏🏾
Monroe has zero genetic relation to Mariah. She’s an egg donor baby.
It's because most don't force their kids into singing or the kids are just not interested. Mariah did say she never forced Monroe. She just allowed it to flow naturally.
@0:36 notice how Monroe starts singing even before she lifts her mic to her mouth? It reminds of when Mariah sung with her mom and her mom almost forgot her que to lip sync lol. So judge for yourselves, I'm not saying Mariah has passed on the Art of Lip syncing to her daughter but yeah 😌 Like mother like daughter like grand daughter, all are lip syncing queens 🤣
Daughter sucks compared to kids I’ve seen on talent shows 😂
@@chadddouglas5453 Exactly and this is despite the fact that she's lip syncing here lol. You can even see the way she pretends to sing that she can't sing at all lol. And these lambs are already simping lol.
1:06 my ears are BLESSED
I loved how proud Mimi looked as roe walked away at the end. Mimi so loves dem kids!
Wow wow wow!!!! Their tones!!! Roc has a voice and husky beautiful tone as well!
I need Roc and Roe to be a duo act, we havent seen a boy/girl duo in a loooong time, it would be very refreshing.
Yes! I was shook when I heard him speak! ❤
I cried so much watching and hearing this omg... this is such a raw sentiment of a mother and a daughter bonding over something so magical and beautiful such as music. This is soulwarming.
@0:36 notice how Monroe starts singing even before she lifts her mic to her mouth? It reminds of when Mariah sung with her mom and her mom almost forgot her que to lip sync lol. So judge for yourselves, I'm not saying Mariah has passed on the Art of Lip syncing to her daughter but yeah 😌 Like mother like daughter like grand daughter, all are lip syncing queens 🤣
❤I cried as well😍
Singing is a beautiful gift. I sang a lot for my children. Now we do not even talk, as they were stolen from me. Maybe one day they can see how important singing with each other is, right?
She can still hit those notes and taught her daughter so sweet
That baby can SING ❤❤❤❤❤
😇😇😇😇😇😇😇🤗🥰
@0:36 notice how Monroe starts singing even before she lifts her mic to her mouth? It reminds of when Mariah sung with her mom and her mom almost forgot her que to lip sync lol. So judge for yourselves, I'm not saying Mariah has passed on the Art of Lip syncing to her daughter but yeah 😌 Like mother like daughter like grand daughter, all are lip syncing queens 🤣
Lipsync 😂
@@Zarumaans I noticed too
@@RickyRyans yup
DID MONROE JUST WHISTLED WITH MARIAH ? Omg
I couldn’t really hear it with all
The screaming
She did!! You have to see it from another fan's perspective (e.g on Twitter). There's a video from someone that was closer to the stage
She can’t whistle and this wasn’t live 🙄
Oh my gosh what a treat. This was so beautiful! Monroe has such a sweet, whispery register just like her Mum and the whistles were just heavenly! 😢🤧
Monroe’s voice is soo mature for her voice
Omg. RoeRoe’s voice 😢❤❤
Oh my gosh…. they both sound like angels.
0:35 I know it’s still her voice and she sounds soooo amazing, it’s in her genes!! But you can tell she’s lip syncing, she missed her queue, Mariah had to touch her and the vocals started playing before Monroe put the mic to her mouth. There’s another duet they did in Toronto on December 11 where she’s totally on point. I can’t wait to see this live 12/16/22 this Friday in Madison square garden in NYC!!!!!🐑🦋💖
I think I'm going Friday too!!! Can't wait
Lol. I seen that too., it's actually pretty pathetic that she's teaching her daughter that young to fake it.
1:34 Monroe's tone sounds like Mariah
And this is right
The “did they just whistle together” part had me 💀 the commentary
Omg 😭 so cute. I love how you can tell Mariah is so happy.
She has the same tone as her mom. Love it!! Very full.
Her daughter looks so much like her. I like that she wears her hair natural, many people at this age start straightening it
I think Monroe is a very grounded person. This is what I really miss of Mariah.
OMG this is so beautiful.
WOOOOOWWW!!! This is too precious🥺
She does have a nice voice and it clearly runs in the family. However will anybody aknowledge that this is a lyp sinc? The voice has started off a little bit early than her “singing”. No shade as I can barely imagine how scary can be for an eleven yo to debut in a sold out arena…voice is good, she is the cutest, hopefully as she gains more confidence over the years she will feel more compfortable in going fully live! Good job anyway ❤
Yes!!! I noticed that, and no-one else is seeming to notice!!! I wonder if it's really her on the track to begin with??
I noticed too
She recorded it earlier and lip synced it obviously... in case she pulled out. She was probably very nervous.
@@jentyson9538 I think most people notice. It's still her singing but I guess an 11 year old doesn't feel like performing live. Plus mariah is showing her when to jump in
what a beautiful lil girl, mariah is a great mommy that shows so much love and adornment of her kids, that girl can sing.
😍😍😍😍😍😍😍❤❤❤❤❤ Monroe voice is beautiful !!!!
We need a studio version!!! 😭😭😭
You got one... Both of their vocals are pre-recorded
@@inthelionsden03 lol y’all really are this delusional! This is live it’s literally accapela 😂
@@axelito6342 A cappella means with no accompanying music. There is music playing.
@@inthelionsden03 still outsanging your fav even if it’s pre recorded
@@alonzoclarkston1781 She surely did when she was younger! I’m a Mariah fan, just don’t need to play make believe with some of the girlies who swear she’s singing live when she’s clearly not 🤷🏻♂️
Yes! The Mom and daughter duet!!!!
0:36 Roe misses her cue and Mariah nudges her shoulder to help her come in. For those of you wondering whether or not this is live. No, these are pre-recorded vocals. However, Roe has and Momma MC both have beautiful voices pre-recorded or not.
I love how her kids are dressed and appropriately carrying themselves like normal kids unlike those hollywood kids, well done Mimi!
Wow! The little one can actually sing!! Amd the tone!!! THE TONE!!!
You do know she is lip singing right!
That guy's scream took me out lol 😂😂😂😂😂 at the beginning
Awww. lil Monroe already singing circles around JLo
The SHADE! 💀
Que lindeza ver a Mariah e a Monroe cantando juntas... e Monroe cantando lindamente!!! Emotionssssssssss!!!!
Just precious! It's giving I love my mommy!
1:37 And Roc? On his hoverboard backstage 💀💀💀
i indeed was 💀
Monroe the magnificent 💎. Mariah I hope you release this on your new Christmas album. Love Dem Babies.💞 Mariah and Nick are both good for parents.
So Amazing 😮Go Monroe 🫶🏻
This is just so magical and beautiful!
SHUT UP AND LISTEN to them sing 🥺
🤣🤣🤣 that’s what I was thinking like shhhhhhhh 🤫
@@rainbowstarmced191 fr omg we get it but still
They paid for the tickets lmao, don't like it then go yourself
No my thing is it's fine if you wanna scream if you're not gonna share it but if you're gonna share it then tape it quietly as everybody can hear
@@codywalsh2075 if you’re recording it for others to see and hear don’t scream over Mariah. she already has a soft singing voice let’s not overpower her so her fans that couldn’t go will be able to hear her. Thank you.
❤️❤️❤️ Mariah and Roe. Such a beautiful and sweet moment.
Like mommy, like daughter...good job baby.
Omg, the husky tone 💜💜💜
roe did great job she sounds like her mom talent
The commentary was an unexpected delight ❤ love
The daughter got Mariah's tone!!!!!!!
I love ya Mariah God bless you and your family and have a very merry Christmas to you and this whole World.
Wow Monroe has grown up so much she is beautiful like her mom. Beautiful voice as well. Well done Mariah and Monroe
Rock in his hoverboard backstage 😭🤣
Wowwwwwwwww this young lady has beautiful talent, following in her mother's footsteps💝her Mom's soooooo proud of her, love that🌹 #MotherAndDaughter #AmazingTalent
A billion blessings Fantabulous Shondo
I'm sure it was nice. But it was hard to hear over those people talking over their singing. I wish I could see a professional's clean and clear version of their performance.
Monroe's voice is so pure and angelic. But I don't want her to be the next Mariah Carey. She just needs to be herself ❤
Lovely voice
She’s a little sweetheart!
How cute!!!
You can hear the exhales and inhales on their mics, still trying to decipher if I heard both of them whistling
Never been more jealous of any moment in my LIFE.
Lil Mariah💕
Heavenly voices
Wish the guy taking the video would keep quiet.
This is so beautiful ❤️
I must be hormonal. This brought tears to my eyes. So beautiful.😭😭😭
To everyone debating whether this was lipped or not, yes it was lipped *but that is not the point!*
The point is *that's monroe's voice, and its beautiful!*
She is 11, and her mother is a powerhouse vocalist, the pressure is immense. Do not do to Monroe what everyone did to Whitney's daughter, let the girl find her feet. We do not want to make her have stage fright, Mariah had bad stage fright in the beginning of her career and she was a grown woman with a strong voice.
For children of talented musicians it's much harder if they try to enter the same space their parents dominate, there are high expectations and haters before the kids even open their mouths.
But at least we know *she can sing!*
It wasn’t lipped
@@JTScott1988 honey, yes it was. Mariah's first whistles were live, but everything after that was lipped. Roe Roe missed her cue to put the mic to her mouth, and then when they whistled together Mariah grabbed her shoulder for dear life so she didn't miss her cue.
There's nothing wrong with admitting an 11 year old is lip syncing. It's her first time ever being on stage with her mother doing a duet, she's clearly nervous.
@@Nicole-kc1vx it’s crazy how folks try to take away Mariah’s accomplishments routinely but no one comes for say dua lipa no singin ass
Mariah voice will live on
She sounds like mommy the tone
So cute. She's very beautiful ❤️❤️
#Queremos Mariah Carey aqui no Brasil 🇧🇷 😍😍🤩🤗🤗
Wait her daughter is actually really good this is adorable aww
Her daughter will slay jlo’s daughter vocally lol ...just like mother ..
That is soooooo cute❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Thank you very much appreciated
my gawdddddd
Damn the talking 🫠😂🤣 just listen!
I know!!
Yes I was like got damn!!
Hopefully someone will repost it 😆
Perfect ❤
The dude screaming. That would SOOO be me
Was pre-recorded, haha the way she cues her daughter twice by ruffling her hair
She couldn’t miss it. Her dad sings as well. I actually would be shocked if they had NOT have produced a child who could at minimum, sing.
I just died and am waiting for Christmas day to be resurrected 🦋🦋🦋
did they whistle together 🤣
In other news, we may be getting a new Christmas album with this song on it somewhere. I'm sure Mimi has been recording new tracks, this was deffo made in the studio so she better release it!
Omg this was fast! ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Amazing
“And Roc??” Haha
Did they whistle together? Or am I tripping?
they did 🥹😭
No
This was a 😇BEAUTIFUL performance & maybe Monroe's part was lip synced but I think that's just bc of nerves & not wanting to mess up in front of thousands of people😳 (well millions if you count the live broadcast on CBS!) I don't understand why so many people are 🗣️complaining about it in the comments on other videos I've watched, I don't hold it against either one of them..she's clearly very gifted just like her mother👩👧 At the end of the day I know I still enjoyed the performance & I'm sure others did too which is really all that matters!🐑🎄♥️
Wow 👌 beautiful mom and daughter 😍
MASSIVE FAN of Mariah but I wish they stood up so they could sing live.
Even tho it was giving lip sync Monroe definitely got the vocals to give the girls live !!!
even though it's lip-sync.... but she got the voice from mama! she will be ready in the future.
OMG !!!THANKS 😮FOR POSTING THIS ❤
I think Jesus is smiling down with this one God bless Mariah and her family and her being able to see God bless Nick Cannon and his family much love love to see this beautiful
Adorable 💙
So Beautiful 😍💚💫
OMG DID THEY WHISTLE TOGETHER
Moroc on his hoverboard backstage 💀
I SCREAMED when they said that!!!!
Aww this is so awesome
that baby better SAANNGGG❣️😍❤️😇